A Thesis Entitled SEDIMENTOLOGY and ICHNOLOGY of LATE
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Thesis entitled SEDIMENTOLOGY AND ICHNOLOGY OF LATE CAMBRIAN TO EARLY ORDOVICIAN SKOLITHOS SANDSTONE IN THE DEADWOOD FORMATION, NORTHERN BLACK HILLS, SOUTH DAKOTA, AND SOUTHEASTERN BEAR LODGE MOUNTAINS, WYOMING by William P. Sokoloski Submitted as partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Master of Science Degree in Geology Thesis Committee: Dr. James A. Harrell, Professor ________________________ Coadvisor: James A. Harrell Dr. Vernon M. Brown, Associate Professor ________________________ Coadvisor: Vernon M. Brown Dr. Mark J. Camp, Associate Professor ________________________ Graduate School The University of Toledo May 2005 An Abstract of SEDIMENTOLOGY AND ICHNOLOGY OF LATE CAMBRIAN TO EARLY ORDOVICIAN SKOLITHOS SANDSTONE IN THE DEADWOOD FORMATION, NORTHERN BLACK HILLS, SOUTH DAKOTA, AND SOUTHEASTERN BEAR LODGE MOUNTAINS, WYOMING William P. Sokoloski Submitted in partial fulfillment of The requirements for the Master of Science Degree in Geology The University of Toledo May 2005 The upper part of the Cambrian-Ordovician Deadwood Formation contains a Late Cambrian Skolithos-bearing sandstone unit (LCSS) and an Early Ordovician Skolithos- bearing sandstone unit (EOSS). These rock units were originally referred to as the Aladdin sandstone. Sections of these rock units (5 in the LCSS and 8 in the EOSS) in the northern Black Hills of South Dakota and southeastern Bear Lodge Mountains of Wyoming were measured, described and sampled. A literature search was conducted for other Skolithos sandstone units to determine the stratigraphic range and physical characteristics of the Skolithos ichnospecies. In addition, 13 petrographic thin sections of samples were examined to obtain detailed information on the sandstones and Skolithos trace fossils. Overall, environmental interpretations based on outcrop and petrographic thin section descriptions agree well with the findings of previous investigators. Rock intervals containing abundant Skolithos tubes are formed by succeeding periods of burrowing, erosion and deposition as the suspension-feeding polychaetes and/or phoronids burrowed vertically into the substrate to form Skolithos tubes in order to feed ii at the sediment surface. Cross-bedding features and Skolithos tubes that terminate at bedding planes indicate the susceptibility of these substrates to wave-generated bottom currents. This condition is characteristic of the Skolithos ichnofacies. Beds containing only Skolithos trace fossils in the EOSS were deposited during storm events with finer- grained, lower energy deposits, bioturbated by deposit-feeding animals, following these beds. The presence of variously shaped fodinichnia (feeding) or pascichnia (grazing) trace fossils mark an environmental change at the end of EOSS time, which correlates with the timing of other events that apparently reduced the abundance and diversity of the Skolithos-making animals into two long ranging (Precambrian to Recent) representative ichnospecies, S. linearis and S. verticalis. The modal Skolithos density is 0.4 Skolithos tubes per cm in the LCSS and 0.5 Skolithos tubes per cm in the EOSS, although the LCSS contains thicker portions that do not contain any Skolithos tubes. S. linearis (tubes larger than 4 mm in diameter) and S. verticalis (tubes 1 to 2.5 mm in diameter) occur in both rock units, but S. verticalis is predominant in both sandstones. These trace fossils do not necessarily represent different organisms as both ichnospecies can be the same size (3 to 4 mm in diameter). Petrographic thin section analysis reveals these sediments must have been rapidly eroded and quickly buried in order for low-survivability grains like feldspar to be preserved rather than weathered away in the humid climate as this part of the North American craton was located near the equator. Quartz-mica schist fragments also indicate Precambrian basement rocks were exposed in the Black Hills during EOSS time. Thin section analysis of 183 Skolithos tubes did not provide any definitive results regarding how the Skolithos-making animal constructed its burrow. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I sincerely thank my thesis committee members Dr. James A. Harrell, Dr. Vernon M. Brown and Dr. Mark J. Camp of the University of Toledo, Department of Earth, Ecology and Environmental Science. Dr. Harrell deserves credit for the thesis topic, objectives, methodology and main overview. Dr. Brown supervised the fieldwork and was particularly helpful at the initial site in Spearfish Canyon, which the knowledge he shared with me carried over to the other sites. Dr. Camp provided helpful comments as well, which I greatly appreciate. Thank you all for your commitment, expertise and guidance. I thank the University of Toledo for the financial support I received as a graduate teaching assistant. And, most of all, I thank my parents William S. and Janet L. Sokoloski, grandmother Evelyn R. (Greiger) Finke, and sister Jennifer J. Sokoloski for their love, support and inspiration. iv DEDICATION This work is dedicated in loving memory of my grandparents William Rinehart Finke, Stephen Paul and Verdine (Hug) Sokoloski. v TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT........................................................................................................................ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS............................................................................................... iv DEDICATION.................................................................................................................... v LIST OF FIGURES .........................................................................................................viii LIST OF TABLES............................................................................................................. xi CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION.................................................................................. 1 Statement of the Problem................................................................................................ 1 Objectives of the Study................................................................................................... 2 CHAPTER TWO LITERATURE REVIEW...................................................................... 3 Geology of the Black Hills ............................................................................................. 3 Introduction................................................................................................................. 3 Precambrian Rocks ..................................................................................................... 3 Early Paleozoic Rocks ................................................................................................ 6 Structure and Physiography ........................................................................................ 7 Aladdin Sandstone ........................................................................................................ 11 Skolithos Trace Fossil ................................................................................................... 23 Introduction............................................................................................................... 23 Previous Work on the Skolithos Ichnofacies ............................................................ 24 Depositional Environment .................................................................................... 24 Type of Animal..................................................................................................... 34 Stratigraphic Range............................................................................................... 42 CHAPTER THREE METHODOLOGY .......................................................................... 60 Fieldwork ...................................................................................................................... 60 Laboratory Work........................................................................................................... 63 CHAPTER FOUR RESULTS .......................................................................................... 67 Fieldwork ...................................................................................................................... 67 Introduction............................................................................................................... 67 Composition and Color............................................................................................. 68 Grain Size.................................................................................................................. 68 Bedding Characteristics ............................................................................................ 71 Bedding Contacts...................................................................................................... 72 Skolithos Characteristics ........................................................................................... 75 Orientation and Shape........................................................................................... 75 Length and Diameter............................................................................................. 76 vi Spacing.................................................................................................................. 86 Filling.................................................................................................................... 89 Other Trace Fossils ..................................................................................................