Social and Behavioural Sciences Epsbs E-ISSN: 2357-1330
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`:6!9!7F'.42;!7;a?PF'b2:=F' c'R!3YF'(-,O_@'d967B'H60>M9'34EF'47'4743<969'E49'=48!'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!='1>'=47<'9545!9F' >1:'!G4=03!F'K29964'\K29471C9P6<F'e4:P1CF'c'f:1CP1C4F'(-,O_F'R13478'\A6!936P'c'.!:!96g9P6F'(-,+_F'd$S' \h!C48199F' c' V2?P95!48F' (-,i_F' f:4Y63' \A/42C67F' Q34!9!:F' e4F' c' .1;61F' (-,+_F' e!G6?1' \Rj:!Y" A4=02Y471F' Q2Y=k7"U4:B49F' c' S7B231"f:1E7F' (-,*_F' A/674' \`4::!33' c' %6JP4=0F' (-,]_F' #7864' \V2?P95!48'c'h!C48199F'(-,^_F'R4P69547'\S:9/48F'D2F'c'S9/:4>F'(-,]_'478'15/!:9@' #7'91=!'E1:P9F'65'E49'>1278'5/45'H60>I9'34E'E1:P9';!95'E/!7'9528<67B'1;J!?59'869567B269/!8'715';<' 48=67695:456C!F';25';<'>27?561743';12784:6!9'\U!7!:6F'(-,i_@'./!'Z:47P"96Y!['0455!:7'69'29!8'E/!7'4743<Y67B' 5/!'8695:6;25617'1>'715'173<'5/!'0102345617F';25'4391'15/!:'6786?451:9F'>1:'!G4=03!F'!=031<=!75'\.9!P!:69F' (-,]_F'>6:=9'\f!!F'K6??4;176F'c'$?/64C1F'(-,+_F'!5?@' ' "#1#! 23/%,45/'&%!5++,)567%.!/)!5..%..'48!/7%!0%8,%%!)*!953546%!)*!/7%!+)+-35/')4!0'./,'9-/')4! .:./%;! S9'47'400:14?/'51':!C!4367B'5/!'9045643';4347?!'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!=F'715'173<'H60>I9' 34E'?47';!'40036!8F';25'4391'5/!'V1:!75Y'?2:C!F'Q676'?1!>>6?6!75'\`4::!33'c'%6JP4=0F'(-,]_F'5/!'D!:>6784/3" D6:9?/=47'678!GF'5/!'?43?23456179'1>'A/:695433!:F'V19?/F'!5?@'H60>I9'34E'?47';!'29!8'67'?1=;6745617'E65/' 15/!:'9045643'0455!:79F'>1:'!G4=03!F'5/!'869547?!';!5E!!7'?656!9'\Q17Yk3!Y"U43F'(-,]_@''' ''' ! 251 !""#$%&&'()*(+,&-.*-/0./&1#$2$*3.3.*.0*435 6(++1$#(7')7,589"!(+%5:*5;*5<=>?(>5 @1?1A")(75=7'5#11+B+1>)1C597'1+5+1$#(7$)2)?)"D5(E5"!15F+,=7)G)7,56(HH)""115(E5"!15A(7E1+17A155 1I@@J%534/KB-44.5 ! CA! 5,/60+7'#*-*+7+)*' 1#"#! $%.%5,67!7:+)/7%.'.! ./!'/<015/!969'1>'5/!'9528<'69'5/!'?177!?5617';!5E!!7'5/!'04?!'1>'8!C!310=!75'1>'5/!':!B617'478' 5/!';4347?!'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!=@'./!'477243'B:1E5/':45!'1>'QKR'\Q:199'K!B61743'R:182?5_' 0!:'?40654'45'5/!'0:6?!9'1>'5/!'0:!C6129'<!4:'69'29!8'49'47'6786?451:'?/4:4?5!:6Y67B'5/!'!?171=<'1>'5/!':!B617@' ./!'H60>I9'?1!>>6?6!75'69'29!8'51'?/4:4?5!:6Y!'5/!'8!B:!!'1>';4347?!'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!=@' ./!'?17?!75:45617'1>'5/!'0102345617'?47'/4C!';15/'019656C!'478'7!B456C!'!>>!?59@'`1:'!G4=03!F'E65/' ?17?!75:45617F' 47' 4BB31=!:45617' !>>!?5' 1??2:9F' E/6?/' 4??!3!:45!9' 8!C!310=!75' ?1=04:!8' 51' 4' 276>1:=' 8695:6;25617' 1>' 5/!' 0102345617@' D1E!C!:F' !G?!996C!' ?17?!75:45617' ?47' 3!48' 51' 5/!' !=!:B!7?!' 1>' 4' 4BB31=!:45617' 869!?171=6!9F' E/6?/' 69' 5/!' 1001965!' 1>' 5/!' 4BB31=!:45617' !>>!?5F' E/6?/' E633' 2356=45!3<' 278!:=67!'5/!'?1=0!5656C!'48C4754B!9'1C!:'5/!'!C!7'8695:6;25617'1>'5/!'0102345617@'W>'?12:9!F'5/!';4347?!' 1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!='81!9'715'8!5!:=67!'5/!'8!C!310=!75'1>'5/!':!B617';<',--NF';!?429!' 5/!:!'4:!'=47<'15/!:'>4?51:9@'#7'48865617F'5/!'8!B:!!'1>'67>32!7?!'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!='69' 82!'51'5/!'B!1B:40/6?43'478'!?171=6?'?177!?56C65<'1>'5/!'9!553!=!759'E65/67'5/69'9<95!=@' ' 1#1#! </-0:!2..-;+/')4.! ./!'>1331E67B'4992=056179'E!:!'=48!'49'04:5'1>'5/!'9528<&' ,_! A656!9' 1:' 4715/!:' 9!553!=!759' 4:!' 292433<' 4??!05!8' 49' !3!=!759' 1>' 4' 0102345617' 8695:6;25617' 9<95!=@' #7' 5/69' 9528<F' 6795!48' 1>' 9!553!=!759F' 31?43' 48=67695:456C!' 2765' \E/6?/' ?433!8' =276?6043656!9_' 1>' 5/!' >6:95' 3!C!3' \5/!<' 4:!' 715' 67?328!8' 67' 15/!:' =276?6043656!9_' E!:!' 67C!956B45!8&' 2:;47' 8695:6?59' 478' =276?6043' 4:!49@' b65/67' =276?6043' 4:!49' 5/!:!' 4:!' 9!C!:43' 31E!:"3!C!3'=276?6043656!9'\!@B@'2:;47'9!553!=!759F':2:43'9!553!=!759_@'#7'5/69'9528<F'92?/'4'/6B/' 3!C!3'1>'8!5463'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!='E49'715'?4::6!8'125F'?17>6767B'659!3>'51'>6:95" 3!C!3'=276?6043656!9@' (_! e276?6043656!9' E!:!' ?17968!:!8' E65/67' 5/!6:' 48=67695:456C!' ;12784:6!9@' D1E!C!:F' 67' :!4365<F' 91=!'48=67695:456C!'27659'>1:='4'967B3!'91?61"!?171=6?'9<95!=F'5/!6:';2635"20'5!::651:6!9'4:!' ?1=;67!8F'49'4':!9235'1>'E/6?/'47'4BB31=!:45617'69'>1:=!8@'./!:!>1:!F'65'E1238';!'=1:!'31B6?43' 51' ?17968!:' 91=!' 675!B:45!8' =276?6043656!9' 49' 4' 967B3!' =276?604365<' \49' 47' 4BB31=!:45617_@' D1E!C!:F'67'K29964'5/!:!'4:!'71'95456956?9'17'4BB31=!:456179@' )_! S9'47'6786?451:'?/4:4?5!:6Y67B'5/!'8!C!310=!75'1>'5/!':!B617F'5/!'477243'B:1E5/':45!'1>'QKR' 0!:'?40654'45'5/!'0:6?!9'1>'5/!'0:!C6129'<!4:'E49'54P!7@'S7'435!:7456C!'6786?451:'?1238';!'34;1:' 0:182?56C65<F'4C!:4B!'=175/3<'E4B!9F'!5?@' ''' DA! E+8+-,1='FB+8*./)8' ./!'9528<'019!8'5/!'>1331E67B'l2!956179&' ,_' h1!9' 5/!' 8!B:!!' 1>' ;4347?!' 1>' 5/!' 0102345617' 8695:6;25617' 9<95!=' 4>>!?5' 5/!' 04?!' 1>' 8!C!310=!75'1>'5/!':!B617m' (_'#>'5/!'8!B:!!'1>';4347?!'1>'5/!'0102345617'8695:6;25617'9<95!='/49'47'!>>!?5F'69'65'019656C!'1:' 7!B456C!m' 252 ! !""#$%&&'()*(+,&-.*-/0./&1#$2$*3.3.*.0*435 6(++1$#(7')7,589"!(+%5:*5;*5<=>?(>5 @1?1A")(75=7'5#11+B+1>)1C597'1+5+1$#(7$)2)?)"D5(E5"!15F+,=7)G)7,56(HH)""115(E5"!15A(7E1+17A155 1I@@J%534/KB-44.5 ! GA! 5B,"/8+'/2'*=+'#*B?>' #7'4??1:847?!'E65/'5/!':!9!4:?/'l2!956179F'5/!'>1331E67B'B1439'E!:!'9!5&' ,_' `678' 5/!' 8!C645617' 1>' 5/!' :!B617M9' 0102345617'