Exceptional Queerness: Defining the Boundaries of Normative U.S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EXCEPTIONAL QUEERNESS: DEFINING THE BOUNDARIES OF NORMATIVE U.S. CITIZENSHIP, 1876-1936 BY EMILY ELIZABETH SKIDMORE DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History with a minor in Gender and Women‘s Studies in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2011 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral Committee: Professor Antoinette Burton, Chair Professor David R. Roediger, Director of Research Associate Professor Kristin Hoganson Assistant Professor Fiona I.B. Ngô Associate Professor Siobhan Somerville Abstract ―Exceptional Queerness‖ tracks the cultural, legal, and medical narratives produced around moments of ―discovery‖ wherein the female body of an individual whom a community knew to be male was revealed. This study investigates nineteen such cases, and tracks the ways in which the stories changed as they circulated from local newspapers and trial courtrooms to the pages of sensational national newspapers and medical journals in the period between 1876 and 1936. Such careful attention to the circulation of narratives is important because it was in this period that sexologists first identified homosexuality, thereby creating a new lens through which ―normal‖ sexuality was defined. Homosexuality in women was defined by ―sexual inversion,‖ a pathology physically signified by a predilection toward masculinity and cross-dressing. Previous scholarship has argued that sexological texts were immensely influential in shaping popular understandings of gender and sexual normativity, and that the mass circulation press had embraced the sexological figure of the ―female invert‖ as the symbol for lesbianism by the late nineteenth century. However, this dissertation is motivated by the conviction that the mere construction of new identity categories did not mean that all bodies would automatically be legible through them, and thus seeks to understand how shifts in national discourse impacted the ways in which local communities categorized the queer bodies in their midst. Because of the purported connection between public notions of lesbianism and cross-gender identification, stories of ―revelation‖ wherein the female body of an individual whom a community knew to be male was revealed provide a unique window into the ways in which local communities negotiated with national discourses of normative gender and sexuality. Whereas previous studies on the formation of gender and sexuality in the United States have generally utilized only one genre of sources—focusing exclusively on representations of gender and sexual deviance in ii novels, the sensational press, or sexology literature—―Exceptional Queerness‖ highlights the dissonance between the genres, and in so doing, illustrates that sexological theories of gender and sexual deviance did not dictate community responses to queer bodies at the turn of the twentieth century, and furthermore, that the geography of queer identity formations is much more complicated (and much more interesting) than previously thought. iii Acknowledgments This portion of my dissertation is, without a doubt, the section I have most looked forward to writing. Not simply because doing so would signal the project‘s completion, but because it would be the moment in which I would finally be able to express publicly the overwhelming feelings of gratitude I have felt throughout this long and tedious process. Indeed, I have been tremendously lucky to have benefitted from the generosity of dozens of people and institutions throughout my academic career, and it is my privilege to be able to acknowledge them here. Financially, this project would not have been possible without funding I have been extremely grateful to receive from a variety of sources, both within the University of Illinois community and from outside. The University of Illinois Graduate College, History Department, Gender and Women‘s Studies Department, and the Unit for Criticism and Interpretative Theory have kindly supplied the funds necessary for me to complete my research. In addition, a generous grant from the Center for Lesbian and Gay Studies (CLAGS) was particularly beneficial in helping me fund the initial portions of this project. Additionally, this dissertation would not have been possible without the guidance and support from dozens of librarians and archivists at libraries throughout the country. In particular, the staff at the University of Illinois‘ Inter-Library Loan office has tracked down countless obscure publications for me, for which I am very grateful. I am also grateful to the staff at the Denver Historical Society, San Francisco‘s GLBT Historical Society, Los Angeles Public Library, ONE National Archive, the Lesbian Herstory Archive, and the Harry Ransom Center at the University of Texas-Austin. Additionally, I‘d like to personally mention the following librarians and archivists for going far beyond the call of duty in helping me track down resources iv that have been particularly important to this project: Jim Huff at the Portland Police Museum; Anne Frantilla at the Seattle Municipal Archives; David Matte and Craig Williams at the Idaho State Historical Society; John Russell at the Pioneer Museum in Manhattan, Montana; Mary Jo Lanphear at the Ontario County Records and Archive Center, and Zach Wilske at the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Historical Reference Library. This project would have never been started had it not been for my tremendous luck at encountering two incredible mentors as an undergraduate at Macalester College. It was in Peter Rachleff‘s classes that I fell in love with History, and because of that, I am forever in his debt. Additionally, it was Mary Wingerd who first encouraged me to pursue graduate school, and if it wasn‘t for her faith in my abilities as a historian, I don‘t think I would have ever taken those first steps. And as incredible as it now seems, I was lucky enough to find mentors just as caring and inspiring as Peter and Mary during my graduate work at the University of Illinois. I was drawn to Illinois to work with Dave Roediger, who proved to be an excellent advisor—it is truly impossible to convey how much I learned from him, as an activist, teacher, and scholar. I also had the excellent fortune of working closely with Antoinette Burton at Illinois, and I know without a doubt that my work is better today because of her engagement. Indeed, I first encountered Antoinette during my second semester of graduate school, at a moment in which I was seriously considering dropping out. However, Antoinette inspired me to not only stay put, but to work harder than ever before. She has been an amazing advisor; always willing to read (and re-read) drafts, provide insightful comments, and thoughtful advice. I truly would not be where I am today if it wasn‘t for her. In addition to Dave and Antoinette, I have had the good fortune of benefitting from an incredible dissertation committee. Fiona I.B. Ngô has been particularly helpful—she has an v incredible skill for always asking the most clarifying questions. Her feedback on multiple drafts of this dissertation has proven to be invaluable, and I have greatly appreciated her good humor throughout this process. Kristin Hoganson has also been a tremendous help to me; her close readings and thoughtful insights have greatly strengthened this dissertation. Lastly, Siobhan Somerville has been an amazing reader—always providing thoughtful comments and difficult questions. I‘m grateful to each of the members of my committee, and hope that the final version of this dissertation reflects the profound impact they each have had upon me. I have benefitted from questions and feedback from audiences at many conferences throughout the course of this project, for which I am very grateful. In particular, I would like to thank audience members at the 2008 Annual Meeting of the American Studies Association (especially Audra Simpson and Scott Morgensen), Connexions: A Working Paper‘s Conference on Race and Sex in North America (especially Ian Carter and Jennifer Brier), and the 2011 American Historical Association Annual Meeting (especially Susan Stryker). I know that my work was made better through the thoughtful comments provided me at each of these conferences. And lastly, I would like to thank the many friends and family members who have made the process of completing this project bearable. Indeed, graduate work at the University of Illinois was made much more fun because of the support and silliness of Anna Kurhajec, Andy Eisen, Ian Hartman, Nathan Chio, and Myra Washington. Thank you all for your willingness to engage with my work, as well as your eagerness to provide welcome diversions from said work. Other graduate students in the History department have also made my time spent therein thought- provoking and inspiring, particularly Kwame Holmes, Sarah Frohart-Lane, Andy Bruno, and Janine Giordano Drake. I‘d also like to thank my Macalester friends, who, luckily for me, are vi now spread throughout the country—I‘m tremendously grateful that my research provided multiple opportunities for extended visits in numerous cities. Josh Aas provided me with amazing hospitality in Philadelphia, Sarah McColl delighted me in New York, Michael McNamara and Eliza Schrader provided me with a home away from home in San Francisco, and Marc Robins provided numerous wonderful distractions during my visit to Los Angeles. My research trips were made far more pleasant (in fact, they were lovely!) because of them. Additionally, Minneapolis/St. Paul continued to be a home base for me throughout my graduate career, and I‘d be remiss to not mention the rock-solid support (as well as countless home- cooked meals, dance parties, days on Cedar Lake, and Thanksgiving dinners) I‘ve enjoyed with Amelia Goodyear, Aaron Brosier, Lauren Gaffney, and Peter Gaffney over the years. Additionally, I‘d like to thank my Albuquerque friends (particularly Clare Daniel, Jess Fishken- Harkins, and Elizabeth Tannen) for providing an excellent space for me to complete my dissertation from.