sign in sign up
<<
Home , Positron

arXiv:1404.2022v1 [hep-ph] 8 Apr 2014 ytersnneeet fthe of effects resonance the by rdcino l id fSadr oe S)- (SM) (except Model pair Standard of antifermion kinds all of production etoso h rdcinapa eka olso CM collision at peak a around appear production the of sections ue i h nefrneo the of interference the via duced etio,the , mono-energy Z- etc. a an the as source with of used detected even luminosity be detector, may a accessible neutrinos what and produced with externals, the with or factory neutrinos ex- whether room light answer is the the on to neutrinos of restriction light mixing the the normal e.g. for interesting, of be kinds to three pected produc- the the pro- of characteristics, the tion the so Considering state, momentum energy. final definite and in have anti-fermion body and two fermion of duced is order leading at iiainand nihilation Z † ∗ h ettoseis h rdcinof production the species, two rest the uhaZfcoyi uttepouto via production the in just production neutrino is so Z-factory Z-factory, a a such as called is mass, inat sion tmyb esrdacrtl nuh hnntonly realized, be not may then species neutrino enough, light the accurately of number measured and the be production neutrino may from it contributions the to due is niil it of width invisible and (, svathe via is email:[email protected] email:[email protected] bsnie ttecne aseege around mass center the at i.e. -boson ftepouto ftetreknso omllight normal of kinds three the of production the Of neeto-oirnclie,rniga h ekof peak the at running , -positron An s Z canlanhlto,s ti ral enhanced greatly is it so , -channel bsnpa.I at ic ta at since fact, In peak. -boson Z e ASnmes 32.e 32.t 32.w 44.b 14. 14.40.Lb, 13.25.Hw, 13.25.Ft, 13.20.He, numbers: PACS ν rmrfie esrmnso h niil it of width invisible extern the possible with of The neutrinos measurements light refined tables. of numerical from species as well three as the figures of of terms in presented eeatdffrnilcosscin n h forward-backw the and sections cross differential relevant rdcini -atr)i netgtdtoogl.The thoroughly. investigated is Z-factory) a in production eateto oenPyis nv fSineadtechnolo and Science of Univ. Physics, Modern of Department boson µ h rdcino h he omlnurnsvia neutrinos normal three the of production The W pi and -pair ν Z hoHiChang Chao-Hsi e .INTRODUCTION I. ν bsnms,mroe,teproduction the moreover, mass, -boson ¯ Z nttt ftertclPyis hns cdm fScien of Academy Chinese Physics, theoretical of Institute boson e d bsnmaue at measured -boson arpouto sseil ti pro- is it special: is production pair etioPouto via Production Neutrino s eateto hsc,Dla nvriyo ehooy Da Technology, of University Dalian Physics, of Department canlanhlto steother the as annihilation -channel ν t τ canlecag,atog of although exchange, -channel a c t pi rdcinaepeetdi aiu set.Nml t Namely aspects. various in presented are production -pair qakpi)i anyvia mainly is pair) - eateto hsc,HbiUiest,Boig 071002, Baoding, University, Hebei Physics, of Department CS WrdLbrtr)POBx83,Biig109,Ch 100190, Beijing 8730, Laboratory),P.O.Box (World CCAST τ lpo) oevr fthe if Moreover, -). b Z a,b,c Z tt e aoaoyo hoeia hsc (KLTP), Physics Theoretical of Laboratory Key State bsn ..tecross- the i.e. -boson, ∗ boson a-uFeng Tai-Fu , Z ν fcoyindeed -factory µ Z s ν ¯ canlan- -channel µ fcoythe -factory e − and e Z + -boson b,c,d ν colli- τ ν ¯ τ Z e † , egYoHou Feng-Yao , − e + uto nasuper a pro- neutrino in the of duction measurements (explore) discuss refined will of we meaning and results the based production, fresh will, and neutrino precise we the the col- paper with calculate this in precisely in progress SM, mind, externals on possible in with the detectors and Bearing mixing lider neutrinos improved. light be on for conclusion will left the are so errors room greatly), (the the suppressed accurately be more to measured expected be will boson o h itr ftelgtnurnswt external(s). with neutrinos light new left light the room a the some of If is mixture means there the three but three for than be smaller can being species and species neutrino integer neutrino light an of not number effective the here sotie.Nml h ffcienme flgtneu- light of number effective species: the neutrinos trino light Namely of species obtained. three is are there that conclusion h earlier the oiyaon 10 around nosity ooy sepce ob ul,teivsbewdhof width invisible the built, tech- be present to the expected under is now nology, accessible is that detectors, uigte‘niil it’o the of width’ ‘invisible the suring it ai of invisible ratio of width measurements experimental the via obtained ohi ocmaeteivsbewdhof externals width with invisible mixing the species for compare left to neutrino is room light both the physics[1–4]. the examine of neutrino to number on and the possible topic the determine the absorbing in To whereas an left one(s), is neutri- still light external mixing ‘room’ normal possible the a with of big mixing nos how the for see width may invisible one also but nsuyn h rdcino h he pce fthe of species three the of a in interested production which neutrinos now the are neutrinos, studying we the Thus in of theoretically. specie estimated each are of production from utudralmnst f10 of luminosity a under just ue at sured Z olso at Collision bsni discussed. is -boson h earlier The 40.Nd e − smer t o hs etio are neutrinos these for etc asymmetry ard l haynurllposado stereos) and/or neutral (heavy als e olso at collision + ieecsof differences Z etito ntero o h mixing the for room the on restriction Z fcoyeprmnal ihtecontributions the with experimentally -factory Z fcoy alda ue n,wt lumi- a with one, super a as called -factory, b yo hn,Hfi 306 China 230026, Hefei, China, of gy hn Liu Chang , e,Biig 010 China 100190, Beijing, ces, fcois5 ] eei goigteerrors, the ignoring if Here 6]. -factories[5, N Z Z Z eff ν fcois uha E- n L,run SLC, and LEP-I as such -factories, fcoytertclywt care. with theoretically -factory -boson: 35 Z in 104 China 116024, lian, ∼ = bsnPeak -boson Z Z ν 10 R fcoywt rprdtcosin detectors proper with -factory e ettlcossections, cross total he bsnpa (neutrino peak -boson pi rdcinfrom production -pair inv 0 36 e R China cm n a Pan Zan and inv ( 0 Γ ina Γ ν Z − l l Z ≡ l ¯ ν 1 31 ¯ l s ) − cm Γ SM Γ 1 inv Z Z l Z l ¯ n rprimproved proper and − 2 = oo,tevaluable the boson, 2 5 = s − b . 1 9840 . 943 Z n i mea- via and bsnmea- -boson ± ± 0 0 . . 02is 0082 1 at 016 Z - 2

ν ν ν ν future. e e e e The paper is organized as follows: after INTRODUC- W− TION in section II, we present formulas of the neutrino Z0 production at a Z-factory; in section III we present the numerical results for the neutrino production; the sec- tion IV is to contribute to understanding the results and e− e+ e− e+ discussions. − + FIG. 1: The Feynman diagrams for the process e e νeν¯e → . II. NEUTRINO AT

-FACTORY ν Z ℓ νℓ

The neutrino production at a Z-factory[7, 8]: Z0 − + e e νi ν¯i (i =1, 2, 3) ; → − + where e e

− + ν = V ν , FIG. 2: The for the process e e νlν¯l i ij j → j=e,µ,τ (l = µ, τ). where Vij is the elements of neutrino mixing matrix. The (SM) gives rise to the relevant interac- 1 γ5 1 γ5 tion between Z-boson and leptons: II = D(W )u¯(k)γµ − u(p)¯v(p′)γν − v(k′) , µν 2 2 µ int = gZµJZ , (1) and q = p+p′ = k+k′. Namely now the whole amplitude L − + µ for the process e e νeν¯e is shown where JZ , the so-called ‘weak neutral current’, is → g2 D(Z)(q) 1 γ5 1 1 γ5 µν µ ′ µ µ i = 2 u¯(k)γ − v(k ) JZ = ν¯iγ − νi M 2 2cos θw 2 2cos θw 2 i=e,µ,τ X 1 γ5  5 ′ ν 2 µ 1 2 γ v¯(p )γ + 2 sin θw + u(p) +ψ¯iγ ( + 2 sin θw + )ψi . −2 2 −2 2   1 γ5 1 γ5  ± (W ) ′ µ ′ ν ′ Here another relevant interaction is that between W Dµν (q )¯u(k)γ − u(p)¯v(p )γ − v(k ) . − 2 2 and leptons: ! Here to do the calculation, we take the unitary gauge for = g(W +J µ + W −J µ†) (2) Lint µ W µ W weak , so the for Z-boson: µ 2 where JW , the charged weak current, is (Z) i( ηµν + qµqν /mZ ) Dµν (q)= −2 2 , q m + iΓZ mZ 1 1 γ5 − Z J µ = ν¯ γµ − ψ . W √ i 2 i and that for W -boson: 2 i=e,µ,τ X 2 (W ) i( ηµν + qµqν /mW ) Dµν (q)= 2− 2 . At the tree level, there are two relevant Feynman dia- q m + iΓW mW − + W grams for the process e e νeν¯e, which are shown in − − →+ Here Γ , m and Γ , m appearing in the denom- Fig.1. For the processes, e e νlν¯l (l = µ, τ), there is Z Z W W one Feynman diagram only which→ is shown in Fig.2. It is inators are the total widths, masses of Z and W bo- straightforward to write down the amplitudes according son respectively. Whereas the amplitude for the process − + e e νlν¯l (l = µ, τ) is shown to the diagram(s). We have → 2 (Z) 5 i2g2 g Dµν (q) µ 1 γ ′ i = (I + II) i = 2 u¯(k)γ − v(k ) M 2! M 2 2cos θw 2 5 ′ ν 1 2 γ where v¯(p )γ + 2 sin θw + u(p). −2 2 (Z) 5   Dµν (q) µ 1 γ ′ Hence the differential cross-sections for unpolarized in- I= 2 u¯(k)γ − v(k ) −2cos θw 2 coming beams are related to the amplitudes via 5 ′ µ 1 2 γ v¯(p )γ + 2 sin θw + u(p); 1 2 · −2 2 dσ = dΠ ,   2E12E2 v1 v2 spins|M| | − |X 3

− + i.e. in C.M. system for the process e e νeν¯e it is 4 → 2 4 θ dσ α s cos 2 3 = 2 4 2 θ 2 2 2 ) [nb] dΩ 16sin θw s sin + m +Γ m ℓ " 2 W W W ν ℓ 1 ν 2  → (2 ) +

2 e

− − cos θw − 2 θ θ (e 1 2 2 4 σ ΓZ mZ ΓW mW (s m ) s sin + m cos − − Z 2 W 2 2 ·[(s m2 )2 +Γ2 m2 ] s sin2 θ + m2 +Γ2 m2 − Z Z Z · 2 W W W 0 4 4 θ 2 θ 86 88 90 92 94 96 h 1  2 4 i E [GeV] 1 sin θw sin 2 + ( 2 sin θw) cos 2 cm + 4 2 2 − 2 2 ; (3) cos θw (s mZ ) +ΓZ mZ # − FIG. 3: The dependence of the total unpolarized cross- − + sections on the C.M.S. energies: the dished curve is those for the process e e νlν¯l (l = µ, τ) it is − + → of the processes e e νlν¯l (l = µ,τ) and the solid curve is →− + 2 4 4 θ 1 2 2 4 θ that of the processes e e νeν¯e. dσ α s sin θw sin + ( sin θw) cos → = 2 2 − 2 , (4) dΩ sin4 2θ (s m2 )2 +Γ2 m2 w − Z Z Z where unpolarized cross-sections vs C.M.S. energies √s are col- lected in TABLE I, and the curves of the cross-sections e e2 g = , α = are plotted in FIG.3. In order to see the the difference sin θw 4π − + between the production of e e νeν¯e and that of − + → e e νlν¯l (l = µ , τ), we also plot ∆σ, the differ- are adopted. Moreover, from Eq.(3) one may see that the → contributions to the cross-section from t-channel of W - ence in total cross-sections, vs √s in FIG.4. From scattering and s-channel of Z-annihilation are destruc- tive. 0.2 The total cross-sections can be calculated by integrat- ing the relevant differential ones respectively. 0.1 To calculate out the cross-sections numerically, we

take the parameters, which appear in the formula, from [nb]

σ 0

PDG[6]: ∆

mZ = 91.1876 GeV , ΓZ =2.4952 GeV , −0.1 mW = 80.385 GeV , ΓW =2.085 GeV , 2 sin θW =0.23116 ( or 0.2231) , α =1/127.944 , 86 88 90 92 94 96 Ecm[GeV] mνe mνe mνe 0.0 eV , (5) ≃ ≃ ≃ FIG. 4: The difference ∆σ in the total cross sections between i.e. the values of the parameters are taken to be renor- − + − + those of e e νeν¯e and e e νlν¯l (l = µ, τ). Here → → ∆σ = 0.0 is located at√s 91.163GeV (mZ ). ≃ TABLE I: Total unpolarized cross sections vs the c.m. energy 2 √s, where σ1 denotes the results with sin θW = 0.2312, while 2 the table TABLE I and the figures FIG.3, FIG. 4 we σ2 denotes those with sin θW = 0.2231. νl denotes νµ and may see that i). The difference caused by a different ντ . 2 value of sin θW is remarkable; ii). The differences be- − + √s [GeV] 89 90 91 92 93 94 tween the total cross-sections for process e e νeν¯e − + → and for processes e e νlν¯l, l = µ , τ are tiny at the Z- σ1(ν ν¯ ) [nb] 0.8101 1.8814 3.8314 3.0146 1.4988 0.8305 e e pole, but become sizable→ when C.M. energy √s is away σ1(νlν¯l) [nb] 0.9477 2.0470 3.8769 2.8379 1.3134 0.6779 from the Z-pole. The differences are the consequences σ2(νeν¯e) [nb] 0.8514 1.9834 4.0500 3.1943 1.5916 0.8836

σ2(νlν¯l) [nb] 1.0023 2.1648 4.1001 3.0013 1.3890 0.7170

paratively better results we take the values renormalized at Z- malization at Z pole1. Precisely the values of the total pole for the parameters, but to see uncertainties and for com- parison, when doing the calculation of the total cross-sections 2 2 we take a different value of sin θW , i.e. sin θW = 0.23116 and 2 sin θW = 0.2231 in different schemes in cases. Whereas in the rest calculations of the paper without declara- 1 2 Here we do the calculation only at tree level, thus to have com- tion, we will take sin θW = 0.23116 only. 4

C.M. energy √s = Ecm around Z-boson mass mZ in FIG.6. It is interesting that owing to the interference 3 of Z-annihilation and W -exchange the forward-backward ) [nb]

ℓ − +

ν asymmetry AF B of the production e e νeν¯e changes ℓ ν sign from minus to plus as the collision energy→ increasing,

→ − +

+ but that of the production e e νeν¯e keeps constant e 2 − (see FIG.6). → )(e θ

/dcos III. CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSIONS

σ 1 (d

−1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 The differential cross-sections for the neutrino pair pro- − + − + − + cosθ duction: e e νeν¯e, e e νµν¯µ and e e ντ ν¯τ around the CM→ energy region→ of Z-boson mass→ (at a Z-factory) are studied thoroughly. Since there are two FIG. 5: The differential cross-sections for the production Feynman diagrams: t-channel exchange and s-channel − + e e νlν¯l. The solid curve denotes all the production annihilation contributing to the first process (FIG.1), but → at √s = mZ . The upper and lower dashed curves denote there is only one Feynman diagram, s-channel annihila- the production for l = e at √s = mZ 0.5ΓZ respectively. tion contributing to the second and third ones (FIG.2), The upper and lower dot-dashed curves± denote the produc- − + − + thus we have paid more attention on the differences tion for e e νµν¯µ or e e ντ ν¯τ at √s = mZ 0.5ΓZ among the processes. Since the processes being con- respectively. → → ± cerned around √S mZ , the t-channel exchange dia- gram’s contribution≃ is much smaller than that from the s-channel annihilation. The differences between the pro- of the interference of Z-annihilation and W -exchange for duction e−e+ ν ν¯ and e−e+ ν ν¯ or e−e+ ν ν¯ e−e+ ν ν¯ (see FIG.1) and there is Z-annihilation only e e µ µ τ τ e e are tiny at Z-boson→ peak, but become→ visible when→ off for e−→e+ ν ν¯ , l = µ , τ (see FIG.2); iii). The inter- l l the peak (FIGs.3-5 and TABLE.I). Namely the shape ference of→ the Z-annihilation and the W -exchange in the − + of the Z-boson resonance for the production process process e e νeν¯e) is ‘constructive’ when √s mZ , − + → ≥ e e νeν¯e around the Z-boson peak is distorted by but it is ‘destructive’ when √s mZ (FIG.4). To see → ≤ the two diagram interference in certain degree. There- fore we think that the facts described here should be treated very carefully, especially when someone consid- ers the room left for the mixing of the three light neutri- 0.2 )

ℓ nos with heavy neutral leptons and/or stereos via taking ν ℓ

ν the invisible width of Z-boson into account. Precisely we →

+ mean that if one would like to obtain the effective num- e − 0 ν (e ber Neff of the light neutrino species and to suppress the FB

A relevant errors, the way to obtain it via the data of the earlier Z-factories[5, 6] below: − 0.2 Z Γ ¯ 86 88 90 92 94 96 ν 0 ll Neff = Rinv( )SM =2.9840 0.0082 , Ecm[GeV] Z Γνlν¯l ±

− + FIG. 6: The forward-backward asymmetry AF B for e e → ΓZ νlν¯l as a function of √s. The solid curve presents that of the 0 inv − + Rinv Z =5.943 0.016 production of e e νeν¯e, and the dashed curve presents ≡ Γ ¯ ± → − + − + ll that of the production of e e νµν¯µ or e e ντ ν¯τ . → → should be added the distortion effects being affected care- the characters of the production, we have also calculated fully. the differential cross-sections at three C.M. energies for Since the neutrino-antineutrino pair production by − + electron-positron annihilation at Z-boson resonance is of the processes e e νlν¯l, l = e,µ,τ numerically in C.M.S., and plot them→ vs the angle θ between the direc- a two-to-two body process and with resonance enhance- tions of the electron beam and the produced neutrinos ment, so the produced neutrino and antineutrino at a Z- in FIG.5. From the figure one may see that the differen- factory are productive and of mono-energy. Moreover Z- tial cross-sections are clearly asymmetric in forward and boson mass is quite heavy mZ 91.2GeV, so roughly the ≃ mZ energy of the produced neutrino Eν = 45.6GeV backward. They are favoured in forward direction and 2 ≃ have a minimum at θ π/2. To highlight the asym- (tens GeV order). Thus the produced neutrinos with the ≈ (R1>cosθ>0 − R0>cosθ>−1)dσ character: a quite high energy and mono-energy, seems metry, we plot AF B dσ vs the ≡ R1>cosθ>−1 may find some special usages in principle. 5

Based on the estimates of the production cross-sections detector2. But considering the possible progress in tech- in this paper (TABLE.I) and the differential cross- nology on Z-factory and the detectors, one may dream sections (FIG.5) quantitatively, one may realize that in- to apply the mono-energy neutrinos produced at a Z- deed the cross-section is greater in the forward direction factory to doing experiments on neutrino physics one day than those in the other directions, thus if the produced in future. neutrinos are considered as beams in directions then the Acknowledgement The author (C.-H. Chang) beam intensity in forward direction is biggest. Namely, would like to thank Prof. Zuo-Xiu He for valuable dis- considering the cross-sections of neutrino with cussions on the subject. The work is supported by the are very tiny, if one would like to detect the produced National Natural Science Foundation of China (NNSFC) neutrinos directly and successfully, then the most hopeful with Grant No. 11275243, No. 11147001, No. 11275036, way is to put the detector at the forward direction. More- No. 11047002, No. 11205227; the open project of State over, the production cross-sections at a Z-factory are in Key Laboratory of Theoretical Physics with Grant No. the order of a few nb as shown in TABLE.I and FIG.5, Y3KF311CJ1; the Natural Science Foundation of Hebei therefore only when the luminosity of the Z-factory is province with Grant No. A2013201277; and Natural higher than 1036 cm−2s−1, so that the flux of the pro- Science Foundation of Hebei University with Grant No. duced neutrinos may be great enough for an accessible 2011JQ05, No. 2012-242.1 2 The cross-sections of the energetic neutrinos (several tens GeV in of the Z-factory is so high as pointed here, i.e., the intensity of energy) colliding with common are so small in the magni- the produced neutrinos reaches to the ability of the accessible −36 −37 2 tude order of 10 ∼ 10 cm , so even with a huge detector, detector to detect them. e.g. a detector with 10km long (thickness), the neutrinos pro- duced at a Z-factory can be detected only when the luminosity

[1] A.Y. Smirnov, Theory of neutrino masses and mixing, and LEP Electroweak Working Group, and SLD Elec- arXiv:1402.6580. troweak Group, and SLD Heavy Flavour Group, Precision [2] Chao-Hsi Chang, Tai-Fu Feng, Yu-Li Yan, Hai-Bin Zhang, Electroweak Measurements on the Z Resonance, Phys. Re- Shu-Min Zhao, Spontaneous R-parity violation in the min- ports 427, 257 (2006). imal gauged (B L) with a 125 GeV Higgs, [6] J. Beringer et al. ( Data Group), Review of Parti- arXiv: 1401.4586[hep-ph].− cle Physics, Phys. Rev. D 86, 010001 (2012), [3] M.C. Gonzalez-Garcia, Y. Nir, Neutrino Masses and Mix- [7] V.A.Novikov, L.B.Okun, Theory of Z boson decays, Rept. ing: Evidence and Implications, Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 345 Prog. Phys. 62, 1275 (2009). (2003). [8] M.E. Peskin, D.V. Schroeder, An Introduction to Quan- [4] R.D. McKeown, P. Vogel, Neutrino Masses and Oscilla- tum Field Theory, Addison-Wesley (1995); R. D. McKe- tions: Triumphs and Challenges, Phys. Report 394, 315 own and P. Vogel. Phys. Report, 394, 315 (2004). (2004). [5] ALEPH, DELPHY, L3, OPAL, and SLD Colliborations,