DOCSLIB.ORG

Pennon Group and Bournemouth Water Final Report

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Pennon Group and Bournemouth Water Final Report Pennon Group and Bournemouth Water A report on the completed acquisition by Pennon Group plc of Bournemouth Water Investments Limited 5 November 2015 © Crown copyright 2015 You may reuse this information (not including logos) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government- licence/ or write to the Information Policy Team, The National Archives, Kew, London TW9 4DU, or email: [email protected]. Website: www.gov.uk/cma Members of the Competition and Markets Authority who conducted this inquiry Simon Polito (Chair of the Group) Sarah Chambers Andrew Popham Jayne Scott Chief Executive of the Competition and Markets Authority Alex Chisholm The Competition and Markets Authority has excluded from this published version of the report information which the Inquiry Group considers should be excluded having regard to the three considerations set out in section 244 of the Enterprise Act 2002 (specified information: considerations relevant to disclosure). The omissions are indicated by []. Contents Page Summary .................................................................................................................... 3 Findings .................................................................................................................... 16 1. The reference ..................................................................................................... 16 2. Industry background ........................................................................................... 16 3. Water regulation and key bodies......................................................................... 21 Regulatory framework and approach .................................................................. 21 Wholesale price controls ............................................................................... 22 Retail price controls ....................................................................................... 24 Wholesale quality of service: outcome delivery incentives ............................ 25 Retail quality of service: Service incentive mechanism ................................. 26 Planned regulatory reforms ................................................................................. 27 Key regulatory and industry bodies ..................................................................... 29 Ofwat ............................................................................................................. 29 Drinking Water Inspectorate .......................................................................... 31 Environment Agency ..................................................................................... 31 Consumer Council for Water ......................................................................... 32 Customer challenge groups ........................................................................... 32 Competition and Markets Authority ................................................................ 33 4. The merger parties .............................................................................................. 33 Pennon ............................................................................................................... 33 SWW ................................................................................................................... 33 Bournemouth Water Limited ............................................................................... 35 5. The merger ......................................................................................................... 37 The transaction ................................................................................................... 37 The rationale ....................................................................................................... 37 Jurisdiction .......................................................................................................... 37 6. Assessment of the impacts of the merger on Ofwat’s ability to make comparisons 39 Ofwat’s approach to assessing the merger ......................................................... 39 CMA’s approach to assessing the merger .......................................................... 40 Wholesale price controls ..................................................................................... 45 How Ofwat uses comparators in wholesale price controls ............................. 45 How a merger might result in adverse impacts .............................................. 45 How a merger might result in adverse impacts: precision effect .................... 47 Pennon’s submissions on the precision effect ............................................... 48 Ofwat’s submissions on the precision effect .................................................. 48 CMA’s analytical approach to the precision effect ......................................... 49 CMA analysis of the precision effect .............................................................. 52 How a merger might result in adverse impacts: benchmarking effect ............ 67 Pennon’s submissions on the benchmark effect............................................ 68 Ofwat’s submissions on the benchmark effect............................................... 70 CMA’s analytical approach to the benchmark effect ...................................... 71 CMA analysis of the benchmark effect .......................................................... 75 Conclusion on wholesale price controls ......................................................... 78 Retail price controls ............................................................................................ 80 How Ofwat uses comparators in retail price controls ..................................... 80 How a merger might result in adverse impacts .............................................. 81 Pennon’s submissions on retail price controls ............................................... 82 1 Ofwat’s submissions on retail price controls .................................................. 83 CMA’s analytical approach to retail price controls ......................................... 83 CMA analysis of retail price controls .............................................................. 85 Conclusion on retail price controls ................................................................. 86 Monitoring and incentivising service quality: outcome delivery incentives .......... 87 How Ofwat uses comparators in monitoring and incentivising service quality through ODIs ................................................................................................ 87 How a merger might result in adverse impacts .............................................. 87 Pennon’s submissions on ODIs ..................................................................... 90 Ofwat’s submissions on ODIs ........................................................................ 90 CMA’s analytical approach to ODIs ............................................................... 91 CMA analysis of ODIs ................................................................................... 95 Conclusions on ODIs ................................................................................... 101 Monitoring and incentivising service quality: service incentive mechanism ...... 103 How Ofwat uses comparators in monitoring and incentivising service quality through the SIM .......................................................................................... 103 How a merger might result in adverse impacts ............................................ 103 Pennon’s submissions on the SIM ............................................................... 103 Ofwat’s submissions on the SIM .................................................................. 104 CMA’s analytical approach to the SIM ......................................................... 105 CMA analysis of the SIM ............................................................................. 107 Conclusion on the SIM ................................................................................ 108 Spreading of best practice ................................................................................ 108 How Ofwat uses comparators in spreading best practice ............................ 108 How a merger might result in adverse impacts ............................................ 109 Ofwat’s submissions on spreading of best practice ..................................... 109 Pennon’s submissions on spreading of best practice .................................. 113 CMA analysis of spreading best practice ..................................................... 114 Conclusion on spreading best practice ........................................................ 115 7. Conclusions on prejudice .................................................................................. 116 Appendices A. Terms of reference and conduct of inquiry B. Current regulatory approach C. Ofwat’s use of comparators and planned reforms D. Impact on the precision of Ofwat’s wholesale cost models E. Impact of the merger on Ofwat’s wholesale benchmarks F. Setting household retail prices G. Outcome delivery incentives H. Monitoring and incentivising service quality: service incentive mechanism Glossary 2 Summary 1. On 8 June 2015 the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) referred the completed acquisition by Pennon Group plc (Pennon)
Load more

Recommended publications
  • South West River Basin District Flood Risk Management Plan 2015 to 2021 Habitats Regulation Assessment
    South West river basin district Flood Risk Management Plan 2015 to 2021 Habitats Regulation Assessment March 2016 Executive summary The Flood Risk Management Plan (FRMP) for the South West River Basin District (RBD) provides an overview of the range of flood risks from different sources across the 9 catchments of the RBD. The RBD catchments are defined in the River Basin Management Plan (RBMP) and based on the natural configuration of bodies of water (rivers, estuaries, lakes etc.). The FRMP provides a range of objectives and programmes of measures identified to address risks from all flood sources. These are drawn from the many risk management authority plans already in place but also include a range of further strategic developments for the FRMP ‘cycle’ period of 2015 to 2021. The total numbers of measures for the South West RBD FRMP are reported under the following types of flood management action: Types of flood management measures % of RBD measures Prevention – e.g. land use policy, relocating people at risk etc. 21 % Protection – e.g. various forms of asset or property-based protection 54% Preparedness – e.g. awareness raising, forecasting and warnings 21% Recovery and review – e.g. the ‘after care’ from flood events 1% Other – any actions not able to be categorised yet 3% The purpose of the HRA is to report on the likely effects of the FRMP on the network of sites that are internationally designated for nature conservation (European sites), and the HRA has been carried out at the level of detail of the plan. Many measures do not have any expected physical effects on the ground, and have been screened out of consideration including most of the measures under the categories of Prevention, Preparedness, Recovery and Review.
    [Show full text]
  • Recreation 2020-21
    Conservation access and recreation 2020-21 wessexwater.co.uk Contents About Wessex Water 1 Our commitment 2 Our duties 2 Our land 3 Delivering our duties 3 Conservation land management 4 A catchment-based approach 10 Engineering and sustainable delivery 12 Eel improvements 13 Invasive non-native species 14 Access and recreation 15 Fishing 17 Partners Programme 18 Water Force 21 Photo: Henley Spiers Henley Photo: Beaver dam – see 'Nature’s engineers' page 7 About Wessex Water Wessex Water is one of 10 regional water and sewerage companies in England and About 80% of the water we supply comes from groundwater sources in Wiltshire Wales. We provide sewerage services to an area of the south west of England that and Dorset. The remaining 20% comes from surface water reservoirs which are includes Dorset, Somerset, Bristol, most of Wiltshire, and parts of Gloucestershire, filled by rainfall and runoff from the catchment. We work in partnership with Hampshire and Devon. Within our region, Bristol Water, Bournemouth Water and organisations and individuals across our region to protect and restore the water Cholderton and District Water Company also supply customers with water. environment as a part of the catchment based approach (CaBA). We work with all the catchment partnerships in the region and host two catchment partnerships, Bristol What area does Wessex Water cover? Avon and Poole Harbour, and co-host the Stour catchment initiative with the Dorset Wildlife Trust. our region our catchments Stroud 8 Cotswold South Gloucestershire Bristol Wessex
    [Show full text]
  • TAUWI Response to Ofcom Consultation
    TELECOMMUNICATION ASSOCIATION OF THE UK WATER INDUSTRY - TAUWI - RESPONSE TO OFCOM’S CONSULTATION On Spectrum Management Strategy Ofcom’s approach to and priorities for spectrum management over the next ten years INTRODUCTION This response is provided by the Telecommunications Association of the UK Water Industry (TAUWI) on behalf of its members: Anglian Water Services Ltd Severn Trent Water Ltd Black Sluice Internal Drainage Board South East Water Ltd Sembcorp Bournemouth Water South Staffordshire Water Bristol Water plc South West Water Services Ltd Cambridge Water plc Southern Water plc Dee Valley Water plc States of Jersey Transport and Technical Natural Resources Wales Services Department Environment Agency Sutton & East Surrey Water plc Essex & Suffolk Water Thames Water Utilities Ltd Hartlepool Water United Utilities Water plc Lindsey Marsh Drainage Board Veolia Water Central Welsh Water Veolia Water East Ltd Northern Ireland Water Ltd Veolia Water South East Ltd Northumbrian Water Ltd Wessex Water Services Ltd Scottish Water Yorkshire Water Services Ltd Atkins Ltd act as the main point of contact for TAUWI members and represent their interests on a range of matters, including responding to strategic consultation documents on their behalf. This response has been circulated for review to each of the 29 member organisations that form TAUWI and therefore negates the need for submissions from individual water companies. The Association was formed in April 2004 and replaces the Telecommunications Advisory Committee (TAC) which for the previous 14 years had acted as the focus for the UK Water Industry in relation to fixed and mobile communications and scanning telemetry from a technical and regulatory aspect.
    [Show full text]
  • Written Evidence Submitted by Pennon/South West Water Pennon Group
    Pennon /South West Water WQR0056 Written evidence submitted by Pennon/South West Water Pennon Group Pennon Group is a FTSE100 company and the owners of South West Water and Bournemouth Water. We provide water and wastewater services to a population of c.1.7 million in Cornwall, Devon and parts of Dorset and Somerset, and water-only services to c.0.5 million in parts of Dorset, Hampshire, and Wiltshire. South West Water sustains 6,000 jobs in the regional economy and, since 1989, has invested more than £7 billion to maintain and improve water and wastewater services. At the time of privatisation our coastal bathing waters were blighted by raw sewage outfalls but years of sustained investment by South West Water has transformed them into some of the best in Europe. Our pioneering Upstream Thinking catchment management scheme was one of the first to demonstrate nature-based improvements to water quality. We care deeply about the environment and are currently making our largest environmental investment for 15 years, with additional proposals submitted to Defra and our regulators to accelerate and expand investment to support a Green Recovery. In addition to the written views provided below, our CEO Susan Davy would be delighted to assist the Committee’s inquiry further by providing oral evidence. Summary of our view Our customers and communities are placing increasing importance on river water quality for amenity, in addition to ecology We care deeply about the environment and the priorities of our customers and communities - the environment is now our top priority, second only to safe clean drinking water Experience has taught us that working in partnership and understanding how most effectively to intervene will be essential if we are to play our part in delivering a step-change in river quality.
    [Show full text]
  • Thames Water.48 This Is a Pricing Impact That Demonstrates the Commitment to Sustainable Performance
    Water Infrastructure Thames Water Utilities Limited: The Business Case of a Regulated Utility CASE (A) The Business Case for Sustainable Infrastructure Prof. S.N. Pollalis, E. Hagistavrou The Zofnass Program at Harvard April 15, 2019 Contents Part 1: Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 3 A water company’s singular nature of business .................................................................... 3 What it means to be a private utility .................................................................................... 3 The UK water sector and Thames Water Utilities Ltd ........................................................... 4 Part 2: The UK privatized water sector ........................................................................................... 6 Privatization of the water and wastewater sectors in the UK ............................................... 6 What privatization has delivered so far ................................................................................ 6 UK water sector’s risk profile ................................................................................................ 7 Part 3: The UK regulatory framework ............................................................................................. 7 Overview ............................................................................................................................... 7 Regulatory toolkit for risk and reward management
    [Show full text]
  • Water, Water Everywhere?
    Water, water everywhere? Delivering resilient water & waste water services (2018-19) Overview Key Highlights The amount of time that consumers were extent to which metering is encouraging In this report we present water and/ left without water reduced by 39.9% in consumers to reduce their water use. or sewerage companies’ (referred to as 2018-19. Although this appears to be a companies) performance in 2018-19 in significant reduction, the starting point It is good to see a reduction in sewer the key service areas that can have a big was much higher due to the widespread flooding, both inside and outside impact on consumers. The report identifies supply interruptions experienced during the home. However, any flooding is poor performing companies, as well as the ‘Beast from the East’ and Storm Emma unacceptable to customers and so good practice that can be shared across in early 2018. Looking back prior to this companies still have more to do in the industry. The data contained within incident, supply interruptions have in this area. We were disappointed to this report has been supplied directly to us fact increased by 21.8% since 2016-17. see the disbanding of the 21st Century by companies, unless otherwise stated. All We, therefore, question what has been Drainage Board and hope that the company specific data is included in the learnt from this incident and emphasise work started on sewer misuse can appendices of this report for reference. the importance for companies to learn continue through different channels. from these experiences. Companies must recognise the need to plan for extremes For water quality in England, the figure in our weather or one-off events, which for public water supply compliance are becoming more common due to with the EU Drinking Water Directive climate change.
    [Show full text]
  • Customer Charter – Code of Practice for Household Customers Contents
    Customer charter – code of practice for household customers Contents 1 Security 1 Purpose of this charter 1 About Bournemouth Water 2 Charges and bills 4 Service standards and compensation 12 Water regulations 12 Pipework and leaks 15 Contact with us 17 Regulation of the water industry 19 Further information 20 Other relevant organisations 22 Table of compensation payable under the ........Guaranteed Standards Scheme (GSS) Bournemouth Water supplies your drinking water, so if you have a question regarding drainage or sewerage you will need to contact your sewerage provider. – Wessex Water 0345 600 3600 – Southern Water 0845 272 0845 Security All our employees carry identification cards which display their name, photograph and our company logo. They’ll usually be wearing a uniform. Always check a caller’s identity card before letting them into your home, and if you’ve agreed a password, make sure that they give it to you. Purpose of this charter This charter informs you of the services Bournemouth Water provides, our commitment to customers and tells you where you can get more help and advice. All our codes of practice are reviewed and approved by Ofwat, the economic regulator of the water industry. A list of our codes of practice and useful contacts can be found throughout this booklet. Please let us know if you’d like a copy of any of our codes or leaflets in large print, by contacting Customer Services on 01202 590059. About Bournemouth Water We provide clean drinking water to about half a million people in an area that stretches from Poole to Beaulieu and from Bournemouth to Salisbury – 1,041 square kilometres.
    [Show full text]
  • The Chief Inspector's Report for Drinking Water in England
    Drinking water 2020 The Chief Inspector’s report for drinking water in England www.dwi.gov.uk Published by Drinking Water Inspectorate Nobel House 17 Smith Square London SW1P 3JR Tel: 0300 068 6400 Website: www.dwi.gov.uk © Crown Copyright 2021 ISBN 978-1-911087-33-5 Copyright in the typographical arrangement and design rests with the Crown. This publication (excluding the logo) may be reproduced free of charge in any format or medium provided that it is reproduced accurately and not used in a misleading context. The material must be acknowledged as Crown copyright with the title and source of the publication specified. Drinking water 2020 The Chief Inspector’s report for drinking water in England www.dwi.gov.uk Drinking water 2020 The Chief Inspector’s report for drinking water in England Contents Executive Summary 5 Drinking water 2020 11 The Chief Inspector’s report for England 11 Drinking water quality testing 14 Influence of CoViD-19 on Water Industry Performance 17 Regulation 7 and Zonal Sampling 19 Analysis of Sampling Response 19 E. coli analysis 22 Conclusions 28 Compliance with Standards 30 Compliance Risk Index 30 Learning from compliance failures 33 Microbiological parameters 34 Chemical and physical parameters 44 Isles of Scilly Water 60 Events 63 Regulation 31 and Supervision of Contractors 67 Hardham Treatment Works (SRN) 67 Rill Chillerton Service Reservoir (SRN) 68 Testwood UV Blockage (SRN) 69 Taste and Odour (SVT) 71 Misconnection (SES) 72 Do Not Drink Advice (WSX) 73 1 Drinking water 2020 The Chief Inspector’s report for drinking water in England Discolouration Events 76 Ingleby Barwick (NES) 80 Manchester (UUT) 80 Rownhams (SRN) 81 Tees Cross Valve (NES) 81 Media Interest in Sussex and Kent (SEW) 82 Loss of Supply (TMS) 83 Cryptosporidium Detections at Surface Water Treatment Works 84 Littlehempston Cryptosporidium, Devon (SWB) 84 Eccup Cryptosporidium, West Yorkshire (YKS) 86 Ashford Common Cryptosporidium, London (TMS) 87 E.
    [Show full text]
  • Code of Practice on Leakage for Household Customers Contents
    Code of practice on leakage for household customers Contents 1 Introduction 1 Responsibility for pipework 3 Paying for the water you use 4 Meters 6 How to check for a leak 8 How we can help if your supply pipe is leaking 14 Leaks from other pipework 15 Leak allowance 16 FAQs – Frequently asked questions 21 Process flowchart for leaks 22 Useful information 23 If you’re not satisfied 24 Option 1 – Free and subsidised leak repair form All our employees carry identification cards which display their name, photograph and our company logo. Always check a caller’s identity card before letting them into your home, and if you’ve agreed a password, make sure they give it to you. If a caller says they work for us but you’re not sure, tell them to wait outside and call our Customer Service team on 01202 590059. Don’t use any other number which the caller might give you. Our staff won’t mind waiting while you call us. Bournemouth Water supplies your drinking water, so if you have a question regarding drainage or sewerage you will need to contact your sewerage provider. – Wessex Water 0345 600 3600 – Southern Water 0330 303 0277 Introduction This code of practice covers underground leaks from household customers’ external supply pipes, and actions customers must take to ensure leaks on their supply pipes and internal plumbing are repaired promptly. This code of practice also covers any mixed-use properties (where the property has both domestic and commercial water use). However, some policies such as the free repair scheme will only apply where the water is predominantly used by the household.
    [Show full text]
  • South West Water Bournemouth Water Trading and Procurement Code
    southwestwater.co.uk bournemouthwater.co.uk South West Water Bournemouth Water Trading and Procurement Code Draft for Consultation July 2018 Contents_Toc518917010 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Purpose of the Code ............................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Use of the Code ....................................................................................................................... 1 1.3 Contact Details ........................................................................................................................ 1 2 Our position on water trading ........................................................................................................ 2 2.1 South West Water ................................................................................................................... 2 2.2 Our Regulators and Watchdogs .............................................................................................. 2 2.3 Water Resources ..................................................................................................................... 3 2.4 Water Trading ......................................................................................................................... 5 3 Principles of the code .....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • You Need to Know
    Water All you need to know wessexwater.co.uk 1 Contents Here to help you] We’re one of the leading drinking water We aim to do this by: Here to help you 1 and sewerage companies in England • encouraging and enabling our Water sources 2 and Wales and water is a precious customers to use water wisely resource for us. Water environment 2 • controlling leakage So we’re committed to providing you • protecting our water sources from Water treatment 3 with the best quality drinking water pollution, especially nitrates. Our water network 4 and giving you the highest levels of customer service and environmental Although water is one of the world’s Pipework responsibility 5 performance that we can. natural resources and falls quite literally out of the sky, the job of collecting it Water supply interruptions 6 And we’re determined to meet future and making it clean and safe to drink demands for water without restrictions, Water pressure 7 isn’t a simple matter. without harming the environment and Water quality 8 whatever extreme weather we face in So we’ve put together this booklet to the future. give you some idea of what goes into Water leakage 9 getting drinking water from its source Water resources for the future 10 to the taps in your home. What you can do 11 Cold weather advice 12 Important information 12 Stroud Cotswold How we can help 13 South Gloucestershire Contact us Back cover Bristol Wessex Water Chippenham North Somerset Bath BANES Devizes Weston-super-Mare Trowbridge Wiltshire Sedgemoor Mendip Warminster West Bridgwater Somerset Salisbury
    [Show full text]
  • Service Delivery Report 2016-17
    January 2018 Trust in water Service delivery report 2016-17 www.ofwat.gsi.gov.uk Trust in water 1 Introduction This report provides information on the services delivered to customers by the 17 largest water and wastewater companies (‘companies’) for whom we set price controls. It looks at their performance in relation to the commitments each company agreed to when we set price controls for the period 2015 to 2020 in the 2014 price review (PR14). Introduction At PR14, we required companies to talk to and listen to their customers about the services they wanted companies to deliver over the long term (‘outcomes’); the specific levels of service or outcomes they expected companies to deliver (‘performance commitments’); and the level Key points of any outperformance payments and underperformance penalties for meeting or exceeding them (‘outcome delivery incentives’ or ‘ODIs’). Companies must report annually on their performance on their outcomes in an Annual Performance Report (APR). Overall sectoral We expect the comparisons we make in this report, together with the information water companies publish themselves, to highlight areas of performance good and poor performance. This information will help us and others – such as customer groups, environmental groups and investors – to hold companies to account. Performance & resilience At PR14, companies set their own performance commitments, which led to a number of similar, but not identical, definitions. As a result, it is not always possible to directly compare companies’ performance in the current control period. Glossary There are core performance commitments that all customers across Wales and England value highly. We consider it is beneficial for all companies to therefore have a core of commitments with common definitions.
    [Show full text]