Immune Complex Tubulointerstitial Nephritis Due to Autoantibodies to the Proximal Tubule Brush Border
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY of the RENAL BIOPSY www.jasn.org Immune Complex Tubulointerstitial Nephritis Due to Autoantibodies to the Proximal Tubule Brush Border † ‡ Ivy A. Rosales,* A. Bernard Collins,* Paula Alves S. do Carmo, Nina Tolkoff-Rubin, R. Neal Smith,* and Robert B. Colvin* Department of *Pathology and ‡Division of Nephrology, Renal Transplantation Program, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts; and †Centro Especializado em Anatomia Patologica, Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais, Brazil ABSTRACT Immune complex tubulointerstitial nephritis due to antibodies to brush border associated with focal tubulitis. Interstitial antigens of the proximal tubule has been demonstrated experimentally and rarely in fibrosis and tubular atrophy were diffuse humans. Our patient developed ESRD and early recurrence after transplantation. and present in 70% of the cortex. No gi- IgG and C3 deposits were conspicuous in the tubular basement membrane of antcellswereseen.Anarteryshowed proximal tubules, corresponding to deposits observed by electron microscopy. mild intimal fibrosis. Few IgG4-positive Rare subepithelial deposits were found in the glomeruli. The patient had no plasma cells were detected in the intersti- evidence of SLE and had normal complement levels. Serum samples from the tium (mean of 2 per high-power field). patient reacted with the brush border of normal human kidney, in contrast with the Immunofluorescence (IF) showed negative results with 20 control serum samples. Preliminary characterization of widespread granular deposits along the the brush border target antigen excluded megalin, CD10, and maltase. We postulate proximal tubular basement membrane that antibodies to brush border antigens cause direct epithelial injury, accumulate in (TBM), which stained for IgG (3+), C3 the tubular basement membrane, and elicit an interstitial inflammatory response. (3+), and equally for k and l (Figure 1). The TBM deposits stained with IgG1 J Am Soc Nephrol 27: 380–384, 2016. doi: 10.1681/ASN.2015030334 (widespread 3+), IgG2 (focal 2+), and IgG4 (widespread 3+). IgG3 was nega- tive. The glomerular deposits were sparse, and they showed very segmental CLINICAL HISTORY blood cell counts and platelets were nor- staining for IgG and did not stain for the mal. Serologies were negative, including phospholipase-A2 receptor. A 73-year-old man presented with nausea, ANCA, anti–glomerular basement Ultrastructural analysis showed wide- vomiting, and progressive renal failure. membrane (GBM), anti-nuclear anti- spreadamorphouselectron-densedeposits His serum creatinine had increased from body, anti–double-stranded DNA, and within the TBM, sometimes abutting the 1.3 mg/dl to 15.2 mg/dl in the 10 months hepatitis B and C. C3 and C4 levels basal plasma membrane of the tubular before admission. He had a history of were normal. An ultrasound showed cell (Figure 1). Scattered penetrating coronary artery disease, diabetes, and no evidence of a mass, obstruction, or subepithelial deposits were present in a hypertension, and he was taking multi- stenosis. small minority of glomerular capillaries ple medications including omeprazole, without spike formation (Figure 1). The lisinopril, metformin, simvastatin, meto- GBM was diffusely but mildly thickened prolol, aspirin, and insulin. On admission, KIDNEY BIOPSY his BP was 148/78 mmHg. His other vital signs were normal and his physical exam- Ten histologically normal glomeruli were ination was unremarkable. He had no present with no endocapillary hypercellu- Published online ahead of print. Publication date prior history of autoimmune disease and larity or GBM abnormality. There was available at www.jasn.org. no family history of autoimmune or renal prominent diffuse tubular injury mani- diseases. fested by loss of brush borders, blebs, Correspondence: Dr. Ivy A. Rosales, Department of Pathology, Massachusetts General Hospital, 55 Urinalysis showed protein (2+), vacuoles, and regenerative changes. An Fruit Street, Thier 831A, Boston, MA 02114. Email: blood (1+), 3–5 white blood cells per interstitial infiltrate of lymphocytes, [email protected] fi high-power eld, and no casts. His he- plasma cells, and a few eosinophils af- Copyright © 2016 by the American Society of moglobin was 12.6 g/L, although white fected 50%–60% of the cortex (Figure 1), Nephrology 380 ISSN : 1046-6673/2702-380 J Am Soc Nephrol 27: 380–384, 2016 www.jasn.org PATHOPHYSIOLOGY of the RENAL BIOPSY Figure 1. Native kidney.(A) Mononuclear inflammatoryinterstitial infiltrate with few admixedneutrophilsand eosinophils, tubular atrophy, and normal-looking glomerulus (hematoxylin and eosin staining). (B) Granular IgG staining of TBMs. (C) Amorphous electron-dense deposits along the TBM. (D) Penetrating subepithelial electron-dense deposits along the GBM. Original magnification, 3400 in A and B; 38900 in C and D. (harmonic mean thickness of 602 nm), Lupus serologies remained negative and were detected in the TBM abutting the indicating early diabetic glomerulopathy. complement levels were normal. An allo- proximal tubule basal membrane, similar These findings were interpreted as graft biopsy showed a sparse inflamma- to the native kidney biopsy. These findings immune complex tubulointerstitial ne- tory infiltrate of about 5% of the cortex, were interpreted as recurrent immune phritis (TIN) with minor involvement of composed of lymphocytes, occasional complex TIN. the glomerulus resembling early mem- neutrophils, and rare eosinophils. Loss The patient’s pretransplant and post- branous GN. of brush borders, dilation, and protein transplant sera were tested for anti–brush casts were focally present, but there was border autoantibodies (ABBAs) by indi- no tubulitis. Glomeruli and vessels were rect IF on cryostat sections of normal kid- CLINICAL FOLLOW-UP unremarkable. IF was similar to the native neys at a 1:5 dilution. Strong and selective biopsy, with diffuse granular TBM depos- binding of IgG to the brush border of The patient was treated with steroids but its that stained for IgG (4+), C3 (4+), and proximal tubules was evident without re- remained hemodialysis dependent. He C4d (4+). The glomeruli were negative. activity to the TBM (Figure 2). Control received a deceased donor allograft kidney C4dwasnegativeinperitubularcapillaries. normal human sera (n=20) did not stain 4 years later. The immediate post-transplant The polyoma stain was negative (SV40 brush borders under the same conditions. course was unremarkable and he was large Tantigen). The TBMdeposits stained To seek the antigenic target, double staining maintained on tacrolimus, mycophenolate forIgG1(widespread3+)andwerenega- with the patient’s serum was repeated com- mofetil, and prednisone. tive for IgG2, IgG3, and IgG4. The signif- bined with antibodies to megalin (Figure 3), Seven weeks later, the patient again icance of the difference in IgG subclasses CD10, or maltase. No colocalization was developed nausea and vomiting and his in the native and allograft biopsies is not present (data not shown). serum creatinine level increased (2 mg/dl). clear. Amorphous electron-dense deposits Plasma exchange was initiated, along with intravenous Ig and rituximab, without dramatic benefit. At 45 weeks post-transplant, the patient’sserum creatinine was 3 mg/dl. A repeat allo- graft biopsy showed progression of the TIN, now involving 30% of the cortex, loss of tubular brush borders, and flat- tened epithelial cells and persistent TBM deposits by IF and electron mi- croscopy (Figure 4). C4d was negative in peritubular capillaries and SV40 was negative. Rare subepithelial glomerular deposits were identified. The patient received methylprednisolone pulses, Figure 2. Indirect IF of the patient’s serum on normal human kidney. (A) IgG staining of rituximab, and later belatacept. Serum proximal tubule brush borders. (B) Proximal tubule brush border IgG staining and negative creatinine levels slowly increased to glomerular staining. (C) Control normal serum on normal human kidney. 3.1 mg/dl 2 years post-transplant. J Am Soc Nephrol 27: 380–384, 2016 Anti–Brush Border Antibodies and Nephritis 381 PATHOPHYSIOLOGY of the RENAL BIOPSY www.jasn.org failure.3 The antigenic target remains uncertain, but ABBAs have not been reported. Idiopathic hypocomplementemic TIN is manifested by granular TBM de- posits of IgG and C3 in association with hypocomplementemia. This preferential TBM deposition has been reported in eight cases, all in the setting of low com- plement levels and not associated with SLE or Sjögren’s syndrome. ABBAs have not been reported in this setting.4 Drug-induced TIN with TBM im- Figure 3. Patient IgG-megalin on normalhuman kidney, colocalization by IF. (A) Patient IgG mune complex deposition has been staining on proximal tubule brush borders. (B) Megalin staining on proximal tubule brush rarely documented in association with borders. (C) No evident IgG-megalin colocalization. nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.5 Polyclonal IgG and C3 TBM deposits are Antibody titers were determined by should be considered in the differential present without glomerular deposits. indirect IF using sera from pretransplant diagnosis (Table 1). Two cases showed giant cell tubulitis and post-transplant immunosuppressive Lupus nephritis is the most common with TBM deposits.6 In both settings, treatment time points. The titer before cause of immune complex deposition in the deposits were postulated to arise kidney transplantation was .1:960. Be- the TBM, occurring in about 60% of from antidrug antibodies or elicited fore