Importance of Generalized Logistic Distribution in Extreme Value Modeling
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Applied Mathematics, 2013, 4, 560-573 http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/am.2013.43080 Published Online March 2013 (http://www.scirp.org/journal/am) Importance of Generalized Logistic Distribution in Extreme Value Modeling K. Nidhin1, C. Chandran2 1Department of Mathematics, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India 2Department of Statistics, University of Calicut, Calicut, India Email: [email protected], [email protected] Received September 10, 2012; revised February 1, 2013; accepted February 8, 2013 ABSTRACT We consider a problem from stock market modeling, precisely, choice of adequate distribution of modeling extremal behavior of stock market data. Generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution and generalized Pareto (GP) distribution are the classical distributions for this problem. However, from 2004, [1] and many other researchers have been empiri- cally showing that generalized logistic (GL) distribution is a better model than GEV and GP distributions in modeling extreme movement of stock market data. In this paper, we show that these results are not accidental. We prove the theoretical importance of GL distribution in extreme value modeling. For proving this, we introduce a general multi- variate limit theorem and deduce some important multivariate theorems in probability as special cases. By using the theorem, we derive a limit theorem in extreme value theory, where GL distribution plays central role instead of GEV distribution. The proof of this result is parallel to the proof of classical extremal types theorem, in the sense that, it pos- sess important characteristic in classical extreme value theory, for e.g. distributional property, stability, convergence and multivariate extension etc. Keywords: Financial Risk Modeling; Stock Market Analysis; Generalized Logistic Distribution; Generalized Extreme Value Distribution; Tail Equivalence; Maximum Stability; Random Sample Size; Limit Distribution 1. Introduction different from normal and lognormal to model large val- ues of finance data. For example t-distribution, alpha sta- An important problem from the field of stock market modeling is the determination of adequate model for ex- ble distribution, etc. In 1990’s the interest in modeling treme stock movement. In financial literature, the choice large values of finance data have been diverted to ex- of using an appropriate probability model for financial treme value theory where modeling maximum of the data, returns are clearly exemplified rather than selecting a generalized extreme value distribution for maxima (GEV conventional model (see for ex. [2]). The fitted tale dis- (max)) or generalized Pareto (GP) distribution are used tribution is crucially important in financial studies. For and for minimum of the data, generalized extreme value Value at Risk (VaR) estimation, one requires appropriate distribution for minima (GEV(min)) is used. These dis- probability distribution of extremes as input. A vast num- tributions enjoy strong theoretical support for analyzing ber of literature show the importance of best fitted dis- extreme movement of a data compared to other models. tribution in VaR analysis (see [3]). Another important Below we give an outline of these theoretical properties area of application of probability models of extremes is of the distributions. in hedging procedure. Hedging procedure is clearly based The theoretical representation for GEV(max) and on the probability of fitted distribution (see [4]). Also GEV(min) have been established by Jenkinson and Von measuring the risk attached to a share or portfolio will Mises (see von Mises (1954) and Jenkinson (1955)). We critically depends on the tale distribution. [5] largely il- define GEV(max) below. lustrates the importance of appropriate probability mod- Definition 1.1 A random variable X is said to follow els for extremes of financial returns data. the generalized extreme value distribution for maximum Initially, normal and lognormal distributions were used (GEV(max)) if its distribution function is given by, to model data which arise from financial sector. In the 1 k last five decades, different authors have been showing exp 1kx if k 0 Gx that the distribution of extreme daily returns is far from k exp expxk if 0 normal (see [5-11]. They used a number of distributions Copyright © 2013 SciRes. AM K. NIDHIN, C. CHANDRAN 561 and the supports are Theorem 1.1 (see [12]): Let Xnn , 1 be a se- quence of i.i.d.r.v.’s and M =maxXX , ,,X . If xk1 for k 0 nn12 there exist sequences of norming constants xk1 for k 0 abn 0, n , and a non-degenerate d.f. G such that, xRfor k 0. Mb w PxGnn x, (1.1) The related location-scale family can be introduced by an x replacing the argument x above by for R then G , in Equation (1.1), is the GEV(max) distribution defined in Definition 1.4. and 0 . The parameter k is known as the shape Since parameter of the distribution and different values of k min X12 ,XX , ,nn = max XXX1 , 2 , , , the leads to different well known distributions. That is, for asymptotic distribution of minima of i.i.d.r.v.’s can be k 0 , it is the Gumbel (Type I) distribution which is derived as 1 Gx , where G is the GEV(max). interpreted as limk0 Gk, For k 0 , it is the reverse- Hence the asymptotic distribution for minima is the Weibull (Type III) distribution, for k 0 , it is Frechet GEV(min) distribution defined in Definition 1.2. These (Type II) distribution. Also GEV(min) can be defined as theories have been extended to multivariate case, where follows. multivariate generalized extreme value distributions play Definition 1.2 A random variable X is said to follow central role (see [13,14]). the generalized extreme value distribution for minimum Another alternative model for maxima is the gene- (GEV(min)), if its distribution function is given by, ralized Pareto distribution, has been suggested by two in- 1 k dependent works [15] and [16]. Below we define GP dis- 1exp1kx if k 0 tribution. Hx k Definition 1.4 A random variable X is said to follow 1expexpxk if 0 the generalized Pareto (GP) distribution if its distribu- and the supports are tion function is given by, xk1 for k 0 1 k 1 11kx if k 0 xkfor k 0 Qx xRfor k 0. 1exp xk if 0 The parameter k is the shape parameter and k . and the supports are One can introduce the related location-scale family by xk1 for k 0 x replacing the argument x above by for R xk 1 for k 0 xk0for0. and 0 . For k 0 (which is interpreted as limk0 Fk), the distribution is called reverse-Gumbel, for k 0 , it is called reverse-Frechet distribution and for The parameter k is the shape parameter and k . k 0 , the distribution is the Weibull distribution. One can introduce the related location-scale family by x The above two distributions possess the characterizing replacing the argument x above by for R properties called max-stability and min-stability respec- tively. In the following we define max-stability for non- and 0 . With respect to k 0 , k 0 and k 0 random sample size. we get the exponential distribution, beta distribution and Definition 1.3 A non-degenerate random variable X Pareto distribution. is said to be max-stable if, for each n 2,3, there are GP distribution possess characterizing property called Peak over Threshold (POT) stability w.r.t non-random constants an 0 and bn such that d sample size. In the following we define POT stability for maxX12 ,XXaXb , , nn n. non-random sample size. Definition 1.5 A non-degenerate random variable X where X ,,,XX are same copies of X . 12 n is said to be POT-stable if, for each u 0 there are Similarly, one can define min-stability. By the extre- constants a 0 and b such that mal types theorem, asymptotic distribution of maxima of u u d independent and identically distributed random variables X uX u aXb. (i.i.d.r.v.’s) under proper normalization can be approxi- uu mated by the GEV(max) distribution. Below we give an By Peak over threshold theorem, under proper norma- outline of the theorem. lization, the asymptotic distribution of the observations Copyright © 2013 SciRes. AM 562 K. NIDHIN, C. CHANDRAN above exceedances of a level u has a generalized pareto variate extremal types theorem and multivariate random distribution iff asymptotic distribution of maximum of sum convergence theorem are special cases of this theo- the observations, under proper normalization, is the rem. In Section 5, we use the above general limit theo- GEV(max) distribution. We give an outline of the theo- rem to prove the convergence of random maxima and rem below. random minima to GL distribution. For an additional Theorem 1.2 (see [15,16]) let Xnn ,1 be a se- support to our claim, we present a data analysis in Sec- quence of i.i.d.r.v.’s with common continuous distri- tion 6. We introduce a multivariate generalized logistic bution function F x . Suppose there exists a pair of se- distribution in Section 7, and also we prove a charac- quences an and bn with an 0 for all n and a teristic property of this multivariate distribution by using non-degenerate distribution function Gx such that the general multivariate theorem in Section 4. To prove the results we require some basic concepts lim PMnnn b a x n (1.2) which we discuss below. n Definition 1.6 The right end point and left end point of lim F axnn b G x n a d.f. F , denoted by xF and yF respectively, are for all x at which Gx is continuous.