Jade Trade and Sociocultural Ciiange: a Case Study in Iipakant .Jade Mine Area, Kachin State
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JADE TRADE AND SOCIOCULTURAL CIIANGE: A CASE STUDY IN IIPAKANT .JADE MINE AREA, KACHIN STATE PhD DISSERTATION HLAHLAKYI UNIVERSITY OF YANGON DEPARTMENT OF ANTHROPOLOGY MYANMAR MAY, 2013 JADE TRADE AND SOCIOCULTURAL CHANGE: A CASE STUDY IN HPAKANT JADE MINE AREA, KACHIN STATE Submitted: Hla H1 a Kyi Roll No: 4 PhD - Anth-3 This dissertation is submitted to the Department ofAnthropology, University ofYangon in partial fulfillment ofthe requirements for the Degree ofDoctor ofPhilosophy May, 2013 JADE TRADE AND SOCIOCULTURAL CHANGE: A CASE STUDY IN HPAKANT JADE MINE AREA, KACHIN STATE HLAHLAKYI THIS DISSERTATION IS SUBMITTED TO THE BOARD OF EXAMINERS IN ANTHROPOLOGY, UNIVERSITY OF YANGON FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY. i{\/' EXTERNAL EXAMINER CHAIRPERSON & REFEREE Dr. Moe Moe SUPERVISOR Dr. Khin Htay Htay Lecturer Dr. Mya Mya Khin Associate Professor and Head Department ofAnthropology Professorand Head Department of Anthropology Dagon University Department ofAnthropology Dagon University Universityof Yangon ~ SUPERVISOR CO-SUPERVISOR Dr. Tin Thein Dr. Htay Win Professor (Part-time) Professor Department ofAnthropology Department ofGeology University of Yangon East Yangon University LN,q/ "B~ c» MEMBER MEMBER Dr. LwinLwin Mon Dr. Than Pale Associate Professor Associate Professor Department of Anthropology Department ofAnthropology University of Yangon University ofYangon ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First of011. 1would like to express my thanks to Dr. Myn My" Kh!n, Professor & Head, Department of Anthropology. University of Ynugon; who guided and advised Ole to fulfill this PhD thesis research ns Chuir person and Supervisor and to her keen interest and pcrrnisssion to carry out this research. I would like to express my thanks to Snyngyi Dr. Tin Thein. Professor (Part time) . Department of Anthropology, University of Yangon; who guided and advised me to fulfill this PhD thesis research as Supervisor. I would like to express my thanks to Dr. Moe Moe. Lecturer. Department of Anthropology. Dagon University; who guided and advised me to fulfill this PhD thesis research as External Examiner. I would like to express my thanks to Dr. Khin Htay Htay, Associate Professor & Head, Department of Anth ropology. Dagon University; who guided, adviced and assisted me to fulfill this PhD thesis research as Referee. I would like to express my thanks to Dr. Htay Win, Professor, Geology Department. East Yangon University; who guided and advised me to fulfill this PhD thesis research as Co-supervisor. I am also deeply grateful to Dr. Thidar Htwe Win. Professor & Head. Department of Anthropology, Yadanapon University; who guided advised and assisted me to fulfill this PhD thesis. In addition, I would like to express my thanks to Sayamagyi Daw Sein Sein, (Retired Director, Higher Education Department, Lower Myanmar) and Sayagyi UKyaw Win, Director General (Retired), Department of Archaeology. Ministry of Culture, for their invaluable guideline, earnest support and encouragement from start to finish this PhD thesis. I am also deeply grateful to Sayagyi Dr. Than Tun Sein, Director (Retired), Socio-Medical Research Division, Department of Medical Research, Lower Myanmar, Ministry of Health for his kind assistance in the application of Research Methodology to be able to use it systematically and for his invaluable guidelines to accomplish this thesis. ii Moreover, I wo uld like Itl express 111 )' thnnks 10 Dr. Tin Maung Chit. Visit ing Lecturer, Department of I\ nlhnlilolog). University IIf Yangon. fur his valuable guidance and kind advice relating 10 this thesis . I would like III express Ill)' Ihnnks to Dr. Aye Kyaw, Vi""i ting Lecturer. Department o f Anthn'f"t,h'llY. University of Yangon. for his kind ness. earnest support and COC(1Ur.lgcmcnt Irom start to finish. I am al so deeply gratitude 10 Dr. Le Le Win. Director. Health Sys tem Research Division. and Dr. Saw Saw. Research Scientist. Health System Research Division. Departm ent of Medical Research (Lower Myanmar). Ministry of Health. for their invaluable guideline and kindness. systematic Instructions 10 complete this PhD thesis. I am deepl y gratitude to Dr. Lwin Lwin Mon. Associate Professor. Department of Anthropology. University of Yangon and Dr. Than Pale. Associate Professor. Departm ent of Anthropology. University of Yangon. who adivised me to fulfill this PhD thesis research as members. In addition, I am deeply gratitude to my beloved husband. parents, younger brothers and sister-in-law, for their kindness. financial support and encouragement from start to finish this PhD thesis. Finally. I would like to express my thanks to all the key infonnants for their kindness, earnest support and help during field research. iii ABSTRACT The term sociocultural system is the real-life expression of designs for living in particular envirorunents. Sociocultural change comes about through processes and events that are either internal or external to a society. The title of this thesis is "Jade Trade and Sociocultural change": A Case Study in Hpakant Jade Mine Area, Kachin State. This study explore jade trade effects on economic system in the study area, describe the influences of the economic system on sociocultural aspects of a community. elicit how jade trade affects the natural envirorunent in the study area. This study was done through the approach to culture of consumption. from an economic anthropological point of view. This thesis was conducted by descriptive study design involving case study design. This study was done qualitative method. In this study, data were collected by using participant observation. key informant interviews. in-depth interview and focus group discussion. Jade mining and marketing is the main source of economic survival not only for the locals but also the migrants. Before 2000. jade mining was carried out through the use of simple technology and simple tool s thus harming the natural environment to a small extent. After 2000 with the advent of jade companies. jade mining is carried out through the use of modem technology and modem machines. thus harming the natural environment considerably. However. the use of modem machines make for production of various kinds ofjade. Therefore, family's income increased for jade business and associated with other economic activities. Then, businessmen dependent on jade mining and marketing bring in consumer goods for sale. When fortune seekers from various regions arrive in jade mine area, their relations with locals develop, leading to more general knowledge on the latter's part. They concentrate more on children's education. and health care for the family. Moreover. the locals' lifestyle begin to change, especially in the styles of food, clothing and shelter constituting the basic needs of human society. Under government's direction the companies have come in and their working with modem technologies in jade mine causes much economic developm ent. For this reason sociocultural change which has accompanied the economic development were explored in this study. Keywords : consumption culture. socio-cultural change, environmental change. economic system. subsistence patterns iv CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ABSTRACT iii LIST OF TABLES vi LIST OF FIGURES vii Chapter 1. INTRODUCTION I 1.1 Background I 1.2 Rationale 3 1.3 Aim and Objectives 4 1.4 Conceptual Framework 5 1.5 Composition of Thesis 6 2. LITERATURE REVIEW 8 2. 1 Anthropological Consideration on the Linking of 8 Economic and Environment 2.1. 1. Anthropological Consideration on Economy 8 2.1.2 Anthropological Consideration on Environment 9 2.1.3 Anthropological Consideration on Trade 11 2.2 Anthropological Considerationon Sociocultural Change 12 2.3 Technology 16 3. METHODOLOGY 18 3.1 Study Design 18 3.2 Study Site 18 3.3 Study Population 20 3.4 Data Collection Method 21 3.5 Data Analysis 22 3.6 Study Period 23 3.7 Ethical Considerations 24 4. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF JADE 26 4.1 The Popularity ofMyanmar Jade 26 v 4.2 Development ofJude Trude in Myanmar 30 4.3 Hnckground of the Research Area 41 4.3 .1 Uru Creek and J.ocu I Culture 43 4.3.2 Demography and Transportation 44 4.3.3 Folklore and Omen 46 5. ECONO MIC SYSTEM 49 5.1 Production 50 5.1.1 Types of Workers 59 5.2 Distribution 65 5.3 Consumption 67 5.3.1 Recorded Inscription of Lonekhinn-Hpakant 67 Jade Mines Region 1988 to Date 5.3 .2 Myanmar Gems Law 72 5,4 Environmental Conditions 73 5.5 Other Economic Activities 81 6. SOCIOCULTURAL CHANGES OF LIFESTYLE 88 6.1 Education 88 6.2 Health 96 6.3 Food Habit 102 6.4 Mode ofDress 103 6.5 Patterns ofHousing 104 6.6 Daily Routine in Family 106 6.7 The Relationship among Family Members 107 7. DISCUSSION 110 7.1 Changes in Demography and Transportationdue to 110 jade trade 7.2 Patterns of Jade Consumption 111 7.3 Sociocultural changes of Li festyle 114 8. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 119 8.1 Conclus ion 119 8.2 Recommendations 123 REFERENCES ANNEXES vi LIST OF TABLES Page Tabl e I. Time Frame 23 Table 2. Table showing the Average amountof duty annually collected 35 onjade stones Table3. Table shewing jade export to Yannan from 1897·1 908 36 Table 4. Annual Jade Sales of Myarunar Gems Exhibition 38 Table 5. Population in Hpakant Township (2009 census) 44 Table 6. Racial and Ethnic Groups Residing in Hpakant Township (2009) 44 Table 7. Population by Religion in Hpakant Township (2009) 45 Table 8. Showing for Jade exhibition and Sale Proceeds 66 Table 9. Annual Rainfall Records in Lonekhinn-Hpakant Jade MineArea 77 (From 200 1 to 2012) Table 10. Hpakant Township's use of Land 79 Tabl e I I. Hpakant Township's Schools, Teachers and Students 88 Table 12. EnrolmentofSchool-aged Children 89 Table 13. Basic Education High School, Grade 11 lh Pass % 89 Table 14. The Basic Education High School (Branch). Lonekhinn village 90 Table IS. The Basic Education Primary School 91 Table 16.