DOCSLIB.ORG

International Development Non-Government Organisations and Partnership

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
International Development Non-Government Organisations and Partnership IINTERNATIONAL DDEVELOPMENT NNON--GGOVERNMENT OORGANISATIONS AND PPARTNERSHIP by Barbara Stephens (B..A..) A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Sociology School of Social and Political Sciences UNIVERSITY OF CANTERBURY 2013 Table of Contents Acknowledgements .................................................................................................... i Abstract .................................................................................................................... ii List of Acronyms ....................................................................................................... iv 1. Introduction .......................................................................................................... 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1 Partnership Connotations.................................................................................................................... 2 Locating Partnership ............................................................................................................................ 6 Resource Base ..................................................................................................................................... 7 The Aid and Development Sector ........................................................................................................ 9 Parameters of the Research ........................................................................................... 12 Background to the Research .......................................................................................... 13 The Purpose of the Research .......................................................................................... 15 2. Methodology ...................................................................................................... 17 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 17 Research ....................................................................................................................... 18 Theoretical Basis ................................................................................................................................ 18 Design ................................................................................................................................................ 19 Methods ............................................................................................................................................ 21 Interview Process ......................................................................................................................... 21 Questions ..................................................................................................................................... 23 Discussion ..................................................................................................................................... 24 Findings ............................................................................................................................................. 25 3. Literature Review ................................................................................................ 27 The Concept and Practice of Partnership in the Work of International Development Non- Government Organisations (INGOs) ............................................................................................. 27 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 27 The Literature ................................................................................................................ 27 The Problem ...................................................................................................................................... 27 Relevant Literature ............................................................................................................................ 29 Structure of Review ........................................................................................................................... 31 INGO Roots and Contemporary Context ......................................................................... 31 Development Ideology ...................................................................................................................... 32 From Charity to the Aid Industry ....................................................................................................... 35 Third Sector Research ........................................................................................................................ 38 INGOS and Partnership .................................................................................................. 43 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 43 North/South/North Interactions ....................................................................................................... 45 21st Century Interactions ................................................................................................................... 48 Cross-Cultural Relations .................................................................................................................... 53 Using Partner Language ..................................................................................................................... 57 Knowledge, Understanding, and Partnership.................................................................................... 64 Reclaiming Partnership ...................................................................................................................... 70 Conclusion..................................................................................................................... 72 4. The Ingos ............................................................................................................ 75 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 75 Save the Children ............................................................................................................................... 77 Oxfam ................................................................................................................................................ 79 Caritas and Christian World Service .................................................................................................. 81 World Vision ...................................................................................................................................... 87 Evangelicalism .............................................................................................................................. 91 TEAR Fund.......................................................................................................................................... 91 Conclusion..................................................................................................................... 92 5. INGOs and Partnership: Research Findings ........................................................... 95 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 95 Identified Practices ........................................................................................................ 96 Concepts of Intervention and Reciprocity ....................................................................... 97 Intervention ....................................................................................................................................... 97 Reciprocity ......................................................................................................................................... 98 INGO Practice ............................................................................................................... 101 Interventionist Practices ..................................................................................................................101 Interfere – Obstruct, Impede, Hamper ......................................................................................101 Intrude – Encroach, Infringe .......................................................................................................105 Meddle – Pry, Butt In .................................................................................................................109 The Intentions of INGO Interventions ........................................................................................112 Individuals or Communities? ......................................................................................................116 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................118 Practices of Reciprocity ...................................................................................................................119 Introduction................................................................................................................................119 The Intercultural
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Fifth Sunday of Easter - for the Congregations of St James' East Malling and Holy Trinity Larkfield
    The Fifth Sunday of Easter - for the congregations of St James' East Malling and Holy Trinity Larkfield Into the heart of our Easter celebrations comes a week which is set aside each year for us to consider our response to the plea to help some of the poorest in the world. Christian Aid Week begins this Sunday, an annual event across the United Kingdom, in many places in past years, though not this year because of the prevailing circumstances, a door-to-door fundraising drive to do something, however small, to help cope with some of the world's need. There will, of course, be no red collection envelopes placed this year through doors and collected a few days later, and what Christian Aid usually raises will be vastly reduced. In the last couple of weeks people up and down this country have again shown their generosity, through the BBC's Big Night Live, in raising more than 27 million pounds for people in the UK who need our support now more than ever, an amount matched by the Government, and Colonel Tom's efforts even exceeded that in helping to raise a staggering £31 million for the NHS, but for Christian Aid there will probably be a fraction of the £9m usually raised in this coming week. Here is a challenge for every Christian, not least as we face the Question which St John in his letter (1 John 3, 17) posed: "How does God’s love abide in anyone who has the world’s goods and sees a brother or sister in need and yet refuses help?" In these weeks of Easter, when we have heard again the gospel accounts of Jesus’ appearing to his friends after his resurrection, we might reflect on that story of the journey to Emmaus, when Jesus came to two of his friends but was unrecognised: so often we also fail to recognise Him in the poor, the deprived, the suffering and the hungry.
    [Show full text]
  • 17Th October 1974
    The Australian 20 cents Rahfly OW People BIBLE SOCIETY LEADER BRISBANE The Rev Robert Roy Braun, formerly Assistant Curate of St Clement's. Stafford. as s o.otant Curate of Christ Church. FOR UBS Bundaberg. Church Record The Rev Alec Maurice Fox, formerly of the Diocese of 11.10er.n tor posting a. No 1573 First published 1880 • n.resoauer—Caleporr 0( 1 Otit R 17. 1974 Carpentaria. as Rector of St Paul's, East'Brisbane. The Rev Graham Henry Perry. formerly of the Diocese of Rockhampton. as Priest-in-Charge of the Parish of Brisbane Valley. CONFERENCE The Rev Henry Taylor, formerly Vicar of Glen Hines in theDiocese of Armidale. as Rector of St Peter.. Wsimum Students succeed IN POLAND CMS APPOINTS ITS FIRST I he Commonwealth Secretary of the Bible at London BD exams Society in Australia, the Rev James Payne, will attend a meeting of the United Bible Moore College students Stephen William H inks, were again successful with Ross Melville Kennedy, Societies' Executive Committee, in Poland, London BD examinations Rodney Norman Marsh, Joe this month. 'OVERSEAS' SECRETARY this year. Mock, Francis William movement was finding The seven candidates from Mostyn, Coryn O'Nians, This is the first time the increasing opportunities for Moore College who sat for Robin Ashley Payne. Paul United Bible Societies' its activities in most Eastern the London BD edamination Frederick Perini, Paul Blake Executive Committee has European countries, he said. last June passed successfully Weaver. met behind the Iron Curtain. A former Dean of Perth with honours. The meeting will be held in Mr Payne is the only Angli- Thirteen candidates who Warsaw.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017-2018 School of Medicine Catalog
    School of Medicine Catalog Vanderbilt University 2017/2018 Archived 2017/2018 School of Medicine Catalog Containing general information and courses of study for the 2017/2018 session corrected to August 2017 Nashville Communicating with the School of Medicine Office of the Dean Office of Enrollment Services Jeffrey R. Balser, M.D., Ph.D. Dean, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine Admissions D-3300 Medical Center North Jennifer S. Kimble, M.Ed. Nashville, Tennessee 37232-2104 Director of Admissions (615) 936-3030 303 Rudolph A. Light Hall Nashville, Tennessee 37232-0248 Office of Health Sciences Education (615) 322-2145 Bonnie M. Miller, M.D., M.M.H.C. Senior Associate Dean for Health Sciences Education Scholarships and Financial Aid 201 Rudolph A. Light Hall Sherry Stuart Nashville, Tennessee 37232-0685 Assistant Director, Student Financial Services (615) 322-7221 303 Rudolph A. Light Hall Nashville, Tennessee 37232-0248 Faculty Affairs (615) 322-1792 David S. Raiford, M.D. Senior Associate Dean for Faculty Affairs Student Records 320 Rudolph A. Light Hall Logan S. Key, M.Ed. Nashville, Tennessee 37232-0260 Director, Student Records (615) 875-8721 303 Rudolph A. Light Hall Nashville, Tennessee 37232-0248 Biomedical Research, Education and Training (615) 322-2145 Roger Chalkley, D. Phil. Senior Associate Dean for Biomedical Research, Education and Training Center for Experiential Learning and Assessment (CELA) 340 Rudolph A. Light Hall Arna Banerjee, M.D. Nashville, Tennessee 37232-0301 Director (615) 343-4611 3450 Medical Research Building IV Nashville, TennesseeCatalog 37232-0432 Undergraduate Medical Education (615) 936-8801 Kimberly D. Lomis, M.D. Associate Dean for Undergraduate Medical Education Continuing Medical Education/Maintenance of Certification 201 Rudolph A.
    [Show full text]
  • April 2011: Discipleship
    Candour N e w s a N d views for mi N i s t e r s ISSUE 3 // APRIL 2011 Discipleship www.presbyterian.org.nz Contents CoNTENTS Candour is a monthly magazine Guest editorial: ............................................................3 about ministry and leadership. A new ecumenical body ISSN 1171-1027 (Print) Scott Thomson ISSN 1179-402X (Online) essays The articles in Candour reflect the views of individual ministers Direct training .............................................................6 or contributors writing in a personal capacity. They are not Peter Cheyne representative of the Church’s official position. Please approach Take it personally – discipleship ...........................10 the author for permission if you as personal interaction wish to copy an article. rather than programme Contributions Martin Macaulay We welcome responses to published articles. If you would AES column ..................................................................12 like to write a piece replying to any Martin Baker of this month’s featured articles, please contact: The editor on (04) 801-6000 or [email protected] Advertising one-quarter page: $80 plus gst one-third page: $95 plus gst Half page: $130 plus gst Any artwork must be supplied electronically and in a high- resolution format. Measurements are indicative only and subject to layout requirements. The next deadline (for the May issue) is Friday, 29 April 2011. Glen Innis Free holiday accommodation for Cover image ministers in Central Hawkes Bay © istockphoto.com Upcoming vacancies April 18 - 25 Homestead / Cottage May 30 - June 6 Homestead / Cottage June 6 - 13 Homestead / Cottage June 20 - 27 Homestead / Cottage For information and bookings, please con- tact Margaret Black at [email protected] or (06) 855-4889.
    [Show full text]
  • FULL ISSUE (48 Pp., 2.5 MB PDF)
    Vol. 21, No.2 nternatlona• April 1997 etln• Culture: The Ambiguous Ally of Mission ast November, in Salvador, Bahia, Brazil, the World ary movement occurred in the Highlands of Scotland. And we L Council of Churches convened a Conference on World conclude with essays on two twentieth-century Roman Catholic Mission and Evangelism and addressed the topic of Gospel and missionary leaders-the latest contributions to our award­ culture. On page 52 of this issue readers will find the official winning Mission Legacy series. conference message. A key sentence highlights the ambiguity inherent in culture: "We have sought to understand better the way in which the Gospel challenges all human cultures and how culture can give us a clearer understanding of the Gospel." Obviously, understanding culture may be the key for entree to a On Page particular people. But both the culture of the recipients and the 50 The Dialogue of Gospel and Culture: Reflec­ culture of the messengers may also stand in the way of authentic tions on the Conference on World Mission and engagement with the Gospel of Jesus and his kingdom. Evangelism, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil Our lead article provides seasoned reflections on the Salva­ Lesslie Newbigin dor conference by Lesslie Newbigin, INTERNATIONAL BULLETIN contributing editor. Newbigin reports that he perceived a one­ 53 Conference Message from Salvador sided emphasis on affirming culture at the WCC conference. One Conference on World Mission and Evangelism, cannotblindlyaffirmculture,for to do so couldlead,as Newbigin Salvador, Bahia, Brazil offers by way of illustration, to "legitimating the Afrikaner 55 My Pilgrimage in Mission reading of the Bible as validating apartheid...
    [Show full text]
  • Knox Church and James Matheson
    Knox Church and James Matheson. Knox Church in the 1950’s was a microcosm of the surging church life of the time, when everything was “going like a train”. (A.D. Horwell) Church Extension boomed in the new suburbs, as part of the New Life Movement. Some sixty new parishes were established during the decade. Some remarkable Presbyterian preachers up and down the land open up new horizons of theology, social justice, ecumenism, and as Allan Davidson has pointed out, dynamic laypeople cut through the old clerical autocracy.1 Schools trained ministers and elders in visitation evangelism. The Bible Class movement boomed. Women’s claims for leadership roles were slowly being recognized by the mid-1950’s. Jim Matheson, then, this is my thesis in advance, did not wave some magic wand of renewal during his decade at Knox Church, 1951-1960. His contribution was substantial and indeed remarkable but he also surfed the waves of a buoyant church life in Otago and Southland, which sent hundreds of young people to train as nurses and students in Dunedin. He inherited a congregation which in 1951 was strong, had a good conceit of itself, and was exceptional in its provision of staff, with deaconess, nurse, organist, secretary as well as two ministers and its own missionary. In its AGM of 1948 it was described as the biggest congregation of the Presbyterian Church in NZ and it was regarded as fitting that it should also have in David Herron the best minister. The ‘ruggedness and toughness’ of his addresses was noted. 2 The Rev Dr David Herron CBE, had played a magisterial role as Moderator of the Church, as Chancellor of Otago University and had been awarded an honorary Doctorate by St Andrew University.
    [Show full text]
  • Dialogue Between Christians, Jews and Muslims: the Concept of Covenant As Basis
    Dialogue Between Christians, Jews and Muslims: The Concept of Covenant as Basis By Ian Rex Fry RDA A thesis submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy MCD University of Divinity March 14, 2012 Acknowledgements I wish to acknowledge and record my gratitude for advice, guidance and personal assistance received from a number of people during the course of my research. In particular, Revd. Dr. Ruwan Palapathwala, Research Associate, Melbourne College of Divinity, who has been my mentor and has facilitated my research in various ways in addition to being my nominated Supervisor, and my wife, Lynette, whose support, encouragement and considerable tolerance and understanding over several years, as well as assistance with reading and facilitating reference searches, have been enormously important in enabled me to complete the task. There are a number of scholars who have provided specific assistance with works of reference, in personal discussions, correspondence or introductions, including Professor Richard Law, Washington State University, for permission to use his hominid evolution references; Dr. Edmund Chia, Catholic Theological Union. Chicago, for providing his doctoral thesis; Professor Abdul Khaliq Kazi, International Islamic University Islamabad, for personal assistance, guidance and as a mentor for many years; Professor Ira Bashkow, University of Virginia, as a mentor and for introducing me to the scholars of the Children of Abraham Institute; Professor Leonard Swidler, Temple University,
    [Show full text]
  • Interfaith Dialogue
    Christian Conference of Asia ccanews Interfaith Dialogue Christianity and Other Faiths Peace and Reconciliation Environmental Protection K.H. Ting Volume 37 • Number 4 • December 2002 Editorial Interfaith Cooperation This issue of CCA News calls on us to reflect on interfaith cooperation as a vital part of our ecumenical calling and commitment. Historically, Asian Christians have been deeply involved in nation-building in their re- spective countries. They carried out such involvement along with groups of other reli- gious traditions. The common desire for national independence and reconstruction was enough to bind them together in collaboration. Together with other citizens, including those of other faiths, Asian Christians also actively participated in pro-democracy move- ments in various parts of Asia during the 1960s and 1970s. During the 1980s and 1990s, Asian Christians became committed to the promotion of common values of peace and justice, protecting human dignity and security, and preventing the further exploitation of God’s creation. Once again, this was done together with other citizens of other faiths. Hence, as some Asian theologians have claimed, interfaith cooperation has always been part of the Asian way of life. When the ecumenical movement (from the Greek word oikoumene) began, coopera- tion was initially undertaken among certain Christian groups, particularly Protestants, Anglicans and Orthodox. It has since expanded to include the dialogue and cooperation with Roman Catholic and other Christian groups. And now, many feel that faithfulness to the whole meaning of the word, ‘whole household of God’ and ‘whole inhabited earth’, requires much greater openness than in the past to other religions, world-views and ide- ologies, cooperating and collaborating with them where appropriate in the service of God, our neighbours and the whole earth.
    [Show full text]
  • A Sociological Interpretation of the History of New Zealand Missionaries in China from 1877 to 1953 and Beyond
    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. “Kiwis” in the Middle Kingdom üü A Sociological Interpretation of the History of New Zealand Missionaries in China from 1877 to 1953 and Beyond A thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology at Massey University, Albany, New Zealand Sylvia Yang Yuan 2013 i Abstract Between 1877 and 1953, 254 men and women went to China as missionaries who were associated with Aotearoa/New Zealand in one way or another. This thesis presents a sociological interpretation of this historical phenomenon using Goffman’s Dramaturgy as a theoretical framework. The dramaturgical narration begins from the “back-stage” of New Zealand as a sending country and then extends to the “front-stage” of China as a mission field. Substantial space is dedicated to a scrutiny of the day-to-day life of “Kiwi” missionaries living in the arena of the “Middle Kingdom”, including adoption of Chinese names, language learning, clothing changes, dietary changes, compound accommodation, itinerant and residential evangelism, medical and educational works, summer retreats, racial and gender dynamics, romance and marriage, child-bearing and child-rearing, and the childhood of “missionary kids”. There were various interludes to their missionary career when their sense of self-identity was heightened and challenged. The change of government in China brought an abrupt end to all missions.
    [Show full text]
  • Jakobsen, David; Øhrstrøm, Peter
    Aalborg Universitet The Metaphysics of Time Themes from Prior Hasle, Peter; Jakobsen, David; Øhrstrøm, Peter Publication date: 2020 Document Version Også kaldet Forlagets PDF Link to publication from Aalborg University Citation for published version (APA): Hasle, P., Jakobsen, D., & Øhrstrøm, P. (red.) (2020). The Metaphysics of Time: Themes from Prior. Aalborg Universitetsforlag. Logic and Philosophy of Time General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. ? Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. ? You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain ? You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ? Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us at [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from vbn.aau.dk on: December 25, 2020 The Metaphysics of Time Logic and Philosophy of Time, Vol. 4 Per Hasle, David Jakobsen, and Peter Øhrstrøm (Eds.) The Metaphysics of Time: Themes from Prior Edited by: Per Hasle, David Jakobsen and Peter Øhrstrøm Logic and Philosophy of Time, Volume 4 The Metaphysics of Time: Themes
    [Show full text]
  • 31St October 1974
    The Australian 20 cents MaMO NW People Festival of Light SI Ws. Fa the Rev J. H. A. Gibson, The Rev John Wise, rector formerly assistant priest at St of St Jame,... South Canter- John's Canberra, and St rally attracts 7000 bury, with St Mark's, Clem- Matthew's, Albury, and most ton Park, since 1971, has en- recently in the Parish of Sydney's Dean Shilton told a recent rally of Church Record Roolsterecl for oostlise tered the army. He is chap- Havant, Hampshire, No 1574 First published 1880 g n•rowapiCate.or A OCEOBER 31, 1974 lain at Bandiana, Victoria England, has been appointed nearly 7000 that the Festival of I.ight was one of The Rev Bill Holland has Rector of Gunning with the "most positive organisations" in the been appointed to Robert- effect from early December. community today. son (NSW) to replace the The Rev David Rein is pre- Rev Arthur Horrex who has sently relieving in the parish The Rev l.ance Shilton Dean Shilton said FOL sup- joined BCA. Mr Holland of Koorawatha. The Rector was addressing a protest porters were not imposing has been curate-in-charge at of Koorawatha, The Rev meeting at the Miranda their will on others, but on Manly Vale since 1971. Michael Cockayne, is at pre- Fair Shopping Centre. those who "for filthy lucre's sake" were seeking to Bishop Graham A member of the editorial sent on leave in Europe, visi- south of Sydney. Delbridge manipulate the community. staff of the Reader's Digest ting Taize and other Com- It was the largest e'er at- "We are a concerned has been appointed hono- munities.
    [Show full text]
  • September 2007
    e-Messenger The Methodist Church of New Zealand ~ Te Hāhi Weteriana O Aotearoa “Our Church's Mission in Aotearoa New Zealand is to reflect and proclaim the transforming love of God as revealed in Jesus Christ and declared in the Scriptures. We are empowered by the Holy Spirit to serve God in the world. The Treaty of Waitangi is the covenant establishing our nation on the basis of a power-sharing relationship, and will guide how we undertake mission”. CONTENT S Official Communications…….. ………………2 - A message from the President & Vice President - A message from the General Secretary Connexional News……………………… ………..4 Remember in your Prayers ………………….4 Mission & Ecumenical…………….……. ………4 Ecumenical News & Views ……………..…4 Job Opportunities ……………………………….…4 Yearbook Amendments ……………………...4 September 2007 Web Site Address: www.methodist.org.nz A MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT It’s September: we expect to be in springtime. Certainly, travelling through Otago last week, the new green is showing, blossoms are beginning to appear, lambing is underway. As is often the case, though, following a period of warm weather, a cold front then brought snow. The uncertainty of weather can make life difficult, especially for those tending new animals or new growth on tree or vine. We urban dwellers do well to remember the economic impact of what is often simply an inconvenience for us. As I noted last month, August was a month of celebrations – amongst the ongoing life of worship and business meetings and pastoral concerns. St Johns Church, Opotiki, celebrated the centennial of its church building, with a lively dinner and appropriate worship (even dancing from the worship leaders!).
    [Show full text]