TE19.11.101
78-90 Queen’s Park UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO Centre for Civilization, Cultures and Cities
Toronto and East York Community Council Meeting (TEYCC) - Agenda Item TE 19.2 | October 15th, 2020
Diller Scofidio + Renfro | architectsAlliance | ERA | Bousfields | NAK Design Strategies TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1. 16 total community consultation meetings held on this subject site by the University of Toronto over a 9 year period from 2011-2020. 2. Positive City Staff recommendation from Community Planning, Urban Design, Heritage Preservation Services. 3. Considerable height reduction from 81m in 2011 down to 42.25m now proposed. 4. Considerable Building Setback 36m from property line at Queen’s Park. 5. All applicable planning policy met, including view protection of Ontario Legislature. 6. Retention of heritage buildings on site with all major views to historic house (Falconer Hall) ensured. 7. Cultural Landscape of Queen’s Park and Philosopher’s Walk strongly considered, respected, and incorporated in the design by architects, landscape architect and heritage consultant. 8. All prominent old-growth trees retained. Some necessary tree removal to facilitate construction, but 31 new trees to be planted, ` well above tree replacement requirements. 9. Tree removal already reviewed closely and approved by City of Toronto Urban Forestry staff. 10. Approximately 3,380 sm of landscaped open space is proposed across the site (50% of the total site area). 11. No shadow impact to Philosopher’s Walk. Final version: Master Plan, 2011 Height: 81m
TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 3
EVOLUTION OF CCC SITE MASSING 2011 BUILDING HEIGHT = 81m MASTERPLAN + small forecourt
Secondary Plan Masterplan CONSULTATION Workshops 1. March 16, 2010 2. April 26, 2010
2016 BUILDING HEIGHT= 66m Secondary Plan Community SECONDARY PLAN + MPH Consultation Meetings 1. March 1, 2017 2. May 8, 2018 3. June 22, 2017 CONSULTATION 4. February 6, 2018 CITY COMMENTS 5. April 5, 2018
• Heritage • Public realm • Movement policies SECONDARY PLAN BUILDING HEIGHT • Growth and new buildings (REVISED) = 43.5m + MPH = 49.5m Total • Student input and • Overall revisions were discussed 2011 MASTERPLAN, 81m CONSULTATION
CURRENT PROPOSAL BUILDING HEIGHT = 38.7m + MPH = 42.25m Total TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 4
CONTINUED COMMUNITY CONSULTATION PROCESS
Community Liaison Consultation Meetings 2018 Public Meeting & Working Group Meetings 2019-2020 Building Height = 49.5m Building Height = 42.25m (Chaired by Councillor Joe Cressy) (Chaired by Councillor Mike Layton)
PARTICIPANTS: PARTICIPANTS: Huron-Sussex Residents Association (HSRO) Huron-Sussex Residents Association (HSRO) Harbord Village Residents Association (HVRA) Harbord Village Residents Association (HVRA) Annex Residents Association (ARA) Annex Residents Association (ARA) Grange Community Association (GCA) Grange Community Association (GCA) Bay Cloverhill Community Association (BCCA) East Annex Condominium Association (EACA) Royal Ontario Museum (ROM) Greater Yorkville RA (GYRA) UofT Students’ Union (UTSU) Royal Ontario Museum (ROM) UofT Students’ Union (UTSU) Architectural Conservancy Ontario (ACO) Trinity College (TC) ABC RA (Public meeting only)
1. June 11, 2018 1. Public Meeting - June 12, 2019
2. July 5, 2018 2. City Design Review Panel - July 18, 2019
3. Working Group #1 - October 15, 2019 • Concerns raised primarily related to interface of new building with Falconer Hall. 4. Working Group #2 - November 20, 2020
5. Working Group #3 - January 27, 2020
6. Working Group #4 - March 11, 2020
7. Public Meeting - July 14, 2020 TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 5
1. MASSING DEVELOPMENT & PARAMETERS TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 6 SITE MASSING PARAMETERS
1.
SET BACK BUILDING MASSING FROM STREET TO:
• MAINTAIN CLEAR VIEW OF ROM SOUTH FACADE
• MAINTAIN HISTORIC LANDSCAPE ALLEE ALONG QUEEN’S PARK
• MAINTAIN CLEARANCE FROM EXISTING STRUCTURE OF EJB
36 M TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 7 SITE MASSING PARAMETERS
1.
SET BACK BUILDiNG MASSING FROM STREET TO:
• MAINTAIN CLEAR VIEW OF ROM SOUTH FACADE
• MAINTAIN HISTORIC LANDSCAPE ALLEE ALONG QUEEN’S PARK
• MAINTAIN CLEARANCE FROM EXISTING STRUCTURE OF EJB TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 8 SITE MASSING PARAMETERS
2.
ALIGN SOUTH FACADE OF CCC TO SOUTH FACADE OF EJB, MAINTAINING AND ENHANCING CONNECTION TO PHILOSOPHER’S WALK. TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 9 SITE MASSING PARAMETERS
3.
SCULPT BUILDING MASS AROUND HERITAGE BUILDING TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 10 ELEVATION LOOKING WEST
+100.45M +100.45M
200 BLOOR200 ST BLOOR ST
+59.25 M +59.25 M
+42.25 M +38.7 M +42.25 M +37.1 M +38.7 M +37.1 M +31 M +29.6 M +28.9 M +31 M +29.6 M +28.9 M +20 M +18 M +16.5 M +20 M +18 M +16.5 M +17.4 M +17.4 M
ROM ROM PARK (UoT) (UoT) (UoT) ROM ROM HYATTPARK JACKMAN(UoT) FLAVELLE(UoT) FALCONER(UoT) HALL HYATT JACKMAN FLAVELLE FALCONER HALL TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 11 OVERALL HEIGHT CONTEXT
206 Bloor 74.22 m
Top of EJB Flytower 27.6m + 200 Bloor Top of Jackman Building Top of EJB Top of Curatorial Wing 100.45 m 16.5m + 12.3m MPH Roof + 31+ m Top of Jackman MPH Top of Crystal 20m Top of Curatorial Wing Top of ROM Top of CCC Original West Wing 37.1 m + Top of CCC MPH Lower Roof 28.9 m 23 m + Top of Flavelle 38.7m 42.25m + 17.4m + + + Park Hyatt + Top of ROM 59.25 m East Wing + 18 m + + Top of ROM East Central Rotunda 29.4 m
Top of 151 Bloor Street West 48.6m + TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 12 ANALYSIS OF SASP 398 REQUIREMENT TO PROTECT SILHOUETTE OF ONTARIO LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
CCC
VIEW LOOKING NORTH FROM QUEEN STREET ON CENTRE MEDIAN
VIEW LOOKING NORTH FROM COLLEGE STREET ON CENTRE MEDIAN
Proposal complies with the SASP 398 TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 13 AERIAL VIEW KEY MAP
View 1 Devonshire Pl & Bloor Street Level View 3 Bloor St. North of ROM 151 Bloor St. W Street Level 48.6m
Top of ROM Crystal View 5 37.1m Street Level Bloor & Avenue NE Corner
View 4 Street Level Bloor & Avenue Centre
Victoria College 47.9m
View 2 Bloor St. North of Phil. Walk Street Level
View 6 Hoskin Ave. & Queen’s Park Street Level TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 14 CONTEXT VIEWS WITH PROPOSED BUILDING
VIEW 1 - DEVONSHIRE PL. & BLOOR_STREET LEVEL VIEW 2 - BLOOR ST. NORTH OF PHIL. WALK_STREET LEVEL
151 Bloor St. W 48.6m
Top of ROM Crystal 22 37.1m 11
Victoria College 47.9m TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 15 CONTEXT VIEWS WITH PROPOSED BUILDING
VIEW 3 - BLOOR ST. NORTH OF ROM_STREET LEVEL VIEW 4 - BLOOR & AVENUE CENTRE_STREET LEVEL
151 Bloor St. W 48.6m
33 Top of ROM Crystal 37.1m 44
Victoria College 47.9m TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 16 CONTEXT VIEWS WITH PROPOSED BUILDING
VIEW 5 - BLOOR & AVENUE NE CORNER_STREET LEVEL VIEW 6 - HOSKIN AVE. & QUEEN’S PARK_STREET LEVEL
151 Bloor St. W 48.6m
Top of ROM Crystal 37.1m 55
Victoria College 47.9m
66 TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 17
2. BUILT FORM TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 18 BUILDING CONCEPT SUMMARY
EVENT
OFFICES RECITAL
URBAN LAB
CAFE TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 19
N-SPROGRAM SECTION DIAGRAM & NORTH-SOUTH SECTION
+42.5M
+38.7M MECHANICAL PENTHOUSE
EVENT SPACE CONFERENCING ARTS & SCIENCE : RESEARCH INSTITUTES 31M FTF 3.65M / ARTS & SCIENCE : HISTORY 12’ (TYPICAL)
RECITAL HALL ARTS & SCIENCE : HISTORY
RECITAL LOBBY NMC LAW
ARTS & SCIENCE: NMC & ARCHAEOLOGY LAB
ROYAL ONTARIO MUSEUM ROYAL ONTARIO MUSEUM CLASSROOMS SCHOOL OF CITIES
URBAN LAB CLASSROOMS 100 PERSON CLASSROOMS
CAFE SOUTH LOBBY NORTH LOBBY
LOADING LOADING DOCK DRIVE TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 20 TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 21 1. Copyright of this drawing is reserved by the Architect. The drawing and all associated documents are an instrument of service by the Architect. The drawing and the information contained therein may not be reproduced in whole or in part without prior written permission of the Architect.
2. These Contract Documents are the property of the Architect. The Architect bears no responsibility for the interpretation of these documents by the Contractor. Upon written application, the Architect will provide written/graphic clarification or supplementary information regarding the intent of the Contract Documents. The Architect will review Shop Drawings submitted by the Contractor for design conformance only.
3. Drawings are not to be scaled for construction. The Contractor is to verify all existing conditions and dimensions required to perform the work and report any discrepancies with the Contract Documents to the Architect before commencing any work.
4. Positions of exposed finished mechanical or electrical devices, fittings, and fixtures are indicated on architectural drawings. The locations shown on the architectural drawings govern over the1 Mechanical p r ht and th Electrical r drawings. re er e Those b the r h te t he r items not clearly located will be located te as directed me t by the Architect. re tr me t er e b the r h te t he r the rm t t e there m t be repr e h e r p rt 5. These drawings are not to be used th t for construction pr r r tte unless perm noted below the as r h te t "Issuance: For Construction" 2 he e tr t me t re the pr pert the r h te t he r h te t be r 6. All work is to be carried out in conformance re p b t with the r Code the and terpret t Bylaws of the the e me t b the tr t r p authorities having jurisdiction. r tte pp t , the r h te t pr e r tte / r ph r t r pp eme t r rm t re r the te t the tr t me t he 7. The Architect of these plans and specifications r h te t re e gives no Sh p warranty r or bm tte b the tr t r r e TORONTO AND EAST YORK COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING (TEYCC) - AGENDA ITEM TE 19.2 - OCTOBER 15TH, 2020 22 representation to any party about the rm e constructability of the building(s) represented by them. All contractors or subcontractors must satisfy themselves when bidding and at all times ensure that they can 3 properly r construct re t the t workbe e represented r tr t by he tr t r t er these plans. e t t me re re t per rm the r rep rt EAST - WEST SECTION rep e th the tr t me t t the r h te t be re mme © architectsAlliance, r
NO. ISSUANCE t e p e he me h DATE r e e tr e e , tt , 1 85% SD Pricing t re re te r h te t r 06/01/2018 r he t h the I H G F-S F-N E D-S D-N C-S C-N B A I H G F-S F-N E D-S D-N C-S C-N B A r h te t r r er er the e h e tr r h e 85% SD Pricing - Addendum tem 1 t e r te be te 06/19/2018 re te b the r h te t 2 100% SD 07/06/2018 he e r re t t be e r tr t e te be 3 85% SD Redux Pricing e r tr t 12/14/2018 40,830 25,130 4 85% SD Redux Pricing - Addendum 1 01/10/2019 r t be rr e t rm e th the e the 5 Rezoning Submission 01/25/2019 2,310 4,435 2,2601,085 4,000 4,050 890 5,760 340 8,000 7,700 2,310 4,435 2,2601,085 4,000 4,050 890 5,760 340 th r t e h r t 6 50% DD Backgrounds 03/29/2019 he r h te t the e p pe t e rr t r UPPER ROOF 7 50% DD Backgrounds - Updaterepre e t t t p rt b t the04/19/2019 tr t b t the b repre e te 1 ,12 156,125 00 1 ,12 00 8 50% DD Backgrounds - Updateb them 2 tr t r r b tr t r 04/26/2019 m t t them e e he b UPPER ROOF t t me e re th t the pr per tr t the r repre e te b 156,125 9 50% DD Backgrounds - Updatethe e p 3 05/03/2019 3, 0 3, 0 3,550 3,550 11 50% DD Backgrounds - Update 4 06/25/2019 r h te t e, LOWER ROOF550 LOWER ROOF 12 DRP Issuance 07/18/2019 1 2, 152,575 152,5751 2, 14 50% DD Pricing Issue SS 07/12/2019 2, 0 2, 0 10 10TH FLOOR 2,450 10TH FLOOR10 2,450 17 50% DD Submission 1 e S bm 08/09/2019 01/2 /2019 1 0,12 150,125 150,1251 0,12 18 Re-Issued for Rezoning and1 2 SPA e e r e 09/30/2019 S 09/30/2019
FURNITURE 3, 0 3, 0 3,650 EVENT HALL 3,650 STORAGES ST-B EVENT HALL 9 9TH FLOOR 9TH FLOOR9 1 , 146,475 146,4751 , 3, 0 3, 0 3,650 GR ACAD. 3,650 8TH FLOOR TECHINCALTECHINCAL ATTIC ATTIC 8TH FLOOR TECHNICAL ATTIC 1 2, 2 142,825 142,8251 2, 2 A&S