ANNUAL REPORT 2016-2017 Our Mission
We support research that informs economic policymaking while engaging future leaders and scholars. We share knowledge and build relationships among academics, government officials, the business community and the public. Table of Contents
Director’s Letter...... 2 Donors...... 27 Policy Impact...... 4 Senior Fellows...... 32 Student Support...... 8 Faculty Fellows...... 36 Events and Conferences...... 12 Researchers...... 36 Policy Briefs...... 20 Visitors and Young Scholars...... 37 Income and Expenditures...... 21 Steering Committee...... 39 Philanthropy...... 22 Advisory Board...... 41
John Gunn Janet Yellen speaks at SIEPR
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Director’s Letter
Dear Friends, Thinking of the past year reminds us of because the future of economic what’s at stake when it comes to economic policymaking can only be as good as those policymaking. Many of the biggest national trained to analyze, craft and implement debates — whether about tax reform, health the policies that will affect millions care or jobs — have huge implications. of lives. Our faculty and affiliates at the Stanford We’ve made major strides in the past Institute for Economic Policy Research year to bring many more students into are involved in those topics and so many our orbit. Thanks in large part to your more, producing data-driven, credible support, we assisted more than 100 and impartial scholarship intended to graduate and undergraduate students understand and inform the ideas and with fellowships and research assistant legislation shaping the economy. positions. The fellowships funded a wide range of graduate students who were able Your generous support is instrumental to to conduct field research all around the the work we do, and I very much appreciate world. And our new program for undergraduate research your dedication to our mission of fostering policy-relevant assistants provided valuable research experience and research, engaging future leaders and scholars, and mentorship for aspiring economics and public policy sharing our scholarship with a broad audience. students who worked closely with our faculty members. The pages ahead will remind you of our accomplishments After launching a successful pilot, we have established a during the 2016-17 academic year. You will see familiar predoctoral research fellows program designed to train faces in the photos of events that convened policymakers, those interested in a graduate degree in economics, academics and business leaders. You will see that SIEPR is public policy, or a related discipline. The fellows are on strong financial ground. assisting SIEPR faculty while earning credits for classes But I want to take some extra space here to shine the light that they take. on what I see as one of SIEPR’s most important roles: Our relationships with student groups like the Stanford Teaching and training the next generation of economists Economics Association and Stanford in Government are and economic policymakers. stronger, and we’ve hosted more robust programs and SIEPR is not only home to some of the world’s most events that dig into the topics that students care deeply well-established economists. It is also a magnet for the about — issues like the cost of housing, the price of our youngest and most promising stars in the field. That’s criminal justice system and the promise and perils of a something we take very seriously as an institution tech-based economy.
2 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR And we took every opportunity available to connect celebration of Ken’s academic contributions — which were Stanford students directly with policymakers. Fed chief many — he was remembered for his humility, kindness, Janet Yellen and White House budget director Mick and ability to connect with students and younger Mulvaney both met privately with groups of students scholars. At least five of Ken’s students went on to win during their visits to SIEPR. Undergraduates and graduate their own Nobels. students also had the chance to meet with officials from Of all the lessons we’ve learned from Ken, perhaps one the U.S. Treasury Department, regional Federal Reserve of the most important is that we should make a bold banks, and the International Monetary Fund. investment in our students. With your continued support Along with attracting more students to SIEPR, we have and involvement with SIEPR, I am confident those broadened our set of scholars. The last academic year saw investments will yield tremendous rewards in the coming our roster increase by three Faculty Fellows. And visitors year and generations ahead. from Columbia, MIT, Harvard and Northwestern were part of our Young Scholars Program as junior professors or recent PhDs from those institutions. Best regards, This past year also brought the loss of one of the giants of economics. Kenneth Arrow, a Nobel Prize winner and SIEPR Senior Fellow, died on Feb. 21. We paid tribute Mark Duggan to Ken in a daylong event organized in October by John The Trione Director of SIEPR Shoven, Alvin Roth and Matthew Jackson. Along with a The Wayne and Jodi Cooperman Professor of Economics
Students engage in a private meeting with Janet Yellen
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | DIRECTOR’S LETTER 3 Policy Impact
SIEPR researchers bridge academia and government. Their scholarship and expertise informs congressional testimony, leads to advisory roles, and builds relationships with leaders of various federal and state agencies. Their work is covered by some of the most influential journalists, and their policy-relevant ideas are broadly circulated in the essays, commentaries and opinion pieces they write for leading news organizations.
Adrien Auclert Gopi Shah Goda
4 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR Here are some examples from the past year.
SIEPR Director Mark Duggan’s Policy Brief on the The Indian state of Tamil Nadu is funding and supporting Affordable Care Act was cited in a New York Times story research conducted by Grant Miller, a Senior Fellow about health care sector jobs. and Director of the Stanford Center for International Development, focusing on rice fortification. The state The Wall Street Journal wrote about a paper co-authored government has committed to scaling the intervention for by Duggan, SIEPR Deputy Director Gopi Shah Goda, as many as 80 million people if Miller’s study shows it is and PhD student Emilie Jackson, showing no evidence successful. the Affordable Care Act has driven workers out of the labor force. Senior Fellow Pete Klenow presented one of his papers at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s Economic Maya Rossin-Slater, a Faculty Fellow, presented her Symposium on Fostering a Dynamic Global Economy. research on paid family leave to the Washington State Legislature. She also co-authored a report for the Senior Fellow Daniel Ho wrote an op-ed in The Seattle California Employment Development Department on the Times discussing the food safety rating algorithm he economic and social impact of paid family leave. developed for the public health department in Seattle and King County. SIEPR Senior Fellow Gregory Rosston advised presidential candidate Hillary Clinton as a member of her Senior Fellow Michael Boskin was an adviser to the Fiscal campaign’s Technology Policy and Innovation Working Law Reform Commission in India. He also served as an Group. adviser to the White House, Treasury Department and the House Ways and Means and Senate Finance committees A Policy Brief about the coal industry written by Senior on tax reform. Fellow Charles Kolstad received widespread media attention, including coverage by The Washington Post. Raj Chetty’s work on income inequality received widespread media coverage. The Senior Fellow’s work on The country of Ghana decided to institute free secondary “quantifying the American dream” was the subject of a education, citing research by Senior Fellow Pascaline New York Times column. Dupas as background evidence that helped shape the policy. Four of Dupas’ studies were mentioned in a World Senior Fellow Edward Lazear wrote an op-ed in Development Report, which makes recommendations The Wall Street Journal about a balanced approach to widely followed by policymakers. immigration policy.
Leading news organizations — including The Washington Congress introduced a bill, Protecting Consumers’ Access Post, Esquire, and The Atlantic, wrote about research by to Credit Act of 2017, that references a research paper by Senior Fellow Matthew Gentzkow that focused on social Faculty Fellow Colleen Honigsberg. media and political polarization.
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | POLICY IMPACT 5 Pascaline Dupas John Taylor
Several news outlets, including The Atlantic, The Nation Senior Fellow Anat Admati served on the U.S. Commodity and Columbia Journalism Review, discussed Senior Futures Trading Commission and on the agency’s Risk Fellow Jay Hamilton’s research on the economics of Management subcommittee. She also sits on the FDIC investigative reporting. Systemic Resolution Advisory Committee and testified before California state lawmakers about the fraudulent Fed Chair Janet Yellen cited research by Faculty practices of Wells Fargo. Fellow Adrien Auclert in a speech she delivered on “Macroeconomic Research After the Crisis.” Yellen Senior Fellow John Taylor testified three times on Capitol cited Auclert’s work as an example of new research on Hill about monetary policy and bankruptcy reform. He monetary policy and heterogeneity. also argued his case for a rules-based Federal Reserve system in a Wall Street Journal opinion piece. Taylor was Senior Fellow Alan Sykes co-wrote an op-ed in The also named to the G20 Eminent Persons Group on Global Wall Street Journal about the Trump administration’s Financial Governance. emphasis on bilateral trade agreements.
6 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR Anat Admati Raj Chetty
Grant Miller Edward Lazear
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | POLICY IMPACT 7 Student Support
SIEPR and the Stanford Center for International Development (SCID) supported115 about 115 graduate and undergraduate students during the 2016-17 academic year through fellowships and research assistant positions. The fellowships funded graduate student projects on topics ranging from health care economics to political corruption and helped make field research possible in Ukraine, Tanzania and other spots around the world. A program for undergraduate research assistants — in its second year — also continued to provide valuable research experience for aspiring economics students.
SIEPR’s dissertation fellowships, which totaled approximately $490,000, allowed PhD candidates on the job market to complete their research and travel for job seminars. Award recipients from 2016–17 have gone on to secure jobs in academia, private industry and the public sector, including the International Monetary Fund, Pandora, Social Capital, The Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, Yale and Brown.
At SCID, the Ronald McKinnon Memorial Fellowship provided $7,800 in student support while an additional $98,000 in fellowship awards were made possible by general gifts. Moritz Lenel receives the Landau Student Discussion Paper Prize
8 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR SIEPR Fellowships and Awards B.F. Haley and E.S. Shaw Fellowship Kapnick Fellowship Program Ala’ Alrababa’h – Seeds of Support for Economics Megha Patnaik – Management separatism: Eastern Ukraine Monica Bohle – Applied economics: practices and productivity Travis Baseler – Information Public vs. private student loans, firm Kelly Zhang – Voter pessimism and frictions in the migration decision: recruitment, Medicaid political corruption Kenya Evan Mast – Municipal tax incentives Fulya Esroy – Roles of information Kohlhagen Fellowship Fund Davide Malacrino – Entrepreneur and beliefs on study effort and wealth and firm dynamics Moritz Lenel – Effects of asset risk performance and maturity structure on money Bobak Pakzad-Hurson – Policy effects Casey Maue – Effect of water risk markets, asset prices on wage transparency within firms on agricultural investment and Santiago Saavedra – Tax evasion in Juan Rios – Welfare analysis of migration: Tanzania illegal mining: Colombia transfer programs with jumps in Odyssia Ng – Liability contracts for reported income: Brazil The Leonard W. Ely and Shirley R. Ely farmers: Kenya Graduate Student Fund Michael Webb – How automation The Bradley Research Fellowship destroys jobs: UK Program Barbara Biasi – Economics of education Kareem Elnahal – Theoretical Claire and Ralph Landau Student finance and political economy Atul Gupta – Health care economics Discussion Paper Prize Luis Alonso Villacorta – The Perez Santiago – Railroads and the Moritz Lenel – “Safe Assets, roles of financial intermediaries, rural-to-urban transition: Argentina Collateralized Lending and Monetary Policy” nonfinancial firms in the economy Shultz Graduate Student Fellowship in E. S. Shaw and B.F. Haley Fellowship Economic Policy for Economics Aala Abdelgadir – Effects of parental Stephen Nei – Information effects on involvement and resources on school consumption performance: Uganda
SCID Fellowship Recipients The Ronald McKinnon Memorial Andrew Brooks – Impact of colonial Christiana Parreira – Kinship, Fellowship militaries on economic development religious identity, and local service Emanuele Colonnelli – Corruption Cauê de Castro Dobbin – Returns to provision in weak states: Lebanon and firms: Brazil tertiary education: Brazil Anna Popova – Education technology Joshua Kim – Food labeling and Joshua Kim – Saliency effects and in developing countries (mis)information: Chile currency choice: Armenia Shiran Shen – Career incentives Salma Mousa – Overcoming the trust of local leaders and air pollution Graduate Student Fellowships deficit: Inter-group contact in Iraq control: China Hernán Barahona – Public-private Edgar Franco Vivanco – Origins of wage differentials: Brazil cooperative behavior: Rural Mexico
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | STUDENT SUPPORT 9 “We’ve made major strides in the past year to bring many more students into our orbit.”
— Mark Duggan, The Trione Director of SIEPR
10 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR 2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | STUDENT SUPPORT 11 Events and Conferences 3,000 Events hosted by SIEPR and its centers drew more than 3,000 participants over the course of the year, providing informative discussions on some of the most important economic issues of today. Some speaker visits — such as those of Fed Chair Janet Yellen and White House budget chief Mick Mulvaney — were incredibly timely with political happenings. And our longstanding practice of hosting conferences and academic workshops continued to cover both emerging research and deepening economic issues. Students, scholars, industry experts and thought leaders were privy to lively, collaborative forums allowing them to learn about, question and explore the work ahead in improving economic policy.
Edward Lazear chats with attendees following his Associates Meeting talk
12 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR Policy Forum on Gentrification and Affordable Housing SIEPR’s fall Policy Forum on Oct. 14 focused on housing and its effects on education, employment, a region’s economic health, and even a person’s upward mobility. The event, featuring five sessions, posed a question in its title, “Can Policy be the Key to Affordable Housing?” The answer that emerged from the dozen panelists — leading experts in academia, business and policy — was “yes.” They explained how deepening lines of inequality and the cumulative effects of some government actions have exacerbated the nation’s housing crisis. But solutions can be found in better policy prescriptions.
At SIEPR, Yellen warns against running a “hot” economy Janet Yellen Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen met with a group of Stanford students and spoke at an event hosted by SIEPR on Jan. 19. Her visit came on the eve of Donald Trump’s presidential inauguration, and her remarks explaining the Fed’s decision-making strategy signaled potential conflicts with the White House. In a pointed rebuttal to what some lawmakers were calling for, Yellen said it would be “risky and unwise” to run a “hot” economy and defended the Fed’s current approach of gradual interest rate adjustments.
SIEPR Economic Summit The 2017 SIEPR Economic Summit on March 10 drew an engaging mix of insights from experts in academia, industry and policy, taking participants on a daylong ride from the dark days of Wall Street and the Golden Age of Hollywood to the uncertain future of the world’s geopolitical shifts. The annual event, in its 14th year, featured panel discussions and two keynotes — one from former National Security Advisor Stephen Hadley and another from former Treasury Lawrence Summers Ruth Porat Secretary Lawrence Summers.
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | EVENTS AND CONFERENCES 13 Policy Forum on Crime, Policing and Incarceration At the SIEPR Policy Forum on April 21, panelists went beyond the headlines to present a deeper look at the nation’s criminal justice system. The analytical insights and sometimes heated discussions ranged from the impact of police use of stun guns to the high price of instant noodles at jail commissaries. Panelists — including scholars, a police chief, the co-founder of TASER International and a former inmate-turned-PhD student — tackled pressing issues such as prison overcrowding and what police could do to build public trust.
Economic Experiments in the Tech Industry Facebook, Amazon and Google all have teams of economists on their payrolls, and econ PhDs are heading increasingly for technology companies. What are their Mick Mulvaney roles? What experiments are they running? How are consumers affected? On May 8, SIEPR hosted an event that cast a spotlight on this emerging trend, bringing together economists from both the private sector and academic world. The businesses represented in attendance had conducted more than 30,000 experiments in 2016 alone, according to event organizer Michael Luca, who was a SIEPR visiting scholar during the academic year.
Trump’s budget chief answers student questions at SIEPR As lawmakers on Capitol Hill were locked in a battle over a Republican health care plan, Stanford students had an opportunity on May 11 to get direct answers from the White House budget chief on a slew of hot-button issues facing the administration. Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney’s appearance at SIEPR was jointly organized with Stanford in Government and the Stanford Economics Association. More than 50 Kate Glazebrook Geoff Donaker students attended the intimate, town hall-like session.
14 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen holds a special meeting with students at SIEPR
Kim Mai-Cutler, Karen Chapple and Amie Fishman at the Policy Forum on housing
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | EVENTS AND CONFERENCES 15 Attendees gather to talk to Arthur Brooks Esther George
Helen Qiao, Jin-Yong Cai and Shang-Jin Wei at the SIEPR Summit Shea Streeter
16 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR David Maldonado of UC Berkeley at the Policy Forum on Crime, Rebecca Hetey and Eric Jones discuss ways for police Policing and Incarceration to build public trust
Raphael Bostic at the Policy Forum Students interview a Policy Forum panelist for a Facebook Live video on housing
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | EVENTS AND CONFERENCES 17 In addition to the events highlighted earlier, SIEPR and its centers hosted the following:
Associates Meeting Speakers SCID: Fall Regional Meeting of the Working Group in African Political Economy. November 2016 Niall Ferguson, Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution. October 2016 SIEPR-Bill Lane Center for the American West: State of the West Symposium. December 2016 Karen Dynan, Assistant Secretary for Economic Policy and Chief Economist at the U.S. Department of the Stanford Media Research Forum. December 2016 Treasury. October 2016 SEEPAC Research Workshop: China’s Cap-and-Trade Arthur Brooks, President of the American Enterprise Climate Policy Efforts. January 2017 Institute. November 2016 Conference on Health Care & Competition. January 2017 Esther George, President and CEO of the Federal Reserve Workshop on Micro to Macro Growth: Firms & Workers. Bank of Kansas City. February 2017 February 2017
Sarah Bloom Raskin, Former Deputy Secretary of the U.S. SCID: Stanford-Berkeley Health Economics Workshop. Department of the Treasury. February 2017 February 2017
Maurice Obstfeld, Chief Economist at the International SIEPR Breakfast with John Vickers on the Economics of Monetary Fund and Professor of Economics, UC Berkeley. Brexit. March 2017 April 2017 SIEPR-Hoover Institution Debate: “Has the ‘Neutral’ Edward Lazear, SIEPR Senior Fellow, the Morris A. Cox Interest Rate Declined and How Does It Affect Fed Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution and the Davies Decisions?” May 2017 Family Professor of Economics, Stanford Graduate School of Business. June 2017 SCID: BREAD Conference on Development Economics. May 2017 Conferences, Workshops and Special Events SCID: Development and Political Economics Graduate Student Conference. May 2017 Celebration honoring outgoing SIEPR Deputy Director Greg Rosston. September 2016 SEEPAC Research Workshop: Advances in Estimating Economic Effects from Climate Change Using Weather SIEPR Postdoctoral Fellows Conference. September 2016 Observations. May 2017 Conference on Working Longer and Retirement. SIEPR-GSB Conference in honor of Nobel Prize winner October 2016 Bengt Holmström. May 2017 The Rise of ASEAN and the Future of the U.S.-ASEAN The Empirical Revolution in Economics. June 2017 Strategic Partnership. October 2016 Conference on A Gender Agenda. June 2017 SCID-IGC Conference on Trade, Firms, and Development. November 2016 30th Summer Economic Institute for Teachers. July 2017
18 STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR Gavin Wright with attendees at the Summer Economic Institute for Teachers
Maurice Obstfeld
Igor Popov Sarah Bloom Raskin Rina Rosenberg and Victor Fuchs at the SIEPR Summit
2016–2017 ANNUAL REPORT | EVENTS AND CONFERENCES 19 Policy Briefs
Health Insurance: Choices, Changes, and Policy Challenges What Is Killing the US Coal Industry? Maria Polyakova Charles D. Kolstad September 2016 March 2017
When Affordable Housing Moves in Next Door What History Tells Us about Assimilation of Immigrants Rebecca Diamond Ran Abramitzky October 2016 April 2017
Ten Important Economic Policy Areas for Financing Black-Owned Businesses President-elect Trump Rob Fairlie Gregory Rosston May 2017 November 2016 What Yelp Data Can Tell Us About The Minimum Wage What Higher Interest Rates Could Mean for You (and other policies) Adrien Auclert Michael Luca December 2016 June 2017
Changes to Medicare under the Affordable Care Act Risky Business: Bank Loans to Local Governments Jack Davidson, Jonathan Levin Benji Nguyen, Sylesh Volla, and Annabel Wong January 2017 August 2017
When Businesses Go Bust: Liquidate or Reorganize? Shai Bernstein February 2017 February, 2017 siepr.stanford.edu April, 2017 siepr.stanford.edu
Stanford Institute for Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research Policy Brief Economic Policy Research Policy Brief
When Businesses Go Bust: What History Tells Us about Assimilation
Liquidate or Reorganize? of Immigrants June, 2017 siepr.stanford.edu
By Shai Bernstein By Ran Abramitzky
January, 2017 siepr.stanford.eduDuring the recent financial crisis, assets of the distressed firms. And There are two main approaches Immigration has emerged as a and who do not promise well for Leah Boustan of UCLA, Katherine we saw a surge in the number of that can have an impact on local through which bankruptcy courts March, 2017 siepr.stanford.edu Stanford Institute for decisive—and sharply divisive—issue the standard of civilization in the Eriksson of UC Davis, and I have corporate bankruptcy filings. In 2008, economies as well as individual operate in the U.S.: liquidation Economic Policy Research Policy Brief more than 60,000 cases were filed. businesses. (Chapter 7 of the U.S. Bankruptcy in the United States. Skepticism about United States.” The speaker was not tried to fill part of this gap by Stanford Institute for The number might be staggering, but Code) and reorganization (Chapter whether new arrivals can assimilate Donald Trump on the campaign trail looking at immigration during the If a firm is not the most productive Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research Policy Briefcorporate bankruptcy filings are by no 11). The liquidation procedure into American society was a key but Massachusetts Sen. Henry Cabot Age of Mass Migration from 1850 to user of its assets, shutting it down means confined to recessions. Over winds down the firm and puts Economic Policy Research Policy Brief could even be desirable, as the real concern in the 2016 presidential Lodge in 1891. 1913, when U.S. borders were open the last four decades, an average of all assets back on the market estate, employees, machinery, and election and remains an ongoing and 30 million Europeans picked 50,000 bankruptcy cases were filed by through an auction. In contrast, the The immigration debate raises a What Yelp Data Can Tell Us About The Minimum other resources could be reallocated theme in the public debate on up stakes to move here. By the businesses in a given year. Ultimately, reorganization procedure allows fundamental issue: Are immigrants and put to better use. If an auto parts immigration policy. This controversy early 20th century, some 15 percentWage (and other policies) insolvency and distress of firms are the firm to continue operations and able to successfully integrate into company shuts down and its factory is not new. The U.S. has experienced of the U.S. population was foreign Changes to Medicare under the Affordable Care unavoidableAct consequences of an attempts to rehabilitate the distressed is better used for producing sewing hat s illing the Coal ndustry American society by adopting the By Michael Luca evolving economy. firm’s capital structure and financial repeated waves of hostility toward born, comparable to the share today. By Jack Davidson and Jonathan Levin machines, then reallocating the economic, social, and cultural condition. By ha es D o stad immigrants and today’s concerns If we want to know how today’s The institutions that handle distressed factory to a sewing machine company norms of native-born Americans? Or In April 1992, New Jersey increased restaurants before and after the new achieved relatively high response The Affordable Care Act (ACA) made the microscope again. This Policy these cost changes should incorporatebusinesses play a significant role could boost the productivity and echo alarms sounded often in the newcomers will fare, we can thefind state’s hourly minimum wage wage went into effect to see if it rates. Ultimately, they were able to How do the different approaches 2 are they likely to remain an alien substantial changes to Medicare. Brief reviews the ACA reforms to productivity growth that enables One of the themes of Donald Trump’s protecting streams near coal mines, The statepast. of Both coal today in theand in earlier times, important clues by examining what in the economy. The bankruptcy growth attributed to these assets. affect the allocation of assets of presence inside our borders long from $4.25 to $5.05. The change was had an impact on employment in an complete 410 phone interviews, for a Supporters of the ACA hoped Medicare and how they have played health care providers to use their presidential campaign was bringing in an effort to relieve the coal system attempts to balance a delicate bankrupt firms? At a first glance, the Taking themany long in view this countryof coal inhave the viewed happened to those who arrivedcontroversial, on as some policymakers industry concentrated with minimum response rate of 87 percent. the 2010 law would improve the out over the last seven years. resources more efficiently. This logic holds also at the macro back coal jobs to the Midwest. As industry of “burdensome” regulations. after they settle here? This argument trade-off. It strives to protect firms effects are quite ambiguous. United States,immigrants one is as struck a threat by theto the integrity our shores during the greatestraised surge concerns that higher minimum wage workers. In need of a control efficiency of Medicare by reforming level. Recent papers argue that president, he has doubled down on typically generates more heat than Several months after the minimum Figure 1 illustrates the impactand of entrepreneurs and encourage risk Motivating the political focus on of the nation’s culture, fearing that of immigration in U.S. history. payments and health care delivery economies that reallocate assets Critics of reorganizationthis, promising argue to “lift restrictions on steady expansion of output since light. Many people have opinions wages might have the unintended group where there was no increase in the ACA productivity adjustmenttaking, while making sure creditors coal is a simple pair of facts: Coal wage increase, the interviewers called while also lowering costs. Traditional Medicare more efficiently between firms are that conflicts of interestsAmerican among energy — including shale oil, World Warforeigners II. among us somehow make consequence of increasing the minimum wage, the researchers using CMS Inpatient Hospitalwill data get their money back and will production in the United States has on the subject, but relatively little In our previous work on immigration, the same stores again for a follow-up (Parts A & B) more productive and recover more 1 America less American. Consider the have the confidence to make loans in claimholders and complicatednatural gas and beautiful, clean coal.” empirical evidence is available on my co-authors and I looked atunemployment rates. Business leaders chose the neighboring state of Some of the notable reforms included (2000-2017). So far, the adjustments quickly following adverse economic declined recently after a half century Figure 1 shows U.S. coal production survey. While the majority of stores bargaining processes allow following statement: Immigration also expressed mixed opinions, with Pennsylvania. adjustments to slow the growth of The ACA mandated several broad sets have been relatively small onthe an first place. Many Republicans have blamed of growth, and employment in the since 1949, separating the West how fully and quickly immigrants occupation data of immigrants who picked up the phone, 39 did not, shocks (Eisfeldt and Rampini, 2006; businesses that file for Chapter 11 to of reforms to the traditional fee-for- “is bringing to the country people some worrying that higher minimum Medicare prices, attempts to reduce annual basis, on the order ofBut 0.5 the system plays yet another Hsieh and Klenow, 2009; Bartelsman environmental regulations enacted coal industry has dropped for years. (the region west of the Mississippi assimilate into U.S. culture. arrived during the Age of Mass Flipping through telephone books so the research team drove to all 39 continue operating inefficiently and whom it is very difficult to assimilate expenditures in Medicare Advantage, service (FFS) Medicare program. to 1.0 percent (the 2017 number is during the Obama administration 1 wages might be bad for business. important role — it allocates the et al., 2013). stall the better use of their assets. This Policy Brief explores the River) from the East (the region east Migration. The classic narrative is in the months before the new holdouts and asked them to complete and a range of programs that reward These reforms included an attempt slated at 0.3 percent). However, the for the decline of the country’s coal arguments made to explain those of the Mississippi). The East is the that penniless immigrants workedPrinceton economists David Card wage became effective, the authors the survey in person. This resulted in or penalize health care providers to slow cost growth by changing the adjustments cumulate over time, so Liquidation, those criticsindustry. say, Republicans prevents have pledged declines. And those who are inclined traditional home of U.S. coal whereas low-paying jobs to pull themselvesand Alan Krueger were watching identified 473 stores in New Jersey a 99.8 percent response rate for the based on how they perform relative to formula for Medicare payments, as that as of 2017 payments are 3.45 that complication. Theto bring reasoning back the is industry and its About the Author to place most — or all — of the the West is primarily a post-1970 up by their bootstraps, eventually quality or cost targets. Early evidence well as programs and demonstrations percent lower than they would have that liquidation leadsjobs, to primarilyan auction by neutering those About the Author the discussion unfold, and set out and Pennsylvania to be in their follow-up survey. blame on environmental regulations supplier.3 suggests some success in slowing cost that attempt to shift the structure been with the old unadjusted index. Shai Bernstein is a Faculty Fellow at the Stanford of all assets. And thatregulations. auction One of the first actions reaching equality of skills andto understand exactly how the wage sample. A team of interviewers will learn there are other, likely Ran Abramitzky is a SIEPR Senior Fellow and an Associate The labor-intensive survey yielded growth, but the potential long-term of Medicare payments and the income with natives. We found 1 Institute for Economic Policy Research and an Associate should assure that byall theassets new will Congress be was to cancel Although over the past 60Professor years of Economics at Stanford. He is also a research hike would affect New Jersey jobs. sat down and called each of the impact of far-reaching payment incentives of health care providers. Over time, the policy will cut stronger, influences at work. important results. Despite the large Professor of Finance at the Stanford Graduate School of reallocated to the bestthe updateduser, right? Stream Protection Rule, associate at4 the National Bureau of Economic Research and They made a plan to survey fast food stores, sometimes up to nine times reforms is still hard to assess. meaningfully into prices. A hospital output of coal more than doubled, hike in the minimum wage, the Medicare reimburses providers for Business. His research interests include corporate and Well, Chapter 7 raises a new set of the co-editor of Explorations in Economic History. His before someone answered, and that receives $2,500 for performing a note that 2009 marked the start of a 1 Abramitzky, Ran, Leah Platt Boustan, authors found that employment at These policy changes have been services based on administrative entrepreneurial finance. complications and questions: What 2 The Stream Protection Rule of December research is in economic history and applied microeconomics, and Katherine Eriksson. (2014). “A Nation cardiac catheterization and expects moderate decline in output. Also note asked questions about employment, if there are only few potential users 2016 was an update of an earlier rule, with a focus on immigration and income inequality. of Immigrants: Assimilation and Economic these establishments did not seem overshadowed by the controversy payment schedules. The Centers for this to rise to $3,000 over a decade implemented as part of the 1977 Surface Mining Outcomes in the Age of Mass Migration.”1 Card, David, and Alan B. Krueger. 1994. starting wages, prices, and other for the defunct company’s assets? that the post-World War II boom in “Minimum Wages and Employment: A Case to suffer. Now, 25 years later, the over the ACA’s reforms to the Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) might see that growth cut by $150. Control and Reclamation Act (SMCRA). The Journal of Political Economy. 122(3): 467-506. Congressional Review Act authorizes Congress Study of the Fast-Food Industry in New Jersey store characteristics. With the individual health care market and the update these schedules each year to coal is not uniform over the country. findings are still regularly cited in by vote to cancel regulations less than 6 months and Pennsylvania.” American Economic Review, interviewers’ persistent efforts, they expansion of Medicaid. But with the reflect changes in medical costs. The An open and significant question is old. President Trump signed into law the Virtually all of the gain in output was 84(4): 772-793. discussions of the minimum wage. whether the productivity adjustment 1 Speech by Donald J. Trump to Conservative cancellation of the Stream Protection Rule on new Congress poised to revisit and update reflects changes in the costs in the West, with mining in the East Moreover, the study is still taught will be sustainable. In the short Political Action Conference, February 24, 2017. February 17, 2017. likely repeal parts of the Affordable of providing different services. The peaking in 1990 and declining slowly for its methodological approach of Care Act, Medicare may come under ACA mandated that calculations of run, Medicare has some flexibility ever since. About the Author comparing changes in New Jersey to reduce payment growth. Over with changes in the control state of a longer period, payments need About the Author Michael Luca is a Visiting Scholar at SIEPR and an assistant to be high enough to induce professor at Harvard Business School. His research and Pennsylvania — a canonical example About the Authors Charles D. Kolstad is a Senior Fellow at the Stanford hospitals and physicians to accept teaching focus on the economics of digitization and on of what economists call a difference- Institute for Economic Policy Research and Professor of 3 The West primarily consists of coal deposits Medicare insurance. Ultimately, the using data to improve policy and managerial decisions. Jack Davidson is a Jonathan Levin is the Economics, by courtesy. He is also a Senior Fellow at the from New Mexico and Arizona, as far north in-differences analysis. as Montana and as far east as Texas. The sophomore at Philip H. Knight sustainability of the ACA adjustment Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment and the East primarily consists of coal deposits in In the decades since the Card and Dartmouth College, Professor and Dean will depend on whether health care Stanford Precourt Institute for Energy. He specializes in the Midwest and Appalachia, from Ohio and majoring in of the Stanford productivity gains keep up with environmental economics, particularly regulation and Pennsylvania down to Alabama. Krueger paper, there has been a economics. He was Graduate School of those of the economy at large so climate change. He is past president of the Association of 4 Coal output in both physical and value terms a research assistant Business and a senior that providers remain willing to Environmental and Resource Economists and served as convening lead more than doubled 1949-2011. According to the 20 STANFORD INSTITUTEEIA, the price of coal at the mine was $36.14/ FOR ECONOMIC POLICY RESEARCH | SIEPR at SIEPR during the fellow at SIEPR. participate. author for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (co-recipient of ton in 1949 and $32.56 in 2011, in constant, summer of 2016. the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize). inflation-adjusted 2005$. Income and Expenditures Sources of Income Expenditures September 1, 2016 – August 31, 2017 September 1, 2016 – August 31, 2017 Associates & Friends...... $7,136,349 SIEPR Central...... $7,628,754 Foundations...... $3,856,102 Stanford Center for International Development (SCID)... $4,971,293 Endowment...... $2,790,204 Center for Public & Private Finance (CPPF)...... $1,873,627 Miscellaneous...... $1,861,506 Center for Employment & Economic Government...... $1,099,550 Growth (CEEG)...... $1,007,684 University...... $1,073,030 Centrally Administered Research Projects...... $856,356 Corporations...... $968,973 Stanford Environmental & Energy Policy Analysis $18,785,714 Center (SEEPAC)...... $195,228 $16,532,942 Associates University C F CEE SEE AC S E R Miscellaneous Corporations & Friends SC D 6% C 11% 6% 1% C 10% 5% 38% A 47% 30% Government R 6% 5%