Churches, Ryedale, North Yorkshire 2 Volumes
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Vandalism and Social Duty: The Victorian Rebuilding of the ‘Street Parish’ Churches, Ryedale, North Yorkshire 2 Volumes Volume I of II David C Smith PhD University of York Archaeology December 2014 Abstract The mid-19th century saw the greatest change to the material culture of Anglican worship since the Reformation. Yet despite the singular importance of this period to the life of the parish church, archaeologists have rarely engaged with these buildings. This thesis proposes an archaeological methodology for the examination of parish churches heavily restored or rebuilt during the 19th century. This innovative and flexible archaeological methodology integrates metric recording, systematic visual and stratigraphic analyses, 3D reconstruction, and a detailed synthesis of documentary resources. The ‘Street Parish’ churches in Ryedale, North Yorkshire, which were restored between 1855-1872, are utilised as case studies to test this methodology. Rather than being wholly dictated by national trends, the Victorian restoration of parish churches is shown to be a complex negotiation between these trends and local factors, including local personalities and the existing fabric. Indeed this thesis demonstrates that Victorian rebuild churches are heavily influenced by the earlier structures on the same site, often retaining the medieval plan form and architectural development. This study shows that through the archaeological study of 19th-century restoration, it is possible to recover a huge dataset which represents a significant thread of evidence about the character and development of the medieval church as well as post-medieval church investment, which have hitherto been missed or deliberately ignored by existing academic discourses. This research informs our understanding of these under-valued buildings, in order to enable their strategic future management. 2 Table of Contents Abstract .................................................................................................................................... 2 Table of Contents ................................................................................................................... 3 List of Illustrations (Volume II) ........................................................................................ 9 Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................... 23 Author’s Declaration ......................................................................................................... 24 Chapter 1 – Introduction ................................................................................................. 25 1.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 25 1.1.1 ‘The Street’ benefice ........................................................................................................ 27 1.2 Context and definitions – Victorian ‘restoration’ ......................................... 29 1.2.1 The Eighteenth Century - ‘necessary repairs’ versus ‘improvements’ ...... 30 1.2.2 Early Victorian church building ................................................................................. 31 1.2.3 The Anglican Revival and the return of Catholic tradition ............................. 32 1.2.4 The Ecclesiologists and Victorian church restoration ...................................... 33 1.2.5 Transmission and diffusion ......................................................................................... 37 1.2.6 Backlash - The anti-restoration movement and the redefining of ‘restoration’ .................................................................................................................................... 37 1.2.7 Legacy – Early 20th Century ........................................................................................ 38 1.2.8 Conclusions ......................................................................................................................... 39 Chapter 2 – Review of Relevant Literature ................................................................ 41 2.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 41 2.2 Art History: Style and the Cult of Personality ................................................ 42 A Style Fetish ................................................................................................................................. 42 The Cult of Personality .............................................................................................................. 44 Recent Developments ................................................................................................................ 46 2.3 Restoration and the Evolution of Modern Conservation ........................... 47 Modern Conservation ................................................................................................................ 48 2.4 Church Archaeology ............................................................................................... 49 Archaeological specialisms and ‘Questions that Count’ .............................................. 50 Church Archaeology ................................................................................................................... 51 Archaeological approaches to destruction and reuse .................................................. 56 3 Chapter 3 – Methodology ................................................................................................. 60 3.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 60 3.2 The Study Area - the ‘Street Parish’ churches ................................................ 61 3.3 Technical and intellectual methods .................................................................. 64 3.3.1 Documentary and archival research ........................................................................ 64 3.3.2 Archaeological Recording and Analysis .................................................................. 67 3.4 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 71 Chapter 4 – All Saints, Hovingham ................................................................................ 72 4.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 72 4.1.1 Historical Background - Hovingham village ......................................................... 73 4.1.2 Historical Account – All Saints’ Church ................................................................... 74 4.2 Description of the Current Church .................................................................... 75 4.2.1 Setting of the Current Church ..................................................................................... 76 4.2.2 Nave ........................................................................................................................................ 76 4.2.3 South Aisle ........................................................................................................................... 77 4.2.4 Porch ...................................................................................................................................... 79 4.2.5 North Aisle ........................................................................................................................... 79 4.2.6 Chancel .................................................................................................................................. 81 4.2.7 North Chancel Aisle ......................................................................................................... 83 4.2.8 Tower ..................................................................................................................................... 84 4.2.9 Features/fabric altered, added or removed 1860-Present ............................ 86 4.2.10 Analysis of Current Church ........................................................................................ 87 4.2.11 Reused material in the present church ................................................................ 88 4.3 Reconstruction of the Pre-Restoration Church ............................................. 90 4.3.1 Sources .................................................................................................................................. 90 4.3.2 Setting of the Earlier Church ....................................................................................... 91 4.3.3 Nave & South Aisle ........................................................................................................... 91 4.3.4 North Aisle ........................................................................................................................... 94 4.3.5 Chancel .................................................................................................................................. 95 4.3.6 North Chancel Aisle & Vestry ...................................................................................... 96 4.3.7 Tower ..................................................................................................................................... 98 4.3.8 Architectural Phasing ....................................................................................................