IC Planning Consultant
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City Final Report Age Friendly Community Plan Prepared for URBP8001 | Community Planning Studio Group 2 | 2020-2021 Semester 1 December IC PLANNING CONSULTANT Strive to See, See to Serve CHENG Chi Chiu David, CHU Wing Sing Don, LEE Ming Wai Vivian, LEI Shuyu Leslie, TAM Tsz Ho Cyrus, TSE Yi Lam Gloria, WONG Yui Hin Isaac, YING Pui Yan Anson Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City Final Report Executive Summary In view of the double ageing trend as well as the ample development opportunities in Kowloon City, IC Planning Consultant was commissioned by the Department of Urban Planning and Design, University of Hong Kong in September 2020 to provide consultancy services regarding the study titled “Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City”. The study aims to develop an Age Friendly Community Plan (AFCP) with reference to the 8 domains proposed by the WHO Age-friendly City model. Throughout the 2 stages of baseline review and plan recommendation, 6 study tasks were covered with an emphasis on soliciting community needs and aspirations through (1) Questionnaire and Roadshow Survey, (2) Interview with relevant Stakeholders and (3) Community Workshop. With baseline findings and community inputs incorporated, this Age Friendly Community Plan put forward the planning vision “to build an age friendly, sustainable, smart and liveable community that enables Kowloon City dwellers to live with autonomy, health and well-being, social connectedness, sense of security and resilience as they age”. A total of 8 overarching planning and design principles were developed to guide each of the proposals. The plan also features the “4I Strategies”, namely Interconnected Web, Integrative Environment, Intergenerational Cohesion and Independent Wellness in which 12 proposals are recommended as follows: 4I Strategies Proposals Connected Waterfront Interconnected Web Circular Feeder Service 龍城脈絡 Universal Access & Design Improvement Integrative Green Corridor Environment 綠在社區 Smart Environmental Monitoring App Intergenerational Co-Living Units Intergenerational Cohesion Shared Spaces in GIC Facilities 跨代共融 5 Streets Cultural and Creative Incubator Multi-Level Healthcare Composite Building Institution-led Specialist Healthcare Building Independent Wellness 健康無界 Private-led Wellness Services Dementia-friendly Park While the plan provides both quick-win and long-term solutions towards an age-friendly Kowloon City, all proposals are expected to be completed by 2031. With the Preliminary Impact Assessment and Sustainability Impact Assessment conducted, the positive impact of this AFCP is solidly proven. IC Planning Consultant 齡活龍城 Strive to see, see to serve 1 Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City Final Report Table of Contents 1. Introduction 10 1.1 Study Background 10 1.2 Study Goal and Objectives 10 1.3 Study Area 11 1.4 Study Process and Methodology 12 1.5 Study Management 14 1.6 Structure of this Report 14 2. Key Planning Concepts and Case Studies 15 2.1 Age Friendly Cities and Communities 15 2.2 Sustainable Community 16 2.3 Active Ageing 18 2.4 Ageing-in-Place 20 2.5 Universal Design 21 2.6 Implications on Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City 23 3. Baseline Findings and SWOT Analysis 24 3.1 Reconnaissance of the Study Area 24 3.2 Physical Aspects 28 3.3 Environmental and Infrastructural Aspects 36 3.4 Socio-Economic Aspects 41 3.5 SWOT Analysis 45 4. Community Engagement 46 4.1 Overview of Community Engagement 46 4.2 Stage 1 Roadshow and Questionnaire Survey 46 4.3 Stage 2 Community Planning Workshop 47 4.4 Rationales in Adopting Community Inputs 48 4.5 Summary of Public Comments and Responses 49 5. Final Age Friendly Community Plan 52 5.1 Vision 52 5.2 Planning and Design Principles 52 5.3 Overview of Strategies and Proposals 53 5.4 Strategy 1 Interconnected Web 龍城脈絡 57 5.5 Strategy 2 Integrative Environment 綠在社區 72 5.6 Strategy 3 Intergenerational Cohesion 跨代共融 82 5.7 Strategy 4 Independent Wellness 健康無界 94 5.8 Overall Implementation Programme 107 5.9 Preliminary Impact Assessment 109 6. Sustainability Impact Assessment 114 6.1 Selection Criteria 114 6.2 List of SIV 115 6.3 Assessment Mechanism 117 6.4 Results and Implications 118 7. Conclusion and Way Forward 120 7.1 Conclusion 120 7.2 Way Forward 120 IC Planning Consultant 齡活龍城 Strive to see, see to serve 2 Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City Final Report List of Figures Figure 1.3.1 Study Area (Source: Study Team) Figure 1.4.1 Illustration of Study Process (Source: Study Team) Figure 2.1.1 The Age-friendly City Model (Source: WHO, 2007) Figure 2.1.2 Dimensions of the Age friendly community (Source: Lui et al., 2009) Figure 2.1.3 The Old Adult Plan (Source: The Council on Ageing of Ottawa) Figure 2.1.4 Evaluation Framework “How Age-friendly is Ottawa?” (Source: The Council on Ageing of Ottawa) Figure 2.2.1 Edan Wheel for Sustainable Communities (Source: Egan, 2004) Figure 2.2.2 Living Room in Nathalie Salmon House (Source: DNA Info, 2017) Figure 2.3.1 The Determinants of Active Ageing (Source: WHO, 2002) Figure 2.3.2 TWGH Navigation Application (Source: TWGH, 2020) Figure 2.3.3 Silver Employment at Chatters Cafe (Source: Silver Spring) Figure 2.4.1 Dr. Janež’s Memorial Building (Source: Camillian Saint Mary’s Hospital Luodong) Figure 2.4.2 Initiating Ceremony for the All-in-one Elderly Medical and Community Care Building (Source: Camillian Saint Mary’s Hospital Luodong) Figure 2.5.1 The 7 Principles of Universal Design (Source: bijoumind, 2017) Figure 2.5.2 The Portland Memory Garden (Source: Pacific Horticulture Society, 2020) Figure 3.1.1 Existing Uses of Kowloon City (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.1.2 Percentage of Elderly in the Study Area (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 3.1.3 Percentage of Elderly and Elderly-to-be (55+) in the Study Area (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 3.1.4 Kai Tak OZP (Source: PlanD, 2006) Figure 3.2.1 Uneven Width of Sidewalks (Sources: Geoinfo Map, 2020; Google Map, 2020; modified from Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.2.2 Shop Frontage Typologies in the Study Area (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.3 Common Signages in the Study Area (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.4 Shading on Streets of the Five Sub-Areas in the Study Area (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.5 Two Types of Street Furnitures in Hung Hom and To Kwa Wan (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.6 Examples of Inaccessible Entrances and Facilities at Tin Kwong Road Playground and Hutchison Park (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.7 Tenement Buildings Over 50 Years Without Lift Provision (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.8 Poor Conditions Observed in Tenement Buildings (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.9 Observation of Entrance in PRH, G/IC facilities and Private Development (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.10 Double Ageing in the Study Area (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.2.11 Six Strategic Double Ageing Areas (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.3.1 Distribution of Existing Open Spaces (Source: Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.3.2 Types of Existing Open Space (Source: Study Team) Figure 3.3.3 5-min Walking Distance from Open Space for Elderly (Source: Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.3.4 Distance to Closest Open Space from Street Blocks (Source: Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.3.5 Green Coverage in Kowloon City (Source: Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.3.6 Transit Service in Kowloon City (Source: Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.3.7 Inter-district Transit from Kowloon City (Source: Age 0+, 2020) Figure 3.3.8 Disconnected Waterfront (Source: Age 0+, 2020) IC Planning Consultant 齡活龍城 Strive to see, see to serve 3 Planning for an Age Friendly Kowloon City Final Report Figure 3.4.1 Declared Buildings and Monuments in the Study Area (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 3.4.2 Timeline of the Festive Events in the Study Area (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 3.4.3 Location Map of Social Service for the Elderly (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 3.4.4 Percentage of Working Elderly in Total Elderly Population in the Study Area (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 3.4.5 Percentage of Working Population in Social-service Related Industries in Total Working Population in the Study Area (Source: Fellows, 2020) Figure 4.2.1 Photos of Stage 1 Community Engagement Activities (Source: Study Team) Figure 4.3.1 Promotion Poster of Community Planning Workshop (Source: Study Team) Figure 4.3.2 Group Photo of Community Planning Workshop (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.2.1 8 Planning and Design Principles (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.3.1 Conceptual Spatial Framework (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.3.2 4I Strategies (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.3.3 Final AFCP (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.1 Proposals of Strategy 1 Interconnected Web (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.2 Location Map of Major Obstructions along the Waterfront (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.3 Thematic Precincts of the Connected Waterfront (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.4 Waterfront Promenade designated on Kai Tak OZP (Source: PlanD) Figure 5.4.5 Plan Amendment on Hung Hom OZP (Source: PlanD) Figure 5.4.6 Photomontage of Green Sensory Pathway (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.7 Design Elements of Green Sensory Pathway (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.8 Section of the Landscape Deck (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.9 Circular Feeder Service Routing (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.10 Lower Floor Wheelchair Accessible Public Light Bus (Source: info.gov.hk) Figure 5.4.11 Re-provision of BFA in Ma Tau Wai Estate (Source: Study Team) Figure 5.4.12 Wheelchair-friendly Bus Stop Designs (Source: Study Team)