Llspllllitln«N ™W£*J?Ti *F Controversy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
XEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE. SUXDAY. SEPTEMBER 26. 1909. hear Mr. "Whitney had 12 that returned safely v t PEARY AT THE DINNER GIVEN BY PORTLAND FRIENDS IS OUT OF IT he said to-day that be knew of no reason wfey I WHITNEY any one of the officers of the Peary Arctic Qtjk WINS TAFTRETAINS riNCHO should communicate with Mr. Whitney oa fw JUDGE SCRIPTOEE Cook controversy. The Peary proofs are still kept under Continued «rom firM!».«' SAYS COMMANDER PEARY. cover. sjm neither General Hubbard aor CoaasMwder Vesj* OXEIDA COUNTT. will make known their nature, but It is leans! GETS most kind toward me and most favorable toTvarg that they do not m any way depend on what D- Explorer to Issue Statement on Cook Cook tnld either Harry Whitney or Prttchant, th* coneerva tk% by defln* hia attitude toward - cabin boy of the Roosevelt, at nor asy Mm convincing Etah. in. and Election Said tionDollcie* with clearness. Controversy. that may have been la iJ{h}Xomination resign, but shall remain In the formation obtained Grtea. ISail not land by any member or crew of the Peary government aervice. I-tall *™."g Portland. Me.. Sept. ».—"Hairy Whitney does erg* To Be Assured. a. In the past, to proJ^J;mo« another, my evi- dltlon. The proof*, farther, it la learned. ar* forts, in the future of ror not play any part, one way or to not and development our reaching built upon any statements that have been u,e the conservation minerals, W defena dence regarding Dr. CooTs claim of first mads - to s ests. waters, lands and and of so far by Dr. Cool* on hia trip In the N the need Commander Peary to a score Arctic. \u0084 TE?£S7sTi?i« consen-atlon policies whenever tbe sole.** said Pending a meeting of the officers of the Peary fhe espedaUy shall continue to newspaper men at his summer home to-day. He arises. 1 advocate way Whit- Arctic Club In New York, the proofs which an the control of water power said that he was makes to say in what llSpllllitln«n ™w£*J?ti *f controversy. He has being so closely withheld will bo put Into the distrut judiciary £non,l- public Tnterest. and the use bow Is connected with the form £™/°f £ laws and natural resourced forof^'J^fftfJthe benefit from Whitney since the latter for publication. The proofs will show. It la vIZ, equality of^t^e received no word common plain people. Ibelieve In yesterday at In the Jeanle. that it to a matter of knowledge la the policies, and 1B2X£e arrived Indian Harbor Peary unity and the Roosevelt the etren«tn and be says that he has no Intention of attempt- Arctic region that Commander knows m to stand for them as long as Ihave £££»\u25a0• personally, and that bo-has sag; anything. Ing to with him. the Esquimau* fcioira stand communicate to for meetlncmeeting A-Pel-Lah, the two who \u25a0 ,T,, , It waa thought yesterday that the Whitney, he said, was wtth htm on the Roosevelt Tuck-a-Sho and T that Dr. Cook, they were babies In hoods. of the President. Secretary Balllnger and from August 17 to M. but new told him w'.th sine* Cos*. here nor he know that Peary's sources Information la the might out some further state- Cook tad discovered the pole, did mander of Arc- Mr. Pincnot call received many, It In asserted that when Plnchot came from any one oa the RooseveM knew Ituntil he tic are and his ment from Mr. Taft Mr. Continuing. made public they will prove a surprise. an Interview with a mssss— from The Associated Press. proofs are California especially to seek Peary expected here late on the Commander Peary said: Commander t» Ifoa. ' *'" the With the exception of meet- •*«\u25a0 llia) iif President. "I have absolutely no Intention of making a day. He will spend the night at th« horn* of niitric- rudldaJ Cony. ono.- ing the station yesterday, when neither spoke ;./... \u25a0« dllln-ulO «\u25a0 at statement previous to my Interview with General General Hubtard. wmmm to other. Secretary Balllnger and Mr.Pinchot Harbor, unless there is a change the stay Huhhari at Bar were not thrown in contact during their in of pUn» to salt General Hubbard. Having turned are also la tbe ..th Judicial Salt Lake. Pinchot attended several enter- over pavers to him. the whole matter is now Ix^is counties, which Cmeida, Mr. certain COOK ON M'KINLEYCIJMB. present mother candidate. along with the party escorting th« m his hands. These papers bear almost entirely ni-rict should balance tainment* Herkimer counties hold the President to-day, but Mr. Ballinger. pleading a on the mate proposition, which is. 'Has Cook been SnVn^a'and Scripture* renom nation , With Justice sore throat, remained indoors roost of the time. to the peter" Nceessary, He Says, to Answer £s"r£ Is a foregone concision, as was expected was to Not Enured, his re-election private secretary met him here, and he de- It that General Hubbard Is ovcrwhelmlnKly Republican. His own statement regarding his findings, but • the district of his time to disposing of business. issue his Denials of His Claim. voted much at the rawest of the newspaper men to-day. Com- TO MR. BALLINGER ALSO TO STAY. mander Peary screed to Issue the statement him- For the first time sine* M*return. Dr. Frederick- XO HUGHES MAS BUN. to- yesteriay of th* widely circulate Mr. Ballinger had no comment to make The Rev. De Witt Hyde, president of Bowtfotn College; Cyrus H. X. self. A. Cook spoke From Jeft to rlgtit are: William Hubbard*a claim to have ascended Mount Mo> night on the latest phase of the discussion. Philadelphia; Mayor Adam P. Lelgbton, of Portland; Robert B. Peary; Jud»r« Edward "Ifeel the utmost reliance la General report that hia Curtis of Main*; judgment.'' Is of doubtful value. In answer to a i£m- both Mr. Ballinger and Mr. Pinchot C. Reynold, of South Portland; Bert M. Fernald. Governor of Brigadier General Mort- he added. Ktnley Republicans Friends of It to possible that Commander Peary will go to tlon as to what wou>d he his course in the Monst First Xiagara District declare the President's statement to be such aHty. and Mayor FVed Hamilton, of Bouth PortUnd. the Bar Harbor or. Monday for *conference with Gen- McKlnley matter, he said: that both officials can consistently remain In Lewi* A. thins about it? Ihartty Governor, same eral Hubbard. He uadiretsnde that •Why should Ido * Indorse However. government service and work toward the Delafleld Is counsel for the Peary Arctic Club and see that It13 necessary. We !iav» be n trying to declared himself in favor STILL WAITING THE END. DOES NOT DOUBT COOK. acting only Inhis capacity Barrille. my guide, who went with |Hy Teletfiaih t^The Tribune ] ends. Mr Pinchot has that General Hubbard la persuade Mr. policy. Mr. Ballinger president the club. the summit, to come East. Iexpect Mm to l»ckjior«, X. V., Sept. 26-The Republican con- of a strong conservation as of me to was keeping within slander was contem- few days, then you can ask in the Ist Xispara District, which has declared himself in favor of The report that a suit for arrive within \u25a0 and trition to-day without you Uk». Mr. the two weeks -\u0084. was held to-day. Under finally him- Ranks the Immersionists, How- Harry Whitney's Answer to Ques- plated by Dr Cook was received him all the questions Dokkin. adjourned the law. President Taft declares of say. way 08, we compromise agreement the Hughes men strongly progressive comment by Commander Peary. He did how- other guide, who went part \u25a0*! haw the Olcott self ii» being in favor of a were to name the candidate In the district, but amend- ever, Are Thinning Because Delay tion as to Explorer's Statement. ever, that he was unable to understand how his not yet been able to locate." policy, kept within, the law. with such of to they could no available men on their side to secret paper, copies which were left In several The two referred are Edward Barrtlb get may be necessary to carry Dnxbary. Bept. 25—"0 I»rd, don't Sept. Harry Whitney, of New of guld*^ esperiencei run, Assemblyman Merritt was alowed to »*- ment* to the law as West Mass.. Halifax. 2T».— a year ago last July, and which expressed John Dokkin. both of whom are and prayed the Triune Immersionists Haven, Frederick A. hands and lect one of his friends. In his tperch of aceptance out Mr. Roosevelt* Ideas. disappoint us!" who was with Dr. Cook at his views of Dr. Cook's methods, could enter Into mountaineers of the Northwest. had at intervals during the meeting which they held have f Thomas T. Feeley, editor of Th.- I^ockport Re- In an address this afternoon Mr. Taft Annotok and to whom Dr. Cook Is said to the controversy "Is It true that you intend to sue >.mmane* view," nominated, pledged di- throughout last night In The Hethel, their building trip proof. who was himeelf to this further to say regarding conservation: prayera given a detailed account of his to the pole. When ask«d to-day Ifthat paper contained Peary for slander?" he waa asked. nominations, made no mention of the opposite the chapel at Ashdod, but their my r«t but on Congress and ask has sent a wireless message from Indian Har- Commander Peary replied: "The ide« never tame into head." he u- the Hlnman-Green We are going to move remained unanswered to-day.