DOCSLIB.ORG

Australia's Security Relationship with the United States

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Australia's Security Relationship with the United States Calhoun: The NPS Institutional Archive Theses and Dissertations Thesis Collection 1991-12 From alliance to acquaintance: Australia's security relationship with the United States Taylor, Mark J. Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School http://hdl.handle.net/10945/27063 NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL Monterey, California THESIS FROM ALLIANCE TO ACQUAINTANCE i THE AUSTRALIAN - AMERICAN SECURITY RELATIONSHIP by Mark J. Taylor December, 1991 Thesis Advisor: Claude A. Buss Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. T258704 (Unclassified ) SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE la. REPORT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION lb. RESTRICTIVE MARKINGS UNCLASSIFIED 2a. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION AUTHORITY 3 . DISTRIBUTION/ AVAILABILITY OF REPORT Approved for public release; distribution unlimited 2b. DECIjVSSinCATION/DOWNGRADINGSaiEDULE PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMBER(S) 5. MONITORING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMBER(S) 6a. NAME OF PERFORMING ORGANIZATION 6b. OFFICE SYMBOL NAME OF MONITORING ORGANIZATION NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL 38 (If Applicable) 6c. ADDRESS (city, state, and ZIP code) 7b. ADDRESS (city, slate, and ZIP code) Monterey, CA 93943-5100 8 a. NAME OF FUNDING/SPONSORING 8b. OFFICE SYMBOL 9 . PROCUREMENT INSTR UMENT IDENTIFICATION NUMBER ORGANIZATION (If Applicable) 8c. ADDRESS (city, suae, and ZIP code) 10. SOURCE OF FUNDING NUMBERS PROGRAM PROJECT TASK WORK UNIT ELEMENT NO. NO. NO. ACCESSION NO. 1 1 . TITLE (Include Security Classification) FROM ALLIANCE TO ACQUAINTANCE: THE AUSTRALIAN-AMERICAN SECURITY RELATIONSHIP 12. PERSONAL AUTHOR(S) Mark J. Taylor 13a. TYPE OF REPORT 13b. TIME COVERED 14. DATE OF REPORT (year, month.day) 15. PAGE COUNT Master's Thesis JUL 90 TO DEC 91 91 December 19 370 16. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTATION The views expressed in this thesis are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Government of Australia or of the Australian Department of Defence. 17. COSATI CODES 18. SUBJECT TERMS (continue on reverse if necessary and identify by block number) FIELD GROUP SUBGROUP Australia; Colonial Defence; National Defence; Foreign Policy; International Relations; United States; Great Britain; Military Alliances; ANZUS; SEATO Australian History. Southeast Asia; Japan; World War I; World War II. 19. ABSTRACT (Continue on reverse if necessary and identify by block number) This thesis explores the development of Australian concepts of n ational security, in the context of traditional and continuing psychological dependency upon its links of alliance to the West. The Government claims that Australia's policy of defence self- reliance within an alliance framework is a 'conceptual watershed' that has 'liberated' Australian foreign policy; but it is an old theme in defence policy. Australia still awaits a real revolution in its security concepts and sense of regional and world identity. ANZUS, symbol of Australia's ties to the western community, and the false impressions and expectations it creates, now acts more to inhibit than to assist Australia's future growth as a nation. 20. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY OF ABSTRACT 21. ABSTRACT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION (X) UNClj\SSIFIED/UNLIMrrED ( ) SAME AS RPT. ( ) DTK USERS UNCLASSIFIED 22a. NAME OF RESPONSIBLE INDIVIDUAL 22b. TELEPHONE (Include Area Code) 22c OFFICE SYMBOL Claude A. Buss 408-646- 2935 NS/BX DD FORM 1473, 84 MAR 83 APR edition may be used until exhausted SECURITY CLASSIHCATION OF THIS PAGE All other editions are obsolete Unclassified Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. From Alliance to Acquaintance: Australia's Security Relationship With The United States by Mark J. Taylor Commander, Royal Australian Navy Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN NATIONAL SECURITY AFFAIRS from the NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL December 1991 i i . TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION: STILL WAITING FOR THE REVOLUTION 1 I THE AUSTRALIAN-AMERICAN RELATIONSHIP 22 Amae: The Dependency Syndrome 2 5 WHERE IT ALL BEGAN 29 The Search for Security 29 The Colonies: Enterprise and Enervation 3 3 Internal Ideological Conflict 36 Misconstrued Inspiration 40 II EVOLVING SECURITY PERCEPTIONS TO 1918 48 THE COLONIAL ERA 49 Denial By Acquisition 49 Denial by Regulation - Race Patriotism 50 The South Pacific Monroe Doctrine 54 AFTER FEDERATION - PRIDE AND PREJUDICE 58 Cognitive Denial: the Yellow Peril 58 EASTERN MENACE 63 A Glimpse of Salvation 63 A Home Truth From Admiral Sperry 65 THE ROAD TO WAR AND "GLORY" 68 Antipathies and Passionate Attachments 68 Australia • s "Splendid Little War" 70 "Thank God We Have Had An Australian Navy" 72 LOST VICTORY 76 Slave to its Affection 76 Conscription: "One Part Against Another" 79 National-Imperial Schizophrenia 82 iii . T; 6,1 Astray From its Duty or its Interest 84 THE REASON WHY 87 III PARIS TO PEARL HARBOUR 90 HAPLESS RESULT OF A "HAPPY ENCOUNTER" 90 "Honorary Diggers" 90 Mistaken Identity: Australia at War's End 94 "Sympathy For The Favourite Nation" 95 Hughes and Wilson at Versailles 97 Some Unfortunate Precedents 101 The 1921 Imperial Conference 103 The Washington Naval Conference 108 SHARING THE BURDEN OF EMPIRE 113 Trade: A Losing Battle With America 113 Imperial Preferences: "Enmities of Another 115 Imperial Defence: Growing Doubts 120 Australia's Imperial Identity 124 One Last Try For Imperial Defence 128 A DARKENING HORIZON 129 "A Hell of a Way Off" 131 Australia ' s "Melancholy Duty" 133 Regional Weakness 141 IV. CHANGING HORSES: THE WAR IN THE PACIFIC 144 Australia: Desirable But Non-Essential 154 COLD COMFORT FROM UNCLE SAM 156 To The Limits of Mateship 169 The ANZAC Pact 171 Relegation 176 IV • Winding Down 178 Eine Kleine Schmaltzmusik 180 War's End - War's Beginning 190 V. ILLUSORY MATESHIP: 1945 - 1972 194 Frozen Out and Frozen In 195 Salvation II - ANZUS 205 Not Quite All The Way 235 VI. PARTNERSHIP: WHITLAM TO HAWKE 244 THE WHITLAM SHOCKS, 1972-75 244 Postscript: Too Much Too Soon 2 52 "CERTAIN CORRECTIVES" : FRASER, 1976-83 260 THE DROVER'S DOG: HAWKE, 1983-1991 266 "Concerned to do Nothing" 2 69 "Brave Little New Zealand" 272 "After ANZUS - More ANZUS" 278 Discord With Indonesia 284 Straining the Bonds 289 VII. PREPARING FOR THE NEXT CENTURY 294 WHITHER ANZUS? 298 Return of the Prodigal?" 298 "Shoulder to Shoulder" - or Head to Tail? 300 Trade: The "Bad Old Days"? 305 Trade: Divergent Interests 308 The US : Changing Tack 311 FUTURE PROSPECTS 317 A New Cold War? 321 Goodbye To All That 324 AUSTRALIA: CATHARSIS OR STASIS? 326 The Security Outlook 330 New Identities , New Ideas 337 VIII. CONCLUSION 342 BIBLIOGRAPHY 354 VI . EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This thesis explores the development of Australian concepts of national security, in the context of traditional and continuing psychological dependency upon its links of alliance to the West. The Government claims that Australia's policy of defence self-reliance within an alliance framework is a 'conceptual watershed' that has 'liberated' Australian foreign policy; but it is an old theme in defence policy. Australia still awaits a real revolution in its security concepts and sense of regional identity. ANZUS, symbol of Australia's ties to the western community, and the false impressions and expectations it creates, now acts more to inhibit than to assist Australia's future growth as a nation. George Washington observed that "the nation which indulges toward another an habitual hatred, or an habitual fondness, is in some degree a slave" and that a truly independent nation bent upon charting its own course in the world "may safely trust to temporary alliances for extraordinary emergencies". Australia's own history points to the enduring good sense of those observations. There is little more to be gained from alliance than from acguaintance - and to sustain the latter, existence of the former is neither necessary nor desirable as a permanent state of affairs. Both Australia and the United States can in the future "safely trust to temporary alliances for extraordinary emergencies" The need for an independent national defence was recognised before Federation in 1901. However, Australians lacked confidence in their ability to survive as a fully independent nation. Australian national interest was identified with supporting the British Empire, and in maintaining a racially pure "British" society. There also developed a belief in some kind of informal Anglo-Saxon brotherhood that carried with it a moral obligation for America as well as Britain to help protect the 'indefensible continent* against an invasion by an Asian power. Still, Australia developed its own defence policy and acquired a navy of its own; but it continued to allow foreign and economic policy mostly to be determined in London. World War I saw Japan and Australia cooperate to eliminate Germany's Pacific presence before the end of 1914. Australia was safe, but felt obliged to send troops and its navy to support Britain in the northern hemisphere. From this point onward, Australia was drawn ever more toward the notion of a global Imperial Union, with common defence, foreign and economic policies, coordinated from London. The practical difficulties of this were identified and ignored. Australia forsook self-reliance for the promise of British assistance in time of threat, in return for Australia's commitment to Imperial (British) interests. Australian support for Britain hobbled relations with America, but in December 1941 Britain could not provide the promised "main fleet to Singapore". Australia's troops and airmen
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Isolationism & Appeasement in Australia E. M. Andrews
    > Isolationism & Appeasement ü w* in Australia C /3 Reactions to the European Grises, 1935-1939 ‘They tell me things are not too good in Europe, Dave.’ ‘What’s wrong? Drought?’ ‘Unk’ White, Bulletin, 26 July 1939 E. M. Andrews Australian foreign policy in the late 1930s has till now been a neglected topic in historical writing. In this book the author examines Australian reactions to the aggressions which led to World War II — Abyssinia, Spain, Austria, Czecho­ slovakia, and Poland. He describes the early support in Britain and Australia for the League of Nations, and goes on to discuss the causes of the change to a policy of appeasement, culminating in the Munich crisis of 1938, and Australian reactions to that crisis. Additionally, he compares Australian foreign policy at that time and in the sixties, when Australia again supports a powerful ally, this time in Vietnam. To those who lived through the crises of the thirties and now wish to see those years in perspective, as well as to readers of a younger generation, who seek the causes for the development of present-day attitudes to Australian foreign policy, this book will make absorbing reading. For teachers and students of the history of the period it will provide a welcome insight into the reactions of Australian politicians and people to the European crises and to Britain’s part in them. Price in Australia $6.95 This book was published by ANU Press between 1965–1991. This republication is part of the digitisation project being carried out by Scholarly Information Services/Library and ANU Press.
    [Show full text]
  • Whitlam As Internationalist: a Centenary Reflection
    WHITLAM AS INTERNATIONALIST: A CENTENARY REFLECTION T HE HON MICHAEL KIRBY AC CMG* Edward Gough Whitlam, the 21st Prime Minister of Australia, was born in July 1916. This year is the centenary of his birth. It follows closely on his death in October 2014 when his achievements, including in the law, were widely debated. In this article, the author reviews Whitlam’s particular interest in international law and relations. It outlines the many treaties that were ratified by the Whitlam government, following a long period of comparative disengagement by Australia from international treaty law. The range, variety and significance of the treaties are noted as is Whitlam’s attraction to treaties as a potential source of constitutional power for the enactment of federal laws by the Australian Parliament. This article also reviews Whitlam’s role in the conduct of international relations with Australia’s neighbours, notably the People’s Republic of China, Papua New Guinea, Indonesia and Indochina. The reconfiguration of geopolitical arrangements is noted as is the close engagement with the United Nations, its agencies and multilateralism. Whilst mistakes by Whitlam and his government are acknowledged, his strong emphasis on international law, and treaty law in particular, was timely. It became a signature theme of his government and life. CONTENTS I Introduction .............................................................................................................. 852 II Australia’s Ratification of International Treaties .................................................
    [Show full text]
  • NRO Mission Ground Station Declassification "Questions and Answers"
    , On Octcbor 15, 2008, 1'I!X'r Becames UNCP'SSII'IED • National Reconnaissance Office Mission Ground Station Declassification "Questions and Ansvers" Question 1: (U) Why has the National Reconnaissance Office (NRO ) decided now to acknowledge locations of mission ground stations? Answar 1: (U) Mr. Scott Large, NRO Director, in consultation with the DNI, made the decision to declassify the locations of our mission ground stations as a strategic move in keeping with our need to provide on-demand surveillance for real-time engagement by policy and military decision makers. The intent is to ensure that the NRO can fully support the new technical and policy initiatives developed across the Department of Defense (000) and the Intelligence Community (IC). (U) The NRO has taken great strides this year to transform the organization so that it is best aligned to improve acquisitions and deliver improved intelligence data access, content, and timeliness. Question 2: (U) What is Being Declassified? (S//REL) Acknowledgement of NRO domestic Mission Ground Stations (MGSs) and overseas NRO presence begins on 15 October 2008. (S//'l'K//REL) What has been declassified is the "fact of" the NRO operating MGSs at the following locations: a. Aerospace Data Facility (ADF)--Colorado (ADF-C), located on Buckley Air Force Base, Colorado • On October 15, 2008, TEXT Becomes UNCLASSIFIED • • On October 15, 2008, TEX't Becames UNCI·aSSJ:I'J:BD b. ADF-East (ADF-E ), located on Fort Belvoir, Virginia c. ADF-Southwest (ADF-SW), located at White Sands, New Mexico (SI/~R/fREL ) Also declassified is the -fact of U the NRO having a presence at: a.
    [Show full text]
  • INDEPENDENT and PEACEFUL AUSTRALIA NETWORK (IPAN) Oct 2016
    Quaker Peace & Legislation Committee WATCHING BRIEF WB 16-8: INDEPENDENT AND PEACEFUL AUSTRALIA NETWORK (IPAN) Oct 2016 As Quakers we seek a world without war. We seek a sustainable and just community. We have a vision of an Australia that upholds human rights and builds peace internationally, with particular focus on our region. In our approach to government we will promote the importance of dialogue, of listening and of seeking that of God in every person. We aim to work for justice and to take away the occasion for war. This Brief provides a summary of IPAN’s aims and activities. Quakers are affiliated to IPAN through QPLC. Recently IPAN held its annual meeting in Alice Springs NT in conjunction with a protest gathering at Pine Gap Base to mark its 50th anniversary. Background IPAN has emerged from the wider peace movement and, according to its website – www.ipan.org.au – is “a network of organisations from all regions of Australia who are united by our support for an independent Australian foreign policy based on peaceful resolution of conflict”. At its first AGM, held in July 2015 and attended by 40 groups, a Brisbane Declaration affirmed: Australia urgently needs an independent foreign policy that de-escalates regional tensions. Australia’s alliance with the USA should be re-assessed in view of US adventurism and drawing Australia into its strategic plans. The US ‘pivot’ to Asia/Pacific increases the likelihood of war. The Australian Government unfettered level of military spending is to be deplored. We will build links with peace movements in our region.
    [Show full text]
  • Australian Democrats.[1]
    CHIPP, Donald Leslie (1925–2006)Senator, Victoria, 1978–86 (Austral... http://biography.senate.gov.au/chipp-donald-leslie/ http://biography.senate.gov.au/chipp-donald-leslie/ Don Chipp's Senate career almost never happened. Dropped from Malcolm Fraser's Liberal Party ministry in December 1975, he turned this career blow into an opportunity to fight for the causes in which he believed. The result of Chipp's personal and political upheaval was the creation of a third force in Australian politics, the Australian Democrats.[1] Donald Leslie Chipp was born in Melbourne on 21 August 1925, the first child of Leslie Travancore Chipp and his wife Jessie Sarah, née McLeod. Don's father Les was a fitter and turner who later became a foreman. With Les in regular employment during the 1930s, the Chipp family was cushioned from some of the harsher aspects of the Depression years. However, the economic downturn must have had some impact, because Don remembered his father saying to his four boys that 'When you all grow up, I want you to be wearing white collars. White collars, that's what you should aim at'. Chipp matriculated from Northcote High School at the age of fifteen, then worked as a clerk for the State Electricity Commission (SEC). He also began studying part-time for a Bachelor of Commerce at the University of Melbourne. In 1943, at age eighteen, he joined the Royal Australian Air Force, and spent much of the last two years of the Second World War undergoing pilot training within Australia. Discharged as a Leading Aircraftman in September 1945, Chipp took advantage of the Commonwealth Reconstruction Training Scheme which provided ex-service personnel with subsidised tuition and living allowances.
    [Show full text]
  • Presidential Handwriting File, 1981-1989
    PRESIDENTIAL HANDWRITING FILE: PRESIDENTIAL RECORDS: 1981-1989 – REAGAN LIBRARY COLLECTIONS This collection is available in whole for research use. Some folders may still have withdrawn material due to Freedom of Information Act restrictions. Most frequent withdrawn material is national security classified material, personal privacy, protection of the President, etc. PRESIDENTIAL HANDWRITING FILE: PRESIDENTIAL RECORDS: 1981-1989 The Presidential Handwriting File is an artificial collection created by the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM). The Presidential Handwriting File consists of a variety of documents that Ronald Reagan either annotated, edited, or wrote in his own hand. When documents containing the president's handwriting were received at WHORM for filing, the original was placed in the Presidential Handwriting File and arranged by the order received. A photocopy of the document was placed in the appropriate category of the WHORM: Subject File. The first page of the casefile was stamped Handwriting File, indicating the location of the original documents. However, WHORM often failed to indicate on the original documents the original location (i.e. the six digit tracking number, Subject Category Code). The Presidential Handwriting File, as created by the White House, did not contain handwriting found in staff and office files. The Library will be creating a further series of handwriting material from staff and office files. In order to provide better access to the Presidential Handwriting File, the collection has been arranged into six series. Each series is arranged chronologically by the date of the document. Each document has been marked with the appropriate WHORM: Subject File category and a six digit tracking number.
    [Show full text]
  • Whitlam and China
    WHITLAM AND CHINA Prime Ministers Series November 2014 FRONT COVER IMAGE: Gough and Margaret Whitlam visit the Temple of Heaven in Beijing November, 1973. © File photo/NLA/Xinhua CONTENTS Introduction 4 Whitlam and China: 6 Transcript of Panel Discussion, Sydney, November 6 2014 A Note from Graham Freudenberg - Terrill and Taiwan (November 9 2014) 35 Whitlam Timeline 38 Further Reading 40 The Panellists 42 Published by Australia-China Relations Institute (ACRI) University of Technology, Sydney PO Box 123 Broadway NSW 2007 Australia t: +61 2 9514 8593 f: +61 2 9514 2189 e: [email protected] w: www.acri.uts.edu.au © Australia-China Relations Institute (ACRI) 2015 ISBN 978-0-9942825-0-7 The publication is copyright. Other than for uses permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced by any process without attribution. INTRODUCTION ACRI is proud to have hosted this discussion of Gough Whitlam’s 1971 visit which opened up the contemporary relationship between Australia and China. It is sad that we weren’t able to interview Gough Whitlam about China in the way we intend to interview other Australian Prime Ministers. But we are honoured to add this transcript to the many tributes to Australia’s 21st Prime Minister. In our panel conversation, a long-term Whitlam advisor and friend, 81 year old Graham Freudenberg, recreated the tension around the visit. Mr Whitlam was Opposition Leader; he was taking a political risk in going to ‘Red China’. Mr Freudenberg, a master of story- telling, captured the sense of excitement felt by the Whitlam party encamped at the Peking Hotel.
    [Show full text]
  • The Union of National Economic Associations in Japan
    No.27 ISSN 0289 - 8721 NAL ECO IO N Information Bulletin of T O A M N I C F A O The Union of National S N S O O I C N I Economic Associations A U T E I O H T N S in Japan 日本経済学会連合 2007 THE UNION OF NATIONAL ECONOMIC ASSOCIATIONS IN JAPAN 日本経済学会連合 The Union of National Economic Associations in Japan, established in 1950, celebrated its 50th anniversary in 2000, as the sole nationwide federation of associations of scholars and experts on economics, commerce, and business administration. In order to obtain membership an association is subject to an examination of its academic work. As of 2007, the Union had a membership of 63 associations, as listed on pp.66-87. The aims and objectives of the Union are to support the scholarly activities of its member associations and to promote academic exchanges both among members themselves, and between Japanese and academic societies overseas. The main activities of the Union are: (1) the publication and distribution of academic material concerning Japanese economics and papers presented by member scholars, (2) the sending of members to overseas conferences, (3) the holding and supporting of international conferences in Japan, (4) providing financial assistance to member associations who invite foreign scholars to Japan, and (5) collecting information on activities of member associations and the issuing of a news bulletin. The Union published in 1974 Keizaigaku No Doko (The Trend in Japanese Economics), based on a survey of economic studies undertaken in postwar Japan. A supplementary volume covering Japanese economic studies after 1974 was published in 1982.
    [Show full text]
  • Stan Deyo – the Cosmic Conspiracy
    Recruited by the Illuminati, Stan Deyo was taken secretly to Australia in 1971 to design "flying saucer" propulsion systems with them. Deyo reveals years later why "they" keep the alien/UFO agenda from the public. Many have investigated this huge conspiracy from the outside looking in - BUT, only one has come forward from an insider's perspective. Stan Deyo's The Cosmic Conspiracy is his testimony to you who would know the truth.... Table of Contents Proclaimer..................................................................................................................................................5 Section I - Preface.................................................................................................................................7 Prelude to Action........................................................................................................................................7 Section I - Chapter 1............................................................................................................................11 Sightings and Suspicions..........................................................................................................................11 THE AUSTRALIAN INCIDENT.......................................................................................................11 THE TIME SLIP.................................................................................................................................12 THE IRANIAN INCIDENT...............................................................................................................13
    [Show full text]
  • Reiner, Martha
    Asia-Pacific Transnational and Inter-regional Contexts of Scientific Enterprise Development Martha L. Reiner Ph.D. business and public policy University of California at Berkeley, M.A. English Florida International University, graduate study in history College of William and Mary, A.B. history Duke University This study explores transnational and inter-regional parallels and connections in basic science, technological innovation and commercialization, scientific and technological expertise formations, and technologically based development in the Asia-Pacific region during the early and mid 20th century, also considering late 19th century situations. Path dependence and discontinuities, institutional change and organizational development including patent and securities systems and medical, scientific, and engineering publishing are of interest, along with technological innovation and market development linkages, geographic contexts and demographic change, and individual and institutional leadership. East-west linkages in the late 19th century occurred around developments including the Yugoslavian Nicola Tesla’s wireless wave transmission and Thomas Edison’s electrical generator and distribution systems, as uranium mining developed in the western United States and South Africa, as X-ray science and technology developed. Westinghouse, a competitor of GE’s, gained rights to Tesla’s alternating current motor technology, a technology apparently referred to, likely along with high-energy detonation, in New York Times stories about technology diffusion during the 1884 Philadelphia Electrical Exhibition, as the Sino-France conflict developed.1 The Paris 1 Michael Aaron Dennis, “Accounting for Research: New Histories of Corporate Laboratories and the Social History of American Science,” Social Studies of Science 17.3 (August 1987), 483. Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property was adopted in 1883.
    [Show full text]
  • William Mcmahon: the First Treasurer with an Economics Degree
    William McMahon: the first Treasurer with an economics degree John Hawkins1 William McMahon was Australia’s first treasurer formally trained in economics. He brought extraordinary energy to the role. The economy performed strongly during McMahon’s tenure, although there are no major reforms to his name, and arguably pressures were allowed to build which led to the subsequent inflation of the 1970s. Never popular with his cabinet colleagues, McMahon’s public reputation was tarnished by his subsequent unsuccessful period as prime minister. Source: National Library of Australia.2 1 The author formerly worked in the Domestic Economy Division, the Australian Treasury. This article has benefited from comments provided by Selwyn Cornish and Ian Hancock but responsibility lies with the author and the views are not necessarily those of Treasury. 83 William McMahon: the first treasurer with an economics degree Introduction Sir William McMahon is now recalled by the public, if at all, for accompanying his glamorous wife to the White House in a daringly revealing outfit (hers not his). Comparisons invariably place him as one of the weakest of the Australian prime ministers.3 Indeed, McMahon himself recalled it as ‘a time of total unpleasantness’.4 His reputation as treasurer is much better, being called ‘by common consent a remarkably good one’.5 The economy performed well during his tenure, but with the global economy strong and no major shocks, this was probably more good luck than good management.6 His 21 years and four months as a government minister, across a range of portfolios, was the third longest (and longest continuously serving) in Australian history.7 In his younger days he was something of a renaissance man; ‘a champion ballroom dancer, an amateur boxer and a good squash player — all of which require, like politics, being fast on his feet’.8 He suffered deafness until it was partly cured by some 2 ‘Portrait of William McMahon, Prime Minister of Australia from 1971-1972/Australian Information Service’, Bib ID: 2547524.
    [Show full text]
  • Prince Philip Knighthood Is Heck of an Own Goal for Tony Abbott
    Prince Philip knighthood is heck of an own goal for Tony Abbott THE AUSTRALIAN JANUARY 28, 2015 12:00AM Janet Albrechtsen Columnist Sydney THERE is no polite way to describe the Prime Minister’s decision to award a knighthood to Prince Philip. Let’s opt for a rough Latin phrase that sums up the comments of some of Tony Abbott’s close Liberal MPs: Caput ex ano extrahe. It’s something about a head being within close proximity of a backside. And when you get text messages from conservative friends in Queensland asking, “Has Tony completely lost the plot?” you know 2015 is starting out as an annus horribilis for Abbott and the government. The unanswered question is: why? If the PM didn’t foresee that this decision would be controversial, raise questions about his judgment and potentially damage his leadership, you have to ask: why not? If the PM knew all of that, you have to ask why he did it. Clearly the uproar is not simply on social media. The criticism extends beyond anonymous graffiti on the side of a building, as the PM has described it. Abbott’s captain’s call picked an unnecessary fight over a minor issue on Australia Day when MPs would be chatting among themselves and with voters at functions. The common sentiment was utter bewilderment. The year needed to kick off with a great start. A good start was not enough. Instead, it’s kicked off with one heck of an own goal. And the eternal lesson of politics is that people can hate you, even distrust you, but when people, apart from your usual critics, start to ridicule you, it’s difficult to recover.
    [Show full text]