DOCSLIB.ORG

Lnformati0n to USERS

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Lnformati0n to USERS lNFORMATI0N TO USERS This manusuipt has bemn mpmduœd fiom the miaolim master- UMI films the text diredly from the Onphal or copy submii. Thus, smte lhesis and dissertation copies aie in typcrmiter fice, whik c(hers may be fiom any type of cornputer pfinbf. Thequalitydthi.irpPdudknird.p.ndintuponth.quilitydth.copy submitted. Broken or indisünct cokred or poor qualïity illusaatians and photognphs, pnnt b(scidthrwgh, sutstandard margins, and impmper alignment can adversely affect reproductiorr. In the unlikety evmt lhat the author did not send UMI a compkte manuscript and there are rnissing pages, these will be Med. Also, if unauümbd copyright material had do be mmoved, a Mlte will indikate the deleth. Ovenke materials (e-g-. rnaps. drawings, cham) are repIoduC8d by sectiming the original. beginning at the upper leff-hand ooror ar@ conbnuing from len to right in equal sdons Wh small overlaps, - Photographs induded in the original manuscript have kwn reproduœd xemgraphicalfy in this copy. Higher quaiii 6' x W bbck and whiie photographie prints are available for any pimtooraphs or illustrations -ring h mis copy (or an additional charge. Contact UMI di-y to order- Bell & Handl Infomiation and Learning 300 North Zeeb Road, AmArbor, MI 48108-1346 USA THE ~RNATIONALRECOGNmON OF A UNILATERAL SECESSIONOF QUEBEC: The Case of France and the United States Jonathan Paquin Graduate PFogiam in Political Science Submitted in partial fullillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Faculty of Graduate Studies The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario. September, 1999. National Library Bibiiotheque nationale du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliographie Services senrices bibliographiques 395 Wellington Street 395, rue Wellington Ottawa ON KtA ON4 OitawaON K1AW Canada Canada The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive permettant a la National Lfifary of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distribute or sell reproduire, prêter, distribuer ou copies of this thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. la forme de microfiche/film, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriété du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thèse. thesis nor substantial extracts fiom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or othedse de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisati011, This thesis explores the possible international recognition of a unilateral secession of Quebec by France and the United States. In the event where the federal govenunent of Canada would refuse to recopïze a winning referendum on sovereîgnty or to negotiate the secession of Quebec, the Quebec govenuncnt would certainly be forced to issue a unilateral declaration of independence (UDI), in an attempt to make Quebec intemationdy recognized as a country. The issue then becomes purely political, rather than legai. The success or the failure of a UDI depends rnainly on the reaction of France and the United States. This thesis argues that although a strong iink of fiendship exists between France and Quebec, it is unlikely that France would recognize a Quebec UDI. As for the United States, the author Merdemonstrates that for strategic and, most importantly, economic considerations, it is unlikely that the US. would recognize a unilateral secession of Quebec. The methodological approach used in this thesis incorporates. among other things, case studies. Although it is true that each case is unique, these case studies provide relevant information leading to the conclusion of this research. Finaliy, the author examines the issue of a hypothetical secession of Quebec through a realist theory of secession. Considerations such as national interests and power are taken into account. Since the basic principle of international recognition is essentially political, realpolitik rather than law and moral rights guides this research. This thesis is dedicated to my parents. Claude and hcef'e Puquin, for ail the interest they have show in what 1am doing. and for their constant encouragement. Avec toute mon Mection et ma gratitude. Acknowledgements are for me a very fun thing to write. They allow me to put aside the inteiiectuai ngour necessary for the Wfiting of this thesis by giving me the chance to thank aii the people who were then for me during this "obstacle race". First and foremost, I would me to thank my advisor, Professor Robert Young, who is the initial reason for starting rny adventure in London. Man of sound advice and, what's more, Que%écophiCe, Professor Young assisted me during my research, and ofien shared with me his opinions regarding the political future of Quebec. He also taught me one of the most important qualities of political science... doubt. Professeur Young je vous suis redevable de tout cela et d'encore plus. .. je vous suis également redevable d'une ouverture sur de nouveaux horizons. Avec tout mon respecr et mon admiration je vous remercie. 1 would also Wre to thank Winnie King, Dave MacDonald, Jeff MacLeod and George Wootten, as weii as a special thank you to Chris Dwomüuewicz and Michael Southern for having given me assistance to correct mistakes of aii kinds during the writing of this thesis. Without them, this thesis wodd probably have been written in French. Moreover, I wouid iike to give my regards to Chris Dwomikiewicz, Winnie King, Michael Southem and George Wootten for their fnendship, and Manuela Oiivo for her kllidness, her friendship and her good food. And, I cannot forget Professor Martin Westmacott for his kindness and his help. Thauks to ali of you for having made my Me so enjoyable at Western. Finaliy and most importantly, 1 would like to thank my parents. Plus précisément, j'aimerais remercier mon père pour sa générosité et suHout su complicité ainsi que ma mère pour son écoute, su compréhension et ses bons petits plats. Jonathan Paquin London, Ontario August, 1999 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Certificate of Examination Abstract AcknowIedgements Table of Contents List of Figures CHAPTER ONE - Theories of Secession Liberal Theories of Secession A Realist Theory of Secession neInternai Merits of Secessionist Claims The Factors of Disruption . Buchheit's Calcuhtiun of Legitimacy The Statist Calculation of Legitimacy CHAPTER TWO - The Leveis ofhternational Recognition Express Recognition Implied Recognition De facto and de jure Recognition CHAPTER THREE - The Seeession of Quebec: An Anaiyücd Background The 1980 Referendum on Sovereignty4ssociation From the Patriation to the Chat1ottetown Accord The 1995 Referendum on Sovereignty-Partnership The Supreme Court Reference Case on Quebec Secession Why is the Study of the Quebec UDI Crucial? CHAPTER FOUR - The French Recognition of P Quebec UDI ?: Deconstructing the "Grand Game" of Mr Parizeau Franco-Québécoises Relations The "Grand Game" of Premier Parizeau The European Common Foreign Poiicy The German Unilateral Recognition of Slovenia and Croatia Why a German Unilateral Recognition? The Cost of the Unilateml Recognition The French Recognition of a Quebec UDI: An Unlikely Prospect The French National Interefis Conclusions on Parïzau's "Grand Game" CEAPTER FIVE - American Recognition of a Uniiaterai Secession of Quebec? The Stnrcti~~and Mechanisms of the U.S. Recognition Power U.S. Recogniîion Power: A Historical Reminder The Sole EiecurrYe Agreement The U.S. Practice Regarding UDI: The Recognition of Bangladesh The U.S. Reaction towardr the Bangladesh UDX The U.S. Practice Regarding UDI: The Recognition of Slovenia, Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina me US.Reaction towards Sloveniù and Croatia U. UDI Case Studies: Observations and Discussion The American Perception of Quebec in the 1990's The U.S. National Interests mid the 1995 Quebec Referendum American National hterests and Quebec UDI: The Unlikely U.S. Recognition of Quebec The Sofl Lake The Nard Line A Quebec UDI and the Monroe Doctrine CONCLUSION BIBLIOGRAPHY VITA LIST OF FIGURES Page The Calculation of Legitimacy .................................................................... 16 The Statis t Calcutation of Legitimacy ........................................................... -21 Levels of International Recognition .............................................................. 29 Introduction Recognition is a matter of power adrealplitik rather than iaw. The purpose of this thesis is to examine whether France and the United States would recognize a unilaterai secession of Quebec. Although several sovereignists in Quebec assume that France would quickly recognize Quebec. foliowing a unilateral declaration of independence VI), this prospect appears onlikely. hdeed, as this thesis will demonstrate. because France is a member of the European Union (EU), it must take into account the general interest of the EU, which does not lie in the recognition of a Quebec UDI. Moreover. considering the number of separatist movements in Europe. the recognition of a unilateral secession of Quebec by France could be extremely damaging to French national interests as well as the EU interests. This thesis wiii also show that the United States would be the most important actor, and probably the fkst country to react towards a Quebec UDr. It will be demonstrated that, because the United States national interests lie in a stable
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Victor‐Lévy Beaulieu and Québec's Linguistic and Cultural Identity Struggle
    PSU McNair Scholars Online Journal Volume 3 Issue 1 Identity, Communities, and Technology: Article 14 On the Cusp of Change 2009 Victor‐Lévy Beaulieu and Québec's Linguistic and Cultural Identity Struggle Anna Marie Brown Portland State University Follow this and additional works at: https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/mcnair Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Brown, Anna Marie (2009) "Victor‐Lévy Beaulieu and Québec's Linguistic and Cultural Identity Struggle," PSU McNair Scholars Online Journal: Vol. 3: Iss. 1, Article 14. https://doi.org/10.15760/mcnair.2009.25 This open access Article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). All documents in PDXScholar should meet accessibility standards. If we can make this document more accessible to you, contact our team. Portland State University McNair Research Journal 2009 Victor‐Lévy Beaulieu and Québec's Linguistic and Cultural Identity Struggle by Anna Marie Brown Faculty Mentor: Jennifer Perlmutter Citation: Brown, Anna Marie. Victor‐Lévy Beaulieu and Québec's Linguistic and Cultural Identity Struggle. Portland State University McNair Scholars Online Journal, Vol. 3, 2009: pages [25‐55] McNair Online Journal Page 1 of 31 Victor-Lévy Beaulieu and Québec's Linguistic and Cultural Identity Struggle Anna Marie Brown Jennifer Perlmutter, Faculty Mentor Six months ago, the latest literary work from Québécois author Victor-Lévy Beaulieu came off the presses. Known by his fans as simply VLB, Beaulieu is considered to be among the greatest contemporary Québec writers,1 and this most recent work, La Grande tribu, marks his seventieth.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Separatism in Quebec
    1 Separatism in Quebec: Off the Agenda but Not Off the Minds of Francophones An Honors Thesis Submitted to the Department of Politics in Partial Fulfillment of the Honors Program By Sarah Weber 5/6/15 2 Table of Contents Chapter 1. Introduction 3 Chapter 2. 4 Chapter 3. 17 Chapter 4. 36 Chapter 5. 41 Chapter 6. 50 Chapter 7. Conclusion 65 3 Chapter 1: Introduction-The Future of Quebec The Quebec separatist movement has been debated for decades and yet no one can seem to come to a conclusion regarding what the future of the province holds for the Quebecers. This thesis aims to look at the reasons for the Quebec separatist movement occurring in the past as well as its steady level of support. Ultimately, there is a split within the recent literature in Quebec, regarding those who believe that independence is off the political agenda and those who think it is back on the agenda. This thesis looks at public opinion polls, and electoral returns, to find that the independence movement is ultimately off the political agenda as of the April 2014 election, but continues to be supported in Quebec public opinion. I will first be analyzing the history of Quebec as well as the theories other social scientists have put forward regarding separatist and nationalist movements in general. Next I will be analyzing the history of Quebec in order to understand why the Quebec separatist movement came about. I will then look at election data from 1995-2012 in order to identify the level of electoral support for separatism as indicated by the vote for the Parti Quebecois (PQ).
    [Show full text]
  • What Has He Really Done Wrong?
    The Chrétien legacy Canada was in such a state that it WHAT HAS HE REALLY elected Brian Mulroney. By this stan- dard, William Lyon Mackenzie King DONE WRONG? easily turned out to be our best prime minister. In 1921, he inherited a Desmond Morton deeply divided country, a treasury near ruin because of over-expansion of rail- ways, and an economy gripped by a brutal depression. By 1948, Canada had emerged unscathed, enriched and almost undivided from the war into spent last summer’s dismal August Canadian Pension Commission. In a the durable prosperity that bred our revising a book called A Short few days of nimble invention, Bennett Baby Boom generation. Who cared if I History of Canada and staring rescued veterans’ benefits from 15 King had halitosis and a professorial across Lake Memphrémagog at the years of political logrolling and talent for boring audiences? astonishing architecture of the Abbaye launched a half century of relatively St-Benoît. Brief as it is, the Short History just and generous dealing. Did anyone ll of which is a lengthy prelude to tries to cover the whole 12,000 years of notice? Do similar achievements lie to A passing premature and imperfect Canadian history but, since most buy- the credit of Jean Chrétien or, for that judgement on Jean Chrétien. Using ers prefer their own life’s history to a matter, Brian Mulroney or Pierre Elliott the same criteria that put King first more extensive past, Jean Chrétien’s Trudeau? Dependent on the media, and Trudeau deep in the pack, where last seven years will get about as much the Opposition and government prop- does Chrétien stand? In 1993, most space as the First Nations’ first dozen aganda, what do I know? Do I refuse to Canadians were still caught in the millennia.
    [Show full text]
  • A Note on Quebec Attitudes Toward Constitutional Options
    A NOTE ON QUEBEC ATTITUDES TOWARD CONSTITUTIONAL OPTIONS ALLAN KORNBERG* AND KEITH ARCHERt I INTRODUCTION In a recent essay, Alan Cairns observed that the making of a new Canadian constitution has been an elite activity characterized by the assertion of blatant self- interest on the part of key political actors and by strenuous attempts to manipulate public opinion in support of their respective interests.' For example, the sugges- tion that popular referenda be used in constitutional amending procedures appears to have been motivated by self-interest and the tactical advantage this device might provide political elites, rather than by genuine concern over pro- viding the public with an opportunity to express its policy preferences. Paradoxi- cally, the electoral imperative-the need to harvest votes-appears to have led elected public officials at both levels of the federal system to curry favor with their constituents by representing themselves as their true "champions" despite an increasing contempt for their opinions. However, rather than focusing on their rhetoric or on their attempts to secure tactical advantages in the struggle over the new constitution, this paper examines public opinion on five possible constitu- tional arrangements: the status quo, renewed federalism, special status for Quebec, sovereignty association, and Quebec independence. Since the last three options have more than a modicum of support only in Quebec, the analysis is restricted to opinions in that province. An examination of those opinions will indicate that the parameters structuring the debate over Quebec's future constitutional status have changed. The status quo no longer is a viable option. Instead, the choice is between moderate and radical change.
    [Show full text]
  • Analyzing the Parallelism Between the Rise and Fall of Baseball in Quebec and the Quebec Secession Movement Daniel S
    Union College Union | Digital Works Honors Theses Student Work 6-2011 Analyzing the Parallelism between the Rise and Fall of Baseball in Quebec and the Quebec Secession Movement Daniel S. Greene Union College - Schenectady, NY Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalworks.union.edu/theses Part of the Canadian History Commons, and the Sports Studies Commons Recommended Citation Greene, Daniel S., "Analyzing the Parallelism between the Rise and Fall of Baseball in Quebec and the Quebec Secession Movement" (2011). Honors Theses. 988. https://digitalworks.union.edu/theses/988 This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Work at Union | Digital Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of Union | Digital Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Analyzing the Parallelism between the Rise and Fall of Baseball in Quebec and the Quebec Secession Movement By Daniel Greene Senior Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for Graduation Department of History Union College June, 2011 i Greene, Daniel Analyzing the Parallelism between the Rise and Fall of Baseball in Quebec and the Quebec Secession Movement My Senior Project examines the parallelism between the movement to bring baseball to Quebec and the Quebec secession movement in Canada. Through my research I have found that both entities follow a very similar timeline with highs and lows coming around the same time in the same province; although, I have not found any direct linkage between the two. My analysis begins around 1837 and continues through present day, and by analyzing the histories of each movement demonstrates clearly that both movements followed a unique and similar timeline.
    [Show full text]
  • “Grab the Signatures and Run”: Federal Unity Strategy in Canada from the Referendum to Patriation
    International Political Sociology (2009) 3, 194–217 ‘‘Grab the Signatures and Run’’: Federal Unity Strategy in Canada from the Referendum to Patriation Neal Carter St. Bonaventure University AND Patrick James University of Southern California Whether as a traumatic event or great accomplishment, the legacy of the First Ministers’ Conference of 1981 lives on in Canadian politics. Consti- tutional negotiations among the prime minister and provincial premiers in 1981 produced the only ‘‘packaged’’ agreement since Confederation to achieve even the minimal support necessary to achieve ratification. The resulting Constitution Act of 1982, which included the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, remains in place and is the principal manifestation of intergovernmental bargaining from over two decades ago. This study reevaluates the strategic interaction and conflict processes that took place between Ottawa and the provinces in negotiations leading up to that fate- ful November 1981 conference. We apply the sociological framework for assessment of the dynamics of identity contention adopted from McAdam, Tarrow, and Tilly (2001) and find tentative support for its prop- ositions. After an overview of the article’s agenda, we present an analytic framework for the study of conflict processes. Second, the background to the constitutional crisis of 1980-81 is summarized. Using the analytic framework, the third section focuses on the federal strategy in the crisis as suggested by minutes from cabinet meetings, and the fourth section examines key events of the First Ministers Conference of November 1981. Fifth, and finally, the contributions of the preceding sections are summed up and ideas are put forward for further research. I remember it was quoted back to me later that Le´vesque said, ‘‘Trudeau screwed me.’’ But the reality was that Rene´Le´vesque was a gambler.
    [Show full text]
  • Grade 11 History of Canada
    Grade 11 History of Canada A Foundation for Implementation G RADE 1 1 H ISTORY OF C ANADA A Foundation for Implementation 2014 Manitoba Education and Advanced Learning Manitoba Education and Advanced Learning Cataloguing in Publication Data Grade 11 history of Canada : a foundation for implementation Includes bibliographical references. ISBN: 978-0-7711-5790-5 1. Canada—History—Study and teaching (Secondary). 2. Canada—History—Study and teaching (Secondary)—Manitoba. 3. Canada—History—Curricula. I. Manitoba. Manitoba Education and Advanced Learning. 971.007 Copyright © 2014, the Government of Manitoba, represented by the Minister of Education and Advanced Learning. Manitoba Education and Advanced Learning School Programs Division Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada Every effort has been made to acknowledge original sources and to comply with copyright law. If cases are identified where this has not been done, please notify Manitoba Education and Advanced Learning. Errors or omissions will be corrected in a future edition. Sincere thanks to the authors, artists, and publishers who allowed their original material to be used. All images found in this document are copyright protected and should not be extracted, accessed, or reproduced for any purpose other than for their intended educational use in this document. Any websites referenced in this document are subject to change. Educators are advised to preview and evaluate websites and online resources before recommending them for student use. Print copies of this resource can be purchased from the Manitoba Text Book Bureau (stock number 80699). Order online at <www.mtbb.mb.ca>. This resource is also available on the Manitoba Education and Advanced Learning website at <www.edu.gov.mb.ca/k12/cur/socstud/index.html>.
    [Show full text]
  • National Separation: Canada in Context - a Legal Perspective Kevin Sneesby
    Louisiana Law Review Volume 53 | Number 4 March 1993 National Separation: Canada in Context - A Legal Perspective Kevin Sneesby Repository Citation Kevin Sneesby, National Separation: Canada in Context - A Legal Perspective, 53 La. L. Rev. (1993) Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/lalrev/vol53/iss4/12 This Comment is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Reviews and Journals at LSU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Louisiana Law Review by an authorized editor of LSU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. National Separation: Canada in Context-A Legal Perspective Table of Contents I. Introduction ........................................................... 1357 II. Background-Canada: Moving Towards Separation ..... 1359 III. The "Right" to Separate: Comparative Constitutional L aw ..................................................................... 1365 A. The Canadian Constitution ............................... 1365 1. By a Province or a Territory ....................... 1367 2. By First Nations ......................................... 1369 B. Analogy to the American and Australian Constitutions .................................................... 1370 1. The United States Constitution ..................... 1371 2. The Australian Constitution ......................... 1373 IV. The "Right" to Separate Under International Law ..... 1375 A. The Role of International Law in the Canadian Schem e ..........................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Does Quebec Have a Right to Secede at International Law?
    DOES QUEBEC HAVE A RIGHT TO SECEDE AT INTERNATIONAL LAW? Neil Finkelstein* George Vegh** Camille Joly*** This article addresses the issue ofwhether Québec has the right to secedefrom Canada, and claim international recognition at international law. The authors argue that, absent recognition by the Government ofCanada, the answer to both questions is in the negative. The authors review conventional and customary international law respecting the right to self-determination, and conclude that that right is only applicable where the secessionist movement meets certain subjective criteria. First, the seceding unit must be comprised of "people" meeting both subjective and objective international law standards . Second, thatpeople musthave beensubjectto denial ofpolitical freedom or human rights in a discriminatory manner. Third, the seceding unit must demonstrate in practical terms that it can, and indeed has, created apracticable and governable state which can asserteffective control over reasonably well defined and recognized territory. The authors conclude that theprovince ofQuébec does notmeet these criteria. As a result, ifa thirdparty State purports to recognize Québec's independence in the absence of Canadian recognition, that State would be challenging Canada's territorial integrity and thus be acting contrary to conventional and customary international law. Cet article examine la question de savoirsi le Québec a le droitdefaire sécession du reste du Canada et de réclamer la reconnaissance internationale, en droit international. Les auteurs soutiennent qu'en l'absence d'une reconnaissancepar le Gouvernement du Canada, la réponse à cette double question est négative. Les auteurspassentenrevue le droitinternational, tantcoutumierqueconventionnel, concernant le droità l'autonomie; ils en concluent que ce droitnepeuts'appliquer que lorsque le mouvement sécessionniste satisfait une série de critères subjectifs.
    [Show full text]
  • Between Crisis and Preservation: the Canadian Jewish Congress and the Quebec Nationalist Movement, 1976-1980 Ryan Mercado a Thes
    Between Crisis and Preservation: The Canadian Jewish Congress and the Quebec Nationalist Movement, 1976-1980 Ryan Mercado A Thesis In The Department of History Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Masters of Arts (History) at Concordia University Montréal, Québec, Canada April 2020 ©Ryan Mercado, 2020 CONCORDIA UNIVERSITY School of Graduate Studies This is to certify that the thesis prepared By: Ryan Mercado Entitled: Between Crisis and Preservation: The Canadian Jewish Congress and the Quebec Nationalist Movement, 1976-1980 and submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Master of Arts (History) Complies with the regulations of the University and meets the accepted standards with respects to originality and quality. Signed by the final Examining Committee: ___________________________________________Chair Dr. Andrew Ivaska ___________________________________________Examiner Dr. Gavin Taylor ___________________________________________Supervisor Dr. Peter Gossage ___________________________________________Supervisor Dr. Ira Robinson Approved by: _______________________________________ Chair of the Department Dr. Matthew Penney ________ 2020 _______________________________________Dean of Faculty Dr. André G. Roy iii Abstract Between Crisis and Preservation: The Canadian Jewish Congress and the Quebec Nationalist Movement,1976-1980 Ryan Mercado In November 1976, the predominately English-speaking Jewish population of Quebec found itself in crisis. That month, René Lévesque led the
    [Show full text]
  • Searching for a National Unity Peace, from Meech Lake to the Clarity Bill
    Searching for a National Unity Peace, from Meech Lake to the Clarity Bill Edward Butcher Department of Political Science McGill University, Montreal June 2003 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Master of Arts Edward Butcher 2003 Abstract For much of the last twenty years, political leaders and academics have assumed that the survival of Canada depends on constitutional reform, and never more so than in the wake of the 1995 Quebec referendum. This thesis updates the literature by explaining the remarkable story of the last several years: the achievement of a national unity peace in the absence of constitutional reform. The explanation centres on the post-referendum shift in federal strategy from constitutional reform to Plan B, a strategy based on the rules of secession that has its origins, it is argued, in the Reform Party's response to Mulroney- era constitutional reform. The thesis concludes that Plan B was a successful national unity strategy because it made secession seem risky and undesirable, but also because the strategy - unlike constitutional reform - was based on widespread national support and on the viability of the constitutional status quo. n Resume Depuis la plus grande partie des vingt dernieres annees, les politiciens et les universitaires supposent que la survie du Canada depende de la reforme constitutionnelle, et jamais plus ainsi qu'a la suite du referendum de 1995 au Quebec. Cette these met a jour la litterature en expliquant l'histoire remarquable des dernieres annees: l'accomplissement de la paix d'unite nationale sans reforme constitutionnelle.
    [Show full text]
  • Reviews Bibliographie the Canadian Charter Ofrights Andfreedoms
    Reviews Bibliographie The Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms: Commentary . Edited by WALTER S . TARNOPOLSKY and GÉRALD-A. BEAUDOIN . Toronto: The Carswell Co. Ltd. 1982. Pp. liii, 590 . ($60 .00) This provocative Commentary on Canada's recently-entrenched rights guarantees, appearing only a few months after the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms itself, contains interpretative articles by six fran- cophone and nine anglophone constitutional scholars on all aspects of the Charter. Like the Federalist,' the anthology explores the ramifications of a constitutional document the operation of which could not be foreseen with clarity when the authors wrote . Such an undertaking is always risky, but the result can be enormously stimulating . Hamilton, Madison and Jay, of course, wrote their Federalist essays in 1787-88 as propaganda tracts to support the adoption of the United States Constitution in New York where strong opposition had arisen to its ratification . They wrote also, before the United States Bill ofRights was enshrined in the Constitution on December 15th, 1791, although Hamilton discussed the omission at length in Feder- alistNo. 84.Z But despite their immediate practical purpose, their work has endured and remains one of the great classics ofpolitical theory, cited often in subsequent works on statecraft,3 and, whether explicitly acknowledged or not, powerfully influencing subsequent constitutional decisions. 4 The present Commentary likewise appears at a time of constitutional change, and its authors, conscious of the divisive debate on patriation ' A good recent edition ofthe 1787-88 work by Hamilton, Madison andJay is Jacob E. Cooke (ed.), The Federalist (1961). Z Ibid., pp. 575-587.
    [Show full text]