Pharmacological Modulation of Aversive Responsiveness in Honey Bees
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT My admirations and endless thanks … to my foster father during these past 4 years; once … le Pr Giurfa once … el señor Giurfa and once … simply Martin. i Infinite thanks to countless, but mentionable persons I encountered, for which they contributed in different ways to the finalisation of this dissertation. My family who shaped me and let me savour Europe, even though it is still not easy for them. Hiromu “Ron” Tanimoto who showed me the stepping stone and encouraged me to take the leap of faith to France. Prof. Ricarda Scheiner and Prof. Jeremy Niven who reviewed the dissertation in relatively short time and kindly managed to. Prof. Claudio Lazzari and Jean-Marc who kindly became members of the jury to examine the dissertation as well. Rodrigo “Muchacho” and Nobuhiro “Nobu” who were my two dear mentors at the beginning of my adventure into the bee world, in good times and in bad, and keep being my mentors in many aspects. Julie, without her I would have stayed clueless in the laboratory and homeless in France. Edith, without her results my project would not have been present. Gabriela for her being so welcoming and motherly in and outside the laboratory. Theo who has been a helpful lab-mate in my early days and become cachaça-mate in later days. Margaux and Elodie for having been so patient dealing with me and co-authoring my publications. Isabelle for her advices and supports, particularly remarkable that one time when we had to race to “préfecture de Haute-Garonne” minutes before they closed. Ayse for being my heroine when things did seem to end badly. Lucie for her efforts in selecting the right foragers. Je remercie Christine pour ses aides administratives et particulièrement pour avoir réussi à commander la salle de l’UPS qui a le nom le plus cool et très français (ou toulousain). Maud and Patrick for their technical support. Gérard pour m’avoir toujours invité de venir faire du ski ensemble qu’on n’a jamais concrétisé. Postdoc Power Rangers who show me that justice shall prevail; Alfonso, Dañao, Fabien, Sara (whose laughter always brightens up dark corridors) and Sepideh (who was for me identical to Sara on our first encounter). Constance, Jessica et Sophia pour avoir traduit et corrigé des parts français dans ma thèse, entre autres. I also thank other actual and previous PAMI members Alexei “Alexov”, Amelie, Aurore, Damien, Cathy, Celeste, Cindy, Clement (✝), Florencia, Florian, Guillaume, Jonas, Lilha Margot, Marie, Marion, Maru, Mathieu, Mehdi, Monique, Pierre, PYM, Thierry and Yannice ii for the time for our discussions in corridors and outside on the terrace. Additionally, Petnoi and Benedikt as non-PAMI members. Elodie avec sa coupe rasta for letting me know the beauty of nature in France as well as in New Zealand. Prof. Alison Mercer who hosted me during my stay in New Zealand with outmost hospitality and her spotless team - “Jamie” McQuillan, who passionately taught me gently to stay clean and left, David and Charles. Prof. Buchner for the α-SynORF antibody which accompanied me during my whole doctoral study. Prof. Karen Mesce for her brain samples. Marie-Laure and Jacques from ITAV for their excellent assistance in confocal microscopy. Anja, Sebastian and Igor “Big Guy” for their helps in developing my technique immunocytochemistry, which made me go this far. Prof. Randolf Menzel, der mich herzlich in seinem Labor empfing und Geheimtipps bezueglich der Elektrophysiologie gab, und Gisela, die mir leidenschaftlich intrazelluläre Ableitung beibrachte. Genauso warmherzig haben mich die anderen Kollegen in Berlin wie Prof. Bjoern Brembs, Sathiskumar “Sati”, Adriana, Andreas, Christine “Chrissi”, and Julien empfangen. Und selbstverständlich meine Freunde in München, im Guten wie im Schlechten: Arnab, Basti “Brenz“, Basti “Swob“, Erika, Johanna, Kristina, Natalie and “Olly” Hawlitschek. My indonesian friends who keep me checked and sane: Anastasia, “Agus” Karen, Indra “Buabeh”, Kurniawan “Kuri”, Neki “QQ Djavor” and Prudence “Prudi”. Sophie “Sophsky” and Ana “Muchacha” for connecting me with parts of the world. Paul for his generous donation of his bottles of scottish whiskeys and south french wines in the infamous fortress Hamer. La famille Le Liboux, la famille Sirac and la famille Taurand for having me as their oldest son in the family. My friends from the indonesian student association: Afif, Adrian, Agung, Aziz, Ananda, Adhitya “Saiko”, Bulan, Deni, Devi, Ester, Fito Beng, Ivan, Nadya, Kus, “Nemi” Sinaga, Rama, Reggie, Ruby “Liu Liu”, Surya, Tya, Yoga and Zulkifli “Kipli”. Disclaimer: Statements above are only the tip of the Eisberg. They don’t represent your true infinite good deeds. Bless you all, I feel overwhelmed having you around me, but we can’t afford getting the acknowledgement longer than the content of the dissertation per se, can we? iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgement ................................................................................................................... i Table of contents ................................................................................................................... iv Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 1 1. Learning and Memory: Basic Definition ............................................................................ 3 1.1. Classical Conditioning: Principles and Definitions ................................................... 4 1.2. Classical Conditioning in Invertebrates ..................................................................... 5 2. The Honey Bee as a Model for the Study of Learning and Memory ................................. 7 2.1. Sucrose Responsiveness in Honey Bees ..................................................................... 8 2.2. The Appetitive Olfactory Conditioning of PER in the Honey Bee ............................. 9 2.3. The Architecture of the Honey Bee Brain ................................................................. 10 2.4. The Neural Circuits Underlying Appetitive Olfactory Learning in the Honey Bee . 16 2.4.1. Appetitive US (sucrose) Pathway Underlying Olfactory PER Conditioning . 16 2.4.2. Olfactory CS Pathway Underlying Olfactory PER Conditioning ….............. 18 2.5. Appetitive Memories Induced by Olfactory PER Conditioning ............................... 20 3. The Advent of a New Conditioning Protocol for Harnessed Bees: the Aversive Olfactory Conditioning for the Sting Extinction Reflex ................................................................... 22 3.1. Aversive US Pathway Underlying Olfactory SER Conditioning ............................. 26 3.2. Olfactory US Pathway Underlying Olfactory SER Conditioning ............................. 28 3.3. Aversive Memories Induced by Olfactory SER Conditioning ................................. 29 3.4. Aversive Shock Responsiveness and Colony Organization ...................................... 31 3.5. Shock Sensitivity and Olfactory SER Conditioning ................................................. 34 3.6. Shock Sensitivity, Olfactory SER Conditioning and Caste Specialization within the Hive ........................................................................................................................... 35 iv Objectives .............................................................................................................................. 39 Part 1: Pharmacological modulation of aversive responsiveness in honey bees ............. 41 Part 2: A tyrosine-hydroxylase characterization of dopaminergic neurons in the honey bee brain ................................................................................................................................ 85 Part 3: Aversive learning increases the expression of dopamine-receptor genes in specific cell populations of the honey bee brain ............................................................... 135 Discussion ............................................................................................................................ 171 1. Different Functionality of Dopaminergic Neurons (neuropharmacological study – responsiveness to electric shock, an aversive stimulus) ................................................. 174 1.1. Dopaminergic Modulation of Aversive Learning and Memory ............................. 174 1.2. Dopaminergic Modulation of Aversive Responsiveness ........................................ 175 1.3. Different Classes of Dopaminergic Neurons .......................................................... 176 2. Neuroanatomy of the Dopaminergic Network in the Bee Brain .................................... 178 2.1. Dopaminergic Processes in the MB ........................................................................ 179 2.2. Dopaminergic Neurons as Modulators of Behaviour .............................................. 181 3. Learning-Dependent Modulation of DA Receptor Expression in the MBs ................... 182 3.1. A Molecular Mechanism Accounting for the Rescorla-Wagner Model? ............... 185 4. General Conclusions ....................................................................................................... 188 References ........................................................................................................................... 189 Annexe ................................................................................................................................. 207 v vi IINTRODUCTIONNTRODUCTION 1 2 Introduction