SEMMMS'road'should'not'be'commissioned!
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
" " Follow%on'report'by'the'North'West' " Transport'Roundtable'and'the' Campaign'for'Better'Transport'to'the' critiques'commissioned'by'them'in' their'January'2013"‘contrary'case’' document':'‘A"folly"in"the"making’" '''''July'2013' June More'reasons'why'the'A6%Manchester'Airport'' SEMMMS'Road'should'not'be'commissioned! The only SEMMMS measures that local authorities have so far progressed are road building ones. The'SEMMMS'rail'recommendations'that' ought'to'be'delivered'first'–'before'plans' for'road'building'are'progressed'further:''' improve'the'frequency'of'radial'services' into'Manchester,'station'environments,' car'parking'at'stations'and'rolling'stock'..' bring'about'an'‘urban'metro’'system'..' introduce'tram%trains'&'smart'ticketing'..' re%open'Cheadle'and'Baguley'stations''''0" " 6/1/2013' " More'reasons'why'the'SEMMMS'A6%Manchester'Airport'Relief' Road'should'not'be'commissioned' ' CONTENTS' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ''''''''Page' Introduction' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '3' Endorsements' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '4' SEMMMS'final'report'' The'recommendations' ' ' ' ' ' ' '''5''%''11' An'examination'of'the'progress'of'the'recommendations' ''12'%''20' Summary'situation' ' ' ' ' ' ' ''''''''''21' Organisational/'policy'changes'that'influenced'–'or'failed'to'influence'–' the'multi%modal'studies'and'national'studies/'policy'directions/'' legal'obligations'since'the'2001'SEMMMS'final'report' ' '''22'–'34' ' Recently'delivered'or'committed'schemes' ' Sub'national'rail'initiatives' ' ' ' ' ' '''35'%''37' ' Metrolink' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ''''''''''''38' Trunk'road'initiatives' ' ' ' ' ' ' ''''38'%'39' Conclusions'drawn'from'the'preceding'analysis:'' ' ' ' ''''''''''''40' Commentary'&'conclusions'by'transport'consultant'Keith'Buchan' ''''41'%'47' Another'plea'to'government'&'promoting'local'authorities' ' ' '48' ' ' Thanks'are'due'to'David'Butler,'Janet'Cuff,'Tony'Fawthrop,'Andrew'MacFarlane'and'Keith' Pennyfather'for'their'contributions'to'this'report.'' 2" NW"TAR"&"CfBT:""More"reasons"why"the"SEMMMS"A6<Manchester"Airport"Relief"Road"should"not"be"commissioned" More'reasons'why'the'SEMMMS'A6%Manchester'Airport'Relief' Road'should'not'be'commissioned' ' INTRODUCTION' As"their"response"to"the"first"full"public"consultation"on"the"SEMMMS"A6<Manchester"Airport" Relief"Road,"the"North"West"Transport"Roundtable"(NW"TAR)"and"the"Campaign"for"Better" Transport"(CfBT)"produced"a"‘Contrary"Case’"report"which"was"a"series"of"independent" critiques"about"the"supporting"evidence"that"was"in"the"public"domain"at"that"stage"including" the"business"case.""The"critiques"were"written"by"professionals"in"the"relevant"fields.""They" raised"many"pertinent"and"worrying"issues.""The"report,"entitled:""‘A"folly"in"the"making"–" SEMMMS"A65Manchester"Airport"Relief"Road’,"is"available"to"download"from"the"NW"TAR" website:""www.nwtar.org.uk"(‘consultations’"page)"where"it"is"listed"under"‘January"2013’." " Since"then"some"of"the"report’s"authors"have"met"with"some"key"SEMMMS"team"members" who"confirmed"that"their"case"for"road"building"was"predicated"to"a"large"extent"on"the" SEMMMS"findings"that"were"published"in"2001.""They"relied"on"traffic"models"that"predicted" high"traffic"growth"that"has"not"materialised"and"evidence"from"the"1990s.""At"that"meeting," the"environmental"NGOs"present"stressed"how"much"had"happened"and"changed"since"the" final"SEMMMS"report"was"published"and"the"measures"which"ought"to"be"adopted"before" road"building"is"even"considered.""We"were"asked"to"catalogue"what"we"were"referring"to."" This"is"what"we"have"done"in"this"submission,"whilst"assembling"other"arguments.""This" report"is"also"on"the"NW"TAR"website,"listed"under"‘July"2013’"on"the"‘consultations’"page." " This"document"has"been"compiled"by:" LILLIAN'BURNS' ' ' ' ' '''''''SIAN'BERRY' Convenor' ' ' ' ' ' '''''''Road'Campaigner' North'West'Transport'Roundtable' ' '''''''Campaign'for'Better'Transport' Greater'Manchester'Transport'Resource'Unit,''''16'Waterside,' St.'Thomas'Centre,' ' ' ' ''''''''44%48'Wharf'Road,' Ardwick'Green'North,' ' ' ' ''''''''London,''N1'7UX' Manchester,'M12'6FZ.' ' e:''[email protected]' ' ' '''' ' ''''e:'[email protected]" Website:''www.nwtar.org.uk' ' '''''''''''''''''Website:'www.bettertransport.org.uk''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' NW 'TAR' ''''''''''''' ' 3" " NW"TAR"&"CfBT:""More"reasons"why"the"SEMMMS"A6<Manchester"Airport"Relief"Road"should"not"be"commissioned" ' This'report'is'also'endorsed'by:' The'Campaign'to'Protect'Rural'England'(CPRE),'Lancashire'Branch'' ' ' ' ' Friends'of'the'Peak'District' ' ' Cyclists'Touring'Club' ' ' ' Friends'of'the'Earth' ' ' ' 4" " NW"TAR"&"CfBT:""More"reasons"why"the"SEMMMS"A6<Manchester"Airport"Relief"Road"should"not"be"commissioned" SEMMMS'FINAL'REPORT'RECOMMENDATIONS' The"South"East"Manchester"Multi"Modal"Study"(SEMMMS)"was"one"of"a"series"of"Multi< Modal"Studies"commissioned"by"the"Department"for"Transport"(DfT)"in"the"late"1990s"to" investigate"transport"corridors"judged"to"have"transport"issues"and"to"come"forward"with" packages"of"multi<modal"solutions.""Coalitions"of"consultants"were"assembled"to"conduct" each"study"and"regional"government"offices"took"charge"of"them."""The"SEMMMS"study"was" co<ordinated"by"Government"Office"for"the"North"West"(GONW)"and"the"consultants"were" Steer"Davies"Gleave,"Llewelyn"Davies"and"W."S."Atkins.""The"final"report"was"issued"in"2001" http://www.semmms.info/140683/433764/semmmsstrategyreport."""(N.B."It"did"not"number" the"recommendations.""The"ordering/numbering"and"synopsis"below"is"the"authors’)." " ROADS' ' 1"" Based"on"an"expected"steep"upward"trajectory"for"traffic"growth,"the"SEMMMS"final" report"recommendation"was"that"all"but"one"of"the"roads"remitted"to"the"study" should"be"delivered"–"but"at"a"lower"standard"than"they"were"remitted.""It"said"that" the"A6"Stockport"North<South"Bypass,"the"A555"Manchester"Airport"Western"and" Eastern"Link"Roads"and"the"A523"Poynton"Bypass"should"all"be"built"to"dual" carriageway"standard.""Subsequently"the"government"instructed"Stockport"MBC," Manchester"City"Council"and"Cheshire"County"Council"to"work"collaboratively." " 2""" The"opinion"of"the"consultants"and"the"SEMMMS"steering"group"was"that"the" junctions"of"the"roads"they"endorsed"should"be"‘at’"grade"(ie."at"ground"level"with" junctions"that"intersect"with"existing"roads).""" " 3' On"the"A523"Poynton"to"Macclesfield"Improvement"Road,"the"report"said:""" “It"is"judged,"at"this"stage,"that"…"improvements"can"be"achieved"through"on5line"(or" close"to"line)"improvements.""However,"it"is"accepted"that"more"detailed"investigation" will"be"required"by"Cheshire"County"Council,"as"highway"authority,"in"conjunction"with" Macclesfield"Borough"Council,"as"planning"authority.""An"off5Line"scheme"may"be" required.""If"this"is"the"case,"traffic"forecasts"indicate"a"single"carriageway"scheme" would"be"sufficient”.""(Para."7.10,"page"109).""""Here"again,"of"course,"it"should"be" noted"that"the"‘traffic"forecasts’"in"question"all"predicted"a"high"level"of"traffic"growth" that"has"not"taken"place"in"the"intervening"12"years." " Following"these"(fairly"inconclusive)"findings"and"with"no"new"evidence"to"promote" an"off<line"road,"Macclesfield"Borough"Council"removed"the"protected"line"of"the" Poynton"to"Macclesfield"Improvement"from"their"Local"Plan"in"2004.""This"was"the" last"Local"Plan"they"produced"before"Cheshire"was"divided"into"two"new"Unitary" Authorities"and"the"Macclesfield"Borough"area"became"part"of"Cheshire"East"Council." 5" " NW"TAR"&"CfBT:""More"reasons"why"the"SEMMMS"A6<Manchester"Airport"Relief"Road"should"not"be"commissioned" " 4'' A'fundamental'condition'to'the'recommendations'in'respect'of'road%building'was' that'eXisting'road'space'relieved'of'traffic'by'new'roads'should'be're%allocated'to' sustainable'modes''of'transport'and'to'support'regeneration'initiatives.'' " The"SEMMMS"report"said:" “Integral"to"the"recommendations"outlined"…"is"a"further"recommendation"that"road" space"on"roads"relieved"by"new"construction"is"reallocated"to"pedestrians,"cyclists," public"transport"and"to"support"urban"regeneration"initiatives.""The"exact"nature"of" the"reallocation"must"be"a"matter"for"the"implementing"authorities"and"should"be" informed"by"detailed"investigation"of"local"needs"and"priorities,"supported"by" consultation"with"local"residents"and"businesses."" " "If"new"roads"are"built"without"road"space"reallocation"elsewhere,"the"traffic" generation"which"will"result"will"lead"to"a"failure"to"achieve"the"benefits"that"have" been"identified"as"resulting"from"the"recommended"strategy”.""" (Para."7.11,"page"110"–"our"underlining)"""""" ' ROAD'SPACE'' 5'"" The"point"about"the"reallocation"of"road"space"was"re<emphasised"in"the"SEMMMS" report"in"the"section"on"the"‘Use"of"Road"Space’"where"it"is"also"recommended"that,' prior'to'the'new'roads'being'built:' • area%wide'traffic'calming'and'measures'such'as'‘Home'Zones’'are'introduced" • an'area%wide'cycle'network'is'developed'and'promoted'and'" • urban'regeneration'initiatives'are'used'to'promote'walking'and'cycling'in'eXisting' local,'town'and'village'centres'" (Para."7.47,"page"124"–"our"highlighting)" ' METROLINK' There"were"two"key"recommendations"relating"to"light"rail:" " 6' that"there"should"be"an"extension"of"Metrolink"beyond"Stockport"to"serve"Portwood," Bredbury,"Romiley"and"Rose"Hill,"Marple"and" " 7"" that"there"should"be"a"link"between"Stockport"and"the"Wythenshawe"loop"(part"of"the"