DOCSLIB.ORG

Response to Application for Leave to Appeal and Conditional Application for Leave to Cross-Appeal of the Respondent, Attorney General of Ontario

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Response to Application for Leave to Appeal and Conditional Application for Leave to Cross-Appeal of the Respondent, Attorney General of Ontario Court File No: 38921 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CANADA (ON APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO) BETWEEN: CITY OF TORONTO Applicant (Respondent) and ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO Respondent (Appellant) and TORONTO DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD Intervener (Intervener) RESPONSE TO APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL AND CONDITIONAL APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO CROSS-APPEAL OF THE RESPONDENT, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO POWERLAW Constitutional Law Branch 130 Albert Street, Suite 1103 McMurtry-Scott Building Ottawa, ON KIP 5G4 720 Bay Street, 4th Floor Toronto, ON M7 A 2S9 Fax: 416-326-4015 Robin K Basu (LSO# 32742K) Maxine Vincelette Tel: 416-995-5249 Tel: 613-702-5573 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Yashoda Ranganathan (LSO# 57236E) Tel: 647-637-0883 Email: [email protected] Aud Ranalli (LSO# 72362U) Tel: 416-73 8-2840 Email: [email protected] Of Counsel for the Respondent (Appellant), Agent for the Respondent (Appellant), The Attorney General of Ontario The Attorney General of Ontario THE CITY OF TORONTO BORDEN LADNER GERVAIS City of Toronto, Legal Services, World Exchange Plaza Metro Hall, 55 John Street, 26th Floor 1300-100 Queen Street Toronto, Ontario M5V 3C6 Ottawa, ON KlP 1J9 Fax: (416) 397-5624 Karen Perron Diana W. Dimmer Tel: 613-369-4795 Tel: 416-392-7229 Fax: 613-230-8842 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Ottawa Agent for the Applicant Glenn K.L. Chu Tel: 416-392-7224 Email: [email protected] Fred Fischer Tel: 416-397-5407 Email: [email protected] Philip K. Chan Tel: 416-392-1650 Email: [email protected] Counsel for the Applicant (Respondent), The City of Toronto AND TO: TORONTO DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD LEGAL SERVICES 5050 Yonge Street, 5th Floor Toronto, ON M2N 5N8 PaulKoven Tel: 416-397-3565 Email: [email protected] Counsel for the Intervener (Intervener) i INDEX TAB DOCUMENT PAGE 1 Memorandum of Argument of the Respondent, Attorney General of Ontario 2 dated January 16, 2020 - Response to Application for Leave to Appeal 2 Notice of Conditional Application for Leave to Cross-Appeal of the 56 Respondent, Attorney General of Ontario, dated January 16, 2020 3 Memorandum of Argument of the Respondent, Attorney General of Ontario 64 dated January 16, 2020 - Conditional Application for Leave to Cross-Appeal Documents in Support of the Response to Application for Leave to Appeal 4 Legislative Assembly of Ontario, Hansard, August 2, 2018 (Excerpt from the 92 Joint Appeal Book, Vol. 5, Tab 50, pp 352, 355-56) 5 Factum of the Respondent, the City of Toronto, filed at the Court of Appeal 98 for Ontario in proceeding C65861, dated May 6, 2019 at p 30 (Excerpt) 6 Affidavit of Andrew Sancton, sworn October 30, 2018 (Excerpt; Exhibits 104 excluded) (From the Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 3, Tab 4, pp 1517- 1557, 1565) 7 Affidavit of Anthony Fowler, sworn October 30, 2018 (Excerpts; Exhibits 188 excluded) (From the Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 3, pp 266- 68, 283) 8 Cross-examination of Giuliana Carbone on her Affidavit sworn August 22, 196 2018 and her Affidavit sworn December 3, 2018, held March 5, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 1A and B, pp 9, 18-19, 39-40, 50-56, 76-77, 81-82, 91, 192-94) 9 Cross-examination of Gary Davidson on his Affidavit affirmed August 27, 234 2018, held March 11, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence ii Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 3A, pp 414-15, 419-23, 426, 431, 434, 449, 450, 451, 458, 461, 464, 467-70, 472-76) 10 Cross-examination of Mariana Valverde on her Affidavit sworn August 20, 284 2018, held March 7, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 3, Tab 12A, pp 1802, 1821-22, 1855, 1859-61, 1864-66, 1870, 1888-89, 1894-1900, 1912-15, 1932, 1962, 1966-70) A. Exhibit 1 to the Cross-Examination of Mariana Valverde: “City 348 Bureaucrats and Village Elders: The Dysfunctional Dance of Local Governance” in Everyday Law on the Streets by Mariana Valverde (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 3, Tab 12A1) 11 Cross-examination of Myer Siemiatycki on his Affidavit sworn August 21, 382 2018, held March 8, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 3, Tab 11A, pp 1647, 1649-57, 1660-62, 1664-69, 1711) 12 Cross-examination of Lily Cheng on her Affidavit affirmed August 21, 2018, 404 held February 13, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 2A and B, pp 306-07, 359-60, 363, 373, 380-81) 13 Cross-examination of Chiara Padovani on her Affidavit sworn August 21, 420 2018, held March 1, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 3, Tab 10B, pp 1520-22, 1534, 1543, 1548-49, 1551) 14 Cross-examination of Chris Moise on his Affidavit sworn August 20, 2018, 438 held February 14, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 2, Tab 8B, pp 819-20) 15 Cross-examination of Dyanoosh Youssefi on her Affidavit affirmed August 442 22, 2018, held March 5, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 4, Tab 14B, pp 2119-22, 2146) 16 Cross-examination of Jennifer Hollett on her Affidavit affirmed August 21, 452 2018, held February 13, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 5A and B, pp 587-88, 621) 17 Cross-examination of Megann Willson on her Affidavit sworn August 21, 462 2018, held February 12, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence iii Motion Record, Vol. 4, Tab 13B, pp 2023-25, 2032, 2041) 18 Cross-examination of Susan Dexter on her Affidavit sworn August 21, 2018, 470 held February 11, 2019 (Excerpts) (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 4A, pp 500-01). A. Exhibit 3 to the Cross-Examination of Susan Dexter: City of Toronto 474 By-Law 598-2018 (From the Supp Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 4A3) 19 Members of the Resource Task Force, Municipal Government in a New 476 Canadian Federal System: Report of the Resource Task Force on Constitutional Reform – Federation of Canadian Municipalities – Ottawa (1980) (Excerpt, pp 123, 126) 20 Affidavit of Aleksei Ponomarev, affirmed January 14, 2020 482 A. Exhibit A: Toronto City Manager, “Report for action” (October 15, 488 2019), online: City of Toronto https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2019/ex/bgrd/backgroundfile- 138688.pdf (Excerpt, pp 1-4) 21 Ontario Ministry of Transportation, News Bulletin, “Joint Statement by 496 Ministers of Transportation on the Province’s GTA Transit Plan” (29 October 2019), online: Queen’s Printer for Ontario < https://news.ontario.ca/mto/en/2019/10/statement-by-minister-of- transportation-on-the-provinces-gta-transit-plan.html> (Excerpt) 22 Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing, News Bulletin, 500 “Governments of Canada and Ontario Sign Canada’s First Housing Benefit” (19 December 2019), online: Queen’s Printer for Ontario < https://news.ontario.ca/mma/en/2019/12/governments-of-canada-and- ontario-sign-canadas-first-housing-benefit.html> 23 Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing, News Bulletin, “Ontario 508 Investing in Supportive Housing in Toronto” (24 October 2019), online: Queen’s Printer for Ontario <https://news.ontario.ca/mma/en/2019/10/ontario-investing-in-supportive- housing-in-toronto.html> iv Additional Documents in Support of the Conditional Application for Leave to Cross-Appeal 24 Affidavit of Josh Hunter, sworn October 31, 2018 (Exhibits excluded) (from 514 the Fresh Evidence Motion Record, Vol. 1, Tab 2) 25 Letter from Counsel for Ontario to Justice Belobaba, dated August 24, 2018 560 (Enclosures excluded) (from the Joint Appeal Book, Vol. 1, Tab 21) 26 Affidavit of Adam Kanji, affirmed August 27, 2018 (Exhibits excluded) (from 568 the Joint Appeal Book, Vol. 5, Tab 47) 27 Notice of Application of the City of Toronto dated August 22, 2018 (Excerpt) 576 (From the Joint Appeal Book, Vol. 1, Tab 17, pp 2423-2426) -1- -2- Court File No: 38921 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CANADA (ON APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO) BETWEEN: CITY OF TORONTO Applicant (Respondent) and ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO Respondent (Appellant) and TORONTO DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD Intervener (Intervener) MEMORANDUM OF ARGUMENT OF THE RESPONDENT, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO (Response to Application for Leave to Appeal) (Rules 27 and 29 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Canada) ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO POWER LAW Constitutional Law Branch 130 Albert Street, Suite 1103 McMurtry-Scott Building Ottawa, ON K1P 5G4 720 Bay Street, 4th Floor Toronto, ON M7A 2S9 Fax: 416-326-4015 Robin K Basu (LSO# 32742K) Maxine Vincelette Tel: 416-995-5249 Tel: 613-702-5573 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Yashoda Ranganathan (LSO# 57236E) Tel: 647-637-0883 Email: [email protected] Aud Ranalli (LSO# 72362U) Tel: 416-738-2840 Email: [email protected] Of Counsel for the Respondent (Appellant), Agent for the Respondent (Appellant), The Attorney General of Ontario The Attorney General of Ontario ----3- -4- THE CITY OF TORONTO BORDEN LADNER GERVAIS City of Toronto, Legal Services, World Exchange Plaza Metro Hall, 55 John Street, 26th Floor 1300-100 Queen Street Toronto, Ontario M5V 3C6 Ottawa, ON K1P 1J9 Fax: (416) 397-5624 Karen Perron Diana W. Dimmer Tel: 613-369-4795 Tel: 416-392-7229 Fax: 613-230-8842 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Ottawa Agent for the Applicant Glenn K.L.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • " We Are Family?": the Struggle for Same-Sex Spousal Recognition In
    INFORMATION TO USERS This manuscript has been reproduced from the microfilm master. UMI films the text directly from the original or copy submitted. Thus, some thesis and dissertation copies are in typewriter face, while others may be fmrn any type of computer printer, The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleedthrough, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reprodudion. In the unlikely event that the author did not send UMI a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Oversize materials (e-g., maps, drawings, &arb) are reproduced by sectioning the original, beginning at the upper left-hand comer and continuing from left to tight in equal sections with small overlaps. Photographs included in the original manuscript have been reproduced xerographically in this copy. Higher quality 6' x 9" black and Mite photographic prints are available for any photographs or illustratims appearing in this copy for an additional charge. Contact UMI directly to order. Bell 8 Howell Information and Leaning 300 North Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48106-1346 USA 800-521-0600 "WE ARE FAMILY'?": THE STRUGGLE FOR SAME-SEX SPOUSAL RECOGNITION IN ONTARIO AND THE CONUNDRUM OF "FAMILY" lMichelIe Kelly Owen A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Sociology and Equity Studies in Education Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto Copyright by Michelle Kelly Owen 1999 National Library Bibliothiique nationale l*B of Canada du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliographic Services sewices bibliographiques 395 Wellington Street 395.
    [Show full text]
  • City of Toronto — Detached Homes Average Price by Percentage Increase: January to June 2016
    City of Toronto — Detached Homes Average price by percentage increase: January to June 2016 C06 – $1,282,135 C14 – $2,018,060 1,624,017 C15 698,807 $1,649,510 972,204 869,656 754,043 630,542 672,659 1,968,769 1,821,777 781,811 816,344 3,412,579 763,874 $691,205 668,229 1,758,205 $1,698,897 812,608 *C02 $2,122,558 1,229,047 $890,879 1,149,451 1,408,198 *C01 1,085,243 1,262,133 1,116,339 $1,423,843 E06 788,941 803,251 Less than 10% 10% - 19.9% 20% & Above * 1,716,792 * 2,869,584 * 1,775,091 *W01 13.0% *C01 17.9% E01 12.9% W02 13.1% *C02 15.2% E02 20.0% W03 18.7% C03 13.6% E03 15.2% W04 19.9% C04 13.8% E04 13.5% W05 18.3% C06 26.9% E05 18.7% W06 11.1% C07 29.2% E06 8.9% W07 18.0% *C08 29.2% E07 10.4% W08 10.9% *C09 11.4% E08 7.7% W09 6.1% *C10 25.9% E09 16.2% W10 18.2% *C11 7.9% E10 20.1% C12 18.2% E11 12.4% C13 36.4% C14 26.4% C15 31.8% Compared to January to June 2015 Source: RE/MAX Hallmark, Toronto Real Estate Board Market Watch *Districts that recorded less than 100 sales were discounted to prevent the reporting of statistical anomalies R City of Toronto — Neighbourhoods by TREB District WEST W01 High Park, South Parkdale, Swansea, Roncesvalles Village W02 Bloor West Village, Baby Point, The Junction, High Park North W05 W03 Keelesdale, Eglinton West, Rockcliffe-Smythe, Weston-Pellam Park, Corso Italia W10 W04 York, Glen Park, Amesbury (Brookhaven), Pelmo Park – Humberlea, Weston, Fairbank (Briar Hill-Belgravia), Maple Leaf, Mount Dennis W05 Downsview, Humber Summit, Humbermede (Emery), Jane and Finch W09 W04 (Black Creek/Glenfield-Jane
    [Show full text]
  • Item 6C - Mabellearts - Long Term Lease and Operating Agreement for Parts of Mabelle Park TCHC April 27, 2021 Board Meeting Report #: TCHC:2021-27 Attachment 2 Item
    Item 6C - MABELLEarts - Long Term Lease and Operating Agreement for parts of Mabelle Park TCHC April 27, 2021 Board Meeting Report #: TCHC:2021-27 Attachment 2 Item MABELLEarts 6C VALUATION OF PROGRAMS AND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS - TCHC:2021-27 and BACKGROUND AND HISTORY WORKING WITH TCH Executive Summary This document sets out the value proposition supporting MABELLEarts proposal to lease Mabelle Park - on which MABELLEarts will construct a community building, improve the park and run programming. Attachment In exchange for entering into the lease TCH receives: • Capital Investment on its land of approximately $2 million+ • A commitment to provide programming which we value at $500,000+ per year 2 In addition, TCH tenants and the community benefit from heightened safety of an animated park space and opportunities to connect, inspire and lead. There is no way to place a number on that value. We have demonstrated below our ability to raise and sustain the funds to complete the Project and operate programming. The lease and proposed project are the result of years of community consultation and enjoys the support of the Mayor and local City Councillor. The cost to TCH is intended to be neutral – with its current cost of maintaining the park being paid to MABELLEarts as a fee for carrying out maintenance duties in the park. TCH will complete its own risk analysis. However, any risk can be mitigated in the Lease. Effectively the downside to TCH is that the lease will default and it will acquire ownership of a better park. “It's kinda weird. This is the first neighbourhood where I walk down the street and everyone is saying hi to me.
    [Show full text]
  • A Community Benefits Policy Framework for Ontario
    Boldly Progressive, Fiscally Balanced: A Community Benefits Policy Framework for Ontario Community Benefits Ontario March 2017 March 13, 2017 Who We Are This Community Benefits Framework for Ontario was developed collaBoratively through participants in the Community Benefits Ontario network, a Broad network of Ontario nonprofits, foundations, labour groups, community organizations, municipal representatives and social enterprise leaders. This brief is brought forward by the following: Colette Murphy, Executive Director, Atkinson Foundation Anne Gloger, Principal, East Scarborough Storefront Terry Cooke, President & CEO, Hamilton Community Foundation Howard Elliott, Chair, Hamilton RoundtaBle for Poverty Reduction Marc Arsenault, Stakeholder Relations, Ironworkers District Council of Ontario Mustafa ABdi, Community Organizer, Communities Organizing for ResponsiBle Development, LaBour Community Services Elizabeth McIsaac, President, Maytree Sandy Houston, President and CEO, Metcalf Foundation Cathy Taylor, Executive Director, Ontario Nonprofit Network John Cartwright, President, Toronto & York Region LaBour Council Rosemarie Powell, Executive Director, Toronto Community Benefits Network Anne Jamieson, Senior Manager, Toronto Enterprise Fund Anita Stellinga, Interim CEO, United Way of Peel Region Lorraine Goddard, CEO, United Way/Centraide Windsor-Essex County Daniele Zanotti, President and CEO, United Way Toronto & York Region 1 March 13, 2017 “Infrastructure projects such as the Eglinton Crosstown LRT can create benefits for communities that go beyond simply building the infrastructure needed. Through this agreement, people facing employment challenges will have the opportunity to acquire new skills and get good joBs in construction. We’re Building more than transit. We’re Building partnerships and pathways that are creating more opportunities for people to thrive in the economy.” - Premier Kathleen Wynne 1 December 7, 2016 Premier Wynne greets contractors and construction workers at the ground breaking of the first Eglinton Crosstown station.
    [Show full text]
  • Toronto City Council: Gardiner East Debate Vote/Support PROJECTION Based on Public Statements/Voting History
    Toronto City Council: Gardiner East Debate Vote/Support PROJECTION Based on public statements/voting history. Subject to change. And then change again. For novelty purposes only. Got a tip or correction? Email [email protected] or get me at @GraphicMatt. 2015-06-10 Preferred option for Gardiner Expressway Team Tory Member of Council Notes between Jarvis St. and Percentage Don Valley Parkway PROJECTION Dec 2014 - May 2015 John Tory Maintain/Modify 100.00% Publicly stated his support 01 Mayor of Toronto Stephen Holyday Maintain/Modify 100.00% Officially endorsed "hybrid." 02 Ward 3 Etobicoke Centre Norman Kelly Maintain/Modify 100.00% Not 100% confirmed but supported maintaining Leslie stub in 03 Ward 40 Scarborough-Agincourt 1999. Likely Maintain/Modify. Denzil Minnan-Wong Maintain/Modify 100.00% 100% Maintain/Modify. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 04 Ward 34 Don Valley East 1999. Frances Nunziata Maintain/Modify 100.00% Publicly announced her support on June 3. Supported removing 05 Ward 11 York South-Weston east-of-DVP spur in 1999. Jaye Robinson Maintain/Modify 100.00% Publicly announced her support on June 4 06 Ward 25 Don Valley West Gary Crawford Maintain/Modify 94.74% Publicly announced support for Maintain on June 2 07 Ward 36 Scarborough Southwest Christin Carmichael Greb Maintain/Modify 94.44% Support for Maintain/Modify here: http://carmichaelgreb.com/can- 08 Ward 16 Eglinton-Lawrence toronto-afford-to-remove-the-gardiner-expressway-east/ James Pasternak Maintain/Modify 93.33% Has talked about tolling non-residents to pay for Maintain/Modify 09 Ward 10 York Centre option.
    [Show full text]
  • Authority Meeting #4/16 Was Held at TRCA Head Office, on Friday, May 27, 2016
    Authority Meeting #4/16 was held at TRCA Head Office, on Friday, May 27, 2016. The Chair Maria Augimeri, called the meeting to order at 9:32 a.m. PRESENT Kevin Ashe Member Maria Augimeri Chair Jack Ballinger Member Ronald Chopowick Member Vincent Crisanti Member Glenn De Baeremaeker Member Michael Di Biase Vice Chair Jennifer Drake Member Chris Fonseca Member Jack Heath Member Jennifer Innis Member Colleen Jordan Member Matt Mahoney Member Giorgio Mammoliti Member Glenn Mason Member Mike Mattos Member Frances Nunziata Member Linda Pabst Member Anthony Perruzza Member Gino Rosati Member John Sprovieri Member Jim Tovey Member ABSENT Paul Ainslie Member David Barrow Member Justin Di Ciano Member Maria Kelleher Member Jennifer McKelvie Member Ron Moeser Member RES.#A55/16 - MINUTES Moved by: Chris Fonseca Seconded by: Kevin Ashe THAT the Minutes of Meeting #3/16, held on April 22, 2016, be received. CARRIED ______________________________ CITY OF TORONTO REPRESENTATIVE ON THE BUDGET/AUDIT ADVISORY BOARD Ronald Chopowick was nominated by Jack Heath. 110 RES.#A56/16 - MOTION TO CLOSE NOMINATIONS Moved by: Linda Pabst Seconded by: Glenn De Baeremaeker THAT nominations for the City of Toronto representative on the Budget/Audit Advisory Board be closed. CARRIED Ronald Chopowick was declared elected by acclamation as the City of Toronto representative on the Budget/Audit Advisory Board, for a term to end at Annual Meeting #1/17. ______________________________ DELEGATIONS 5.1 A delegation by Martin Medeiros, Regional Councillor, City of Brampton, in regard to item 8.3 - Hurontario-Main Street Light Rail Transit (LRT). 5.2 A delegation by Andrew deGroot, One Brampton, in regard to item 8.3 - Hurontario-Main Street Light Rail Transit (LRT).
    [Show full text]
  • Summary by Quartile.Xlsx
    Re Agenda Item #11 TORONTO PUBLIC LIBRARY QUARTILE 2012 OPERATING BUDGET SUBMISSION (Report No.11) Monday to Saturday & Sunday Service Hours Reduction Branches Current Proposed Loss of Hrs (By Quartile) Ward Councillor Hrs/Wk Hrs/Wk per week 1 Toronto Reference Library 27 Kristyn Wong-Tam 63.5 59.5 (4.0) 2 North York Central Library 23 John Filion 69.0 59.5 (9.5) R&R Libraries 132.5 119.0 (13.5) 3 Agincourt 40 Norm Kelly 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 4 Albert Campbell 35 Michelle Berardinetti 65.5 59.5 (6.0) 5 Albion 1 Vincent Crisanti 66.5 59.5 (7.0) 6 Barbara Frum 15 Josh Colle 63.0 59.5 (3.5) 7 Bloor/Gladstone 18 Ana Bailão 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 8 Brentwood 5 Peter Milczyn 66.5 59.5 (7.0) 9 Cedarbrae 43 Paul Ainslie 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 10 Don Mills 25 Jaye Robinson 63.0 59.5 (3.5) 11 Fairview 33 Shelley Carroll 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 12 Lillian H. Smith 20 Adam Vaughan 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 13 Malvern 42 Raymond Cho 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 14 Maria A. Shchuka 15 Josh Colle 66.5 59.5 (7.0) 15 Northern District 16 Karen Stintz 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 16 Pape/Danforth 30 Paula Fletcher 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 17 Richview 4 Gloria Lindsay Luby 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 18 S. Walter Stewart 29 Mary Fragedakis 69.0 59.5 (9.5) 19 York Woods 8 AAnthonynthony Perruzza 63.0 59.5 ((3.5)3.5) District Branches 1,144.0 1,011.5 (132.5) 20 Bayview 24 David Shiner 50.5 50.5 - 21 Beaches 32 Mary-Margaret McMahon 62.0 56.0 (6.0) 22 Bridlewood 39 Mike Del Grande 65.5 56.0 (9.5) 23 Centennial 10 James Pasternak 50.5 50.5 - 24 Danforth/Coxwell 32 Mary-Margaret McMahon 62.0 56.0 (6.0) 25 Deer Park 22 Josh Matlow 62.0 56.0 (6.0)
    [Show full text]
  • Agenda Item History - 2013.MM41.25
    Agenda Item History - 2013.MM41.25 http://app.toronto.ca/tmmis/viewAgendaItemHistory.do?item=2013.MM... Item Tracking Status City Council adopted this item on November 13, 2013 with amendments. City Council consideration on November 13, 2013 MM41.25 ACTION Amended Ward:All Requesting Mayor Ford to respond to recent events - by Councillor Denzil Minnan-Wong, seconded by Councillor Peter Milczyn City Council Decision Caution: This is a preliminary decision. This decision should not be considered final until the meeting is complete and the City Clerk has confirmed the decisions for this meeting. City Council on November 13 and 14, 2013, adopted the following: 1. City Council request Mayor Rob Ford to apologize for misleading the City of Toronto as to the existence of a video in which he appears to be involved in the use of drugs. 2. City Council urge Mayor Rob Ford to co-operate fully with the Toronto Police in their investigation of these matters by meeting with them in order to respond to questions arising from their investigation. 3. City Council request Mayor Rob Ford to apologize for writing a letter of reference for Alexander "Sandro" Lisi, an alleged drug dealer, on City of Toronto Mayor letterhead. 4. City Council request Mayor Ford to answer to Members of Council on the aforementioned subjects directly and not through the media. 5. City Council urge Mayor Rob Ford to take a temporary leave of absence to address his personal issues, then return to lead the City in the capacity for which he was elected. 6. City Council request the Integrity Commissioner to report back to City Council on the concerns raised in Part 1 through 5 above in regard to the Councillors' Code of Conduct.
    [Show full text]
  • Can Toronto Be Run Like a Business? Observations on the First Two Years of the Ford Mayoralty in Torontoi
    Can Toronto be Run Like a Business? Observations on the First Two Years of the Ford Mayoralty in Torontoi. Richard Stren Cities Centre University of Toronto Prepared for Presentation at the CPSA Annual Conference, Edmonton, Alberta June, 2012 Draft Only. No Citations or References without Express Consent of the Author. Mayoral candidate Rob Ford’s speech at the National Ethnic Press and Media Council of Canada (August 9, 2010): I come from the private sector, where my father started a labeling company….I’m proud to say that with the help of my brothers we have expanded to three locations in New Jersey, Chicago and Rexdale, and we now employ approximately 300 people….What I have seen in the last ten years is very disturbing at City Hall. I’ve seen taxes go up and services go down… In the private sector, we deliver, it’s very simple. The first rule is, the customer is always right. The second rule is, repeat the first rule…In politics we should take the exact same attitude….The taxpayer is the boss of all the civil servants….I really take a business approach to politics…in that customer service is lacking at city hall. …Customer service is number one. Downloaded on May 10, 2012 at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QOBotCHFRZE Video interview with Rob Ford on the day before the 2010 election: …[my brother and I have] run my father’s business that he started in 1962. We’ve expanded into Chicago and New Jersey. That’s the business approach I want to take to running the city.
    [Show full text]
  • October 2018 Montreal, QC Canadian Parliament to Approve Filipino Heritage Month
    Volume XXXVI No. 10 October 2018 Montreal, QC www.filipinostar.org Canadian Parliament to approve Filipino Heritage Month Paulina Corpuz Zalma Sahid. Liberal MP, Mike Colle, Liberal MPP, Neethan Shan, Councilor, Ward 42, first conceived the idea of Filipino Scarborough-Center Eglinton-Lawrence Scarborough-Rouge River Heritage month The House Commons is 1st, and a second reading on October 31st. For this reason, the executive the bill. Nineteen members have accelerating the passage of a private 25th to be followed by short speeches assistant of Madame Zahid signed on to be joint seconders of M- member Bill M-155 sponsored by a from members supporting the bill. recommended to have a Montreal 155: Sukh Daliwhal (Surrey-Newton), Liberal Party MP, Madame Salma Zahid News communicated by e-mail group to be organized to go to Ottawa Gary Anandasangaree (Scarborough- of Scarborough Center, who presented indicated that the bill has been moved and witness the historic vote in the first reading of the bill on October up for expected adoption on October Parliament adopting the passage of See Page 4 Filipino Heritage Canada just legalized pBy Goretcthe.n FWrazee,hPBoS Newcs Hoour,ualccdordinpg torthoe WforildtBa? nk, whereas Making Sense. Canada has a population of 36 million (Oct. 17, 2018) Recreational and a GDP of $1.7 trillion. marijuana in Canada became legal “A lot of countries are going to Wednesday, opening up a new multi- be looking at Canada and their ability billion dollar cannabis market to to make this a success,” said Colin businesses and investors. Busby, a research director at the The move will likely have Canadian-based Institute for Research significant economic implications for on Public Policy.
    [Show full text]
  • Minutes of Meetings Held on May 25 and June 13, 2016
    Toronto District School Board June 22, 2016 Regular Meeting June 22, 2016 A regular meeting was convened at 2:04 p.m. on Wednesday, June 22, 2016, in the Boardroom, 5050 Yonge Street, Toronto, with Robin Pilkey, Chair of the Board, presiding. The following members were present: Trustees Jennifer Arp, Alexander Brown, Sheila Cary- Meagher, Jerry Chadwick, Tiffany Ford, Gerri Gershon, Chris Glover, Pamela Gough, Parthi Kandavel, Shelley Laskin, Ken Lister, Ausma Malik, Chris Moise, Robin Pilkey, Neethan Shan, Marit Stiles, Jennifer Story, Chris Tonks, Manna Wong and Student Trustees Sammy Al Rubaie and Hamima Fattah. Regrets were received from Trustee David Smith. The office of Trustee held by Howard Kaplan was vacated following his death on April 11, 2016. The office of Trustee held by Michael Ford was vacated following his resignation on May 4, 2016. 1. Official Election Results for By-election in Toronto Centre-Rosedale, Ward 14 and Appointment to the Program and School Services Committee The office of Trustee held by Sheila Ward was vacated following her death on February 17, 2016. In addition, with the departure of former Trustee Ward and following the Organizational meeting held on December 1, 2015, a vacancy on the Program and School Services Committee was created. A by-election to fill the vacancy in Ward 14, Toronto Centre-Rosedale was held on Monday, June 20, 2016. The Board received a posting from City of Toronto’s City Clerk’s Office informing the Board of the results of the by-election (see page 16) and declaring Chris Moise elected as a member of the Toronto District School Board for the term of office June 21, 2016 to November 30, 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Remuneration Report Appendix and Attachments
    Attachment 1 City of Toronto Summary of Remuneration and Expenses for Members of Council For the year ended December 31, 2020 Expenses from the Corporate Expenses Expenses Paid by Remuneration Office Expenses Council General Business Travel Charged to Agencies, Corporations Total Ward and Benefits (See Support Staff (See Appendices Budget (See (See Appendix City Divisions and Other Bodies (See Remuneration and Member of Council No. Appendix A) Salaries B1, F) Appendices B2, F) C1) (See Appendix D) Appendix C2, E) Expenses $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ Ainslie, Paul 24 147,654 443,918 29,844 17,376 1,844 579 641,215 Bailão, Ana 9 143,254 481,178 13,930 52,703 1,667 349 693,081 Bradford, Brad 19 147,654 479,659 36,241 62,145 1,930 121 727,750 Carroll, Shelley 17 148,260 454,737 23,397 22,060 376 648,831 Colle, Mike 8 128,150 422,517 31,823 38,719 44 621,253 Crawford, Gary 20 147,654 449,990 21,304 18,601 3 637,552 Cressy, Joe 10 147,654 468,989 13,031 105,462 735,136 Filion, John 18 143,169 481,189 30,030 12,881 84 667,353 Fletcher, Paula 14 145,881 465,850 31,082 18,149 389 661,351 Ford, Michael 1 143,254 438,940 19,614 43,058 644,866 Grimes, Mark 3 147,654 427,231 17,748 22,052 5,342 620,027 Holyday, Stephen 2 147,654 303,412 198 13,591 464,855 Karygiannis, Jim (Note 9) 22 91,151 273,994 15,931 13,269 2,545 396,890 Lai, Cynthia 23 148,780 448,702 27,024 41,840 1,430 161 667,937 Layton, Mike 11 147,654 472,441 13,955 19,798 653,848 Matlow, Josh 12 147,654 482,000 17,795 35,742 95 683,286 McKelvie, Jennifer 25 150,979 433,588 26,612 49,358 660,537 Minnan-Wong,
    [Show full text]