Women, Slavery, and British Imperial Interventions in Mauritius, 1810–1845
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Women, Slavery, and British Imperial Interventions in Mauritius, 1810–1845 Tyler Yank Department of History and Classical Studies Faculty of Arts McGill University, Montréal October 2019 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy © Tyler Yank 2019 ` Table of Contents ! Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... 2 Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... 4 Résumé ........................................................................................................................................... 5 Figures ............................................................................................................................................ 6 Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 7 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 10 History & Historiography ............................................................................................................. 15 Definitions ..................................................................................................................................... 21 Scope of Study .............................................................................................................................. 24 Chapter One: Quiet Strength, Loud Defiance: Assessing Bondwomen’s Labour, Maternity, and Resistance in early British Mauritius ................................................................................ 30 Defining Enslaved Women’s Labour ............................................................................................ 33 Pregnancy and Childbirth across Colonies ................................................................................... 36 Considering Resistance and Maternity ......................................................................................... 46 The Arrest, Interrogation, and Sentencing of Sophie ................................................................... 50 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 66 Chapter 2: “I have never belonged to anyone!”: The Commission of Eastern Enquiry and Contested Freedom, 1820–1828 ................................................................................................. 67 Part One: Conditions of Freedom and Law ................................................................................. 69 Anti-Slavery Activism and Imperial Investigation ....................................................................... 73 The Commission of Eastern Enquiry in Mauritius ....................................................................... 75 Case Studies of Contested Freedom ............................................................................................. 82 Case of Nina ........................................................................................................................... 83 Case of Estelle ........................................................................................................................ 84 Case of Elizabeth .................................................................................................................... 85 Case of Victorine .................................................................................................................... 86 Case of Catherine ................................................................................................................... 86 Case of Marie Saladin & Family ............................................................................................ 88 Perceptions of (Un)freedom .......................................................................................................... 94 Part Two: The Contested Freedom of Recaptive Africans .......................................................... 96 Recaptive Africans and the British Royal Navy ........................................................................... 97 Occupations and Indenture ......................................................................................................... 100 Recaptive Women and Children ................................................................................................. 106 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 113 2 Chapter 3: Dubious Protection: Mauritian Slavery Amelioration Measures and Resistance ..................................................................................................................................................... 114 Amelioration, Empire, & Legal Pluralism .................................................................................. 118 Punishment and Protection ......................................................................................................... 122 Women, Motherhood, and Violence ........................................................................................... 127 Resistance and Protection ........................................................................................................... 135 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 144 Chapter Four: British Missionary and Imperial Slave Education in Mauritius ................ 147 Part One: LMS Rev. Jean Le Brun and Early Mission Schools ................................................ 152 British Colonialism and Anti-Slavery in the Indian Ocean World ............................................. 158 French Colonialism and British Protestantism ........................................................................... 163 Charles Telfair & the Anti-Slavery Movement .......................................................................... 167 Considering Violence and Slave Instruction ............................................................................... 175 Part Two: Imperial Education Schemes for Apprentices and Ex-Slaves .................................. 178 Imperial Education Grants & Lady Mico’s Charity ................................................................... 181 Instruction for Women and Girls ................................................................................................ 188 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 193 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 196 Bibliography .............................................................................................................................. 204 3 Abstract This dissertation examines the history of enslaved women and girls in British Mauritius from 1810 to 1845. Through an exploration of British colonial interventions in slaveholding, this study focuses on the narratives of enslaved women and girls to reveal intersections between colonialism, motherhood, violence, and resistance to bondage. The British colonial government introduced a series of measures to reform slavery conditions in Mauritius prior to the Emancipation Act (1833), as they did in several Atlantic colonies. This included the establishment of a Commission of Eastern Enquiry to investigate slaveholding and manumission practices, and make recommendations related to the amelioration of slavery in Mauritius. The Commission found that freedom was markedly difficult to achieve for bonded women in the island. Slave complaints registered with the Protector of Slaves office in 1829–30 indicate that unfree women and girls in Mauritius experienced unique forms of violence, and that they sometimes used the Protector of Slave’s services for different ends than their male counterparts. In comparison with men and boys, enslaved and newly emancipated women and girls also took part in disparate forms of religious and elementary instruction with the London Missionary Society and Lady Mico’s Charity. In sum, this dissertation significantly enriches the current scholarship about slavery in the Indian Ocean world through exploring, for the first time, the distinct experiences of bonded women in Mauritius. 4 Résumé Cette thèse vise à examiner l’histoire des femmes et filles esclaves à Maurice sous l’empire britannique entre 1810 et 1845. Au moyen d’une considération détaillée des diverses interventions dans le système d’esclavage par le gouvernement colonial britannique à cette époque, cette étude se penche sur les récits des femmes et jeunes filles esclaves afin d’exposer l’interrelation entre le colonialisme, la maternité, la violence, et la résistance à la servitude. Le gouvernement colonial britannique introduisit une série de mesures visant à reformer les conditions de vie des esclaves à Maurice avant de promulguer l’acte d’émancipation en 1833, tout comme les gouvernements britanniques faisaient dans d’autres colonies atlantiques. Ce programme de réforme comprenait l’établissement d’une Commission