Prevalence of Linear Configuration Among Chain Trivalents at Metaphase I in Pollen Mother Cells of Petunia Axillaris (LAM.) B
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
_??_1991 by Cytologia, Tokyo Cytologia 56: 367 -371 , 1991 Prevalence of Linear Configuration among Chain Trivalents at Metaphase I in Pollen Mother Cells of Petunia axillaris (LAM.) B. S. P. P. China Pullaiah, P. S. R. L. Narasinga Rao and V. Padmaja Department of Botany, Andhra University, Waltair, India Accepted February 28, 1991 At somatic metaphase the kinetochore of each sister chromatid interacts with the spindle in such a way that the two subsequently disjoin one to each pole. At metaphase I of meiosis in disomics, a pair of chromatids is one half of a bivalent. Here, in their involvement with the spindle, the two kinetochores of a chromatid pair are not poised disjunctionally, and the centromere is thus said to be syntelic. For a 'double kinetochore' of each member of a meiotic bivalent, 'syntelic' aspect is thus a derived state. Failure of the 'double kinetochore' to attain to 'syntelic' state is rare for the members of a bivalent. On the other hand, the 'kinetochore pair' of a univalent at meiosis I may assume an amphitelic state at metaphase I even if the initial development was towards a syntelic state (Bauer et al. 1961, Sybenga 1975). When we consider chain trivalents, which indeed are the simplest of multivalents, syntelic state for all three kinetochore pairs is quite prevalent and is often seen in the alternate configuration where the mid-member is poised disjunctionally from both its neighbours. Much rarer is the variant, where the three syntelic centromeres disjoin in a 2-1 manner as in the case of ad jacent orientation. In several species, the frequency of non-linear forms is so overwhelmingly great that the 'linear configuration' is not thoroughly described. A serious consideration of the linear forms is the main theoretical difference between two recent reviews (Rickards 1983, Sybenga and Rickards 1987). The descriptive data are of greater interest when they come from species where a large proportion of chain trivalents assume a 'linear form'. It is possible that a 'kinetochore pair' which fails to attain syntelic status reverts to an amphitelic behaviour pattern. But it is more rigorous to describe it as 'non-syntelic', when it is as yet part of an association. Petunia pollen mother cells at metaphase I are not ideal for light microscopic studies of acetocarmine squash preparations. However, in view of the prevalence of linear forms, their description is of some interest. Material and methods Triploid plants were raised from reciprocal crosses between diploids and colchicine induced tetraploids of Petunia axillaris (Lam.) B. S. P. For meiotic study, young flower buds of 0.2 to 0.4mm size were fixed in 1:4 acetic alcohol between 9:00 and 11:00 a.m. Smear preparations of PMC's were made in 1% acetocarmine and in alcoholic hydrochloric acid carmine (Snow 1963). Paucity of interstitial chiasmata and disjunction of at least one con figuration per PMC were taken as criteria to discriminate late metaphase I cells from mid metaphase. Quantitative data on chain trivalents at metaphase I were collected from intact cells when the entire chromosome complement could be made out. In addition, trivalent data in cells with clumped chromosomes were separately recorded. 368 P. China Pullaiah, P. S. R. L. Narasinga Rao and V. Padmaja Cytologia 56 Results In pollen mother cells of Petunia axillaris, the commonest form of a chain of three has both end members in a syntelic state. These are poised clearly disjunctionally with reference Figs. 1-3. Pollen mother cells of triploid Petunia axillaris (Lam.) B. S. P. showing orientation pattern of chain trivalents at late metaphase I. 1, PMC showing 2 linear III (T ), 1 alternate (+), 4 II, and 4 I. 2, PMC showing 3 linear III (•ª), 4 II, and 4 I. 3, PMC showing 3 III, 5 II, and 2 I; amphitelic activity (•ª) of the centromere of the middle chromosome can be in ferred from the spindle connection. Table 1. Orientation pattern of chain trivalents at late metaphase I in four triploid plants of Petunia to each other. The mid member is rarely seen to be associated with the spindle components. It is regarded as ineffective (Narasinga Rao, unpublished: Cf. Sybenga and Rickards 1987) whether or not it is "denied effective activity" by being late (Narasinga Rao and Sybenga 1984) and whether or not it is assumed to be "inactivated" (Sybenga 1975) and whether or not it is believed to be "amphitelic" (Rickards 1983). 1991 Chain Trivalents at Metaphase I in Pollen Mother Cells of Petunia axillaris 369 Apart from the adjacent and virtually vertical linears (Figs . 1, 2) two flexed forms of the linear chain trivalent are also occasionally seen. One was the hook type configuration, which was earlier described as 'L' type trivalent (Reddy and Padmaja 1984). The other flexed form is the linear configuration with an amphitelic middle centromere (Fig. 3). However, such apparently amphitelic centromeres were very rarely seen; 5 out of 1754 chain trivalents. Furthermore, amphitelic state for other than the mid-centromere was not seen at all (Table 1). In each of the four triploid plants the frequency of linears exceeded that of alternates (Table 1). This is a clear deviation from the (upper) limit of 33.3 percent set for linears on the basis of a theoretical model (Narasinga Rao and Sybenga 1984, Arundhati et al. 1986). The four triploid plants showed a similar frequency distribution pattern of the orientation types. Discussion The simplest multivalent is an unbranched (symmetrical), trivalent with two fully ter minalised chiasmata. If the cell, the spindle and the chromosomes are all fairly large, studies on orientation and the subsequent consequences of the same are further facilitated. These conditions do not obtain in Petunia. The data drastically deviate from the 33.3 percent limit for "non-neighbour co-orientation", suggested by Narasinga Rao and Sybenga (1984). Although the suggested model shifts the emphasis of orientation studies from quadri to tri-valents, it bypasses the question concerning the interaction between the midcentromere which is trapped and the spindle, if any. This theoretical quandary (Sybenga and Rickards 1987)points to the need for a larger body of data and the round table did not underestimate the relevance of light microscopic studies. In the present studies, the observations were from late metaphase I stage, as the PMC's screened for analysis were those showing complete terminalisation of at least one chiasma. In the linear forms, the centromere of the middle chromosome fails to attain 'syntelic condi tion' more often than either end member (Fig. 2). This could in part be because the centro mere of the mid-chromosome is more subject to the 'shielding effect' of chromatin mass, com pared to the other two. The unequal shielding effect between the three chromosomes, would not be due to unequal 'chromatin mass' proximal to the centromeres because the three chro mosomes are homologous. Opposed to this paucity of mid member interaction with the spindle in Petunia is the picture in rye (Sybenga and Rickards 1987, Arundhati et al. 1986). In rye, it is a case of unfailing interaction between mid centromere and the spindle. This is said to arise from a form of rigidity. The chain trivalents are seen bent at the mid-centromere. The bend would nullify any 'shielding effect' i.e., the mid member is markedly less shielded from the spindle than it would be if the chromosome were straight. It is not known whether any physical constraints exist at diakinesis in Petunia PMC's as would create a difference between 'end' vs. 'mid' centromeres with respect to readiness of their interaction with the spindle. For the present, seeking-out such a feature that would speed up end members, but restrain the mid member from spindle interaction would seem reasonable. Another relevant aspect which could contribute to the less than optimum performance of the mid-centromere of a chain trivalent is the asymmetric karyotype of Petunia axillaris. The second and third longest members of the karyotype have subterminal centromeres (Smith et al. 1973, Padmaja and Reddy 1981). Furthermore, these sets quite often form multivalents (45% and 34% of PMC's have second and third chromosome trivalents respectively; Reddy and Padmaja 1982). A chain trivalent of such chromosomes thus has two chiasmata, one 370 P. China Pullaiah, P. S. R. L. Narasinga Rao and V. Padmaja Cytologia 56 connection between long arms and another between short arms. Let X, Y, Z be the centromeres and p and q their short and long arms. Then the six possible patterns of the three homologous chromosomes in the chain trivalent are: p X qq Y pp Z q; p X qq Z pp Y q; p Y qq Z pp X q p Y qq X pp Z q; p Z qq X pp Y q; p Z qq Y pp X q ' pp' is the shortest inter centromere segment within the chain trivalent and 'qq' the longer stretch. Hence, the manoeuvrability (of the centromeres) at the limits of 'pp' is lesser com pared to that at the limits of 'qq'. Therefore, the segment between short arms is comparative ly less supple and it behaves as if it were a single unit in its relation to the less rigid region, qq. Whenever 'end members' of a trivalent have more than optimum chance to interact with the spindle components, the probability is enhanced that the middle centromere fails to take its place on the spindle (Arundhati et al. 1986). This would contribute to the higher propor tion of linears among chian trivalents. In the more symmetric sets of the chromosome complement, the intercentric segments may not differ in their manoeuvrability and chance processes continue to operate in a random manner.