SALMON FISHERIES OF THE COASTAL RIVERS OF OREGON SOUTH OF THE COLUMBIA
JOHN T. GHARRE1T AND JOHN I. HODGES
OREGON FISH COMMISSION PORTLAND, OREGON
Contribution No. 13
December, 1950 TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page INTRODUCTION 3 PAST REGULATION OF THE FISHERIES 5 CHINOOK SALMON 6 Spring Chinook 8 Fall Chinook 10 SILVER SALMON 12 CHUM SALMON 16 STEELHEAD 17 OTHER FACTORS AFFECTING THE POPULATION 20 Watershed Cover 20 Water Use Projects 20 Miscellaneous Factors 21 Recreational Fishery 21 Ocean Troll Fishery 26 MANAGEMENT PROGRAM 26 Stream Improvement 26 Fishery Regulations 27 Artificial Propagation 28 CONCLUSIONS 30 LITERATURE CITED 31 SALMON FISHERIES OF THE COASTAL RIVERS OF OREGON SOUTH OF THE COLUMBIA
JOHN T. GHARRFTT AND JOHN I. HODGES
OREGON FISH COMMISSION PORTLAND, OREGON
Contribution No. 13
December, 1950 LIST OF FIGURES
Page Figure 1. Oregon Coastal Rivers 4 Figure 2. Annual Production of Spring Chinook Salmon by the Commer- cial Fisheries of the Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1923-1947 . . . 8 Figure 3. Total Gill Net License Sales for all Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1921-1949 9 Figure 4. Time and Area Open to Commercial Spring Chinook Salmon Fishing on Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1891-1948 10 Figure 5. Annual Production of Fall Chinook Salmon by the Commercial Fisheries of the Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1923-1949 11 Figure 6. Time and Area Open to Commercial Fall Chinook Salmon Fishing on Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1891-1948 12 Figure 7. Annual Production of Silver Salmon by the Commercial Fish- eries of the Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1892-1949 13 Figure 8. Time and Area Open to Commercial Silver Salmon Fishing on Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1891-1948 14 Figure 9. Total Gill Net License Sales for Oregon Coastal Rivers Still Open to Commercial Fishing, 1905-1949 15 Figure 10. Annual Production of Chum Salmon by the Commercial Fish- eries of the Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1892-1949 16 Figure 11. Annual Production of Steelhead by the Commercial Fisheries of the Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1923-1949 18 Figure 12. Time and Area Open to Commercial Steelhead Fishing on Oregon Coastal Rivers, 1891-1948 19 Figure 13. The Coquille River of Oregon Showing Areas of Survey and Ob- structions to Salmon Migration 22 Figure 14. Tillamook Bay and Tributary Rivers Showing Areas Under Study and Obstructions to Salmon Migrations 23 Figure 15. Log jams on the Siuslaw and Trask Rivers and a Splash Dam on the S. Fork of the Coos River 24 Figure 16. Log Jams and Falls on Wilson River and Salmonberry River 25
9 SALMON FISHERIES OF THE COASTAL RIVERS OF OREGON SOUTH OF THE COLUMBIA JOHN T. GHARRETT1 AND JOHN I. HODGES
INTRODUCTION Biological studies of the anadromous food fishes of the Oregon coastal rivers were begun in 1945 by the Oregon Fish Commission. Although considerable re- search work had been centered on the salmon populations in the Columbia River prior to that time, practically no studies had been made on the valuable runs of food fishes in the smaller coastal rivers. Indications of decreases in the sizes of the populations of salmon had caused considerable concern to both the commercial and recreational fishery interests for many years previous. This report is the first of a series dealing with the fisheries management on rivers south of the Columbia. The Oregon coast line, stretching a total distance of about 300 miles, is broken by numerous rivers and streams. The two largest rivers are the Rogue and the Umpqua which have their headwaters in the Cascade Range. The others are considerably shorter and flow from the coastal range of mountains. The streams range in size from those with annual mean water flows of less than twenty-five cubic feet per second to those with flows of 7,000 or 8,000 cubic feet per second. The location and relative sizes of the various stream systems are shown in Figure 1. The river fishing industry has been one of the major factors in the devel- opment of the Oregon Coast. The species of fish which are of commercial im- portance are as follows: chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tschawytscha), silver salmon or silverside (O. kisutch), chum salmon (0. beta), steelhead trout (Salmo gairdnerii), shad (A losa sapidissima), and striped bass (Roccus saxatilis). The salmon and steelhead are indigenous to Oregon whereas the shad and striped bass are introduced species. This report will deal exclusively with the three species of salmon and the steelhead; the results of shad and striped bass inves- tigations will be discussed at length in other publications of the Fish Commission. Several types of fishing gear have been of importance in the development of the salmon fisheries on the coastal rivers. These were designed to capture the adult fish as they progressed through the lower reaches of the rivers on their spawning migrations. Seines, traps, and gill nets were all used in the early periods of the fishery with the gill nets being the most popular type of gear and the only type permitted at present. Seines and traps were of the conventional type used in the salmon fisheries along the Pacific Coast. The gill nets used today are much the same type as have been used since the beginning of the fishery and are of two types — the drift net and the set net. The drift net is fished from a boat and is generally laid out at right angles to the flow of the stream. The boat and net drift with the current. Considerable change has taken place in the type of boat used in such drift netting. The row boats of earlier years have for the most part given way to the larger power boats of the present day. Boats today range in size from skiffs of 18 to 20 feet in length, powered by outboard motors, to those of 26 to 28 feet in length, powered by marine engines and of the same design as those used on the Columbia River. Set nets are gill nets which are at- tached to stakes or from the shore in a stationary position.
1 This paper completed after senior author became Research Coordinator for the Pacific Marine Fisheries Commission. 3 TILLAMOOK BAY
NETARTS BAY
SANOLAKE
LOWER TENNILE
COOS BA
FLORAS C Cape Blanco
FIGURE 1. Oregon Coastal Rivers.
4 PAST REGULATION OF THE FISHERIES As late as 1900 all the waters of Oregon tributary to the Pacific Ocean south of the Columbia were open to commercial fishing. Considering the development of the coast at that time, it is doubtful that all the streams were fished. How- ever, those rivers close to points of transportation were apparently supporting substantial fisheries as early as the 1880 s (Table 1). Following 1900 the fishing regulations were so worded that only those streams specifically designated by law were open to commercial fishing. There were at that time 22 river systems so designated. In this number, Tillamook Bay and its five tributaries have been counted as one river system; likewise, the Umpqua including Smith River, the Siletz including Schooner and Drift Creeks, etc., have been so counted. Subsequently, many of these rivers have been closed and others opened to commercial fishing. In all about 30 stream or river systems have been open to commercial fishing at some time or other since 1900. At pres- ent, there are only seven such rivers on which commercial salmon fishing is permitted. These are the Nehalem, Tillamook, Siletz, Yaquina, Alsea, Siuslaw and Coquille Rivers. In addition, there are two other areas, Netarts Bay and Sandlake, where small chum salmon fisheries are permitted. As early as 1878 closed fishing seasons were applied to the coastal river sal- mon fisheries. In 1878 a law was enacted prohibiting commercial fishing be- tween sunset Saturday and sunset Sunday. This continued in force until 1891 when, in addition to this one closed day per week, a blanket regulation was enacted prohibiting commercial fishing from November 15 until April 1 on all coastal streams. These regulations, with few exceptions, were in effect until 1901. Gradually the rivers came to be considered in groups or individually and various closed seasons were devised and revised for particular rivers and groups of rivers, depending on the species of salmon present. In general, the number of days open to commercial fishing has been progressively restricted. In the early days commercial fishing was permitted the entire length of the rivers. For the most part, even then, the majority of the fishery was confined to the tidewater reaches of the rivers. In the large rivers, however, such as the Umpqua and Rogue, fishing was carried on a considerable distance up the rivers. Gradually deadlines were established beyond which no fishing was permitted, and the areas available to commercial fishing have been repeatedly reduced. At the same time that the various rivers were being withdrawn from com- mercial fishing, the fishing area reduced, and the seasons shortened, restrictions on gear were also placed in effect. At the inception of these fisheries, any gear was permitted. In 1891, fixed gear such as traps, setnets, and weirs was restricted to only one-third of the distance across the breadth of any stream. In 1901 such fixed gear, except setnets, was prohibited in the coastal streams. The use of seines for capturing salmon, shad, and sturgeon was prohibited by 1925, and by 1947 the use of setnets for capturing salmon was illegal except for taking chum salmon in Tillamook, Sandlake and Netarts Bays. Also during this interim, various detailed mesh size regulations were developed and applied on specific rivers. Figures 4, 6, 8, and 12 indicate the trend of the restriction of the time and area open to commercial salmon fishing. The days open depict for each year the total of the number of days open on all rivers. The miles represent the sum of the number of miles open each year on all rivers. In years when no dead- 5 lines were named, arbitrary distances based on interviews with old-time fisher- men or on observations of the physical size of the river were decided upon for this analysis. Such estimates were necessary only in some of the very early years. Since for the most part, five specific fisheries have operated on the coastal streams, an attempt has been made to indicate the effect of the regulations on the various fisheries. The spring chinook season has been arbitrarily considered as March 1 to June 30. The fall chinook season has been considered as July 1 to September 1. The silver season and steelhead season have likewise been con- sidered as September 25 to November 30 and December 1 to February 28 re- spectively. It is realized that there is some overlapping of the runs between these arbitrarily designated seasons and that this overlapping may vary in extent from year to year depending on river flow conditions. Since the peak of the chum runs varies considerably in time from year to year depending on water conditions, no attempt has been made to analyze the effects of changes in season on this run. In each fishery only those rivers contributing to the catch of a particular species are considered in the analysis of that species. In many streams the sea- son has been open from March 1 to June 30 although those streams supported no spring chinook runs. Consequently, these streams were not considered and not included in the analysis of spring chinook. With the development of the shad, striped bass, and bait fisheries, open seasons and gear regulations have been devised so that these fisheries would take but few salmonoid species. There- fore, their regulations have not been considered in the analysis.
CHINOOK SALMON Two races of chinook salmon are found in the coastal rivers—the spring run and the fall run. The spring runs of chinook salmon are most abundant in the Rogue and Umpqua Rivers, both of which have their headwaters in the snow fields of the Cascade Mountains. However, they appear to be present to some extent in nearly all of the coastal rivers, and some rivers such as the Trask and Wilson, tributaries of Tillamook Bay, have supported fair numbers of spring chinooks (Hodges 8c Gharrett, 1949) . The spring chinooks enter the rivers from March to June. After gradually progresssing to the cool headwaters of the rivers, they remain in the deep pools through the summer and spawn in the early fall. From preliminary studies it appears that the predominate age at maturity is five years for Umpqua River spring chinooks. Records covering a twelve-year period give an average weight of 21.5 pounds for 11,000 of these fish taken by the Tillamook Bay commercial fishery. The fall chinook salmon are considered as those entering the rivers from July through November. They are found along the entire length of the Oregon coast in the larger stream systems. In the early days of the fishery, sizable catches of chinook salmon were made in July. In more recent years only small numbers of chinook have been present in the rivers in the mid-summer months and the bulk of the fish have been entering the rivers in the late summer and early fall. The fall chinooks spawn soon after entering the rivers and, in general, do not progress as far upstream as the spring run. The average age at maturity appears to be four years. Records covering a period of 18 years and 59,000 fish give an average weight of 25 pounds for the Tillamook Bay fishery. Studies of the early life history of the chinook salmon indicate that the 6 young fish on their journey to the ocean pass through the tidal zones of the rivers from May through September, at which time they range in size from about 2 to 71/2 inches (fork length). Studies to date have indicated no method of dis- tinguishing between the fall and spring chinook in these small downstream migrants. TABLE 1. Total Pack of Canned Salmon on Oregon Coastal Rivers (From Cobb, 1930)
Year Cases Pounds Year Cases Pounds
1877 7,804 546,280 1885 ,, 33,410 2,338,700 1878 26,934 1,885,380 1886 77,547 5,428,290 1879 8,571 599,970 1887 73,996 5,179,720 1880 7,772 544,040 1888 92,863 6,500,410 1881 12,320 862,400 1889 98,800 6,916,000 1882 19,186 1,343,020 1890 47,009 3,290,630 1883 23,156 1,620,920 1891 24,500 1,715,000 1884 27,876 1,951,320