From Pupilla Muscorum (Linnaeus, 1758) (Pulmonata: Pupillidae)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MORPHOLOGY, ECOLOGY AND DNA-BARCODING DISTINGUISH PUPILLA PRATENSIS (CLESSIN, 1871) FROM PUPILLA MUSCORUM (LINNAEUS, 1758) (PULMONATA: PUPILLIDAE) TED VON PROSCHWITZ1, CHRISTOFFER SCHANDER2,UWEJUEG3 AND SOLVEIG THORKILDSEN2 1Section of Invertebrate Zoology, Go¨teborg Natural History Museum, PO Box 7283, SE-40235 Go¨teborg, Sweden; 2Department of Biology, University of Bergen, PO Box 7800, 5020 Bergen, Norway; and 3Schweriner Allee 16, D-19288 Ludwigslust, Germany (Received 29 August 2006; accepted 13 February 2009) ABSTRACT The taxonomic identity of Pupilla pratensis (Clessin, 1871), normally considered to be an ecopheno- type of Pupilla muscorum (Linnaeus, 1758), was investigated using morphological, ecological and mol- ecular data (cytochrome c oxidase subunit I and cytochrome b). We conclude that these two forms represent distinct species. This underused combined approach proves to be a powerful tool in dis- tinguishing among closely related species within the genus Pupilla, and we suggest that it should be more widely adopted when sorting out complexes in other groups. INTRODUCTION We have therefore compared populations of pratensis with typical P. muscorum, both morphologically in terms of shell The genus Pupilla s. s. (Fleming, 1828) comprises some 20–30 characters, and genetically using sequences of the mitochon- species and is widely distributed throughout the northern drial genes cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) and cyto- hemisphere – Europe, northernmost Africa, N. Asia and chrome b (CytB). Here we offer a redescription of the shell of North America (Zilch, 1959). The most common and wide- pratensis in comparison with related species of Pupilla, details of spread species is Pupilla muscorum (L., 1758), which inhabits its ecology and distribution, and an account of the molecular nearly the entire range of the genus (Ehrmann, 1933; Pilsbry, basis for the separation of pratensis from muscorum. 1948) and has proved to be important indicator species in eco- logical studies (e.g. Chappell et al., 1971; Jurickova´ & Kucera, 2005), especially in the study of climatic change (e.g. MATERIAL AND METHODS Rousseau, 1985, 1987; Rossignol, Moine & Rousseau, 2004; Specimens of Pupilla were collected from various locations and Moine, Rousseau & Antoine, 2005; Chlachula et al., 2007). transported live to the laboratory where they were measured to Pupilla muscorum is also the type species (Pupa marginata nearest 0.1 mm, determined to taxonomic group on the basis Draparnaud, 1801 ¼ P. muscorum) of the genus Pupilla. of shell morphology, and then fixed in 96% alcohol for DNA Pupilla muscorum is rich in forms and highly variable, as is the analysis. Voucher specimens from each locality and for each genus as a whole. Several authors have pointed out the need taxon were preserved dry in the collection of the Go¨ teborg for the taxonomic revision of Pupilla species and forms (e.g. Natural History Museum (GNM). Lozek, 1964). Pupilla muscorum var. pratensis was first described The material collected for sequencing is listed in Table 1. by Clessin (1871) based on material from Dinkelscherben in Additionally, more than 100 samples of Pupilla from Bavaria (Germany), where it occurred in wet peat meadows. Scandinavia were inspected by eye in order to confirm the Since then, however, the form has attracted little attention and stability of shell characters, and to obtain a broad picture of there are only scattered and brief references to it in the litera- the geographical and ecological distribution of the two forms. ture. Mostly, it has been referred to as an ecophenotype (e.g. A syntype of Pupilla pratensis from Dinkelscherben, Bavaria, Ehrmann, 1933; Lohmander, 1955, 1956; Jaeckel, 1962). Germany (Fig. 1A) and a specimen from Kobyllno, Upper Lohmander (1956) also mentioned specimens which he Silesia, Poland (Fig. 1B) (both coll. Westerlund no. 2306, interpreted as intermediate between pratensis and typical GNM) were also studied. The studied samples of Pupilla alpicola P. muscorum. The rank of pratensis has been variously given as were collected from two localities in the Austrian Alps: ‘variety’, ‘form’ or ‘mutation’. In the latest comprehensive field Franz-Josef Ho¨ he (Carinthia) and Krahberg bei Landeck guide of the terrestrial molluscs from North and Central (Tyrol). Europe (Kerney, Cameron & Jungbluth, 1983) P. pratensis was DNA from specimens to be sequenced was extracted using not mentioned. It was not until the publication of the study by the DNeasy Kit (QIAgen), following the manufacturer’s Jueg (1997) on Pupilla material from the province of protocol for animal tissue, by crushing the entire animal in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern in north-eastern Germany, that an ependorph tube. The best results were obtained when the form attracted serious attention in recent times. As the ethanol in the tissue was allowed to evaporate prior to results of Jueg (1997) coincided with observations on mor- extraction, using RNase, and when the DNA was eluted using phology and ecology of the forms in Scandinavia, we decided the elution buffer provided with the kit. Extracted DNA was to study them more closely, using a combined approach invol- diluted 10Â in ddH O, and stored at 2208C prior to ving morphology, ecology and molecular data. 2 amplification. All PCRs were carried out in a final volume of 50 mlwith4ml of DNA template, 1 ml of each primer, 4 mldNTP,4ml10Â Correspondence: T. von Proschwitz; e-mail: [email protected] PCR buffer, 36.8 mlddH2O and 0.2 ml Taq DNA polymerase Journal of Molluscan Studies (2009) 75: 315–322. Advance Access Publication: 17 August 2009 doi:10.1093/mollus/eyp038 # The Author 2009. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of The Malacological Society of London, all rights reserved T. VON PROSCHWITZ ET AL. Table 1. Material of Pupilla muscorum and Pupilla pratensis used in the molecular genetic studies. Locality Species Haplotypes of COI Haplotypes of CytB Number of specimens Borgunda, Va¨stergo¨tland, Sweden muscorum 1, 2, 3 1, 2, 3 30 Kla¨dner Plage, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany muscorum 4, 5 3 Heiterbachtal, Baden-Wu¨rttemberg, Germany muscorum 64 2 Kla¨dner Plage, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany pratensis 75 13 Lagmansro, O¨ stergo¨tland, Sweden pratensis 7, 8, 9 6, 7 15 Ombergsliden, Omberg, O¨ stergo¨tland, Sweden pratensis 10 8 1 Figure 1. A. Pupa (Pupilla) muscorum v. pratensis Clessin ¼ Pupilla pratensis (Clessin) Dinkelscherben, Bavaria, Germany. Syntype. (coll. Westerlund 2306, GNM). B. Pupilla pratensis, Kobyllno, Upper Silesia, Poland. (coll. Westerlund 2306, GNM). C. Pupilla pratensis, Ombergsliden, O¨ stergo¨ tland, Sweden. D–F. Pupilla pratensis, Kla¨ dner Plage, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany. G. Pupilla muscorum, Borgunda church, Va¨ stergo¨ tland, Sweden. H. Pupilla muscorum, Kla¨ dner Plage, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany. I. Pupilla alpicola, Franz-Josef Ho¨ he, Carinthia, Austria. Scale bar ¼ 1 mm. 316 SEPARATION OF TWO SPECIES OF PUPILLA Table 2. Number of specimens of each haplotype for COI and CytB SYSTEMATIC DESCRIPTION and GenBank accession numbers. Pupilla pratensis (Clessin, 1871) Haplotype no. Number of GenBank no. Pupilla species (Fig. 1A–F) specimens Pupa (Pupilla) muscorum var. pratensis Clessin, 1871: 101 COI 1 6 EF457915 muscorum (Dinkelscherben, Bavaria, Germany). Clessin, 1884: 246. COI 2 23 EF457916 muscorum Clessin, 1887: 256, fig. 155. Westerlund, 1871: 243–244. COI 3 1 EF457917 muscorum Westerlund, 1887: 121. COI 4 2 EF457918 muscorum Pupa muscorum var. pratensis—Goldfuss, 1883: 37. COI 5 1 EF457919 muscorum Pupilla muscorum f. pratensis—Steenberg, 1911: 174. Ehrmann, COI 6 2 EF457920 muscorum 1933: 46. Jaeckel, 1962: 98 [with authority Reinhardt, in error]. Jueg, 1997: 277–285. von Proschwitz, 1998: 40, 52 COI 7 14 EF457921 pratensis [as pratense]. von Proschwitz, 2001: 56. von Proschwitz, 2002: COI 8 7 EF457922 pratensis 16. Zettler et al., 2006: 133. COI 9 7 EF457923 pratensis Pupilla muscorum mut. pratensis—Pilsbry, 1921: 178, pl. 20: fig. 9. COI 10 1 EF457924 pratensis Pupilla muscorum pratensis—Lohmander, 1955: 53–54. CytB 1 16 EF457907 muscorum Lohmander, 1956: 47. CytB 2 4 EF457908 muscorum Pupa (Pupilla) muscorum var. madida Gredler [in part] Clessin, CytB 3 1 EF457909 muscorum 1876: 201–202. CytB 4 2 EF457910 muscorum Types examined: One syntype, Dinkelscherben, Bavaria, CytB 5 12 EF457911 pratensis Germany (leg. S. Clessin) (Fig. 1A) (coll. Westerlund no. CytB 6 6 EF457912 pratensis 2306, GNM) CytB 7 5 EF457913 pratensis CytB 8 1 EF457914 pratensis Material examined: Kobyllno, Upper Silesia, Poland (leg. O. Goldfuss) (Fig. 1B) (coll. Westerlund no. 2306, GNM); Kla¨ dner Plage, Meckenburg-Vorpommern, Germany (leg. U. Jueg); Ombergsliden, O¨ stergo¨ tland Sweden (leg. T. von Proschwitz); Lagmnasro, O¨ stergo¨ tland, Sweden (leg. T. von (Amersham Biosciences). We used the following temperature Proschwitz). profile: 968C 2 min (938C30s,478C 30 s and 728C 1 min) Â 40; In addition, the following material of other species was 728C 7 min; 48C hold. The primers used for COI were LCO examined for comparative purposes: P. muscorum: Kla¨ dner 1490 (GGTCAACAAATCATAAAGATATTGG) and HCO Plage, Meckenburg-Vorpommern, Germany (leg. U. Jueg); 2198 (TAAACTTCAGGGTGACCAAAAAATCA) (Folmer Heiterbachtal, Baden-Wu¨ rttemberg, Germany(leg. H.-J. et al., 1994). For comparison we also sequenced CytB for a Niederho¨ fer); Borgunda, Va¨ stergo¨ tland, Sweden (leg. T. von smaller number of specimens. For the CytB gene, the primers Proschwitz). Pupilla alpicola: Franz Josef-Ho¨ he, Carinthia,