Maori Purpose Zone As Notified in the PAUP

BEFORE THE AUCKLAND UNITARY PLAN INDEPENDENT HEARINGS PANEL

IN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991 and the Local Government (Auckland Transitional Provisions) Act 2010

AND

IN THE MATTER of TOPIC 080g Rezoning and Precincts (General)

AND

IN THE MATTER of the submissions and further submissions set out in the Parties and Issues Report

EVIDENCE REPORT ON SUBMISSIONS BY JYM HALLAM CLARK ON THE MĀORI PURPOSE ZONE

3 DECEMBER 2015

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. SUMMARY ...... 1 PART A: OVERVIEW AND BACKGROUND ...... 1 2. INTRODUCTION ...... 1 3. CODE OF CONDUCT ...... 1 4. SCOPE ...... 2 5. INTERIM GUIDANCE FROM THE PANEL ...... 2 6. APPROACH TO ZONING WITHIN THE PAUP ...... 3 7. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK ...... 3 8. PAUP FRAMEWORK TO THE MĀORI PURPOSE ZONE ...... 3 PART B –REZONING SUBMISSIONS AND ANALYSIS ...... 5 9. ZONING SUBMISSION THEMES ...... 5 10. ANALYSIS OF ZONING SUBMISSIONS ...... 6 11. EXPLANATION OF MAPPING ...... 7 12. CONCLUSIONS ...... 7 ATTACHMENT A: STATEMENT OF EXPERIENCE ...... 9 ATTACHMENT B: ZONING ANALYSIS AND PLANNER POSITION ...... 10 ATTACHMENT C: ANALYSIS OF SUBMISSIONS ...... 16

1. SUMMARY

1.1 The purpose of this Evidence Report (Report) is to consider zone-specific submissions and further submissions to the Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan (PAUP) for Topic 080g Rezoning and Precincts General (Topic 080g) in relation to the spatial extent of the Special Purpose - Māori Purpose zone.

1.2 The Report includes my proposals on whether the council supports or does not support the submissions, in full or in part, and what amendments, if any, should be made to address matters raised in submissions.

1.3 In summary I consider that six existing marae in Auckland should be rezoned as Māori Purpose, as requested by submissions. This would ensure that most marae in Tamaki Makaurau have a zone which reflects the social the cultural outcomes of the marae activity. In addition, I support all the locations of the Maori Purpose zone as notified in the PAUP.

1.4 I do not support submissions seeking to remove the Maori Purpose zone at Te Atatu Marae or add it to new locations such as cultural redress properties which have public open space and conservation values, such as rezoning the Tūpuna Maunga.

PART A: OVERVIEW AND BACKGROUND

2. INTRODUCTION

2.1 The purpose of this Report is to consider submissions and further submissions received by the Council in relation to the spatial extent of the Special Purpose - Māori Purpose zone and in particular requests to rezone specific sites.

2.2 This Report has been prepared by Jym Hallam Clark. My qualifications and experience is attached in Attachment A.

2.3 The Report includes my proposals on whether to support or not support the submissions, in full or in part, and what amendments, if any, should be made to address matters raised in submissions.

3. CODE OF CONDUCT

3.1 I confirm that I have read the Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses contained in the Environment Court Practice Note 2014 and that I agree to comply with it. I confirm

Page 1

that I have considered all the material facts that I am aware of that might alter or detract from the opinions that I express, and that this Report is within my area of expertise.

4. SCOPE

4.1 I am providing an evidence report in relation to submissions received to rezone sites from and to the Special Purpose - Māori Purpose zone across the Auckland region.

4.2 In preparing this Report I have relied on the Auckland-wide evidence of John Duguid for Topic 080 and Topic 081 Rezoning and Precincts Geographic (Topic 080) which sets out the statutory framework, methodology, principles and section 32 evaluations, used to guide the development and application of zones and precincts. I have read and accept this evidence.

4.3 My response to the submissions regarding Puketutu Island has been prepared in conjunction with Ms Lucy Deverall, and should be read in conjunction with the parts of the Public Open Space Rezoning Evidence, dated 3 December 2015.

4.4 I have previously prepared primary1 and rebuttal2 evidence with respect to the objectives, polices and methods for the Maori Purpose zone for Topic 036. With respect to the Maori Purpose zone, my evidence did not propose to make significant changes generally as there were few submissions with respect to it, and the zone provisions were in a workable condition at notification of the PAUP. Changes were made to the objectives and policies to reflect the changes made to the Auckland-wide Maori Land and Treaty settlement land sections which have similar objectives and policies.

5. INTERIM GUIDANCE FROM THE PANEL

5.1 The Panel has provided interim guidance with respect to rezoning which I have read, the following in particular:

(a) Chapter G: General Provisions, dated 9 March 2015;

(b) Best practice approaches to re-zoning and precincts, dated 31 July 2015;

1 Statement of primary evidence of Jym Hallam Clark, notably section 16, dated 17 April 2015. 2 Statement of rebuttal evidence of Jym Hallam Clark, notably section 11, dated 18 May 2015.

Page 2

6. APPROACH TO ZONING WITHIN THE PAUP

6.1 The Council’s zoning principles are set out in Mr Duguid’s statements of evidence for Topic 080, dated 3 December 2015 I have read and agree with this evidence.

6.2 Section 32 and 32AA

6.3 As outlined in the Auckland Unitary Plan Evaluation Report (the Evaluation Report), the Council has focussed its section 32 assessment on the objectives and provisions within the PAUP that represent significant changes in approach from those within the current operative Auckland RMA policies and plans. Whilst the Evaluation Report applies to the entire plan, the report targets the 50 topics where the provisions represent a significant policy shift.

6.4 The spatial extent to which the Māori Purpose zone is applied does not reflect a major policy shift from the operative plans which are evaluated in this Report in accordance with the s32 analysis which was notified with the PAUP. The new locations proposed in this evidence would continue to apply to marae and other Maori cultural and educational institutions in the same way as the legacy plans.

7. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK

7.1 The statutory framework is detailed in the evidence of Mr Duguid, dated 3 December 2015 and is not repeated here.

8. PAUP FRAMEWORK TO THE MĀORI PURPOSE ZONE

8.1 The approach of providing for the Māori Purpose zone within the Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan (PAUP) was discussed in my evidence on behalf of Auckland Council for Topic 036. In my evidence, I supported the retention of the Māori Purpose zone,3 Including objectives and policies which allow the Māori Purpose zone to be located in urban, rural and coastal areas, including beyond the Rural Urban Boundary (RUB).

8.2 The PAUP Regional Policy Statement recognises Maori economic, social and cultural development as an issue of significance to Mana Whenua (B5.3). With respect to the Maori Purpose zone, B5.3 provides for the development of Maori cultural institutions (Policy 4) and provides for papakāinga, marae, customary use, cultural activities and commercial activities across urban and rural Auckland (Policy 1). The Maori Purpose zone is recognised as a regulatory method in B5.3.

3 Jym Clark, Topic 036 EIC, paragraphs 10.4 – 10.6.

Page 3

8.3 The notified PAUP specifically provides for Māori cultural, social and economic activities on their ancestral lands through the Auckland-wide Māori land and Treaty settlement land provisions, as well as the Special Purpose – Māori Purpose zone. The Māori Purpose zone provisions enables papakāinga, small scale care centres and retail, marae, education facilities, organised sport, urupā and other activities which provide for Māori cultural activities.

8.4 The range of activities provided in the Māori Purpose zone is also provided for in other urban PAUP zones, typically requiring a restricted discretionary or discretionary resource consent. Notably, the Māori Purpose zone permits marae and associated activities and provides for these to be co-located.

8.5 The Māori Purpose zone is mostly a rollover of legacy plan Māori special purpose zones4. Five additional locations were included in the Māori Purpose zone for the notification of the PAUP in 2013. The PAUP has 15 Māori Purpose zone locations, mostly marae, but also includes kura kaupapa Māori (schools) and urupā.

8.6 Locations of the rollover of this zone from legacy plans are:

 Awataha Marae, Akoranga Drive

 Ōrakei (Bastion Point), Kupe Street and Kepa Road, Ōrakei

 Te Piringatahi o te Maungaarongo Marae, Luckens Road, West Harbour

 Te Atatu Marae, Harbour View Reserve, Te Atatu Road

 Te Henga Marae, Bethells Road, Bethels Beach

 Makaurau Ihumatao Road, Mangere

 Pukaki Road, Mangere

 Umupuia Marae, Maraetai Coast Road

 Matahuru Papakāinga, Miro Road, Mangere Bridge

 Ōtara Marae, Alexander Crescent, Ōtara

 Manurewa Marae, Finlayson Avenue, Manurewa

 Hoani Waititi Marae, Pars Cross Road, Glen Eden

4 Legacy plans which have a Māori special purpose zone equivalent: Waitakere, Auckland City Isthmus, Manukau, North Shore.

Page 4

And, additional locations as notified in the PAUP:

 Te Onekiritea / Bomb Point, Hobsonville

 Puketutu Island, Mangere

 Pukaki urupā, Puhinui

8.7 The locations listed above are shown in a map in Attachment D.

PART B –REZONING SUBMISSIONS AND ANALYSIS

9. ZONING SUBMISSION THEMES

9.1 A total of 108 submission points were received by the Council requesting relief in relation to the Māori Purpose zone. Of the submission points received:

(a) Three (3) submissions seek that the Māori Purpose zone be retained at three separate locations;

(b) Forty seven (47) submissions are seeking the Māori Purpose zone in new locations;

(c) Fifty (50) submissions are seeking to remove the Māori Purpose zone from Te Atatu Marae at Orangihina / Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu;

(d) Seven (7) submissions seek to rezone part of Māori Purpose zone to another zone which will provide for the same or similar outcomes;

(e) One (1) submission seeks to rezone Treaty settlement land and Maori land from the Rural Coastal zone to Rural Production zone (miscoded submission);

(f) Two (2) submission points from Auckland Council seek to rezone two foot access way strips at Ōrākei which are gazetted reserves.

9.2 Eighteen (18) themes emerge based on the six broader groupings listed above. Typically each of these themes has one submission point which seeks that the Maori Purpose zone is identified in various locations across the Auckland region.

Page 5

10. ANALYSIS OF ZONING SUBMISSIONS

10.1 Attachment B contains my analysis and position with regard to the themes raised above in submissions requesting relief in relation to the zoning of Special Purpose – Māori Purpose zone.

10.2 In undertaking this analysis I have had regard to:

(a) Deeds of settlement for Treaty settlements in Tamaki Makaurau, Office of Treaty Settlements (OTS)

(b) Māori land online maps, by the Māori Land Court, Ministry of Justice

(d) Environment Court decision, Te Atatu Residents and Ratepayers Association Inc. v Waitakere City Council, dated 25 July 2007, ref. W041/07.

10.3 Almost half of all submissions were received with respect to removing the Māori Purpose zone from Orangihina / Harbourview Reserve. I do not support these submissions as the establishment of a marae at this location has been identified in the operative Waitakere Plan section which was given effect to by a 2007 Environment Court decision.

10.4 No other submissions were received to remove the Maori Purpose zone in any other location as notified in the PAUP.

10.5 The other half of submissions received to this Topic 080 sought that the Maori Purpose zone be identified in additional locations. I support two of these submissions which will rezone six existing marae to Maori Purpose. These marae are located in the South Kaipara: Rewiti, Haranui, Kakanui, Araparera, Puatahi, and at Point Chevalier: Mahurehure marae.

10.6 In respect of the remainder of the submissions which seek to rezone to Maori Purpose, either I do not support them, or I propose an alternative approach in a small number of instances. I give a range of reasons for not supporting a Maori Purpose zone. Generally these are areas where the notified PAUP zone would more appropriately provide for the existing and future anticipated activities. In some instances, not enough information has been provided by the submitter to justify why the Maori Purpose zone would be more appropriate, such as giving a context for the future anticipated use and development of a site.

Page 6

10.7 Attachment C contains my analysis and position on individual submissions.

10.8 My proposed response to submissions can be summarised as follows:

(a) I support retention of the Māori Purpose zone in notified locations;

(b) I support rezoning six existing marae to Māori Purpose;

(c) I do not support requests for Māori Purpose zone for land returned for cultural redress which has public open space and conservation values;

(d) I do not support requests for Māori Purpose zone on land which is yet to be returned as part of a Treaty settlement;

(e) I do not support requests for Māori Purpose zone on land which has existing zones which provide for existing activities better than the Māori Purpose zone would.

11. EXPLANATION OF MAPPING

11.1 Attachment E contains two maps for each of six locations which are proposed to be rezoned Maori Purpose. The first map for each location shows the notified PAUP zone and the second shows the extent of rezoning.

11.2 Having regard to the requirements of section 32 and 32AA of the RMA and the other statutory criteria of the RMA outlined in the evidence of Mr Duguid and the matters raised by submitters, I consider that the proposed zoning changes are appropriate because additional existing marae will be identified, therefore ensuring a consistent approach across the region.

12. CONCLUSIONS

12.1 I have considered the submissions received on the Māori Purpose rezoning. I consider that the zoning changes proposed by the Council as set out in the maps included within Attachment E meet the purpose of the Act.

Jym Hallam Clark

3 December 2015

Page 7

Attachment A – Statement of experience Attachment B – Rezoning analysis and planners position Attachment C – Analysis of submissions Attachment D – Existing locations of Māori Purpose zone Attachment E – Additional locations of Māori Purpose / Proposed zoning changes

Page 8

ATTACHMENT A: Statement of experience

Career Summary: Jym Hallam Clark

 Planner, Unitary Plan, Auckland Council: February 2012 to present  Planner, Resource Consents, Auckland Council / Waitakere City Council: January 2009 – June 2011  Planner (part-time, student role), Haines Planning: Part time July 2008 – December 2008.  Planner (summer role), MWH International: November 2007 – February 2008.  Planner (part-time), Planning Help Desk, Auckland City Environments, Auckland City Council: December 2006 – October 2007.

Qualifications

Batchelor of Planning with honours, University of Auckland, 2008

Affiliations

Graduate member of the New Zealand Planning Institute

Page 9

ATTACHMENT B: Zoning Analysis and Planner Position

THEME OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS PLANNER’S POSITION Orangihina / Harbourview Submitters seek to rezone Māori Purpose zone within Proposal: Submissions are not supported and the Maori Purpose zone at Orangihina should remain as Reserve Orangihina / Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu Peninsula to a notified. Public Open Space zone. Submitters have sought that the Maori Purpose zone be removed and replaced with a Public Open Space zone for reasons of: public access, including access for horse riders, ecological values and maintaining the remnant coastal edge characteristics.

The Maori Purpose zone at Orangihina is a roll over from the legacy Operative Waitākere Section “Special Purpose: Marae”. The zone covers approximately 2.5 ha of land within the southern extent of the Orangihina Reserve and is as such surrounded by the Public Open Space – Informal Recreation zone. The Maori Purpose zone is located approximately 100m from the coastal edge at its closest point. Orangihina Reserve is covered by the Outstanding Natural Feature overlay – ID 40, Harbour View Pleistocene terraces.

This zone was identified in plan change 2 of the Operative Waitakere Section in 2003 as part of a wider review of the Harbourview Park land. The plan change became operative on 23 July 2007 on the decision of the Environment Court (W041/2007). The plan change to establish the Marae zone was the result of a long standing movement to establish a marae in Te Atatu. As well as the plan change, Waitakere City Council, now Auckland Council would provide land within the Orangihina Reserve to establish a the marae.

It was found by the Environment Court that development of the park and marae would be compatible within the receiving environment at that time. The Court decision recognised that development of a marae should be designed to ensure that adverse effects on natural resources, landscape character and qualities should be maintained, whilst recognising that landscape character may change provided that it is managed to be visually compatible with the receiving environment.

As addressed in the legal closing statement for Topic 036,5 it is considered that the is no need to incorporate the outcomes of the 2007 Environment Court decision into the PAUP on the basis that the existing and future planned environment has changed substantially since that time, and the Maori Purpose zone provisions will be sufficient for the site and its context.

It is noted that applications and ongoing appeals through the courts have been occurring with respect to how the land was required for port activities under the Public Works Act and how it was later transferred to a Auckland Council reserve without it being offered back to the original owners. The Appeal Court has made a decision in faviour of Auckland Council. It remains to be seen if this will be taken to the Supreme Court.

Maunga Submitters seek to rezone maunga within Tūpuna Maunga o Proposal: Submissions are not supported, the Maunga should retain the Public Open Space zones as notified. Tamaki Makaurau Authority to the Māori Purpose zone. Parts of the maunga returned under the Tūpuna Maunga o Tamaki Makaurau Settlement Act are: Maunga are zoned by the PAUP with a Public Open Space zone, mostly POS Conservation, although some  Maungakiekei, POS – Sport and Active Recreation and POS - Informal is present, which is appropriate given that this identifies  Mangere Mountain, present activities, such as sports fields. The exception is that Matukutururu / Wiri is zoned for Quarry Purposes. Given that Matukutururu is an Outstanding Natural Feature and of significance to Mana Whenua, it should be  Matukutururu, zoned Public Open Space – Conservation.  Maungarei, A Public Open Space zone is more appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the conservation and  Maungaika, recreational attributes of the maunga. A Māori Purpose zone would introduce activities such as dwellings which  Maungawhau, in most circumstances would not be appropriate on the maunga. It is noted that an Integrated Management Plan, under the Reserves Act 1978 is being drafted for the  Owairaka, management of the maunga and is anticipated to be operative by mid-2016. Any activity or development

5 Closing statement and points of clarification on behalf of Auckland Council, by Jennifer Caldwell, Leigh Walker and James Hassall, Topic 036, paragraph 6.4, dated 15 September 2015.

Page 10

THEME OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS PLANNER’S POSITION  Puketapapa, identified in the Integrated Management Plan will be permitted by the Public Open Space zone. Specific  Mount St John, activities on part of the maunga sought by iwi or the Tūpuna Maunga Authority may be addressed in this manner.  Ohinerau,  Ohuiarangi,  Otahuhu,  Rarotonga,  Takarunga,  Te Tatau a Riukiuta. Future Treaty settlement Marutūāhu Iwi seek to rezone the following sites to Māori Proposal: Submission is not supported to rezone various locations across Auckland to Maori Purpose zone. Purpose:  Motuora motu The change is not supported as Marutūāhu Iwi are yet to conclude Treaty settlement negotiations with the  Tritiri Matangi motu Crown to settle their historical Treaty claims. In May 2013 Marutūāhu Iwi and the Crown signed a record of  Motuihe motu agreement that lists potential settlement properties the Crown could vest as part of a collective Treaty  Schoolhouse Bay properties, Kawau Island settlement, many of which are similar to the locations sought to be rezoned Māori Purpose. It is not considered  Mahurangi Scenic Reserve appropriate to rezone land for Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, without the Crown’s  Blackettes Point, Parnell (Gladstone Road) agreement. When settlement properties transfer, Marutūāhu Iwi can seek to rezone them as Māori Purpose.  Mangarei manuga (Homestead Drive)  Fort Takapuna  Mechanics Bay (Stanley St / Beach Rd)  19-23 Anzac St & 1-3 The Terrace Takapuna  35 Grafton Rd, Grafton  Panmure Probation Centre &  Boston Road Probation Centre  45, 47 & Calliope Rd, Devonport [sic.]  Tamaki Leadership Centre property, Whangaparaoa  De-gaussing property, Shakespeare Regional Park Whangaparaoa  Torpedo Bay Naval Museum  NZDF Housing Blocks (94 Lots) – Potter/Greenslade: Tennyson; Corella; Alamein  21-23 Waikare Rd, Waiheke Island  18 Jellicoe Parade Waiheke Island  Takarunga maunga  Maungaika maunga Details regarding each of the sites and the extent of the land have not been provided by Marutūāhu. Muriwai Ngati Whatua o Kaipara seek that a large block of land Proposal: Submission is not supported to rezone land at Muriwai from Rural Production to Maori Purpose. retuned via a Treaty settlement adjacent and to the north of the Muriwai settlement be rezoned Māori purpose. It is not considered appropriate to rezone this site as it would substantially increase the extent of which Muriwai is an un-serviced settlement, more robust consideration is needed before this change can be made. There is an opportunity for the iwi to develop in accordance with the Auckland-wide Treaty settlement land provisions given that the land has been returned from the Crown. The investigation of a new precinct can consider if any rezoning is also appropriate over all or part of the site. South Kaipara marae Ngati Whatua o Kaipara seek that all Māori land around five Proposal: Submission is supported in part, and the sites occupied by Rewiti, Haranui, Kakanui, Araparera and marae of the South Kaipara be rezoned to Māori Purpose Puatahi marae be rezoned from Rural Production and Rural Coastal zones to Maori Purpose zone. zone. The five marae are (south to north):  Rewiti (near Woodhill) Some of the largest Māori land blocks of Tamaki Makaurau are present in the South Kaipara area around the  Haranui (north of Parakai) five marae listed. All land is identified with a Rural Production or Rural Coastal zone. Development of this land for papakāinga and other activities which support Māori social, cultural and economic

Page 11

THEME OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS PLANNER’S POSITION  Kakanui wellbeing is provided for in accordance with the Auckland-wide Māori land section. It is recognised that the  Araparera Māori Purpose zone provides for a greater extent of development in terms of the range and intensity of development, including housing.  Puatahi (adjacent to the Hoteo River) It is recognised that the five marae operate as a cultural and social centres for the hapū which associate with each of these marae. Development at each of the sites generally consists of a wharenui and wharekai, with kāinga located on adjacent Māori land blocks. It is recognised that further development Māori Reservations which the marae complex’s reside on would be appropriate to create a strong focal point for Māori social, cultural and supporting economic development. Recognising the site with a Māori purpose zone within the cadastral boundaries of each marae is proposed to achieve this. South Kaipara ancestral land Ngati Whatua o Kaipara seek to rezone commercial Treaty Proposal: Submission is not supported, the land should retain the Rural Coastal zone and not the to Rural settlement land and Māori land located between Muriwai and Production zone as sought. Kaipara South Head from Rural Coastal: West Coast area to Rural Production. Where appropriate, based on visual The land has been identified as Rural Coastal zone by a recent decision by the Environment Court via Rodney assessment, the Rural Coastal zone should be retained only section Plan Change 132. Any changes to the Rural Production zone would be inconsistent with this decision. where land is directly adjacent to the coastal edge and lakes. Te Mahurehure Marae Rezone 65 Premiere Avenue, Point Chevalier from Proposal: Submission is supported, the land at Mahurehure marae at 65 Premiere Avenue, Point Chevalier Community Open Space to Māori Purpose. from Public Open Space – Community to Maori Purpose.

The change of zone is supported given that the site is privately owned. Council’s approach to the Public Open Space zone is that it should only apply to publicly owned land, or private land which has the express permission of the landowner to do so. Also, the Maori Purpose zone is appropriate as there is an established marae, including a wharenui, wharekai and a hall which is better provided for by the objectives, policies and rules of the Māori Purpose zone rather than those of the Public Open Space – Community zone.

Urquharts Peninsula Rezone land on Urquharts Peninsula (NA17C/1398 Lot 1 DP Proposal: Submission is not supported to rezone land at Urquharts Peninsula from Rural Coastal to Maori 58566) from Rural Coastal to Māori Purpose. Purpose.

Given the land is Maori Land under Te Ture Whenua Maori Act 1993, the land may utilise the Auckland-wide Māori land section rules. The subject site is used for farming and two buildings are located near the coast which are possibly used as a dwelling. The Māori Purpose zone is not appropriate given the large extent of the site which could give rise to significant permitted development in a rural location. There are no existing developments such as marae which makes the application of the Maori Purpose zone appropriate. No information has been supplied which supports the future development aspirations of the site. Cronin Road, Pukekohe Rezone land at 45-49 Cronin Road, Pukekohe from Rural Proposal: Submission is not supported to rezone land at 45-49 Cronin Road, Pukekohe from Rural Production Production to Māori Purpose. to Māori Purpose.

The present Rural Production zone is sufficient to provide for the current rural use. No detail has been provided which indicates what the future intended use of the site will be which might give rise to the appriate application of the Maori Purpose zone. 1995 Raupatu Settlement Rezone land in rural areas returned under the 1995 Raupatu Proposal: Submission is not supported to rezone land returned by the 1995 Raupatu Treaty settlement to settlement as commercial redress to Māori Purpose zone. Maori Purpose.

The sites returned to Tainui through the 1995 Raupatu Treaty settlement are located within the Pukekohe urban area. These sites have appropriate urban zones and provide for sufficient future development. No detail has been provided which indicates what the future intended use of the site will be and why the Maori Purpose zone would be appropriate in these locations. Puketutu Island Rezone Puketutu Island to Public Open Space Conservation Proposal: Submission is supported in part, the Maori Purpose zone as notified in the PAUP should remain, as zone and Māori Purposes zone. well as the Quarry zone, the Public Open Space – Informal Recreation zone should be rezoned Public Open Space – Conservation zone.

The freehold title of Puketutu Island is with the Island Trust comprising six representatives from three iwi. A Governance Trust, with four trustees from the same iwi, Watercare and Auckland Council provide a forum to

Page 12

THEME OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS PLANNER’S POSITION consider issues relating to the island, including allocation of funding for development of the island.

The area zoned Special Purpose – Quarry zone (“the Quarry zone”) reflects the Watercare designation area, the purpose of which is to rehabilitate the island for the future use as a public park. The designation allows the application of biosolids to land, landform rehabilitation and associated activities. In 2014, Watercare obtained a lease for 55 years which is the anticipated timeframe for completion of rehabilitation. Rehabilitation will be staged and the development programme and landscape plans have not yet been produced. Detailed design works will be produced at the time of each stage.

Living Earth Limited has a lease over a portion of land contained within the southern section of the Quarry zone. The lease expires in 2024, with a right of renewal until 2027. There is an existing resource consent enabling a green waste recycling operation, approved by the Environment Court in 2006.

Auckland Council has a renewable lease for 999 years with the purpose to provide a public park in perpetuity. It is the intention that as rehabilitation stages are complete, land will be transferred to council for public park. This purpose to rehabilitate the island for use as a public park is reflected in the designation and the Governance Deed of Trust.

The request to rezone the existing park areas from Public Open Space – Informal Recreation to Public Open Space – Conservation (‘Conservation zone’) is supported. Under the operative plan the island is identified as being a Outstanding Natural Feature and contains a number of waahi tapu and archaeological sites. This is reflected in the overlays under the proposed plan. The objectives and policies of the Conservation zone provides for a higher level of protection for the significant cultural and heritage values than the Informal Recreation zone. The Conservation zone would provide for the development of appropriate recreational infrastructure.

The request to rezone the Quarry zone to Conservation zone is not supported. Both Watercare and Living Earth have long-term property rights and approvals to undertake activities with effects which are inconsistent with the objectives, policies and rules of the Conservation zone. Those effects are also now part of the existing and future environment.

With regards to the Watercare lease area, the existing activity to fill the closed quarry with biosolids from the nearby wastewater treatment facility is projected to operate for 54 years. The programme and design of works is an evolving project and will be subject to change over time, subject to resource consent. Areas of land within the Watercare lease area which are not for the direct application of bio solids may be required to accommodate associated activities such as lay-down areas, temporary stormwater mitigation devices and the storage of machinery.

With regards to the Living Earth operation located near the southern shore of Puketutu Island, resource consents have been obtained to provide for the composting of green waste and associated activities. Although some regional consents for the operation will expire shortly, there is scope to renew those consents and the operation has land use consent to operate indefinitely. It is noted that the Quarry zone does not specifically provide for green waste recycling activities. However, it is considered that the objectives, policies and methods in the Quarry zone are better suited to monitor the potential environmental effects of the activity than the Conservation zone would.

A separate submission was received from Living Earth Ltd requesting the zone boundaries be amended to accurately reflect the consented area. Under the notified version of the PAUP, the Quarry zone does not cover all of the originally consented area of works. This has been supported as the Quarry zone is more appropriate to monitor potential effects of the activity. This is addressed further in the evidence report by Carol Stewart, Anthony Reidy, Lucy Deverall and Juliana Cox entitled ‘Topic 080: Rezoning, Public Open Space Zones’ and dated 3 December 2015.

Page 13

THEME OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS PLANNER’S POSITION

It is considered that the Conservation zone would be appropriate to provide for the long-term strategic vision for Puketutu Island as a public regional park. However, this vision will be not achieved over the entire Island for a minimum of 54 years. The Quarry zone is more appropriate than the Conservation zone to accommodate the longevity and changing nature of the Watercare and Living Earth activities. As rehabilitation progresses, there will be opportunities to review the zoning of the Island at the time of future plan reviews.

The matters regarding Puketutu Island have been prepared in conjunction with Ms Lucy Deverall, and should be read in conjunction with the parts of the Public Open Space Rezoning Evidence, dated 3 December 2015. Outside of the scope of this submission, it is noted that the reclaimed land adjoining Puketutu Island, including Island Road has been zoned incorrectly or has a Coastal Transition zone which has an uncertain interpretation given that it adjoins two zone. Under the operative plan, this land was designated Watercare Services Ltd: Wastewater Treatment Plan. It is Coastal Transition Zone under the PAUP. This zone is inappropriate as these areas of land have legal titles. Lot 1 DP 156421 is south of Island Road and Lot 2 DP 156421 is north of Island Road.

Watercare as the landowner and requested at a meeting 26 November 2015 that the land to the north of Island Road which contains the stormwater ponds should be Rural Production. The remaining land along the northern boundary of the island and the land adjoining the island to the south of Island Road was requested to be rezoned to Public Open Space – Conservation to be consistent with the adjoining park. It is considered appropriate to rezone the land as described as the activities are in keeping with the relevant objectives and policies of each zone.

Cultural redress land Te Kawerau a Maki that the properties returned via a Treaty Proposal: Submissions are not supported to rezone Treaty settlement cultural redress land form Public Open Settlement Act as cultural redress should be zoned Māori Space to Maori Purpose except to retain the Maori Purpose zone at Te Onekiritea Point which was notified as Purpose, these are for Te Kawerau a Maki: such in the PAUP.  Henderson Valley Scenic Reserve  Swanson Conservation Area The other cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act statuses and has public open space and conservation values. It is appropriate that it retains a Public Open Space zone to ensure that these value are  Te Henga Recreation Reserve [7ha and 1ha] appropriately maintained and enhanced.  Motutara Settlement Scenic Reserve.  Parihoa [Muriwai Marginal Strip, 2.03ha and 0.5248ha]  Te Onekiritea Point  Te Kawau Pa on Tiritiri Matangi Island

And Marutūāhu:  Mahurangi Scenic reserve

Paremoreremo Prison Rezone the 31.9155 ha prison housing property, subject to Proposal: Submission is not supported to rezone the Pareremoremo Prison housing land from Countryside Housing potential purchase under differed selection (Treaty settlement Living to Maori Purpose. land for Te Kawerau a Maki and Ngati Whatua o Kaipara) from Countryside Living to Māori Purpose The Prison housing land is subject to differed selection under the deeds of settlement for Te Kawerau a Maki and Ngati Whatua o Kaipara. The land has not yet been purchased by iwi as differed selection and it remains owned by the Department of Corrections. The land is also still subject to designation for prison purposes. It would not be appropriate to change the zone until, or if the land is transferred to iwi. The Prison Housing land should be revisited for rezoning and a potential precinct if the Department of Corrections disposes of it.

Ōrākei non-Māori purpose NZ Institute of Architects and the Urban Design Forum seek Proposal: Submissions are supported in part to rezone land at Ōrākei from Maori Purpose to a range of other that properties within the Māori Purpose zone at Ōrākei urban zones. These changes are considered and reflected in Topic 081.

Page 14

THEME OVERVIEW OF SUBMISSIONS PLANNER’S POSITION should be rezoned with a mix of general urban zones. The Māori Purpose zone will be maintained in most parts of Ōrākei as it is appropriate for the location and allows for a wide range of activities. Land will be rezoned from Maori Purpose to Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone at the ends of Te Arawa, Rukutai and Aotea Streets as part of the rezoning for Topic 081. Ōrākei Public open space Auckland Council seek that two pedestrian access ways, Proposal: Submissions are not supported to rezone the legal access ways from Māori Purpose to Public Open legally described as Lot 6 DP 92924 and Lot 7 DP 92925 be Space – Informal Recreation. rezoned Open Space Informal Recreation from Māori Purpose. It is not considered necessary to amend the zone as the surrounding zone, including the zone which the pedestrian access way provides access to is Māori Purpose. The Maori Purpose zone provides for informal recreation activities. Cultural zone The Urban Design Forum and the NZ Institue of Architect Proposal: Submissions are not supported to rezone land at Manurewa and Te Hana Domain to an unknown seek to rezone land on Mahia Road and Sykes ‘cultural zone’, possibly Maori Purpose. An alternative identification of Public Open Space – Community is Road, Manurewa as shown from Mixed Housing Suburban to supported at Te Hana. Retain residential zone at Manurewa. ‘Special Purpose – cultural zone’. Similarly the Te Hana The land at Manurewa is zoned Mixed Housing Suburban and occupied by a religious organisation. The Community Development Charitable Trust seeks to rezone purposes of the Māori Purpose zone would not align with the current land use. There is no specific ‘cultural the Te Hana Domain to a special purpose zoning (Community zone’ as sought by the submitters. Marae and Māori Culture Centre). Similarly there is no cultural zone as sought at Te Hana, I do not support the Māori Purpose zone for the Domain which is owned by council but leased to an operator of a ‘model Māori village’ tourist activity. I consider that alternative relief be given by rezoning from the split Public Open Space – Sport, and Informal Recreation to Public Open Space – Community to reflect the present development and activity. Retain Retain Māori Purpose zone at 50 Alexander Cr, Otara and Proposal: Submissions are supported to retain land at 50 Alexander Cr, Otara as Maori Purpose. Pukaki Marae and associated urupa. See primary evidence of Jym Clark on behalf of Council for Topic 036.

Page 15

ATTACHMENT C: Analysis of Submissions

Page 16 SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 1563-1 Miss Melissa Rezone Harbourview Park, Te Atatu, from Maori Purpose to Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Public Open Space. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council. 1764-1 Ngati Whatua o Kaipara Rezone the 31.9155 ha property bounded by Paremoremo North Countryside Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; Land still owned by Ministry of Corrections. Not yet No change No and Te Kawerau a Maki Scenic Reserve to the north, Paremoremo Prison to the Living SUPPORT RETAIN aquired through differed selection. south-west and rural-residential lifestyle blocks to the south- east from Countryside Living to Special Purpose - Maori Purpose zone [refer to submission page 4/8 for details]. Paremoreremo Priso 1846-1 John Fawcett Delete the Maori Purpose zone in Harbourview Reserve Te Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Atatu Peninsula. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

1869-1 David P C Smith Remove the Special Purpose-Maori Purpose zone from Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Harbour View Reserve, Te Atatu Peninsula. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

1869-3 David P C Smith Prohibit any Zoning for development in Harbour View Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Reserve, Te Atatu peninsula in perpetuity [Retain as public Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by open space]. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

2043-1 Jane Gilmour Remove the Special Purpose-Maori Purpose zone from Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Harbour View Reserve, Te Atatu Peninsula. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

2043-3 Jane Gilmour Prohibit any Zoning for development in Harbour View Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Reserve, Te Atatu Peninsula in perpetuity. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

2067-2 Te Hana Community Rezone Allot 272, Te Hana, from Rural Production to Cultural zone North POS - Sport Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; Land is the Te Hana Domain which is owned by Split POS - No Development Charitable operative special purpose zoning (Community Marae and Active SUPPORT council. Rezoning to POS - Community rather than Sport and Trust Māori Culture Centre). Recreation and ALTERNATIVE ZONE two other POS zones (split) would better reflect the Passive POS - Informal present level of development and activity. Recretion to Recreation POS - Community 2159-2 Te Atatu Pony Club [Delete provisions that provide for] a Marae on the land Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No used for the Te Atatu Pony Club. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

2385-1 Stan Baron Remove the Special Purpose - Maori Purpose zone from Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

2385-3 Stan Baron Amend to prohibit Zoning for development of any kind in Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu, in perpetuity. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

4321-111 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Henderson Valley Scenic Reserve to Maori Cultural redress West Public Open Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) Purpose, which is cultural redress settlement land. Refer to land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural pages 28 and 64/117 of submission. Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a Public Open Space zone. SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 4321-112 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Swanson Conservation Area to Māori Purpose, Cultural redress West Public Open Maori Purpose None DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) which is cultural redress settlement land. Refer to pages 28 land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural and 65/117 of submission. Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a Public Open Space zone. 4321-113 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Te Henga Recreation Reserve [7ha and 1ha] to Cultural redress West Public Open Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) Maori Purpose, which is cultural redress settlement land. land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural Refer to pages 28, 61, 62/117 of submission. Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a Public Open Space zone. 4321-114 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Motutara Settlement Scenic Reserve to Maori Cultural redress West Public Open Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) Purpose, which is cultural redress settlement land. Refer to land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural pages 28 and 60/117 of submission. Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a Public Open Space zone. 4321-115 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Parihoa [Muriwai Marginal Strip, 2.03ha and Cultural redress North Public Open Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) 0.5248ha] to Maori Purpose, which is cultural redress land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural settlement land. Refer to pages 28 and 63/117 of Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a submission. Public Open Space zone. 4321-116 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Te Onekiritea Point to Maori Purpose, which is Cultural redress West Maori Purpose SUPPORT; RETAIN Land notified with Maori Purpose zone. No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) cultural redress settlement land. Refer to pages 28 and land 66/117 of submission. Maori Purpose 4321-117 Te Kawerau a Maki Rezone Te Kawau P─ü on Tiritiri Matangi Island to Maori Cultural redress North Public Open Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (Attn: Edward Ashby) Purpose, which is cultural redress settlement land. Refer to land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural pages 28 and 67/117 of submission. Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a Public Open Space zone. 5100-27 Forest and Bird Motu Rezone Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu Peninsula, for Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Manawa Restoration recreational activities compatible with protection of the Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by Group resources. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5149-10 Kirsten McLeod Retain the whole area of Harbourview Park as a reserve. Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5189-1 Heather Steadman Rezone the Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu from Maori Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Purpose to to Public Open Space. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5275-1 Caroline Panesar Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu, from Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Special Purpose Maori zone to undeveloped open space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by parkland. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5276-1 Jo Major Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu, from Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Special Purpose Maori zone to undeveloped open space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by parkland. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5277-199 The Urban Design Rezone land on Kiwi Mahia Road and Sykes Cultural zone Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; No Forum New Zealand Road, Manurewa as shown in the submission [refer to page SUPPORT RETAIN 36/104] from Mixed Housing Suburban to Special Purpose. Land is occupied by a religious organisation which South Mixed Housing s has not requested a change in zone. No change SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 5277-239 The Urban Design Rezone land on Ngati Whatua O Orakei as shown in the Orakei non-Maori Central Maori Purpose Neighbourhood DO NOT SUPPORT; No Forum New Zealand submission [refer to page 48/104] from Special Purpose to purpose Centre & Mixed SUPPORT RETAIN zone allows for a range of activities which is also Neighbourhood Centre and Mixed Housing Suburban. Housing supported by the Ōrakei precinct contained in the Suburban PAUP. No change 5280-201 The New Zealand Rezone land on Kiwi Mahia Road and Sykes Cultural zone Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; No Institute of Architects Road, Manurewa as shown in the submission [refer to page SUPPORT RETAIN 36/104] from Mixed Housing Suburban to Special Purpose. Land is occupied by a religious organisation which South Mixed Housing s has not requested a change in zone. No change 5280-241 The New Zealand Rezone land on Ngati Whatua O Orakei as shown in the Orakei non-Maori Central Maori Purpose Neighbourhood DO NOT SUPPORT; No Institute of Architects submission [refer to page 48/104] from Special Purpose to purpose Centre & Mixed SUPPORT RETAIN zone allows for a range of activities which is also Neighbourhood Centre and Mixed Housing Suburban. Housing supported by the Ōrakei precinct contained in the Suburban PAUP. No change 5287-1 Elizabeth Grimmer Rezone all of Harbourview Orangahina, Te Atatu Peninsula Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No (including the Special Purpose zone) to an open space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone that Retains the natural open space character and a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to provides for passive recreation, but excludes the park from be established and is still supported by council. being leased to groups, and limit development to basic facilities for passive recreation. 5291-1 Sandra Galbraith Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula, from Special Purpose Maori zone to an open Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5293-1 Joanne Ramsay Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula, from Special Purpose Maori zone to an open Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5295-1 Warwick Aspin Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula, from Special Purpose Maori zone to an open Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5296-1 Lisa Aspin Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula, from Special Purpose Maori zone to an open Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5297-1 Peter Gilbert Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula, from Special Purpose Maori zone to an open Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5298-1 Cheryl J Blanch Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula, from Special Purpose Maori zone to an open Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5322-1 Michael P Martin Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Atatu Peninsula, from Māori Special Purpose zone to an Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by Open Space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council. SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 5336-1 Garry McKenzie Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5336-1 Garry McKenzie Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5342-1 Andrea G Hotere Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5344-1 Ann McKenzie Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5349-1 Kulwinder S Panesar Rezone Harbourview Orangihina Reserve, Te Atatu, from Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Special Purpose zone to an Open Space zone. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5351-1 Brad Morrow Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5353-1 Bernadette McBride Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5357-1 Andrew J D White Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council. SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 5357-1 Andrew J D White Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5360-1 Lloyd Blanch Rezone Orangihina Reserve [465 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Peninsula] from Maori Purpose zone to an Open Space Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5415-1 Kimina Styche Rezone Orangihina Reserve at 465 Te Atatu Road, Te Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Atatu Peninsula from Special Purpose: Maori, to a Public Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by Open Space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5417-1 Birgit Wendt-Dickson Rezone Orangihina Reserve at 465 Te Atatu Road, Te Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Atatu Peninsula from Special Purpose: Maori, to a Public Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by Open Space zone. a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5552-1 Lauren Kirkley Delete the Maori Purpose zone from the site at 465 Te Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Atatu Road, Te Atatu Peninsula. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

5716-2340 Auckland Council (Attn: Rezone Lot 6 DP 92924 [Rukutai Street, Orakei] from Maori Orakei open space Central Maori Purpose Public Open None DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered necessary to amend the zone to No change No Stephen Town) Purpose to Public Open Space Informal Recreation. Refer Space - Informal SUPPORT RETAIN Open Space Informal Recreation as the surrounding to submission [Volume 4, page 34/35 and Volume 25, page Recreation zone including the zone which the foot access way 200/439]. provides access to from a road is also Māori Purpose. 5716-2366 Auckland Council (Attn: Rezone Lot 7 DP 92925 [Aotea Street, Orakei] from Maori Orakei open space Central Maori Purpose Public Open None DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered necessary to amend the zone to No change No Stephen Town) Purpose to Public Open Space Informal Recreation. Refer Space - Informal SUPPORT RETAIN Open Space Informal Recreation as the surrounding to submission [Volume 4, page 34/35 and Volume 24, page Recreation zone including the zone which the foot access way 203/439]. provides access to from a road is also Māori Purpose. 5716-3414 Auckland Council Retain the Special Purpose - Maori Purpose zone at 50 Retain South Maori Purpose Maori Purpose No Alexander Cr, Otara [Refer to Otara - Papatoetoe Local Supported. See primary evidence of Jym Clark on Board Views, Volume 26, page 7/103]. SUPPORT; RETAIN behalf of Council for Topic 036. No change SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 5728-1 Nicholas Keating Rezone 465 Te Atatu Road Te Atatu Peninsula [Harbour Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No View Reserve] from Special Purpose/Maori Purposes to Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by Public Open Space a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

Zone the Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu (being the land Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No between Te Atatu Road, Harbourview Road, Motorway, Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by Danica Esplanade and Province Esplanade, Longbush a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to 5787-1 Sid Suha Aksoy Road and Riverside Road) to ensure there is no be established and is still supported by council. development of buildings, and to retain the area as open space. 5818-12 Ngati Whatua o Kaipara Rezone the land shown in submission pg 13/21, vol 2 Muriwai Rural Maori Purpose It is not considered appropriate to rezone this site as No from Rural Production to Special Purpose: Maori Purpose. Production Māori purpose as it would effectively increase the DO NOT SUPPORT; extent of Muriwai, leave for precint to potentially North SUPPORT RETAIN manage. No change Rezone ancestral land located between the requested South Kaipara North Rural Coastal Rural Production ONC HNC DO NOT SUPPORT; Land has been carefully identified as Rural Coastal No change No Special Maori Purpose zone at Muriwai land to the Kaipara ancestral lands SUPPORT RETAIN zone by a recent decision by the Environment Court harbour (see map in Submission pg 11/11, vol 1) via Rodney section Plan Change 132. from Rural Coastal: West Coast area to Rural Production. 5818-7 Ngati Whatua o Kaipara Where appropriate, based on visual assessment, the Rural Coastal zone in the Kaipara harbour and South Head area should be retained directly adjacent to the coastal edge and lakes only within this landholding. 5818-9 Ngati Whatua o Kaipara Rezone the Maori land from Rural zone to Special Maori North Rural Maori Purpose SEA, HNC Rezoning support existing marae activities and No Purpose zone at the five marae of South Kaipara, namely Production and (one location) recognises these locations as a cultural centre. Haranui [64 Haranui Road, Parakai], Reweti, Kakanui, Rural Coastal SUPPORT; PARTIAL Surounding Maori land may utilise Auckland-wide Maori Purpose Araparera and Puatahi. South Kaipara marae CHANGE maori land rules. zone 6050-1 Coral Wong Delete the Maori Purpose zone from Harbourview Reserve, Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Te Atatu. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

6050-1 Coral Wong Delete the Maori Purpose zone from Harbourview Reserve, Orangihina West Maori Purpose Public Open ONF DO NOT SUPPORT; Retain zone as a roll over from the legacy Waitakere No change No Te Atatu. Space SUPPORT RETAIN Section “Special Purpose: Marae” and recognised by a 2007 Environment Court Decision. Marae is yet to be established and is still supported by council.

6092-18 Waikato-Tainui Te Rezone land in rural areas returned under the 1995 1995 Raupatu Urban zones Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; Sites have appropriate urban zones given their No Kauhanganui Raupatu settlement as commercial redress to Maori Settlement SUPPORT RETAIN location and provide for sufficient future Incorporated Purpose zone. South development. No change 6092-46 Waikato-Tainui Te Rezone land at 45-49 Cronin Road, Pukekohe from Rural Cronin Road South Rural Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; The Rural Production zone proposed at 45-49 Cronin No Kauhanganui Production to Maori Purpose. Production SUPPORT RETAIN Road is sufficient to provide for the current rural use Incorporated of the site. No change 6386-18 Te Akitai Waiohua Retain the Maori Purpose zoning as it applies to the Pukaki Supported. See primary evidence of Jym Clark on No Waka Taua Trust Marae and Urupa landholdings. Retain South Maori Purpose Retain SUPPORT; RETAIN behalf of Council for Topic 036. No change 6386-226 Te Akitai Waiohua Rezone Puketutu Island to Public Open Space Puketutu Island South Maori Purpose, Maori Purpose ONF; Maori SUPPORT; PARTIAL The existing Maori Purpose zone is supported to be Public Open No Waka Taua Trust Conservation zone and Maori Purposes zone. Quarry, POS - Cultural CHANGE retained. The request to rezone the existing park Space - Informal Informal Heritage areas from Public Open Space – Informal Recreation Recreation and recreation overlays to Public Open Space – Conservation (‘Conservation Coastal zone’) is supported. Under the operative plan the Transition zone island is identified as being an Outstanding Natural to be rezoned Feature and contains a number of waahi tapu and Public Open archaeological sites. This is reflected in the overlays Space - under the proposed plan. The Quarry zone to the Conservation. notified extent is supported given that it will continue to provide for the rehabilitation activity and green waste recycling activity.

6386-41 Te Akitai Waiohua Retain Maori Purposes zone as it applies to the land at Supported. See primary evidence of Jym Clark on No Waka Taua Trust Pukaki Marae & urupa. Retain South Maori Purpose Retain SUPPORT; RETAIN behalf of Council for Topic 036. No change 6488-100 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Maungauika (North Head) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 6488-102 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Mount Albert to Maori Purpose zone (See Appendix Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the submission). Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-104 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Mount Roskill to Maori Purpose zone (See Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Maunga Recreation 6488-106 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Mount St John to Maori Purpose zone (See Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Maunga Recreation 6488-108 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Ohinerau (Mount Hobson) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Maunga Recreation 6488-110 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Ohuiarangi (Pigeon Mountain) to Maori Purpose Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-112 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Otahuhu (Mount Richmond) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-114 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Rarotonga (Mount Smart) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Maunga Recreation 6488-116 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Takarunga (Mount Victoria) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-118 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Te Tatua a Riukiuta (Three Kings) to Maori Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) 18/31 of the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-120 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Mangere Mountain to Maori Purpose zone (See Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-124 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Maungawhau (Mount Eden) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-94 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Matukutururu (Wiri Mountain) to Maori Purpose Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Maunga Recreation 6488-96 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Mangakiekie (One Tree Hill) to Maori Purpose zone Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Tamaki Makaurau (Attn: (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the Paul Majurey) submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6488-98 Nga Mana Whenua o Rezone Maungarei (Mount Wellington) to Maori Purpose Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No 6493-100 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Mahurangi Scenic reserve to Māori Purpose zone Cultural redress Public Open Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; This cultural redress land is subject to Reserves Act No change No (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the land Space - SUPPORT RETAIN statuses and has public open space and natural submission). Conservation values, and therefore appropriate that it retains a North Public Open Space zone. SUBMISSION THEME PROPOSED PAUP ZONE SUBMISSION REQUESTED RELEVANT POSITION PROPOSED CONSEQUENTIAL NUMBER SUBMITTER NAME SUMMARY LOCALITY ZONE OVERLAYS REASONS ZONE CHANGE CHANGES 6493-102 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Blacketts Point Parnell (Gladstone Rd) to Māori POS Sport and Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page Active SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, 18/32 of the submission). Future Treaty land Central Recreation without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-104 Marutuahu Iwi (Attn: Rezone Maungarei maunga (Homestead Drive) to Maori Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Paul Majurey) Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the 18/32 of the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6493-106 Marutuahu Iwi (Attn: Rezone Fort Takapuna to Maori Purpose zone (See North Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Paul Majurey) Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-108 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Mechanics Bay (Stanley St/Beach Rd) to Māori Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, 18/32 of the submission). Future Treaty land Central without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-114 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone 19-23 Anzac St & 1-3 The Terrace Takapuna to Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; No Maori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and SUPPORT RETAIN It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for page 18/32 of the submission). Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, Future Treaty land North without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-116 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone 35 Grafton Rd Grafton to Maori Purpose zone (See Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land Central without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-118 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Panmure Probation Centre to Māori Purpose zone Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land North without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-120 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Boston Road Probation Centre to Māori Purpose Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land Central without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-122 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone 45,47 Calliope Rd Devonport to Maori Purpose Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land North without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-124 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Tamaki Leadership Centre property Whangaparoa Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No to Māori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, page 18/32 of the submission). Future Treaty land North without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-126 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone De-gaussing property Shakespear Regional Park Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Whangaparaoa to Māori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission). Future Treaty land North without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-128 Marutuahu Iwi (Attn: Rezone Torpedo Bay Naval Museum to Māori Purpose North Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Paul Majurey) zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-130 Marutuahu Iwi (Attn: Rezone New Zealand Defence Force Housing Blocks (94 North Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; No Paul Majurey) lots) - Potter/Greenslade; Tennyson; Corella; Alamein SUPPORT RETAIN It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for to Māori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, page 18/32 of the submission). Future Treaty land without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-92 Marutuahu Iwi (Attn: Rezone Takarunga, Mount Victoria, to Māori Purpose Zone Maunga Maunga POS - Maori Purpose ONF, Historic DO NOT SUPPORT; Retaining the Public Open Space zone is more No change No Paul Majurey) (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the Conservation Heritage, Maori SUPPORT RETAIN appropriate than the Māori Purpose zone given the submission). and Sport and Cultural conservation and recreational attributes of the Active Heritage maunga Recreation 6493-94 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Tiritiri Matanga motu to Māori Purpose zone (See Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, submission). Future Treaty land North POS - Conservat without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6493-98 Marutuahu Iwi Rezone Schoolhouse Bay properties Kawau motu to Maori Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; It is not considered appropriate to rezone land for No Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page SUPPORT RETAIN Māori Purpose which is still held by the Crown, 18/32 of the submission). Future Treaty land North without the Crown’s agreement. No change 6742-1 Te Mahurehure Cultural Rezone 65 Premiere Avenue, Point Chevalier from Central Public Open Maori Purpose SUPPORT; CHANGE Change best reflects existing marae activity rather Maori Purpose No Marae Society Community Open Space to Maori Purpose. Space - than a POS zone over privately owned land. zone Incorporated (Attn: Community Christine R Panapa) Te Mahurehure Mara 6791-1 Te Mahurehure Cultural Rezone land on Urquharts Peninsula (NA17C/1398 Lot 1 Urquharts Maori Purpose DO NOT SUPPORT; No Marae Society DP 58566) from Rural Coastal to Māori Purpose. Peninsula SUPPORT RETAIN This Maori land may to utilise the Auckland-wide Incorporated Māori land section rules. The subject site is used for South Rural Coastal farming which is provided by the Rural Coastal zone. No change Attachment D – Existing locations of Māori Purpose zone Appendix D

Te Onekiritea Awataha Te Piringatahi Marae o te Maungaarongo Marae

Orakei Marae Te Atatu Marae Pourewa

Te Henga Marae

Hoani Umupuia Marae Waititi Marae Matahuru Papakainga

Puketutu Otara Marae Island

Makaurau Marae

Pukaki urupa Pukaki

Manurewa Marae

Created Date: 13 Apr 2015 Scale @ A1: 1:155,256 Projection: NZTM ´ Datum: NZGD2000 The Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan File Name: Maori Special Purpose Zones.mxd

Maori Special Purpose Locations Date: 13/04/2015 0 1,100 2,200 3,300 4,400 m Document Name: Maori Special Purpose Zones Attachment E – Additional locations of Māori Purpose / Proposed zoning changes Auckland Council Map ´

t Road Coas West

y a w h g i H

t s

a K

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Araparera Marae - PAUP zoning = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

t Road Coas West

y a w h g i H

t s

a K

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Araparera Marae - Proposed = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

d a o R i

Sou th Hea d R oad

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Haranui Marae - PAUP zoning = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

d a o R i

Sou th Hea d R oad

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Haranui Marae - Proposed = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

K a i p a r a

o a s t

i g h w

a y

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Kakanui Marae - PAUP zoning = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

K a i p a r a

o a s t

i g h w

a y

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Kakanui Marae - Proposed = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

t e e tr S a k u n a K

Pre mie r A ve t nu e e e r t S

e l t t e K R i ro S tr e e t

et tre i S Tu Moray Place e

M e o v a A

R a

o n a e

d d

DISCLAIMER: 0 10 20 30 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Mahurehure Marae - PAUP = 1:2,500 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

t e e tr S a k u n a K

Pre mie r A ve t nu e e e r t S

e l t t e K R i ro S tr e e t

et tre i S Tu Moray Place e

M e o v a A

R a

o n a e

d d

DISCLAIMER: 0 10 20 30 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Mahurehure Marae - Proposed = 1:2,500 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

y a w h ig H t s a o C a r a ip a K

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Puhatahi Marae - PAUP zoning = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

y a w h ig H t s a o C a r a ip a K

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Puhatahi Marae - proposed = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

Sh 16

d oa R on

e k

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Reweti Marae - PAUP zoning = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

Sh 16

d oa R on

e k

DISCLAIMER: 0 25 50 75 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be independently verified on site before taking Meters any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Scale @ A4 Reserved). Whilst due care has been taken, Auckland Reweti Marae - Proposed = 1:5,000 Council gives no warranty as to the accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and Date Printed: accepts no liability for any error, omission or use of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 2/12/2015 p ´ a

d a 0

: o 1 d

R 5

0 e

1 l A t i 0

0 0 n 0

s 0 H i 1

2 ,

r e r /

t 8

e : e e 2

l v M

0 l e i a 5 / t

c = S 3 a S D 0

t e e Sh 1 tr S P n

o U ti a n A o r P

C -

o a R

a a

r i

a H

h e W T n e e s o i b u t

s a r s d i l a o m

h u e h r

t n

. o h e o t o n n f h

r i s s a o o n o

i i t s

c t

i n

n y c s . o e o r i m a i a 6 u

t a t o y 4 a y d d a ,

t l n 9 r t n m n m i s a 1 o r

u l

r a r i g r o o d r o f h r f c n e B n i

n a n l i a i W k y

e l w . a k

n l n y c ) t c a a

r o n

d e u a r a n d e

r u P A o f v s

n f o r :

f o e d a

y e e v o s n m i t y s i s b l a g l

u e i n e L t l e

i R b

n t a o

C i c .

t a l e d i i s

e n t l

c t v e u n g i l o i h n t o o r d g p n

u a i

C y r

d o s e t m p t d e C s n i o

o H p n

f u c . i d C l

e a

l r l n n c i a n

n e k c a o a s l l i v c l i a w

u p y o a

c n l d r A : k t a d

u n m l

, C R n n a r ( A n p

E e a c o / t

Z e n f d p M y k h a n N I n

l c i I g a a u

i e t A a L p

e r m L / p

y n h u p e C s m t p e i A c S

a d o I f e o h c r n o b a m i C f D T 1

H ´ S

D A O R U A IR P

A S K A H

H W 1 CO RO NA TI ON ST RE ET

D OAD A ILL R O ER H R SILV U A R I P A K A H

D A O R

R 1 I

H A

S K

0 60 120 180 Scale:1:7,500 Metres TE HANA - PROPOSED CHANGES Date Printed: 3/12/2015 Auckland Council Map ´

ad Ro nd Isla

d oa R gi an ar ru O

DISCLAIMER: 0 100 200 300 This map/plan is illustrative only and all information should be Meters independently verified on site before taking any action. Copyright Auckland Council. Land Parcel Boundary information from LINZ (Crown Copyright Reserved). Whilst due care has Scale @ A4 been taken, Auckland Council gives no warranty as to the Puketutu Island - PAUP = 1:15,000 accuracy and plan completeness of any information on this map/plan and accepts no liability for any error, omission or use Date Printed: of the information. Height datum: Auckland 1946. 3/12/2015 ´

IS LAND ROAD

D A O I R G N A R A U R O

0 100 200 300 Scale:1:12,500 Metres PUKETUTU ISLAND - PROPOSED CHANGES Date Printed: 3/12/2015