Columbia Pictures Indus., Inc. V. Miramax Films Corp., 11 F

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Columbia Pictures Indus., Inc. v. Miramax Films Corp., 11 F. Supp. 2d 1179 (C.D. Cal. 1998) Year 1998 Court United States District Court for the Central District of California Key Defendant Miramax Films Corp. created an advertising poster and trailer for Facts the Michael Moore documentary The Big One that incorporated elements of advertising previously used for the film Men In Black. Posters for both films featured figures carrying a large object standing in front of a nighttime New York skyline, and used similar colors and layout. The two films’ trailers had “a virtually identical theme, format, pace, and sequence of events,” and used the same music. Defendant admitted that the advertising campaign for The Big One was intended to parody Men In Black. Plaintiff Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. filed for a preliminary injunction, alleging that defendant’s poster and trailer infringed its copyright for Men In Black. Issue Whether defendant’s use of expressive elements from the Men In Black advertising poster and trailers in an advertising poster and trailer for a documentary constituted fair use. Holding The court granted the injunction, holding that defendant failed to establish a likelihood of success on the merits of its fair use defense. It held that defendant’s advertisements were not transformative because they “cannot reasonably be perceived as commenting on or criticizing the ads for ‘Men In Black’” because they merely incorporated elements of plaintiff’s advertisements. The court further held that the amount and substantiality of the portion used was not reasonable, finding that defendant’s proffered justifications were unpersuasive given the non-transformative nature of the use. Finally, the court held that defendant failed to meet its burden of providing affirmative evidence relating to market harm. Tags Ninth Circuit; Film/Audiovisual; Painting/Drawing/Graphic; Parody/Satire Outcome Fair use not found Source: U.S. Copyright Office Fair Use Index. For more information, see http://copyright.gov/fair- use/index.html. .

Copy Link

Recommended publications

New Programming Customer Movie
EVERYTHING YOU NEED FOR successful events, SIMPLY Programming Toolkit | Fall/Winter 2017 © Universal Studios Press © 2017 Disney/Pixar © Universal Studios © Paramount Pictures © Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. New Movie Programming Customer Releases Event Ideas Ideas Spotlight NEW Releases © Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. © Warner © 2017 Disney/Pixar © Universal Studios Despicable Me 3 Wonder Woman Cars 3 Anticipated October 2017 Anticipated September 2017 Anticipated October 2017 PG; 90 minutes; Universal Studios PG-13; 141 minutes; Warner Bros. G; 109 minutes; Walt Disney Pictures Gru battles Balthazar Bratt, a 1980s child star- An Amazon princess leaves her island home Race car Lightning McQueen suffers a severe turned-supervillain, in this animated sequel. and journeys to the outside world, which is crash while trying to compete with a younger being consumed by a massive war. With the rival named Jackson Storm. Afterward, help of an American pilot, she works to put an McQueen embraces new technologies as he end to the conflict. trains for a return to the racetrack. EVENT Idea! EVENT EVENT Promotion Idea Idea The minions are back at it again! Create Allow guests the opportunity to In this movie, legendary Lightning buzz for your movie showing by passing craft their own Tiara or Bracelets of McQueen has to prove that he still has out yellow balloons in your community that Submission. Give them the chance to what it takes to win. Foster a friendly look just like the little stars of the movie. show off their creations at a pop-up sense of competition that mimics the All you need are markers, yellow balloons, photo booth at the event.
[Show full text]
2013 Movie Catalog © Warner Bros
1-800-876-5577 www.swank.com Swank Motion Pictures,Inc. Swank Motion 2013 Movie Catalog 2013 Movie © Warner Bros. © 2013 Disney © TriStar Pictures © Warner Bros. © NBC Universal © Columbia Pictures Industries, ©Inc. Summit Entertainment 2013 Movie Catalog Movie 2013 Inc. Pictures, Motion Swank 1-800-876-5577 www.swank.com MOVIES Swank Motion Pictures,Inc. Swank Motion 2013 Movie Catalog 2013 Movie © New Line Cinema © 2013 Disney © Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. © Warner Bros. © 2013 Disney/Pixar © Summit Entertainment Promote Your movie event! Ask about FREE promotional materials to help make your next movie event a success! 2013 Movie Catalog 2013 Movie Catalog TABLE OF CONTENTS New Releases ......................................................... 1-34 Swank has rights to the largest collection of movies from the top Coming Soon .............................................................35 Hollywood & independent studios. Whether it’s blockbuster movies, All Time Favorites .............................................36-39 action and suspense, comedies or classic films,Swank has them all! Event Calendar .........................................................40 Sat., June 16th - 8:00pm Classics ...................................................................41-42 Disney 2012 © Date Night ........................................................... 43-44 TABLE TENT Sat., June 16th - 8:00pm TM & © Marvel & Subs 1-800-876-5577 | www.swank.com Environmental Films .............................................. 45 FLYER Faith-Based
[Show full text]
The Survival of American Silent Feature Films: 1912–1929 by David Pierce September 2013
The Survival of American Silent Feature Films: 1912–1929 by David Pierce September 2013 COUNCIL ON LIBRARY AND INFORMATION RESOURCES AND THE LIBRARY OF CONGRESS The Survival of American Silent Feature Films: 1912–1929 by David Pierce September 2013 Mr. Pierce has also created a da tabase of location information on the archival film holdings identified in the course of his research. See www.loc.gov/film. Commissioned for and sponsored by the National Film Preservation Board Council on Library and Information Resources and The Library of Congress Washington, D.C. The National Film Preservation Board The National Film Preservation Board was established at the Library of Congress by the National Film Preservation Act of 1988, and most recently reauthorized by the U.S. Congress in 2008. Among the provisions of the law is a mandate to “undertake studies and investigations of film preservation activities as needed, including the efficacy of new technologies, and recommend solutions to- im prove these practices.” More information about the National Film Preservation Board can be found at http://www.loc.gov/film/. ISBN 978-1-932326-39-0 CLIR Publication No. 158 Copublished by: Council on Library and Information Resources The Library of Congress 1707 L Street NW, Suite 650 and 101 Independence Avenue, SE Washington, DC 20036 Washington, DC 20540 Web site at http://www.clir.org Web site at http://www.loc.gov Additional copies are available for $30 each. Orders may be placed through CLIR’s Web site. This publication is also available online at no charge at http://www.clir.org/pubs/reports/pub158.
[Show full text]
The Business of Making Movies
Cover Story THE BUSINESS OF MAKING MOVIES B Y S. MARK Y OUNG,JAMES J. GONG, AND W IM A. V AN DER S TEDE The U.S. motion picture industry generates close to $100 billion in revenues, is one of the country’s largest exporters, and exerts enormous cultural influence worldwide. But today it also faces enormous pressures. 26 STRATEGIC FINANCE I F ebruary 2008 oing to the movies has always been one of ney Pictures, Warner Brothers Pictures, Paramount Pic- society’s most pleasurable pastimes. Over tures, Columbia Pictures, and Universal Pictures. The the past few years, though, enormous MPAA represents these studios internationally and plays a changes have occurred in the movie- number of roles: It advocates for the U.S. film industry, making business: escalating production protects producers from copyright theft, and fights pira- and marketing costs, the significant impact cy. In 2006, the MPAA studios released 203 films (34%), of increased piracy, the uncertainty in film and other, independent distributors released 396 (66%). financing, the proliferation of digital tech- Even though major studios have made their name in Gnology, and the increase in available entertainment Hollywood, large, vertically integrated conglomerates options for consumers. These and other factors have own them today. These conglomerates also incorporate a implications for the motion picture business, the types of number of other forms of entertainment and media, such movies it will produce, and how and where people will as radio stations, cable and network television stations, view them. Based on research sponsored by the Foundation for Applied Research (FAR) of the Institute of Management THE LARGEST DISTRIBUTORS OF Accountants (IMA®), this is the first in a series of articles on the U.S.
[Show full text]
Foreign Claims Settlement Commi~Ion of the United States Washington, D.C
FOREIGN CLAIMS SETTLEMENT COMMI~ION OF THE UNITED STATES WASHINGTON, D.C. 20579 COLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES, INC. COLUMBIA PICTURES INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION COLUMBIA PICTURES DE CUBA, S.A. Claim No.6~-2970 Decision No. (~U- 6 02 9 -Under the International Claims Settlement A~ of 1949. as amended Schwartz, Mermelsteln, Burns, Counsel for claimants: Lesser & Jacoby by Everett A. Frohllch FINAL DECISION Under date of January 12, 1971, the Commission issued a Proposed Decision in this matter, listing the counsel for claimant as then of record. Counsel has under date of February 2, 1971, informed the Commls- sion that as of January I, 1971, the law firm of Schwartz & Frohlich was to be known as Schwartz, Mermelstein, Burns, Lesser & Jacoby, and that claimants are now so represented. Accordingly, the matter is amended to reflect the correct name of counsel. No objections having been entered, the Proposed Decision is entered as the Commission’s Final Decision in this matter. Dated at Washington, D. C., and entered as the Final Decision of the Commission FOREIGN CLAIMS SETTLEMENT COIt~IISSION OF THE UNITED STA~TES WASHINGTON, D.C. 20579 I~ THE MATT~m OF T~E C~M OF COLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES, INC. [ Claim No.CU ~2970 ~ IA ~PICTURES. INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION IA PICTURES DE CUBA, Decision No.CU ~ 6029 Under the International Claims Settlement Act of 1949. as amended Counsel for claimants: Schwartz & Frohlich By: Everett A. Frohlich, Esq. PROPOSED DECISION This claim against the Government of Cuba~ filed under Title V of the International Claims
[Show full text]
Columbia Pictures Dreamworks Pictures Hollywood Pictures
USD #416 has purchased a performance license for ’08-‘09 that allows our staff to legally show copyrighted entertainment videotapes or DVD’s from most major producers, even if they do not fall under the copyright “fair use” guidelines. The license allows us to show productions from the following producers even if we are not using them as an essential part of our curriculum: Columbia Pictures DreamWorks Pictures Hollywood Pictures Lionsgate Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Miramax Films NBC Universal New Line Cinema Paramount Pictures Sony Pictures Touchstone Pictures Tri-Star Pictures United Artists Walt Disney Pictures Warner Bros. (list updated Aug. 2008) This license was not purchased to encourage use of materials not directly related to the curriculum, but to cover USD #416 and its staff for the rare occasions that these showings occur. It covers outside groups that use our facilities, as well (such as PTA.) Note that video productions from companies other than the ones listed above are NOT covered. For more information go to: www.movlic.com What the Law Says The Federal Copyright Act (Title 17, United States Code, Public Law 94-553, 90 stat. 2541) governs how copyrighted materials, such as movies, may be used. Neither the rental nor the purchase of a videocassette or DVD carries with it the right to use the movie outside the home. "Fair Use" In some instances, it is not required to obtain a Movie Copyright Compliance Site License when exhibiting copyrighted materials such as videocassettes or DVDs. This "face-to-face teaching exemption" applies only if: • A teacher is in attendance and • The showing takes place in a classroom setting and • The movie is used as an essential part of the current curriculum being taught Examples of situations where a Movie Copyright Compliance Site License must be obtained are showings at public libraries, day-care facilities, and entertainment movies being used at schools for After School activities.
[Show full text]
Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. V. Fung
FOR PUBLICATION UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT COLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES, No. 10-55946 INC.; DISNEY ENTERPRISES, INC.; PARAMOUNT PICTURES D.C. No. CORPORATION; TRISTAR PICTURES, 2:06-cv-05578- INC.; TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX SVW-JC FILM CORPORATION; UNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS LLLP; UNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS PRODUCTIONS, LLLP; OPINION WARNER BROS ENTERTAINMENT, INC., Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. GARY FUNG; ISOHUNT WEB TECHNOLOGIES, INC., Defendants-Appellants. Appeal from the United States District Court for the Central District of California Stephen V. Wilson, District Judge, Presiding Argued May 6, 2011 Submitted March 21, 2013 Pasadena, California Filed March 21, 2013 2 COLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES V. FUNG Before: Harry Pregerson, Raymond C. Fisher, and Marsha S. Berzon, Circuit Judges. Opinion by Judge Berzon SUMMARY* Copyright The panel affirmed in part and vacated in part the district court’s judgment in favor of film studios, which alleged that the services offered and websites maintained by the defendants induced third parties to download infringing copies of the studios’ copyrighted works. Affirming the district court’s summary judgment, the panel held that under Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios, Inc. v. Grokster Ltd., 545 U.S. 913 (2005), the defendants were liable for contributory copyright infringement on an inducement theory because the plaintiffs established (1) distribution of a device or product, (2) acts of infringement, (3) an object of promoting the product’s use to infringe copyright, and (4) causation in the defendants’ use of the peer-to-peer file sharing protocol known as BitTorrent. The panel held that the defendants were not entitled to protection from liability under any of the safe harbor provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, including safe harbors provided by 17 U.S.C.
[Show full text]
When Do Ineed the License
MOVIE NIGHTS AT THE MARSHALL STUDENT CENTER WHAT DO I NEED? If you are planning to show a copyrighted film during your event, you will need a public performance license! The MSC Administration will need proof, such as a copy of the public performance license for the film in question, before the event. MSC Event and Meeting Services cannot arrange the license for you. WHEN DO I NEED THE LICENSE BY? You must turn in a copy of your license to your event planner no later than three (3) business days before your event. If we do not receive a valid license in time, you will have the chance to cancel your event or hold another activity. You may also chose to show a public domain film. You may not show a copyrighted film without a license. WHY DO I NEED A LICENSE? Per University policy, the Marshall Student Center requires a license for all copyrighted materials publicly distributed in the MSC. Also, if you are with a student organization and you want to use Student Government funding, the Student Business Services Shared Services Center will need proof of the public performance license before they can approve any expenses related to the showing, such as food or MSC event expenses. HOW DO I GET A LICENSE? Getting a public performance license for a film is relatively easy and usually requires no more than an email or phone call and payment of a fee. Fees are determined by factors such as: the number of times a particular movie is going to be shown, how large the audience will be, how recently the film was released, etc.
[Show full text]
The Big 6 Entertainment Corporations
THE BIG 6 ENTERTAINMENT CORPORATIONS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ News Corporation (abbreviated to News Corp) (NYSE: NWS) is one of the world's largest media conglomerates. Its chief executive officer is Rupert Murdoch, an influential and controversial media tycoon. News Corporation is a public company listed on the New York Stock Exchange and as a secondary listing on the London Stock Exchange (LSE: NCRA). Formerly incorporated in Adelaide, Australia, the company was re- incorporated in the United States state of Delaware after a majority of shareholders approved the move on 12 November 2004. The company is still listed on the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX: NWS). News Corporation's United States headquarters is on Sixth Avenue (Avenue of the Americas) in New York City, in the 1960s-1970s portion of the Rockefeller Center complex. Revenue for the year ended 30 June 2005 was $23.859 billion. This does not include News Corporation's share of the revenue of businesses in which it owns a minority stake, which include two of its most important assets, DirecTV and BSkyB. Almost 70% of the company's sales come from its US businesses. Holdings: Film/TV Production and Distribution 20th Century Fox 20th Century Fox Home 20th Century Fox TV Fox Filmed Entertainment Fox 2000 Blue Sky Studios Fox Searchlight Pictures Fox Animation Studios(defunct) Fox Family World Wide Fox Sports Fox News IGN Entertainment Inc New World Communications Direct TV News Papers/Magazines/Publishers (select) New York Post The Times(Eng) The Sun (Eng) HarperCollins Ecco Press Perennial The Weekly Standard TV Guide Radio/Multimedia (select) Sky Radio Fox Sports Radio News American The Street.com Line One Orbis ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The Walt Disney Company (most commonly known as Disney) (NYSE: DIS) is one of the largest media and entertainment corporations in the world.
[Show full text]
Paramount Pictures
Before we start with the individual studios, let’s cover one additional situation. It didn’t really belong in the last chapter because it is more of a research problem. But it is one that should be addressed. Many of the major studios submitted their primary production code numbers to the Library of Congress. These records are a tremendous help with one caveat. Almost all of the production codes submitted DID NOT INCLUDE THE LETTER PREFIX THAT WAS ASSIGNED BY SOME OF THE INDIVIDUAL STUDIOS. So, while the production code number would be the same, only some have letter prefixes. In several instances, there are different letter prefixes. The bottom line is that numbers recorded at the Library of Congress may require additional research. Columbia Pictures Columbia’s production codes are by far the most confusing and most difficult to use for identification. This may be an indication that Columbia was not quite certain how to effectively number and utilize production codes. - - Columbia started production codes for their 1926- 1927 season. The first film to have codes was False Alarm, which was issued a “C-1” production code. They produced 24 films that season, marking them “C -1” through “C-24.” The Library of Congress records show only the numbers 1-24, but the stills reflect the letter “C,” a dash (-) and the number. The next season (1927-1928), they produced 30 films, with the first one being The Blood Ship. Instead of issuing new production codes, they simply started over with their numbering, marking them “C-1” through “C-30.” The next season (1928-1929), they produced 31 films, starting with Court Martial.
[Show full text]
(Walt Disney Pictures & Pixar Animation
Cast Crew Hanham Players Hanham Players Youth Group Act 2 – Creatures to Animals Frozen… (Walt Disney Animation Studios, Walt Disney Pictures, Walt Disney Studio Motion Pictures (2013)) Minions… (Illumination Entertainment & Universal Pictures International (2015)) The Nightmare Before Christmas… (Touchstone Pictures, Skellington Productions Inc., Tim Burton Productions & Walt Disney Pictures (1993)) Monsters Inc.… (Walt Disney Pictures, Pixar Animation Studios & Buena Vista International (2001)) Shrek… (DreamWorks Animation, DreamWorks SKG, Pacific Data Images & United International Pictures (2001)) There will be a 20 minute interval between the two acts. The use of photography and filming equipment is strictly prohibited. Aladdin… (Walt Disney Pictures, Silver Screen Partner, Walt Disney Feature Animation & Buena Vista International Monsters vs. Aliens… (DreamWorks Animation (2009)) (1992)) Despicable Me… (Universal Pictures, Illumination Entertainment & Universal Studios (2010)) Brave… (Walt Disney Pictures, Pixar Animation Studios & Walt Disney Studio Motion Pictures (2012)) Anastasia… (Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, Fox Animation Studios, Fox Family Films, The Big Gun Project, Little Wolf Entertainment & 20th Centure Fox (1997)) Toy Story… (Pixar Animation Studios, Walt Disney Pictures & Buena Vista International (1995)) Cars… (Walt Disney Pictures & Pixar Animation Studios (2006)) The Polar Express… (Castle Rock Entertainment, Shangri-La Entertainment, Playtone, ImageMovers, Golden Mean, Universal CGI, Warner Bros. & Park
[Show full text]
CPLG Expands Representation of Sony Pictures Consumer Products in EMEA
CPLG Expands Representation of Sony Pictures Consumer Products in EMEA London, UK, 12th September 2019: In a new agreement that expands on their current multi-year relationship in Italy and Spain, Sony Pictures Consumer Products has appointed CPLG as its licensing agent for additional EMEA markets: Benelux, France, Germany, Austria, Switzerland, the UK and Middle East. CPLG will represent Sony Pictures’ extensive and diverse theatrical film and TV catalogue, which includes much-loved blockbuster entertainment franchises such as Ghostbusters and Jumanji; Vivo, Sony Pictures Animation’s upcoming 2020 holiday release featuring original songs by Lin- Manuel Miranda; hit TV series such as Breaking Bad and its spin-off prequel Better Call Saul; the romantic sci-fi drama Outlander; the #1 hit series on YouTube Premium, Cobra Kai; and popular Columbia Pictures back-catalogue classics such as The Karate Kid and Poetic Justice. Leveraging its expertise in entertainment brand representation, CPLG will build extensive cross- category licensing programmes across the Sony Pictures portfolio, with immediate focus on the Ghostbusters franchise, which has embarked on a year-long celebration to mark its 35th anniversary with new products, events and collaborations and a new movie slated for summer 2020. Jamie Stevens, EVP Sony Pictures Consumer Products, said: “CPLG’s influence and pedigree in representing entertainment properties in these EMEA territories appealed to us when seeking a licensing agent to represent our diverse slate of properties and franchises. We look forward to collaborating with them to develop customized consumer product campaigns on a per territory basis.” Steve Manners, EVP, Business Development at CPLG, said: “We’ve already created exciting licensing programmes for Sony Pictures in Spain and Italy and we are delighted to now be working with Jamie and her team to expand that footprint.
[Show full text]