DOCSLIB.ORG

Chapter Two. Between Russia and Europe

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Chapter Two. Between Russia and Europe Russian — European Centre for Multidisciplinary Research “Baltic Practice” Russia and the Council of Europe: Topics for Common Agenda A Look from Norway Academic Papers of the 10th International Session of the HSE Russian — European Centre for Multidisciplinary Research Oslo, 1-8 August, 2010 Edited by Nina Belyaeva Academic Director of the “Baltic Practice” Centre INTELCORP Moscow 2011 This Academic Papers Collection has been published with the support of National Research University “Higher School of Economics” (Moscow) www.hse.ru http://balticpractice.hse.ru Academic Papers of the 10th International Session of the HSE Russian — European Centre for Multidisciplinary Research Oslo, 1-8 August, 2010 This publication is an continuation of the series of yearly Academic Papers, published since 2006, by the “Baltic Practice” interdisciplinary research Center, in a form of structured and edited collection of research papers of participants of the International HSE Summer School “Practice at the Baltic Sea” or simply “Baltic Practice”, submitted by the students of National Research University “Higher School of Economics”, as well undergraduate and graduate students from several European universities, complimented by the commentaries and research articles by research groups academic leaders and experts. The book is not intended for sale, is a scientific publication and is distributed free of charge. The volume was prepared by Baltic Practice Editorial Group: Galina Petrenko, English Language Editor Dmitry Zaytsev, Secretary of the Editorial Board Shota Kakabadze, Managing Editor © 2011 Nina Belyaeva, idea, selection and editorial matter © 2011 Pawel Sandomirskii, Design © 2011 INTELCORP Publishing House, Design All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in written from the Russian — European Centre of Multidisciplinary Research “Baltic Practice”, Higher School of Economics ISBN 978-5-91769-008-7 Editorial Board Nina Belyaeva, professor of Higher School of Economics, Chair of Public Policy Department; Academic Director of the HSE Russian — European Centre for Multidisciplinary Research “Baltic Practice” Bill Bowring, Barrister, Professor in Law, School of Law, London Thomas Bull, professor in Public Law at Uppsala University; Sweden Katia Dolgova-Dreyer, Secretary to the Steering Committee for Higher Education and Research, Directorate of Education and Languages of the Council of Europe; Strasbourg, France Leonidas Donskis, professor and Dean of the Faculty of Political Science and Diplomacy at Vytautas Magnus University (Lithuania); a Member of the European Parliament; Strasbourg, France Lucia Serena Rossi, professor, Director of EU Law Institute, University of Bologna, Italy Michel Grosmann, professor of Physics at the University of Strasbourg, France. Carsten Herrmann-Pillath, professor of Business Economics at the Frankfurt School of Business and Management; Frankfurt, Germany Edouard Jagodnik, President, European Federation of Schools, Council of Europe, President of the Commission for Culture, Science and Education of the INGO Conference of the Council of Europe Neil Jarman, Director of the Institute for Conflict Research, leader of the Expert Panel on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly at the OSCE/ODIHR; Belfast, UK Alexander Nikitin, professor of MGIMO-University, director of Centre of Euro-Atlantic security Rustem Nureev, Honorary professor of the SU-HSE, Chair of the Department of Economic analysis of organizations and markets; Moscow, Russia Ana Perona-Fjeldstad, Executive Director of The European Wergeland Centre Vladimir Zuev, professor of Higher School of Economics 3 CONTENTS PREFACE TO THE VOLUME BY PROF. NINA BELYAEVA, ACADEMIC DIRECTOR OF BALTIC PRACTICE ..................................................................................................................................7 GREETINGS ON 10TH ANNIVERSARY OF BALTIC PRACTICE BY ANA PERONA-FJELDSTAD, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE EUROPEAN WERGELAND CENTRE (OSLO, NORWAY) ...............9 CHAPTER ONE. UNIVERSITY AS RES PUBLICA..............................................10 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP....................................................................10 NINA BELYAEVA, GILIBERTO CAPANO GOVERNING MODERN RESEARCH UNIVERSITY : BETWEEN ACADEMIC FREEDOM AND MANAGERIAL CONSTRAINTS ....................................................................................................12 EKATERINA TUPOVA “TYPICAL STUDENT” IN RUSSIAN UNIVERSITY : TRANSFORMATION OF THE PUBLIC IMAGE....30 NICOLAY TELESNIN UNIVERSITY AS A SOURCE OF LIBERAL MIND ..........................................................................40 LAURA PETRONE DEMOCRATIC CULTURE IN HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS : COMPARING RUSSIAN AND ITALIAN UNIVERSITIES ....................................................................................................45 CHAPTER TWO. BETWEEN RUSSIA AND EUROPE.........................................56 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP....................................................................56 MILAN ALEKSIĆ RUSSIA'S PRESENCE IN THE SHARED NEIGHBOURHOOD..........................................................57 CARLO DE MARCO KALININGRAD IN THE INTERNATIONAL ARENA.......................................................................73 CINZIA TARLETTI DO NO HARM : ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF FOREIGN AID IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA.....88 LANA ZEKOVIĆ THE EU-RUSSIA “VISA DIALOGUE” : A CRITICAL ASSESSMENT .............................................106 CHAPTER THREE. MODELS OF DEMOCRACY EVALUATION..................140 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP..................................................................140 MARIA SHABANOVA, MIKHAIL KLIMUSHKIN DEMOCRACY IN THE WORLD : MODELING MULTIDIMENSIONAL WORLD MAP .......................142 ELENA SHEETOVA, KRISTINA POPOVA, ANASTASIA NOVOKRESHCHENOVA “DEMOCRACY WITH ADJECTIVES” : ANALYZING ALTERNATIVE DISCOURSES........................156 MARIA KOYSINA, IGOR JUDANOV, NIKITA ROMASHKIN FREEDOM OF SPEECH ON RUSSIAN TV : EDITORIAL POLICIES ON FEDERAL TV TALK-SHOWS .........................................................................................................................165 ANASTASIA NOVOKRESHCHENNOVA AND MARIA SHABANOVA WESTERN LEADERS ON DEMOCRACY AND HUMAN RIGHTS IN RUSSIA : AVOIDING THE SUBJECT MATTER ...........................................................................................173 CHAPTER FOUR. CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY .......................185 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP..................................................................185 ZOYA BRAGINA COMPARATIVE STUDY OF CORPORATE NON-FINANCIAL REPORTING PRACTICES : CASES ON USA, EUROPE AND RUSSIA...................................................................................187 5 Russia and the Council of Europe: Topics for Common Agenda: A Look from Norway ELENA DRUZHININA BOTTOM OF PYRAMID (BOP) MARKETS : HOW CAN THIS CONCEPT BE USED TO FACILITATE THE ERADICATION OF POVERTY IN RUSSIA AND CIS COUNTRIES .......................206 MAXIM MARKIN, ELENA NAZARBAEVA, SVETLANA BORISOVA COMPETITION AND “COOPETITION” IN RUSSIAN INTERNET RETAILING : NEW FORMS OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ..........................................................213 LEVYKINA KSENIVA, NACHINKIN DENIS CHARACTERISTICS OF THE GERMAN MODEL OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE : CASE OF ALLIANZ SE AND PROSPECTS AFTER THE WORLD FINANCIAL CRISIS.......................222 CHAPTER FIVE. LOCAL GOVERNANCE..........................................................243 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP..................................................................243 LUCIO PICCI REPUTATION-BASED GOVERNANCE AND MAKING STATES “LEGIBLE” TO THEIR CITIZENS ....244 JULIA MINAEVA IMPROVING THE QUALITY OF MUNICIPAL SERVICE : CASES ON ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS IN THE UK AND SWEDEN .......................................................................................................252 SVETLANA TOKUNOVA LOCAL GOVERNANCE IN SCANDINAVIAN COUNTRIES : IS THERE A COMMON MODEL ? .......258 CHAPTER SIX. LANGUAGE OF PUBLIC POLICY...........................................263 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP..................................................................263 ANITA SOBOLEVA SPEAKING ABOUT HUMAN RIGHTS: WHAT IS THE LANGUAGE WE USE? ..............................264 DILYARA MULYUKOVA THE ROLE OF POLITICAL MYTH IN REGIONAL POLITICAL PROCESS IN RUSSIA: CASE OF THE REPUBLIC OF TATARSTAN ................................................................................275 ALENA PUSTOVALOVA METAPHORIC CONCEPTUALIZATION OF THE GLOBAL ECONOMIC CRISIS IN THE RUSSIAN MEDIA ...................................................................................................................................279 MAXIM BOGACHEV “SINGING TOGETHER”: USING POP SONGS IN POLITICAL CAMPAIGNING ................................287 CHAPTER SEVEN. HUMAN RIGHTS ..................................................................296 INTRODUCTION OF RESEARCH WORKING GROUP..................................................................296 CLAUDIA LENZ, CAROLINE GEBARA BUILDING HUMAN RIGHTS CULTURES THROUGH EDUCATION — THE CONTRIBUTION OF THE EUROPEAN WERGELAND CENTRE.............................................................................297
Load more

Recommended publications
  • NINA BELYAEVA 2016 University of Turin, Visiting Professor
    NINA BELYAEVA WORK EXPERIENCE 2016 University of Turin, Visiting professor 2016 Science Po (Grenoble), Visiting professor 2014 UNIBO, Visiting professor 2009-now University of Sarajevo (ERMA), Visiting professor 2000 – now Professor, Department Head: National Research University “Higher School of Economics” / Faculty of Social Sciences / Public Policy Department. Moscow 2006 - now Academic Director of HSE MP in Public Policy & Policy Analysis of National Research University “Higher School of Economics”. Moscow 2005 Cape Town University, Visiting professor 1998 Colorado College, Visiting professor 1994, 1995 Moscow State University Law School, Visiting professor 1994-1995 Colorado College, Visiting professor 1993 Georgetown University, Visiting professor 1993 Salzburg University Law School, Visiting professor 1992 Johns Hopkins University, Visiting professor 1990, 1992, Colorado College, Visiting professor 1991 - now International Public Foundation for Political and Legal Research, President EDUCATION AND TRAINING 2009 - 2011 EU Scholarship for visiting fellows to University of Bologna 1993 Senior research fellow in residence in USIP. Washington DC 1992 Senior research fellow in residence in CSIS. Washington DC 1991 International Fellowship in Philanthropy Institute for Policy Studies John's Hopkins University. Baltimore 1987 UNESCO scholarship to University of London School of Law. London 1983 - 1986 Doctoral courses in Constitutional Law and Comparative Politics. Institute of State and Law Academy of Sciences of the USSR. S.J.D., Doctoral Dissertation Defended. Doctoral Thesis: ‘Political Activity of voluntary organizations in the USSR and enabling legal regime for it’ Moscow 1976 – 1981 Moscow State University, Law School (Theory and History of State and Law, Political System, Constitutional Law, Comparative Legal Systems, International Public Law), Moscow. J.D & LL.M.
    [Show full text]
  • “Ideal University” As Viewed by “University People
    Anton N. Afanasiev, Ksenia V. Komosa “IDEAL UNIVERSITY” AS VIEWED BY “UNIVERSITY PEOPLE”: EXPERIENCE IN RECONSTRUCTING THE VALUE CATEGORIES OF RESEARCH AND PEDAGOGICAL ACTIVITIES BASED ON INTERVIEWS IN THE 2010S BASIC RESEARCH PROGRAM WORKING PAPERS SERIES: HUMANITIES WP BRP 202/HUM/2021 This Working Paper is an output of a research project implemented at the National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE). Any opinions or claims contained in this Working Paper do not necessarily reflect the views of HSE Anton N. Afanasiev1, Ksenia V. Komosa2 “IDEAL UNIVERSITY” AS VIEWED BY “UNIVERSITY PEOPLE”: EXPERIENCE IN RECONSTRUCTING THE VALUE CATEGORIES OF RESEARCH AND PEDAGOGICAL ACTIVITIES BASED ON INTERVIEWS IN THE 2010S3 The article examines the self-identification and professional values of the university community in post-Soviet Russia. On the basis of the corpus of the interviews, which were recorded by the Poletayev Institute for Theoretical and Historical Studies in the Humanities (Moscow) in the 2010s, the authors analyse how the contemporary Russian scholars consider the problems of university autonomy and university management, as well as the criteria to define an ideal University and an ideal Professor. Instead of the unique perceptions on the specifics of research and educational characteristics of university space and people, the present investigation represents the problematization of the basic definitions of university and its purposes by the contemporary Russian scholars. Keywords: oral history, history of post-soviet universities, university community, academic persona JEL Classification: Z. 1 National Research University Higher School of Economics (Moscow, Russia). Poletayev Institute for Theoretical and Historical Studies in the Humanities. Senior research fellow.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report, 2014–2015 1 Downside up Annual Report, 2014–2015 1 Russian State Registration Certifi Cate Socially Oriented No
    DOWNSIDE UP Charitable Fund July 2014 – Annual June 2015 Report 1997 – 2015 DOWNSIDE UP’S 2015 CHARITY AWARDS AND THEIR WINNERS WERE AS FOLLOWS: On March 10, 2015, Downside Up For Exceptional Contribution into Sergey Koloskov, President of “Down Drawing the Attention of Society Syndrome Association”, an interregional held its fi rst Charity Awards cere- and the Government to the Issue NGO for disabled people mony to celebrate supporters of of Down Syndrome in Russia: children with Down Syndrome in Russia. For Contribution to the Development of Ministry for Family Aff airs, Demographics a Public System for the Support and Social Policy of Kaluga region; The awards recognized the con- of Children with Down Syndrome: Novosibirsk State Pedagogical University tribution made by governmental agencies, NGOs, Russian and inter- national commercial companies, For Cooperation in the Development Special Education Institute of the Russian mass media, and members of the of Research and Resource Framework Academy of Education general public towards the cause of Early Intervention Programmes of helping children with Down syn- for Children with Down Syndrome: drome in Russia. For Contribution to the Development “Kindergarten for Everybody”, a resource of Inclusive Education for Preschool centre of inclusive preschool education Children with Down Syndrome: (Moscow) For Professional Media Coverage of the First Channel (TV); Russia Today Down Syndrome Issues: international news agency, Life Without Barriers project; aif.ru (Argumenty i Fakty) website For Contribution
    [Show full text]
  • Civil Society and the Challenge of Russian Gosudairstvennost
    Civil Society and the Challenge of Russian Gosudairstvennost JOHN SQUIER S oon after being named acting president of the Russian Federation in early 2000, Vladimir Putin announced that one of his priorities would be the restoration in Russia of what he termed gosudarstvennost. Treating this term as more or less synonymous with "sovereignty," Western observers tended to inter- pret this declaration with a certain alarm (as indeed they interpreted most of Putin's initial declarations), emphasizing a hypothesized connection of the term gosudarstvennost to resurrected notions of Russian national greatness and inter- national assertiveness. That Western observers would express such concerns, in the context of diplomatic disputes over U.S. intervention in Serbia and Russian policy toward "states of concern" such as Iran, Iraq, and North Korea, is under- standable, but more recent events have demonstrated that Western concerns over gosudarstvennost, at least as far as international relations are concerned, were misplaced. Western observers' initial negative reaction seems to stem from a misunder- standing of the term gosudarstvennost, which is, in and of itself, neutral; the Ozhegov L)ictionary of the Russian Language (1986) defines it as "state system, state organization" (literally, gosudatstvennyi stroi, gosudarstvennaya organizat- siya). Gosudarstvennost thus refers less to sovereignty in the international arena than to sovereignty understood as an aspect of domestic politics-the ability of the state to act as an internally coherent governing body. Actual usage of the term seems to indicate that it means something like "statehood" or "the quality of being a state." In the aftermath of the chaos of the 1990s, when the Russian state vir- tually ceased functioning in some respects, restoration of gosudarstvennost seems an eminently sensible priority.
    [Show full text]
  • Cvs Forschool.Pdf
    2016 Nina Lecture: Belief-based organization: between Freedom of Association and Freedom of Conscience. Regulations and Belyaeva practices through ECHR cases Marco Lecture: Laicity and Religion in Europe Balboni Carmelo Lecture: Religion, Public Space, Gender: Danisi Perspectives on the Islamic Face Veil Yury Lecture: International Mechanisms of Human Rights protection: cases on religion, identity and freedom of Forgelson conscience Iftikhar Lecture: Extremism and Human Rights: Liberal Societies at Lodhi the Crossroads Lectures: Newly emerging religious communities in Europe: Sanjay Kumar challenges to European Identity; Challenging the concept of tolerance: convergence of religious plurality in Europe; Rajhans Interactive Workshop: Limitation on “manifestation” of religion or belief: its necessity in a democratic society Mahama Lecture: Who is a minority in Europe? The multiple facets Tawat of a concept Anita Interactive Workshop: Freedom of arts and religious rights: Soboleva the search for balance Dmitry Lecture: Religious minorities and their rights: Causes of Discrimination Zaytsev and the strategies of protection Sergey Interactive Workshop: Culture, religion, and ethics in public sphere: public participation and anti-corruption Parkhomenko reforms Nina Y. Belyaeva Phone: +7 (495) 772-95-90 (int. 12435) E-mail: [email protected] Address: Moscow, Myasnitskaya 20, of. 526 Professor at the National Research University “Higher School of Economics” (HSE) Head of HSE Public Policy Department, Academic Director of HSE MP in Public Policy & Policy Analysis President of Interlegal Foundation of Political & Legal Research, enjoying participatory status with the Council of Europe Expert Panel Member of OSCE/ODIHR “On the Freedom of Peaceful Assembly” Education and Degrees 1983 - 1986 Doctoral courses in Constitutional Law and Comparative Politics.
    [Show full text]
  • Conference Papers from a November 1993 Workshop at the Kennan Institute
    #256 Russian and American Think Tanks: An Initial Survey Conference papers from a November 1993 workshop at the Kennan Institute "Consulting on the Policy of Reform: A Workshop for New Russian Think Tanks/' was held at the Kennan Institute for Advanced Russian Studies and independent research institutes throughout Washington, D.C., during the week of 8--12 November 1993. The conference was cosponsored by the Kennan Institute; Interlegal Research Center, Moscow; Interlegal USA, Inc., New York; and the Samuel Rubin Foundation, New York; with funding provided by the Eurasia Foundation of Washington, D.C. The Kennan Institute for Advanced Russian Studies The Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars The Kennan Institute for Advanced Russian Studies is a division of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars. Through its programs of fellowships, meetings, and publications, the Institute encourages scholarship on Russia and the former Soviet Union, embracing a broad range of fields in the social sciences and humanities. The Kennan Institute is supported by contributions from foundations, corporations, individuals, and the United States Government. Kennan Institute Occasional Papers The Kennan Institute makes Occasional Papers available to all those interested in Russian studies. Occasional Papers are submitted by Kennan Institute scholars and visiting speakers, particularly those who wish to receive timely feedback on their work. Copies of Occasional Papers and a list of papers currently available can be obtained free of charge by contacting: Occasional Papers Kennan Institute for Advanced Russian Studies 370 L'Enfant Promenade, SW, Suite 704 Washington, D.C. 20024-2518 (202) 287-3400 This Occasional Paper has been produced with support provided by the Russian, Eurasian, and East European Research and Training Program of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • The Kennan Institute 38
    KENNAN INSTITUTE 30 Year Report KENNAN INSTITUTE KENNAN INSTITUTE KENNAN INSTITUTE 30 Year Report Kennan Institute Staff Blair A. Ruble, Director Margaret Paxson, Senior Associate Nancy Popson, Senior Associate F. Joseph Dresen, Program Associate Jennifer Giglio, Program Associate Atiq Sarwari, Program Associate Summer Brown, Program Specialist Edita Krunkaityte, Program Assistant Erin Trouth, Program Assistant Kennan Moscow Project Galina Levina, Program Manager Ekaterina Alekseeva, Program Manager and Editor Irina Petrova, Office Manager Pavel Korolev, Program Officer Anna Toker, Accountant Murad Pateev, Technical Support Kennan Kyiv Project Yaroslav Pylynskyi, Project Manager Nataliya Samozvanova, Office Manager WOODROW WILSON INTERNATIONAL CENTER FOR SCHOLARS Lee H. Hamilton, Director BOARD OF TRUSTEES Joseph B. Gildenhorn, Chair; David A. Metzner, Vice Chair. Public Members: James H. Billington, Librarian of Congress; John W. Carlin, Archivist of the United States; Bruce Cole, Chair, National Endowment for the Humanities; Roderick R. Paige, Secretary, U.S. Department of Education; Colin L. Powell, Secretary, U.S. Department of State; Lawrence M. Small, Secretary, Smithsonian Institution; Tommy G. Thompson, Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Private Citizen Members: Joseph A. Cari, Jr., Carol Cartwright, Donald E. Garcia, Bruce S. Gelb, Daniel L. Lamaute, Tamala L. Longaberger, Thomas R. Reedy WILSON COUNCIL Bruce S. Gelb, President. Elias F. Aburdene, Jennifer Acker, Charles S. Ackerman, B.B. Andersen, Russell Anmuth, Cyrus A. Ansary, Lawrence E. Bathgate II, Theresa Behrendt, John Beinecke, Joseph C. Bell, Steven Alan Bennett, Rudy Boschwitz, A. Oakley Brooks, Donald A. Brown, Melva Bucksbaum, Richard I. Burnham, Nicola L. Caiola, Mark Chandler, Peter B. Clark, Melvin Cohen, William T.
    [Show full text]
  • Political Analysis and Public Policy
    Internships and graduates’ employment Our graduates are trained to: ■ provide analytical support for decision-making at state bodies, 20 Myasnitskaya Street, Moscow political parties and civil organizations, as well as in the media 101000, Russian Federation and business, Tel: +7 (495) 771 3232 ■ organize research, conduct political analysis and expertise in Fax: +7 (495) 628 7931 the sphere of public policy, public administration, human www.hse.ru rights, political economy, corporate governance, politics, global governance, ■ analyze and expand the existing achievements of researchers in social sciences from both Russia and abroad, ■ organize political & advocacy campaigns, ■ successfully work in business companies and large corporations, “Non scholae, sed vitae ■ conduct political analysis based on qualitative & quantitative discimus...” data, ■ teach social sciences at schools and universities All these competences allow to our graduates to build carriers in: ■ federal and regional authorities (Presidential Administration, State Duma, Council of the Federation, Russian Ministry of Economic Development Industry and Trade, Ministry of Regional Development, Central Election Commission, Ombudsmen’s offices), Master’s Program ■ leading Russian and foreign think tanks (Carnegie Moscow Centre, Gorbachev Foundation, Centre for Political Technologies, Foundation for the Development of Political Analysis Information Policy, Interlegal Foundation, ZIRCON Research Group, Levada Centre, Public Opinion Foundation, VTsIOM), and Public Policy ■ consulting
    [Show full text]
  • THE EMERGING POLITICAL PARTY SYSTEM in RUSSIA: 1 Oqt:: 1 00") ~./Uv-~//~ the EMERGING POLITICAL PARTY SYSTEM in RUSSIA: 1986-1992 By
    THE EMERGING POLITICAL PARTY SYSTEM IN RUSSIA: 1 OQt::_1 00") ~./uv-~//~ THE EMERGING POLITICAL PARTY SYSTEM IN RUSSIA: 1986-1992 By NEIL C. LEVINE A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts McMaster University © copyright by Neil C. Levine, August 1995 MASTER OF ARTS (1995) McMaster University (Political Science) Hamilton, Ontario TITLE: The Emerging Political Party System in Russia: 1986-1992 AUTHOR: Neil C. Levine, B.A. (Hons) McMaster University SUPERVISOR: Professor Peter J. Potichnyj NUMBER OF PAGES: vii, 176 ii Abstract This thesis investigates the emerging political party system in Russia, from the beginnings of pluraJism in 1986 through 1992. It does so in the context of the theoretical and methodological implications of the literature on transitions to democracy, and with reference to literature on political party systems. This thesis examines the beginnings of independent group activity, the groups' formation into movements and blocs and their participation in elections, and their evolution into proto-parties as the USSR collapsed and the Russian state gained independence and its own identity. The literature on transitions to democracy is agency-oriented, in that it places an emphasis on political parties in the transition process. While it is unclear--~------- at--- this----- rDoint - -- in--- time whether Russia is indeed undenwin{!v '-' a transition to democracy, proto-parties in Russia have played - and will continue to play - a key role in the transformation of Russia from Communism to post­ Communism. The future shape and structure of the Russian multi-party system is, however, difficult to predict, because of the nascent and immature nature of the system in the time period this paper examines.
    [Show full text]
  • Members of the Academic Advisory Board of the Community of Democracies
    MEMBERS OF THE ACADEMIC ADVISORY BOARD OF THE COMMUNITY OF DEMOCRACIES ----------------- BIOGRAPHIES As of 27 July 2017 Wojciech Sadurski (Chair) is a Challis Professor of Jurisprudence at the University of Sydney and a Professor of the University of Warsaw. He has previously held a professorship at the European University Institute in Florence, and he has taught most recently at Yale Law School, New York University School of Law, Cardozo Law School in New York, the University of Toronto, and the University of Trento. He is a member of a number of supervisory or program boards, including the Institute of Public Affairs (Poland), the Freedom of Press Observatory (Poland), and the Centre for International Affairs (Poland) He has written extensively on the philosophy of law, political philosophy, and comparative constitutional law. His most recent books include Constitutionalism and the Enlargement of Europe (OUP 2012) and Equality and Legitimacy (OUP 2008). Nina Belyaeva is a Russian professor and head of the Public Policy Department at the National Research University Higher School of Economic (NRU HSE) of Moscow. She is also the founder of the Russian Political Science Association. During her career, Nina Y. Belyaeva taught courses on political science and law in the universities of Georgetown, Colorado (USA), Salzburg (Austria) and Cape Town (South Africa). Since 2000, Ms. Belyaeva has been working at the Higher School of Economics. She is also a member of the HSE Scientific Council, head of the Public Policy Department, and academic head of the Master program “Political Analysis and Public Policy”, which is the only Public Policy programme in Russia taught in English.
    [Show full text]
  • STATE and CIVIL SOCIETY in RUSSIA: the Role of Nongovernmental Associations
    CONTENTS Abstract i Introduction 1 Part I: Theories of Civil Society and Conceptualizing State-Society Relationship in Russia 2 Part II: Non-Governmental Associations and Their Contribution to the Development of Civil Society in Pre-Soviet Russia 6 Part III: Russia Now and the Development of Civil Society 20 THE STATE AND CIVIL SOCIETY IN RUSSIA: The Role of Nongovernmental Associations Joseph Bradley University of Tulsa The Author's main conclusion is that nongovernmental associations play an essential role in the formation of a civil society in Russia (as well as in ex-totalitarian, autocratic and bureaucratic- authoritarian societies generally), and are a pre-condition of other limitations on state power. The paper addresses civil society theory, analyzes the historic role of such associations in pre-Soviet Russia, and their current rapid growth in Russia to that role.2 Abstract "In Russia the state is everything and civil society is primordial and gelatinous." (Antonio Gramsci) Generations of scholars, Russian and Western alike, have concurred with the observation of Gramsci, which seems so aptly to describe Russian political culture. Although in the past decade historians and social scientists have begun to utilize the concept of civil society and to examine aspects of historical civil societies, Russia is rarely invoked as an example. And not without reason. Russian subjects had none of the rights that undergirded civil society in the West. While "classical" western theories of civil society originated in the penumbra of royal absolutism, no such philosophical tradition emerged in the darkness of eastern absolutism. Moreover, historical models of Russian political culture reinforce the philosophical silence.
    [Show full text]
  • Determinants of the Policy Impact of Analytical Communities in Russian Regions: Cases of Karelia, Tatarstan and Saratov
    Cent. Eur. J. Public Policy 2017; 11(2): 23–42 DOI: 10.1515/cejpp-2016-0033 Dmitry Zaytsev, Nina Belyaeva*1 Determinants of the Policy Impact of Analytical Communities in Russian Regions: Cases of Karelia, Tatarstan and Saratov ABstract: This paper evaluates the policy impact of analytical communities in three Russian regions (Karelia, Tatarstan and Saratov). Based on the existing methods to assess the political power of think tanks, the authors develop a method to evaluate this impact. The authors test this method using the empirical data and findings from interviews, workshops with representatives of analytical communities of the three regions, and from observations and assessments of experts in regional politics. In conclusion, the authors argue that the capacity of analytical communities to impact policy change in a region depends on the level of political competition and pluralism and democratic institutions in the region; the level of consolidation of the analytical community, its autonomous political status and authority. KEYWORDS: Think tanks, analytical communities, political power, influence, policy impact RECEIVED 17 October 2016; accEPTED 1 August 2017. INTRODUCTION The consideration of policy making as a top-down process, as an activity exclusively or primarily of state and municipal authorities, overlooks the effect of non-state actors on the policy making process such as NGO’s, associations of business, and think tanks. The complication of political processes in modern societies led to the rise of importance of policy specialists − intellectuals, who have special knowledge in public policy and specific expertise in diverse policy fields. Efficient policy-making without those actors and their knowledge become impossible (Dahl, 1989).
    [Show full text]