THE REPUBLIC A JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY AND HISTORICAL DEBATE No 4 Spring 2005 Editors: Finbar Cullen Aengus Ó Snodaigh Published by the Ireland Institute, 2005 Copyright © The Republic and the contributors, 2005 ISSN 1393 - 9696 Cover design: Robert Ballagh The Republic aims to provide a forum for discussion, debate and analysis of contemporary and historical issues. Irish and international matters across a range of disciplines will be addressed. Republican ideas and principles will shape and inform the contents of the journal. Our aim is to serve a general rather than a specialist readership. The opinions expressed in the articles do not necessarily represent those of the Ireland Institute. Correspondence to: The Editors, The Republic, The Ireland Institute, 27 Pearse Street, Dublin 2 or e-mail
[email protected] Visit the journal's web site at http://www.republicjournal.com Cover photograph by Robert Ballagh 1916 Monument at Arbour Hill, Dublin, with Proclamation carved by Michael Biggs Layout and design by Éamon Mag Uidhir Printed by CRM Design & Print, Dublin CONTENTS Editorial 5 In Praise of ‘Hibernocentricism’: Republicanism, Globalisation and Irish Culture 7 P. J. MATHEWS Multiculturalism, Secularism, and the State 15 TARIQ MODOOD Why France, Why the Nation? 31 JULIA KRISTEVA Cultúr an Phoblachtánachais faoi Léigear 46 TOMÁS MAC SÍOMÓIN The Cultural Turn versus Economic Returns: The Production of Culture in an Information Age 60 PASCHAL PRESTON Peadar O’Donnell, ‘Real Republicanism’ and The Bell 80 LAWRENCE WILLIAM WHITE Exploding the Continuum: The Utopia of Unbroken Tradition 100 RAYMOND DEANE ‘Our songs are our laws …’—Music and the Republic (Part 2) 116 PATRICK ZUK Debate Culture, Politics and Civil Society: The Role of the Critical Journal 133 ROY JOHNSTON The Contributors 151 CULTURE IN THE REPUBLIC (PART 2) EDITORIAL EASY ASSUMPTIONS about Ireland’s sense of itself and Irish exceptionalism have not stood up well to recent developments.