MONTHLY EDUCATIONAL JOURNAL OF THE FOUNDATION OF THE AMERICAN SUBCONTRACTORS ASSOCIATION AUGUST 2021
Sharing Best Practices
1004 Duke Street, Alexandria, VA 22314 | (703) 684-3450 | www.asaonline.com | [email protected] Fonn is the new way to manage your construction projects.
TM
Request a demo
25,000 projects, 16,000 users and counting...
There are many functionalities of Fonn that we know to be the best. The intent of using a Project Management software is to have everything in one place. “Fonn has done an impeccable job of building a software that does just that.
- Project Manager Roche Constructors
Easy to communicate while in the field with team instead of having to write things down and communicate when back at a computer or text from phone.
- Office Manager Todd Bonneau Homes
For more information reach out to your Fonn ASA representative: Eric Crawford [email protected], M: (970) 980-5734 FASA'S AUGUST 2021
EDITORIAL PURPOSE The Contractor’s Compass is the monthly educational FEATURES journal of the Foundation of the American Subcontractors Association, Inc. (FASA) and part of FASA’s Contractors’ Knowledge Network. Health and Safety Best Practices for Subcontractors when FASA was established in 1987 as a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt Staying Prepared for COVID-19 During the Current Outbreak...... 14 entity to support research, education and public awareness. by Kevin J. McMahon, MS, CIH, HazTek Inc. Through its Contractors’ Knowledge Network, FASA is committed to forging and exploring the critical issues How to Share Construction Opportunities with Students – shaping subcontractors and specialty trade contractors in the construction industry. The journal is designed to equip and Why You Should...... 16 construction subcontractors with the ideas, tools and tactics by Rachel Burris, NCCER they need to thrive. The views expressed by contributors to The Contractor’s Post-Pandemic Drives Best Practices...... 19 Compass do not necessarily represent the opinions of FASA by Jack Rubinger, Freelance writer or the American Subcontractors Association, Inc. (ASA). Tips for Today’s Harsh Reality of Communication...... 21 by Chad Pearson, Plexxis MISSION To educate and equip subcontractors and suppliers with the Five Ways to Ensure the Safety of Your Workers education and resources they need to thrive in the construction industry. Additionally, FASA raises awareness Without Breaking the Bank...... 24 about issues critical to and about construction in the United by Michael Zalle, YellowBird States. Best Practices 101: Ask the Right Questions...... 26
SUBSCRIPTIONS by Duane Craig, Freelance writer The Contractor’s Compass is a free monthly publication for ASA members and nonmembers. For questions about Everything I Learned About Business subscribing, please contact communications@asa-hq. from Michael Scott and Dunder Mifflin...... 31 com. by Gregg Schoppman, FMI
ADVERTISING Insurance Captives Grow in Popularity Among Contractors...... 34 Interested in advertising? Contact Richard Bright by Greg Hess, AssuredPartners at (703) 684-3450 or [email protected] or [email protected]. How to Handle Late Payments in Construction...... 35 by Patrick Hogan, Handle.com EDITORIAL SUBMISSIONS Contributing authors are encouraged to submit a brief Registration and Sponsorships at SUBExcel 2022...... 36 abstract of their article idea before providing a full-length feature article. Feature articles should be no longer than 1,500 words and comply with The Associated Press style guidelines. Article submissions become the property of ASA DEPARTMENTS and FASA. The editor reserves the right to edit all accepted editorial submissions for length, style, clarity, spelling and punctuation. Send abstracts and submissions for The ASA PRESIDENT'S LETTER...... 5 Contractor’s Compass to [email protected]. CONTRACTOR COMMUNITY...... 7 ABOUT ASA ASA is a nonprofit trade association of union and non-union ALWAYS SOMETHING AWESOME...... 9 subcontractors and suppliers. Through a nationwide network of local and state ASA associations, members LEGALLY SPEAKING: Reaching Your Best Subcontract Self: receive information and education on relevant business Tips for Negotiating Subcontract Terms to Maximize Profit...... 11 issues and work together to protect their rights as an by Michael Metz-Topodas, Cohen Seglias Passa Greenhall & Furman PC. integral part of the construction team. For more information about becoming an ASA member, contact ASA at 1004 Duke LEGALLY SPEAKING: The Ties that Don’t Necessarily Bind: St., Alexandria, VA 22314-3588, (703) 684-3450, [email protected], or visit the ASA Web site, Force Majeure and Price Escalations...... 13 www.asaonline.com by Jordan R. Pavlus, Esq., Byrne Costello & Pickard, P.C.
LAYOUT Angela M Roe QUICK REFERENCE [email protected]
Upcoming Webinars...... 36 © 2021 Foundation of the American Coming Up...... 36 Subcontractors Association, Inc. ASA Platinum Sponsor
wants to help you with Risk Transfer.
The following are important coverage considerations before executing a sub-contract agreement with an upper tier.
INDEMNIFICATION REVIEW
Are you indemnifying Owner/Developers, GC’s and Prime Contractors for contract provisions that are not covered by your Liability Insurance?
ADDITIONAL INSURED REQUIREMENTS
Does your Additional Insured coverage comply with contract language?
COVERAGE RESTRICTIONS & EXCLUSIONS
Do your insurance policies include coverage exclusions and conditions which may either restrict or not respond at all to certain contractual obligations you entered into, and land you in breach of contract litigation?
33assuredpartners.comAUGUST 2021 THE [email protected]’S COMPASS PRESIDENT'S LETTER
Dear ASA Members: As the summer draws to a close, my oldest son Creighton has been asking lots of wonderful questions as he explores the balance of his K-12. Last week, he informed me that he wanted to study Civil Engineering when he goes to college and we discussed that path. Given that Engineering was the path I followed into the Construction Industry, I couldn’t be prouder that my son was laying a foundation that might take him into the industry that I love so dearly. In each of your companies, I hope you will reflect as we finish out summer on who are the next generation of leaders in your company. Are they your children? Trusted employees that you have trained from ground up? Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, or Marines who have returned home after the longest war in our nation’s history who now chose to build our nation? This is the time, as it should be every single day, to develop and invest in the leaders in your company and the leaders in our industry. These will ultimately be our community, state and national leaders. ASA is a key cornerstone in building our next great industry leaders. As ASA members, I encourage each of you to take advantage of the endless benefits available to you locally and nationally. • Attend local/national events (available both in-person and virtually); • Read local and national ASA news to stay on top of the critical issue that affect our livelihoods; and • Make sure you access the online area of the ASA National website (known as the Info Hub) to unlock the knowledge base and tools of the vast resource library and special membership benefits Additionally, ASA members should take pride in the work going on to represent each of you behind the scenes on Capitol Hill. For example, ASA's top priority this legislative cycle was to ensure performance and payment bonds were included in federal Public Private Partnership transportation projects and the Senate voted 97-0 in favor of ASA supported legislation with the Van Hollen (MD) Amendment to protect subcontractors. This legislation already passed the House and will become law upon presidential signature. Candidly, a 97-0 vote in the Senate is HUGE, and this is our second such vote in two years with the first being the ban on reverse auction in federal bidding practices for construction projects. Our voices as ASA members are being heard loudly and clearly in the halls of Congress! Also, ASA’s Subcontractors Legal Defense Fund (SLDF) is active in a lien waiver case in Oklahoma (click here to learn more). So, ASA is full speed ahead representing subcontractors where laws are made and where laws are interpreted, both critical to how your businesses function. Another part of engagement is communication. Let us know if you aren’t receiving our weekly e-newsletter ASAToday, or our bi-weekly updates via Hammer & Nails. We want to make sure you are getting everything you possibly can from your ASA Membership. Let us know how we are doing. We are here for you. Together, we build America!
Sincerely in your service, Brian K. Carroll ASA President 2021-2022 JOINING THE SBA MENTOR-PROTÉGÉ PROGRAM IS AS EASY AS ABC AND 123! The SBA Mentor-Protégé Program (SBA MPP) is the government's largest business development program aimed at helping small businesses gain capacity in 1 the federal marketplace by teaming with more experienced businesses. Are you a small business that's ready to enhance your goods and services 2 offerings to the federal government? 3 2 3
STAYING IN— GETTING IN—THE ABC's AS EASY AS 1, 2, 3! ASSEMBLE MAINTAIN YOUR TEAM 1 ANNUAL EVALUATIONS Find a mentor. Complete your annual Ensure you and your mentor evaluation each year are eligible. within 30 days from your anniversary date 30 Register both businesses in (on your welcome letter). SAM.gov.
BE SURE LET US KNOW YOU’RE READY 2 HOW IT’S GOING. Visit the SBA website. Any changes to the Mentor- Complete the MPP tutorial. Protégé Agreement (MPA)? Keep the certificate. Any changes to the relationship? Decide if MPP is right for you. Need advice?
CERTIFY FORMING AND GROW! 3 A JOINT VENTURE? Prepare your documents. Create a SAM profile for your Apply at certify.sba.gov. new entity. Allow 105 days for SBA to process. Provide Joint Venture compliance certificate to the Remain responsive. SBA and the contracting officer. Grab your welcome Send SBA your annual letter and grow. statements upon contract award.
For more information and a detailed FAQ about the SBA MPP visit www.sba.gov/mpp. Email [email protected] for any questions. CONTRACTOR COMMUNITY
Smith Currie Named along with the IIJA, will be debated by the CDC Provides Updated House starting on Monday, August 23, 2021. Construction Law Firm of the Guidance Year ASA Submits Comments on This article is from our friends at SESCO Management Consultant, ASA's Human We congratulate Smith Currie being OSHA’s COVID-19 ETS Resource partner. To learn more about this named 2021 Construction Law Firm of the On Friday, August 19, 2021, ASA, along and all of the incredible benefits that are Year by Chambers and Partners USA and with the Construction Industry Safety included in your ASA membership, click its deputy editors. Coalition (CISC), submitted comments to here. The USA deputy editors at Chambers OSHA’s Emergency Temporary Standard The Centers for Disease Control and and Partners USA noted that Smith Currie’s (ETS). These comments supported the Prevention (CDC) has issued updated expertise in healthcare-related construction Agency’s determination not to include the guidance recommending that even fully- positioned the firm well to assist clients construction industry within the scope of vaccinated individuals should wear providing essential construction services the rule. The construction industry has masks indoors in geographic areas of across the U.S. in responding to the been consistently characterized as low risk “substantial or high transmission.” The CDC COVID-19 pandemic. The firm’s ability to for exposure to COVID-19 by OSHA and also recommends even fully-vaccinated help guide clients through the pandemic other regulatory agencies. The construction individuals get tested and wear a mask in helped place Smith Currie as the choice for industry has been at the forefront of public indoor settings for 14 days if they Construction Law Firm of the Year. efforts to implement proactive mitigation have a known exposure to someone with “In a challenging year for the sector, measures specific to COVID-19. Per our suspected or confirmed COVID-19 or until clients looked to the construction comments, “any attempts by OSHA to they receive a negative test. specialists at Smith Currie for guidance expand the ETS to cover construction is The CDC does not directly regulate through the unprecedented turbulence not supported by the evidence and would employers – it just offers recommendations of the COVID-19 pandemic,” said be impermissible under the Occupational and guidance. Time will tell how the Maddy Vincent, deputy editor USA, Safety and Health Act of 1970.” federal Occupational Safety and Health with Chambers and Partners USA. Our comments were separated into Administration (OSHA) and state agencies/ “Smith Currie’s COVID-19 task force several parts with Part 1 explaining governors will respond to the updated played a key role advising developers, the proactive measures taken by the CDC guidance. Of course, we will provide owners, contractors, and subcontractors on CISC and the construction industry to further updates when new guidance or the latest pandemic-related developments, address COVID-19 in construction. Part requirements are released. assisting them in remaining operational as 2 addresses the process that OSHA has SESCO retainer clients and members of lockdowns, delays, furloughs, and materials undertaken to develop the ETS and how shortages rocked the sector.” The firm’s select associations can call or email SESCO applying the ETS to the construction to discuss specific industry, state and/or task force was led by Scott Walters. Smith industry without engaging the Advisory Currie was nominated for this award and company questions and concerns. Those Committee on Construction Safety and receiving these alerts that are not SESCO chosen as the winner largely based upon Health (“ACCSH”) and specifically raising client input received through the Chambers clients can contact SESCO by phone, fax or construction-specific issues in the ETS email to explore support options. and Partners USA thorough ranking would be inappropriate and unlawful. Part methodology. 3 describes how and why the construction industry is low risk and thus applying Nonresidential Spending Infrastructure Status the ETS to the construction industry Slumps in June and Year-to- On Tuesday, August 10, 2021, the would be impermissible. Part 4 describes Date; Wages Post Record Senate voted 69-30 to pass a $550 billion how it would be inappropriate to apply bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and the requirements of the ETS, the vast Jump in Second Quarter Jobs Act (IIJA), which was highlighted majority of which would be inapplicable This article is from the Associated General in the August 6th ASAToday. House to the construction work environment, in Contractors of America. You can learn more Democrats are trying to keep the Senate the construction industry. Finally, Part 5 about the AGC at www.agc.org. passed infrastructure package intact and discusses how OSHA’ s anti-retaliation Construction spending in June climbed any changes that the House wants to make paragraph permitting OSHA to pursue 0.1% from May rate and 8.2% from June on infrastructure issues will likely take place Citations and Notifications of Penalty 2020 to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of on the reconciliation bill. On Wednesday, for alleged retaliation is unlawful and $1.55 trillion, the Census Bureau reported. August 11, 2021, the Senate passed a $3.5 impermissible under the OSH Act and Because project shutdowns depressed trillion budget resolution by a party line OSHA must delete this provision from any spending in the spring of 2020, it is more vote of 50-49 that is expected to have a final rule. useful to compare year-to-date figures for final vote in September. This resolution,
7 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS January-June combined in 2020 and 2021 the past 12 months increased 3.1% for total in permanent-site structures rose 4.8% than June rates alone. Year-to-date, total compensation, 3.5% for wages and salaries, (single-family structures, 2.6%; multifamily, spending increased 5.4% but there was a and 2.0% for total benefits (including 0.4% 16%). There was a 7.0% decrease in real huge disparity between strong residential for health insurance, the least since 1997). gross private domestic investment in spending growth and diminishing Construction employment, not nonresidential structures, (commercial nonresidential activity. Private residential seasonally adjusted, decreased from and health care, -11%; manufacturing, -10%; construction spending jumped 25% year- February 2020—the pre-pandemic power and communication, -14%; wells and to-date: single-family, 36%; multifamily, peak month for seasonally adjusted mining structures, 33%; other non-mining 19%; and owner-occupied improvements, employment—to June 2021 in 80 (22%) of structures, -14%). Real government gross 12%. Private nonresidential construction the 358 metro areas (including divisions investment in structures declined 25%, spending declined 9.4% year-to-date, with of larger metros) for which BLS posts including federal investment for defense decreases in all 11 components. The largest construction employment data, increased structures, -6.9%; nondefense structures, private nonresidential segment (ranked in 257 (68%) and was unchanged in 21, -36%; and state and local structures by year-to-date spending)—power— according to an analysis AGC released investment, -12%. The GDP price index slumped 6.3% (including electric power, on July 28. The share of metros with increased 6.0%, with price indexes for -4.0%, and oil and gas field structures and employment increases was far below the nonresidential structures investment up pipelines, -14%), followed by commercial, typical share—on average, 92% of metros 8.8%; residential investment, 14.5%; and -4.7% (including warehouse, 7.5%, and added construction jobs between February government investment in structures, 10%. retail, -20%); manufacturing, -3.8%; and and June from 1990 through 2019. (BLS Steel remains problematic. Steel office, -12%. Lodging had the largest reports combined totals for mining, logging, Market Update reported that hot- decrease, -29%. Public construction and construction in most metro areas, rolled coil averaged $1860, more than spending slumped 7.1% year-to-date. The to avoid disclosing data about industries four times the August 2020 low point largest public segment, highway and street with few employers; AGC assumes the of $440. Contractors report mills are construction, slid 6.0%. Public education construction-only changes in these areas quoting 11-12 month lead times for bar construction declined 8.7% (primary/ match the combined change.) The largest joists. New South Construction Supply secondary, -4.0%, and higher education, losses over 16 months occurred in Houston- reported, “Rebar remains in extremely high -20%). Public transportation construction The Woodlands-Sugar Land (-33,400 demand and tight supply. All four major fell 6.8%. (Census includes data centers construction jobs, -14%), followed by New rebar manufacturers in the southeast are in office construction and does not break York City (-22,000 combined jobs, -14%); reporting large backlogs, little to no sitting them out. Nonresidential combines Midland, Texas (-9,300 combined jobs, inventory, and a continual flow of incoming renovation and new construction.) As -25%); and Odessa, Texas (-7,900 combined purchase orders for more material. Lead usual in August, Census posted annual jobs, -38%). Odessa had the steepest times are running at a month’s time after state totals for private and state/local percentage decline, followed by Lake purchase order is placed….Wire rod nonresidential spending, and updated Charles, La. (-34%, -6,700 construction availability remains a major issue and length-of-construction-time studies. jobs), Laredo, Texas (-25%, -1,000 combined production is outpacing the arrival of more Wages and salaries in the construction jobs) and Midland. The Chicago-Naperville- raw materials. Lead times are out to almost industry rose 1.4 %, seasonally adjusted, Arlington Heights division added the four months, depending on gauge and size.” in the second quarter (Q2) of 2021, up from most jobs (14,300 construction jobs, 12%), 0.9% in Q1 2021 and 1.1% in Q2 2020, the followed by Minneapolis-St. Paul, Minn.- Construction Industry adds Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported Wis. (13,800 combined jobs, 18%) and on July 30. The increase was the largest Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson (10,700 11,000 Jobs in July 3-month gain since the series began in construction jobs, 20%). Fargo, N.D.-Minn. The construction industry added 2000, Total compensation (wages, salaries, had the highest percentage increase (50%, 11,000 jobs between June and July but and benefits, including required employer 3,700 combined jobs), followed by Sierra nonresidential construction employment payments) in construction rose 1.2% in Vista-Douglas, Ariz. (48%, 1,200 combined remains far below pre-pandemic levels, Q2 2021, up from 0.9% in both Q1 2021 and jobs) and Bay City, Mich. (500 combined according to an analysis by the Associated Q2 2020,. Over 12 months, compensation jobs, 45%). Seven areas set new lows for General Contractors of America of increased 3.0%, vs. 3.3% in the previous June and 48 set new highs, in series dating government data released on August 6. 12 months, while wages and salaries rose in most cases to 1990. Association officials said nonresidential 3.2%, down from 3.9% in the previous 12 Inflation-adjusted gross domestic construction has been affected by declining months. BLS does not break out benefit product (real GDP)rose 6.5% at a demand for projects, particularly for public costs for construction, but the fact that total seasonally adjusted annual rate in Q2 2021, infrastructure work, and urged Congress compensation increased less than wages the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) to quickly pass the new bipartisan (3.0% vs. 3.2%) indicates that benefit costs reported on July 29, following a 6.3% infrastructure measure. rose less rapidly than wages. For all private gain in Q1. Real residential investment industry employees, employer costs over
THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS AUGUST 2021 8 It's always something
TM Martin T. Rucker Development by Mary Klett, ASA Communications Team
DeLano Sheffield, Executive Director of Kansas City ASA, recommended I chat with Martin T. Rucker II, and find out his Always Something Awesome story. It ends with a doozy. As with any professional sports player, your life is consumed with getting better and being the best you can be. And Martin did just that, playing professional football for five years, before an ACL tear got him thinking about life after football. He knew he wanted to own his own business, but what would be best suited for him? So he got to thinking...What do people always need? Healthcare (“Do I really want to go to medical school?”), Funeral homes (“Just can’t do it.”), BBQ (“But I can’t compete with Gates.”), and...construction (“It slows down, but still never ends.”) His mentor suggested Martin meet with Jim Kissick, who owned one of the larger civil contracting companies in the region. Jim advised Martin to come work for him. “Lose a little of my money before you go out on your own and lose all of yours.” At Kissick Construction Company his first job was installing water lines outdoors in the winter months before the new streetcar lines. After six years, he was a project engineer, in the interim soaking up how to run a business, how the industry works, how projects work. He noticed that there were never enough trucks to haul debris away. In 2019 he saw his opportunity and bought three trucks. From April
9 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS through December he hauled asphalt and other construction materials. Just as COVID-19 closed down the country in 2020, he bought nine more trucks. Many businesses closed, and he was able to provide jobs for school bus drivers and others that needed critical income. Martin T. Rucker Development LLC went from 3 employees in January 2020 to 23 in August of 2020, with an impressive 33% female and 60% minority makeup. He has less than that now, but is actively hiring and looking for good employees (hint, hint). Contact mrucker at mruckerdevelopment.com or call 816-237-0015. Felicia, a school bus driver, joined Martin T. Rucker Development Employees typically work solo, when the pandemic hit and so masks and vaccinations are not schools were closed. mandated, although he has stepped up cleaning measures, sanitizing trucks between drivers. As far as being a member of ASA? It's construction month at their “It’s a no-brainer! I spoke to a buddy school so we brought a piece of the from college who’s a member, and industry to them. They were very also chatted with DeLano. He’s got a excited and loved the loud horn! lot of great ideas, and I look forward to having a positive impact on our chapter.” A bible version from Proverbs directs his life: “In all your ways acknowledge him, and he will make straight your paths.” And football taught him another lesson - “Never get too high, or too low. Keeping an even keel alleviates a lot of stress.” He’s going to need those thoughts in the near term, as the most amazing Something Awesome happened on August 14, when Martin's family welcomed Martin T. Rucker, III into this world. Welcome, Martin, to the ASA family, and keep being awesome!
The Contractor’s Compass is recognizing excellence in ASA’s ranks. Every month we are highlighting the activities, achievements, and actions of ASA members that might inspire others. Do you have something you want to share? Send us an email at [email protected].
THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS AUGUST 2021 10 LEGALLY SPEAKING Reaching Your Best Subcontract Self: Tips for Negotiating Subcontract Terms to Maximize Profit by Michael Metz-Topodas, Cohen Seglias Passa Greenhall & Furman PC
With each new subcontract negotiated, when negotiating such clauses and drawings and specifications. And most contractors have an opportunity for adjusting their pricing. contractors know to review those the “art of the possible”—a chance to documents carefully and raise questions negotiate the best possible deal to work Price Escalation and issues with the owner, designer, on a new project. Doing so depends on Typically, subcontractors provide bid or GC regarding technical details and considering not only the scope of work pricing for a scope of work based on constructability. Some specifications, and pricing but also other commonly expectations for labor and materials however, do not address the technical used terms and conditions, as these can costs. The executed subcontract locks aspects of construction but merely affect how scope and pricing operate. To in that pricing, shifting the risk to the direct that the final constructed product help subcontractors successfully enter subcontractor should any costs change performs according to certain standards. agreements that maximize profit, here between when the subcontract is For example, such performance are considerations for negotiating several signed and the work is performed. In specifications can require a building common contract provisions. the past, subcontractors often accepted envelope to meet certain LEED such risk because they could rely on standards regarding air infiltration. Force Majeure relatively stable materials markets. Performance specifications create Construction subcontracts often Recent pandemic aftershocks have risk for subcontractors. To achieve contain provisions that excuse delayed resulted in larger price fluctuations for performance specifications’ standards, performance, partial performance, or materials, potentially creating a greater a subcontractor may need to modify, even non-performance resulting from risk to subcontractors. To account adjust, or even redesign work an unpreventable or uncontrollable for such dramatic price changes, performed in the field within what other event, often called force majeure subcontractors can negotiate to have project specifications permit. Those clauses. In the past, such clauses general contractors share some of this adjustments, modifications, or redesigns covered wars, floods, or acts of nature. risk through price escalation provisions. may require additional labor or materials, Recently, they have received greater Although such clauses come in almost but receiving additional compensation attention and use because the COVID- endless varieties, they typically establish via a change order for this in-scope 19 pandemic and related restrictions criteria under which the general work would likely face challenges. disrupted construction work nationwide. contractor (GC) agrees to pay an So, in negotiating agreements, Generally speaking, courts will enforce increased contract price due to a rise in subcontractors should pay close such provisions but construe them materials costs. For example, a clause attention to performance specifications, narrowly and apply them only to events may require that should average lumber the discretion afforded to meet them, and unforeseeable to the parties when they prices rise during the time between pricing and other terms so that they can entered the contract. At the pandemic’s execution and performance by more than control this risk as much as possible. onset, when such clauses did not 10% based on an agreed metric (e.g., a expressly list “pandemic” as a covered price index), the GC would compensate Pay-if-Paid event, subcontractors faced challenges a portion of the subcontractor’s actual Subcontracts frequently include in obtaining protection under them. And increased lumber costs. As this example provisions that tie a subcontractor’s now, over 18 months into this pandemic, reflects, such clauses can contain payment for work performed to the it hardly qualifies as an unforeseen many details about the conditions and GC receiving payment for that work. event. So, going forward, subcontractors terms for adjusting the subcontract Some clauses, typically called “pay- should consider ensuring that the force price due to materials escalation costs. when-paid,” pertain to a payment’s majeure clauses in their agreements Subcontract negotiations should find the timing and direct that when the GC explicitly include specific unforeseeable best arrangement that fits the project’s receives payment for a subcontractor’s instances that could reasonably circumstances. work, the GC must, in turn, pay the threaten performance. Unfortunately, no subcontractor, often within a specified agreement can cover all circumstances, Performance Specifications time. The more stringent “pay-if-paid” so subcontractors must consider the Most contracts outline a scope of clauses make a GC’s obligation to pay risks presented for a particular project work with reference to applicable its subcontractor conditioned on the
11 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS GC actually receiving payment for the cannot enforce a “no damages for on the requirements’ reasonableness subcontractor work performed. That delay” provision. Nor do such clauses relative to the project. Specifically, means the GC has no obligation to pay apply to delays from events that were does the requirement afford sufficient a subcontractor for work performed and unforeseen when the parties entered time to prepare the notice? Are timing accepted unless and until the GC is paid the contract. Regardless of the defenses requirements measured from when for that work. Unlike a pay-when-paid to a “no damages for delay” provision, the notice is sent or received? Also, clause, a pay-if-paid clause removes any subcontractors should negotiate their applicable law can affect the burden independent obligation for the GC to pay agreements to afford as much recovery notice requirements impose. Some its subcontractors and passes the risk of as possible for delay costs. Otherwise, states’ laws bar enforcing notice owner non-payment from the GC to the subcontractors should price their work to provisions when the party invoking subcontractor. To account for this risk, account for such potential costs. them, usually the GC, has actual notice subcontractors can adjust their pricing or does not suffer any prejudice despite or negotiate to modify this language— Work Continuation a breach of the contractual notice both challenging propositions. Some Most subcontracts have clauses that requirements. In other states, a missed jurisdictions, however, enforce a pay- require a subcontractor to continue notice deadline almost invariably waives if-paid clause only if it has very explicit working even after submitting a claim the right to any claim or right connected and clear language that payment to the for payment or after initiating any other to that notice. So, for example, failing to subcontractor is conditioned on the GC proceeding under the agreement’s provide a required 10 days’ notice likely receiving payment. dispute resolution process. Under makes a claim lost forever. In negotiating Further, under many states’ laws, this requirement, if a GC withholds such provisions, subcontractors need to if the GC’s actions are causing non- payment to a subcontractor because it understand how they operate within both payment for a subcontractor’s completed disputes the quality or extent of the work the project’s context and the applicable work, then the GC may lose the right performed, or for any other reason, a underlying law. to rely on a pay-if-paid clause. Lastly, subcontractor faces a no-win dilemma: a smaller number of states have found keep working without getting fully paid Conclusion pay-if-paid clauses unenforceable. So, or risk breaching the subcontract by A common theme runs through these negotiating such payment clauses needs stopping work. Fortunately, some states subcontract negotiation considerations: to account for the risk presented under have laws that permit a subcontractor to they vary with the circumstances of the the applicable law. suspend work for non-payment despite underlying project and the law of the what a subcontract may direct, as long applicable jurisdiction. For that reason, No Damages for Delay as the subcontractor complies with subcontract negotiations benefit greatly Due to the many “moving parts” and certain notice and other requirements. when involving experienced construction other variables on construction projects, Such laws should play a role in gauging counsel. The lawyers at Cohen Seglias delays frequently happen. Such delays whether to negotiate or accept a have been helping clients analyze, create extra costs for subcontractors— subcontract's requirement to continue assess, and negotiate subcontracts and often additional labor and extended working despite a pending claim or their provisions for over thirty years general conditions costs, to name a few. dispute. and welcome further opportunities to Typical subcontracts, however, limit a continue supporting subcontractors in subcontractor’s remedies for delays Notice Requirements the difficult contract negotiation process. to time extensions to the contractual Most subcontracts require the deadline for the subcontractor to subcontractor to notify the GC about About the Author complete its work. These “no damages certain project developments, especially Michael Metz-Topodas is a partner at for delay” clauses present another area events that could lead to a claim for Cohen Seglias. As a construction litigator, in which subcontractors end up bearing additional payment or performance time. he represents general contractors, significant risk. Extensions of time relieve Often, such notice requirements direct subcontractors, owners, designers, and a subcontractor of liability for liquidated the form, delivery method, and, most suppliers through all stages of private, damages or other consequences from importantly, timing for such notices. public, and federal projects. Michael not meeting contractual deadlines but For example, AIA A201-2017 Art. 15, helps clients navigate construction leave subcontractors without remedies Sec. 15.1.3.1 requires notice of a claim project disputes, including delay for costs incurred from extra time spent within 21 days after the event leading and inefficiency claims, design and on a project. In some jurisdictions, to the request for extra payment or construction defects, unforeseen site however, where an owner or GC causes the claimant’s awareness of such an conditions, project scope disputes, and a subcontractor’s delay by actively event (whichever is later). Negotiating payment claims. He can be reached at interfering with the subcontractor such notice requirements depends performing its work, the owner or GC and 267.238.4755.
THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS AUGUST 2021 12 LEGALLY SPEAKING The Ties that Don’t Necessarily Bind: Force Majeure and Price Escalations by Jordan R. Pavlus, Esq., Byrne Costello & Pickard, P.C.
When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, we Price (De)Escalation Clause? order at the start of the pandemic. At this all got a stark refresher in force majeure Ideally, a subcontractor would negotiate point, no one knows when the project clauses, which prior thereto were rarely language into its subcontract prior to will re-commence, if ever. For over one invoked. Force majeure clauses typically commencing work on the project which year during the pandemic shut down, the excuse contractual performance for some allows for an equitable adjustment in subcontractor receives periodic notices identified reason outside the control of the contract price due to material price from its material supplier of price increases. the contracting party, like an act of god, escalations which meet an agreed upon The subcontractor does not provide these war, labor strikes, etc. When the pandemic threshold. notices to the contractor or owner because shut down construction projects, many it does not know if/when the project will subcontractors combed their subcontracts Any such material price escalation clause re-commence. When the project is finally to determine whether they could obtain requires that the subcontractor keep re-commenced, the price of materials has any relief via a force majeure clause. records of material prices used to formulate sky-rocketed. The subcontractor submits Inasmuch as many force majeure clauses its contract price so that they can be its request for a material price adjustment did not explicitly reference pandemics, contrasted with later price escalations. when the project is re-commenced. The it was usually not a perfect fit, and it has It is no easy task to negotiate a material owner denies the claim because contractual been a mixed bag for subcontractors price escalation clause into a subcontract notice was not provided within fifteen days regarding whether they could obtain relief because the upstream parties are of discovery of the price increases (as via these clauses. Unfortunately, for many looking for certainty in cost. The typical required by contract). subcontractors, they had to work with what construction bid is a gamble based on Do not be a cautionary tale. Negotiating was already in their subcontracts, many of certain assumptions in material price, for a material price escalation clause at the which are for a lump sum price. schedule, labor costs, sequence of the front end of a project is a critical aspect work, etc. If the subcontractor made the of a successful project and notification Look Back. Learn. Look Ahead right gamble, it will be a profitable project. If requirements must be observed at all times. not, the project will be a loss. Most owners One of the positives to come out of this and general contractors will take this situation is that subcontractors can learn position. About the Author from it and recognize the potential project impacts from a global pandemic and its If a subcontractor is successful in Jordan Pavlus focuses his practice effect on their supply chain. This will allow negotiating for a material price increase primarily on all facets of construction law, subcontractors to anticipate potential clause, it should be anticipated that the including contract review, contract and impacts and negotiate to address them upstream parties will likewise seek a addendum drafting, terms and conditions on the front end of a project, rather than material price decrease clause. In other review and drafting, litigation, arbitration relying on a force majeure clause which is words, if the price of materials goes down, and mediation. He regularly advises they pay less. If it goes up, they pay more. not a perfect fit for the situation. clients on the nuances associated One of those issues which should be Subcontractors should also make with construction law, including bond careful note that they must comply with addressed by subcontractors on the claims, lien law, prompt payment law, applicable contractual notice provisions front end of a project is the potential for and a broad variety of issues faced construction material price escalations. when it comes to material price escalation clauses. If the subcontract requires notice in the commercial construction field. The construction industry continues to Jordan has served as solo trial counsel deal with extreme price volatility in the of any changes in price within seven days, in numerous matters and has also been material supply sector. The price of many the subcontractor must ensure to notify materials have more than doubled within the contractor within seven days of each lead attorney on multi-week arbitrations the last several months, much of which can discovery of material price escalations. This with damages in seven figures. He is a be attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic. means that every time the subcontractor frequent lecturer on construction related Even if price escalations are more modest, gets notice from a supplier of a material issues. For more information on Jordan any material price escalation can turn price increase, the subcontractor must in Pavlus and Byne, Costello, & Pickard, what could have been a profitable project turn notify the contractor. P.C., visit http://bcplegal.com/ into a money pit. The good news is that a subcontractor can protect itself from being It Pays to be Overly Cautious forced to proceed with a project without an Here is a recent cautionary tale which equitable mechanism by which it can seek is illustrative: the owner on a government relief from material price escalations. construction project issues a stop work
13 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS FEATURE Health and Safety Best Practices for Subcontractors when Staying Prepared for COVID-19 During the Current Outbreak by Kevin J. McMahon, MS, CIH, HazTek Inc.
The Delta variant of the coronavirus, we know of and that I have seen in my longer need to wear a mask,” he said, which began appearing in the US in 20-year career.” It spreads as similarly summarizing new CDC guidance and March 2021, now accounts for over easy as chicken pox, and although encouraging more Americans to roll up 90% of new cases. This form of the fully vaccinated individuals have good their sleeves. “Get vaccinated – or wear virus is much more transmissible, likely protection, breakthrough cases are a mask until you do.” (AP, May 13, 2021) more severe, and is affecting more occurring. As a result, many employers are younger people than the original virus. This is a rapid turnaround from when re-evaluating their approach to Dr. Rochelle P. Wilensky, director of President Biden announced on May 13 preventing further spread. There are the Centers for Disease Control and that we could take our masks off as a updated steps-to-take to ensure the Prevention, has said that “It is one of result of the distribution of vaccines. health and safety of subcontractors the most infectious respiratory viruses “If you are fully vaccinated, you no amid the pandemic.
THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS AUGUST 2021 14 spread of the virus and to apply the measures that are most effective in preventing the spread at their work sites. It is best to take a multi-layered approach, using a combination of control measures that will assure effective results, including engineering methods (e.g., ventilation and physical barriers), administrative controls (e.g., physical distancing, work from home, staggered shifts, temperature and symptom screening, infection testing, cleaning and disinfecting), as well as face coverings/masks and personal protective equipment (e.g., respirators, gloves). While mandating of vaccines Among the recent developments, Most importantly, employers should has not become universal, companies employers are using the following continue to follow the CDC guidelines should evaluate their specific needs, approaches: for preventing spread, as they have and encourage their employees to • Delaying return to the office/ from before the delta variant appeared. be vaccinated if eligible, and with a workplace for employees, i.e., AIHA, the association for scientists healthcare professional’s consultation. and professionals committed to continuing to work from home. An important tool for subcontractors preserving and ensuring occupational • Requiring vaccinations of employees to continuously evaluate their specific and environmental health and in the workplace or testing needs, and apply critical safety safety (OEHS) in the workplace and employees weekly. practices, is the use of Job Safety community, has from the beginning • Asking for proof of vaccination Analyses (aka, Job Hazard Analysis, of the pandemic, published guidance (showing documentation) or Task Hazard Analysis) discussed in the documents for workplaces. Recently attesting to having received the AIHA Back to Work Safely™ Guidance it published a series of Back to Work vaccine. Documents. In addition, AIHA Safely™ Guidance Documents (2nd members – Industrial Hygienists – can • Requiring the use of face coverings/ ed.) for small to mid-size businesses play a vital role in assisting employers masks for all individuals, regardless in 27 industry sectors including the to develop plans and evaluate their of vaccine status, or requiring those construction industry. https://www. workplaces to assure that controls are who have not received the vaccine backtoworksafely.org/construction- effectively being practiced. to wear face coverings/masks unless reopening-guidelines-covid-19 working outside and at least 6 feet Visit the AIHA’s COVID-19 The free guidance documents, (physical distancing) from others. Resource Center to access updated available only in English now (and in comprehensive information for Additional best practices include: Spanish this Fall), provide clear and responding to the pandemic. • daily tool-box talks to update and actionable steps towards the safe re-enforce hygiene procedures, operations of a variety of workplaces • frequent inspections to confirm through prevention, early detection, About the Author compliance with required and control of COVID-19. The 2nd Kevin J. McMahon, MS, CIH, is procedures, and editions offer practical guidance for Director of Technical Services for • limiting the use of pool cars and ride employers to implement multiple HazTek, Inc. a safety management sharing among employees, or use of layers of risk mitigation strategies consulting firm that specializes in N-95 respirators when traveling with through use of engineering controls services to the construction industry. He 2 passengers or more for more than (e.g., increased ventilation and air has contributed to the Focus on Health: 30-minutes. filtration), administrative controls COVID-19 document published by AIHA (e.g., staggered shifts), and personal Should the number of new cases and is a current member of the TAG protective equipment (e.g., respirators continue to grow rapidly, or other WG5 Committee for the forthcoming and gloves). variants appear, more companies are ISO 45006 standard for Occupational expected to take new measures to Since conditions are changing Health and Safety Management — curtail the spread, including possibly rapidly, and to varying degrees at preventing and managing infectious more requirements for vaccinations. different locations, it is critical for all diseases – General guidelines for companies to continue to monitor the organizations.
15 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS FEATURE
How to Share Construction Opportunities with Students—and Why You Should by Rachel Burris, NCCER
You can help make a difference — After that experience, I found a circumstances.” — Holly Mathis, Build not just for the industry, but for the job posting for the Build Your Future Your Future Manager young people who aren’t aware of the Manager role and started working at We’ve all seen the stats about the opportunities that construction offers. NCCER in September 2019. Part of my workforce shortage in the construction “I grew up in a small town with little focus is on helping the construction industry: education about career opportunities industry make connections with • 53% of the seasoned workforce is outside of the typical mold of a four- education, as well as recruiting and expected to retire by 2036. reaching people, with a large focus on year degree. Back in 2019, I drove • More than half of construction students. through my hometown and stopped at firms are having a hard time filling a fast-food restaurant to find that three However, the part of my job that both salaried and hourly craft of my high school classmates worked gets me out of bed in the morning positions. there — 14 years post-high school is knowing that what I do impacts • For more than seven straight graduation. It made me sad to realize lives. It is my mission to empower years, construction skilled trades that they probably didn’t know there students through information to find are the hardest roles to fill. were and are other options for them. opportunities that can change their
THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS AUGUST 2021 16 Let’s take a second to step back story and what construction has done to share how you got into the industry, and think less about the effect on for you. Be a mentor. what you find most satisfying and what construction and more about the you would recommend to the next impact a job in the industry could Be a spokesperson at your generation. have on somebody. For too long, local school construction careers have not been Be a mentor BYF works with many companies traditionally seen as a path to success. While mentorship typically begins The university route is portrayed as that connect with their local schools and do presentations, career day visits when somebody has already chosen the best way for students to ‘make their career, having an encouraging something of themselves’ only for and provide resources for educators and counselors. We always recommend mentor can be the key element them to fall into massive debt getting a to the mentee choosing to stay in degree that may not be needed in the having a craft professional attend these events — Gen Z, in particular, are the industry. In addition, although workforce. In fact, 25% of workers with the benefits to yourself may not be student loan debt are employed out looking for authentic experiences and who better to tell what it’s like working the first thing you think of when of their chosen field because of debt becoming a mentor, it’s definitely worth obligations. on the job site than you. Not only are you contributing to building a talent consideration. A 2006 study found As Holly’s story illustrated, young pipeline, but you’re inspiring the next that mentors were promoted six times people can also fall into jobs that don’t generation to consider a career they more often than standard employees give them much room to grow because may not have thought of. and the retention rate was higher — they see that as the only option 72% compared to 49%. Keep that available. Volunteer on local school in mind when the next opportunity We know that construction offers presents itself to become a mentor. The more — it teaches skills that are in advisory councils exchange of knowledge and guidance high demand, it has high salaries and Your local school has an advisory from those who are more experienced it provides satisfaction from jobs that council — or most likely several — and is an important part of craft training, have meaning. But how do we show they’re looking for volunteers from the and you’ll be furthering the education students that there are more options community. General councils come up of those newer to construction. available to them? with annual plans to improve education Working with BYF, you can help It’s up to you. in vital areas of the school, while make a difference — not just for the We’re not asking you to do this on other councils are more specialized industry, but for the students and your own. Build Your Future (BYF) is an in areas such as career and technical young people who aren’t aware of the initiative that aims to be the catalyst for education. Garrett High School’s world of opportunity that construction recruiting the next generation of craft Career Development program credits offers. Be a voice in your community professionals. Powered by NCCER, a good portion of their success to local about the benefits of construction and BYF creates pathways that bridge industry representatives sitting on their impact a student’s life. the gap between curiosity and career advisory board. Contact your local high Visit byf.org to see other ways you placement. school to see how you can contribute. can get involved. As a grassroots effort, we work to Share your story and what equip industry representatives with the About the Author resources needed to reach students, construction has done for Rachel Burris is the communications families and educators and effectively you manager at NCCER. She has over seven promote careers in construction. With Build Your Future is always on the years’ experience in communications Gen Z expected to make up 27% lookout for inspiring stories to tell. Our and public relations, including writing and of the global workforce by 2025, success stories bridge from apprentice editing content for emails, social media, it’s important to start making those to journeyman to CEOs — students and press releases, blogs and articles. She connections now. young people want to hear it directly holds a Bachelor of Arts in English from Check out these four ways that you from the source that construction the University of South Florida and a can get involved: Be a spokesperson offers viable, successful career paths. Master of Business Administration degree at your local school. Volunteer on local Contact us at [email protected] from Webster University. school advisory councils. Share your
17 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS As risk management becomes more prevalent, subcontractors are often forced to fill lengthy forms for a chance to win the project
COMPASS is the first tool built for subcontractors to efficiently and securely satisfy General Contractor prequalification requirements using one standard form (1Form), updated once a year.
To support moving the industry to a universal qualification form, sign up for the petition below
https://forms.gle/CKoejWC7jCJowvPt9
1-800-689-6819 [email protected] http://compass.bespokemetrics.com FEATURE
Post-Pandemic Drives Best Practices by Jack Rubinger, freelance writer
Right now we’re coming back to life. Some the cost of building materials, which was a change orders. We quote what it will cost may even be looking at the pandemic from reason to slow projects down with hopes that and we stick to it. He recommended us just their rearview mirrors. Many are reviving long the prices would become reasonable again. because we weren't a nuisance to deal with. dormant projects, programs, practices.The Lumber costing two to four times what it had So there are other indirect parts of business reopening of libraries, for example, means cost months prior caused most construction people don't think about,” said Cansler. ideas and books are being shared again. companies to look to other ways to build Mack Turner heads the Institute People are traveling again. using concrete beams and columns or lower for Safety in Powerline Construction. To survive and thrive in this current climate, quality materials like MDF and melamine,” Their business took a big hit during the networking and sharing ideas is vital — even said Alexander. pandemic. if the meetings are boring. If you go once in In Alexander’s experience, during the “When COVID hit we had 80% of our a while, that’s better than not going at all — pandemic the "low-guy" trumped hiring other business at customer locations and of course whether they’re virtual or in person. contractors. The cost of necessary materials that dried up completely. We started going Marketing construction-related products reduced the group of competing contractors after more work that we could do in-house and services is a lot about timing, filling considered. once we were able to get back to the office. a need and providing above-the-call-of- Another best practice?—Keeping We also started doing more webinars. Now duty customer service. It’s making on construction site documentation visible things have opened back up. We will try to the fly adjustments to rapidly changing and free from damage from the elements. go back to 80% at the customer’s workplace conditions. Themes can always be changed. Because construction doesn’t stop when it but still offer more distance learning How accurately can you project out six rains or snows and workplace documents opportunities,” said Turner. months from now? The pandemic changed like permits and procedures should always Finally, there’s Rigdon Fair, the founder predictions. be visible, TUFFA Products has introduced of The Pothole Man. Fair started five new Resiliency is the big theme of best a weatherproof permit document holder to businesses this year and is doing all he can practices. You adjust or you die. It takes store and display Permit to Works, Safety to keep up. Rigdon found ways to adapt to creativity. Persistence. Substance. Since Data Sheets, Instruction Manuals, Written difficult and challenging times that came the pandemic, companies have changed Procedures, and Checklists. along with the pandemic. strategies to survive, grow and compete in Health and Wellness Changes—At the time Looking ahead, the vibe among most this new environment. of this article, some states have removed small businesses is cautiously optimistic. Christine Zielke is the Operational the requirement for masks and a third of the While Dodge Data & Analytics forecasts Manager at the BC Municipal Safety people in the U.S. have accepted vaccines, construction starts to rebound in 2021 and Association in British Columbia, Canada. but two-thirds still threaten the population by 2022, with the prospect of far greater gains not getting vaccines. “The BCMSA made some large-scale if a Federal infrastructure spending plan is transitions to ensure we could continue In the workplace even a report of the flu or passed. to serve our membership throughout the a cold is intimidating for many people. The construction industry will continue to pandemic,” said Zielke. “This included “I think that employers are more willing to innovate, create and inspire new ideas, new transitioning our occupational health and let sick workers recover at home now and ways of thinking and add new influencers to safety training to a virtual platform. Now we employees are more willing to remain at home the mix. It's best to listen to others, weigh the reach more remote and small communities.” when they are sick to protect other people,” pros and cons and ultimately make your own The association provided a wealth of said Alexander. decision with respect to what’s best for you, resources in relation to COVID-19 as well as Maybe the days of being a martyr and your company and your customers. a venue to connect membership utilizing the showing up for work when ill are becoming a collective mind of experts in the construction thing of the past. About the Author industry to share knowledge and support Andrea Cansler is with Quality Tank & Jack Rubinger is a safe workplaces across the province. The Construction Co, Inc. in Sandy, Oregon. freelance writer, with more association also provided a free toolkit for They’re “over-servicing” customers to stay than 10+ years of mental health related to COVID-19. competitive. workplace safety and “A silver lining of the pandemic has been “We fix broken components that are construction industry how mental health has become a prioritized necessary to keep entire facilities running. research and writing subject,” said Zielke. It is necessary to find what companies need experience. Looking for an Laura Alexander is a Federal most. We try to help customers find long term article on a specific construction project manager. solutions to keep running smoothly and more construction topic? Construction continued through COVID efficiently for the long haul. I don't see our Contact: [email protected] or call even though buildings being constructed competitors going that extra mile,” she said. 503-964-4877. were vacant or would be vacant for a while. “I had a conversation with a purchasing “What harmed the industry the most was manager. He loved the fact that we never had
19 AUGUST 2021 THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS A card to help optimize your per diem process. Say goodbye to complicated employee per diem. With the Prepaid Expense Card, you’ll be able to remove the hassle of cash by directly loading or unloading funds onto an employee’s card. Plus, no more worrying about incorporating per diem into employees’ payroll. They’ll have the funds they need, when they need it. It’s per diem made simple.
866.946.3017 commercebank.com/expensecard [email protected] Special pricing for © Commerce Bancshares, Inc. ASA members CommercePayments™ solutions are provided by Commerce Bank. THE CONTRACTOR’S COMPASS AUGUST 2021 20