I n t e r n at i o n a l J o u r n a l o f H i g h - E n e r g y P h y s i c s CERN
COURIERV o l u m e 47 N u m b e r 6 J u ly/A u g u s t 2 0 07
LHCb prepares for RICH physics
Neutrinos LHC focus Inside story Borexino starts On the trail of At the far side to take data p8 heavy flavour p30 of the world p58
CCJulAugCover1.indd 1 11/7/07 13:50:51 Project1 10/7/07 13:56 Page 1 CONTENTS
Covering current developments in high- energy physics and related fields worldwide CERN Courier is distributed to member-state governments, institutes and laboratories affiliated with CERN, and to their personnel. It is published monthly, except for January and August. The views expressed are not necessarily those of the CERN management. Editor Christine Sutton CERN CERN, 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland E-mail [email protected] Fax +41 (0) 22 785 0247 Web cerncourier.com
Advisory board James Gillies, Rolf Landua and Maximilian Metzger
Laboratory correspondents: COURIERo l u m e u m b e r u ly u g u s t V 47 N 6 J /A 20 07 Argonne National Laboratory (US) Cosmas Zachos Brookhaven National Laboratory (US) P Yamin Cornell University (US) D G Cassel DESY Laboratory (Germany) Ilka Flegel, Ute Wilhelmsen EMFCSC (Italy) Anna Cavallini Enrico Fermi Centre (Italy) Guido Piragino Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (US) Judy Jackson Forschungszentrum Jülich (Germany) Markus Buescher GSI Darmstadt (Germany) I Peter IHEP, Beijing (China) Tongzhou Xu IHEP, Serpukhov (Russia) Yu Ryabov INFN (Italy) Barbara Gallavotti Jefferson Laboratory (US) Steven Corneliussen JINR Dubna (Russia) B Starchenko KEK National Laboratory (Japan) Youhei Morita Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory (US) Spencer Klein Los Alamos National Laboratory (US) C Hoffmann A closer look at antimatter p13 VERITAS seeks more truth p19 Cold physics at the Pole p58 NIKHEF Laboratory (Netherlands) Paul de Jong Novosibirsk Institute (Russia) S Eidelman News 5 NCSL (US) Geoff Koch Orsay Laboratory (France) Anne-Marie Lutz CERN announces new date for LHC start-up … and Council approves PSI Laboratory (Switzerland) P-R Kettle additional resources. DØ and CDF find same new baryon. VIRGO opens Saclay Laboratory (France) Elisabeth Locci Science and Technology Facilities Council (UK) Peter Barratt up new astronomy. Borexino begins data taking at Gran Sasso. AGILE
Produced for CERN by IOP Publishing Ltd takes its place in orbit. German particle physics gets funding boost. IOP Publishing Ltd, Dirac House, Temple Back, Bristol BS1 6BE, UK Tel +44 (0)117 929 7481; e-mail [email protected]; web iop.org Sciencewatch 10 Publisher Joseph Tennant Astrowatch 11 Art director Andrew Giaquinto Production editor Jesse Karjalainen 12 Technical illustrator Alison Tovey CERN Courier Archive Advertising manager Ed Jost Display sales North America Heather Harad Features Recruitment advertisement manager Moo Ali Keeping antihydrogen: the ALPHA trap 13 Recruitment and classified sales Adam Hylands and Sonia Nardo Recruitment and classified sales North America Mark Gaglione Jeffrey Hangst describes a new antihydrogen experiment at CERN. Advertisement production Jayne Boulton Marketing executive Chinh Dinh Carbon ions pack a punch 17 Advertising Oncologist Hirohiko Tsujii talks about his work to Carolyn Lee. Tel +44 (0)117 930 1026 (for UK/Europe display advertising), +1 215 627 0880 (for North American display advertising), or VERITAS telescopes celebrate first light 19 +44 (0)117 930 1196 (for recruitment advertising); e-mail [email protected]; fax +44 (0)117 930 1178 David Hanna looks at the VHE gamma-ray telescope array in Arizona.
General distribution Courrier Adressage, CERN, 1211 Geneva 23, DIS 2007: physics at HERA and beyond 23 Switzerland. E-mail [email protected] A report from the latest workshop on deep-inelastic scattering. In certain countries, to request copies or to make address changes, contact: China Keqing Ma, Library, Institute of High Energy Physics, Heavy-ion workshop looks to the future 27 PO Box 918, Beijing 100049, People’s Republic of China. Physicists meeting in Finland warm up for heavy-ion physics at the LHC. E-mail [email protected] Germany Veronika Werschner, DESY, Notkestr. 85, 22607 Hamburg, Germany. E-mail [email protected] LHCb prepares for a RICH harvest of rare beauty 30 Italy Loredana Rum or Anna Pennacchietti, INFN, Casella Postale RICH detectors get ready for heavy-flavour physics at the LHC. 56, 00044 Frascati, Rome, Italy. E-mail loredana.rum@i nf.it UK Mark Swaisland, Chadwick Library, Daresbury Laboratory, Daresbury, Warrington, Cheshire WA4 4AD, UK. Faces and Places 35 E-mail [email protected] US/Canada Published by Cern Courier, 6N246 Willow Drive, Recruitment 42 St Charles, IL 60175, US. Periodical postage paid in St Charles, IL, US. Fax 630 377 1569. E-mail [email protected] Bookshelf 53 POSTMASTER: send address changes to: Creative Mailing Services, PO Box 1147, St Charles, IL 60174, US Inside Story 58 Published by European Organization for Nuclear Research, CERN, 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland. Tel +41 (0) 22 767 61 11 Telefax +41 (0) 22 767 65 55
Printed by Warners (Midlands) plc, Bourne, Lincolnshire, UK
© 2007 CERN ISSN 0304-288X
Cover: Ring imaging Cherenkov (RICH) detectors will play an important role in the LHCb experiment at CERN (p30). This photograph, taken from the front of the detector, shows hexagonal elements of the spherical mirrors of RICH2, with reflections of the flat mirrors and the photon-detector enclosures. It also shows Michael Hoch, who took the photograph.
CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugContents3.indd 3 11/7/07 13:55:28 CCJul07p04 10/7/07 11:39 Page 1
PO Box 870 / 300 Crane Street Sweetwater, Texas 79556 (USA) Ph: 325-235-4276 or 888-800-8771 Fax: 325-235-2872 e-mail: [email protected] NEWS
L H C N e w s CERN announces new date for LHC start-up…
Speaking at the 142nd session of the CERN Council on 22 June, CERN’s director-general, Robert Aymar, announced that the LHC will start up in May 2008, taking the first steps towards studying physics at a new high- energy frontier. A low-energy run originally scheduled for 2007 has been dropped as the result of a number of minor delays accumulated over the final months of LHC installation and commissioning, including the failure in March of a pressure test in an inner-triplet magnet assembly. The first cool-down of an eighth of the machine (sector 7-8) to the operating temperature of 1.9 K began earlier this year (CERN Courier May 2007 p5). While this took longer than scheduled, it provided important lessons, allowing the LHC’s A welder at work on LHC sector 1-2. This is the last sector to be interconnected. operations team to iron out teething troubles and gain experience that will The new schedule foresees successive and low intensity to give the operations team be applied to the other seven sectors. cooling and powering of each of the experience in driving the new machine, before Now tests on powering up sector 7-8 are LHC’s sectors in turn this year. Hardware the intensity and energy are slowly increased. underway, and the cool-down of sector 4-5 commissioning will continue throughout Installation of the large and equally has begun. At the same time, physicists the winter, allowing the LHC to be ready innovative apparatus for experiments at this and engineers are making modifications to for high-energy running by the time CERN’s new and unique facility will continue at the the inner-triplet magnet assemblies (CERN accelerators are switched on in the spring. same time, to be completed on a schedule Courier June 2007 p5). Beams will be first injected at low energy consistent with that of the accelerator. …and Council approves additional resources
In another major development, Council amount to an extra SwFr240 million for the LHC at its nominal luminosity; renovation approved a programme of additional 2008–2011. The host states, France and of the injector complex; a minimum R&D activities together with the associated Switzerland, have committed to providing programme on detector components and budget resources. This decision follows half of these additional funds. focusing magnets in preparation for an the definition of the European Strategy for The extra resources are essential to ensure increase in the LHC luminosity and for Particle Physics adopted by Council last full exploitation of the discovery potential of enhancement of the qualifying programme year (CERN Courier September 2006 p29). It the LHC and to prepare CERN’s future. The for the Compact Linear Collider study; makes it possible to start implementing the programme consists of four priority themes: and activities of scientific importance for strategy as presented by CERN management an increase in the resources dedicated to which contributions from other European last autumn. The approved resources the experiments and to reliable operation of organizations will be essential.
Sommaire Le CERN annonce un nouveau calendrier de démarrage pour Début de l’acquisition de données pour Borexino 8 le LHC… 5 Lancement du satellite AGILE 8 …et le Conseil approuve des ressources supplémentaires 5 La physique des particules allemande reçoit un appui bienvenu 9 DØ et CDF découvrent le même baryon 6 Des diamants pour les ordinateurs quantiques 10 VIRGO ouvre la voie à une astronomie nouvelle 7 Hubble détecte un anneau de matière noire 11
CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugNews5-9.indd 5 11/7/07 14:26:12 NEWS
F e r m i l a b DØ and CDF find same new baryon
8 DØ,1.3 fb–1 –1 CDF Run II Preliminary L~1.9 fb 7 8 6 yield = 17.5 ± 4.3 ) 2 data 2 5 M = (5792.9 ± 2.5) MeV/c 6 fit 4
3 4 2
candidates / (15 MeV/ c 1 2 events/(0.05 GeV) 0 5.4 5.6 5.8 6.0 6.2 6.4 M(J/ΨΞ–) (GeV/c2) 0 5.5 6 6.5 7 – – Invariant mass distributions for Ξb candidate events found in the D0 (left) and CDF (right) M(Ξb) (GeV) – experiments at Fermilab. The two experiments yield consistent values for the Ξb mass.
After several years of independently Λ0 → pπ–. While the Λ and Ξ– have decay a significance of 5.5 σ for the observed – gathering and analyzing data at Fermilab’s lengths of a few centimetres, the Ξb travels signal. At the seminar, CDF presented a Tevatron, the DØ and CDF collaborations only a millimetre or so before it decays. preliminary mass value of 5.7929 ± 0.0024 have reported the observation of the same The analysis basically consists of (stat.) ± 0.0017 (syst.) GeV/c2, with a new baryon within days of each other. searching for events with muon pairs that significance of 7.8 σ. DØ has also measured The DØ collaboration announced the first correspond to a J/Ψ together with a proton the ratio of the cross-section multiplied by – direct observation of the strange b baryon, and two pions of the same sign. One pion the branching ratio of their observed Ξb – Ξb, in a paper submitted to Physical Review and the proton must have a mass equivalent events relative to that for the well-known Λb Letters on 12 June. Then, at a packed to the Λ and come from a vertex that is an baryons. The measured ratio is 0.28 ± 0.13. – Fermilab seminar on 15 June, no sooner had appropriate distance from the origin of the The discovery of the Ξb is the latest in a Eduard De La Cruz Burelo reported on DØ’s second pion. The Λ and this pion should chain of discoveries made by CDF and DØ discovery than Dmitry Litvintsev from the CDF then have a mass equivalent to a Ξ– and a over the past few years. Last October, the collaboration rose to present independent common vertex corresponding to the Ξ–’s CDF collaboration reported the observation evidence for the very same particle. decay point. The next step is to match the of Σb particles, related to the Ξb (CERN Consisting of three quarks – d, s and b – the origins of the Ξ– candidates with those of the Courier December 2006 p9). As the – – Ξb is the first observed particle to be formed J/Ψs to reconstruct the decay of the Ξb. Tevatron delivers more and more data, the of quarks from all three generations. In an analysis of 1.3 fb–1 of data collected possibilities increase for the observation of The ALEPH and DELPHI experiments at LEP during 2002–2006, the DØ collaboration even rarer processes. – had previously found indirect evidence for the found 19 candidate events for Ξb while the – Ξb in the form of an excess of events with a CDF collaboration found 17 candidates in Further reading Ξ– and a lepton of the same sign. Now the 1.9 fb–1. Both experiments measured the DØ collaboration V Abazov et al. 2007 two experiments at the Tevatron have been mass of the new particle, with consistent http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.1690. able to reconstruct fully the specific decay, results. In their submitted paper, DØ gives CDF collaboration http://www-cdf.fnal. – – Ξb →Ξ J/Ψ , where the products decay the measured mass as 5.774 ± 0.011 gov/physics/new/bottom/070607. in their turn: J/Ψ → μ+μ–, Ξ– → Λ0π– and (stat.) ± 0.015 (syst.) GeV/c2, and quotes blessed-cascadeB/.
www.vseworld.com A-6890 LUSTENAU (AUSTRIA), Sandstr. 29 Tel: +43 (0) 55 77 - 82 6 74 Fax: +43 (0) 55 77 - 82 6 74 - 7 e-mail: [email protected] UHV VACUUM Motion in Vacuum Leakvalve TECHNOLOGY
CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugNews5-9.indd 6 12/7/07 09:49:59 NEWS
GRAVITATIONAL WAVES VIRGO opens up new astronomy
A view of the two arms of the Virgo interferometer. (Photos courtesy INFN.) Setting up the injection bench for laser input.
On 18 May, the Virgo laser interferometer bounce between two widely spaced mirrors. events from local noise. The arrival-time for the detection of gravitational waves Laser interferometers, such as Virgo, difference of a gravitational-wave signal of started its first science run at the European are ideal instruments to detect these various detectors enables reconstruction by Gravitational Observatory, Pisa, marking phenomena. They can compare with triangulation of the position of the source a step forward towards a new astronomy. enormous accuracy the times that light takes in the sky and measuring the wave-front If Virgo and its counterparts, LIGO in the to go back and forth along two perpendicular at several points allows the determination US and GEO600 in Germany, succeed in arms, 3–4 km long. Miniscule changes in of all of the parameters characterizing detecting gravitational waves, they will these times caused by gravitational waves gravitational waves. reveal new information about the universe. will appear as microscopic changes in the With the instruments close to their design Until now, astronomy has been based interference fringes. sensitivities, researchers could detect on photons – electromagnetic waves Having reached a sensitivity close to the gravitational waves in the coming four – originating from the accelerated motion design value, and comparable to that of the months of common data-taking, although of electric charges, as in a burning star. LIGO interferometers, Virgo has now begun the “discovery” probability is estimated to Gravitational waves originate instead in scientific operation. The data collected will be only about 1%, even for binary neutron- matter’s most intrinsic characteristic, complement data from other detectors, and star coalescence – one of the better known its mass. A direct consequence of improve the overall statistical significance. sources. To increase this probability, the general relativity, gravitational waves are In an important step that greatly researchers have set up a coordinated, perturbations of the gravitational fields that increases the value of the data collected two-stage improvement campaign. This are produced by the accelerated motion of in Europe and the US, Virgo and the LIGO will bring the overall detection probability masses, as in star collisions. According to Science Collaboration have agreed to share into the range of one event a year for general relativity, gravitational fields distort their data. The constitution of a worldwide 2009–2010, and a few tens of events a year space–time and the passage of gravitational network of detectors, the data for which for 2013–2014. If attained, it will mark the waves produces ripples, like on the surface are analysed coherently, has several basic birth of gravitational-wave astronomy. of a pond. A light beam travelling through advantages. The coincidence between ● Virgo is funded on an equal basis by the this perturbed space–time should be subject weak signals sensed in widely separated Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique to tiny oscillations in the time it takes to locations allows the rejection of spurious and the Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare.
Les physiciens des particules du monde entier sont invités à CERN Courier welcomes contributions from the international apporter leurs contributions aux CERN Courier, en français ou particle-physics community. These can be written in English or en anglais. Les articles retenus seront publiés dans la langue French, and will be published in the same language. If you have a d’origine. Si vous souhaitez proposer un article, faites part de vos suggestion for an article, please send your proposal to the editor suggestions à la rédaction à l’adresse [email protected]. at [email protected].
CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugNews5-9.indd 7 11/7/07 14:26:35 NEWS
N e u t r i n o s Borexino begins data taking at Gran Sasso
The Borexino detector is now fully of purified water. A stainless-steel sphere operational at the Laboratori Nazionali del contains the pseudocumene and also Gran Sasso. This milestone comes after supports 2200 photomultipliers to detect several years of technical developments that the light produced by neutrino interactions, have led to the lowest background levels while 200 phototubes facing into the ever achieved, followed by construction and shielding water provide a veto for muons. commissioning. In addition, problems at Borexino will cast light on the low mixing- the underground laboratory and with local angle solution for neutrino oscillation, which authorities – owing mainly to environmental is still to be confirmed at low energies, concerns – caused four years of delay. and should provide information on the Borexino’s main goal is the measurement electron–neutrino survival probability in the of the monoenergetic (862 keV) neutrinos transition region (0.7–4.0 MeV) between from the decay of 7Be formed in a branch vacuum and matter oscillations. With its of the proton–proton (pp) fusion chain in very low threshold – well below 1 MeV – the the Sun (CERN Courier October 1998 p12). experiment also has the potential to explore Previous experiments indicate a severe At work inside Borexino’s steel sphere lined other solar neutrino signals for the first suppression of these neutrinos, which are with phototubes. (Courtesy INFN.) time, and to test the astrophysical model important in understanding solar neutrinos of the Sun at the level of a few per cent. and neutrino oscillations. liquid scintillator (100 tonnes of fiducial In addition, Gran Sasso provides the ideal The experiment will detect neutrino– mass). This is shielded by 1000 tonnes location for the study of geoneutrinos, electron scattering in real time in its of ultrapure quenched pseudocumene thanks to the low level of backgrounds from central volume of 300 tonnes of ultrapure (1-2-4 trimethylbenzene) and 2400 tonnes nuclear reactors.
A s t r o n o m y 80270260250240 2902
AGILE takes its 20 20
place in orbit 10 10
On 23 April, the Indian Polar Satellite 0 0 Launch Vehicle (PSLV) launched the Italian astronomical satellite, AGILE, into orbit from –10 –10 the Sriharikota base in Chennai-Madras. AGILE (Astrorivelatore Gamma a lmmagini –20 –20 Leggero) is a 350 kg satellite dedicated to –30 –30 high-energy astrophysics. Its main goal is 80270260250240 2902 the simultaneous detection of hard X-ray and gamma-ray cosmic radiation in the energy Left: A preliminary map (galactic co-ordinates) of photons with energy above 100 MeV of bands 15–60 keV and 30 MeV – 50 GeV, with the Vela Pulsar region. The observation took about half a day (7 orbits) on 29–30 May. optimal imaging and timing. The image represents only the central part of the field of view of the AGILE gamma-ray Ten days after launch, on 4 May, the imager and background rejection is based on an instrument configuration that is not yet instruments on board the satellite – the optimized. Right: The AGILE satellite integrated on the fourth stage of the PSLV rocket on tracker, the mini-calorimeter, and the X-ray 15 April. (Courtesy AGILE and ASI Science Data Centre.) detector – were switched on and the first data transmitted back to Earth. All proved The AGILE Mission is funded and managed Agency for New Technologies, Energy to work well, and commissioning proceeded by the Italian Space Agency (ASI), with and the Environment, and the Consorzio according to schedule until the end of June. co-participation from the Italian Institute Interuniversitario per la Fisica Spaziale. The The tracker, the main scientific instrument of Astrophysics, the Italian Institute of industrial contractors involved are Carlo on AGILE, is based on state-of-the-art, Nuclear Physics, and several universities Gavazzi Space, Oerlikon-Contraves, Alcatel- reliable technology of solid-state silicon and research centres – including the Alenia Space Italia-LABEN, Telespazio, detectors developed by INFN laboratories. National Research Council, the National Galileo Avionica, Intecs and Mipot.
CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugNews5-9.indd 8 11/7/07 14:26:43 NEWS
R e s e a r c h f u n d i n g German particle physics gets funding boost
Physicists in Germany will soon be able to willNEG offer VACUUM.qxp its facilities for16/04/2007 testing and 9.50 Paginapositions 1 will be opened at the laboratory. strengthen their role in the international development of detector and accelerator An analysis centre for LHC data will also be quest to understand the fundamental laws technology, and 10 Helmholtz Alliance established at DESY. of nature. On 15 May, the Senate of the Helmholtz Association of German Research Centres announced that it will grant €25 m in funding over the next five years to SAES® support the Helmholtz Alliance, Physics The light NEG Technologies at the Terascale, in a proposal led by the DESY research centre. In this alliance, of innovation The innovative non-evaporable getter DESY – together with Forschungszentrum solutions for leading edge machines Karlsruhe, 17 universities and the Max into extreme SOLEIL Synchrotron - NEG coating Planck Institute for Physics in Munich � of nearly 60% of the ring chambers – will bring together existing competencies vacuum to improve static and dynamic in Germany in the study of elementary vacuum particles and forces. At the same time, the Helmholtz Alliance � RHIC at BNL - NEG coating of 450 m will provide the basis to drive technological warm sections to reduce pressure advancement in a much more focused rise and allow higher beam intensity way. This new initiative comes at a time � Beijing Electron Positron Collider II when German particle physicists are NEG vacuum pumps to ensure making large contributions to international 3 x 10-10 mbar pressure in the collaborations at particle accelerators, electron-positron rings such as the LHC at CERN, and a future Petra III at Desy - More than 1,5 km International Linear Collider. � of NEG strip to provide distributed Alliance funds will finance more than pumping capability all around the 50 new positions for scientists, engineers ring and technicians during the initial five-year period. Junior scientists, in particular, will be given the opportunity to lead research Boosting performance of high energy groups with options for tenure positions. machines around the world This is intended to open up attractive new perspectives for a future career in particle physics. Joint junior positions at all partner institutes, coordinated recruitment and teaching substitutes for researchers who are abroad will together provide a framework where it is possible for scientists to work away from their home institutes at large- scale international research centres without interfering with teaching provision. The new network will enhance collaboration between universities and research institutes in data-analysis fields and the development of new technologies. Particular support will be given to the design we support your i n n o v a t i o n of new IT structures, as well as detector and accelerator technologies that are of central www.saesgetters.com importance for the sustainable development [email protected] of particle physics in the future. As a member of the alliance, DESY
CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugNews5-9.indd 9 11/7/07 14:26:51 SCIENCEWATCH
Compiled by Steve Reucroft and John Swain, Northeastern University Diamonds offer solution Muons see inside for quantum computers an active volcano If you want to look at what lies inside a volcano, it turns out that cosmic rays may Quantum computing relies on the ability to between the nitrogen-vacancy spin system be just what you need. Hiroyuki Tanaka and store and manipulate qubits (superpositions and the nuclear spins of nearby carbon-13 colleagues from the University of Tokyo and of 1 and 0), but this is not easy to do without nuclei, which naturally make up 1.1% of a Nagoya University have managed to use losing coherence. Now, Mikhail Lukin and diamond. Their observations indicate that cosmic-ray muons to create a “radiograph” colleagues from Harvard University, Stuttgart when advanced nuclear magnetic resonance near the top of Mt Asama, one of the University and Texas A&M University have techniques are used, controlled manipulation largest and most active volcanoes in Japan. made a huge breakthrough. Using optical of a few coupled nuclear spin qubits is They succeeded in measuring the internal and microwave manipulation of electron and possible with coherence times that can structure of a newer crater region known as nuclear spins associated with a nitrogen approach seconds. These registers could Mt Kama-yama, through the bulk of an older vacancy in diamonds, they have succeeded be used as a basis for scalable, optically volcanic rim, Mt Maekake-yama. in creating a controllable quantum register. coupled quantum information systems. Tanaka and colleagues used emulsion Using the spins to store qubits and transfer chambers with some shielding to help them without loss of coherence even at room Further reading prevent exposure to the effects of lower- temperature, the team got them to interact M V Gurudev Dutt et al. 2007 Science 316 energy natural radioactivity. The approach coherently, having made use of the coupling 1312. is novel, a big advantage of emulsion chambers being that they need no electric power and are light enough to carry up a mountain. The technique has clear potential Meditation improves attention for monitoring active volcanoes from points Many of the claimed benefits of meditation of letters flashed on a screen, with the two that are not too close for comfort. are often fairly subjective, but recent numbers coming as little as half a second research shows a clear and measurable apart. The results showed a boost in correct Further reading effect on attention. Richard Davidson and recognition of the second number, which H K M Tanaka et al. 2007 Nucl. Instrum. colleagues at the University of Wisconsin- increased from 60% of the time to as much Methods Phys. Res. A 575 489. Madison and Leiden University asked as 90% (with an average of 80%). This 17 volunteers to spend three months seems to indicate that the brain can be studying Vipassana meditation, which is trained to make use of its resources in more Cold fusion supposed to help reduce distractions and efficient ways. enhance awareness through mental training. appears again Participants were asked, before and Further reading after their intensive meditation, to try to H A Slagter et al. 2007 PLoS Biology 5 e138; Cold fusion is one of those topics spot one or two numbers among a series doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0050138. that just keeps coming back, most recently as reported in an article in Naturwissenschaften. Frank Gordon of Lunar laser ranging does it better the US Navy's Space and Naval Warfare Systems Center in San Diego and colleagues The Gravity Probe B (GP-B) satellite was are still interesting since they will provide have reported new evidence for low-energy launched by NASA in 2004 to test, among a very direct measurement. GP-B will also fusion in a palladium-deuterium film other things, the effect predicted by general test a related general relativistic effect, the deposited on nickel. Not only do they get relativity that the Earth would drag inertial “geodetic effect”, which is an additional significant rises in temperature, but they find frames with it as it rotates. T W Murphy Jr of gravitation-induced precession. what seem to be nuclear tracks in CR-39, the University of California and colleagues the etch-track detector familiar to particle have argued that as the frame-dragging Further reading: physicists! Is there something interesting effect is a consequence of gravitomagnetism T W Murphy Jr et al. 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 going on? Time and more experiments it has already been confirmed by lunar laser 071102. should eventually find out. ranging measurements in the Earth–Moon S M Kopeikin 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 system to a higher accuracy than GP-B 229001. Further reading will provide. That said, the data from the T W Murphy Jr et al. 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 S Szpak, P A Mosier-Boss and F E Gordon, sophisticated gyroscope system on GP-B 229002. 2007 Naturwissenschaften 94 511.
10 CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugScienceWatch10.indd 10 11/7/07 10:36:27 ASTROWATCH
Compiled by Marc Türler, INTEGRAL Science Data Centre and Observatory of Geneva University Hubble detects ring of dark matter
Astronomers using the Hubble Space tricky to derive the dark-matter distribution Telescope have discovered a ghostly ring in a cluster from the distortion it causes on of dark matter that formed during a titanic the shape of background galaxies, but the collision between two massive galaxy analysis of this weak gravitational lensing clusters. Because ordinary matter in the now seems to be well under control, with cluster shows no evidence of such a ring, the release of the first 3D map of the dark this discovery is among the strongest matter distribution (CERN Courier January/ evidence yet for non-baryonic dark matter. February 2007 p11). Clusters of galaxies are the largest The ring-like structure, which measures gravitationally bound structures in the 2.6 million light-years across, is reminiscent universe. They typically contain hundreds or of the famous Cartwheel Galaxy (CERN thousands of galaxies, forming at the knots Courier March 2006 p12) shaped by a of the filamentary sponge-like distribution frontal collision with another galaxy. A similar of matter on very large scales. Numerical scenario – but on the scale of galaxy clusters simulations show how the accretion of – is most likely at the origin of the dark- matter from the filaments to the knots matter ring found by Jee and colleagues. make galaxy clusters grow in size. This one- To validate this scenario, they performed a dimensional accretion (along a filament) collisionless N-body simulation of the head- results in frequent, near head-on collisions This Hubble Space Telescope composite on interaction between two spherical dark- among clusters or groups of galaxies, image shows in blue the ring-like dark matter halos. The simulation shows how the whereas interactions between individual matter distribution superimposed on the cluster collision triggers a radially expanding galaxies usually occur only when there is optical view of the galaxy cluster shell of dark matter around each cluster significant rotation. Cl 0024+17. (Courtesy NASA, ESA, M J Jee core. These shells superimpose in projection The galaxy cluster Cl 0024+17 – some and H Ford of Johns Hopkins University.) on the sky to form the ring-like pattern. 5 × 109 light-years away (z = 0.4) – is The unique spatial distribution of this ring, supposed to have experienced exactly such the collision scenario and suggest a sub- compared with both the galaxies and the hot a head-on collision 1 or 2 thousand million cluster mass ratio of 2:1. X-ray emitting gas in the cluster, is strong years ago. The first evidence of this was In 2004, when Myungkook Jee from the evidence for the existence of dark matter. It obtained in 2002 by Oliver Czoske, from John Hopkins University started to study confirms a similar result found in the Bullet the University of Bonn, and collaborators. the dark-matter distribution in Cl 0024+17, Cluster (CERN Courier October 2006 p9) By studying the velocity distribution of he was not aware that this was such a and makes it difficult for any theory trying the galaxies in the cluster, they found two peculiar cluster of galaxies. He was at to reproduce the effect of dark matter by distinct groups with opposite velocity, first annoyed when he saw the ring-like modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND). suggesting that there are two sub-clusters distribution because he had never seen moving away from each other along the line- such a pattern in other clusters, and Further reading of-sight. Their numerical simulations confirm thought it was an artefact. It is indeed M J Jee et al. 2007 Astroph. Journal 661 728.
Picture of the month This multiwavelength view of the nearby galaxy Messier 81 was obtained by combining observations in infrared, visible and ultraviolet light. This beautiful spiral galaxy is almost visible with the naked eye in the Great Bear (Ursa Major) constellation, which includes the seven stars forming the Big Dipper. The infrared view by the Spitzer Space Telescope and the ultraviolet image by the GALEX satellite were superimposed on the image from the Hubble Space Telescope. The infrared light (shown red in the image) reveals hot dust in the spiral arms heated by the intense ultraviolet radiation (shown in blue) emitted by young, massive stars. (Hubble data courtesy NASA, ESA and A Zezas of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics; GALEX data courtesy NASA, JPL-Caltech, GALEX Team J Huchra et al. of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics; Spitzer data courtesy NASA/ JPL/Caltech/S Willner of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.)
CERN Courier July/August 2007 11
CCJulAugAstro11.indd 11 11/7/07 10:46:16 CERN COURIER ARCHIVE: 1964
A look back to CERN Courier vol. 4 July/August 1964, compiled by Peggie Rimmer CERN A busy summer season at the PS
On 29 July, the intensity of the circulating Part of the equipment enclosure for the beam in the CERN proton synchrotron (PS) missing-mass spectrometer experiment in reached, for the first time, 1012 (a million the South experimental hall of the proton million) protons per pulse. Adopting the synchrotron at CERN. In the foreground, next prefix in the series (kilo-, mega-, giga-, the paper-tape punch and electronic etc), engineers at the PS are now talking of typewriter can be seen, which are operated the intensity in terms of the “teraproton”. from the Mercury computer in the Data This intensity is a hundred times greater Handling laboratories; to their left is an than the design figure. automatic graph plotter also operated by the computer. The long flexible tube [top] A bubble chamber... provides ventilation in the area of the In the second half of June, the British hydrogen target and the target can be National Hydrogen Bubble Chamber watched by means of the television successfully came into operation in the receiver that can be seen on the table East bubble-chamber building of the behind the blackboard. CERN PS. Before the end of the first week, which had been allotted only for tests, kaons at 5 GeV/c for the T55 experiment, obtained. The progress of the experiment several thousand photographs [of positive in which groups at Cambridge (UK) and is in fact determined by the kind of results pion interactions] were accumulated for Brussels (Belgium), as well as at CERN, that it gives. This is the first time that an physicists in Durham and Turin, and the are collaborating. After a 10 hour rest to experiment has been carried out at the PS chamber's first scheduled experiment allow some emulsion and nuclear chemistry “online” to a computer. began the week after. exposures in the o2 beam, the run ended ● Compiled from “Last Month at CERN” This new liquid-hydrogen bubble chamber (15–19 July) with another 66 000 pictures pp86-88 and pp102–104. is the largest so far operated in Europe. for the T49 experiment, this time using Although usually known as the 150 cm negative kaons at 6 GeV/c. chamber, the British chamber in fact has a Compiler’S NOTE length of 60 inches, equivalent to 152.4 cm …and an online computer (that is, at room temperature, about The “missing-mass spectrometer” has With the advent of electronic counters and 0.6 cm less at the operating temperature been designed to carry out a systematic online computers, particle physics during of –246 °C). The chamber was built by investigation of the unstable mesons (or the 1960s and 1970s was being liberated the collaborative efforts of three British meson “resonances”). This apparatus, from dependence on photography. In their universities (Birmingham, Liverpool and which, incidentally, is of particular interest heyday, bubble chambers were enabling London), the Rutherford High Energy from the point of view of the development several momentous breakthroughs, Laboratory and the Department of Scientific of experimental techniques at CERN, despite some physicists suggesting that and Industrial Research, at a cost of uses a hydrogen target, together with a they would soon become obsolete. In about £1 million (SwFr12 million). collection of sonic spark chambers and February 1964, for example, one of the In the first two weeks of full operation scintillation counters to detect the incoming most famous bubble chamber pictures of for physics experiments (25 June – 5 July), and outgoing particles. The electrical all was taken with the 80 inch hydrogen 100 000 pictures were obtained showing signals from the detection system are bubble chamber at Brookhaven. It showed interactions of negative kaons of momentum registered by electronic scalers, which an Ω–, the “missing link” in the ordering 5.08 GeV/c [the o2 beam]. This experiment translate them into numbers ready for of subatomic particles into the “eightfold (T49) was for the “K collaboration” linking recording (in an electrically coded form) way” or SU(3) symmetry, which clinched physicists in Birmingham, Glasgow, London on magnetic tape. The numerical data are the argument for the existence of quarks. (Imperial College) and Oxford Universities as also transmitted over a cable, 1.2 km long, Almost a decade later, in 1973, the large well as groups at the Rutherford High Energy to the “Mercury” computer, which carries heavy-liquid bubble chamber Gargamelle, Laboratory and the Max-Planck Institute out various calculations and transmits the at CERN’s PS, revealed the first example in Munich. In the third week (9–14 July), results back to the physicists at the PS. of a neutral-current process, providing a further 40 000 pictures with K– at This allows a constant check to be kept pivotal evidence for the unification of the 5.08 GeV/c were obtained and the beam on the functioning of the apparatus and, electromagnetic and weak forces. line was then re-adjusted to give positive more particularly, on the results being
12 CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugArchive12.indd 12 11/7/07 10:51:09 Antimatter Keeping antihydrogen: the ALPHA trap
Antimatter is difficult to make, let alone store.Jeffrey Hangst describes how ALPHA, an experiment attempting to trap antihydrogen at CERN, overcomes some of the difficulties and he questions the reality of ever making more than the tiniest amounts of antimatter.
Suppose, as the villain of a story, you absolutely needed to trans- port a macroscopic amount of antimatter, for whatever sinister purpose. How would you go about it and could you smuggle it, for example, into the Vatican catacombs? The truth is that we will probably never have a macroscopic amount of antimatter for such a scenario to ever become reality. According to the preface to the popular novel Angels and Demons (2000), author Dan Brown was apparently inspired by the imminent commissioning of CERN’s “antimatter factory”, the Antiproton Decelerator (AD). The real-life AD has now been fully operational for about five years, and the experiments there have produced some notable physics results. One of the big stories along the way was the synthesis in 2002 of antihydrogen atoms by the ATHENA and ATRAP collaborations (CERN Courier November 2002 p5 and December 2002 p5, respectively). This feat was an important step towards one of the ultimate goals of everyday antimatter science: precision comparisons of the spectra of hydrogen and antihydrogen. According to the CPT Fig. 1. ALPHA’s Penning trap for catching antiprotons from theorem, these spectra should be identical. To get an idea of CERN’s AD. The stack of gold-plated electrodes is placed in a what precision means in this context, take a look at the website cryostat inside a superconducting solenoid magnet generating of 2005 Nobel Laureate Theodor Hänsch, which has the follow- a field of up to 3 T. (Courtesy N Madsen/Swansea.) ing cryptic headline: f(1S–2S) = 2 466 061 102 474 851(34) Hz. This may look like a cryptic puzzle appearing in Brown’s fiction, bine, the neutral antihydrogen is no longer confined by the fields of but it simply means that the frequency of one of the n = 1 to n = 2 the Penning trap, and the precious anti-atom is lost. The ATHENA transitions in hydrogen has been measured with an absolute pre- experiment demonstrated antihydrogen production because it cision of about 1 part in 1014. This is impressive, but where do we could detect the annihilation of the anti-atoms when they escaped stand with antihydrogen? the Penning trap volume and annihilated on the walls. To study antihydrogen using laser spectroscopy, anti-atoms Storing antihydrogen need to be sustained for longer. In the 1s–2s transition mentioned Both ATHENA and ATRAP produced antihydrogen by mixing anti- above, the excited state (2s) has a lifetime of about a seventh of protons and positrons in electromagnetic “bottles” called Penning a second; while in ATHENA, an anti-atom would annihilate on the traps (figure 1). Penning traps feature strong solenoidal magnetic walls of the Penning trap within a few microseconds of its crea- fields and longitudinal electrostatic wells that confine charged tion. Thus, the next-generation antihydrogen experiments include particles. The antiprotons come from CERN’s AD, and the posi- the provision for trapping the neutral anti-atoms that are produced trons come from the radioactive isotope 22Na. The whole process in a mixture of charged constituents. involves cleverly slowing, trapping, and cooling both species of The Antihydrogen Laser Physics Apparatus (ALPHA) collabora- particles (Amoretti et al. 2002 and Gabrielse et al. 2002). But tion has recently commissioned a new device designed to trap here’s the rub: when the charged antiproton and positron com- the neutral anti-atoms. ALPHA takes the place of ATHENA at the s
CERN Courier July/August 2007 13
CCJulAugALPHA13-16.indd 13 11/7/07 14:05:43 Antimatter
Fig. 2. Depiction of a Ioffe–Pritchard trap, surrounding the electrodes of a Penning trap for charged particles. The arrows show the direction of current flow in the magnetic coils.
0 2 4 cm external solenoid bore trap vacuum silicon detector liquid helium three layers vessel barrier
liquid helium vessel wall
multipole windings helium Dewar eight layers wall vacuum Fig. 4. The ALPHA octupole being wound at Brookhaven. The (mirror coils superconducting cable is fixed to an adhesive substrate using not shown) helium Dewar vacuum ultrasonic energy. The magnet has eight layers, similar to the Fig. 3. Schematic cross-section of the ALPHA device. one shown here. (Courtesy J Escallier/BNL.)
AD and features five of the original groups from ATHENA (Aarhus, colder atoms, but their temperature has not yet been measured. Swansea, Tokyo, RIKEN and Rio de Janeiro) plus new contribu- (Note that the highly excited antihydrogen atoms produced in both tors from Canada (TRIUMF, Calgary, UBC and Simon Fraser), the experiments can have significantly larger magnetic moments, thus US (Berkeley and Auburn), the UK (Liverpool) and Israel (Nuclear experiencing higher trapping potentials. The trick, then, is to keep Research Center, Negev). them around while they decay to the ground state.) Both groups Neutral atoms – or anti-atoms – can be trapped because they are investigating new ways to produce colder anti-atoms, and the have a magnetic moment, which can interact with an external 2007 run at the AD (June–October) promises to be revealing. magnetic field. If we build a field configuration that has a mini- mum magnetic field strength, from which the field grows in all Designer magnets directions, some quantum states of the atom will be attracted to A second important issue facing both collaborations is the effect the field minimum. This is how hydrogen atoms are trapped for on the charged particles of adding the highly asymmetric Ioffe– studies in Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC). The usual geometry Pritchard field to the Penning trap. Penning traps depend on the is known as an Ioffe–Pritchard trap (figure 2). A quadrupole wind- rotational symmetry of the solenoidal field for their stability. As ing and two solenoidal “mirror coils” produce the field to provide ALPHA collaborator Joel Fajans of Berkeley initially pointed out, transverse and longitudinal confinement, respectively. Figure 2 the addition of transverse magnetic fields to a Penning trap can also shows the electrodes that provide the axial confinement be a recipe for disaster, leading either to immediate particle loss, in the Penning trap for the charged antiprotons and positrons. or to a slower, but equally fatal, loss due to diffusion. Fajans’ The idea is that the antihydrogen produced in the Penning trap solution, adopted by the ALPHA collaboration, is to use a higher- is “born” trapped within the Ioffe–Pritchard trap – if its kinetic order magnetic multi-pole field for the transverse confinement. A energy does not exceed the depth of the trapping potential. higher-order field can, in principle, provide the same well-depth as This is a big “if”. A ground-state hydrogen atom has a magnetic a quadrupole while generating significantly less field at the axis of moment that gives us a trap depth of only about 0.7 K for a mag- the trap, where the charged particles are confined. netic well depth of 1 T. The superconducting magnetic traps that To construct such a magnet, the ALPHA collaboration surveyed we can build and squeeze into our experiments will give 1–2 T the experts in fabrication of superconducting magnets for accel- of well-depth for neutral atoms. All antihydrogen experiments to erator applications. It turns out that the Superconducting Mag- date occur in devices cooled by liquid helium at 4.2 K, but there net Division at the Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) had are strong indications that the antihydrogen produced by direct previously developed a technique that is almost tailor-made to mixing of antiprotons and positrons is warmer than this, with tem- our needs. The key here is to use the proper materials in the con- peratures of at least hundreds of kelvin. ATRAP has devised a struction of the magnet. To detect antiproton annihilations, ALPHA laser-assisted method of producing antihydrogen that may give incorporates a three-layer silicon vertex detector similar to those
14 CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugALPHA13-16.indd 14 11/7/07 14:05:59 Antimatter
Fig. 5. The working ALPHA device. The corrugated pipe is the superconducting solenoid for the Penning traps. (Courtesy N Madsen.)
used in high-energy experiments (figure 3). However, the annihila- Back to Dan Brown tion products (pions) must travel through the magnets of the atom So let’s look at what is possible in experiments with antimatter trap before reaching the silicon. Therefore, it is highly desirable to today, leaving the speculation to aficionados of sci-fi and NASA. minimize the amount of material used in the magnet construction If you wanted to take antimatter to the offices of your national to minimize multiple scattering between the vertex and the detec- funding agency, you might consider taking some antiprotons, since tor. So bulky stainless-steel collars for containing the magnetic most of the mass-energy of an antihydrogen atom is in the nucleus. forces, as used in the Tevatron or the LHC, cannot be used. This might be tempting, since our charged-particle traps are cer- The Brookhaven process uses composite materials to constrain tainly deeper than those for neutral matter or antimatter. ATRAP the superconducting cable that forms the basis of the magnet. and ALPHA initially capture antiprotons in traps with depths of a Using a specially developed 3D winding machine, the team at few kilo-electron-volts, corresponding to tens of millions of kelvin. BNL was able to wind an eight-layer octupole and the mirror coils But, density is an issue. A good charged-particle trap for cold posi- directly onto the outside of the ALPHA vacuum chamber (figure 4). trons has a particle density of about 109 cm–3. Antiproton density The mechanical strength is provided by pre-tensioned glass fibres is much smaller, but we’ll be optimistic and use this number. So in an epoxy substrate. Only the superconducting cable is metal. to transport a milligram of antiprotons – of the order of 1021 parti- The new ALPHA device (figure 5) was designed and constructed cles – you would need a trap volume of 1012 cm3, or 106 m3. That during the AD shutdown of November 2004 to July 2006 and means a cube 100 m wide, which will not fit in your luggage. Inci- commissioned during the physics run at the AD in July–November dentally, a milligram of antimatter, annihilating on matter, would 2006. The Brookhaven magnets performed beautifully, demon- yield an energy equivalent to about 50 tonnes of TNT. strating that charged antiprotons and positrons can be stored So, what about transporting some neutral antimatter? Neutral in the full octupole field for times far exceeding those necessary atom traps certainly have higher densities. The first BEC result for to synthesize antihydrogen. We even made the first preliminary hydrogen at MIT reported a density in the order of 1015 cm–3 for attempt to produce and trap antihydrogen in the full field configu- about 109 atoms in the condensate. This is better, but still far less ration; but we have yet to observe evidence for trapping. than a milligram, even if you can get the atoms from a gas bottle. Meanwhile, the ATRAP collaboration worked hard to commis- The size of the trap is now down to 105 cm3, which is more man- sion a new quadrupole trap for antihydrogen and succeeded in ageable. Note, however, that the BEC transition in this experiment storing clouds of antiprotons and electrons in their new device. was at 50 μK – far below the 4.2 K that we hope to achieve with The 2007 physics run at the AD promises to be an exciting one antihydrogen. Unfortunately, to get really cold and dense atomic for antihydrogen physics. Both ALPHA and ATRAP should have hydrogen requires using evaporative cooling – throwing hot atoms operational devices that are capable – in theory – of trapping away to cool the remaining ones in the trap. This implies damaging neutral antimatter for the first time. your lab before you send the surviving, trapped antiatoms to s
CERN Courier July/August 2007 15
CCJulAugALPHA13-16.indd 15 11/7/07 14:06:11 Project3 11/7/07 14:26 Page 1
Antimatter
their final, cataclysmic fate. And don’t forget that the total history of antiproton production here on Earth amounts to perhaps a few tens of nanograms in the past 25 years or so. Unfortunately, the antiproton production cross-section is unlikely to change. How many anti-atoms can we trap? The Japanese-led ASACUSA experiment, using an extra stage of deceleration after the AD, can trap around a million of the 30 million decelerated antiprotons that the AD delivers every 100 s or so (CERN Courier March 2005 p8). Suppose we could make all of these into antihydrogen (in comparison, ATHENA achieved about 15%). The trapping effi- ciency for neutral anti-hydrogen is anybody’s guess at this point – we would be grateful for 1%. This is why the very notion of hav- ing a dense cloud of interacting antihydrogen atoms will bring a weary smile to the face of anyone working in the AD zone. Using the above figures, it would take us 1019 s – about 300 billion years – to accumulate just one milligram. One might also question if anyone could engineer a device reliable enough to safely contain an explosive quantity of anti-matter – not in my lab, thanks. Back down to the sober reality here at CERN, we would be happy just to demonstrate trapping of antihydrogen in principle. This means initially trapping just a few anti-atoms – not making a BEC or antihydrogen ice. The future of our emerging field seems Cryogenic Valves to depend on this, although ASACUSA is developing a plan to do spectroscopy on antihydrogen in flight. Time will tell which approach proves more promising. Two things are certain: the real technology of antimatter production and trapping lags far behind The true original since more than 25 years Dan Brown’s imagination; and the Vatican is safe from us.
Further reading More on the ALPHA experiment at http://alpha.web.cern.ch/alpha. M Amoretti et al. (ATHENA collaboration) 2002 Nature 419 456. Cryogenic Valves G Andresen et al. (ALPHA collaboration) 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 and Cryogenic Components 023402. W Bertsche et al. (ALPHA collaboration) 2006 Nucl. Instr. Meth. Proven experience Phys. Res. A 566 746. in cryogenic applications! M Charlton and J S Hangst 2005 Physics World October 2005 p22. G Gabrielse et al. (ATRAP collaboration) 2002 Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 233401. for design, manufacturing, assembling and testing Résumé for proven pneumatic diaphragm Conserver l’antihydrogène: le piège ALPHA actuators Il est déjà difficile de fabriquer de l’antimatière; la stocker est for state of the art digital encore plus difficile. Les expériences ATHENA et ATRAP menées electropneumatic positioners au CERN fabriquaient de l’antihydrogène en mélangeant des antiprotons et des positrons dans un «piège» électromagnétique, Everything from the Group mais une fois constitué l’antihydrogène neutre pouvait s’échapper. La nouvelle expérience ALPHA, menée au Décélérateur d’antiprotons au CERN, va piéger l’antihydrogène en utilisant WEKA AG · Switzerland la méthode Ioffé–Pritchard. L’un des éléments-clés est un 8344 Bäretswil · 2300 La Chaux-de-Fonds aimant supraconducteur innovant où sont utilisés des matériaux [email protected] · www.weka-ag.ch composites au lieu d’acier pour contenir les forces magnétiques. L’article évoque également la possibilité de fabriquer un jour plus China: Ji-Qin Lu · Beijing 100029 · Phone +86 (0)10 84624090 · [email protected] que des quantités infinitésimales d’antimatière. Japan: NIPPON SANSO CORPORATION · Kawasaki-City, 210-0861 Phone +81 (0)44 288 6937 · [email protected] · www.sanso.co.jp Jeffrey Hangst, University of Aarhus, Denmark, ALPHA India: Forbes Marshall · Pimpri, Pune · India 411 018 spokesperson and former ATHENA physics coordinator. Phone +91(0)20 274 42 020 · [email protected] · www.forbesmarshall.com
16 CERN Courier July/August 2007
CCJulAugALPHA13-16.indd 16 11/7/07 14:34:07 INTERVIEW Carbon ions pack a punch
During a recent CERN workshop on hadron therapy, renowned oncologist Hirohiko Tsujii talked to Carolyn Lee about the success of hadron therapy in fighting cancers.
Hirohiko Tsujii is director of the Research example, are often treated with hadron Center for Charged Particle Therapy, at therapy as they can be difficult to oper- the National Institute of Radiological ate on and conventional radiotherapy is Sciences (NIRS), in Chiba, Japan. He not always as effective. is known internationally for his work on “The reason we at NIRS decided to treating cancer with carbon ions and is use carbon ions rather than protons is the first doctor to have treated patients that it is the most balanced particle. It using hadron therapy in a clinical environ- has the property of providing a constant ment. Japan is the first country to have treatment to the tumour and also has a a heavy-ion accelerator for medical pur- higher biological effect on the tumour,” poses, built as part of a national 10-year explains Tsujii. This means that the strategy for cancer control. Since the carbon-ion beam can be more focused Heavy Ion Medical Accelerator in Chiba on the tumour, resulting in the great- (HIMAC) opened in 1994, the facility est cell damage to the tumour with less has provided treatment for more than injury to the surrounding healthy tissue. 3000 patients with various cancers and “Of course, as the mass of the particle has resulted in a significant increase in increases there is a higher relative bio- the number of survivors after treatment. Hirohiko Tsujii, the first oncologist to treat logical effectiveness (RBE). But the ratio Recently, the Committee of Senior Offi- patients with hadron therapy, presented of RBE between the peak to plateau cials for Scientific and Technical Research the results from his clinical studies at the [before the peak] gets worse when using (COST) and the European Network for COST-ENLIGHT workshop at CERN in May. a particle with a higher mass. Therefore, Research in Light-Ion Hadron Therapy when considering the biological effect, (ENLIGHT) invited Tsujii as guest of honour at the COST-ENLIGHT the carbon ion is the most balanced.” workshop on hadron therapy, held at CERN on 3–4 May. After treating more than 3000 patients, Tsujii feels that it has Tsujii has three decades of experience in developing hadron been a good decision to use carbon ions in cancer treatment. therapy as a novel treatment for cancer. The deposited radiation “There was a lot of discussion in deciding what particle would be dose for charged hadrons (protons and heavier ions) rises to a best. We decided to choose carbon ions and, for the time being, peak near the end of the particle’s range. The aim with hadron I am satisfied with this decision.” It took several years before therapy is to use this effect to irradiate tumours, while sparing coming to the optimum level of treatment with carbon ions. The healthy tissue better than with X-rays (CERN Courier December local control for almost all types of tumours is 80–90%, and 2006 p17). “Before working at NIRS, I was involved with proton- after choosing the optimal level of treatment the local control is beam therapy at Tsukuba University,” he says. Tsujii also worked expected to be more than 90%. on research for pion treatment in the US, where the use of pions “Another point that I want to focus on is the use of ‘hypofrac- in cancer therapy was pioneered at Los Alamos in co-operation tionated’ radiotherapy,” says Tsujii. A patient treated with photons with New Mexico University. “The biological effect was not as high – X-ray treatment – will, on average, require about 30–40 fractions as expected and it was also claimed that pions could produce a (doses) over 6–7 weeks. With carbon ions, the treatment can be very nice distribution in the human body,” he explains. “However, given in a single day (just one dose or fraction) for stage I lung compared with hadron therapy, such as with protons or carbon cancer while cervical and prostrate cancer or other large tumours ions, the distribution was not that good. Eventually it was decided require only 16–20 fractions against around 40 fractions using to stop the study that used pions.” conventional treatment. “It is important to note that there is a Japan is a major pioneer of hadron therapy. Each year, 650 000 minimal toxicity to healthy cells. At the beginning we had some people in the country are diagnosed with cancer and the number is severe toxicity, but we analysed the treatment and techniques, expected to increase to 840 000 by 2020. Deep-seated tumours and completely overcame the problem we had when we initially are the most challenging type of cancer and Tsujii has developed started the studies.” a special interest in treating them. Tumours found in the lungs, As chair of the Particle Therapy Co-operative Group, an inter- cervix, head and neck, liver, prostate, or bone and soft tissue, for national group that coordinates all hadron therapy (such as s
CERN Courier July/August 2007 17
CCJulAugTSUJII17-18.indd 17 11/7/07 11:59:13 INTERVIEW
%XPERIENCE -ATTERS protons and carbon ions), Tsujii sees the future development of carbon-ion therapy as the more popular choice for oncologists. &OR