DOCSLIB.ORG

Planning and Environment Handbook VCAT Decisions and Commentary

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Planning and Environment Handbook VCAT Decisions and Commentary Planning and Environment Handbook VCAT decisions and commentary Dr Joseph Monaghan Holding Redlich M:13117515_3 JBM Page 2 About the author Joseph Monaghan is a partner at Holding Redlich. He is a Law Institute of Victoria Accredited Specialist in both Administrative Law, and also Planning and Environment Law. Joseph can be contacted at [email protected]. M:13117515_3 JBM Page 3 Table of Contents List of acronyms and abbreviations.............................................................................................................. 5 Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................................... 6 Introduction and overview ........................................................................................................................... 7 The Decisions .............................................................................................................................................. 12 Admissibility of evidence and experts .................................................................................................... 12 Ancillary use ........................................................................................................................................... 16 Affordable accommodation ................................................................................................................... 17 Cultural Heritage Management Plans .................................................................................................... 19 Compulsory acquisition and acquisition of land .................................................................................... 22 Development Plan Overlay Schedules .................................................................................................... 26 Declarations ............................................................................................................................................ 26 Easements .............................................................................................................................................. 30 Existing use rights ................................................................................................................................... 31 Enforcement ........................................................................................................................................... 34 Gaming and liquor .................................................................................................................................. 41 GAIC ........................................................................................................................................................ 42 Green wedge .......................................................................................................................................... 43 Humorous ............................................................................................................................................... 46 Mediated outcomes and consent orders ............................................................................................... 47 Misconduct ............................................................................................................................................. 49 Natural justice ........................................................................................................................................ 53 Out of sequence subdivisions ................................................................................................................. 55 Panels ..................................................................................................................................................... 56 Permit amendments ............................................................................................................................... 59 Permit conditions – ongoing effect ........................................................................................................ 61 Permit extension .................................................................................................................................... 62 Precautionary principle .......................................................................................................................... 67 Public open space contributions ............................................................................................................ 75 Planning policy, including Plan Melbourne and ResCode ...................................................................... 78 Restrictive covenants ............................................................................................................................. 81 Repeat appeals ....................................................................................................................................... 82 Screening ................................................................................................................................................ 82 Signage ................................................................................................................................................... 83 Standing .................................................................................................................................................. 86 Solar panels ............................................................................................................................................ 90 Subdivision process ................................................................................................................................ 92 M:13117515_3 JBM Page 4 Social effects ........................................................................................................................................... 94 Sea level rise ........................................................................................................................................... 99 Section 173 agreements ....................................................................................................................... 103 Secondary consents .............................................................................................................................. 108 Technical codes and standards ............................................................................................................ 110 Transitional provisions ......................................................................................................................... 111 Water .................................................................................................................................................... 111 List of cases............................................................................................................................................... 117 M:13117515_3 JBM Page 5 List of acronyms and abbreviations AH Act Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006 (Vic) ADJR Act Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1975 (Cth) AH Regulations Aboriginal Heritage Regulations 2007 (Vic) CHMP Cultural Heritage Management Plan EE Act Environment Effects Act 1978 (Vic) EP Act Environment Protection Act 1970 (Vic) EPBC Act Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) EP Amendment Act Environment Protection Amendment Act 2018 (Vic) GR Act Gambling Regulation Act 2003 (Vic) IL Act Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) LG Act Local Government Act 1989 (Vic) P&E Act Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic) SPPF State Planning Policy Framework Subdivision Act Subdivision Act 1988 (Vic) VCAT The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal VCAT Act Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic) VL Act Valuation of Land Act 1960 (Vic) VPPs Victoria Planning Provisions Water Act Water Act 1989 (Vic) Water Act (Cth) Water Act 2007 (Cth) M:13117515_3 JBM Page 6 Acknowledgements This publication is intended as a resource for lawyers, planners, Council officers and others with an interest in planning and environment matters practicing in that jurisdiction in VCAT. The booklet is a consolidation of a number of decision summaries that I prepared over the years as a writer of case summaries for the VPELA Revue, with updates and revisions to those summaries made by me for the purposes of this publication, as well as new commentary, more recent decisions and notes on legislative developments. I would like to acknowledge Mark Marsden for his time taken to review these summaries and Luke Flegeltaub for his assistance proofreading this booklet. Joseph Monaghan, 3 May 2021 M:13117515_3 JBM Page 7 Introduction and overview This booklet is structured around key points that have been the focus of important decisions in the planning and environment jurisdiction. These are arranged in alphabetical order, with decisions summarised under each of those points presented in chronological order. There is a convenient index and I have also hyperlinked the decisions, as well as legislation, to Austlii. I have also included a list of decisions. What then, were some of the trends that developed over the 10 year period? By way of summary: VCAT’s jurisdiction 1. Since the advent of the “new administrative law” in the 1970s specialist Tribunals have proliferated throughout Australian jurisdictions. That role will likely continue
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 7.8 North East Link - Bulleen Park
    Council Agenda 26/11/18 7.8 North East Link - Bulleen Park Abstract This report provides an update on the North East Link Authority (NELA) Bulleen Park land use planning project. It seeks Council support for an initial concept design for the Bulleen Park land use plan which incorporates the Boroondara Tennis Centre (BTC) and the 18-hole Freeway Golf Course (FGC). See Attachment 1 for an aerial image showing the project study area. NELA has initiated the study for the Bulleen Park area and has included the BTC and FGC in the project scope. Officers understand the aim of the project is to ensure no sporting club or facility is worse off as a result of the construction and operation of the North East Link (NEL). NELA has advised it intends to finalise the project by early 2019 for inclusion as an appendix in the NEL Environment Effects Statement (EES). NELA has conducted initial consultation about the project, with a workshop held at the Veneto Club on 8 August 2018. The workshop was attended by sporting clubs impacted by the NEL and Council representatives from Boroondara and Manningham. Officers understand NELA staff have also been meeting with sporting clubs and facility operators on an individual basis to discuss the project. Within a limited timeframe, Boroondara officers have prepared high-level concept plans for the FGC and BTC to be considered in the Bulleen Park land use planning study (Attachments 2 and 3). The plans respond to the impact of the NEL on several holes of the FGC by relocating the BTC to the same location and extending the FGC to land north of the current course edge located in Manningham.
    [Show full text]
  • 03380 Alpine AR FINAL
    Alpine Resorts Co-ordinating Council Annual Report 2002/03 This report covers the period 1 July 2002 to 30 June 2003, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Financial Management Act 1994. Contents 2002-2003 IN REVIEW 4 Chairperson's Report 4 2002-2003 Key Achievements 5 Review of Operations and Financial Conditions 6 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE 7 Introduction 7 Council Mission 7 Organisational Chart 7 Undertakings and Services Provided 7 Council Meetings 8 Membership 8 Freedom of Information 10 Reporting Requirements under Part II of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 10 Reporting Requirements under the Financial Management Act 1994 10 Reporting Requirements under the Whistleblowers Protection Act 2001 11 FINANCIAL REPORTS 12 Certification of Financial Statements 12 Statement of Financial Performance for Year Ended 30 June 2003 12 Statement of Cash Flows for Year Ended 30 June 2003 13 Statement of Financial Position as at 30 June 2003 13 Notes to and forming part of the Financial Report 14 Auditor-General's Report 20 Compliance Index 21 3 2002/03 in Review CHAIRPERSON'S REPORT The Council continues to provide a forum for addressing a range of The Council has been instrumental in tackling the issue of industry wide issues that face Alpine Resort Management Boards adaptability of alpine areas to climate change and has coordinated (ARMBs). the finalisation of a comprehensive, cooperative research study by Council played a critical role in addressing the problems faced by CSIRO, funded by a range of Victorian, New South Wales, the small resorts (Lake Mountain, Mt Baw Baw and Mt Stirling) in Commonwealth, and private sector partners.
    [Show full text]
  • 5281 VCH Ann Report FRONT Section FA1.Indd
    VISION CONTENTS The Foundation envisages a Chair’s Report 3 community where: Board of Governance 4 CEO’s Report 7 • health is a fundamental human right; Investments at a Glance 8 Highlights of an Active Year 10 • everyone shares in the responsibility Health Promotion Action 13 for promoting health; and Reducing Smoking 14 • everyone benefits from improved Increasing Physical Activity 18 health outcomes. Promoting Mental Health and Wellbeing 22 Addressing Health Inequalities 26 Other Areas of Health Promotion Action 30 MISSION Supporting Research 32 The Foundation’s mission is to build Raising Awareness Conference Papers and Presentations 36 the capabilities of organisations, Publications 38 communities and individuals in International Delegations 38 ways that: Major VicHealth Publications 38 Media Coverage 39 • change social, economic, cultural Policy Consultations and Submissions 40 and physical environments to Committees and Working Groups 41 improve health for all Victorias; and VicHealth Awards 43 Funded Projects 45 • strengthen the understanding and Financial Statements 66 the skills of individuals in ways that Organisational Chart 92 support their efforts to achieve and Board Appointed Advisory Panels 93 maintain health. Staff List 96 Photo: Promoting health is a powerful, cost-effective and efficient way to maintain a healthier community. www.vichealth.vic.gov.au 1 VICHEALTH CHAIR’S REPORT THIS YEAR, VICHEALTH AGAIN traction in the broader community, us the opportunity to strengthen PLAYED A LEAD ROLE IN beyond the research and health partnerships and understand some of THE PROMOTION OF PUBLIC sectors. The Walking School Bus, the issues affecting people across the HEALTH BY SUPPORTING AND a VicHealth initiative, for example, state.
    [Show full text]
  • 7.5. Final Outcomes of 2020 General Valuation
    Council Meeting Agenda 24/08/2020 7.5 Final outcomes of 2020 General Valuation Abstract This report provides detailed information in relation to the 2020 general valuation of all rateable property and recommends a Council resolution to receive the 1 January 2020 General Valuation in accordance with section 7AF of the Valuation of Land Act 1960. The overall movement in property valuations is as follows: Site Value Capital Improved Net Annual Value Value 2019 Valuations $82,606,592,900 $112,931,834,000 $5,713,810,200 2020 Valuations $86,992,773,300 $116,769,664,000 $5,904,236,100 Change $4,386,180,400 $3,837,830,000 $190,425,800 % Difference 5.31% 3.40% 3.33% The level of value date is 1 January 2020 and the new valuation came into effect from 1 July 2020 and is being used for apportioning rates for the 2020/21 financial year. The general valuation impacts the distribution of rating liability across the municipality. It does not provide Council with any additional revenue. The distribution of rates is affected each general valuation by the movement in the various property classes. The important point from an equity consideration is that all properties must be valued at a common date (i.e. 1 January 2020), so that all are affected by the same market. Large shifts in an individual property’s rate liability only occurs when there are large movements either in the value of a property category (e.g. residential, office, shops, industrial) or the value of certain locations, which are outside the general movements in value across all categories or locations.
    [Show full text]
  • Melbourne Supply Area–Extractive Industry Interest Areas Review
    DEPARTMENT OF PRIMARY INDUSTRIES Melbourne Supply AreaExtractive Industry Interest Areas Review Geological Survey of Victoria Technical Record 2003/2 A. Olshina & P. Burn Bibliographic reference: Olshina, A. & Burn, P., 2003. Melbourne Supply AreaExtractive Industry Interest Areas Review. Geological Survey of Victoria. Technical Record 2003/2. Geological Survey of Victoria. Ó Crown (State of Victoria) Copyright 2003 Geological Survey of Victoria ISSN 1324 0307 ISBN 1 74106 838 X Keywords: extractive industry, quarry, planning, Melbourne, Victoria, stone resources, sand resources This report may be purchased from: The authors would like to thank Gayle Ellis for Business Centre, proofreading and typesetting this report. Department of Primary Industries Eighth Floor, 240 Victoria Parade, East Melbourne, 3002 Disclaimer: This publication may be of assistance to you but the Or accessed at: State of Victoria and its employees do not guarantee http://www.dpi.vic.gov.au/ that the publication is without flaw of any kind or is wholly appropriate for your particular purposes and For further technical information contact: therefore disclaims all liability for any error, loss or Manager, other consequences which may arise from you relying Geological Survey of Victoria, on any information in this publication. P O Box 500 East Melbourne 3002. Acknowledgments: Many of the original concepts and planning policies used in this report were developed by Barbara Guerin and the Environment and Natural Resources Committee (ENRC) and by Frank Jiricek, formerly of the Department of Natural Resources and Environment. The following MPD staff contributed to this document: Ben White provided significant assistance to the consultation process for this report. Roger Buckley and Linda Bibby provided valuable input to the contents of this report.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Meeting of Council Minutes 12/10/2020
    SPECIAL MEETING OF COUNCIL MINUTES (Open to the public) Monday 12 October 2020 Online - Delivered via Webex Events Commencement 6.34pm Attendance Councillor Cynthia Watson (Mayor) Councillor Jane Addis (at 6.39pm) Councillor Phillip Healey Councillor Lisa Hollingsworth Councillor Steve Hurd Councillor Jim Parke Councillor Coral Ross Councillor Felicity Sinfield Councillor Garry Thompson Councillor Jack Wegman Apologies Nil Officers Phillip Storer Chief Executive Officer Shiran Wickramasinghe Director Urban Living Carolyn McClean Director Community Support Bruce Dobson Director Customer and Transformation Daniel Freer Director Places and Spaces Andrew Dix Chair of Audit and Risk Committee David Thompson Manager Governance and Legal Chris Hurley Integrity Coordinator Callista Clarke Acting Chief Financial Officer Jacinta Stevens Program Management Office Lead Celia Robinson Coordinator Governance Helen Pavlidis Governance Projects Officer Elizabeth Manou Governance Projects Officer Special Meeting of Council Minutes 12/10/2020 Table of contents 2. Declaration of conflict of interest of any councillor or council officer 3 3. Presentation of officer reports 3.1 Annual Report 2019-20 3 3.2 Revised Instrument of Delegation from Council to the Chief Executive Officer 4 3.3 Recommendations of the Audit Committee Meeting held 19 August 2020 5 3.4 Letters Under Seal - Outgoing Mayor and Chairs of Delegated Committees 2019-20 5 3.5 August 2020 Monthly Financial Report 6 City of Boroondara Page 2 Special Meeting of Council Minutes 12/10/2020 2. Declaration of conflict of interest of any councillor or council officer Nil Councillor Addis entered the meeting at 6.39pm 3. Presentation of officer reports 3.1 Annual Report 2019-20 This report is presented for Council endorsement of the Annual Report for the 2019- 20 financial year.
    [Show full text]
  • Making Parks and Tourism Work Free Mount Stirling Resurrecting Reefs Yarra Bend Park Be Part of Nature
    A LOVE LETTER TO PARKS JUNE 2017 NO 269 VOICES FROM THE FOREST Will We stop NAture’s decliNe? MAKING PARKS AND TOURISM WORK FREE MOUNT STIRLING RESURRECTING REEFS YARRA BEND PARK Be part of nature PRESIDENT Euan Moore DIRECTOR Matt Ruchel CONTENTS Level 3, 60 Leicester St, Carlton, VIC 3053 3 From the President ABN 34 217 717 593 4 Updates Telephone: (03) 9341 6500 Facsimile: (03) 9347 5199 5 We Love Parks E-mail: [email protected] 6-7 Voices from the forest Web: www.vnpa.org.au 8-9 Alarm at logging of western forests VNPA’S VISION and woodlands The Victorian National Parks Association vision is to ensure Victoria is a place with a diverse and healthy natural environment 10-11 Will we stop nature’s decline? that is protected, respected and enjoyed by all. 11 A step in the right direction for nature protection EDITORIAL COMMITTEE Euan Moore, Matt Ruchel, Philip Ingamells, Meg Sobey (editor). 12-13 A tale of two marsupials GETTING INVOLVED IN VNPA 14-15 Sanctuary or developers dream? Everyone can help in the conservation of Victoria’s 15 Horses hurting hoodies wild and beautiful places. You can: 16-17 Free Mount Stirling • make a donation • become a regular giver or member 18-19 Making parks and tourism work • volunteer. You’ll be welcome in the office, on a campaign or in a park 20-21 Resurrecting reefs • leave a bequest to VNPA in your will. 22-23 Celebrating two decades of growth PUBLISHING POLICY All advertisements should be compatible with VNPA policies.
    [Show full text]
  • HUME REGION LOCAL GOVERNMENT NETWORK Submission to the Parliamentary Inquiry Into Local Economic Development Initiatives in Victoria August 2012
    HUME REGION LOCAL GOVERNMENT NETWORK Submission to the Parliamentary Inquiry Into Local Economic Development Initiatives in Victoria August 2012 Secretariat: Ann Telford – Executive Officer PO Box 238, Wangaratta 3676 20 August 2012 Mr Neale Burgess MLA Chair Economic Development and Infrastructure Committee Parliament House, Spring Street Melbourne, Vic 3002 Dear Mr Burgess The Hume Region Local Government Network (HRLGN) is pleased to have the opportunity to make a submission to this Parliamentary Inquiry. HRLGN is comprised of twelve member councils: Alpine Shire Council Benalla Rural City Council City of Greater Shepparton Indigo Shire Council Mansfield Shire Council Mitchell Shire Council Moira Shire Council Murrindindi Shire Council Rural City of Wangaratta Strathbogie Shire Council Towong Shire Council Wodonga Rural City Council While some of our members may also make submissions on behalf of their individual council, this submission reflects our shared, regional perspective. We believe economic development - including investment attraction, sustainable growth and tourism is fundamental to the development of prosperous rural and regional communities and critical to the sustainability and liveability of our region. We would welcome the opportunity to present this submission at a hearing and answer any questions the Committee may have. For further information, please contact our Executive Officer Ann Telford, by phone on , or by email to Yours sincerely Cr Roberto Paino CHAIR – HUME REGION LOCAL GOVERNMENT NETWORK SUBMISSION BY HUME
    [Show full text]
  • Shire of Murrindindi 2010 Eee Adolescent Community Profiles I
    Adolescent Community Profile Shire of Murrindindi 2010 eee Adolescent Community Profiles i Adolescent Community Profile Shire of Murrindindi 2010 This Adolescent community profile was prepared by the Office for Children and Portfolio Coordination, in the Victorian Department of Education and Early Childhood Development. The series of Adolescent community profiles draw on data on outcomes for children compilied through the Victorian Child and Adolescent Monitoring System (VCAMS). The profiles are intended to provide local level information on the health, wellbeing, learning, safety and development of adolescents. They are published to: • Equip communties with the information required to identify the needs of adolescents and their families within their local government area. • Assist local government areas to identify key areas of vulnerability for adolescents in their local area and use this information to assist with early intervention strategies. • Support local government and regional planning of youth services; and • Assist community service agencies working with vulnerable families and young people. The Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, the Department of Human Services, the Department of Health , Victoria Police and the Australian Bureau of Statistics provided data for this document. Adolescent Community Profiles ii Published by the Victorian Government Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. June 2011 (revised from May 2011 release) © Copyright State of Victoria, Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, 2011 This publication is copyright. No part may be reproduced by any process except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968. Principal author and analyst: Hiba Molaeb Assisted by: Christopher Reid and Ileana Teleki Authorised by the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, 2 Treasury Place, East Melbourne, Victoria, 3002.
    [Show full text]
  • Director Urban Living
    Success Profile Director Urban Living City of Boroondara JULY 2021 www.davidsonwp.com Table of Contents Online Advert 3 About the City of Boroondara 4 City of Boroondara Councillors 5 Executive Organisational Structure 6 Vision, Values & Purpose 7 Role Overview 8 The Opportunity 8 Accountability Areas 10 The Ideal Candidate 12 What does success look like? 13 For Further Information 15 Davidson | Director Urban Living | City of Boroondara 2 Online Advertisement Join a Contemporary and Progressive Council leading CX at State level Seeking a visionary City Planner Key transformational leadership role Now is an extremely exciting time to join the City of Boroondara, as they enter their second year of implementing their 5 Year Customer First Program (a leading edge, future focused transformation that places customer experience at the centre of everything they do and that delivers a more seamless, convenient and empowering experience). If you wish to play a lead role in reshaping an organization across all dimensions of service design and delivery - culture, technology, skills, work processes - this is the role for you. Located in the leafy inner-eastern suburbs of Melbourne, the City of Boroondara is a vibrant, livable city which fosters the cultural, environmental, economic and personal wellbeing of its community through the delivery of a range of services that positively impact the lives of their 183,000+ community. https://www.boroondara.vic.gov.au/ Reporting to the CEO and forming a critical member of their high callibre executive, the Director Urban Living will be instrumental in providing thought leadership to ensure Council is able to meet the community’s aspirations in relation to land use, sustainable design, heritage conservation and customer experience.
    [Show full text]
  • VICTORIA Royal Botanic Gardens, Melbourne Royal
    VICTORIA Royal Botanic Gardens, Melbourne Royal WHERE SHOULD ALL THE TREES GO? STATE BY STATE VIC WHAT’S HAPPENING? There has been an In VIC, 44% of urban LGAs have overall increase of undergone a significant loss of tree canopy, Average canopy cover for urban VIC is 3% in hard with only 8% having had a significant surfaces, which is increase in shrubbery. 18.83% exactly the same down 2.06% from rate of increase as NSW, but overall 20.89% VIC has around in 2013. 5% less hard surfaces than NSW. THERE HAVE BEEN QUITE A FEW SIGNIFICANT CANOPY LOSSES. – Notably in the City of Ballarat (5%), Banyule City Council (4.6%), Cardinia Shire Council (5.9%), Nillumbik Shire Council (12.8%), Maroondah City Council (4.7%), Mornington Peninsula Shire (4.7%) and Eira City Council (4.8%). WHERE SHOULD ALL THE TREES GO? VICTORIA VIC THE MOST & LEAST VULNERABLE 2.5 Rating Glen Eira City Council, Kingston City 3.0 Rating Council, City of Stonnington 2.0 Rating City of Port Phillip, Maroondah City Council, Moonee Valley City Council, Whittlesea City of Casey, Banyule City Council Council, Wyndham City Council 3.5 Rating 1.5 Rating City of Boroondara, City of Monash, Mornington Peninsula Shire, Frankston City Council, City of Greater Bendigo, City of Greater Dandenong, Cardinia Shire Council, City of Melbourne City of Greater Geelong, Hobsons Bay City Council, City of Melton 1.0 Rating 4.0 Rating City of Brimbank, Maribyrnong City Council, Yarra City Council, City of Whitehorse, Manningham City Council Moreland City Council 4.5 Rating Yarra Ranges Council,
    [Show full text]
  • Mitchell Shire Flood Emergency Plan a Sub-Plan of the Municipal Emergency Management Plan
    Mitchell Shire Flood Emergency Plan A Sub-Plan of the Municipal Emergency Management Plan For Mitchell Shire Council and VICSES North East Region Kilmore & Seymour Units Version 5.0 November 2018 Intentionally left blank Mitchell Shire Flood Emergency Plan – A Sub-Plan of the MEMP Ver 5.0 Nov 2018 - ii - Table of Contents PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .............................................................................................. V DISTRIBUTION LIST ................................................................................................................................ VI DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL FORM / AMENDMENT CERTIFICATE .................................................. VII LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS & ACRONYMS ............................................................................................. 1 PART 1. INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................... 2 1.1 MUNICIPAL ENDORSEMENT ........................................................................................................... 2 1.2 THE MUNICIPALITY ........................................................................................................................ 3 1.3 PURPOSE AND SCOPE OF THIS FLOOD EMERGENCY PLAN .............................................................. 3 1.4 MUNICIPAL FLOOD PLANNING COMMITTEE (MFPC) ....................................................................... 3 1.5 RESPONSIBILITY FOR PLANNING, REVIEW & MAINTENANCE OF THIS PLAN ......................................
    [Show full text]