Draft Stoneman Lake TMDL
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 BACKGROUND & PROBLEM STATEMENT ................................... 1 1.1 Description of TMDL Process ........................................... 1 1.2 Water Quality Standards, 305(b), 303(d), and Impairment ...................... 2 1.3 Lake and Watershed Overview .......................................... 4 1.3.1 Lake Characteristics ............................................ 4 1.3.2 Watershed Characteristics ....................................... 10 1.3.3 Anthropogenic History .......................................... 11 1.3.4 Land Use Management ......................................... 12 2.0 DATA SUMMARY ....................................................... 15 2.1 Watershed ......................................................... 15 2.1.1 Topography .................................................. 15 2.1.2 Soils ....................................................... 20 2.1.3 Geology ..................................................... 21 2.1.4 Land and Land Use Cover ....................................... 21 2.1.5 Vegetation Cover .............................................. 23 2.1.6 Terrestrial Ecosystem Survey ..................................... 23 2.1.7 Roads and Buildings ............................................ 26 2.2 Hydrography and Hydrology ........................................... 26 2.2.1 Watershed Boundaries .......................................... 26 2.2.2 Springs, Streams, and Ditches. .................................... 26 2.2.3 Lake Level, Depth, and Area ..................................... 29 2.2.4 Meteorological Data ............................................ 29 2.2.5 Runoff/Streamflow ............................................. 30 2.3 Water and Sediment Quality ............................................. 34 2.3.1 Precipitation. ................................................ .34 2.3.2 Streams and Springs. ........................................... 34 2.3.3 Stoneman Lake Water Quality. .................................... 34 2.3.4 Stoneman Lake Sediments. ...................................... 42 2.3.5 Stoneman Lake Macrophytes ..................................... 42 2.4 Conceptual Model. ................................................. .43 2.4.1 Data availability ............................................... 43 2.4.2 Patterns in Water Quality ........................................ 44 2.4.3 Primary Production ............................................ 44 2.4.4 Hydrologic and Nutrient Budget ................................... 45 2.5 Recommendations for Quantitative Modeling. ............................... 45 2.5.1 Hydrologic and Nutrient Budget Model ............................. 45 2.5.2 Lake Water Quality Model ....................................... 47 2.5.3 SAV Model. ................................................. 47 2.6 Model Linkages, Calibration & Numeric Targets ............................ 48 3.0 MODEL SETUP .......................................................... 49 3.1 Watershed Loading Model ............................................. 49 3.1.1 Hydrologic Model. ............................................. 49 3.1.2 Nutrient Loads ................................................ 58 3.2 Lake Model (BATHTUB) ............................................. 58 3.3 SAV Model ........................................................ 61 3.4 Dissoloved Oxygen Demand and Diurnal Range ............................. 64 3.5 Model Scenarios .................................................... 67 3.5.1 SAV Removal ................................................ 67 3.5.2 Variable Lake Depth ........................................... 68 3.5.3 Septic System Upgrades ........................................ 68 4.0 MODEL RESULTS ....................................................... 69 4.1 Existing Conditions ................................................... 69 4.2 SAV Removal ...................................................... 71 4.2.1 Effect on Nutrients and Chlorophyll. ................................ 71 4.2.2 Effect on D.O. ................................................ 71 4.3 Variable Lake Level .................................................. 74 4.3.1 Effect on Nutrients and Chlorophyll ................................ 74 4.3.2 Effect on SAV ................................................ 74 4.3.3 Effect on D.O. ................................................ 76 4.3.4 Effect of Alternatives on Lake Level ................................ 76 4.4 Septic System Upgrade ............................................... 79 5.0 FEASABILITY AND COST OF ALTERNATIVES .............................. 81 5.1 SAV Harvest (Removal) or Cutting ...................................... 81 5.1.1 Feasibility and Environmental Issues ................................ 81 5.1.2 Costs ....................................................... 82 5.2 Herbicide Application ................................................. 83 5.2.1 Feasibility and Environmental Issues ................................ 83 5.2.2 Costs ....................................................... 84 5.3 Biological Controls ................................................... 84 5.3.1 Feasibility and Environmental Issues ................................ 85 5.3.2 Costs ....................................................... 85 5.4 CCC Ditch Regulation ................................................ 85 5.4.1 Feasibility and Environmental Issues ................................ 86 5.4.2 Cost ....................................................... 89 5.5 Dredging .......................................................... 89 5.6 Septic Systems Upgrades .............................................. 90 5.6.1 Tier Determination ............................................. 90 5.6.2 “Bright-line” Determination ....................................... 91 5.7 Aeration and Ciculation. ............................................... 91 5.8 Regulatory Redesignation .............................................. 92 6.0 ALTERNATIVES SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION ...................... 93 6.1 Water Quality Benefits. ............................................... 93 6.2 Technical Feasibility .................................................. 93 6.3 Regulatory Feasibility ................................................. 93 6.4 Costs. ........................................................... .93 6.5 Overall Comparison .................................................. 95 6.6 Tmdl Allocation ..................................................... 96 7.0 REFERENCES. ......................................................... .97 LIST OF TABLES Table No. Page No. Table 1-1 Statistical Summay of Water Quality Data ................................... 8 Table 2-1 Clean Lakes Data. ................................................ 36-40 Table 3-1 Estimated Dimensions of Stoneman Lake .................................. 50 Table 3-2 Average Monthly Watershed Yield Coefficients ............................. 53 Table 3-3 Watershed Loading Model Parameters .................................... 55 Table 3-4 BATHTUB Parameters ............................................... 60 Table 3-5 SAV Model Parameters ............................................... 63 Table 3-6 Parameters Used in the Calculation of BOD. ................................ 66 Table 4-1 Summary of Model Results ............................................. 72 Table 6-1 Summary of Alternatives ............................................... 94 LIST OF FIGURES Figure No. Page No. Figure 1-1 Location Map ....................................................... 5 Figure 1-2 Map of Stoneman Lake Area ............................................ 6 Figure 1-3 Aerial Photograph of Lake Showing Dike. .................................. 7 Figure 1-4 Graph Showing D.O. Stratification. ........................................ 9 Figure 2-1 Topographic Map ................................................... 17 Figure 2-2 Topographic Contours from DEM ....................................... 18 Figure 2-3 Slope from DEM .................................................... 19 Figure 2-4 Land Use .......................................................... 22 Figure 2-5 Vegetative Cover .................................................... 24 Figure 2-6 Terrestrial Ecosystem Map Units ........................................ 25 Figure 2-7 Watershed Boundaries ................................................ 27 Figure 2-8 Springs and Major ADEQ Sampling Stations ............................... 28 Figure 2-9 Bathymetry of Stoneman Lake in October 1999. ............................ 31 Figure 2-10 Beaver Creek Watershed Meteorological Stations. ........................... 32 Figure 2-11 Beaver Creek Stream Gaging Stations. .................................... 33 Figure 3-1 Map Showing Watershed 8 and Happy Jack. ............................... 51 Figure 3-2 Graph Showing Hydrologic Model Calibration Results ........................ 56 Figure 3-3 Graph Showing Linear Regression (Lake Volumes) ........................... 57 Figure 3-4 Graph Showing BATHTUB Calibration Results ............................. 62 Figure 4-1 Chart Showing Nutrient Sources ......................................... 70 Figure 4-2 Graph Showing BOD Production in an SAV-Dominated Lake. .................. 73 Figure 4-3 Graph Showing Effect of Lake Level on Nutrients and Chlorophyll. ............... 75 Figure 4-4 Graph Showing Effect of Lake Level and SAV Height on BOD. ................. 77 Figure 4-5 Graph