UC Irvine Electronic Theses and Dissertations
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UC Irvine UC Irvine Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Consuming Narratives: Food and Cannibalism in Early Modern British Imperialism Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4ws0p8n5 Author Wankier, Alisa Marie Publication Date 2016 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE Consuming Narratives: Food and Cannibalism in Early Modern British Imperialism DISSERTATION submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in History by Alisa Marie Wankier Dissertation Committee: Associate Professor Sharon Block, Chair Professor Sharon Salinger Professor Alice Fahs 2016 © 2016 Alisa Marie Wankier DEDICATION To my family and friends in recognition of their continued support ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS iii CURRICULUM VITAE iv ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION vi INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER 1: First Impressions: Foodways in Early Modern Narratives of America 15 CHAPTER 2: Changing Impressions: Foodways in Early Modern Narratives of Africa 42 CHAPTER 3: Complicating Impressions: Foodways in Early Modern Narratives of Asia 71 CHAPTER 4: Conflicting Impressions: English Cannibalism in Jamestown & Newfoundland 99 CONCLUSION 141 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY 145 iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am grateful to my advisor and committee chair, Sharon Block, for her expert guidance, understanding, and encouragement throughout my time at the University of California, Irvine. I am also appreciative of my other committee members: Sharon Salinger, for her continued investment in me, and Alice Fahs, for her positivity. I am sincerely thankful to all three committee members for providing me with flexibility during the process of writing my dissertation. I would also like to thank my parents and my sister for their unwavering moral, emotional, and financial support. Without their continuous love and encouragement, this dissertation would not have been possible. iv CURRICULUM VITAE Alisa Wankier Education University of California, Irvine Doctorate of Philosophy in History (2016) Dissertation: “Consuming Narratives: Food and Cannibalism in Early Modern British Imperialism” Committee: Sharon Block (Advisor), Sharon Salinger, Alice Fahs San Diego State University Master of Arts in History (2009) Bachelor of Arts in History (2007) Honors & Awards PhD Qualifying Exams, Passed with Distinction (2013) Regent’s Fellowship, University of California, Irvine (2010) Stott Memorial Scholarship, San Diego State University (2009) Teaching Instructor, Composition, English Department, University of California, Irvine Writing 39c: Argument and Research (academic year 2015-2016) Writing 39c: Argument and Research (academic year 2014-2015) Writing 39c: Argument and Research (academic year 2013-2014) Instructor, History Department, University of California, Irvine History 40a: Early America (Summer 2015) History 40a: Early America (Summer 2014) Online Instructor, Composition, English Department, University of California, Irvine Writing 39c: Argument and Research (Summer 2015) Writing 39c: Argument and Research (Summer 2014) Teaching Assistant, History Department, University of California, Irvine History 142b: FDR to Obama (Fall 2012) German 150: German Fairytales (Spring 2012) History 110a: Europe in the Early Middle Ages (Winter 2012) History 40a: Early America (Fall 2011) Professional Development Santa Ana College Intern, California Community College Internship Program (2014-2015) University of California, Irvine English 398: Rhetoric and Teaching of Composition (Fall Quarter 2013) v Professional Service Graduate Student Representative Academic Personnel Review Committee, Department of History, UCI (2013) Graduate Student Representative SDSU History Department Search Committee in Ancient Greco-Roman History (2007) Academic Employment Research Assistant, Robert Love's Warnings: Searching for Strangers in Colonial Boston (2013) Professor Sharon Salinger, University of California, Irvine Professor Cornelia H. Dayton, University of Connecticut Research Assistant, The Early English Caribbean, 1570-1700 (2011-2012) Professor Sharon Salinger, University of California, Irvine Professor Carla Gardina Pestana, University of California, Los Angeles Research Assistant, Major Problems in American Women’s History Textbook (2011) Professor Sharon Block, University of California, Irvine vi ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Consuming Narratives: Food and Cannibalism in Early Modern British Imperialism By Alisa Marie Wankier Doctor of Philosophy in History University of California, Irvine, 2016 Associate Professor Sharon Block, Chair During the early modern period, a time of global exploration, Europeans often included descriptions of foodways in their exploration narratives. Indeed, one of the most striking features of early modern travel narratives is the amount of space devoted to foodstuff and eating patterns, and “Consuming Narratives” argues that Europeans, and specifically the English, focused on food because they understood foreign people and places, themselves, and their world through a discourse of foodways. If an Englishman noted a foreigner eating a specific dish, he might infer the temperament of the foreigner by means of the humoral theory; deduce the wealth or status of the foreigner by the perceived cost of the food; or conclude the civility of the foreigner by his manner of eating or by the way the meal was prepared. Beyond the descriptions of customary foodways, stories of foreign peoples eating human flesh proved to be a recurring theme in which Europeans presented themselves as superior, while recordings of English cannibalism at Jamestown and Newfoundland reflected English anxiety about their position in the global world. Thus, descriptions of foodways reveal more than mere victuals. Food and eating provided a vii language to express, and simultaneously shape, English assumptions and anxieties about otherness, status, sovereignty, and power. viii INTRODUCTION In William Shakespeare’s Taming of the Shrew, Petruchio, the male lead, attempts to tame his unruly wife, Katherina; and as part of his efforts, Petruchio refuses to allow Katherina to eat overcooked meat for fear that the dish will make her “choleric.” Petruchio first scolds the servants for serving the burnt meat, and then turns to Katherina and says “I tell thee, Kate, ’twas burnt and dried away. And I expressly am forbid to touch it, For it engenders choler, planteth anger; And better ’twere that both of us did fast” (4.1.106-109). Petruchio’s logic – that burnt meat would lead to choler – came from the humoral theory, a popular early-modern European notion in which the human body was composed of four humors (blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm), with each humor associated with a temperament (sanguine, choleric, melancholic, and phlegmatic), and with food having the ability to affect one’s humoral balance, and consequently one’s disposition and overall health. Following the humoral theory, the overcooked and dry meat could increase one’s yellow bile – the “warm and dry” humor associated with choler, anger, aggression, impulsiveness, and ambition. Thus, Petruchio forbad Katherina from consuming a choleric food in an attempt to control her temperament and keep her from being irritable. With the Taming of the Shrew, we see that in the sixteenth-century English mind, food held much meaning; food was not simply a commodity or a matter of survival, food could be an indicator one’s disposition, temperament, or character, regardless of whether or not the consumer intended that meaning. During the early modern period, a time of global exploration, Europeans often included descriptions of foodways in their exploration narratives. Indeed, one of the most striking features of early modern travel narratives is the amount of space devoted to 1 foodstuff and eating patterns, and “Consuming Narratives” argues that Europeans, and specifically the English, focused on food because they understood foreign people and places, themselves, and their world through a discourse of foodways. If an Englishman noted a foreigner eating a specific dish, he might infer the temperament of the foreigner by means of the humoral theory; deduce the wealth or status of the foreigner by the perceived cost of the food; or conclude the civility of the foreigner by his manner of eating or by the way the meal was prepared. Beyond the descriptions of customary foodways, stories of foreign peoples eating human flesh proved to be a recurring theme in which Europeans presented themselves as superior, while recordings of English cannibalism at Jamestown and Newfoundland reflected English anxiety about their position in the global world. Thus, descriptions of foodways reveal more than mere victuals. Food and eating provided a language to express, and simultaneously shape, English assumptions and anxieties about otherness, status, sovereignty, and power. In other words, ideas about foodways influenced English imperialism. “Consuming Narratives” centers on European explorations narratives available in English in the sixteenth and early seventeenth century, and analyzes the ways in which discussions of foodways informed English ideas about America, Africa, Asia, and themselves. In reviewing these sources, I am not concerned with the veracity of the depicted events; instead, I am interested in the circumstances under which food and eating were described in the texts, what the authors may have sought to convey,