Critical Programming Toward a Philosophy of Computing

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Critical Programming Toward a Philosophy of Computing CRITICAL PROGRAMMING TOWARD A PHILOSOPHY OF COMPUTING by JOHN ROBERT BORK B.A University of Houston, 1993 B.S. Bowling Green State University, 1999 M.I.T. Bowling Green State University, 2005 A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Texts and Technology in the College of Arts and Humanities at the University of Central Florida Orlando, Florida Fall Term 2015 Major Professor: Bruce Janz © 2015 John Robert Bork version 20151108 ii ABSTRACT Beliefs about the relationship between human beings and computing machines and their destinies have alternated from heroic counterparts to conspirators of automated genocide, from apocalyptic extinction events to evolutionary cyborg convergences. Many fear that people are losing key intellectual and social abilities as tasks are offloaded to the 'everyware' of the built environment, which is developing a mind of its own. If digital technologies have contributed to forming a dumbest generation and ushering in a robotic moment, we all have a stake in addressing this collective intelligence problem. While digital humanities continue to flourish and introduce new uses for computer technologies, the basic modes of philosophical inquiry remain in the grip of print media, and default philosophies of computing prevail, or experimental ones propagate false hopes. I cast this as-is situation as the post-postmodern network dividual cyborg, recognizing that the rational enlightenment of modernism and regressive subjectivity of postmodernism now operate in an empire of extended mind cybernetics combined with techno- capitalist networks forming societies of control. Recent critical theorists identify a justificatory scheme foregrounding participation in projects, valorizing social network linkages over heroic individualism, and commending flexibility and adaptability through life long learning over stable career paths. It seems to reify one possible, contingent configuration of global capitalism as if it was the reflection of a deterministic evolution of commingled technogenesis and synaptogenesis. To counter this trend I offer a theoretical framework to focus on the phenomenology of software and code, joining social critiques with textuality and media studies, the former proposing that theory be done iii through practice, and the latter seeking to understand their schematism of perceptibility by taking into account engineering techniques like time axis manipulation. The social construction of technology makes additional theoretical contributions dispelling closed world, deterministic historical narratives and requiring voices be given to the engineers and technologists that best know their subject area. This theoretical slate has been recently deployed to produce rich histories of computing, networking, and software, inform the nascent disciplines of software studies and code studies, as well as guide ethnographers of software development communities. I call my syncretism of these approaches the procedural rhetoric of diachrony in synchrony, recognizing that multiple explanatory layers operating in their individual temporal and physical orders of magnitude simultaneously undergird post-postmodern network phenomena. Its touchstone is that the human-machine situation is best contemplated by doing, which as a methodology for digital humanities research I call critical programming. Philosophers of computing explore working code places by designing, coding, and executing complex software projects as an integral part of their intellectual activity, reflecting on how developing theoretical understanding necessitates iterative development of code as it does other texts, and how resolving coding dilemmas may clarify or modify provisional theories as our minds struggle to intuit the alien temporalities of machine processes. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES......................................................................................................................viii LIST OF TABLES..........................................................................................................................ix CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................1 From Automated Genocide to the Dumbest Generation.............................................................1 A Collective Intelligence Problem..............................................................................................7 Societies of Control................................................................................................................9 The Quintessential Postmodern Object................................................................................11 Foss Hopes............................................................................................................................13 Default Philosophies of Computing.....................................................................................16 Digital Humanities Solutions....................................................................................................19 Not to Use Old Tools for New Problems..............................................................................19 Scholarship Requires a Cybersage.......................................................................................21 Digital Humanities Projects..................................................................................................24 Critical Programming Studies..............................................................................................26 CHAPTER 2: POST-POSTMODERN NETWORK DIVIDUAL CYBORG...............................31 Post-Postmodern Subjectivity...................................................................................................34 Modernism and Postmodernism...........................................................................................35 Regressive Subjectivity........................................................................................................41 Inventing the Posthuman in Heidegger's America...............................................................58 Network Dividual Cyborg.........................................................................................................63 v Closed World Cybernetics....................................................................................................65 Cyborg Embodiment............................................................................................................77 Techno-capitalist Networks..................................................................................................90 Dividual Cyborg.................................................................................................................103 CHAPTER 3: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK AND METHODOLOGY..............................120 Theoretical Framework...........................................................................................................122 Critical Theory....................................................................................................................124 Textuality Studies...............................................................................................................134 Media Studies.....................................................................................................................146 Social Construction of Technology....................................................................................157 Histories of Computing, Software and Networking...........................................................167 Psycho-Social Studies of Computer Programmers.............................................................185 Philosophers of Computing Technologies..........................................................................201 Software Studies.................................................................................................................229 Code Studies.......................................................................................................................264 Procedural Rhetorics of Diachrony in Synchrony..............................................................296 Methodology...........................................................................................................................320 Philosophical Programmers................................................................................................321 Working Code Places..........................................................................................................324 Programming Philosophers................................................................................................340 Critical Programming.........................................................................................................351 CHAPTER 4: CRITICAL PROGRAMMING STUDIES...........................................................358 vi Symposia Remediates Orality.................................................................................................358 Ensoniment.........................................................................................................................373 Tapoc Remediates Literacy.....................................................................................................375 Fossification.......................................................................................................................390
Recommended publications
  • PUC Approves CATV Sale Crackdown Ordered Against Hooligans
    ----------------------S' 1 ^ ■ ■/ ' ■ / -•V, X 'V MANCifiESTER, CONN,, THURSDAY, NOV. 1, 1973— VOL. XCIII, Na; 28 Mqnche,ler^ 4 City of Village Charm _ thirtv.two PACES - two sections - ^I’RICEf KIFTEKN CENTS full Independence Assured It -.fi ~ fire Jaworski had settled on Jaworski and prosecutor not suBject to firing have complete independence. • ’ QJn* * d" nat’ied withouLfirst consulting with the SaxBe. By Nixon. \’ n specified congressional leaders SaxBe said he Believes Nixon SaxBe, a RepuBlican and ^ ' " ^ 1 approved and “ascertaining that their Archibald Cox was fired Oqt. went too far in agreeing to. n - selection of Leon Jaworski consensus is in accord with his former Ohio attorney general, 20 as special Watergate release tapes of presidential - vr ’ths.as new WatergatV soecialspecial proposed action.” “ hacT said earlier In the day he prosecutor for refusing to drop conversations dealing with the prosecutor with full in­ ■ was “relatively sure” he will Be The firing of Cox after his his court Battle for White House case. dependence and safeguards nominated to Be attorney refusal to aBide by Nixon's tape recordings on Watergate. The 57-year-old senator said’ against Being fired. general. orders to drop efforts in court Elliot L, Richardson resigned he Believes the tapes are The President promised not SaxBe told reporters he was to oBtain confidential White ■ as attorney general the same privileged and “about as in­ to discharge Jaworski, as -he satisfied "the President has Hqusje. tapes and documents day rather than carry out timate a thing as cart Be.” He had Archibald Cox, without oB­ act^d honoraBly in the touched off a massive con­ Nixon’s order to fire Cox.
    [Show full text]
  • European Patent Bulletin 1987/20
    1987/20 13.05.1987 0221049>• - 0221891 et**!*» Ubran. ISSf 0170-9305 - \, JUH11987 Europäisches Europea EP^-EPO-O® letin européen Patentblatt Patent Bulletin des brevets Inhalt Contents Sommaire I. Veröffentlichte Anmeldungen 9 I. Published Applications 9 I. Demandes publiées 9 1.1 Geordnet nach der Internationalen 9 1.1 Arranged in accordance with the 9 1.1 Classées selon la classification 9 Patentklassifikation International patent classification internationale des brevets 1.2(1) PCT-Anmeldungen (Art. 158(1)) 113 1.2(1) PCT applications (Art. 158(1)) 113 1.2(1) Demandes PCT (art. 158(1)) 113 1.2(2) PCT-Anmeldungen ; Übersetzung 117 1.2 (2) PCT applications ; translation not 117 1.2(2) Demandes PCT; traduction non 117 nicht zugeleitet (Art. 158(2)) supplied (Art. 158(2)) remise (art. 158(2)) 1.3(1) Geordnet nach Veröffentlichungs- 117 1.3 (1) Arranged by publication number 117 1.3 (1) Classées selon les numéros de 117 nummern publication 1.3(2) Geordnet nach Anmeldenummern 125 1.3(2) Arranged by application number 125 1.3(2) Classées selon les numéros des 125 demandes 1.4 Geordnet nach Namen der 133 1.4 Arranged by name of applicant 133 1.4 Classées selon les noms des 133 Anmelder demandeurs 1.5 Geordnet nach benannten 147 1.5 Arranged by designated Contracting 147 1.5 Classées selon les Etats contractants 147 Vertragsstaaten States désignés 1.6(1) Nach Erstellung des europäischen 174 1.6(1) Documents discovered after 174 1.6(1) Documents découverts après 174 Recherchenberichts ermittelte neue completion of the European search l'établissement
    [Show full text]
  • Winona Daily News Winona City Newspapers
    Winona State University OpenRiver Winona Daily News Winona City Newspapers 2-7-1969 Winona Daily News Winona Daily News Follow this and additional works at: https://openriver.winona.edu/winonadailynews Recommended Citation Winona Daily News, "Winona Daily News" (1969). Winona Daily News. 829. https://openriver.winona.edu/winonadailynews/829 This Newspaper is brought to you for free and open access by the Winona City Newspapers at OpenRiver. It has been accepted for inclusion in Winona Daily News by an authorized administrator of OpenRiver. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Cloudy With Want Ad Occasiona l Very Sel.-E-Phone Light Snow Number Is 3321 ! Witness Links Oswald TO PREVEN T OFFENSIVE With Shaw and Ferrie NEW ORLEANS (AP) — A a codefendant. Dymond reacted cial Equality, which was push- one-time civil rights worker told sharply. ing a voter registration drive. the jury at Clay L. Shaw's con- "We are not here to defend One day, he said, a big black the findings of the Warren Re- car pulled up aid parked near spiracy trial he saw Shaw, Lee Tighten Security port," he told the jury. "I im- him as he was standing outside Harvey Oswald and David W. plore you Ferrie together , do not let the drama tie door to the voter registrar's . and pageantry of what hap- office. The testimony by Corrie C. pened in Dealey Plaza in Dallas Collins said a anan he later re- Collins of Baton Rouge was the highlight obscure the real issues in this cognized as Oswald stepped of opening testimony case." from the back seat.
    [Show full text]
  • In the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware
    Case 20-12085-CSS Doc 33 Filed 09/14/20 Page 1 of 40 IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE In re: Chapter 15 GROUPE DYNAMITE INC., et al., Case No. 20-12085 (CSS) Debtors in a Foreign Proceeding,1 (Jointly Administered) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE I, Colin Linebaugh, am employed in the county of Los Angeles, State of California. I hereby certify that on September 9, 2020, at my direction and under my supervision, employees of Omni Agent Solutions caused true and correct copies of the following documents to be served via the method set forth on the Core Notice Parties Service List attached hereto as Exhibit A: Motion for Order (I) Directing Joint Administration of Cases Under Chapter 15 of The Bankruptcy Code and (II) Authorizing Foreign Representative to File Consolidated Lists of Information Required by Bankruptcy Rule 1007(A)(4) [Docket No. 2]. Verified Petition for (I) Recognition of Foreign Main Proceedings, (II) Recognition of Foreign Representative, and (III) Related Relief Under Chapter 15 of The Bankruptcy Code [Docket No. 3]. Motion for Provisional Relief Pursuant to Section 1519 of The Bankruptcy Code [Docket No. 5]. Foreign Representative’s Motion Seeking Entry of an Order Authorizing the Redaction of Certain Personal Identification Information and Granting Related Relief [Docket No. 6]. Declaration of Foreign Representative Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 1515 and Rule 1007(A)(4) of The Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure and In Support of Verified Petition for (I) Recognition of Foreign Main Proceedings, (II) Recognition of Foreign Representative, and (III) Related Relief Under Chapter 15 of The Bankruptcy Code [Docket No.
    [Show full text]
  • THE WESTFIELD LEADER Hopes a Month Before the Date of Our Bloodmobile Visit
    'Poppy Day* THEWESTFIELD LEADER Tomorrow THE LEADING AKO MOST WIDELY CIRCULATED WEEKLY NEWSPAPER <N UNION COUNTY PEVENTY-THIRD YEAR—Ko. 39 U). NEW JERSEY. THURSDAY. MAY 23. Pvlllaiui* t rt-!»t'r> in« the Pa-t Lee Homestead: A Bit Of Americana Enriching ihi* Futurr , 5<iH<fc f*ifio»_7»^ r;,KV interest- of Kdawjits Uiroaf.l. :lieit repn-SK:! onsi id ii! iof.iut iiiid M"rrK'\ed Kn'Ji 't£ *<! •'> ^'.s-::-l.:?-fi -j* !j:-re '->) pre bV.w. Mrs- Ruben Hetid 1\A Sc.::v i ii ttr.(Ml> Wlrtt pK'.H'fi. CV&t Of If «-.r. o'iit.'!1.i>t Tilt- Lt-t iiymt'tLe.iiij jiud -.(•" ;;-.,t- it. ni",'::-u:y affairs :«•:->»• Msril; Isi'.t reset'.'. «! li* IMH. >.:..ie ::. ;-<n- iisti ; 1 J:«s- .-J^:. .iit ^nd.r.iiter. to itad au'Jie.M.t.;»'.>Bjf i;> ;>re ReioldUii'.wj v.i'I: !.•:••:.•.!;•.: prei-iaer.t o':«r u .. i. s-ki: o! lu-.ij U.at is- «JV f'i* ^ r;ir iK';f£ They u;e IU'.:«;>' tl-UKU'd vn i'-i- "•>'- ::* ?;-.:.:: u' F'recii'.'.derj "" ' > yri-ir •Jif. o:, 0,.; K:.-v.i- Ki ;r. Sv;i:c i'.-:r.j 1; : fi* p:-.-ht. ;-;\::]'.!!Lav) ix* MUM '' v r.:: o'-.\ ci;^«'!i ;: S».K w !.(•!: hit fx-eii -.'it (•,:,:.•: -if' :r...;t; :!:>••- ="*• es: r.:ct ::,t KrpjMn-fc:: Wti-t.f:'. p:f Sa-ietv (.;.i .V;,Lifj;<- acres 111 lxi-fut ;.•! >:'.i:-.: F.v*:^ ;;rs" ii" fi rue: v.ret dt «'.ituu'.t- d.'vsii-d i'i":;.st •.
    [Show full text]
  • Reagan Teiis Judge Bork
    «0 — M ANCH ESTER H ER ALD. Tuesday. Oct. », 1987 N0IIIE8 NaPWiMTEO FOR SALE FUaONTCOAL/ CM» I R M S M i Fair rent; Vete unlikely befere electicn / page 3 R o m p s : M H S girls PERSON Wonttd to cart M ANCHESTER. Colonial BUSINESS-^ SERVICE MRECTORY I^Sm iance^iUI milts, tor 3 cMIdrtfl In mv on nicg doop lot, on o FIREWOOD SALE A/C. AA4-FM Cassette. unbeaten after toppling homo. W ttk d o yttvtrv qulot Cul-do-Soc In con- *S3 per eetd. 8 R. tangMia, 82200. or best offer. ^ t r Saturday. AAuit ygnlgnt locatton. Front grsen, deNveieA 8 oord 871-4451 after 4pm. navt own trontporta- to bock Mostgr plus up minimum. MC/VISA DODGE Mirada 1^2. D o w d ro p ; Analysts unfazed by tumble / p a ge 21 Rockville / p a g e 9 tton. M7-7043. to 3 morg bodrooms. NartiMni FIrgwiaR Good condition, A/C, Dining room, flro- CHILDCora, RGoponsIblg Power windows and part timt, small family ploced living room, full warm parson for 1 locks, cruise, AM -FM THOSE 8UY8 WHO MW REf TREE SERVICE 77E-W16 oporotlon, no prttsurt. baths, garage. $147,900. small cbllp in our M.T.8. Bucket, truck * ch^tper. catsefte.$2S00.447-7045. Will aceomodote scht- D.W. Fish, 443-1591.0 homo. 20-25 hours- PAIHT Stump removBl. dult and ptrtonal con- /WOOk. Days. 444-3974. BUILDERS Interior sfid exterior sldoratlons. Andoytr HIGH Collbrg. Now peinting. Cell today for a consldsrstlon for eldofty RECREATIDNAL free estimate. Tom or Ed 743-TMt, wttkdoyt of- Raised Ranch of mas- 646-2787 and handicapped.
    [Show full text]
  • Rank Downloads Q3-2017 Active Platforms Q3-2017 1 HP
    Rank Brand Downloads Q3-2017 Active platforms q3-2017 Downloads y-o-y 1 HP 303,669,763 2,219 99% 2 Lenovo 177,100,074 1,734 68% 3 Philips 148,066,292 1,507 -24% 4 Apple 103,652,437 829 224% 5 Acer 100,460,511 1,578 58% 6 Samsung 82,907,164 1,997 72% 7 ASUS 82,186,318 1,690 86% 8 DELL 80,294,620 1,473 77% 9 Fujitsu 57,577,946 1,099 94% 10 Hewlett Packard Enterprise 57,079,300 787 -10% 11 Toshiba 49,415,280 1,375 41% 12 Sony 42,057,231 1,354 37% 13 Canon 27,068,023 1,553 17% 14 Panasonic 25,311,684 601 34% 15 Hama 24,236,374 394 213% 15 BTI 23,297,816 178 338% 16 3M 20,262,236 712 722% 17 Microsoft 20,018,316 639 -11% 18 Bosch 20,015,141 516 170% 19 Lexmark 19,125,788 1,067 104% 20 MSI 18,004,192 545 74% 21 IBM 17,845,288 886 39% 22 LG 16,643,142 734 89% 23 Cisco 16,487,896 520 23% 24 Intel 16,425,029 1,289 73% 25 Epson 15,675,105 629 23% 26 Xerox 15,181,934 1,030 86% 27 C2G 14,827,411 568 167% 28 Belkin 14,129,899 440 43% 29 Empire 13,633,971 128 603% 30 AGI 13,208,149 189 345% 31 QNAP 12,507,977 823 207% 32 Siemens 10,992,227 390 183% 33 Adobe 10,947,315 285 -7% 34 APC 10,816,375 1,066 54% 35 StarTech.com 10,333,843 819 102% 36 TomTom 10,253,360 759 47% 37 Brother 10,246,577 1,344 39% 38 MusicSkins 10,246,462 76 231% 39 Wentronic 9,605,067 305 254% 40 Add-On Computer Peripherals (ACP) 9,360,340 140 334% 41 Logitech 8,822,469 1,318 115% 42 AEG 8,805,496 683 -16% 43 Crocfol 8,570,601 162 268% 44 Panduit 8,567,835 163 452% 45 Zebra 8,198,502 433 72% 46 Memory Solution 8,108,528 128 290% 47 Nokia 7,927,162 402 70% 48 Kingston Technology 7,924,495
    [Show full text]
  • Case 19-11740 Doc 1 Filed 08/05/19 Page 1 of 22
    Case 19-11740 Doc 1 Filed 08/05/19 Page 1 of 22 Fill in this information to identify your case: United States Bankruptcy Court for the: DISTRICT OF DELAWARE Case number (if known) Chapter 11 Check if this an amended filing Official Form 201 Voluntary Petition for Non-Individuals Filing for Bankruptcy 4/19 If more space is needed, attach a separate sheet to this form. On the top of any additional pages, write the debtor's name and case number (if known). For more information, a separate document, Instructions for Bankruptcy Forms for Non-Individuals, is available. 1. Debtor's name iPic Media LLC 2. All other names debtor used in the last 8 years Include any assumed DBA See Rider 1 names, trade names and doing business as names 3. Debtor's federal Employer Identification 61-1740150 Number (EIN) 4. Debtor's address Principal place of business Mailing address, if different from principal place of business 433 Plaza Real, Suite 335 Boca Raton, FL 33432 Number, Street, City, State & ZIP Code P.O. Box, Number, Street, City, State & ZIP Code Palm Beach Location of principal assets, if different from principal County place of business Number, Street, City, State & ZIP Code 5. Debtor's website (URL) www.ipic.com 6. Type of debtor Corporation (including Limited Liability Company (LLC) and Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)) Partnership (excluding LLP) Other. Specify: Official Form 201 Voluntary Petition for Non-Individuals Filing for Bankruptcy page 1 Case 19-11740 Doc 1 Filed 08/05/19 Page 2 of 22 Debtor iPic Media LLC Case number (if known) Name 7.
    [Show full text]
  • No Growth to Go for Local Schools
    Zip Code Your Want Ad Is Easy To Place- Just Phone 686^7700 An Official Newspaper For The Borough Of Mountainside MOUNTAINSIDE, N.J., THURSDAY, DECEMBER 12, 1968 PuUiilhtd rjgch Thursday L,"T,um r Pul Inhiny I mh Lic-ripfisn Rgfi 2 N«w Frsyjdines Read, Mnuniaimidi, N J 07052 15 Cent! Per Copy USING TWO SENSES—Patricia Harmlgan combines book and record for a perfect example PATHWAY TO KNOWLEDGE—Allan Zelteliach digs for a card with a study problem for MATTER OF DEGREES-—Blair Smith looks well on the way to a PhJ3, as he works on an of audio-visual learning techniques in Mrs, Aletta Bark's fifth grade classroom at him to solve In Mrs, Aletta Bark's Mountainside classroom, as part of her project for Independent research project at Mountalnside's Echobrook School, financed by a state Mountainside's Eehobrook School, which she was awarded a state grant. grant to his teacher, Mrs, Aletta Bork. Jersey ^mini-grant' aids An anti-Santa letter teacher's maxi-'mgenuity No growth to go A request by Mrs, Aletta Bork for a state arohaelogy to set off an area in her class- Girl doesn't want to believe "minigrant" W do something original with room "with unbleached muslin' curtains, just 'the youngsters in her Mountainside classroom like those used to protect ttie site of a regular Serious doubt was cast on the integrity lucky enough to live in a community where sn-uek the right note with educational of- archaelogical dig. Besides stimulating of Santa Glaus in a litter directed to the children don't really need Santa Claus, for local schools ficials in
    [Show full text]
  • STAR V33,23 April-24-1941.Pdf (6.093Mb)
    HOUGH TON*S-TAR Volume XXXIII Houghton, New York, Thursday, April 24. 1941 Number 23 Model Legislature Calendar Rudolph Ganz to Present Piano Concert Here Is Success Thursday, April 14 Rulolph Ganz visit Assembly Passes Frida·y, April 25 In College Chapel Tomorrow Evening Four Maior Bills 8: 15 - Artist Series - Rudolph G anz Pianist-Conductor to Give Last Number Saturday, April 26 Continuing on the keynote sounded 10:00 - Youth Confer- |n 1940-41 Schedule of Artist Series by Prof. Stanley Wright, "Democracy ence convenes in Action", the Houghton College r It is doubtful if any of the great musical arrists in this Sunday, April 27 Model Legislature electioneered, de- country has a wider circle of personal friends, drawn from the 3: 30 - Vesper Service ar bated, and vociferated in a manner the church general public as well as from fellow artists, as has Rudolph similar to a regular legislature, Satur- Ganz, renowned pianist-conductor who is coming here for a 8:00 - Chapel Choir day, April 19. Temporary Chairman, recital on Friday, April 25, at 8 o'clock in the chapel. Concert a[ Angelica Mr. Stanley Wright, opened the Mr. Ganz has none of the idosyncrasies popularly sup- Monday, April 18 morning assembly and invocation was posed to be associated with great artists. His personality is 7:00 - Expression Club winning, and he has a delightful sense of humor. olfered by the body's chaplain, Mr. Art Club Russel Clark. It took two roll calls The American-Swiss pianist<onductor musr have been Mission Study Club before Clifford Robertson received a a remarkable comedian in a previous incarnation.
    [Show full text]
  • Speaker Biographies
    Speaker Biographies Ope Adebanjo ’20, Student, Harvard Law School Ope Adebanjo is a second year JD Candidate at Harvard Law School. She graduated from Harvard College in 2015 and majored in Comparative Literature and African Studies, with a minor in Sociology and a citation in Yoruba. Ope worked as an operations supervisor at McMaster-Carr Supply Company in Atlanta GA, managing teams of e-commerce and sales representatives and managing warehouse projects and operations during her time before law school. She also has her Masters in International Business from J. Mack Robinson College of Business at Georgia State University. As a HLS student, Ope is interested in intellectual property law and international business law with a focus on the intersection of policy and technology. Kendra Albert ’16, Clinical Instructional Fellow, Cyberlaw Clinic, Harvard Law School Kendra is a clinical instructional fellow at the Cyberlaw Clinic at Harvard Law School, where they teach students how to practice law by working with pro bono clients. Previously, they were an associate at Zeitgeist Law PC, a boutique technology law firm in San Francisco, and a research associate at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society. Kendra’s scholarship and academic work touches on diverse issues, from online harassment to linkrot to video game preservation. They hold a JD cum laude from Harvard Law School and a bachelor’s degree in lighting design and history from Carnegie Mellon University. Julie Anna Alvarez ’88, Director of Alumni and International Career Services, Columbia Law School Julie Anna Alvarez is the Director of Alumni and International Career Services at Columbia Law School’s Office of Career Services and Professional Development.
    [Show full text]
  • EU Competition Law and the Rule of Law: Justification and Realisation
    The London School of Economics and Political Science EU Competition Law and the Rule of Law: Justification and Realisation Ryan R Stones A thesis submitted to the Department of Law of the London School of Economics and Political Science for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy London, September 2018 1 Declaration I certify that the thesis I have presented for examination for the PhD degree of the London School of Economics and Political Science is solely my own work other than where I have clearly indicated that it is the work of others (in which case the extent of any work carried out jointly by me and any other person is clearly identified in it). The copyright of this thesis rests with the author. Quotation from it is permitted, provided that full acknowledgement is made. This thesis may not be reproduced without my prior written consent. I warrant that this authorisation does not, to the best of my belief, infringe the rights of any third party. I declare that my thesis consists of 99,998 words. 2 Abstract This thesis explores the justification for and realisation of the formal rule of law ideal in EU competition law. It argues that the form of market intervention for determining the legality of business conduct matters, although European enforcement has not always appreciated its significance. It defends aspirations towards the formal rule of law in the fundamentally economic endeavour of competition policy: determining lawfulness through the application of generalised, equally-applicable, and comprehensible norms, subject to robust judicial review. While this less-discriminating form of market intervention is necessarily imperfect when compared with conduct-specific evaluations of competitive consequences, thus inaccurately prohibiting the efficient and permitting the inefficient, more restrained and structured determinations of legality facilitate the realisation of other important values.
    [Show full text]