The myth of the effective strongman? Internal constraints, external constraints and economic development in autocracies. Jacob Nyrup∗ October 29, 2018 Abstract Autocratic regimes vary dramatically in their ability to produce ‘better‘ levels of economic performance. Yet, we currently lack a theoretical framework with which to explore this variation. Much of the current literature is guided by ideas and distinctions that are out of touch with the increasingly institutionalized and ho- mogeneous authoritarian regimes of today. This article presents a new framework for understanding development outcomes in authoritarian regimes. It is argued that the autocrat can be constrained by the ruling elite - this is named internal constraints - and the masses - this is named external constraints. An autocrat, who faces constraints on his rule, will be held accountable for bad outcomes, and it is therefore expected that constraints is associated with better economic outcomes. The article presents and uses a new dataset on elites in 135 countries from 1966 to 2017. Using this dataset, I show that a dictator governs over worse economic outcomes when he faces less constraints on his rule. Furthermore, it is shown that this is not the case for democratic leaders. Working paper prepared for the 2018 DPSA Annual Meeting to be presented at the panel ”Dynamics of Autocracies” ∗DPhil student in Politics, Nuffield College, University of Oxford. Mail:
[email protected] 1The author is grateful for the helpful suggestions and advice of Ben Ansell, Victor Menaldo, Anders Woller Nielsen, Mogens Kamp Justesen, Nancy Bermeo, Lasse Aaskoven, Ezequiel González Ocantos, Andy Eggers, David Doyle, Rasmus Fonnesbæk Andersen as well as participants in the American Political Science’s Association’s Annual Meeting 2018 and the workshop “Redistributive Politics: Comparative and Experimental Approaches” at Copenhagen Business School.