DOCSLIB.ORG

The Scientific Way of Warfare: Order and Chaos on the Battlefields of Modernity

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Scientific Way of Warfare: Order and Chaos on the Battlefields of Modernity The Scientific Way of Warfare: Order and Chaos on the Battlefields of Modernity Antoine James Aime Bousquet Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of the PhD London School of Economics and Political Science l UMI Number: U615652 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U615652 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 I, Antoine James Aime Bousquet, declare that the work presented in this thesis is my own. _____________ 4#_________________________ 2 Irrtish Library of Political III °\ * °\ T- Abstract The thesis of the present work is that throughout the modem era the dominant corpus of scientific ideas, as articulated around key machine technologies, has been reflected in the contemporary theories and practices of warfare in the Western world. Over the period covered by this thesis — from the ascendancy of the scientific worldview in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries to present day — an ever more intimate symbiosis between science and warfare has established itself with the increasing reliance on the development and integration of technology within complex social assemblages of war. This extensive deployment of scientific ideas and methodologies in the military realm allows us to speak of the constitution and perpetuation of a scientific way o f warfare. There are however within the scientific way of warfare significant variations in the theories and practices of warfare according to the prevalence of certain scientific ideas and technological apparatuses in given periods of the modem era. The four distinctive regimes I thereupon distinguish are those of mechanistic, thermodynamic, cybernetic, and chaoplexic warfare. Each of these regimes is characterised by a differing approach to the central question of order and chaos in war, on which hinge the related issues of centralisation and decentralisation, predictability and control. 3 Table of Contents Table of Figures..............................................................................................................................6 Acknowledgements......................................................... 7 Chapter 1: Introduction................................................................................................................. 9 Locating the Thesis within the Historical Literature on W ar ..................................................10 Thesis Outline ............................................................................................................................... 18 Chapter 2: Technoscientific Regimes of Order in Warfare — A Theoretical and Methodological Framework............................................................ ............22 Civilisation and the Will to O rder ..............................................................................................22 The Technoscientific Regime of Order ..................................................................................... 26 O f Discourse and Polymorphous Correlations: Science and Culture ................................... 31 The Power of Metaphors.............................................................................................................36 A Brief Review of the Relevant Core Texts .............................................................................. 39 The Four Regimes of the Scientific Way of Warfare............................................................... 43 Chapter 3: Mechanistic Warfare and the Clockwork Universe........................................... 49 From Mechanical Clocks and Automata to Clockwork Metaphor ........................................ 49 The Clockwork Universe: the Ascendancy of the Mechanistic Worldview ......................... 52 The Clockwork Heavens: Newtonian Mechanics and the Clockmaker G od ............. 54 The Clockwork Body and Soul: Descartes, La Mettrie and Mechanistic Physiology 58 The Clockwork State: Enlightened Absolutism ....................................................................... 60 Mechanistic Warfare: Frederick the Great’s Clockwork Army .............................................. 63 Chapter 4: Thermodynamic Warfare and the Science of Energy.......................................72 The Engine: the Industrialisation and Motorisation of Society ............................................. 73 Thermodynamics: the Universe as a Heat Engine ................................................................... 75 The Human Engine: Thermodynamic Bodies and Minds ...................................................... 79 Thermodynamic Warfare .............................................................................................................82 Clausewit2 ‘Translates’ Thermodynamics ................................................................................. 90 Chapter 5: Cybernetics and the Genesis of the Computer................................................... 96 Electromagnetic Telecommunications and W ar ...................................................................... 96 The Computer — Genesis and Embodiment of the Abstract Machine ................................. 99 Bits and Negentropy: Information Becomes Physical ........................................................... 105 Cybernetics: the Science of Control and Communications .................................................. 109 Cybernetic Organisms: From Computerised Brains to Biological Computers .................. 113 Social Cybernetics .......................................................................................................................117 Chapter 6: Cybernetic Warfare: Computers at War...............................................................121 The ‘Closed World’ of Cybernetic Warfare ............................................................................. 122 From Command to Command-and-Control ..........................:...............................................128 Operations Research and Systems Analysis: Solving the War Equation ............................ 136 Vietnam and the Failure of Cybernetic Warfare.................................................... 150 4 Chapter 7: A New Informational Paradigm: Chaos Theory and Complexity Science.................................................................................................................... 159 The Rediscovery of Non-Linearity: Chaos Theory and Positive Feedback ....................... 160 Complexity and Networks of Life at the Edge-of-Chaos ..................................................... 169 Chapter 8: Towards Chaoplexic Warfare? Network-Centric Warfare and the Non-Linear Sciences................................................................................................... 179 John Boyd and the OODA loop ..............................................................................................180 Uncertainty in War: the Non-Linear Clausewitz and the Future of Military Organisation .................................................................................................................................189 The Age of the Network............................................................................................................195 Swarming: Of Ants and M en ................................................................................................ 201 Complexity Goes To War? The Rise of Network-Centric Warfare....................................206 Chapter 9: Conclusions..............................................................................................................225 A Genealogy of Control .......................... 225 Some Final Thoughts....................................................... 230 Bibliography................................................................................................................................ 235 5 Table of Figures Figure 1: Christopher Coker's metaphors of war................................................................................. 40 Figure 2: Geometric warfare................................................................................................................... 65 Figure 3: The geometry of fortification................................................................................................. 66 Figure 4: Diagram of the von Neumann architecture ....................................................................... 102 Figure 5: Schematic diagram of an abstract communication machine ............................................ 107 Figure 6: Information feedback loop in a cybernetic system ............................................................I l l Figure 7: SAGE operator and his console (circa 1959) .....................................................................131 Figure 8: SAGE man-machine cybernetic lo o p ..................................................................................132 Figure 9: WWMCCS architecture........................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Complexity” Makes a Difference: Lessons from Critical Systems Thinking and the Covid-19 Pandemic in the UK
    systems Article How We Understand “Complexity” Makes a Difference: Lessons from Critical Systems Thinking and the Covid-19 Pandemic in the UK Michael C. Jackson Centre for Systems Studies, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7TS, UK; [email protected]; Tel.: +44-7527-196400 Received: 11 November 2020; Accepted: 4 December 2020; Published: 7 December 2020 Abstract: Many authors have sought to summarize what they regard as the key features of “complexity”. Some concentrate on the complexity they see as existing in the world—on “ontological complexity”. Others highlight “cognitive complexity”—the complexity they see arising from the different interpretations of the world held by observers. Others recognize the added difficulties flowing from the interactions between “ontological” and “cognitive” complexity. Using the example of the Covid-19 pandemic in the UK, and the responses to it, the purpose of this paper is to show that the way we understand complexity makes a huge difference to how we respond to crises of this type. Inadequate conceptualizations of complexity lead to poor responses that can make matters worse. Different understandings of complexity are discussed and related to strategies proposed for combatting the pandemic. It is argued that a “critical systems thinking” approach to complexity provides the most appropriate understanding of the phenomenon and, at the same time, suggests which systems methodologies are best employed by decision makers in preparing for, and responding to, such crises. Keywords: complexity; Covid-19; critical systems thinking; systems methodologies 1. Introduction No one doubts that we are, in today’s world, entangled in complexity. At the global level, economic, social, technological, health and ecological factors have become interconnected in unprecedented ways, and the consequences are immense.
    [Show full text]
  • Joint Force Quarterly
    JFQJOINT FORCE QUARTERLY The Security of the Americas Autumn00 A PROFESSIONAL MILITARY JOURNAL ...we must find a better balance between independence and joint- ness. This is bound to be a painful process. Self-sufficiency is a kind of cultural imperative....But we simply cannot afford to configure each service’s combat forces for sustained, independent operations. The key word these days is jointness. And...jointness means depending on one another. —Merrill A. McPeak JFQ AWord fromthe MV–22 Osprey on deck of USS Essex. Chairman U.S. Navy (Jaime D. Hernandez) espite the unparalleled strength of the instances when nations failed to understand that Armed Forces, we should not become successful methods and technologies applied in complacent. Maintaining the status one conflict may be inadequate in the next. Vic- Dquo will not serve national interests. torious powers benefitted from dramatic innova- The evolving security environment of today, re- tions. Such changes, often regarded as a revolu- plete with new challenges and new opportunities, tion in military affairs (RMA), have occurred demands a capable and flexible military. Our throughout history. New technologies and their great strength is service core competencies. We applications can alter the balance of power as the must expand on them to provide seamless inter- champion of a new RMA assumes a position of operability in joint operations—our first joint dominance. Successful warfare in the Middle Ages core competency. was represented by knights in armor. To over- come them, English yeomen introduced the long- Looking Back bow—a revolution in its day—to defeat the close- In developing a transformation strategy, we in superiority of French arms in the 12th century.
    [Show full text]
  • FACETS of SYSTEMS SCIENCE SECOND EDITION International Federation for Systems Research International Series on Systems Science and Engineering
    FACETS OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE SECOND EDITION International Federation for Systems Research International Series on Systems Science and Engineering Series Editor: George J. Klir State University of New York at Binghamtom Editorial Board Gerrit Broekstra Ivan M. Havel Erasmus University. Rotterdam. Charles University. Prague. The Netherlands Czech Republic John L. Casti Manfred Peschel Santa Fe Institute. New Mexico Academy of Sciences. Berlin. Germany Brian Gaines Franz Pichler University of Calgary. Canada University of Linz. Austria Volume 9 CHAOTIC LOGIC: Language. Thought. and Reality from the Perspective of Complex Systems Science Ben Goertzel Volume 10 THE FOUNDATIONS OF FUZZY CONTROL Harold W. Lewis, III Volume 11 FROM COMPLEXITY TO CREATIVITY: Explorations in Evolutionary. Autopoietic. and Cognitive Dynamics Ben Goertzel Volume 12 GENERAL SYSTEMS THEORY: A Mathematical Approach Yi Lin Volume 13 PRINCIPLES OF QUANTITATIVE LIVING SYSTEMS SCIENCE James R. Simms Volume 14 INTELLIGENT ROBOTIC SYSTEMS: Design. Planning. and Control Witold Jacak Volume 15 FACETS OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE: Second Edition George J. Klir IFSR was established "to stimulate all activities associated with the scientific study of systems and to coordinate such activities at intemationallevel." The aim of this series is to stimulate publication of high-quality monographs and textbooks on various topics of systems science and engineering. This series complements the Federation's other publications. A Continuation Order Plan is available for this series. A continuation order will bring delivery of each new volume immediately upon publication. Volumes are billed only upon actual shipment. For further information please contact the publisher. Volumes \-6 were published by Pergamon Press. FACETS OF SYSTEMS SCIENCE SECOND EDITION George J.
    [Show full text]
  • Northcentral University
    Guerilla Warfare During 1 Running head: Guerilla Warfare During WWI and WWII . Guerilla Warfare During WWI and WWII MSG Albert Crawford United States Army Sergeants Major Academy Class 58 SGM Vidakovich 17 Mar 2008 Guerilla Warfare During 2 Abstract An amplification and Comparison of the change in the U.S. Army due to the use of Guerrilla Warfare during World War I and World War II. Illustrating positive and negative factors of the shaping of the U. S. Military due to experiences with the enemy’s use of guerrilla tactics which has caused a considerably change in fighting tactics over the years. Finally, the conclusion will synthesize the insights gained from the analysis of Guerrilla Warfare’s impact on the American military Guerilla Warfare During 3 Thesis During World War I (WWI) and World War II (WWII) there were numerous instances of guerilla warfare being used both against and by the United Sates Military. These techniques were valuable in the shaping of the military and how we would fight in the future. Outline I. Intro A. Used both by and against U.S B. TTP’s II. World War I A. New outlook B. Future doctorine III. World War II A. Need for small force B. Philippines IV. Impact of Guerrilla Warfare on WWI and WWII A. New doctrine and TTPs B. FM’s Guerilla Warfare During 4 Introduction During World War I (WWI) and World War II (WWII) there were numerous instances of guerilla warfare being used both against and by the United Sates Military. These techniques were valuable in the shaping of the military and how we would fight in the future.
    [Show full text]
  • Role of Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos in Applied Sciences
    v.;.;.:.:.:.;.;.^ ROLE OF NONLINEAR DYNAMICS AND CHAOS IN APPLIED SCIENCES by Quissan V. Lawande and Nirupam Maiti Theoretical Physics Oivisipn 2000 Please be aware that all of the Missing Pages in this document were originally blank pages BARC/2OOO/E/OO3 GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION ROLE OF NONLINEAR DYNAMICS AND CHAOS IN APPLIED SCIENCES by Quissan V. Lawande and Nirupam Maiti Theoretical Physics Division BHABHA ATOMIC RESEARCH CENTRE MUMBAI, INDIA 2000 BARC/2000/E/003 BIBLIOGRAPHIC DESCRIPTION SHEET FOR TECHNICAL REPORT (as per IS : 9400 - 1980) 01 Security classification: Unclassified • 02 Distribution: External 03 Report status: New 04 Series: BARC External • 05 Report type: Technical Report 06 Report No. : BARC/2000/E/003 07 Part No. or Volume No. : 08 Contract No.: 10 Title and subtitle: Role of nonlinear dynamics and chaos in applied sciences 11 Collation: 111 p., figs., ills. 13 Project No. : 20 Personal authors): Quissan V. Lawande; Nirupam Maiti 21 Affiliation ofauthor(s): Theoretical Physics Division, Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Mumbai 22 Corporate authoifs): Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Mumbai - 400 085 23 Originating unit : Theoretical Physics Division, BARC, Mumbai 24 Sponsors) Name: Department of Atomic Energy Type: Government Contd...(ii) -l- 30 Date of submission: January 2000 31 Publication/Issue date: February 2000 40 Publisher/Distributor: Head, Library and Information Services Division, Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Mumbai 42 Form of distribution: Hard copy 50 Language of text: English 51 Language of summary: English 52 No. of references: 40 refs. 53 Gives data on: Abstract: Nonlinear dynamics manifests itself in a number of phenomena in both laboratory and day to day dealings.
    [Show full text]
  • Getting the Joint Functions Right JFQ 94, 3Rd Quarter 2019 of U.S
    2K12 Kub mobile surface-to-air missile system fires during multinational live-fire training exercise Shabla 19, in Shabla, Bulgaria, June 12, 2019 (U.S. Army/Thomas Mort) This article provides the first orga- Getting the Joint nizational history of the joint functions in order to better understand why dif- ferences persist in how this concept is implemented in the United States versus Functions Right its North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) partners. Doing so allows us to By Thomas Crosbie better understand enduring challenges in interoperability and persistent cultural clashes within the Alliance. The history reveals that today’s joint functions are built n July 2017, the Chairman of the of Defense (DOD) thinking and around a core of four kinetic principles Joint Chiefs of Staff announced a practice.1 A 2018 article by Alexus G. (leadership or command and control [C2], special out-of-cycle revision to joint Grynkewich in this journal elaborated I maneuver, firepower, and protection), doctrine, adding information to the on why this matters to the national to which subsequent revisions have at- joint functions. The significance of security community.2 Nevertheless, tempted to add a range of “softer” military this policy change was highlighted despite these clear signals that DOD fields (intelligence, information, sustain- by the Secretary of Defense in a Sep- takes the joint functions seriously, and ment, and civil-military cooperation), tember 2017 endorsement, where he despite their centrality in military doc- sometimes successfully, sometimes not. stressed that inclusion in the joint trine, the joint functions remain little The history of the joint functions is functions signaled an “elevation” of understood by those who have not a history of overcoming the resistance information throughout Department served in an operational staff role.
    [Show full text]
  • Annotated List of References Tobias Keip, I7801986 Presentation Method: Poster
    Personal Inquiry – Annotated list of references Tobias Keip, i7801986 Presentation Method: Poster Poster Section 1: What is Chaos? In this section I am introducing the topic. I am describing different types of chaos and how individual perception affects our sense for chaos or chaotic systems. I am also going to define the terminology. I support my ideas with a lot of examples, like chaos in our daily life, then I am going to do a transition to simple mathematical chaotic systems. Larry Bradley. (2010). Chaos and Fractals. Available: www.stsci.edu/~lbradley/seminar/. Last accessed 13 May 2010. This website delivered me with a very good introduction into the topic as there are a lot of books and interesting web-pages in the “References”-Sektion. Gleick, James. Chaos: Making a New Science. Penguin Books, 1987. The book gave me a very general introduction into the topic. Harald Lesch. (2003-2007). alpha-Centauri . Available: www.br-online.de/br- alpha/alpha-centauri/alpha-centauri-harald-lesch-videothek-ID1207836664586.xml. Last accessed 13. May 2010. A web-page with German video-documentations delivered a lot of vivid examples about chaos for my poster. Poster Section 2: Laplace's Demon and the Butterfly Effect In this part I describe the idea of the so called Laplace's Demon and the theory of cause-and-effect chains. I work with a lot of examples, especially the famous weather forecast example. Also too I introduce the mathematical concept of a dynamic system. Jeremy S. Heyl (August 11, 2008). The Double Pendulum Fractal. British Columbia, Canada.
    [Show full text]
  • Chaos Theory and Its Application to Education: Mehmet Akif Ersoy University Case*
    Educational Sciences: Theory & Practice • 14(2) • 510-518 ©2014 Educational Consultancy and Research Center www.edam.com.tr/estp DOI: 10.12738/estp.2014.2.1928 Chaos Theory and its Application to Education: Mehmet Akif Ersoy University Case* Vesile AKMANSOYa Sadık KARTALb Burdur Provincial Education Department Mehmet Akif Ersoy University Abstract Discussions have arisen regarding the application of the new paradigms of chaos theory to social sciences as compared to physical sciences. This study examines what role chaos theory has within the education process and what effect it has by describing the views of university faculty regarding chaos and education. The partici- pants in this study consisted of 30 faculty members with teaching experience in the Faculty of Education, the Faculty of Science and Literature, and the School of Veterinary Sciences at Mehmet Akif Ersoy University in Burdur, Turkey. The sample for this study included voluntary participants. As part of the study, the acquired qualitative data has been tested using both the descriptive analysis method and content analysis. Themes have been organized under each discourse question after checking and defining the processes. To test the data, fre- quency and percentage, statistical techniques were used. The views of the attendees were stated verbatim in the Turkish version, then translated into English by the researchers. The findings of this study indicate the presence of a “butterfly effect” within educational organizations, whereby a small failure in the education process causes a bigger failure later on. Key Words Chaos, Chaos and Education, Chaos in Social Sciences, Chaos Theory. The term chaos continues to become more and that can be called “united science,” characterized by more prominent within the various fields of its interdisciplinary approach (Yeşilorman, 2006).
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of U.S. Military Policy from the Constitution to the Present
    C O R P O R A T I O N The Evolution of U.S. Military Policy from the Constitution to the Present Gian Gentile, Michael E. Linick, Michael Shurkin For more information on this publication, visit www.rand.org/t/RR1759 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available for this publication. ISBN: 978-0-8330-9786-6 Published by the RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, Calif. © Copyright 2017 RAND Corporation R® is a registered trademark. Limited Print and Electronic Distribution Rights This document and trademark(s) contained herein are protected by law. This representation of RAND intellectual property is provided for noncommercial use only. Unauthorized posting of this publication online is prohibited. Permission is given to duplicate this document for personal use only, as long as it is unaltered and complete. Permission is required from RAND to reproduce, or reuse in another form, any of its research documents for commercial use. For information on reprint and linking permissions, please visit www.rand.org/pubs/permissions. The RAND Corporation is a research organization that develops solutions to public policy challenges to help make communities throughout the world safer and more secure, healthier and more prosperous. RAND is nonprofit, nonpartisan, and committed to the public interest. RAND’s publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors. Support RAND Make a tax-deductible charitable contribution at www.rand.org/giving/contribute www.rand.org Preface Since the earliest days of the Republic, American political and military leaders have debated and refined the national approach to providing an Army to win the nation’s independence and provide for its defense against all enemies, foreign and domestic.
    [Show full text]
  • Towards a Cybernetic Foundation for Natural Resource Governance
    Towards a Cybernetic Foundation for Natural Resource Governance A Thesis Presented to the Academic Faculty by Talha Manzoor In Partial Fullfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Electrical Engineering Supervisor: Abubakr Muhammad (LUMS) Co-supervisor: Elena Rovenskaya (IIASA) arXiv:1803.09369v1 [cs.SY] 20 Mar 2018 Syed Babar Ali School of Science and Engineering Lahore University of Management Sciences December 2017 © 2017 by Talha Manzoor To Marwa and her never-ending quest for adventure. Abstract This study explores the potential of the cybernetic method of inquiry for the problem of natural resource governance. The systems way of thinking has already enabled scientists to gain considerable headway in framing global environmental challenges. On the other hand, technical solutions to environmental problems have begun to show significant promise, driven by the advent of technology and its increased proliferation in coupled human and natural systems. Such settings lie on the interface of engineering, social and environmental sciences, and as such, require a common language in order for natural resources to be studied, managed and ultimately sustained. In this dissertation, we argue that the systems theoretic tradition of cybernetics may provide the necessary common ground for examining such systems. After discussing the relevance of the cybernetic approach to natural resource governance, we present a mathematical model of resource consumption, grounded in social psychological research on consumer behavior. We also provide interpretations of the model at various levels of abstraction in the social network of the consuming population. We demonstrate the potential of the model by examining it in various theoretic frameworks which include dynamical systems, optimal control theory, game theory and the theory of learning in games.
    [Show full text]
  • War Theory: the Evolution of War and Military Thought Syllabus Ay 20
    WAR THEORY: THE EVOLUTION OF WAR AND MILITARY THOUGHT SYLLABUS AY 20 JOINT PROFESSIONAL MILITARY EDUCATION PHASE I INTERMEDIATE LEVEL COURSE UNITED STATES AIR FORCE AIR COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE 21st Century Leaders for 21st Century Challenges AIR COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE MAXWELL AFB, AL FOREWORD This syllabus for the War Theory course at the Air Command and Staff College, August-October 2019, provides an overview of the course narrative, objectives, and questions, as well as a detailed description of each lesson to assist students in their reading and preparation for lecture and seminar. Included herein is information about course methods of evaluation, schedule, and the fulfilment of Joint professional military education core goals. James D. Campbell, PhD Course Director, War Theory APPROVED James Forsyth, PhD Dean of Academic Affairs 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE FOREWORD 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 2 COURSE DESCRIPTION, QUESTIONS AND OBJECTIVES 3 COURSE ORGANIZATION AND NARRATIVE 3 JOINT LEARNING AREAS AND OBJECTIVES 5 AY 2019-2020 SPECIAL AREAS OF EMPHASIS 8 COURSE REQUIREMENTS 9 COURSE ADMINISTRATION 10 COURSE SCHEDULE DAY 0 12 DAY 1 15 DAY 2 17 DAY 3 19 DAY 4 21 DAY 5 22 DAY 6 25 DAY 7 28 DAY 8 29 DAY 9 31 DAY 10 34 DAY 11 36 DAY 12 38 DAY 13 40 DAY 14 43 DAY 15 45 APPENDIX: COURSE FACULTY 47 2 WAR THEORY COURSE OVERVIEW COURSE DESCRIPTION War Theory introduces military theory, addressing both the nature and character of war. It examines the theoretical writings of classical military theorists, as well as the evolution of warfare and military thought over the last two centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • Purity Lost: the Ap Radoxical Face of the New Transnational Legal Body Oren Perez
    Brooklyn Journal of International Law Volume 33 | Issue 1 Article 1 2007 Purity Lost: The aP radoxical Face of the New Transnational Legal Body Oren Perez Follow this and additional works at: https://brooklynworks.brooklaw.edu/bjil Recommended Citation Oren Perez, Purity Lost: The Paradoxical Face of the New Transnational Legal Body, 33 Brook. J. Int'l L. (2007). Available at: https://brooklynworks.brooklaw.edu/bjil/vol33/iss1/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at BrooklynWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Brooklyn Journal of International Law by an authorized editor of BrooklynWorks. PURITY LOST: THE PARADOXICAL FACE OF THE NEW TRANSNATIONAL LEGAL BODY Oren Perez* INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 3 I. PURITY: THE WESTPHALIAN NARRATIVE ..................................... 5 II. PARADOXES AND INCONSISTENCIES IN THE CURRENT INVOCATIONS OF THE WESTPHALIAN NARRATIVE ........................... 7 A. Detour: Paradoxes and Inconsistencies in the Law............... 7 1. Paradoxes: A General Exposition ....................................... 7 2. Paradoxes in Law: Incoherence and Paralysis.................. 10 B. Paradoxes in the Westphalian Order: The Cases of the WTO and the ICC............................................................................... 17 1. The Case of the WTO ....................................................... 17 2. The International Criminal Court...................................... 19 III. ALTERNATIVE
    [Show full text]