Acquisition Research Program Sponsored Report Series

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Acquisition Research Program Sponsored Report Series NPS-FM-18-009 ACQUISITION RESEARCH PROGRAM SPONSORED REPORT SERIES Business Case Valuation of Strategic Flexibility in Shipbuilding: Justifying and Assessing the Value of Flexible Ships Design Features in New Navy Ship Concepts 15 November 2017 Dr. Johnathan Mun, Professor of Research, Information Science Dr. Thomas Housel, Professor, Information Science LCDR Lauren B. Majchrzak Graduate School of Business & Public Policy Naval Postgraduate School Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. Prepared for the Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA 93943. Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy Naval Postgraduate School The research presented in this report was supported by the Acquisition Research Program of the Graduate School of Business & Public Policy at the Naval Postgraduate School. To request defense acquisition research, to become a research sponsor, or to print additional copies of reports, please contact any of the staff listed on the Acquisition Research Program website (www.acquisitionresearch.net). Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy Naval Postgraduate School Abstract To successfully implement the Surface Navy’s Flexible Ships concept, PEO- SHIPS requires a new methodology that assesses the total future value of various combinations of Flexible Ships design features and how they will enable affordable warfighting relevance over the ship’s full-service life. Examples of Flexible Ships design features include decoupling payloads from platforms, standardizing platform- to-payload interfaces, implementing allowance for rapid reconfiguration of onboard electronics and weapons systems, preplanning access routes for mission bays and mission decks, and allowing for sufficient growth margins for various distributed systems. This research analyzes the application of strategic Real Options Valuation methodology within the Integrated Risk Management process to assess the total future value of Flexible Ships design features and for use in the Future Surface Combatant Analysis of Alternatives. The current research has the explicit goal of proposing a reusable, extensible, adaptable, and comprehensive advanced analytical modeling process to help the U.S. Navy in quantifying, modeling, valuing, and optimizing a set of ship design options to create and value a business case for making strategic decisions under uncertainty. Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy - i - Naval Postgraduate School THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy - ii - Naval Postgraduate School NPS-FM-18-009 ACQUISITION RESEARCH PROGRAM SPONSORED REPORT SERIES Flexible and Adaptable Ship Options: Assessing the Future Value of Incorporating Flexible Ships Design Features into New Navy Ship Concepts 15 November 2017 Dr. Johnathan Mun, Professor of Research, Information Science Dr. Thomas Housel, Professor, Information Science LCDR Lauren B. Majchrzak Graduate School of Business & Public Policy Naval Postgraduate School Disclaimer: The views represented in this report are those of the authors and do not reflect the official policy position of the Navy, the Department of Defense, or the federal government. Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy - iii - Naval Postgraduate School THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy - iv - Naval Postgraduate School Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................ 1 Research Process and Layout of the Paper .............................................................. 5 Literature Review ......................................................................................... 5 The Theory of Strategic Real Options, Knowledge Value Added, and Integrated Risk Management .................................................... 5 Real Options Valuation Applications in the U.S. Department of Defense ........................................................................................................ 5 FASO/MAS at PEO-SHIPS: AWS Options for the DDG 51 Flight III......................................................................................................... 6 Conclusions and Recommendations ............................................................ 6 Literature Review ....................................................................................................... 7 Flexible and Adaptable Ship Design .................................................................... 7 Royal Danish Navy .............................................................................................. 9 Flyvefisken Class (SF 300) ........................................................................... 9 Absalon Class Support Ships ..................................................................... 11 Iver Huitfeldt Frigates ................................................................................. 13 German Navy .................................................................................................... 15 French Navy ...................................................................................................... 16 Aquitaine Class .......................................................................................... 17 FTI Class .................................................................................................... 19 Royal Australian Navy ....................................................................................... 20 Future Frigate Mandatory Design Characteristics ...................................... 21 Potential Designs ....................................................................................... 22 American Navy .................................................................................................. 23 LCS—Freedom .......................................................................................... 24 LCS—Independence .................................................................................. 25 Small Surface Combatant ........................................................................... 25 Real Options Valuation with Flexible Ships ....................................................... 27 The Theory of Strategic Real Options, Knowledge Value Added, and Integrated Risk Management ............................................................................................................ 41 The Real Options Solution in a Nutshell ............................................................ 43 Industry Leaders Embracing Strategic Real Options .................................. 44 Knowledge Value Added (KVA) ......................................................................... 48 Integrated Risk Management (IRM)................................................................... 52 Acquisition Research Program Graduate School of Business & Public Policy - v - Naval Postgraduate School Real Options Valuation Applications in the U.S. Department of Defense ................ 57 Option to Wait and Defer (Ability to Wait Before Executing) .............................. 57 Option to Switch (Ability to Switch Applications) ................................................ 58 Simultaneous Compound Option (Parallel Development) ................................. 59 Portfolio Option (Basket of Options to Execute) ................................................ 59 Sequential Compound Option (Proof of Concept, Milestones, and Stage-Gate Development) .................................................................................................... 60 Expansion Option (Platform Technology with Spinoff Capabilities) ................... 61 Abandonment Option (Salvage and Walk Away) ............................................... 62 Contraction Option (Partnerships and Cost/Risk Reduction) ............................. 63 FASO/MAS at PEO-SHIPS: Flexibility Options for Guided Missile Destroyers ........ 65 DDG 51 FLIGHT III ............................................................................................ 65 Step 1: Identification of FASO/MAS Options ..................................................... 66 Power Plant Options ................................................................................... 66 Vertical Launch Systems ............................................................................ 68 Step 2: Cost Analysis and Data Gathering ........................................................ 71 Step 3: Financial Modeling ................................................................................ 73 Static Portfolio Analysis and Comparisons of Multiple Projects .................. 76 Step 4: Tornado and Sensitivity Analytics ......................................................... 78 Step 5: Monte Carlo Risk Simulation ................................................................. 84 Simulation Results, Confidence Intervals, and Probabilities ....................... 84 Probability Distribution Overlay Charts ....................................................... 85 Analysis of Alternatives and Dynamic Sensitivity Analysis ......................... 86 Step 6: Strategic Real Options Valuation Modeling ........................................... 88 Real Options Valuation Modeling ............................................................... 89 Step
Recommended publications
  • Saudi Arabia Enter the 21St Century: the Military and Internal Security
    CSIS__________________________________________ Center for Strategic and International Studies 1800 K Street N.W. Washington, DC 20006 (202) 775-3270 (To comment: [email protected]) Saudi Arabia Enters the 21st Century: The Military and Internal Security Dimension VI. The Saudi Navy Final Review Anthony H. Cordesman Arleigh A. Burke Chair for Strategy Center for Strategic and International Studies October 30, 2002 Copyright Anthony H. Cordesman, all rights reserved Saudi Arabia Enters the 21st Century: The Military Dimension I – Strategic Challenges 11/6/2002 Page ii Introduction This analysis is being circulated for comment as part of the CSIS “Saudi Arabia Enters the 21st Century Project.” It will be extensively revised before final publication. Those interested in commenting, or in participating in the project, should contact Anthony H. Cordesman at the address shown on the cover sheet at [email protected]. This draft is copyright. It may be referenced, or quoted at lengths of less than one page, with proper attribution to the author and CSIS, and to the fact it is a draft document. Copyright Anthony H. Cordesman, all rights reserved. Saudi Arabia Enters the 21st Century: The Military Dimension I – Strategic Challenges 11/6/2002 Page iii The CSIS “Saudi Arabia Enters the 21st Century Project” The CSIS is undertaking a new project to examine the trends shaping the future of Saudi Arabia and its impact on the stability of the Gulf. This project is supported by the Smith Richardson Foundation and builds on the work done for the CSIS Strategic Energy Initiative, the CSIS Net Assessment of the Middle East, and the Gulf in Transition Project.
    [Show full text]
  • Vulnerability Without Capabilities? Small State Strategy and the International Counter-Piracy Agenda Smed, Ulrik Trolle; Wivel, Anders
    Vulnerability without capabilities? Small state strategy and the international counter-piracy agenda Smed, Ulrik Trolle; Wivel, Anders Published in: European Security DOI: 10.1080/09662839.2016.1265941 Publication date: 2017 Document version Peer reviewed version Citation for published version (APA): Smed, U. T., & Wivel, A. (2017). Vulnerability without capabilities? Small state strategy and the international counter-piracy agenda. European Security, 26(1), 79-98. https://doi.org/10.1080/09662839.2016.1265941 Download date: 28. sep.. 2021 Vulnerability without capabilities? Small state strategy and the international counterpiracy agenda Ulrik Trolle Smed and Anders Wivel This is an Accepted Manuscript of an article published in European Security 26(1): 79-98. Available online: http://www.tandfonline.com/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09662839.2016.1265941 ABSTRACT Today, small European states regularly need to go out of area and out of tried and tested institutional settings to defend their security interests. How do small European states meet this challenge most effectively? This analysis suggests that small states can influence multilateral decisions on international security by combining norm entrepreneurship with lobbying and taking on the role as an ‘honest broker’. However, economic capacity, an effective state administration and interests compatible with the agendas of the great powers are key to success. Based on a comprehensive empirical material including 19 elite interviews as well as official documents and other written material, we process trace how one small European state, Denmark, influenced the development of international counterpiracy cooperation and the development of an international counterpiracy strategy for the Gulf of Aden and off the Horn of Africa and discuss which lessons the Danish case may hold for other small states.
    [Show full text]
  • The Heroic Destroyer and "Lucky" Ship O.R.P. "Blyskawica"
    Transactions on the Built Environment vol 65, © 2003 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3509 The heroic destroyer and "lucky" ship O.R.P. "Blyskawica" A. Komorowski & A. Wojcik Naval University of Gdynia, Poland Abstract The destroyer O.R.P. "Blyskawica" is a precious national relic, the only remaining ship that was built before World War I1 (WW2). On the 5oth Anniversary of its service under the Polish flag, it was honoured with the highest military decoration - the Gold Cross of the Virtuti Militari Medal. It has been the only such case in the whole history of the Polish Navy. Its our national hero, war-veteran and very "lucky" warship. "Blyskawica" took part in almost every important operation in Europe throughout WW2. It sailed and covered the Baltic Sea, North Sea, all the area around Great Britain, the Atlantic Ocean and Mediterranean Sea. During the war "Blyskawica" covered a distance of 148 thousand miles, guarded 83 convoys, carried out 108 operational patrols, participated in sinking two warships, damaged three submarines and certainly shot down four war-planes and quite probably three more. It was seriously damaged three times as a result of operational action. The crew casualties aggregated to a total of only 5 killed and 48 wounded petty officers and seamen, so it was a very "lucky" ship during WW2. In July 1947 the ship came back to Gdynia in Poland and started training activities. Having undergone rearmament and had a general overhaul, it became an anti-aircraft defence ship. In 1976 it replaced O.R.P. "Burza" as a Museum-Ship.
    [Show full text]
  • PRESS RELEASE Paris, 25Th JUNE 2019
    PRESS RELEASE Paris, 25th JUNE 2019 Naval Group welcomes the Minister for the Armed Forces Florence Parly to its Lorient shipyard to celebrate the end of construction of the FREMM frigate Normandie. Naval Group is extremely honored to host the French Minister for the Armed Forces, Florence Parly. This celebration marks not only the end of work on the six multi-mission frigates, but also the beginning of the manufacturing of the FREMM frigates with reinforced air defence capabilities and of the Defence and Intervention Frigate (FDI), the first fully digital warships. Hervé Guillou, CEO of Naval Group, and Admiral Christophe Prazuck, Chief of Staff of the French Navy, hosted the Minister for the Armed Forces on board the Normandie frigate for a visit. This warship was delivered in a record time of 40 months, the shortest completion time of the whole multi-mission frigates program. Florence Parly and Hervé Guillou had the opportunity to discuss the ongoing and future surface ships programs built in Lorient: FREMM, FDI and aircraft carriers. Hervé Guillou claimed: “We are proud to meet the expectations set by the Millitary Programming Law. Today, with the completion of the FREMM Normandie, Naval Group has fulfilled its commitment. This industrial and technical success, which represents more than 2.5 millions working hours, encourages us to keep on completing our mission in service of our national and international clients. This project shows once again the firm’s capacity to respect its engagements in terms of costs, deadlines and performance”. Industrial excellence The Normandie is the sixth French multi-mission FREMM frigate.
    [Show full text]
  • SAMP/T Autonomy 360° Protection No Restriction Long-Range to Date, SAMP/T Systems Are in Service Rotating Omnidirectional - Preserve in France and Italy
    Mobility Interoperability Fast deployment Easy to integrate into - Compatible with Swiss all types of air defense - roads and Infrastructures. NATO included. The European solution 30 years of cooperation to protect sovereignty In operational service, Eurosam systems are fully Mission-proven capable of defeating present and future threats. Operational Simplicity deployments SAMP/ T Suitable for all EUROSAM is the leading French-Italian JV in europe that designs, for protection of very high value types of armed produces and sells, long range ground and naval based air assets and sensitive forces. defense systems. The JV was created by MBDA and THALES, European areas including Reduced staff. leaders in missiles, systems and radars, endowing it with major in conflict area. expertise in terms of operational requirements for air defense. SAMP/T Autonomy 360° protection No restriction Long-Range To date, SAMP/T systems are in service Rotating omnidirectional - Preserve in France and Italy. radar 1 turn/ second - country Agile missile launched sovereignty. Surface-To-Air System vertically. Protection tailored © EUROSAM - Designed by: / July 2020 to the needs of air space Nations using SAMP/T Operational deployments of SAMP/T In addition, more than 50 ASTER missile-based systems are in service in 12 armed forces around the world. Centre d’Affaires La Boursidière Rue de la Boursidière - Bâtiment K F-92357 Le Plessis Robinson Cedex Tel: +33 (0)1 41 87 14 14 Mail: [email protected] www.eurosam.com Long-range ground Single missile T based integrated air SAMP/T, continuous adaptation to defeat all types of threats to the threat and missile defense system 2050 / ASTER missile covers from short to long-range missions including to protect airspace its self-defense.
    [Show full text]
  • Turkey's S-400 Dilemma
    EDAM Foreign Policy and Security Paper Series 2017/5 Turkey’s S-400 Dilemma July, 2017 Dr. Can Kasapoglu Defense Analyst, EDAM 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY • This report’s core military assessment of a possible • In fact, modern air defense concepts vary between S-400 deal concludes that Ankara’s immediate aim is fighter aircraft-dominant postures, SAM-dominant to procure the system primarily for air defense missi- postures, and balanced force structures. However, if ons as a surface-to-air missile (SAM) asset, rather than Ankara is to replace its fighter aircraft-dominant con- performing ballistic missile defense (BMD) functions. cept with a SAM and aircraft mixed understanding, This priority largely stems from the Turkish Air Force’s which could be an effective alternative indeed, then currently low pilot-to-cockpit ratio (0.8:1 by open- it has to maintain utmost interoperability within its source 2016 estimates). Thus, even if the procurement principal arsenal. Key importance of interoperability is to be realized, Turkey will first and foremost operate between aircraft and integrated air and missile defense the S-400s as a stopgap measure to augment its air systems can be better understood by examining the superiority calculus over geo-strategically crucial areas. Israeli Air Force’s (IAF) recent encounter in the Syrian This is why the delivery time remains a key condition. airspace. On March 17, 2017, a Syrian S-200 (SA-5) battery fired an anti-aircraft missile to hunt down an • Although it is not a combat-tested system, not only IAF fixed-wing aircraft (probably an F-15 or F-16 Russian sources but also many Western military variant).
    [Show full text]
  • French Armed Forces Update November 2020
    French Armed Forces Update November 2020 This paper is NOT an official publication from the French Armed Forces. It provides an update on the French military operations and main activities. The French Defense Attaché Office has drafted it in accordance with open publications. The French Armed Forces are heavily deployed both at home and overseas. On the security front, the terrorist threat is still assessed as high in France and operation “Sentinelle” (Guardian) is still going on. Overseas, the combat units are extremely active against a determined enemy and the French soldiers are constantly adapting their courses of action and their layout plans to the threat. Impacted by the Covid-19 pandemic, the French Armed Forces have resumed their day-to-day activities and operations under the sign of transformation and modernization. DeuxIN huss arMEMORIAMds parachut istes tués par un engin explosif improvisé au Mali | Zone Militaire 09/09/2020 11:16 SHARE On September 5th, during a control operation within the Tessalit + region, three hussards were seriously injured after the explosion & of an Improvised Explosive Device. Despite the provision of + immediate care and their quick transportation to the hospital, the ! hussard parachutiste de 1ère classe Arnaud Volpe and + brigadier-chef S.T1 died from their injuries. ' + ( Après la perte du hussard de 1ere classe Tojohasina Razafintsalama, le On23 November 12th, during a routine mission in the vicinity of juillet, lors d’une attaque suicide commise avec un VBIED [véhicule piégé], le 1er Régiment de Hussards Parachutistes [RHP] a une nouvelle fois été Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt, nine members of the Multinational endeuillé, ce 5 septembre.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Piracy Review Week 49 06 December 2011 Comprehensive Information on Complex Crises
    CIVIL - MILITARY FUSION CEN TRE Anti-Piracy Review Week 49 06 December 2011 Comprehensive Information on Complex Crises INSIDE THIS ISSUE This document provides a weekly overview of developments in Anti-Piracy from 22 November—05 December 2011. Further information on the topics covered is available at www.cimicweb.org. Hyper- Economics links to source material are highlighted in blue and underlined in the text. We encourage you to con- International Response tact the Anti-Piracy Team Leader or our Subject-Matter Experts for more detailed information. Justice Security Erin Foster ► [email protected] Humanitarian Affairs—Somalia Economics Regional Issues—Somalia iracy off the coast of West Africa has Kenya’s Business Daily reports that Kenyan remained a major news item over the consumers will most likely not benefit from an ABOUT THE CFC P past two weeks, with the Integrated expected decrease in the cost of global sea The Civil-Military Fusion Centre Regional Information Networks (IRIN) report- trade. According to the article, the introduc- (CFC) is an information and ing that Benin has seen a 70% drop in local tion of new and larger vessels will decrease knowledge management ship activity. The International Maritime Or- shipping costs. However, analysts point to- organisation focused on improving ganization (IMO) Deputy Director of Mari- wards the added costs maritime piracy impos- civil-military interaction, facilitating time Safety, Chris Trelawny, told IRIN, “most es on the shipping industry as the reason no information sharing and enhancing attacks off Benin are directed at oil and energy decrease will be observed. In Kenya, addition- situational awareness through the tankers and are not only damaging local econ- al monthly fees for imports (USD 23.9 mil- CimicWeb portal and our weekly omies and threatening seafarers but could also lion) and exports (USD 9.8 million) are passed and monthly publications.
    [Show full text]
  • The Future of European Naval Power and the High-End Challenge Jeremy Stöhs
    Jeremy Stöhs ABOUT THE AUTHOR Dr. Jeremy Stöhs is the Deputy Director of the Austrian Center for Intelligence, Propaganda and Security Studies (ACIPSS) and a Non-Resident Fellow at the Institute for Security Policy, HOW HIGH? Kiel University. His research focuses on U.S. and European defence policy, maritime strategy and security, as well as public THE FUTURE OF security and safety. EUROPEAN NAVAL POWER AND THE HIGH-END CHALLENGE ISBN 978875745035-4 DJØF PUBLISHING IN COOPERATION WITH 9 788757 450354 CENTRE FOR MILITARY STUDIES How High? The Future of European Naval Power and the High-End Challenge Jeremy Stöhs How High? The Future of European Naval Power and the High-End Challenge Djøf Publishing In cooperation with Centre for Military Studies 2021 Jeremy Stöhs How High? The Future of European Naval Power and the High-End Challenge © 2021 by Djøf Publishing All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means – electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise – without the prior written permission of the Publisher. This publication is peer reviewed according to the standards set by the Danish Ministry of Higher Education and Science. Cover: Morten Lehmkuhl Print: Ecograf Printed in Denmark 2021 ISBN 978-87-574-5035-4 Djøf Publishing Gothersgade 137 1123 København K Telefon: 39 13 55 00 e-mail: [email protected] www. djoef-forlag.dk Editors’ preface The publications of this series present new research on defence and se- curity policy of relevance to Danish and international decision-makers.
    [Show full text]
  • Naval Craft, Weapon and Sensor Systems
    ++ I&S NAVAL CRAFT, WEAPON AND SENSOR SYSTEMS Fr. Lürssen Werft Abstract: The article provides an inside view on trends in technology of current and future naval construction programmes as seen by Lürssen, the German shipyard for naval vessels located in Bremen, Germany. The changing operational require- ments recognised in many western European and overseas navies focus on a surface combatant such as a corvette-sized ship with advanced capabilities to meet the spe- cific demands for littoral warfare operations. Based on these new requirements the article outlines technologies in current and future designs for Corvette- and Frigate- sized ships. It includes different types of platforms together with their specific benefits and capabilities for the intended employment in littoral warfare. In addi- tion, measures to reduce the ship’s signatures for enhanced survivability are broadly discussed. With respect to adequate sea-keeping, manoeuvrability, speed and en- durance (properties) in the littoral environment, the article also expands on the de- velopment and characteristics of new propulsion systems emphasising the overall need for a high degree of automation in all system components. The discussion on modern combat system technology once again underlines the need for a modular and flexible system design with open system architecture. The highest possible level of system automation reducing the number of personnel in the CIC and en- suring immediate reaction in a threat scenario is a further topic. Full integration of all sensors and weapons coupled with proven operational software is the essential technical requirement in this context. Finally, the article comments on some eco- nomical aspects of current building philosophies touching thereby on possibilities for crew reduction, costs reduction, potential capabilities for midlife refit, and growth potential.
    [Show full text]
  • Ami Project Report
    AAI L-3 Integrated Systems ABB Process Solutions & Service L-3 Klein Associates Abeking & Rasmussen L-3 MAPPS Amicus L-3 Ocean Systems Argon ST L-3 SPD Technologies Armaris L-3 Wescam ASELAN LaCroix ASMAR Shipbuilding Lazard Carnegie Wylie Atlas Elektronik GmbH Lloyd's Register EMEA AuAVEVAstralian Submarine Corp. Lockheed Martin BBAE INSYTEabcock International Group Lopac Pty Ltd BAE North America Lurssen Werft BAE Ship Systems MacArtney AS BAE Systems Land and Armament Malaysian Navy Bath Iron Works Mandanis Applied Technologies Blohm + Voss MATCOM BMT Defence Services Ltd Mazagon Dock Ltd Boeing MBDA Bofors Defense AB Mac Taggart Scott Bofra Monch Publishing Bosch Rexroth M Ship Co. Boston Whaler MTU BrahMos Aerospace Pve. Ltd NATO HQ - Belgium Campbell Industries Naval Surface Warfare Center Caterpillar Navantia CEDOCAR Navy International Programs Office CEA Technologies Pty Ltd Newport News Shipbuilding Central Marine Design Bureau Almaz Nexus Communications Central Marine Design Bureau Rubin Northrop Grumman Ship Systems Chilean Navy Noske-Kaeser GmbH Cincinnati Gear Co. OCEA Cunico Corp. Oerlikon-Contraves David Brown Engineering Orizzonte Sistemi Navali S.p.A DCNS Philippine Navy DGA Polish Navy Dornier Pratt & Whitney DRS Technologies Qatar Armed Forces Joint EW Center EADS Defense Communications QinetiQ EADS Defense Electronics Raytheon Integrated Defense Systems EADS Defense & Security Systems Raytheon International ECA Ericsson Microwave Systems Raytheon Missile Company Evonik Foams Inc. Reflex Advanced Marine EMS Development Corp Rheinmetall Waffe Munition GmbH Energy Power Systems Rockwell Collins Eurosam Rohde & Schwarz GmbH & Co. KG Fincantieri Rolls-Royce Finmeccanica S.p.A. Saab French Embassy Saab Grintek Defence Pty Ltd Furness Enterprise Ltd Saab Bofors Dynamics G&M Power Plant Saab Danmark General Dynamics-Advanced Systems Sagem Defense Securite Co.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Executive Summary In
    Missile Defence Around the World Conclusions for Poland diminish. On the other hand, however, Executive Summary modernisation of Russian missile forces, Moscow’s violations of INF treaty as well Proliferation of weapons of mass as increasingly aggressive rhetoric in the destruction and missile technologies is a NATO-Russia relations cause concerns. growing threat to NATO member states, From the Polish perspective, principal their territories and citizens. Although the issue lies in assuring the ability to provide number of nuclear warheads around the point missile defence against a potential world decreases, states’ nuclear threat of Russia’s ballistic missile strike. capabilities continue to expand with The strategic area that has been development of ever-more precise neglected for many years is the Polish air delivery systems. Approximately 30 defence system. Until now, the core of the states around the World, including Iran Polish weaponry against the air attack has and North Korea, possess or strive to been based on Soviet missile systems. acquire advanced missile technologies. After many years of neglect, the MoD Growing tensions between NATO and planners as well as the policy-makers Russia challenge the air defence realised that further delay of the technical capabilities of the alliance’s eastern flank. modernisation in these areas is no longer By implementing A2AD strategies, Russia possible. As a result, Polish Air Force is puts in question NATO’s capacity to come expected to obtain 8 batteries of medium to aid and assistance of threatened range air defence system WISŁA, which members. Although the Alliance declares are capable of hitting aircraft targets at a that the aim of a NATO Missile Defence distance of 100 km and ballistic missile capability is to provide coverage and targets with a range of 1000 km.
    [Show full text]