Download (4Mb)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick Permanent WRAP URL: http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/131520 Copyright and reuse: This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. For more information, please contact the WRAP Team at: [email protected] warwick.ac.uk/lib-publications SPACES OF POWER: Politics, subjectivity and materiality in post- independence Cairo Aya Mahmoud Ismail Nassar A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Politics and International Studies Department of Politics and International Studies The University of WarwicK September 2018 Table of content TABLE OF CONTENT ................................................................................................... - 2 - LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... - 6 - ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .............................................................................................. - 8 - DECLARATION .............................................................................................................. - 10 - ABSTRACT…. .................................................................................................................. - 11 - LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS .......................................................................................... - 12 - NOTE ON LANGUAGE ................................................................................................. - 13 - CHAPTER 1 THE PRESENT IN WHICH THIS THESIS IS WRITTEN ............. - 14 - Research questions ..................................................................................................................... - 16 - Research assumptions and scope: power, space and the city ................................................. - 17 - Power and the political........................................................................................................... - 18 - The urban problem ................................................................................................................ - 19 - Argumentation and contributions ............................................................................................ - 21 - Narrating postcolonial Cairo ................................................................................................. - 22 - Space as indeterminate and disruptive ..................................................................................... - 23 - Writing in/writing away sovereign subjects .............................................................................. - 25 - Methodology ............................................................................................................................... - 26 - Archival research .................................................................................................................. - 26 - Fieldwork ............................................................................................................................. - 28 - The structure of the thesis ......................................................................................................... - 28 - CHAPTER 2 PATTERNING THE POSTCOLONY ................................................. - 32 - A gesture from the rooftop ....................................................................................................... - 32 - Al-Qāhira: The city from mastery to attachment ..................................................................... - 35 - A quest for order: one, two, three cities .................................................................................... - 36 - Politicising contemporary Cairo: shifting methodologies ............................................................. - 39 - Moving beyond the literature .................................................................................................. - 41 - As if space matters ..................................................................................................................... - 43 - The city and the postcolony ..................................................................................................... - 43 - ‘Material registers’ of space:.................................................................................................... - 48 - Narrating beyond sovereign attachments ................................................................................ - 54 - Sovereign attachments, ambitions and disappointment .............................................................. - 54 - - 2 - Postcolonial promises and their aftermaths ............................................................................... - 57 - The politics of writing: storytelling and selfhood ........................................................................ - 60 - Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. - 61 - CHAPTER 3 DUST METHODOLOGIES: IN DEFENCE OF FRAGMENTS .... - 63 - 6 months+1000 words +1 map ................................................................................................ - 64 - Hygienic methods for a healthy research life ........................................................................... - 69 - Escaping dust storms ................................................................................................................. - 73 - ‘To make space in dust…to breathe there, finally’ .................................................................. - 76 - Archival dust ............................................................................................................................... - 79 - Prayer mats and white gloves .................................................................................................... - 82 - To begin where we started, in perfect circularity .................................................................... - 86 - Conclusions and beginnings ...................................................................................................... - 89 - CHAPTER 4 CAIRO IS BURNING: THE POLITICS OF FIRE ............................ - 92 - The power of fire ....................................................................................................................... - 97 - Fire: a history of confusions (revolutions) ............................................................................. - 100 - The political spatiality of the fire ............................................................................................ - 102 - The city as a political problem ................................................................................................ - 108 - The 1952 Fire as productive of ambivalent subjectivity ....................................................... - 111 - After the fire ............................................................................................................................. - 115 - Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ - 118 - CHAPTER 5 ‘SONS OF THE SOIL’: LAND, MUD AND THE MODERN NATIONAL SUBJECT ........................................................................ - 122 - Geography’s anticipation of the Egyptian subject ................................................................ - 125 - Hamdan’s geographical exceptionalism ................................................................................. - 128 - Post-1967 geopolitics ........................................................................................................... - 128 - A natural homogeneity: mud, geology and landscape ............................................................... - 132 - ‘Ludicrous substance’: mud as an architectural critique ....................................................... - 135 - Mud as a building material ................................................................................................. - 137 - Mud and modernity ............................................................................................................. - 141 - Mud and the city ................................................................................................................. - 145 - Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ - 147 - - 3 - CHAPTER 6 CONCRETE: STAGING THE STATE .............................................. - 149 - Shifting national symbolic orders ........................................................................................... - 154 - Concrete and modernity .......................................................................................................... - 160 - The city of victory within the city victorious ......................................................................... - 165 - The hero of war and peace: complex victory ........................................................................ - 173 - Imagining the monument: symbolic entanglements ............................................................. - 175 - Constructing the monument: