DOCSLIB.ORG

Lessons from Kmart D

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Lessons from Kmart D NORTH CAROLINA LAW REVIEW Volume 74 | Number 4 Article 3 4-1-1996 Corporate Governance and Managerial Incompetence: Lessons from Kmart D. Gordon Smith Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.unc.edu/nclr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation D. G. Smith, Corporate Governance and Managerial Incompetence: Lessons from Kmart, 74 N.C. L. Rev. 1037 (1996). Available at: http://scholarship.law.unc.edu/nclr/vol74/iss4/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Carolina Law Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in North Carolina Law Review by an authorized administrator of Carolina Law Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND MANAGERIAL INCOMPETENCE: LESSONS FROM KMART D. GORDON SMIm Modern corporategovernance scholars often extol an activist role by institutional investors in directing corporate activity. Widely viewed as a solution to the "collective action" problems that inhibit such activism by individual investors, institutional investors are praised for adding value to corporationsthrough their participationin the decisionmaking process. The ouster of Joseph Antonini as Chief Executive Officer of Kmart Corporation in 1995 might be taken as a vindication of this view, because substantialevidence indicates that institutionalinvestors played a crucial role in influencing Kmart's board of directors to remove him. In this Article, Professor Gordon Smith challenges this potential reading of the events at Kmart. Professor Smith poses the fundamental question of whether institutionalinvestor activism designed to address perceived incompetence among corporate managers consistently adds value to corporations in which such activism is present. ProfessorSmith analyzes the effect of internal and external forces on managers, particularly on Antonini. and Kmart's directors, and derives two fundamental lessons: (1) External constraints are ineffective in solving managerial incompetence; and (2) Investor activism will often be counterproductive because it destroys the value of centralized decisionmaking. INTRODUCTION .......................................1038 L JOE ANTONINI'S KMART ........................... 1046 II. KMART'S CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PROBLEM AND How THE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE SYSTEM DEALT WITH IT . 1057 A. Kmart's Corporate Governance Problem ........... 1059 * Assistant Professor of Law, Northwestern School of Law of Lewis & Clark College. Thanks to Brian Blum, Jack Bogdanski, Ed Brunet, Jennifer Johnson, Laura Lin, and Doug Newell for helpful comments and to Andrew Ognall and Lee Street for excellent research assistance. Special thanks to Randall Thomas, not only for useful comments on this Article, but for consistently good advice and encouragement generally. This Article is dedicated to Sue Smith. 1038 NORTH CAROLINA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 74 B. External Constraints on ManagerialBehavior ........ 1062 1. Capital Markets .......................... 1062 2. Market for Corporate Control ............... 1072 3. Product Markets .......................... 1075 4. Managerial Labor Markets .................. 1079 C. Internal Constraints on ManagerialBehavior ........ 1081 1. Board of Directors ........................ 1082 a. Separation of CEO and Chairman Positions .. 1083 b. Outside Directors ...................... 1084 c. Executive Compensation ................ 1088 d. Dividend Policy ....................... 1092 e. Debt Policy .......................... 1096 2. Shareholders ............................. 1099 a. Shareholder Voting .................... 1100 b. Shareholder Suits ...................... 1102 c. Institutional Investor Activism ............ 1104 III. Two FUNDAMENTAL LESSONS FROM KMART .......... 1110 A. Lesson #1: External Constraints Will Not Efficiently Solve ManagerialIncompetence .......... 1113 B. Lesson #2: InstitutionalInvestors Will Not Efficiently Solve ManagerialIncompetence .......... 1115 1. Categories of Shareholder Participation ........ 1117 2. The Value of Centralized Decisionmaking ....... 1119 3. A Theory of Representation for Corporate Shareholders ............................. 1122 C. Policy Implications .......................... 1128 1. Encouraging Board Composition Participation ... 1129 2. Discouraging Policy Participation ............. 1134 IV. CONCLUSION ................................... 1137 INTRODUCTION Three days after Joseph Antonini was forced to resign as Chief Executive Officer of Kmart Corporation, The Wall Street Journalran a front-page story with the headline: "How Wal-Mart Outdid a Once- Touted Kmart in Discount-Store Race."' The story compared Antonini unfavorably with Sam Walton, founder of Kmart-nemesis Wal-Mart Stores Inc., and declared Wal-Mart the victor in the 1. Christina Duff & Bob Ortega, How Wal-Mart Outdid A Once-Touted Kmart In Discount-Store Race, WALL ST. J., Mar. 24, 1995, at Al. 1996] MANAGERIAL INCOMPETENCE 1039 discount store competition. Although competition from Wal-Mart was instrumental in provoking Antonini's ouster, the direct impetus for his ouster was Kmart's shareholders. In June 1994, nine months before Antonini resigned, Kmart's shareholders defeated a proposal endorsed by Kmart's board of directors to raise money for the renovation of Kmart's discount stores through the sale of "targeted stock"-Kmart common stock with returns tied to the performance of Kmart's specialty retail subsidiaries, such as OfficeMax office supply stores and Borders and Waldenbooks book stores. The most vocal opponents of the targeted stock proposal claimed that Antonini was distracted by specialty retailing and that, instead of selling targeted stock, Kmart should sell its specialty retailing subsidiaries outright and focus on Kmart's core business, discount retailing. TIhe shareholder vote was quickly recognized by observers as "one of the most astonishing investor rebellions in corporate history."2 In response to the shareholder vote, Antonini agreed to adopt the strategy advocated by dissident shareholders and announced plans to sell the specialty retail subsidiaries.3 Although the shareholder vote appeared to give directors "a clear mandate to shake up top management,"4 several candidates the board considered to replace Antonini reportedly were nervous about the prospect of working under Antonini without some assurance about when they would assume leadership of the company.' Six months after the shareholder vote, having failed to find a successor for Antonini and still facing pressure from shareholders, Kmart's board of directors removed Antonini as Chairman of the Board and named Donald Perkins-a respected former chairman of Jewel Companies, Inc.-as his tem- porary successor.6 Commenting on Antonini's removal as Chairman, 2. David Woodruff & Judith H. Dobrzynski, Revolt? What Revolt?: Kmart Sticks to Its TurnaroundPlan, Bus. WK., June 20, 1994, at 42; see also Bankers Undaunted By 'No' On Kmart Targeted Stock, GOING PUB.: THE IPO REP., June 13, 1994, at 1, 5 [hereinafter Bankers Undaunted] (quoting a Kmart investment banker as saying, "This was one of the great surprises of all time"); George White, Kmart Gets Red Light on Specialty Stock Plan Retailing: ShareholdersRebuke Management's Proposal to Raise $600 Million by Selling Shares in Other Units, L.A. TIMEs, June 4, 1994, at D1, D2 (quoting Kurt Barnard, a New York-based retail economist: "This is an extraordinary slap to the face of Kmart's management .... It's a new chapter in shareholder relations"). 3. See infra notes 99-105 and accompanying text. 4. Joann S. Lublin & Christina Duff, How Do You Fire a CEO? Very, Very Slowly, WALL ST. J., Jan. 20, 1995, at B1, B2. 5. Christina Duff & Joann S. Lublin, Kmart Board Ousts Antonini as Chairman, WALL ST. J., Jan. 18, 1995, at A3; Ellen Neuborne, Kmart chief Antonini calls it quits, USA TODAY, Mar. 22, 1995, at lB. 6. Duff & Lublin, supra note 5, at A3. 1040 NORTH CAROLINA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 74 James Severance of the State of Wisconsin Investment Board (SWIB), a public pension fund and Antonini's most visible antagonist, said, "The board was too passive. If this represents the board asserting itsel, then that's good news."7 Antonini's removal as Chairman, however, appears to have been less a signal of the board's resolve than an attempt to ward off shareholder pressure. Perkins later admitted that he had hoped his appointment as Chairman would buy Antonini some time as CEO.8 And in February the board of directors appeared to have given up the search to replace Antonini as CEO.9 But Kmart's shareholders were restless. Perkins commented that, after being named Chairman, he had "a number of discussions" with shareholders about Antonini's continued role with the company.'" SWIB's Severance promised, "We are going to continue to keep Joe's and the board's feet to the fire."" On March 20, major Kmart shareholders met with Perkins. Although Perkins expressed confidence in Antonini, the shareholders' message was simple: "Joe has to go."'12 The next day, Kmart's board of directors unanimously agreed to ask Antonini to resign. 3 One view of the events at Kmart holds that this is corporate governance at its best: Institutional investors dissatisfied with the performance of a company in which they had invested took aggressive action to change the company's strategic course and replaced the CEO. Much has been written about the potential contribution of institutional investors to the governance of American corporations, 4 7. Id.Trading in Kmart common stock
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Retail Sector on Long Island Overlooked… Undervalued… Essential!
    The Retail Sector on Long Island Overlooked… Undervalued… Essential! A Preliminary Report from the Long Island Business Council May 2021 Long Island “ L I ” The Sign of Success 2 | The Retail Sector on Long Island: Overlooked, Undervalued, Essential! Long Island Business Council Mission Statement The Long Island Business Council (LIBC) is a collaborative organization working to advocate for and assist the business community and related stakeholders. LIBC will create an open dialogue with key stakeholder groups and individuals to foster solutions to regional and local economic challenges. LIBC will serve as a community-focused enterprise that will work with strategic partners in government, business, education, nonprofit and civic sectors to foster a vibrant business climate, sustainable economic growth and an inclusive and shared prosperity that advances business attraction, creation, retention and expansion; and enhances: • Access to relevant markets (local, regional, national, global); • Access to a qualified workforce (credentialed workforce; responsive education & training); • Access to business/economic resources; • Access to and expansion of the regional supply chain; • A culture of innovation; • Commitment to best practices and ethical operations; • Adaptability, resiliency and diversity of regional markets to respond to emerging trends; • Navigability of the regulatory environment; • Availability of supportive infrastructure; • An attractive regional quality of life © 2021 LONG ISLAND BUSINESS COUNCIL (516) 794-2510 [email protected]
    [Show full text]
  • What Went Wrong with Kmart?
    What Went Wrong With Kmart? An Honors Thesis (HONRS 499) by Jacqueline Matyk Thesis Advisor Dr. Mark Myring Ball State University Muncie, Indiana December 2003 Graduation: December 21, 2003 Table of Contents Abstract. ........... ..................................................... 3 Introduction ................................................................................ 4 History ofKnlart .......................................................................... 4 Overview ofKnlart ................................... .................................. 6 Kmart's Problems That Led to Bankruptcy ....... ............... 6 Major Troubles in 2001 .................................................................. 7 2002 and Bankruptcy ..................................................................... 9 Anonymous Letters Lead to Stewardship Review .................................... 9 Emergence from Bankruptcy........................................................... 12 Charles Conaway's Role ................................................................ 14 The Case Against Enio Montini and Joseph Hofmeister ........................... 17 Conclusion.. ............................................................................. 19 Works Cited ............................................................................. 20 2 Abstract This paper provides an in depth look at Krnart Corporation. I will discuss how the company began its operations as a small five and dime store in Michigan and grew into one of the nation's largest retailers.
    [Show full text]
  • The SEC and the Failure of Federal, Takeover Regulation
    Florida State University Law Review Volume 34 Issue 2 Article 2 2007 The SEC and the Failure of Federal, Takeover Regulation Steven M. Davidoff [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.law.fsu.edu/lr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Steven M. Davidoff, The SEC and the Failure of Federal, Takeover Regulation, 34 Fla. St. U. L. Rev. (2007) . https://ir.law.fsu.edu/lr/vol34/iss2/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Florida State University Law Review by an authorized editor of Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW THE SEC AND THE FAILURE OF FEDERAL TAKEOVER REGULATION Steven M. Davidoff VOLUME 34 WINTER 2007 NUMBER 2 Recommended citation: Steven M. Davidoff, The SEC and the Failure of Federal Takeover Regulation, 34 FLA. ST. U. L. REV. 211 (2007). THE SEC AND THE FAILURE OF FEDERAL TAKEOVER REGULATION STEVEN M. DAVIDOFF* I. INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................. 211 II. THE GOLDEN AGE OF FEDERAL TAKEOVER REGULATION.................................. 215 A. The Williams Act (the 1960s) ..................................................................... 215 B. Going-Privates (the 1970s)......................................................................... 219 C. Hostile Takeovers (the 1980s)..................................................................... 224 1. SEC Legislative
    [Show full text]
  • Faulkner's Wake: the Emergence of Literary Oxford
    University of Mississippi eGrove Honors College (Sally McDonnell Barksdale Honors Theses Honors College) 2004 Faulkner's Wake: The Emergence of Literary Oxford John Louis Fuller Follow this and additional works at: https://egrove.olemiss.edu/hon_thesis Recommended Citation Fuller, John Louis, "Faulkner's Wake: The Emergence of Literary Oxford" (2004). Honors Theses. 2005. https://egrove.olemiss.edu/hon_thesis/2005 This Undergraduate Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Honors College (Sally McDonnell Barksdale Honors College) at eGrove. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of eGrove. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Faulkner’s Wake: The Emergence of Literary Oxford Bv John L. Fuller A thesis submitted to the faculty of The University of Mississippi in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Sally McDonnell Barksdale Honors College. Oxford April 2005 Advisor; Dr. Judson D. Wafson -7 ■ / ^—- Reader: Dr. Benjamin F. Fisher y. Reader: Dr. Andrew P. D^rffms Copyright © by John L. Fuller All Rights Reserved 1 For my parents Contents Abstract 5 I The Beginnings 9 (4Tell About the South 18 A Literary Awakening 25 II If You Build It, They Will Come 35 An Interview with Pochard Howorth 44Football, Faulkner, and Friends 57 An Interview with Barry Hannah Advancing Oxford’s Message 75 An Interview with Ann J. Abadie Oxford Tom 99 An Interview with Tom Franklin III Literary Grounds 117 Works cited 120 Abstract The genesis of this project was a commercial I saw on television advertising the University of Mississippi. “Is it the words that capture a place, or the place that captures the words?” noted actor and Mississippi native Morgan Freeman asked.
    [Show full text]
  • Scrip Order Form
    St. Thomas Aquinas SCRIP ORDER FORM Thank you! Your support is greatly appreciated! Please remember that we can sell only the amounts listed on the order form. Name:_______________________________________________Phone:___________________Date:_______________ Check# :_________________Amount:__________________ * Please make checks payable to: St. Thomas Aquinas * Filled by__________NEEDS:________________________________________________________________________ Retailer Profit Card Qty. Total Retailer Profit Card Qty. Total (c.o.a.) = certificate on account for Amount (c.o.a.) = certificate on for Amount school account school $5.00 $100 Claire’s $0.90 $10 All Seasons Gutter/New All Seasons Gutter/Topper $10.00 $100 Cold Stone $0.80 $10 Creamery American Eagle Outfitters $2.00 $25 Courtyard/Marriott $6.00 $50 Applebees $2.00 $25 Critter $0.50 $10 Nation(Dyvig’s) Arby’s $0.80 $10 Barnes & Noble/B. Dalton $1.00 $10 Derry Auto (c.o.a.) $1.00 $25 Barnes & Noble/B. Dalton $2.50 $25 Derry Auto (c.o.a.) $2.50 $50 Bath and Body Works $1.30 $10 Derry Auto (c.o.a.) $5.00 $100 Bath and Body Works $3.25 $25 Dillard’s $2.25 $25 Bed, Bath and Beyond $1.75 $25 Dress Barn $2.00 $25 Best Buy $0.50 $25 Express $2.50 $25 Best Buy $2.00 $100 Fareway $0.50 $25 Big Time Cinema (Fridley’s) $1.00 $10 Fareway $1.00 $50 Borders/Waldenbooks $0.90 $10 Fareway $2.00 $100 Borders/Waldenbooks $2.25 $25 Fairfield Inn/Marriott $6.00 $50 Build-A-Bear $2.00 $25 Fazoli’s $1.75 $25 Burger King $0.50 $10 Finish Line $2.50 $25 Cabela’s $3.25 $25 Flower Cart (c.o.a.) $1.25 $25 Carlos O’Kelly $0.90 $10 Foot Locker $2.25 $25 Casey’s $0.30 $10 Fuhs Pastry $1.00 $10 Casey’s $0.75 $25 Gap/Old $2.25 $25 Navy/Banana Republic Casey’s $1.50 $50 GameStop $0.75 $25 Cheesecake Factory $1.25 $25 Gerber’s (c.o.a.) $2.50 $50 Chili’s/Macaroni Grill/On the $2.75 $25 Gerber’s (c.o.a.) $5.00 $100 Boarder Chuck E.
    [Show full text]
  • We Help Our Friends Grow We Want to Help You Make More Meaningful Connections Through: PRINT Online • Social Media Partnerships • Email Marketing
    2021 Media Kit Inspirational Art, Crafts & Lifestyle Magazines We Help Our Friends Grow We want to help you make more meaningful connections through: PRINT Online • Social Media Partnerships • Email Marketing A Somerset Holiday Art Journaling Art Quilting Studio Belle Armoire Jewelry GreenCraft In Her Studio Mingle Somerset Studio Willow and Sage & Special Editions 2 About the Publisher When it comes to the art of crafting, no one does it better than Stampington & Company. — Mr. Magazine™ Samir Husni Since 1994, Stampington & Company has been a Leading Source of Information and Inspiration for Artists and Crafts Lovers, Storytellers, and Photographers Around the World Known for its stunning full-color photography and step-by-step instructions, the company’s magazines provide a forum for both professional artists and hobbyists looking to share their beautiful handmade creations, tips, and techniques with one another. Our community loves to immerse themselves in our magazines. These magazines are meant to be curled up with, kept in libraries as a resource to reference, and to share years later with friends and family. The enthusiasm of our readers doesn’t end here. Our community loves to blog and post pictures across social media from a wide range of channels, showing off our exclusive stories and soul-stirring photography. Our Social Profile 100K+ Facebook fans 94K+ Instagram followers 2.7m Pinterest monthly viewers 25K+ Twitter followers Media Kit 3 What’s Inside This media kit contains a wealth of information. Take a moment to read each of our publication descriptions and audience information to find the perfect advertising venue for your products.
    [Show full text]
  • Rethinking the Federal Securities Laws
    Florida International University College of Law eCollections Faculty Publications Faculty Scholarship 2003 Accountants Make Miserable Policemen: Rethinking the Federal Securities Laws Jerry W. Markham Florida International University College of Law Follow this and additional works at: https://ecollections.law.fiu.edu/faculty_publications Part of the Banking and Finance Law Commons Recommended Citation Jerry W. Markham, Accountants Make Miserable Policemen: Rethinking the Federal Securities Laws, 28 N.C.J. Int'l L. & Com. Reg. 725, 812 (2003). This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at eCollections. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of eCollections. For more information, please contact [email protected]. +(,121/,1( Citation: Jerry W. Markham, Accountants Make Miserable Policemen: Rethinking the Federal Securities Laws, 28 N.C.J. Int'l L. & Com. Reg. 725 (2003) Provided by: FIU College of Law Content downloaded/printed from HeinOnline Tue May 1 11:26:02 2018 -- Your use of this HeinOnline PDF indicates your acceptance of HeinOnline's Terms and Conditions of the license agreement available at https://heinonline.org/HOL/License -- The search text of this PDF is generated from uncorrected OCR text. -- To obtain permission to use this article beyond the scope of your HeinOnline license, please use: Copyright Information Use QR Code reader to send PDF to your smartphone or tablet device Accountants Make Miserable Policemen: Rethinking the Federal
    [Show full text]
  • Alemany, Ricard
    1 As I finished my first year of the MBA, one of my mentor’s advice was to read. Used to reading case studies, the question really was “what books should I read?”. After two years at IESE, and experiencing first hand the breadth and depth of knowledge shared from IESE Faculty, I thought the most valuable advice on what to read was right in front of me. How could I continue to learn from professors beyond the classroom, once the MBA path comes to an end. I thought a reading list from IESE Faculty could serve not just me, but my whole class and perhaps future IESE graduates, as a guide to continue learning. Therefore, I asked professors for book recommendations that would inspire and guide us in our future endeavors. The document that follows is the result of it. I hope you find this document insightful and useful. I would like to thank all the participating professors for their recommendations and participation in the project and for sharing their knowledge not only in class, but also beyond it. Additionally, I am grateful for the help and patience of Eduardo Pérez (IESE MBA 2019), the creative genius, who has given shape of the document that I here present to you. Antonio Recio Sanromán. " Our brain is like our body: it needs exercise. If you don’t read at least one good book every month, you will lose most of the good intellectual and analytical shape you got during the MBA reading every day case after case… So, don’t stop reading.
    [Show full text]
  • The New Investor Tom C.W
    The New Investor Tom C.W. Lin EVIEW R ABSTRACT A sea change is happening in finance. Machines appear to be on the rise and humans on LA LAW LA LAW the decline. Human endeavors have become unmanned endeavors. Human thought and UC human deliberation have been replaced by computerized analysis and mathematical models. Technological advances have made finance faster, larger, more global, more interconnected, and less human. Modern finance is becoming an industry in which the main players are no longer entirely human. Instead, the key players are now cyborgs: part machine, part human. Modern finance is transforming into what this Article calls cyborg finance. This Article offers one of the first broad, descriptive, and normative examinations of this sea change and its wide-ranging effects on law, society, and finance. The Article begins by placing the rise of artificial intelligence and computerization in finance within a larger social context. Next, it explores the evolution and birth of a new investor paradigm in law precipitated by that rise. This Article then identifies and addresses regulatory dangers, challenges, and consequences tied to the increasing reliance on artificial intelligence and computers. Specifically, it warns of emerging financial threats in cyberspace, examines new systemic risks linked to speed and connectivity, studies law’s capacity to govern this evolving financial landscape, and explores the growing resource asymmetries in finance. Finally, drawing on themes from the legal discourse about the choice between rules and standards, this Article closes with a defense of humans in an uncertain financial world in which machines continue to rise, and it asserts that smarter humans working with smart machines possess the key to better returns and better futures.
    [Show full text]
  • 33124462-MIT.Pdf
    RELATIONS BETWEEN THE TRADING AREA POPULATION OF DIFERF TYPES OF SHOPPIRG CENTRS by Edwin Dreyfus Abrams B.A. in Political Science, Boston University (1957) Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master in City Planning at the Massachusett8 Institute of Technology June 1962 Edwin D. Abrams Thas Supervisor T " ,NAi Head,kartment of City and Regional Planning Room 14-0551 77 Massachusetts Avenue Cambridge, MA 02139 Ph: 617.253.2800 MITLibries Email: [email protected] Document Services http://Iibraries.mit.edu/docs DISCLAIMER OF QUALITY Due to the condition of the original material, there are unavoidable flaws in this reproduction. We have made every effort possible to provide you with the best copy available. If you are dissatisfied with this product and find it unusable, please contact Document Services as soon as possible. Thank you. The images contained in this document are of the best quality available. ACKNOW4 DGEMENTS In a Thesis the student autncr should be skeptical of naming the professors who were of aid, due to the fear that the contents might incriminate those mentioned. Nevertheless, while accepting the total responsibility for the be conent of this Thesis, it would /both ungracious and unkind of me not to thank Professors Fleisher and Haward for the friendship and thoughtfulness which they have repeatedly extended in y behalf. Although they too may trish to disassociate themselves, I would like very much to thank my fellow students whoin many a time of crisis, willing y answered their telephones and came to my aid. ABSTRACT Relations between the Trading Area Population of Different Types of Shoping Centers by Edwin Dreyfus Abrams The purpose of this Thesis is to inquire into the possible relation that may exist between the quality of a shopping center and the characteristics of the people living in proximity thereto.
    [Show full text]
  • A Business Lawyer's Bibliography: Books Every Dealmaker Should Read
    585 A Business Lawyer’s Bibliography: Books Every Dealmaker Should Read Robert C. Illig Introduction There exists today in America’s libraries and bookstores a superb if underappreciated resource for those interested in teaching or learning about business law. Academic historians and contemporary financial journalists have amassed a huge and varied collection of books that tell the story of how, why and for whom our modern business world operates. For those not currently on the front line of legal practice, these books offer a quick and meaningful way in. They help the reader obtain something not included in the typical three-year tour of the law school classroom—a sense of the context of our practice. Although the typical law school curriculum places an appropriately heavy emphasis on theory and doctrine, the importance of a solid grounding in context should not be underestimated. The best business lawyers provide not only legal analysis and deal execution. We offer wisdom and counsel. When we cast ourselves in the role of technocrats, as Ronald Gilson would have us do, we allow our advice to be defined downward and ultimately commoditized.1 Yet the best of us strive to be much more than legal engineers, and our advice much more than a mere commodity. When we master context, we rise to the level of counselors—purveyors of judgment, caution and insight. The question, then, for young attorneys or those who lack experience in a particular field is how best to attain the prudence and judgment that are the promise of our profession. For some, insight is gained through youthful immersion in a family business or other enterprise or experience.
    [Show full text]
  • An Inventory of Its Dairy Trade Hearing and Docket Files
    MINNESOTA HISTORICAL SOCIETY Minnesota State Archives AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT An Inventory of Its Dairy Trade Hearing and Docket Files OVERVIEW OF THE RECORDS Agency: Minnesota. Dept. of Agriculture. Series Title: Dairy trade hearing and docket files. Dates: [ca. 1957] – 1976 (bulk 1957-1976). Abstract: Hearing and docket files documenting the department’s role in regulating unfair trade practices in the dairy products industry, particularly the under pricing of products. Quantity: 12.1 cu. ft. (11 boxes and 2 partial boxes). Location: See Detailed Description section for box locations. SCOPE AND CONTENTS OF THE RECORDS In 1961, the administration of the Dairy Industry Unfair Trade Practices Act of 1957 was transferred from the Department of Business Development to the Agriculture Department. The purpose of the law was to stabilize prices on selected dairy products and to prevent unfair trade practices in marketing those products. It required manufacturers, wholesalers, and distributors of milk and selected dairy products to file schedules of prices at which sales would be made wholesale to retailers and governed unfair trade practices, particularly the under pricing of products. The hearings files (ca. 1960s-1976, bulk 1957-1961) consist mainly of hearing transcripts, most often with company employees; while the docket files (ca. 1957-1976) contain transcripts, assorted legal documents, and facilitative correspondence. Mainly dealing with under pricing claims, the files cover wholesalers and retailers statewide and a few in neighboring states. ARRANGEMENT OF THE RECORDS Arranged in two series: a set of numerical hearings files (ca. 1960s – 1964) and a set of docket files (ca. 1957-1976). The latter is divided into alphabetical (ca.
    [Show full text]