DOCSLIB.ORG

A Vast Machine: Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

A VAST MACHINE COMPUTER MODELS, CLIMATE DATA, AND THE POLITICS OF GLOBAL WARMING PAUL N. EDWARDS A Vast Machine A Vast Machine Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming Paul N. Edwards The MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England © 2010 Massachusetts Institute of Technology All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by any electronic or mechanical means (including photocopying, recording, or information storage and retrieval) without permission in writing from the publisher. For information on special quantity discounts, email [email protected] .edu. Set in Stone by Toppan Best-set Premedia Limited. Printed and bound in the United States of America. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Edwards, Paul N. A vast machine : computer models, climate data, and the politics of global warming / Paul N. Edwards. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-262-01392-5 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Weather forecasting. 2. Climatology — History. 3. Meteorology — History. 4. Climatology — Technological innovation. 5. Global temperature changes. I. Title. QC995.E296 2010 551.63 — dc22 2009030678 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 for Steve The meteorologist is impotent if alone; his observations are useless; for they are made upon a point, while the speculations to be derived from them must be on space. The Meteorological Society, therefore, has been formed not for a city, nor for a kingdom, but for the world. It wishes to be the central point, the moving power, of a vast machine, and it feels that unless it can be this, it must be powerless; if it cannot do all it can do nothing. It desires to have at its command, at stated periods, perfect systems of methodical and simultaneous observations; it wishes its infl uence and its power to be omnipresent over the globe so that it may be able to know, at any given instant, the state of the atmosphere on every point on its surface. — John Ruskin (1839) Contents Acknowledgments ix Introduction xiii 1 Thinking Globally 1 2 Global Space, Universal Time: Seeing the Planetary Atmosphere 27 3 Standards and Networks: International Meteorology and the Ré seau Mondial 49 4 Climatology and Climate Change before World War II 61 5 Friction 83 6 Numerical Weather Prediction 111 7 The Infi nite Forecast 139 8 Making Global Data 187 9 The First WWW 229 10 Making Data Global 251 11 Data Wars 287 12 Reanalysis: The Do-Over 323 13 Parametrics and the Limits of Knowledge 337 14 Simulation Models and Atmospheric Politics, 1960 – 1992 357 15 Signal and Noise: Consensus, Controversy, and Climate Change 397 Conclusion 431 Notes 441 Index 509 Acknowledgments Two people in particular made this book possible. Stephen Schneider brought me into the world of climate science during a professional devel- opment fellowship sponsored by the National Science Foundation. He gave me access to his library, involved me in projects, introduced me to col- leagues, and taught me how climate models work. He also taught me much about the politics of climate change. I learned more from Steve than from anyone else I ’ ve ever worked with. His generosity, both intellectual and personal, is beyond compare. Gabrielle Hecht read many versions of the manuscript, tearing it apart and helping me put it back together. I have no better editor or colleague. At various points she also took notes for me at interviews and provided other assistance, and she kept her confi dence in the project even when I lost my own. Far more than that, though: as the best life partner I can imagine, she taught me the fullest depths of what those words can mean. Without her this book could never have been written. I owe much to certain colleagues for extended exchanges that helped me develop my ideas. Special thanks go fi rst to Myanna Lahsen, Clark Miller, Simon Shackley, Jim Fleming, and Peter Taylor. Spencer Weart, Sheila Jasanoff, Johan Schot, Timothy Lenoir, and Thomas Parke Hughes provided crucial professional opportunities as well as intellectual frame- works. Others I would like to thank for comments, criticisms, ideas, and other help that shaped this book include Amy Dahan Dalmedico, Manuel Castells, Donna Haraway, Pascal Griset, John Carson, Joel Howell, Alex Stern, Catherine Badgley, Frederick Suppe, John Leslie King, Richard Rood, Erik van der Vleuten, Arne Kaijser, Tineke Egyedi, Wiebe Bijker, Trevor Pinch, Ben Santer, Susan Joy Hassol, Naomi Oreskes, Ted Parson, Geof Bowker, Susan Leigh Star, Steve Jackson, David Ribes, Chris Borgman, Chunglin Kwa, Dharma Akmon, Ted Hanss, Janet Ray Edwards, Dan Hirschman, Jeroen van der Sluijs, Michael Cohen, Rachelle Hollander, x Acknowledgments Arthur Petersen, and Judith Reppy. I thank Terry Root for everything she taught me, and especially for keeping Steve alive. The Stanford University Science, Technology and Society Program pro- vided the base from which I began this project. The University of Michigan School of Information, where I have worked since 1999, has been an incomparable intellectual home, with an unparalleled range, depth, and quality of scholarship as well as exceptional collegiality. My research assis- tants at Stanford and Michigan, including Yuri Takhteyev, Tom Allison, Amy Cooper, Zilia Estrada, and Archer Batcheller, provided invaluable help. At meteorological libraries around the world, numerous librarians and archivists helped me locate rare and obscure materials and references; among them, I particularly thank Diane Rabson. I interviewed numerous scientists during research for this book, some of them at great length and some of them several times. Though I rarely quote them directly, their generous gifts of history and explanation lie behind this book ’ s every page. My deepest thanks to Akio Arakawa, David Baumhefner, John Bergengren, William Bourke, Bruce Callendar, Robert Chervin, William Clark, Curt Covey, Richard Davis, Anthony Del Genio, Carter Emmart, John Firor, Jim Hack, Milt Halem, James Hansen, Bill Holland, Anthony Hollingsworth, Sir John Houghton, Barrie Hunt, Geoff Jenkins, Roy Jenne, Tom Karl, Akira Kasahara, Jeff Kiehl, Andrew Lacis, Cecil E. “ Chuck ” Leith, Richard Lindzen, Jerry Mahlman, Syukuro Manabe, Bryant McAvaney, Linda Mearns, John Mitchell, Roger Newson, Abraham Oort, Graeme Pearman, David Pollard, Kamal Puri, Robert Quayle, David Rind, William Rossow, Peter Rowntree, Robert Sadourny, David Schimel, Gus Schumbera, Stephen Schneider, Joseph Smagorinsky, Starley Thompson, Kevin Trenberth, Joe Tribbia, Warren Washington, Richard Wetherald, Tom Wigley, and Austin Woods. The National Science Foundation Research supported research for this book under grants SBE-9310892, SBR-9710616, SES-0630263, and BCS-0827316. The Alfred P. Sloan Foundation and the Center for the History of Physics at the American Institute of Physics funded oral history interviews, research assistance, and the production of a website on the history of climate modeling. The School of Information at the University of Michigan provided generous research support. At the MIT Press, I espe- cially want to thank the incomparable Margy Avery, who eased the pro duction process and thought so creatively about this book, and the extraordinary manuscript editor, Paul Bethge. Extraordinary friends eased the path of this long journey. Susan Douglas and T. R. Durham never lost faith in the project, or in me (and we ate so Acknowledgments xi well). Joel Howell ’ s wisdom and advice in time of need mattered more than he can ever know. Keith Breckenridge, Catherine Burns, Nolizwi Mpandana Stofela, and Cyprian Stofela gave us their beloved and beautiful South Africa. Ruth Oldenziel, Sven van Kuijk, and Marijn de Roos made Amsterdam a second home for us. In a category all their own, spanning intellectual, personal, and musical companionship, are my bandmates from the unforgettable Tensations: Andreas Fickers, Alec Badenoch, Susanne Lommers, Judith Schueler, Donna Mehos, Frank Schipper, and Nil Disco. Other very special friends are Todd Jones, Kali Israel, Alison Cook Sather, Robin White, Susan Bodnar, Eric Griffi ths, Ilona Bray, C. S. Soong, Rick Zinman, Dori Schack, and Eli and Isaac Schack Zinman. And no words can express my gratitude to my family: Carl, Janet, Craig, and Michael; Teresa and Mary K; Jesse, Annie, Maddie, and Spencer; Don, Elaine, and Lauren. Finally, I thank my son Luka, and Maya, for reminding me so often of why I wanted to do this. This book is for Steve, but it is also for them, and for the world they will inherit. Introduction Unless you have been in a coma since 1988, you have certainly heard or read a story that goes something like this: Global warming is a myth. It ’ s all model predictions, nothing but simulations. Before you believe it, wait for real data. “ The climate-studies people always tend to overestimate their models, ” the physicist Freeman Dyson told an interviewer in April 2009. “ They forget they are only models. ” 1 In the countless political controver- sies over climate change, the debate often shakes out into a contest: models versus data. This supposed contest is at best an illusion, at worst a deliberate decep- tion — because without models, there are no data . I ’ m not talking about the difference between “ raw ” and “ cooked ” data. I mean this literally. Today, no collection of signals or observations — even from satellites, which can “ see ” the whole planet — becomes global in time and space without fi rst passing through a series of data models. Since both observing systems and data models evolve, global data also change. We have not one data image of the global climate, but many. The past, or rather what we can know about the past, changes. And it will keep right on changing. I call this reverberation of data images “ shimmering. ” Global data images have proliferated, yet they have also converged. They shimmer around a central line, a trend that tells us that Earth has already warmed by about 0.75 ° C (1.35° F) since 1900.
Recommended publications
  • Jule Charney's Influence on Meteorology'

    Jule Charney's Influence on Meteorology'

    Jule Charney's Influence Norman A. Phillips National Weather Service, NOAA on Meteorology' Washington, D.C. 20233 The opportunity to address the Society on the contributions of Jule Charney to our science is an honor of the highest rank, and I thank you for this invitation. I will try to capture for you a meaningful impression of the extent to which our common undertaking has been influenced by this man (Fig. 1). Let me begin by recalling three historical contexts. The first of these is January 1,1917. Jule is born on this day in San Francisco, to Stella and Ely Charney. Five thousand miles away in Bergen, Norway, Vilhelm Bjerknes and his collabor- ators are developing the concepts of fronts and air masses. Some distance south of Bergen, Lewis Richardson is trans- porting wounded soldiers with the Friends Ambulance Corps. In spare moments, he is working on his monumental formulation of what is now called numerical weather prediction. My second context is around 1940. Jule had entered the University of California at Los Angeles in the mid-thirties, and is now a graduate student there in mathematics. UCLA is expanding, and Jacob Bjerknes and Jrirgen Holmboe ar- rive about this time. (A few years earlier, Bjerknes had pub- lished an important paper on long waves. In 1939, while he was at M.I.T., Carl Rossby published his well known model FIG. 1. A picture of Jule Charney (left), with E. Lorenz, taken in of long waves. These events are unknown to Jule.) Jule 1976 during a visit by Chinese meteorologists to the Massachusetts knows nothing of meteorology until one day he hears a talk Institute of Technology.
  • Satellite Meteorology in the Cold War Era: Scientific Coalitions and International Leadership 1946-1964

    Satellite Meteorology in the Cold War Era: Scientific Coalitions and International Leadership 1946-1964

    SATELLITE METEOROLOGY IN THE COLD WAR ERA: SCIENTIFIC COALITIONS AND INTERNATIONAL LEADERSHIP 1946-1964 A Dissertation Presented to The Academic Faculty By Angelina Long Callahan In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in History and Sociology of Technology and Science Georgia Institute of Technology December 2013 Copyright © Angelina Long Callahan 2013 SATELLITE METEOROLOGY IN THE COLD WAR ERA: SCIENTIFIC COALITIONS AND INTERNATIONAL LEADERSHIP 1946-1964 Approved by: Dr. John Krige, Advisor Dr. Leo Slater School of History, Technology & History Office Society Code 1001.15 Georgia Institute of Technology Naval Research Laboratory Dr. James Fleming Dr. Steven Usselman School of History, Technology & School of History, Technology & Society Society Colby College Georgia Institute of Technology Dr. Kenneth Knoespel Date Approved: School of History, Technology & 6 November 2013 Society Georgia Institute of Technology ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I submit this dissertation mindful that I’ve much left to do and much left to learn. Thus, lacking more elegant phrasing, I dedicate this to anyone who has set aside their own work to educate me. All of you listed below are extremely talented and because of that, managing substantial workloads. In spite of that, you have each been generous with your insight over the years and I am grateful for every meeting, email, and gesture of support you have shown. First, I want to thank my dissertation committee. I am extremely proud to claim each of you as a mentor. Please know how grateful I am for your patience and constructive criticism with this work in progress as it evolved milestone by milestone.
  • Roots of Ensemble Forecasting

    Roots of Ensemble Forecasting

    JULY 2005 L E W I S 1865 Roots of Ensemble Forecasting JOHN M. LEWIS National Severe Storms Laboratory, Norman, Oklahoma, and Desert Research Institute, Reno, Nevada (Manuscript received 19 August 2004, in final form 10 December 2004) ABSTRACT The generation of a probabilistic view of dynamical weather prediction is traced back to the early 1950s, to that point in time when deterministic short-range numerical weather prediction (NWP) achieved its earliest success. Eric Eady was the first meteorologist to voice concern over strict determinism—that is, a future determined by the initial state without account for uncertainties in that state. By the end of the decade, Philip Thompson and Edward Lorenz explored the predictability limits of deterministic forecasting and set the stage for an alternate view—a stochastic–dynamic view that was enunciated by Edward Epstein. The steps in both operational short-range NWP and extended-range forecasting that justified a coupling between probability and dynamical law are followed. A discussion of the bridge from theory to practice follows, and the study ends with a genealogy of ensemble forecasting as an outgrowth of traditions in the history of science. 1. Introduction assumption). And with guidance and institutional sup- port from John von Neumann at Princeton’s Institute Determinism was the basic tenet of physics from the for Advanced Study, Charney and his team of research- time of Newton (late 1600s) until the late 1800s. Simply ers used this principle to make two successful 24-h fore- stated, the future state of a system is completely deter- casts of the transient features of the large-scale flow mined by the present state of the system.
  • Prospects for Improving Forecasts of Weather and Short-Term Climate Variability on Subseasonal

    Prospects for Improving Forecasts of Weather and Short-Term Climate Variability on Subseasonal

    NASA/TM_2002-104606, Vol. 23 Techmcal Report Series• on Global Modehn_,• _J and Data Assimilation Volume 23 Prospects for Improved Forecasts of Weather and Short-Term Climate Variability on Subseasonal (2-Week to 2-Month) Time Scales S. Schubert, R. Dole, H. van den DooL MI Suarez, and D. Waliser Ptvceedings flvm a _fbrkshop Sponsored hy the Earth Sciences Directorate at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Centez Co-sponsored by 2v_dSA Seasonal-to-bm_rannual Prediction Project and NAS_d Data Assimilation OJfice April 16-18, 2002 Nc_vember__ 2002 The NASA STI Program Office ... m Profile Since its founding, NASA has been dedicated to CONFERENCE PUBLICATION. Collected the advancement of aeronautics and space papers from scientific and technical science. The NASA Scientific and Technical conferences, symposia, seminars, or other hlf()rmation (STI) Program Office plays a key meetings sponsored or cosponsored by NASA. part in helping NASA maintain this important role. SPECIAL PUBLICATION. Scientific, techni- cal, or historical information from NASA The NASA STI Program Office is operated by programs, projects, and mission, often con- Langley Research Center, the lead center for cemed with subjects having substantial public NASA's scientific and technical information. interest. The NASA STI Program Office provides access to the NASA STI Database, the largest collection TECHNICAL TRANSLATION. of aeronautical and space science STI in the English-I angu age translations of foreign scien- world. The Program Office i s also NASA' s tific and technical material pertinent to NASA's institutional mechanism for disseminating the mission. results of its research and development activi- ties. These results are published by NASA in the Specialized services that complement the STI NASA STI Report Series, which includes the Program Office's diverse offerings include creat- following report types: ing custom thesauri, building customized data- bases, organizing and publishing research results..
  • Craniord High to Graduate Largest Class Next Tuesday

    Craniord High to Graduate Largest Class Next Tuesday

    A.,. rue six CRANTOBD <N. J.) CITIZEN AND . JtOT*; !*•> been installed as the dominant in terior motif. ^- , - '.- •. City Savings Founded in 1887. City" Federal, Savings has grown from a single Opens New office in downtown Elizabeth to four' offices/including the new air- domebranch in,Elmora, with total Air-Dome assets in excess of $55,000,000. The ^ssociatlon'is'.'tlieTlarigEStrfederaUjr Association, with; offices in Eliza chartered savings association in the beth, Kenilworth and Linden; state and the largest sayings and opened the world's first air-dome loan association in Union County financial building in, the Elmora Entered as second class mall matter al section of Elizabeth on Saturday Vol. LXVH. No.2J. 3 SecUbn^, 24 Pages . NEW JERSEY, THURSDAY; JUNE 16,1960 The Post Office at Cranford. tt. J. TEN CENTS Erected as an interim measur while a new' permanent Elmora Office is. being built, the u'niqui savings center,has walls of trans Record Year J as estion parent vinyl.material supported by 's School Craniord High to Graduate an air pressure differential of onl; HOME PURCHASED—air. and Mre. Louis MoncelM of Bayonne Report Given four-hundredths of a point per have purchased the above home at 2 Amherst road* Mr. and Mrs. At Elizabeth, North Avenues square inch. A. special revolving George Miller, the former owners, have moved to Scotch Plains. diplomas to71 In an effort to help alleviate traffic congestion during the morn- door'" permits;.', only a minimal On Cranteen ing rush hour at Elizabeth and North avenues, a traffic patrolman •J..L-! This home was sold through the offices of G.
  • Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming (Cambridge: MIT Press, 2010)

    Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming (Cambridge: MIT Press, 2010)

    Complete bibliography of all items cited in A Vast Machine: Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming (Cambridge: MIT Press, 2010) Paul N. Edwards Caveat: this bibliography contains occasional typographical errors and incomplete citations. Abbate, Janet. Inventing the Internet. Inside Technology. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1999. Abbe, Cleveland. “The Weather Map on the Polar Projection.” Monthly Weather Review 42, no. 1 (1914): 36-38. Abelson, P. H. “Scientific Communication.” Science 209, no. 4452 (1980): 60-62. Aber, John D. “Terrestrial Ecosystems.” In Climate System Modeling, edited by Kevin E. Trenberth, 173- 200. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992. Ad Hoc Study Group on Carbon Dioxide and Climate. “Carbon Dioxide and Climate: A Scientific Assessment.” (1979): Air Force Data Control Unit. Machine Methods of Weather Statistics. New Orleans: Air Weather Service, 1948. Air Force Data Control Unit. Machine Methods of Weather Statistics. New Orleans: Air Weather Service, 1949. Alaka, MA, and RC Elvander. “Optimum Interpolation From Observations of Mixed Quality.” Monthly Weather Review 100, no. 8 (1972): 612-24. Edwards, A Vast Machine Bibliography 1 Alder, Ken. The Measure of All Things: The Seven-Year Odyssey and Hidden Error That Transformed the World. New York: Free Press, 2002. Allen, MR, and DJ Frame. “Call Off the Quest.” Science 318, no. 5850 (2007): 582. Alvarez, LW, W Alvarez, F Asaro, and HV Michel. “Extraterrestrial Cause for the Cretaceous-Tertiary Extinction.” Science 208, no. 4448 (1980): 1095-108. American Meteorological Society. 2000. Glossary of Meteorology. http://amsglossary.allenpress.com/glossary/ Anderson, E. C., and W. F. Libby. “World-Wide Distribution of Natural Radiocarbon.” Physical Review 81, no.
  • Global Weat Her Prediction and High-End Computing at NASA

    Global Weat Her Prediction and High-End Computing at NASA

    Global Weat her Prediction and High-End Computing at NASA Shian-Jiann Lin, Robert Atlas, and Kao-San Yeh* NASA Goddard Space Flight Center *Corresponding author address: Dr. Kao-San Yeh Code 900.3, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD 20771 E-mail: [email protected] August 18th, 2003 Abstract We demonstrate current capabilities of the NASA finite-volume General Circulation Model an high-resolution global weather prediction, and discuss its development path in the foreseeable future. This model can be regarded as a prototype of a future NASA Earth modeling system intended to unify development activities cutting across various disciplines within the NASA Earth Science Enterprise. 1 1. Introduction NASA’s goal for an Earth modeling system is to unify the model development activities that cut across various disciplines within the Earth Science Enterprise. Applications of the Earth modeling system include, but are not limited to, weather and chemistry-climate change predictions, and atmospheric and oceanic data assimilation. Among these applications, high-resolution global weather prediction requires the highest temporal and spatial resolution, and hence demands the most capability of a high-end computing system. In the continuing quest to improve and perhaps push to the limit of the predictability of the weather (see the related side bar), we are adopting more physically based algorithms with much higher resolution than those in earlier models. We are also including additional physical and chemical components that have not been coupled to the modeling system previously. As a comprehensive high-resolution Earth modeling system will require enormous computing power, it is important to design all component models efficiently for modern parallel computers with distributed-memory platforms.
  • Ensemble Forecasting and Data Assimilation: Two Problems with the Same Solution?

    Ensemble Forecasting and Data Assimilation: Two Problems with the Same Solution?

    Ensemble forecasting and data assimilation: two problems with the same solution? Eugenia Kalnay(1,2), Brian Hunt(2), Edward Ott(2) and Istvan Szunyogh(1,2) (1)Department of Meteorology and (2)Chaos Group University of Maryland, College Park, MD, 20742 1. Introduction Until 1991, operational NWP centers used to run a single computer forecast started from initial conditions given by the analysis, which is the best available estimate of the state of the atmosphere at the initial time. In December 1992, both NCEP and ECMWF started running ensembles of forecasts from slightly perturbed initial conditions (Molteni and Palmer, 1993, Buizza et al, 1998, Buizza, 2005, Toth and Kalnay, 1993, Tracton and Kalnay, 1993, Toth and Kalnay, 1997). Ensemble forecasting provides human forecasters with a range of possible solutions, whose average is generally more accurate than the single deterministic forecast (e.g., Fig. 4), and whose spread gives information about the forecast errors. It also provides a quantitative basis for probabilistic forecasting. Schematic Fig. 1 shows the essential components of an ensemble: a control forecast started from the analysis, two additional forecasts started from two perturbations to the analysis (in this example the same perturbation is added and subtracted from the analysis so that the ensemble mean perturbation is zero), the ensemble average, and the “truth”, or forecast verification, which becomes available later. The first schematic shows an example of a “good ensemble” in which “truth” looks like a member of the ensemble. In this case, the ensemble average is closer to the truth than the control due to nonlinear filtering of errors, and the ensemble spread is related to the forecast error.
  • Storm Data and Unusual Weather Phenomena

    Storm Data and Unusual Weather Phenomena

    Storm Data and Unusual Weather Phenomena Time Path Path Number of Estimated June 2002 Local/ Length Width Persons Damage Location Date Standard (Miles) (Yards) Killed Injured Property Crops Character of Storm ALABAMA, North Central ALZ006 Madison 03 1600CST 0 0 0 0 Excessive Heat The afternoon high temperature measured at the Huntsville International Airport was 95 degrees. This reading tied the previous record high temperature last set in 1998. Talladega County 5 S Talladega 04 1219CST 0 0 5K 0 Hail(1.75) Golf ball size hail was reported in the Brecon community, just south of Talladega. St. Clair County Ragland 04 1301CST 0 0 0 0 Hail(1.00) Quarter size hail was observed in and around the city of Ragland. St. Clair County Ragland 04 1301CST 0 0 3K 0 Thunderstorm Wind (G55) Several trees had their tops snapped off along SR 144 south of Ragland. A few of the downed trees snapped power lines. Tallapoosa County Newsite 04 1314CST 0 0 2K 0 Hail(1.75) Tallapoosa County Newsite 04 1314CST 0 0 2K 0 Thunderstorm Wind (G50) Tallapoosa County Alexander City 04 1320CST 0 0 0 0 Hail(1.00) Golf ball size hail was reported and trees were blown down on SR 22 near New Site. Quarter size hail was observed in Alexander City. Cherokee County 4 S Centre 04 1335CST 0 0 0 0 Hail(0.75) Penny size hail was reported at the Tennala community about 4 miles south of Centre. Clay County 13 N Ashland 04 1400CST 0 1 3K 0 Lightning A seven year old girl was struck by lightning inside the Cheaha State Park grounds.
  • An Abstract of the Dissertation Of

    An Abstract of the Dissertation Of

    AN ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION OF Kristine C. Harper for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History of Science presented on April 25, 2003. Title: Boundaries of Research: Civilian Leadership, Military Funding, and the International Network Surrounding the Development of Numerical Weather Prediction in the United States. Redacted for privacy Abstract approved: E. Doel American meteorology was synonymous with subjective weather forecasting in the early twentieth century. Controlled by the Weather Bureau and with no academic programs of its own, the few hundred extant meteorologists had no standing in the scientific community. Until the American Meteorological Society was founded in 1919, meteorologists had no professional society. The post-World War I rise of aeronautics spurred demands for increased meteorological education and training. The Navy arranged the first graduate program in meteorology in 1928 at MIT. It was followed by four additional programs in the interwar years. When the U.S. military found itself short of meteorological support for World War II, a massive training program created thousands of new mathematics- and physics-savvy meteorologists. Those remaining in the field after the war had three goals: to create a mathematics-based theory for meteorology, to create a method for objectively forecasting the weather, and to professionalize the field. Contemporaneously, mathematician John von Neumann was preparing to create a new electronic digital computer which could solve, via numerical analysis, the equations that defmed the atmosphere. Weather Bureau Chief Francis W. Reichelderfer encouraged von Neumann, with Office of Naval Research funding, to attack the weather forecasting problem. Assisting with the proposal was eminent Swedish-born meteorologist Carl-Gustav Rossby.
  • CICS Annual Report 2014

    CICS Annual Report 2014

    Volume II CICS Annual Report 2014 Figure 1: Example of spurious line of fires present in the IDPS-based Active Fires EDR caused by an improperly cali- brated M13 scan acquired on 23 July 2013. We continued our assessment of the VIIRS SDRs in mid-2013 and identified additional problems in several bands with respect to the conversion of radiance to brightness temperatures (Figure 2). Several DRs have been filed as a result of our efforts. Figure 2: Example of flawed band I5 brightness temperatures present in August 2013 VIIRS SDR. Unlike the pattern shown here, there should of course be just one brightness temperature associated with each radiance value. In August 2013 we attended the Suomi NPP EDR Product Review for Active Fires, Surface Reflectance, and Vegetation Indices. Based on our product development and validation results presented to the review panel, the VIIRS Active Fire (formerly Active Fires) EDR was assigned a maturity status of pro- visional in October. 201 Volume II CICS Annual Report 2014 In December 2013 we updated the Joint Polar Satellite System (JPSS) Algorithm Specification Volume II: Data Dictionary for the Active Fires at the request of our NESDIS lead. PLANNED WORK Continue assessment of VIIRS SDR radiance, brightness temperature, and QF data used to generate the VIIRS Active Fire product. Continue work to refine the algorithm parameters and improve performance. Transition algorithm to operations (NDE or IDPS). PUBLICATIONS Csiszar, I., W. Schroeder, L. Giglio, E. Ellicott, K. P. Vadrevu, C. O. Justice, and B. Wind (2014), Active fires from the Suomi NPP Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite: Product status and first evaluation results, J.
  • The ENIAC Forecasts

    The ENIAC Forecasts

    THE ENIAC NCEP–NCAR reanalyses help show that four historic forecasts made in 1950 with a pioneering electronic FORECASTS computer all had some predictive skill and, with a A Re-creation minor modification, might have been still better. BY PETER LYNCH he first weather forecasts executed on an auto- However, they were not verified objectively. In this matic computer were described in a landmark study, we recreate the four forecasts using data avail- T paper by Charney et al. (1950, hereafter CFvN). able through the National Centers for Environmental They used the Electronic Numerical Integrator and Prediction–National Center for Atmospheric Research Computer (ENIAC), which was the most powerful (NCEP–NCAR) 50-year reanalysis project. A com- computer available for the project, albeit primitive parison of the original and reconstructed forecasts by modern standards. The results were sufficiently shows them to be in good agreement. Quantitative encouraging that numerical weather prediction be- verification of the forecasts yields surprising results: came an operational reality within about five years. On the basis of root-mean-square errors, persistence CFvN subjectively compared the forecasts to analy- beats the forecast in three of the four cases. The mean ses and drew general conclusions about their quality. error, or bias, is smaller for persistence in all four cases. However, when S1 scores (Teweles and Wobus 1954) are compared, all four forecasts show skill, and three FIG. 1. Visitors and some participants in the 1950 ENIAC are substantially better than persistence. computations. (left to right) Harry Wexler, John von Neumann, M. H. Frankel, Jerome Namias, John Freeman, Ragnar Fjørtoft, Francis Reichelderfer, and Jule Charney.