Small RNA and Transcriptional Upregulation Victoria Portnoy, Vera Huang, Robert F
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Advanced Review Small RNA and transcriptional upregulation Victoria Portnoy, Vera Huang, Robert F. Place and Long-Cheng Li∗ Small RNA molecules, such as microRNA and small interfering RNA, have emerged as master regulators of gene expression through their ability to suppress target genes in a phenomenon collectively called RNA interference (RNAi). There is growing evidence that small RNAs can also serve as activators of gene expression by targeting gene regulatory sequences. This novel mechanism, known as RNA activation (RNAa), appears to be conserved in at least mammalian cells and trig- gered by both endogenous and artificially designed small RNAs. RNAa depends on Argonaute proteins, but possesses kinetics distinct from that of RNAi. Epigenetic changes are associated with RNAa and may contribute to transcriptional activation of target genes, but the underlying mechanism remains elusive. Given the potential of RNAa as a molecular tool for studying gene function and as a therapeutic for dis- ease, further research is needed to completely elucidate its molecular mechanism in order to refine the rules for target selection and improve strategies for exploiting it therapeutically. 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. WIREs RNA 2011 DOI: 10.1002/wrna.90 INTRODUCTION positively, thereby composing the ‘yin and yang’ of the RNA-mediated gene-regulation network. he quest to manipulate gene expression at Recently, several classes of small RNA have been Twill has been a fascinating pursuit since shown to upregulate gene expression at the transcrip- the establishment of the central dogma of gene tional and/or epigenetic level.7–11 To describe such expression. The discovery of posttranscriptional RNA phenomena, the term RNAa (RNA activation) has interference (RNAi) has partially fulfilled this goal— been coined to distinguish it from RNAi.7 In this that is the ability to suppress the expression of any review, we discuss (1) the observations made so far gene using small double-stranded RNAs (dsRNAs). 1,2 on RNAa; (2) our current understanding of its mech- Since the initial discovery of RNAi, several other anism of action; and (3) its potential application both related mechanisms of gene silencing have been as a tool to study gene function and as a therapy for identified that occur at the levels of chromatin, disease. We also speculate on the possibility of RNAa DNA, transcription, mRNA, and translation, each 3–6 being mediated by endogenous small noncoding RNA triggered by small RNA. It has been proposed (ncRNA). that RNAi is an evolutionarily conserved defense mechanism to suppress foreign sequences (i.e., viral infection); however, such examples are rare in higher SMALL dsRNA-MEDIATED eukaryotes despite the presence of intact RNAi TRANSCRIPTIONAL ACTIVATION machinery. Therefore, it is now believed, instead, that (RNAa) evolution has adapted this innate defense mechanism as a means to regulate gene expression. In this The discovery of RNAa came as a surprise. In early regard, it is reasonable to suggest that RNA-mediated 2004, our group was interested in how aberrant DNA gene regulation may have evolved the capability methylation of promoter sequences was regulated in to regulate target sequences both negatively and cancer cells. It was speculated that ncRNA could induce sequence-specific DNA methylation, a phe- ∗Correspondence to: [email protected] nomenon that had been known to occur in plants 12 Department of Urology and Helen-Diller Comprehensive Cancer for over 10 years. At the time, our laboratory was Center, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, investigating epigenetic mechanisms of gene silencing, USA including DNA hypermethylation in gene promot- DOI: 10.1002/wrna.90 ers. One particular gene of interest was E-cadherin, a 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Advanced Review wires.wiley.com/rna tumor suppressor gene silenced in several types of can- Definition, Observations, and Features cers. The E-cadherin promoter contains a typical CpG of RNAa island surrounding the transcription start site that, 13,14 Definition upon methylation, silences E-cadherin expression. The term RNAa was originally used to describe We sought to examine whether DNA methylation gene activation at the transcriptional level mediated could be induced at the E-cadherin promoter by expos- by small dsRNA designed to target gene promoter ing cells to synthetic small dsRNAs, the known trigger sequences.7 These dsRNAs, termed ‘small activating for RNAi. By implementing rational small interfering RNAs’ (saRNAs) to distinguish them from siRNAs, RNA (siRNA) design rules15 against the E-cadherin exert an effect opposite to that of RNAi. Similar to promoter sequence, two high-scoring targets at sites just outside the CpG island were selected for testing. the term RNAi, whose definition has been expanded When dsRNA for either target was transfected into the to describe both transcriptional and posttranscrip- prostate cancer PC-3 cell line, surprisingly, E-cadherin tional gene silencing mechanisms, RNAa may also expression was robustly upregulated instead of being be used to describe other related mechanisms by downregulated.7 This sparked subsequent identifica- which small RNAs positively regulate gene expres- tion of additional examples of RNAa [e.g., p21 and sion and the epigenome, including transcriptional vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) genes]7 activation via targeting the 3 flanking regions of (Table 1). Shortly thereafter, another group reported genes with small dsRNAs,26 piwi-interacting RNA activation of the progesterone receptor (PR) and major (piRNA)-mediated epigenetic activation,27 microRNA vault protein (MVP) genes by dsRNA,8 implying that (miRNA)-mediated translational activation,28,29 and the phenomenon could be a general mechanism of additional gene activation mechanisms yet to be gene regulation. discovered. TABLE 1 RNA activation examples Gene Symbol (alias) Full Name Species Target Location Trigger RNA References Ccnb1 Cyclin B1 Mouse Promoter saRNA/agRNA 11 CDH1 (E-cadherin) Cadherin 1, type 1, Human and nonhuman Promoter saRNA/agRNA 7, 9, 11, 16–18 E-cadherin (epithelial) primates and miRNA CDKN1A (p21) Cyclin-dependent kinase Human and nonhuman Promoter saRNA/agRNA 7, 11, 19–22 inhibitor 1A primates CSDC2 Cold shock Human Promoter miRNA 9 domain-containing protein C2 CXCR4 Chemokine (C–X–C motif) Rat Promoter saRNA/agRNA 11 receptor 4 KLF4 Kruppel-like ¨ factor 4 Human Promoter saRNA/agRNA 23 LDLR Low-density lipoprotein Human Promoter saRNA/agRNA 24 receptor MVP Major vault protein Human Promoter saRNA/agRNA 8 NKX3-1 NK3 homeobox 1 Nonhuman primates Promoter saRNA/agRNA 11 PAWR (PAR4) PRKC, apoptosis, WT1, Nonhuman primates Promoter saRNA/agRNA 11 regulator PGR (PR) Progesterone receptor Human Promoter and saRNA/agRNA 8, 25 3 terminus TP53 (p53) Tumor protein 53 Nonhuman primates Promoter saRNA/agRNA 11 VEGFA (VEGF) Vascular endothelial growth Human and nonhuman Promoter saRNA/agRNA 7, 11 factor A primates Vegfa (Vegf) Vascular endothelial growth Mouse Promoter shRNA 10 factor A WT1 Wilms tumor 1 Nonhuman primates Promoter saRNA/agRNA 11 agRNA, antigene RNA; miRNA, microRNA; saRNA, small activating RNA. 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. WIREs RNA Small RNA and transcriptional upregulation Promoter-Targeting RNAa For example, in a side-by-side comparison, p21 activa- In our initial studies, by testing six genes and designing tion by saRNA did not emerge until ∼48 h following one or two saRNA targets on the promoter of each saRNA transfection, while knockdown of two genes gene, three of the tested genes (E-cadherin, p21, and [male absent on the first (MOF) or E2F1] by siRNA VEGF) were activated by their respective saRNAs.7 was detectable as early as 6 h.32 Perhaps, the delay These saRNAs have a target size of 19 nt with 3 in RNAa activity reflects a more complex mechanism dTdT overhangs—an identical structure to standard with additional rate-limiting steps. Because RNAa is a siRNAs. They targeted locations on gene promoters nuclear process acting on gene transcription, acquiring ranging from −200 to −700 relative to the transcrip- access to the nucleus may be one of the rate-limiting tion start site. Soon after, the Corey group reported steps. Changes in chromatin structure associated with that synthetic dsRNAs, termed antigene RNAs (agR- RNAa may also contribute to the delayed kinetics. NAs) to distinguish them from siRNAs that target Another peculiar feature of RNAa is its pro- mRNA, targeting the promoter regions of PR and longed effect. After a single saRNA transfection, gene MVP activated the expression of their respective target activation can last for nearly 2 weeks in certain cell genes. These agRNAs also have a target size of 19 nt lines.7,32 The duration of PR gene activation demon- but they target sequences located on or near the tran- strated by the Corey group8 and of E-cadherin and scription start site, ranging from −56 to −2. Interest- p21 induction observed by our group7,32 is remarkably ingly, in the example of the PR gene, the agRNA PR11, similar, suggesting prolonged activation is a general which targets sequence −11/+8, robustly induced PR feature of RNAa. It is reasonable to speculate that gene expression in the MCF7 breast cancer cell line, such long-lasting gene activation is due to epigenetic but suppressed PR expression in the T47D cell line changes, which may persist well beyond the life of which has higher basal expression of PR compared saRNA molecules. In support, several types of epige- to MCF7 cells.8 In these studies, RNAa was observed netic changes have been associated with RNAa (see when the saRNA/agRNA was introduced into the cells the section Transcriptional Activation is Associated at concentrations ranging from 5 to 50 nM.7,8 Since with Epigenetic Changes). these initial reports, additional examples of promoter- targeting RNAa have been identified (Table 1). Complementarity Requirement of Guide-Target Sequences for RNAa Nonpromoter-Targeting RNAa Classic RNAi mediated by siRNA requires perfect Targeting genomic regions outside promoter complementarity between the siRNA and its cognate sequences may also affect gene transcription both mRNA sequence.