Newash and Tecumseth: Analysis of Two Post-War of 1812 Vessels

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Newash and Tecumseth: Analysis of Two Post-War of 1812 Vessels NEWASH AND TECUMSETH: ANALYSIS OF TWO POST-WAR OF 1812 VESSELS ON THE GREAT LAKES A Thesis by LEEANNE ELIZABETH GORDON Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS May 2009 Major Subject: Anthropology NEWASH AND TECUMSETH: ANALYSIS OF TWO POST-WAR OF 1812 VESSELS ON THE GREAT LAKES A Thesis by LEEANNE ELIZABETH GORDON Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Approved by: Chair of Committee, Kevin J. Crisman Committee Members, Troy O. Bickham Donny L. Hamilton Head of Department, Donny L. Hamilton May 2009 Major Subject: Anthropology iii ABSTRACT Newash and Tecumseth: Analysis of Two Post-War of 1812 Vessels on the Great Lakes. (May 2009) LeeAnne Elizabeth Gordon, B.A., Auburn University Chair of Advisory Committee: Dr. Kevin J. Crisman In 1953 the tangled, skeletal remains of a ship were pulled from the small harbor of Penetanguishene, Ontario. Local historians had hoped to raise the hull of a War of 1812 veteran, but the vessel pulled from the depths did not meet the criteria. Identified as H.M. Schooner Tecumseth, the vessel was built just after the War of 1812 had ended. Historical research of Tecumseth and her sister ship Newash, which remained in Penetanguishene harbor, illuminated the ships’ shadowy past. Conceived and built after the war, the vessels sailed for only two years before being rendered obsolete by the terms of the Rush-Bagot disarmament agreement. Nevertheless, the two vessels offer a unique perspective from which to view the post-war period on the Great Lakes. The schooners’ hulls were interpreted and analyzed using archaeological evidence. A theoretical rigging reconstruction was created, using contemporary texts and documentary evidence of the ships themselves. Architectural hull analysis was carried out to explore the nature of these vessels. From these varied approaches, a conception of iv Newash and Tecumseth has emerged, revealing ways in which the hulls were designed to fulfill their specific duties. The hulls were sharp, yet had capacious cargo areas. The rigs combined square-rigged and fore-and-aft sails for maximum flexibility. The designs of the hulls and rigging also reflect predominant attitudes of the period, in which naval vessels on the lakes gave way to merchant craft. Taken as a whole, Tecumseth and Newash illustrate how ships, while fluid in the nature of their work, are also singular entities that truly encapsulate a specific point in time and place. v “If you are flammable and have legs, you are never blocking a fire exit.” -Mitch Hedberg vi ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The preparation of this thesis could not have been done without the tremendous assistance of many people who have contributed in various ways. I wish to thank, in no particular order: Marita and the staff of the Penetanguishene Public Library; Mike Seraphin and the staff of Discovery Harbour (Havre de la Découverte); Erich Heinold, Chris Sabick, Eric Emery, Brian Atchison and the other student archaeologists who took part in the surveys of Tecumseth and Newash in 1997 and 1998; Mr. John R. Stevens; Captain Walter Rybka, of the U.S. Brig Niagara; Captain Jamie Trost, of the topsail schooner Pride of Baltimore II; Captain Tiffany Krihwan, of the schooner Denis Sullivan; the irrepressible and unflappable Ms. Carrie Sowden, to whom I am forever in debt, financially and otherwise; Mrs. Elizabeth Hutchinson; the thesis committee, Drs. Kevin J. Crisman, Donny L. Hamilton and Troy O. Bickham; my underrated fellow students: Heather Brown, Carlos Cabrera, Claire Collins, Ben Ford, Heather Hatch, Brad Krueger, Ryan Lee, John Littlefield, Bridget McVae, Drew Roberts and Will Moser; my mom and dad, grandma and grandpa; and of course, the makers of Giant Eagle Bavarian ham, Lemonheads and, certainly, Dr. Pepper. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................. iii DEDICATION .......................................................................................................... v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS......................................................................................... vi TABLE OF CONTENTS .......................................................................................... vii LIST OF FIGURES................................................................................................... xi LIST OF TABLES .................................................................................................... xiv NOMENCLATURE.................................................................................................. xv CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION: THE ROYAL NAVY IN CANADA AND THE TREATY OF GHENT ......................................................................... 1 II TWO SHARP SCHOONERS .............................................................. 18 III MASTING AND DISMASTING ........................................................ 30 IV LIFE ABOARD THE SCHOONERS .................................................. 42 V THE NEWASH-MINK INCIDENT AND BORDER RELATIONS .... 50 The Case of Lieutenant Alexander Vidal............................................. 53 Seizure of Julia..................................................................................... 55 Customs House Boats on Lake Champlain .......................................... 56 VI WINTER ON LAKE ERIE .................................................................. 58 Re-Rigging the Ships ........................................................................... 62 Life at Grand River .............................................................................. 64 Crossing the Bar ................................................................................... 65 Later Seasons for the Vessels............................................................... 69 viii CHAPTER Page VII CAPTAIN WILLIAM BOURCHIER AND THE DISARMAMENT OF THE GREAT LAKES.................................................................... 71 The Rush-Bagot Agreement................................................................. 77 VIII DECAY AT PENETANGUISHENE................................................... 81 IX ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND HISTORICAL RESEARCH................. 87 The 1953 Salvage of Tecumseth........................................................... 88 Early Publications ................................................................................ 91 1970s Examination and Conservation Efforts...................................... 92 1997 – 1998 Archaeology .................................................................... 94 2007 – 2008 Investigations .................................................................. 98 X ARCHAEOLOGICAL EVIDENCE OF THE SCHOONERS’ CONSTRUCTION ............................................................................... 99 Keels and Posts..................................................................................... 100 Deadwood............................................................................................. 108 Frames .................................................................................................. 109 Keelsons, Stemsons and Sternsons....................................................... 111 Mast Steps ............................................................................................ 112 Mast Section......................................................................................... 116 Pump Wells and Limber Holes ............................................................ 117 Clamps, Deck Beams, Waterways and Wales...................................... 118 Chainplates ........................................................................................... 124 Planking the Ships................................................................................ 126 Newash and Tecumseth and War of 1812-Era Ship Construction ....... 128 XI HULL ANALYSIS .............................................................................. 134 Design Lines......................................................................................... 135 Coefficients and Ratios ........................................................................ 144 Waterplane Area and Immersion.......................................................... 149 Deck-Edge Immersion and Downflooding........................................... 150 Tender and Stiff Vessels ...................................................................... 152 Discussion: Hull Design and Purpose ................................................. 153 Penetanguishene’s Sailing Replica....................................................... 155 ix CHAPTER Page XII RECONSTRUCTING THE SCHOONER RIG................................... 158 Main Rigging........................................................................................ 164 Fore Rigging......................................................................................... 166 Bowsprit Rigging ................................................................................. 168 Trestletrees, Crosstrees and Mast Caps................................................ 170 Topmast Rigging .................................................................................. 170 Topgallant Rigging............................................................................... 173
Recommended publications
  • Armed Sloop Welcome Crew Training Manual
    HMAS WELCOME ARMED SLOOP WELCOME CREW TRAINING MANUAL Discovery Center ~ Great Lakes 13268 S. West Bayshore Drive Traverse City, Michigan 49684 231-946-2647 [email protected] (c) Maritime Heritage Alliance 2011 1 1770's WELCOME History of the 1770's British Armed Sloop, WELCOME About mid 1700’s John Askin came over from Ireland to fight for the British in the American Colonies during the French and Indian War (in Europe known as the Seven Years War). When the war ended he had an opportunity to go back to Ireland, but stayed here and set up his own business. He and a partner formed a trading company that eventually went bankrupt and Askin spent over 10 years paying off his debt. He then formed a new company called the Southwest Fur Trading Company; his territory was from Montreal on the east to Minnesota on the west including all of the Northern Great Lakes. He had three boats built: Welcome, Felicity and Archange. Welcome is believed to be the first vessel he had constructed for his fur trade. Felicity and Archange were named after his daughter and wife. The origin of Welcome’s name is not known. He had two wives, a European wife in Detroit and an Indian wife up in the Straits. His wife in Detroit knew about the Indian wife and had accepted this and in turn she also made sure that all the children of his Indian wife received schooling. Felicity married a man by the name of Brush (Brush Street in Detroit is named after him).
    [Show full text]
  • Anticipating Anchoring Story and Photos by Jeff Merrill
    power voyaging Anticipating anchoring STORy ANd phOTOS by JEff MERRIll he freedom to explore which goes into great detail Let’s presume that the Tremote cruising grounds on a number of theoretical windlass (horizontal or verti- and to anchor out overnight aspects and practical applica- cal) and anchor (so many or for days at a time is one tions for a variety of situa- variations) have already been of the great attractions of tions. Over time voyagers selected and installed on the trawler lifestyle. Under- generally develop techniques your trawler and are appro- standing how your ground for setting their anchor, priately sized to provide breaking it loose and you with sufficient holding securely stowing the strength. With this article ground tackle while I’d like to share some com- underway — practice, mon sense techniques you fine-tune and keep can adapt to your trawler learning. that will improve your com- There are many fort level and to help you factors involved in “dial-in” your anchoring selecting a safe place routine. Be sure that the to drop the hook — connection between your wind, tide, currents, anchor and chain (swivel other boats, etc. You with Loctite or shackles with seizing wire on the pins) is secure so it can’t disconnect. Above, an tackle connects your Securing the anchor anchor bridle floating palace to the It is vitally important that setup evenly sea floor and being your anchor, when raised distributes the properly prepared will and stowed on its roller, load. Right, an give you more con- is secure in place and not anchor keeper fidence to visit new free to wobble around.
    [Show full text]
  • Winter 2019 Full Issue the .SU
    Naval War College Review Volume 72 Article 1 Number 1 Winter 2019 2019 Winter 2019 Full Issue The .SU . Naval War College Follow this and additional works at: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/nwc-review Recommended Citation Naval War College, The .SU . (2019) "Winter 2019 Full Issue," Naval War College Review: Vol. 72 : No. 1 , Article 1. Available at: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/nwc-review/vol72/iss1/1 This Full Issue is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Naval War College Review by an authorized editor of U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Naval War College: Winter 2019 Full Issue Winter 2019 Volume 72, Number 1 Winter 2019 Published by U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons, 2019 1 Naval War College Review, Vol. 72 [2019], No. 1, Art. 1 Cover Aerial view of an international container cargo ship. In “Ships of State?,” Christopher R. O’Dea describes how China COSCO Shipping Corporation Limited has come to control a rapidly expanding network of ports and terminals, ostensibly for commercial purposes, but has thereby gained the ability to project power through the increased physical presence of its naval vessels—turning the oceans that historically have protected the United States from foreign threats into a venue in which China can challenge U.S. interests. Credit: Getty Images https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/nwc-review/vol72/iss1/1 2 Naval War College: Winter 2019 Full Issue NAVAL WAR COLLEGE REVIEW Winter 2019 Volume 72, Number 1 NAVAL WAR COLLEGE PRESS 686 Cushing Road Newport, RI 02841-1207 Published by U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Last Voyage of the Hornet: the Story That Made Mark Twain Famous
    Last Voyage of the Hornet: The Story that Made Mark Twain Famous Kristin Krause Royal Fireworks Press Unionville, New York For Greg, Duncan, and Luke – Never give up. Copyright © 2016, Royal Fireworks Publishing Co., Inc. All Rights Reserved. Royal Fireworks Press P.O. Box 399 41 First Avenue Unionville, NY 10988-0399 (845) 726-4444 fax: (845) 726-3824 email: [email protected] website: rfwp.com ISBN: 978-0-88092-265-4 Printed and bound in Unionville, New York, on acid-free paper using vegetable-based inks at the Royal Fireworks facility. Publisher: Dr. T.M. Kemnitz Editors: Dr. T. M. Kemnitz, Rachel Semlyen, and Jennifer Ault Book and cover designer: Kerri Ann Ruhl 8s6 ps Chapter 1 The clipper ship Hornet drifted across the mirroring waters of the Pacific Ocean in a blistering hot calm. Not a breath of wind stirred on deck, but upper air currents filled the skysails and royals, gently propelling the vessel along. The morning air was already sweltering. The crew, all barefoot and mostly shirtless, moved lethargically in the tropical heat. Those not on duty sought shade where they could find it or lazily dangled fishing lines in the water. All the hatches, skylights, and portholes were open to admit air, making it tolerable for those below decks. Since crossing the equator two days before, the ship had been slipping slowly north through a series of hot and windless days. But that was about to change. The captain of the Hornet was Josiah Mitchell, fifty-three years old, capable and levelheaded, with an inexpressive face hidden under a bushy beard.
    [Show full text]
  • NX Wind PLUS
    NX Wind PLUS - Instrument - Installation and Operation Manual English WIND English 1 English WIND 1 Part specification .............................................................................................. 3 2 Installation ......................................................................................................... 5 2.1 Installing the instrument ..................................................................................... 6 2.1.1 Installing the instrument to the WSI-box ................................................... 7 2.1.2 Installing the instrument to the NX2 Server ............................................... 8 2.1.3 Connecting to another Nexus instrument. ................................................. 8 3 First start (only in a Nexus Network) ............................................................... 8 3.1 Initialising the instrument ................................................................................... 8 3.2 Re-initialising the instrument .............................................................................. 9 4 Operation ......................................................................................................... 10 4.1 How to use the push buttons ........................................................................... 10 4.1.1 Lighting ................................................................................................... 11 4.2 Main function ..................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Report from the Commodore
    February 2017 Established 1913 Report from the Commodore appy February to all! Our club is alive and kicking early into 2017 and H those of you who enjoyed our rekindling of the New Years Dinner know just what I mean. A great time was had by all as the bar and dining area were transformed by Jill Powell and her decorating crew including Jauhree Walker, Trish Eaton, Tami Sandke, Margo Roberts Ruth Gilliland and Heather Furey. Dick Walker was a stalwart supervisor as well . Chef Benito and his team served a marvelous surf and turf meal to over 170 setting the bar high for the rest of 2017! Member favorites, the Manic Brothers, kept the dance floor full late into the evening. And though it has not Commodore Bill Sandke yet happened as I pen this missive, I am certain the Old Timers’ Brunch was a smash! February 12th will feature a Sunday evening double whammy of Wine and Chocolate! Bring your self and your sweetie to a casual Sunday evening taste bud work out with Susie Owen pouring fabulous St. Suprey wines accompanied by boutique chocolates from San Diego confectioner Nibbles. Fred Hawes has taken the helm of Sail Fleet and has now one meeting under his belt with more Members #1, Ann Kirschner & #2, Libby Davis enjoy the “Old Timers’ Brunch” informative and interesting speakers to come. Glenn Welch will head up Race Committee as they look at a busy spring with local and regional races including the NOODs. Fred, Glenn and long-time CYC racer Rick Harris will review several of the original Deed of Gifts for some of our race series including the always hotly contested Kempf High Point.
    [Show full text]
  • The New York Sloop
    The New York Sloop The most important of the sloop-rigged small-boat types used in the fisheries was the New York sloop, which had a style of hull and rig that influenced the design of both yachts and work-boats for over thirty years. The New York boats were developed sometime in the 1830's, when the centerboard had been accepted. The boats were built all about New York Bay, particularly on the Jersey shore. The model spread rapidly, and, by the end of the Civil War, the shoal centerboard sloop of the New York style had appeared all along the shores of western Long Island Sound, in northern New Jersey, and from thence southward into Delaware and Chesapeake waters. In the postwar growth of the southern fisheries, during the 1870's and 80's, this class of sloop was adopted all along the coasts of the South Atlantic states and in the Gulf of Mexico; finally, the boats appeared at San Francisco. The model did not become very popular, however, east of Cape Cod. The New York sloop was a distinctive boat—a wide, shoal centerboarder with a rather wide, square stern and a good deal of dead rise, the midsection being a wide, shallow V with a high bilge. The working sloops usually had a rather hard bilge; but in some it was very slack, and a strongly flaring side was used. Originally, the ends were plumb, and the stem often showed a slight tumble home at the cutwater. V-sterns and short overhanging counters were gradually introduced in the 1850's, particularly in the boats over 25 feet in length on deck.
    [Show full text]
  • BILGE PUMPING ARRANGEMENTS MSIS27 CHAPTER 5 Rev 09.21
    INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE GUIDANCE OF SURVEYORS ON BILGE PUMPING ARRANGEMENTS MSIS27 CHAPTER 5 Rev 09.21 Instructions to Surveyors – Fishing Vessels Bilge Pumping Document Amendment History PREFACE 0.1 These Marine Survey Instructions for the Guidance of Surveyors (MSIS) are not legal requirements in themselves. They may refer to statutory requirements elsewhere. They do represent the MCA policy for MCA surveyors to follow. 0.2 If for reasons of practicality, for instance, these cannot be followed then the surveyor must seek at least an equivalent arrangement, based on information from the owner/operator. Whenever possible guidance should be sought from either Principal Consultant Surveyors or Survey Operation Branch, in order to maintain consistency between Marine Offices. UK Maritime Services/Technical Services Ship Standards Bay2/22 Spring Place 105 Commercial Road Southampton SO15 1EG MSIS 27.5 R09.21/Page 2 of 16 Instructions to Surveyors – Fishing Vessels Bilge Pumping Document Amendment History RECENT AMENDMENTS The amendments made in the most recent publication are shown below, amendments made in previous publications are shown in the document Amendment History. Version Status / Change Date Author Content Next Review Number Reviewer Approver Date/Expiry Date 10.20 • Add requirement that 20/10/20 D Fenner G Stone 20/10/22 bilge sensors in compartments containing pollutants shall not automatically start bilge pumps • Requirements for supply of powered bilge starting arrangements through separate switchboard updated. • Main watertight compartment is defined 09.21 • Amendments to reflect 31/8/2021 D Fenner G Stone 31/8/23 publication of MSN1871 Amendment No.2 MSIS 27.5 R09.21/Page 3 of 16 Instructions to Surveyors – Fishing Vessels Bilge Pumping Document Amendment History PREFACE .......................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Wreck of the Southampton & Vixen
    The British 32-gun frigate Southampton (Captain Sir James Lucas Yeo) and the captured ship in tow, The American 14-gun brig Vixen Lippold Haken’s pictures of the War of 1812 Shipwreck near Conception Island, Bahamas I was on a summer 2004 R/V Sea Dragon dive trip that included Conception Island, Bahamas. We spent a few days diving on the Southampton reef line. I thoroughly love the variety and beauty of that reef (please see my slide show at http://www.cerlsoundgroup.org/Bahamas/), and could not get enough of it. After many hours of enjoyable diving I was snorkeling and discovered a large number of cannons nestled among beautiful corals. Here are three picture of one of the cannons I saw: 334 More cannons (and remains of armor plating in some of the pictures): It was a beautiful scene, so I tried to remember my path as I snorkeled the quarter mile back to the Sea Dragon. When I described what I had seen, Captain Dan was excited – he had been looking for the wreck of the famed 1812 British frigate Southampton and its ship-in-tow, the American brig Vixen for years. I am not certain he believed what I described (Capt. Dan has heard a lot of fish stories!), but he wanted to check it out. I was happy able to find the wreck again – it is not easy, because the reef is extensive with deep chasms in shallow coral extending above the water. Here is a picture from the snorkel back to the wreck: As you can guess from the picture above, it is difficult to keep your bearings when you are snorkeling through passageways and coral tunnels.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix I War of 1812 Chronology
    THE WAR OF 1812 MAGAZINE ISSUE 26 December 2016 Appendix I War of 1812 Chronology Compiled by Ralph Eshelman and Donald Hickey Introduction This War of 1812 Chronology includes all the major events related to the conflict beginning with the 1797 Jay Treaty of amity, commerce, and navigation between the United Kingdom and the United States of America and ending with the United States, Weas and Kickapoos signing of a peace treaty at Fort Harrison, Indiana, June 4, 1816. While the chronology includes items such as treaties, embargos and political events, the focus is on military engagements, both land and sea. It is believed this chronology is the most holistic inventory of War of 1812 military engagements ever assembled into a chronological listing. Don Hickey, in his War of 1812 Chronology, comments that chronologies are marred by errors partly because they draw on faulty sources and because secondary and even primary sources are not always dependable.1 For example, opposing commanders might give different dates for a military action, and occasionally the same commander might even present conflicting data. Jerry Roberts in his book on the British raid on Essex, Connecticut, points out that in a copy of Captain Coot’s report in the Admiralty and Secretariat Papers the date given for the raid is off by one day.2 Similarly, during the bombardment of Fort McHenry a British bomb vessel's log entry date is off by one day.3 Hickey points out that reports compiled by officers at sea or in remote parts of the theaters of war seem to be especially prone to ambiguity and error.
    [Show full text]
  • The Way of the Sea
    1 The Way of the Sea Cheney Duvall stared up at the great clouds of soaring sail, though her eyes watered from the sun and salt sting. The Brynn Annalea had found a tail of the northeast trade winds, strong and hot, to wend her fast down Baja and push her easily over the Tropic of Cancer. Her sharp prow knifed the water, the jib with the lucky shark’s fin mounted on it splashing in the wave crests. She was a beautiful thing, fast, sharp-hulled, streamlined, proud. And dangerous. Cheney shouted up at Shiloh, and he was shouting back down at her. Neither of them could possibly hear the other, but both of them kept on. “You idiot! Come down from there this instant! You are going to fall and die!” Cheney shrieked. He made an impatient gesture—Get below, you dumb girl!— which made Cheney’s heart almost stop, for he had let go with one arm to make jabbing “get below” motions to her. Twelve seamen were perched along the bucking, straining yard, feet kicked back against the footrope, bellies pressed against the yard, hands gathering up the heavy canvas. Cheney watched, horrified, as they struggled to roll the great main royal sail around the yard. Finally it was wound as neatly as thread on a spool, and the sailors, with strong and agile movements, passed lengths of rope around sail and yard and made it fast with hitches. One by one they started edging back along the yard, making for the weather shrouds to scamper down.
    [Show full text]
  • Artillery Through the Ages, by Albert Manucy 1
    Artillery Through the Ages, by Albert Manucy 1 Artillery Through the Ages, by Albert Manucy The Project Gutenberg EBook of Artillery Through the Ages, by Albert Manucy This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org Title: Artillery Through the Ages A Short Illustrated History of Cannon, Emphasizing Types Used in America Author: Albert Manucy Release Date: January 30, 2007 [EBook #20483] Language: English Artillery Through the Ages, by Albert Manucy 2 Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 *** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK ARTILLERY THROUGH THE AGES *** Produced by Juliet Sutherland, Christine P. Travers and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net ARTILLERY THROUGH THE AGES A Short Illustrated History of Cannon, Emphasizing Types Used in America UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Fred A. Seaton, Secretary NATIONAL PARK SERVICE Conrad L. Wirth, Director For sale by the Superintendent of Documents U. S. Government Printing Office Washington 25, D. C. -- Price 35 cents (Cover) FRENCH 12-POUNDER FIELD GUN (1700-1750) ARTILLERY THROUGH THE AGES A Short Illustrated History of Cannon, Emphasizing Types Used in America Artillery Through the Ages, by Albert Manucy 3 by ALBERT MANUCY Historian Southeastern National Monuments Drawings by Author Technical Review by Harold L. Peterson National Park Service Interpretive Series History No. 3 UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE WASHINGTON: 1949 (Reprint 1956) Many of the types of cannon described in this booklet may be seen in areas of the National Park System throughout the country.
    [Show full text]