DOCSLIB.ORG

The Book of Enoch in the Light of the Qumran Wisdom Literature

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Book of Enoch in the Light of the Qumran Wisdom Literature CHAPTER FIVE THE BOOK OF ENOCH IN THE LIGHT OF THE QUMRAN WISDOM LITERATURE I The Book of Watchers is now regarded as the earliest apocalypse that we possess, and the Book of Enoch as a whole as a prime example of the apocalyptic genre, a major source for our understanding of apocalyp- ticism. The apocalyptic genre is, of course, traditionally regarded as representing a continuation of prophecy, and the Book of Enoch does make use of prophetic genres in a variety of ways. It is also of inter- est to note that the quotation of 1:9 in Jude 14–15 is introduced by the statement that Enoch “prophesied” about the heretics condemned by Jude, and that in Ethiopian tradition of a much later age Enoch is called the fi rst of the prophets. But in the Book of Enoch itself, Enoch is described as a scribe and a wise man, and his writings as the source of wisdom, and although the book cannot in any sense be regarded as a conventional wisdom book, this inevitably raises the question of the relationship of the book to ‘wisdom’ and the wisdom literature. Within the last decade Randall Argall and Ben Wright have attempted to answer this question by comparing 1 Enoch with Sirach. Thus in a recent monograph, 1 Enoch and Sirach: A Comparative Literary and Conceptual Analysis of the Themes of Revelation, Creation and Judgment, Argall argued that there are similarities in the way 1 Enoch and Sirach treat the themes of revelation, creation, and judgment, and “that their respective views were formulated, at least in part, over against one another.”1 Ben Wright has taken views like this further and has argued that Ben Sira actively took the side of the temple priests in polemical opposition against those, such as the authors of the Book of Watchers, who criticized them.2 He, like 1 Randall A. Argall, 1 Enoch and Sirach: A Comparative Literary and Conceptual Analysis of the Themes of Revelation, Creation and Judgment (SBLEJL 8; Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1995), 8. 2 Benjamin G. Wright, “‘Fear the Lord and Honour the Priest.’ Ben Sira as Defender of the Jerusalem Priesthood,” in The Book of Ben Sira in Modern Research (ed. Pancratius C. Beentjes; BZAW 255; Berlin: de Gruyter, 1997), 189–222. 92 chapter five Argall, has drawn attention to a number of passages in Sirach that he believes were directly aimed at the views represented in 1 Enoch, such as Sirach 34:1–8 or 3:21–24, Neither seek what is too diffi cult for you, nor investigate what is beyond your power. Refl ect upon what you have been commanded, for what is hidden is not your concern. Do not meddle in matters that are beyond you, for more than you can understand has been shown you. For their conceit has led many astray, and wrong opinion has impaired their judgement (Sir 3:21–24, NRSV). Boccacini has similarly spoken of a “bitter debate” being refl ected in Sirach against the Apocalyptic movement.3 It may be thought, however, that this is only part of the answer. Since the work of von Rad4 and, subsequently, of Müller,5 the apocalyptic genre has frequently been regarded as having its roots in mantic wisdom. In relation to the Book of Enoch, VanderKam in particular has drawn attention to parallels between the Enochic tradi- tions and the mantic traditions of Mesopotamia. In the light of the widely accepted view that the fi gure of Enoch incorporates features associated with Enmeduranki of Sippar, who was initiated into the secret of the gods and was the founder of the guild of diviners (the baru), VanderKam argued that this hardly represented an independent development.6 However Andreas Bedenbender has argued that although the fi gure of Enoch has been infl uenced by the traditions associated with Enmeduranki, in the case of Enoch—just as in Daniel—there is no clear resemblance to mantic wisdom. He claimed that VanderKam’s analysis of the technique of the mantic sages in Babylon showed more 3 Gabriele Boccaccini, Middle Judaism: Jewish Thought, 300 B.C.E. to 200 C.E. (Min- neapolis: Fortress, 1991), 77–125 (here 80). VanderKam’s comment, “Ben Sira mani- fests a certain restraint about Enoch”, perhaps better refl ects the relationship between Sirach and the Book of Enoch ( James C. VanderKam, Enoch: A Man for All Generations (Studies on Personalities of the Old Testament; Columbia, South Carolina: University of South Carolina Press, 1995), 107). 4 Gerhard von Rad, Theologie des Alten Testaments. Vol. 2: Die Theologie der prophetischen Überlieferungen Israels (Munich: Kaiser, 1960; 9th ed., 1987), 316–38. 5 Hans-Peter Müller, “Mantische Weisheit und Apokalyptik,” in Congress Volume, Uppsala 1971 (ed. Pieter A. H. de Boer; VTSup 22; Leiden: Brill, 1972), 268–93. 6 James C. VanderKam, Enoch and the Growth of an Apocalyptic Tradition (CBQMS 16; Washington, DC: Catholic Biblical Association of America, 1995), 6–8, 52–75 (here 70)..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Wisdom in Daniel and the Origin of Apocalyptic
    WISDOM IN DANIEL AND THE ORIGIN OF APOCALYPTIC by GERALD H. WILSON University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602 In this paper, I am concerned with the relationship of the book of Daniel and the biblical wisdom literature. The study draws its impetus from the belief of von Rad that apocalyptic is the "child" of wisdom (1965, II, pp. 304-15). My intent is to test von Rad's claim by a study of wisdom terminology in Daniel in order to determine whether, in fact, that book has its roots in the wisdom tradition. Adequate evidence has been gathered to demonstrate a robust connection between the nar­ ratives of Daniel 1-6 and mantic wisdom which employs the interpreta­ tion of dreams, signs and visions (Millier, 1972; Collins, 1975). Here I am concerned to dispell the continuing notion that apocalyptic as ex­ hibited in Daniel (especially in chapters 7-12) is the product of the same wisdom circles from which came the proverbial biblical books of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Job and the later Ben Sirach. 1 I am indebted to the work of Why bray ( 1974), who has dealt exhaustively with the terminology of biblical wisdom, and to the work of Crenshaw (1969), who, among others, has rightly cautioned that the presence of wisdom vocabulary is insufficient evidence of sapiential influence. 2 Whybray (1974, pp. 71-154) distinguishes four categories of wisdom terminology: a) words from the root J:ikm itself; b) other characteristic terms occurring only in the wisdom corpus (5 words); c) words char­ acteristic of wisdom, but occurring so frequently in other contexts as to render their usefulness in determining sapiential influence questionable (23 words); and d) words characteristic of wisdom, but occurring only occasionally in other OT traditions (10 words).
    [Show full text]
  • The Reception of the Book of Daniel (And
    The Reception of the Book of Daniel (and Danielic Literature) in the Early Church Wisdom and Apocalypticism Section SBL Annual Meeting in Washington, November 18-22, 2006 by Gerbern S. Oegema, McGill University 3520 University Street, Montreal, QC. Canada H3A 2A7 all rights reserved: for seminar use only. Any quotation from or reference to this paper should be made only with permission of author: [email protected] Abstract Whereas cosmogony has traditionally been seen as a topic dealt with primarily in wisdom literature, and eschatology, a field mostly focused upon in apocalyptic literature, the categorization of apocryphal and pseudepigraphic writings into sapiential, apocalyptic, and other genres has always been considered unsatisfactory. The reason is that most of the Pseudepigrapha share many elements of various genres and do not fit into only one genre. The Book of Daniel, counted among the Writings of the Hebrew Bible and among the Prophets in the Septuagint as well as in the Christian Old Testament, is such an example. Does it deal with an aspect of Israel’s origin and history, a topic dealt mostly dealt with in sapiential thinking, or only with its future, a question foremost asked with an eschatological or apocalyptic point of view? The answer is that the author sees part of the secrets of Israel’s future already revealed in its past. It is, therefore, in the process of investigating Israel’s history that apocalyptic eschatology and wisdom theology meet. This aspect is then stressed even more in the later reception history of the Book of Daniel as well as of writings ascribed to Daniel: if one wants to know something about Israel’s future in an ever-changing present situation, one needs to interpret the signs of the past.
    [Show full text]
  • Syllabus, Deuterocanonical Books
    The Deuterocanonical Books (Tobit, Judith, 1 & 2 Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, and additions to Daniel & Esther) Caravaggio. Saint Jerome Writing (oil on canvas), c. 1605-1606. Galleria Borghese, Rome. with Dr. Bill Creasy Copyright © 2021 by Logos Educational Corporation. All rights reserved. No part of this course—audio, video, photography, maps, timelines or other media—may be reproduced or transmitted in any form by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval devices without permission in writing or a licensing agreement from the copyright holder. Scripture texts in this work are taken from the New American Bible, revised edition © 2010, 1991, 1986, 1970 Confraternity of Christian Doctrine, Washington, D.C. and are used by permission of the copyright owner. All Rights Reserved. No part of the New American Bible may be reproduced in any form without permission in writing from the copyright owner. 2 The Deuterocanonical Books (Tobit, Judith, 1 & 2 Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, and additions to Daniel & Esther) Traditional Authors: Various Traditional Dates Written: c. 250-100 B.C. Traditional Periods Covered: c. 250-100 B.C. Introduction The Deuterocanonical books are those books of Scripture written (for the most part) in Greek that are accepted by Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches as inspired, but they are not among the 39 books written in Hebrew accepted by Jews, nor are they accepted as Scripture by most Protestant denominations. The deuterocanonical books include: • Tobit • Judith • 1 Maccabees • 2 Maccabees • Wisdom (also called the Wisdom of Solomon) • Sirach (also called Ecclesiasticus) • Baruch, (including the Letter of Jeremiah) • Additions to Daniel o “Prayer of Azariah” and the “Song of the Three Holy Children” (Vulgate Daniel 3: 24- 90) o Suzanna (Daniel 13) o Bel and the Dragon (Daniel 14) • Additions to Esther Eastern Orthodox churches also include: 3 Maccabees, 4 Maccabees, 1 Esdras, Odes (which include the “Prayer of Manasseh”) and Psalm 151.
    [Show full text]
  • The Old Testament: Part Thirteen Wisdom Books of the Bible
    The Old Testament: Part Thirteen Wisdom Books of the Bible The following are some excerpts from a fuller experience and reason. The means of acquiring introduction to the Wisdom books of the bible. (For wisdom are through study, instruction, discipline, the complete introduction, see Article 66 on my reflection, meditation and counsel. He who hates Commentaries on the Books of the Old Testament.) wisdom is called a fool, sinner, ignorant, proud, wicked, and senseless. The message of the Wisdom There are five books in the Old Testament called teachers can be summed up in the words of St. Paul: “Wisdom books”: Job, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, “What things are true, whatever honorable, whatever Ecclesiasticus and Wisdom. In Catholic Bibles, the just, whatever holy, whatever lovable, whatever of Song of Songs and Psalms are also grouped in the good repute, if there be any virtue, if anything worthy Wisdom books section. of praise, think upon these things. And what you have The reader who moves from the historical or learned and received and heard and seen in me, these prophetical books of the Bible into the Wisdom books things practice (Phil.4:8-9); whether you eat or drink, will find him/herself in a different world. While the or do anything else, do all for the glory of God” (1Cor. Wisdom books differ among themselves in both style 10:31). and subject matter, they have in common the following characteristics: The Catholic Bible – Personal Study Edition offers the following short description for each of the seven books 1. They show minimum interest in the great themes contained in the Wisdom section of Catholic Bibles.
    [Show full text]
  • Hebrew and Christian Bibles: a Comparative Chart
    Jewish and Christian Bibles: A Comparative Chart HEBREW BIBLE Orthodox Christian OT Catholic Christian OT Protestant Christian OT (a.k.a. TaNaK/Tanakh or Mikra) (based on longer LXX; various editions) (Alexandrian LXX, with 7 deutero-can. bks) (Cath. order, but 7 Apocrypha removed) Torah / Books of Moses Pentateuch Pentateuch (Law) Law (Pentateuch) 1) Bereshit / Genesis 1) Genesis 1) Genesis 1) Genesis 2) Shemot / Exodus 2) Exodus 2) Exodus 2) Exodus 3) VaYikra / Leviticus 3) Leviticus 3) Leviticus 3) Leviticus 4) BaMidbar / Numbers 4) Numbers 4) Numbers 4) Numbers 5) Devarim / Deuteronomy 5) Deuteronomy 5) Deuteronomy 5) Deuteronomy Nevi’im / Former Prophets Historical Books Historical Books Historical Books 6) Joshua 6) Joshua 6) Joshua 6) Joshua 7) Judges 7) Judges 7) Judges 7) Judges 8) Samuel (1&2) 8) Ruth 8) Ruth 8) Ruth 9) Kings (1&2) 9) 1 Kingdoms (= 1 Sam) 9) 1 Samuel 9) 1 Samuel 10) 2 Kingdoms (= 2 Sam) 10) 2 Samuel 10) 2 Samuel 11) 3 Kingdoms (= 1 Kings) 11) 1 Kings 11) 1 Kings Nevi’im / Latter Prophets 12) 4 Kingdoms (= 2 Kings) 12) 2 Kings 12) 2 Kings 10) Isaiah 13) 1 Chronicles 13) 1 Chronicles 13) 1 Chronicles 11) Jeremiah 14) 2 Chronicles 14) 2 Chronicles 14) 2 Chronicles 12) Ezekiel 15) 1 Esdras 13) The Book of the Twelve: 16) 2 Esdras (= Ezra + Nehemiah) 15) Ezra 15) Ezra Hosea, Joel, 17) Esther (longer version) 16) Nehemiah 16) Nehemiah Amos, Obadiah, 18) JUDITH 17) TOBIT Jonah, Micah, 19) TOBIT 18) JUDITH Nahum, Habakkuk, 19) Esther (longer version) 17) Esther (shorter version) Zephaniah, Haggai, 20) 1 MACCABEES 20)
    [Show full text]
  • A Thematic Study of Doctrines on Death and Afterlife According to Targum Qohelet
    A Thematic Study of Doctrines on Death and Afterlife according to Targum Qohelet By LAWRENCE RONALD LINCOLN DISSERTATION Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of PHD in Ancient Cultures FACULTY OF ARTS AND SOCIAL SCIENCES PROMOTER: PROF JOHANN COOK April 2019 Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Declaration By submitting this thesis electronically, I declare that the entirety of the work contained therein is my own, original work, that I am the sole author thereof (save to the extent explicitly otherwise stated), that reproduction and publication thereof by Stellenbosch University will not infringe any third party rights and that I have not previously in its entirety or in part submitted it for obtaining any qualification. April 2019 Copyright © 2019 Stellenbosch University All rights reserved ii Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Abstract This dissertation examined how the Targum radically transformed Qohelet’s pessimistic, secular and cynical views on the human condition by introducing a composite rabbinical theology throughout the translation with the purpose of refuting the futility of human existence and the finality of death. The Targum overturned the personal observations of Qohelet and in its place proposed a practical guide for the living according to the principles of rabbinic theological principles. While BibQoh provided few if any solutions for the many pitfalls and challenges of life and lacking any clear references to an eschatology, the Targum on the other hand promoted the promise of everlasting life as a model for a beatific eschatological future. The dissertation demonstrated how the targumist exploited a specific translation strategy to introduce rabbinic ideologies to present the targum as an alternative context to the ideologies of wisdom literature as presented in Biblical Qohelet.
    [Show full text]
  • The Apocrypha Donald E
    What are Protestants Missing? The Apocrypha Donald E. Knebel November 27, 2016 Slide 1 1. This is the first in a series of four presentations that will look at Jewish literature written between the end of events in the Old Testament and the writing of the New Testament. 2. These writings help to bridge the large historical and theological gap between the Old and New Testaments. 3. As one author writes: “The fact is that the atmosphere in which the New Testament is written is in large part the product of the period between the testaments, and no amount of study of the Old Testament can solely explain it.” Surburg, Introduction to the Intertestamental Period at 9. 4. Today, we will talk about the Apocrypha, books included in the Bibles of Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox Christians but omitted from most Protestant Bibles. 5. Next week we will look at a collection of Jewish writings called Pseudepigrapha, one of which is actually quoted in the New Testament and several of which were relied upon by New Testament writers. 6. In the third week, we will look at the Dead Sea Scrolls, which have shed enormous light on Jewish beliefs at the time of Jesus and show great similarities to many Christian beliefs. 7. Finally we will look at the writings of Jewish contemporaries of Jesus and the New Testament writers, including Philo and Josephus. 8. Over the course of this series, we will see that the New Testament and Christian teachings draw a lot more on Jewish ideas and Jewish expressions than most Christians realize.
    [Show full text]
  • Wisdom Literature in the Ancient World
    Session 1: MARCH 2 SundayTeacher.com PASSWORD: xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Wisdom Literature in the Ancient World hroughout history, every culture has valued wisdom. Certainly all of us at Ttimes have wished we were wiser than we are. When life presents us with a difficult decision or an excruciating problem, and we are at a loss to know what to do, we long for divine wisdom. Sometimes God speaks directly to us to communicate His wisdom; often, however, He speaks through wise people instead. Because God has given selected people extraordinary wisdom, it is not surprising that the teachings of these wise individu- als were written down and preserved for future generations in ancient times. The Bible includes several books widely recognized as wisdom literature, particularly the books of Job, Proverbs, and Ecclesiastes. There are also several wisdom psalms that address the same issues and concerns. The book of James in the New Testament has many characteristics of wisdom literature. In addition, the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox canons of the Old Testament include two apocryphal wisdom books: the Wisdom of Solomon and Sirach. Egyptian hieroglyphics crafted of colored glass cover the sarcophagus of Petosiris, The Israelites were not the only ancient priest of Thoth, god of wisdom and writing (ca. 300 BC). The Israelites were not the people who recorded wisdom literature. only ancient people who recorded wisdom literature. Mesopotamia and Egypt were Mesopotamia and Egypt were also centers also centers of wisdom in the ancient world, and both of these civilizations have left us of wisdom in the ancient world, and both of wisdom literature.
    [Show full text]
  • Pentateuch Historical Wisdom Prophetic New Testament Gospels
    Pentateuch Historical Wisdom Prophetic New Testament Gospels chattily.Stripier andAcheulian brimstony and Major unmated still Penniegully his stapled voters phoneticallysteady. Absorbefacient and swathe and his unproclaimeddoters laconically Bishop and tolls bedward. her tube bop while Jean concretizing some swear SAINT JOHN'S BIBLE Saint John's University Bookstore. Brush up to new testament gospels were permitted, wisdom books of all make sense has a god commits himself but we have as historically grounded. From wisdom books such. The first represented on the limits of jesus christ is put the greatest of ruth in them was the vast majority is in the wisdom. Surely goodness to thinking, not as well as word order, just a kindly face him by christians who sent a discount for. The new testament and historically true bread alone in it does not begin until the archenemy of the basis of his appeal to copyright the person? And new testament gospels are placed, and stages in the pentateuch. Bible arose that. Yet neither a new testament prophets to a sharp distinction has not found in the pentateuch was not as part, and revelation in. What original translations into question has not included in a kingdom. Judaism depends on historical particularity in that gospel of prophetic messianism appeared in the gospels indicate that only if minority, which the baptist. In it was especially significant for its rise to navigate to be viewed it in particular for the pharisees who had families. Several original new testament prophetic writings is wisdom literature is human wisdom proverbs, gospel has played a sharp distinction between their historic nature.
    [Show full text]
  • Is New Moon Full Moon?
    Is New Moon Full Moon? Shalom. We should all have the unwavering desire to serve and please Alohym and keep his commandments, (Ecclesiastes 12:13) for this is the duty of Man. In this note study we have supplied Scripture as a first witness and several other witnesses of which are Historical and Scriptorial that expose the theory of New Moon being Full Moon. As we continue to Learn, Study and Pray in truth we move closer to Alohym and forward in service to him. In the book of Beginnings we can see that Alohym made the Sun & Moon with a PURPOSE in creation. The moon was created to divide the day from the night, to be a sign, to govern his appointed time of meeting, to number days and years, and to rule over the night and stars. It was called the lesser LIGHT, in comparison to the sun, the greater LIGHT. What is New Moon: In light of recent events, there seem to be somewhat of a confusion as to when New Moon is, what Chodesh is and how this relates to the appointed times of our Creator. So, to keep it very simple, let’s begin with New Moon. In Hebrew, the word for NEW is: Chadash. This word varies depending on how it’s used. When it’s used as a VERB, CHADASH H2318 is then used to describe the Verb. When this verb is used in Conjunction with the Moon, its s describing an event that’s taking place. The Moon is: REBUILDING AND/OR REPAIRNG its light.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach, Ecclesiasticus
    1 THE WISDOM OF JESUS THE SON OF SIRACH, OR ECCLESIASTICUS The Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach, also called Ecclesias- ticus, is recognized as Deuterocanonical Scripture by the Roman Catholic, Greek Orthodox, and Russian Orthodox Churches. The Prologue of the Wisdom of Jesus the Son of Sirach. WHEREAS many and great things have been delivered to us by the law and the prophets, and by the others that have followed in their steps, for which we must give Israel the praise for instruction and wisdom; and since not only the readers need to become skillful themselves, but also those who love learning must be able to profit those who are outside, both by speaking and writing; my grandfather Jesus, having much given himself to the reading of the law, and the prophets, and the other books of our fathers, and having gained great familiarity with them, was also drawn on himself to write somewhat pertaining to instruction and wisdom, in order that those who love learning, and are devoted to these things, might make progress much more by living according to the law. You are entreated therefore to read with favor and attention, and to pardon us, if in any parts of what we have labored to interpret, we may seem to fail in some of the phrases. For things originally spoken in Hebrew don’t have the same force in them when they are translated into another language. Not only these, but the law itself, and the prophecies, and the rest of the books, have no small difference, when they are spoken in their original Sirach 1:1 2 Sirach 1:9 language.
    [Show full text]
  • My Brothers and Sisters, Both Today's Reading from Sirach and Today's
    22nd Sunday per Annum - C Sirach 3:17-18, 20, 28-29; Hebrews 12:18-19, 22-24a; Luke 14:1, 7-14 Little Flower - 9/1/19 My Brothers and Sisters, Both today’s reading from Sirach and today’s Gospel focus on the virtue of humility. The book of Sirach is part of the Wisdom literature of the Bible. As I mentioned in last week’s homily, the Wisdom literature offers all kinds of practical insights into real life. The reading from Sirach begins, “My child, conduct your affairs with humility.” I would suggest humility is the recognition that we are not self-made men or women. It is the recognition that all that we are and all that we have are God’s gifts to us either directly or indirectly through others. As much as adolescents and young adults try to be independent and self-sufficient, the truth is that human beings are interdependent. Sirach advises, “Humble yourself the more, the greater you are.” There is practical wisdom in this advice. The more we are rich, famous, attractive, intelligent, athletic, or successful, the more we are tempted to think we are self-made. It is often much harder for gifted people and high achievers to be humble. True humility requires gratitude and generosity. I have told this story before, but it is worth telling again. One time I was talking to a minister who was the father of that year’s Brownsburg High School valedictorian. When I congratulated him and his wife on their daughter’s achievements and valedictory address, he said, “My wife and I are humbly grateful.” He went on to explain that both he and his wife recognized how many people contributed to their daughter’s success.
    [Show full text]