PLANNING COMMITTEE Agenda Item No. APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF MARCH 2016
App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
14/0078 Full Application Milburn Conversion of redundant former farm buildings to MILBURN COURT, REAR/SIDE OF The Milburn Trust APPROVED provide 5 dwellings (including 1 affordable local MILBURN HOUSE, MILBURN, needs dwelling) and including clearance of derelict PENRITH, buildings to provide new garage block and shared amenity space
15/0950 Outline Dacre Outline application for new village shop and three LAND ADJ TO ROSE COTTAGE, Mr J Irving REFUSED Application dwellings with all matters reserved. NEWBIGGIN, PENRITH, CA11 0HS
15/0958 Full Application Hesket Proposed conversion of existing disused stone barns LOW STREET HOUSE, PLUMPTON, Mr R McManus APPROVED to 2no dwellings. PENRITH, CA11 0JD
15/0959 Listed Building Hesket Listed building consent for proposed conversion of LOW STREET HOUSE, PLUMPTON, Mr R McManus APPROVED existing disused stone barns to 2no dwellings. PENRITH, CA11 0JD
15/1044 Full Application Penrith Proposed replacement dwelling THE LODGE, GREENGILL HOUSE, Equorium Property APPROVED GREENGILL, PENRITH, CA11 8SE Company Ltd
15/1045 Full Application Penrith Proposed replacement dwelling. ELM COTTAGE, GREEN LANE, Equorium Property APPROVED GREENGILL, PENRITH, CA11 8SE Company Ltd
15/1066 Tree Works Greystoke 1) Pruning to damaged roots for trees T7, T5, T6 and RECTORY FARM, GREYSTOKE, Mr Nicholas Richards APPROVED (TPO) W1; Reason: Remedial work following damage to PENRITH, CA11 0UJ roots; Tree Preservation Order No 152, 2013, Rectory Farm and The Old Rectory, Greystoke.
15/1082 Full Application Hesket Conversion and change of use of domestic CALTHWAITE HALL LODGE, Mr A Kenvig APPROVED outbuilding to holiday let (Class C3). CALTHWAITE, PENRITH, CA11 9QU
15/1094 Full Application Greystoke Change of use of 2 x garages to holiday let COLBY HOUSE, BERRIER ROAD, Mr D Hutton REFUSED accommodation. GREYSTOKE, PENRITH, CA11 0UB
15/1095 Full Application Asby Variation of condition no. 2 (plans compliance) OAK TOPS, GREAT ASBY, Mr N Hughes APPROVED attached to planning approval 13/0084 comprising of APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, amendments to doors and windows. CA16 6EX
08 April 2016 Page 1 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
15/1097 Full Application Appleby Variation to planning condition 13, LPA ref: 14/0594 LAND ADJ TO CROSS CROFT, Mr A McNally - Story APPROVED dated 13th May 2015 to enable no more than 64 APPLEBY, Homes units to be occupied unless any of the following exceptions occur; i) a footpath diversion and stopping up order that incorporates the diversion of the existing footpath adjacent to the cemetery, the stopping up of it to prevent any access to the Carlisle – Settle public railway crossing from the site (including the erection of signage and fencing prohibiting such access) and re-routing of the footpath to the north east of the site that can in principle afford connectivity to Drawbriggs Lane, has been made and confirmed by the LPA or Secretary of State, or ii) the Secretary of State, upon consideration of a lawfully made stopping up order as aforementioned in point i) does not confirm the order. Upon any confirmed diversion and stopping up order coming into force, the new footpath route shall be fully completed including lighting.
15/1103 Advertisement Penrith Relocate existing signage and erection of new drive MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT LTD, McDonald's Restaurant APPROVED thru signage suite. PENRITH TRAIN STATION, Ltd ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 7JQ
15/1122 Listed Building Great Strickland Proposal to replace the existing windows / doors to TAYLORS FARM, GREAT Mr & Mrs J Cantrell APPROVED all elevations with like for like design / colour STRICKLAND, PENRITH, CA10 3DF
15/1128 Full Application Alston Retrospective planning application to build a poultry 4 HILL TOP COTTAGES, Mr P Drew APPROVED shed. NENTHEAD, ALSTON, CA9 3PB
15/1134 Listed Building Penrith Listed building consent for the refurbishment THE GLOUCESTER ARMS, GREAT R&H Leisure Ltd APPROVED including internal and external alterations and the DOCKRAY, PENRITH, CA11 7DE display of advertisements.
15/1139 Full Application Crosby Garrett Demolition of existing building and erection of MOORSIDE, CROSBY GARRETT, Mr R Harper APPROVED replacement agricultural building. KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4PR
15/1146 Change of Use Ousby Change of use from agricultural building to TODD HILLS, MELMERBY, Mr & Mrs C & C Rowley APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouses. PENRITH, CA10 1HP
15/1158 Full Application Hartley Demolition of existing dormer bungalow and erection KIRKBY VIEW, HARTLEY, KIRKBY Mr & Mrs I Hind APPROVED of replacement dwellinghouse. STEPHEN, CA17 4JJ
15/1165 Full Application Penrith Proposed extension. LOW FELL, LOWTHER STREET, Mr & Mrs R & E APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 7UW Anderson
16/0011 Full Application Kaber Proposed agricultural buiding. POPPIN COTTAGE, KABER, M C S AE Staley REFUSED KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4EF
08 April 2016 Page 2 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
16/0012 Full Application Penrith Change of use of office (use class A2) to drinking 9-10 ST ANDREWS CHURCHYARD, Mr G Gledhill APPROVED establishment (use class A4). PENRITH, CA11 7YE
16/0016 Full Application Glassonby The replacement of the existing 10 metre high replica LAND AT HARTSIDE CAFÉ, EE Ltd APPROVED telegraph pole with a new 15 metre high monopole ALSTON, CA9 3BW supporting 3no antennas and a 600mm transmission dish, the installation of an additional radio equipment cabinet and development works ancillary thereto.
16/0021 Full Application Skelton Proposed erection of a store. MEADOW PLANTATION, NORTH Mr G Moss APPROVED THACKWOOD, SOUTHWAITE, CARLISLE, CA4 0PT
16/0024 Full Application Asby Proposed alteration and extension and double GARTH HILL, GREAT ASBY, Mrs Cockburn APPROVED garage. APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6EX
16/0026 Full Application Penrith Proposed first floor extension above existing ground ASPEN HEIGHTS, CARLETON HILL Mr J Pallister APPROVED floor double garage, together with linking of roof to ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 8WH existing adjoining first floor roof.
16/0027 Full Application Lazonby Refurbishment and rationalisation of the existing LOW PLAINS FARM, CALTHWAITE, Mr C Wickins - AMP APPROVED 1MW(e) biomass gasification combined heat and PENRITH, CA11 9RQ Low Plains Ltd power plant including a new building, an extension to the existing building, a new yard and a backup biomass boiler.
16/0028 Full Application Ravenstonedale Removal of condition 1 (attachment to existing THE COACH HOUSE, BROWNBER Ms SLL & RE APPROVED property) attached to planning permission 03/0956. LANE, NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE, Newcombe & Stickings KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4NX
16/0029 Full Application Penrith Single storey stand alone building for a new electric CUMBRIA CONSTABULARY, Mr P Robinson APPROVED substation and associated switch gear room. POLICE HEADQUARTERS, CARLETON HALL, PENRITH, CA10 2AU
16/0034 Full Application Penrith Change of use of retail unit to provide an additional LONSDALE CINEMAS, ALHAMBRA Mr Alan Towers APPROVED screen to existing cinema. CINEMA, 47 MIDDLEGATE, PENRITH, CA11 7PT
16/0046 Tree Works Penrith T2 Sycamore: Remove the large lower level bough DAISY FARM, OUTHGILL, KIRKBY Mrs B Smart REFUSED (TPO) on the north facing side of tree at or near to the main STEPHEN, CA17 4JU trunk; Tree Preservation Order No 103, 2000, Daisy Farm, Outhgill. Reasons: Detracts from appearance; Substantial size; Possible falling risk during periods of strong winds and potential risk to field users and damage to tree if bough split off.
16/0048 Full Application Penrith Proposed removal of existing rear extension and 7 GRAHAM STREET, PENRITH, Dr S Brading APPROVED construction of new single storey rear extension. CA11 9LG
08 April 2016 Page 3 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
16/0049 Listed Building Glassonby Listed building consent for proposed new door and RED LION BARN, GAMBLESBY, Mr & Mrs K Rodgers APPROVED window openings in rear elevation. PENRITH, CA10 1HR
16/0050 Change of Use Ousby Change of use from agricultural building to TODD HILLS, MELMERBY, Mr & Mrs C&C Rowley APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouse. PENRITH, CA10 1HP
16/0055 Full Application Penrith Change of use of agricultural buildings to 3no PLUMPTON HEAD, PLUMPTON, Mr & Mrs Threlfell APPROVED dwellinghouses (use class C3). Change of use of PENRITH, CA11 9NP 2no agricultural buildings to provide storage/garage accommodation and change of use of land for domestic curtilage area.
16/0070 Change of Use Penrith Change of use from agricultural building to GREENGILL BARN, GREENGILL Equorium Property Co. APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouse. FARM, GREENGILL, PENRITH, Ltd CA11 8SE
16/0072 Change of Use Langwathby Change of use from agricultural building to 3 no. ROAD HEAD FARM, WINSKILL, Messrs Awde APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouses PENRITH, CA10 1PB
16/0074 Reserved Matters Skelton Reserved matters application for residential dwelling. PLOT 4 CHAPELFIELD, SKELTON, Mr M Little APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9TB
16/0079 Full Application Penrith Rear extension / roof alterations to first floor. 40 HOLME RIGGS AVENUE, Mr B Hodgson APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 8NL
16/0081 Full Application Mallerstang Proposed side extension to dwelling. HELMBAR COTTAGE, OUTHGILL, Mr & Mrs I Smart APPROVED KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4JU
16/0086 Full Application Penrith Proposed 2no storey side extension. 10 ROMAN ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 Mrs K Robertson APPROVED 8DZ
16/0088 Full Application Brough Store for agricultural equipment / lambing shed. CASTLE GARAGE, NEW ROAD, Mr J Pattinson APPROVED BROUGH, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4AX
16/0091 Change of Use Ravenstonedale Change of use from agricultural building to POTTS FIELD HOUSE BARN AT Mr N Curr APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouse. BOWDERDALE HEAD, NEWBIGGIN ON LUNE, KIRKBY STEPHEN,
16/0093 Full Application Penrith Silage clamp structure. MILBURN HOUSE, BOWSCAR, Mr R Threlfell APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9NW
16/0094 Full Application Penrith Covered tank. MILBURN HOUSE, BOWSCAR, Mr R Threlfell APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9NW
16/0098 Full Application Alston Proposed rear extension to house, extension to BUNKERSHILL, GARRIGILL, Mr C Jennings APPROVED outbuilding and new garage. ALSTON, CA9 3EW
08 April 2016 Page 4 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
16/0100 Change of Use Mallerstang Change of use of agricultural building to BARN TO THE NORTH EAST OF Mr S Alderson APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouse. AISGILL FARM, MALLERSTANG, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4JX
16/0101 Full Application Ravenstonedale Installation of four new windows on barn conversion LOW THACKTHWAITE, Mr D Caldow APPROVED with permitted development rights removed. RAVENSTONEDALE, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4NN
16/0102 Reserved by Penrith Approval of condition 3 relating to landscaping of FIELD 5070 STONEYBECK Mr R Bell APPROVED Cond application 15/0748. ROUNDABOUT, PLUMPTON, PENRITH, CA11 8RR
16/0104 Full Application Orton Creation of agricultural access and track. LAND AT GHYLL BANK FARM, Messrs J Burra APPROVED RAISBECK, ORTON, PENRITH, CA10 3SG
16/0106 Non-Material Bolton Non material amendment to reserved matters LAND AT NORTH END, BOLTON, Willlan trading APPROVED Amend approval 13/0329 relating to the location of a wall. PENRITH,
16/0110 Full Application Waitby Proposed erection of two storey rear extension. STATION HOUSE, SMARDALE, Mr Keith Venning APPROVED KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4HG
16/0111 Advertisement Penrith Advertisement consent for the Gloucester Arms. GLOUCESTER ARMS, GREAT R & H Leisure Ltd APPROVED DOCKRAY, PENRITH, CA11 7DE
16/0113 Full Application Penrith Erection of extension to front elevation for additional 31 MONNINGTON WAY, PENRITH, Mr & Mrs P Isherwood APPROVED living accommodation. CA11 8QJ
16/0115 Full Application Hesket Proposed demolition and rebuild of detached garage. 1 BROCKLEY MOOR, PLUMPTON, Mr I Cannon APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9NT
16/0116 Full Application Orton Change of use of existing stone built agricultural BOWDERDALE FOOT, Mr P Mells APPROVED building to form two one bedroom self catering units BOWDERDALE, NEWBIGGIN-ON- and prep/common/games rooms above. LUNE, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4NB
16/0117 Full Application Penrith Part first storey, garage, sun room & porch FRENCHFIELD, BROUGHAM, Mr Firth Glassford APPROVED extensions to existing dwelling. PENRITH, CA10 2AA
16/0124 Full Application Sockbridge & Erection of a single car port. FALLOWFIELD, MARGATE CROSS, Mr Montgomery APPROVED Tirril TIRRIL, PENRITH, CA10 2LN
16/0126 Tree Works (CA) Dufton 1) Remove Spruce tree; 2) Plum tree: Reduce height NORFOLK HOUSE, DUFTON, R A Betts APPROVED to 8-12 feet; 3) Weeping Birch: Remove lowest four APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, branches; Dufton Conservation Area. CA16 6DB
16/0127 Tree Works (CA) Orton Ash T2: Remove tree; Laburnum: Remove tree; Ash PETTY HALL - OPEN LAND Mr P Knowles APPROVED T3: Crown raise over farm track; Limes x 2: Crown OPPOSITE VILLAGE HALL, ORTON, thin 20-30% and prune to clear footpath; Orton PENRITH, CA10 3RX Conservation Area.
08 April 2016 Page 5 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
16/0132 Full Application Hesket Proposed extension to existing dwelling to provide THWAITEHOWE, HIGH HESKET, Mr Robert APPROVED new kitchen and dining room. CARLISLE, CA4 0HS Cowperthwaite
16/0134 Full Application Long Marton Variation of condition 2 of application 14/0356 to SITE ADJ MISSION ROOM, KNOCK, Mr Barden APPROVED alter details of proposal. APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6DN
16/0135 Change of Use Crosby Prior approval for change of use of agricultural BARN NORTH OF CRAKE TREES, M/s M & R Tuer APPROVED PD/PN Ravensworth building to dwellinghouse. MANOR FARM, CROSBY RAVENSWORTH, PENRITH, CA10 3JG
16/0137 Reserved by Kirkby Stephen Discharge of conditions 1-13 of 08/0456. BRIDGE END HOUSE, APPLEBY Mr D Jones APPROVED Cond ROAD, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17
16/0140 Tree Works (CA) Appleby Fell Ash tree (due to it being split into two trunks, one FIELD ADJACENT 8 MURTON MISS ELIZABETH APPROVED being dead; loss of dead branches; possible damage CLOSE, APPLEBY-IN- TAYLOR to property); Appleby Conservation Area. WESTMORLAND, CA16 6RE
16/0141 Full Application Appleby Proposed main shop window glazing alterations. 22 BOROUGHGATE, APPLEBY-IN- Mr J Pape APPROVED WESTMORLAND, CA16 6XB
16/0142 Full Application Waitby Kitchen and dining extension to side and rear. HOLME FARM, TOWNGATE, Mr & Mrs R and R Lees APPROVED SMARDALE, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4HG
16/0145 Full Application Appleby Proposed general purpose agricultural building. BARROWMOOR FARM, COLBY, Messrs W.P Williamson APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6BD
16/0152 Full Application Kirkby Stephen Replacement of existing boundary wall and creation 23 NORTH ROAD, KIRKBY Mr Geoff Wall APPROVED of new doorway in gable end with replacement door STEPHEN, CA17 4RH on western side.
16/0159 Householder Greystoke Prior approval for larger home extension, 10 PARK ROAD, GREYSTOKE, Mr M Nicholson APPROVED PD/PN conservatory to rear. PENRITH, CA11 0UF
16/0163 Tree Works (CA) Asby 1) Reduce crown of Hornbeam in rear garden to 6m IVY HOUSE, GREAT ASBY, Mr Andrew Savage APPROVED high, to reduce shading, and maintain at this height APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, for subsequent years; 2) Remove overgrown Holly CA16 6HD hedging plant, to improve driveway access; Great Asby Conservation Area.
08 April 2016 Page 6 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
16/0164 Tree Works (CA) Ravenstonedale T1 Beech: Reduce crown 25% (4m height, 2.5m HIGH CHAPEL HOUSE, Mr David Wedd APPROVED lateral) and shape; T2 Beech: Remove dead wood RAVENSTONEDALE, KIRKBY and prune clear of property by 3.5m; T4 Sycamore: STEPHEN, CA17 4NQ prune clear of building 3.5m; T5 Beech: Crown raise to 4m and remove dead wood; T6 Beech: Prune to clear property by 3.5m and crown raise to improve view from bedroom; Ravenstonedale Conservation Area.
16/0165 Tree Works Penrith Beech tree: Light trimming of 2 branches close to LYNDON HOUSE, CARLETON Mr Gordon Carrick APPROVED (TPO) property as shown on photos provided (and DERRICK DRIVE, PENRITH, CA11 discussed with Rob Sim); Tree Preservation Order 8LS No 123, 2005, The Parklands, Penrith.
16/0170 Notice of Intention Musgrave Proposed forestry track between land adjacent Low FORESTRY TRACK AT BLEATARN, Mr E Hewetson APPROVED Ploughlands and Bleatarn Wood. BLEATARN, KIRKBY STEPHEN,
16/0198 Non-Material Penrith Non material amendment to 14/0948 to alter 34 BRENTFIELD WAY, PENRITH, Mr C Henderson APPROVED Amend windows on rear elevation and roof profile. CA11 8DL
In relation to each application it was considered whether the proposal was appropriate having regard to the Development Plan, the representations which were received including those from consultees and all other material considerations. In cases where the application was approved the proposal was considered to be acceptable in planning terms having regard to the material considerations. In cases where the application was refused the proposal was not considered to be acceptable having regard to the material and relevant considerations. In all cases it was considered whether the application should be approved or refused and what conditions, if any, should be imposed to secure an acceptable form of development.
08 April 2016 Page 7 of 7