A More Impactful Movement for Animals

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A More Impactful Movement for Animals A more impactful movement for animals ANIMALS MEAT ENVIRONMENT HEALTH HUNGER EFFECTIEF ALTRUISME VLAANDEREN © Carl Warner open-mindedess empathy rationality positivity open- mindedness • Veganism is… • You’re not vegan if you… • Vegans are… • Meat eaters are… improve Open-mindedness • Have I thought about this thoroughly? • What info am I missing? • What are my biases? • Practise slow opinion empathy Empathy? Seriously? Empathy • Having an open mind • Listening & asking questions • Building rapport • Trying to understand To be more empathic 1. Understand the situation we’re in. Why do most people eat meat? because Why do most people eat meat STEAKHOLDERS You are special (yes!) To be more empathic 1. Understand the situation we’re in. 2. You don’t have all the info To be more empathic 1. Understand the situation we’re in. 2. You don’t have all the info 3. Remember that empathy works rationality vegalomania On purity 100% vegan 99% vegan 95% vegan 100% vegan Who’s vegan? You’re not You’re not You’re not You’re not You’re not vegan! vegan! vegan! vegan! vegan! 95% vegan tl1 Slide 77 tl1 tobias leenaert, 8/25/2018 99% vegan Your meals in a year Your meals in a year 99,7% I’m not worried about My mom making me eat stuff Confused waiters Watering down veganism A© Carl Warner98% vegan world I’m worried about alienating meat eaters alienating vegans recidivism signaling vegan not vegan vegan 14% +2.7% 12% 10% 8% 6% Market Share Market 4% 2% +0.1% +0.2% 0% Milk Meat Cheese 2018 2017 Source: Nielsen custom defined data set, xAOC + WFM, 52 weeks ending 8/11/18. expectations from yourself from others behavior private public consistency with rules with goals Your impact on eating animals What you eat Your impact on what others eat What goes into your mouth is less important than what comes out of it. positivity “Optimism is a moral duty” (but don’t be naive) “Those who deserve love the least need it the most.” We are the first species to question our own diet Homo erectus Homo sapiens Modern humans -1M -100K /veganstrategist END Two phases 1. Facilitating compassion Ensure a fertile breeding ground for veganism 2. Growing phase Zoom in on animal rights and moral obligations. See the number of “true vegans” grow 1 2 Pragmatic/non-moral Ideological/moral Reduce Go vegan For any reason For the animals Increase skills Become active Focus on the Focus on personal environment/alternat ethics (anti- ives speciesism) Ideological/go vegan • Audiences that are open (young people, students, people who are into animals…) • Audiences that are already well on the way (serious reducers, vegetarians) • People who are interested in having a philosophical/rational debate about the topic • And now and then… animals environmt health motivation variation No reason M. Monday demitarian vegetarian veganish vegan behavior 4 ways to be pragmatic • The call to action • The arguments we use • Focus on the environment • A relaxed definition of veganism factors moral non-moral CHANGE two starting points attitude behaviour attitude behavior animals environmt health motivation variation No reason M. Monday demitarian vegetarian veganish vegan frequency animals environmt health motivation variation No reason M. Monday demitarian vegetarian veganish vegan frequency The narcissism of small differences Distinctiveness threat • “People like to be seen in terms of identities important to them. Being seen in terms of other identities, especially erroneous ones, can evoke “categorization threat“. We also do not like it when another group is so similar to ours, because it undermines the very essence of what our group is that makes us different and special. In other words we tend to be most sensitive when the other group actually is similar to our own (…). Groups that are too similar to our own can therefore threaten the unique identity of the group: “distinctiveness threat“. Some have even argued that having a distinctive group identity is even more fundamental than avoiding a negative one.” .
Recommended publications
  • Fall 2019 Newsletter
    Animals and Society Fall 2019 Newsletter INSIDE THIS ISSUE Letter from the Chair Mission continues to lag in its recognition and action. Some programs seem Letter from the determined to ignore the science. Chair 1 Currently, our dear colleague Dr. Publications 2 David Nibert, founder of the Animals & Society Section of the American Featured Essays and Sociological Association, is fighting a Discussion 5 battle to save the lives of several lambs slated for slaughter at Ohio's Upcoming Conferences 6 Greetings friends and colleagues, Antioch College as part of a Animals and Society “sustainability” program. The Section Awareds 2019 9 I write this editorial on the heels university has launched a character of a very exciting mini- attack against Dr. Nibert and firmly Section Scholarship conference, “Animals, Ecology & refuses to release the lambs to Awards 10 Society,” which our lovely Section sanctuary. I have written on behalf of held in collaboration with the the lambs, soundly criticizing the Animals and Society Environmental Studies notion that speciesist foodways can Section Officers and Department of New York ever be “sustainable.” Over a Council University prior to the 2019 ASA hundred other academics (many of Newsletter Editors meeting. Speakers included whom are fellow members) have Leslie Irvine, Colter Ellis, Kelly joined me in protest of Antioch’s Membership 11 Knight, Colin Jerolmack, Linda highly problematic curriculum. Kalof, Stefano Longo, and Erin Mission Kidder. As we gathered together Please consider signing the petition, that sunny day in Manhattan, the already over 71,000 strong, The purpose of the Section United Nations had just released and contact the university to voice on Animals and Society is a lengthy report underscoring the your concerns.
    [Show full text]
  • Jusqu'où Défendre Les Animaux ?
    LES CAHIERS ANTISPÉCISTES JUSQU’OÙ DÉFENDRE LES ANIMAUX ? Tom REGAN Steven BEST David CHAUVET Bernard BAERTSCHI Estiva REUS NUMÉRO 39 MAI 2017 À propos des Cahiers antispécistes Les Cahiers antispécistes sont une revue fondée en 1991. La périodicité est irrégulière. Rédaction : Brigitte Gothière, Estiva Reus, Pierre Sigler. La rédaction choisit les textes en fonction de l’intérêt qu’elle y trouve et des débats qui peuvent en découler, mais les opinions qui y sont exprimées n’engagent que leurs auteurs. La revue ne fonctionne pas sur le principe de soumission spontanée de textes par des auteurs qui seraient ensuite acceptés ou refusés. Site : cahiers-antispécistes.org Mail : [email protected] FaceBook. Les Cahiers antispécistes publient quotidiennement des informations sur la question animale sur leur page Facebook. Se procurer Les Cahiers antispécistes (version papier) Le n°39 des Cahiers antispécistes (de même que le n°35) n’a pas été édité en version papier. Tous les autres numéros ont été imprimés mais certains sont épuisés. Les anciens numéros restants sont gérés par la boutique en ligne de L214. Certains peuvent être directement commandés sur https://boutique.l214.com/36-revues. Si vous cherchez des numéros plus anciens écrire à [email protected] pour savoir s’ils sont encore disponibles. Les Cahiers antispécistes n°39, mai 2017 1 Sommaire Présentation du numéro 39 3 La Rédaction Comment justifier la violence 7 Tom Regan Paralysie du pacifisme 13 Une défense de l’action directe militante et de la « violence » Steven
    [Show full text]
  • Page 1New.Qxp Layout 1
    FREE Established 1961 Friday ISSUE NO: 17511 SHAABAN 4, 1439 AH FRIDAY, APRIL 20, 2018 Oil soars to highest level Saad Al-Mutawa elected Boursa James’ epic 46 points help 9 in years on Mideast woes 37 chief, Sulaiman Al-Marzouq VC 44 Cavs even series with Pacers MP Hamdan Al-Azemi (right) filed to grill HH the Prime Minister Sheikh Jaber Al-Mubarak Al-Sabah yesterday. PM grilling may lead to Assembly dissolution See Page 9 2 Friday Local Friday, April 20, 2018 Diwaniyas in Kuwait PHOTO OF THE DAY Local Spotlight By Muna Al-Fuzai [email protected] have found that several Western expatriates, espe- Icially male diplomats, like to visit diwaniyas in Kuwait. But what is the secret behind this passion? This article reviews the role and importance of diwaniyas. Diwaniyas in Kuwait hold a strong position in political, social and cultural life, the formation of ideas and discussions and sometimes decision-making accord- ing to the prevailing circumstances. I recalled the important role of diwaniyas while I was reading a statement of a new diplomat in Kuwait, in which he said he looks forward to visiting many Kuwaiti diwaniyas. I believe he will undoubtedly be welcomed. Kuwaiti hospitality is well known and diwaniyas are in fact cultural, social and political spaces to hear what Kuwaitis think and talk about daily. Also, Kuwaitis prefer to welcome visitors in diwaniyas. Visitors feel that they are welcome in their homes and this reflects the gen- erosity and the Arab sense of hospitality. Diwaniyas are the perfect place to share ideas and hold debates without fear or anxiety, as the diwaniya is KUWAIT: Aerial view of Al Shaheed Park and Tijaria Tower by Essam Gad.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter November
    VOLUME 19 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2017 Dear EurSafe members, It is my great pleasure to present to you the third issue of 2017 EurSafe News- letter. Somewhat in accord with the themes of the upcoming EurSafe confer- ence in Vienna this summer, this edition of the newsletter engages questions in the intersection between theories and practitioners. Both the short paper and the book review revolve around the fact that communication, debate, Editorial public discussions and genuinely enganging opposing views are fundamental to type of applied theory that agricultural and environmental ethics is. In their paper The future of hunting in the context of the public discussions over the practice, Mateusz and Waldemar Tokarski describe the complexity of hunting as a practice reaching beyond the core act of killing. They argue for looking at and discussing hunting as a practice that involves forest manage- ment, agricultural management, improvements of ecosystems and a number of wildlife encounters beside the hunt itself. For them, hunting is ‘a practice [that] embodies its own values, linked especially to the construction of multi-spe- cies communities revolving around contact with the natural environment’ and the ethical dilemmas of hunting are best debated with this in mind. CONTENTS The Future of Hunting Paper by Mateusz and Waldemar Tokarski | 3 Tobias Lenaert: How to create a Vegan World Book Review by Mark Stein | 6 Launch of Chinese Society for Agricultural Ethics Report by Franck Meijboom | 8 From the Executive Committee | 10 Announcements & Publications | 11 1 Contact | 16 VOLUME 19 NO. 3 Mark Stein has reviewed Tobias Leenaert’s new book, How to Create a Vegan World: A Pragmatic Approach.
    [Show full text]
  • Unjust Borders: Individuals and the Ethics of Immigration
    Unjust Borders: Individuals and the Ethics of Immigration Frontmatter Unjust Borders: Individuals and the Ethics of Immigration States restrict immigration on a massive scale. Governments fortify their borders with walls and fences, authorize border patrols, imprison migrants in detention centers, and deport large numbers of foreigners. Unjust Borders: Individuals and the Ethics of Immigration argues that immigration restrictions are systematically unjust and examines how individual actors should respond to this injustice. Javier Hidalgo maintains that individuals can rightfully resist immigration restrictions and often have strong moral reasons to subvert these laws. This book makes the case that unauthorized migrants can permissibly evade, deceive, and use defensive force against immigration agents, that smugglers can aid migrants in crossing borders, and that citizens should disobey laws that compel them to harm immigrants. Unjust Borders is a meditation on how individuals should act in the midst of pervasive injustice. Biography: Javier Hidalgo is an Associate Professor of Leadership Studies at the University of Richmond. His work has appeared in venues such as The Journal of Political Philosophy, The Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy and The Journal of Moral Philosophy. 1 Dedication For my parents. 2 Table of Contents: Introduction 0.1 A Story 0.2 From Public Policy to the Individual Ethics of Immigration 0.3 A Comment on Moral Methodology 0.4 Terminology 0.5 An Outline of the Book Chapter 1: The Case Against Exclusion 1.1
    [Show full text]
  • 43º Encontro Anual Da Anpocs
    43º ENCONTRO ANUAL DA ANPOCS ST40 SOCIEDADE E VIDA ECONÔMICA MUITO ALÉM DA CARNE: as práticas alimentares dos restaurantes e consumidores veganos de Porto Alegre Autores: Maycon Noremberg Schubert (UFRGS) Paulo André Niederle (UFRGS) INTRODUÇÃO As mudanças climáticas estão no centro dos debates mais tensos atualmente, tanto no âmbito dos Estados, com iniciativas de austeridade fiscal, intensificação na exploração de recursos naturais, soberania nacional e acordos internacionais, etc (SHUTTE, 2014; ALMEIDA, 2019), quanto no âmbito da sociedade civil, mudanças nos hábitos de consumo, engajamento político em movimento sociais e coletivos, etc (COLOMÉ, 2018; CARLSSON-KANYAMA e GONZÁLEZ, 2009), assim como nos mercados, startups, fusões e incorporações, inovação, e processos de industrialização mais intensos, etc (GERHARD, et all, 2019; SCHUBERT e TAVARES, 2019). Transversalmente a todo esse debate está presente o modo e a forma com que as sociedades se alimentam, produzem, beneficiam, transportam, comercializam, preparam e descartam os alimentos. Segundo relatório da FAO (2013), a produção alimentar é responsável por cerca de 19-29%, provocada pela indução humana, da emissão de Gases de Efeito Estufa (GEE), 60% da perda de biodiversidade da terra, 70% do uso de água. A criação de animais é quem carrega esse maior ‘fardo’, sendo responsável por cerca de 14,4% dos GEE’s (FAO, 2013a). Porém, há distinção em relação aos diferentes tipos (Suínos, Frango, Bubalinos, Pequenos Ruminantes e Outras aves), sendo a produção de leite e carnes, de origem bovina, os maiores causadores desse impacto, representando 65% do total de emissão de GEE’s, referente à criação de animais (FAO, 2013a). Essa relação, entre as mudanças climáticas e a o padrão atual do sistema agroalimentar, é sinérgica, ou seja, uma ‘espiral’ autodestrutiva (FAO, 2015), cujos custos já representam um prejuízo no PIB mundial em torno de 5-10% (SWINBURN, et all., 2019).
    [Show full text]
  • Animals in the Society of Humans: Privileged and Enslaved
    Animals in the Society of Humans: Privileged and Enslaved Tereza Vandrovcová Our current society has a very ambivalent relationship with other species. On the one hand, more and more people are known to be animal lovers, and in opinion polls they state their opnion that it is very important that animals are treated well (Special Eurobarometer 442 2015), and they also usually can't abide the idea or image of another creature suffering or being killed (Lamm et al. 2010). On the other hand, the vast majority of these people consume a large quantity of animal products daily from large-scale, industrial livestock farms, where animals are treated as utility units rather than as individuals with their own needs (Twine 2010). Through the excessive consumption of these products, consumers participate not only in the unnecessary suffering and killing of sentient creatures (Pluhar 2010; Discanto et al. 2014), but also in an environmental threat to our entire planet (FAO 2006; Thaler et al. 2013; Scarborough et al. 2014 Springmann et al., 2016). How do people come to terms with this blatant contradiction? What mechanisms allow the existence of a contradictory relationship in which we love one animal and kill another? Is there any way to allay this paradox and promote a more sustainable way of life and a more empathetic relationship with the other inhabitants of our planet? Contemporary social science research is trying to answer these and other questions. Conformity As Tobias Leenaert writes in his blog, Vegan Strategist (Tobias Leenaert 2016), the question, "Why do most people consume meat?" can be very simply answered, "Because most people eat meat." This is due to man's tendency to conform to the culture to which he/she belongs by birth.
    [Show full text]
  • Growing Green International Contents Index
    GROWING GREEN INTERNATIONAL CONTENTS INDEX Articles are from the UK unless indicated in red (and some titles have been changed a little for clarity) To search for any topic/name use Control+F Articles shown in blue are available online - click on the links All magazines are available in pdf form if you are a VON member, contact [email protected] 46 SPRING/SUMMER 2021 editor Tony Martin 06 Grow your own nuts (part 2) Addy Fern 10 Record harvests at La Ferme de L’Aube Jimmy Videle Canada 12 A revolution in lifestyle and agriculture Colleen McDuling 16 VON summer road tour 2020 Cherry Chung 19 Kindling Trust’s plans for a farm outside Manchester 25 Farmers for Stockfree Farming Rebecca Knowles 28 Grow Veganic Save the Planet Dan Graham 30 Rethinking Food and Agriculture (book by Amir & Laila Kassam) review by Kollibri terre Sonnenblume 34 The Garden of Vegan (book by Cleve West) review by Verona Barnes 36 A season on our farm Iain Tolhurst 39 From seed to plate (spinach and pea gnocchi) Piers Warren 41 Seed planting and human liberation Colin Denny Donoghue USA 43 Sad loss of VON activists Peter & Diana White David Graham 45 AUTUMN/WINTER 2020 editor Tony Martin 06 Growing Green: affordably, healthfully and ethically Colleen McDuling 10 Sowing on a shoestring (or budget gardening) Heather Fowler 11 Cooking in an emergency - some insights from 1939 Alina Congreve 14 Growing vertically Rosie Apps 17 A vegan permaculture garden in your kitchen Graham Burnett 25 Getting creative (or using the bits that we normally leave for the worms)
    [Show full text]
  • Mouvement RWAS Et Mouvement De Libération Animale
    1 Chapitre 4 Mouvement RWAS et mouvement de libération animale Jusqu’à présent, le mouvement de libération animale (ou mouvement des droits des animaux) s’est concentré sur l’objectif de faire cesser les usages que font les humains d’autres animaux au détriment de ces derniers, que ce soit pour les loisirs, la recherche ou la fourniture de biens de consommation. Une grande majorité des acteurs de la mouvance RWAS sont engagés dans le mouvement des droits des animaux, et certains en sont des penseurs ou militants de premier plan. Le site Animal Ethics est une bonne illustration de cette conjonction : il est original par la place importante qu’il accorde à la thématique RWAS, mais si vous êtes familiarisé avec le mouvement de libération animale, ses autres composantes ne vous dépayseront pas (cf. les parties du site traitant de l’exploitation des animaux, de la sentience, ou de l’éthique). À première vue, il semble donc qu’il faille considérer le mouvement RWAS comme un prolongement du mouvement de libération animale, et c’est certainement ainsi que le voient la plupart de ses promoteurs. Un prolongement de taille toutefois, puisque les animaux sauvages sont beaucoup plus nombreux que les animaux domestiques, et que les maux naturels font davantage de dégâts parmi les animaux sauvages que la pêche ou la chasse humaines. On peut y voir aussi un saut qualitatif puisque, pour les éthiciens RWAS, il s’agit d’accéder au sens plein de la logique antispéciste, là où le mouvement de libération animale est resté cantonné dans le provincialisme humain.
    [Show full text]
  • KEY: So That Anyone Can See the Logic of Your Thinking, the Goal in Making
    7/January/2019 KEY: So that anyone can see the logic of your thinking, the goal in making an Ideological Profile is to progress from the most fundamental observations and theories about life and existence to the most practical implications in laws and social issues. This is why the ideas are weighted from 23 to 1. Also, this is to encourage everyone to begin by reaching a common ground with the greatest number of people, from any place or creed. Ideally, we should first establish where our views are the same before we can discern exactly where and why they diverge. However, this is only a suggestion. Egora supports absolute free speech, and you can use your Ideological Profile in any way you wish. TIP: A ‘good’ idea is generally an idea that you are willing to actively promote by asking others to also support it. But you can use your Ideological Profile to express ideas that are only personally relevant to you. NOTE: Countries are listed in order of IP creation for that country. United States of America Dan Kappil (1) 23 END SLAVERY 22 The war on drugs has failed. It has been shown over decades that prohibiting drugs has simply led to a thriving illicit drug trade and resulting violence. Incarcerating drug users does not help them to recover as prison does not give drug users the resources needed to come clean. Drugs should be legalized, controlled, regulated, and taxed. If an adult person decides to partake of drugs, they should be made aware of the risk, but also should be allowed to use drugs even if it is to their detriment.
    [Show full text]
  • Universidad Finis Terrae Facultad De Arte Magister En Investigación Y Creación Fotográfica
    UNIVERSIDAD FINIS TERRAE FACULTAD DE ARTE MAGISTER EN INVESTIGACIÓN Y CREACIÓN FOTOGRÁFICA Esto ha sido / La noción de cautiverio a través de la impronta fotográfica Macarena Quezada Bilbao Memoria presentada a la Facultad de Arte de la Universidad Finis Terrae para optar al grado de Magister en Creación e Investigación Fotográfica Profesor Guía: Andrea Josch Santiago, Chile 2017 Esto ha sido / La noción de cautiverio a través de la impronta fotográfica 2 " ! ! ! A!mi!hija!Martina! " Esto ha sido / La noción de cautiverio a través de la impronta fotográfica 3 " AGRADECIMIENTOS Son muchas las personas que de una u otra forma se involucraron en este proyecto fotográfico: Amigos, familia, profesores e incluso personas que aparecieron en el camino. Esta idea dio sus primeros pasos gracias a Rubén y Daniel, el cargador y el chofer de un camión distribuidor de carne que reparte en la Vega Central, en torno al que desarrollé mi obra CONTENEDOR. La obsesión por este camión repartidor de carne comenzó a tomar forma en el taller de Nicolás Franco y Francisca Montes, ambos desde su visión me aportaron conceptos relevantes para pulir esta idea. Y, en una segunda etapa, en el taller final con Cristian Silva Avaria, se concretó. A Andrea Josch, mi profesora guía, por ordenar las ideas que estaban en mi cabeza y por sus valiosos aportes a la construcción de esta memoria. Quiero agradecer también a mis compañeros y amigos del Magíster, Cristina Muñoz y Alexis Gajardo, por su ayuda concreta en la realización de la obra. A Catalina de la Cruz por compartir sus conocimientos y ayudarme a sacar adelante las emulsiones sobre metal y mi libro foto químico en su taller de emulsiones fotográficas.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Vegan' and 'Vegetarian'
    Report for Animal Charity Evaluators 1 Table of Contents 1. Introduction 2. Strategic Approach 3. Accomplishments 2015/2016 4. Management Effectiveness 5. Organizational Structure, Leadership and Culture 6. Finances & Organizational Growth 7. Long-Term Strategy & Plans for International Growth 8. References 2 Introduction 3 Basic Information about VEBU & ProVeg ● One of Europe’s leading pro-vegan ● As a first step, we are establishing national organizations ProVeg branches in Spain, Poland, France, and ● Founded in 1892, based in Berlin, Germany the UK, implementing our most effective interventions. ● Up to now, mainly active in Germany, with some of its interventions already having ● In addition, we implement some international international reach and impact interventions beyond those four countries. ● To increase our global impact, we are ● In the long run, we plan to establish national creating an international organization based ProVeg branches in all major countries. on the resources, successes and track record ● Our aim is for ProVeg to become the (EA-minded) of VEBU. Its name is ProVeg. ‘Greenpeace of the vegan movement’. ● VEBU will soon turn into ProVeg. 4 The Hearts and Brains Behind ProVeg The following outline of the strategic approach and plans for international growth has been developed and approved by Sebastian Joy and the following four representatives of ProVeg: ● Founder of veganstrategist.org ● Psychologist, author, international ● Co-founder of CEVA (Center for speaker & organizational consultant Effective Vegan Advocacy)
    [Show full text]