Teaching for Meaningful Learning a Review of Research on Inquiry-Based and Cooperative Learning
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TM THE GEORGE LUCAS EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION TM THE GEORGE LUCAS EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION book excerpt TEACHING FOR MEAningFUL LEARning A Review of Research on Inquiry-Based and Cooperative Learning By Dr. Brigid Barron and Dr. Linda Darling-Hammond, Stanford University Introduction Dr. Milton Chen Executive Director The George Lucas Educational Foundation Our Foundation began in 1991 with an school of the future? Or a hybrid car?” These Dr. Brigid Barron and Dr. Linda Darling- ambitious mission: to demonstrate how students are sifting information from many Hammond of Stanford University; Dean P. innovative learning environments in sources and producing projects to present David Pearson, Dr. Alan Schoenfeld, Dr. classrooms, supported by powerful new their knowledge, using computers and the Timothy Zimmerman, Dr. Gina Cervetti, technologies, could revolutionize learning. Internet throughout. Their teachers are and Jennifer Tilson at the University of As an organization founded by George embracing their new role as learning coach California, Berkeley; and Dr. Elizabeth Lucas, we believed that the same benefits and manager, rather than as exclusive Stage at the Lawrence Hall of Science. Dr. of technology that were transforming instructor. Darling-Hammond also served as editor for business, health care, manufacturing, As a Foundation, we have understood the the volume. entertainment, and other sectors could be critical importance of developing a research This impressive group of leaders applied in education. And this was in the basis for these innovations. In order for the in educational research has taken an days before the Internet. exemplars we have profiled to take root important step forward for the field. Nearly two decades later, the world in more places, their effectiveness must Their review of the literature on project- has moved ahead in dramatic ways, but be demonstrated in educational research. based learning, cooperative learning, our schools remain caught in a web of Importantly, policymakers investing funds and instructional strategies in literacy, educational thinking and systems that to bring these innovations to scale must be mathematics, and science summarizes originated a century ago. The instructional able to base their policies on documented what is known and what new research is model of the teacher and the textbook as the results. These beliefs led to our support for needed. While they point to studies of the primary sources of knowledge, conveyed research published in the book, Powerful effectiveness of these strategies, they also through lecturing, discussion, and reading, Learning: What We Know About Teaching for issue this important caveat: effectiveness has proven astonishingly persistent. Understanding (Jossey-Bass, 2008), from relies heavily on the readiness and quality Fortunately, this “dominant paradigm” which this article is excerpted. of teachers implementing them. Their book is showing signs of wear. In our work of On behalf of our Foundation, I express includes vignettes of schools and programs telling stories of innovative learning, we our appreciation to the authors of the book: illustrating these practices, with links to see many more examples of teachers, films and articles on our Edutopia website principals, and district administrators and other web resources. implementing new forms of project- We also thank our partners at Jossey- based curricula and performance-based Bass, editors Kate Gagnon and Lesley Iwa, assessment. In these classrooms, students for bringing this book to publication. are working in teams to address open- We hope that Powerful Learning provokes ended and complex questions, such as new thinking about the investments “What is the air and water quality in your needed to create more powerful twenty- community?” “How would you design a first century schools and school systems. Teaching for Meaningful Learning: A Review of Research on Inquiry-Based and Cooperative Learning By Dr. Brigid Barron and Dr. Linda Darling-Hammond, Stanford University “Decades of research illustrate the benefits of inquiry-based and cooperative learning to help students develop the knowledge and skills necessary to be successful in a rapidly changing world.” ince “A Nation at Risk” application of simple algorithms—won’t implementation of new models. Indeed, was published a quarter- develop students who are critical thinkers or “learning by doing” has a somewhat checkered century ago, mountains of students who can write and speak effectively track record, in part because teachers often lack reports have been written (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, 1999; the information, support, and tools necessary about the need for more Bransford & Donovan, 2005). To develop to fully integrate and support this alternative powerful teaching and these higher-order skills, students need to approach to teaching and learning. learning focused on the take part in complex, meaningful projects that This chapter seeks to expand our knowledge Sdemands of life and work in the twenty-first require sustained engagement, collaboration, of the benefits of inquiry-based learning, as century. Consider this: In 1900, 95 percent research, management of resources, and the well as to deepen our understanding of the of all jobs were low skilled and required only development of an ambitious performance or components of an effective inquiry-based that employees could follow basic procedures product. lesson or unit. We’ll explore three approaches designed by others. In 2008, many jobs require In fact, a growing body of research suggests to inquiry-based learning: project-based specialized knowledge and skills. Today’s that students learn more deeply and perform learning, problem-based learning, and employees must be able to communicate better on complex tasks if they have the learning by design, highlighting key research and collaborate, research ideas, and collect, opportunity to engage in more “authentic” and unpacking important elements of each synthesize, and analyze information. They learning—projects and activities that require approach. need to develop new products and to be able them to employ subject knowledge to solve real- to apply different areas of knowledge to new world problems. Studies have shown a positive A Pathway to Deeper Knowledge problems and challenges. impact on learning when students participate Project-based learning involves completing In short, the nature of work has changed— in lessons that require them to construct and complex tasks that typically result in a realistic and continues to do so. According to the U.S. organize knowledge, consider alternatives, product, event, or presentation to an audience. Department of Labor, the average worker will engage in detailed research, inquiry, writing, Thomas (2000) identifies five key components hold more than 10 jobs before the age of 40. and analysis, and to communicate effectively of effective project-based learning. It is: central The top 10 “in demand” jobs projected for to audiences (Newmann, 1996). For example, to the curriculum, organized around driving 2010 did not exist in 2004. a study of more than 2,100 students in 23 questions that lead students to encounter The changing workforce and the need for so- schools found significantly higher achievement central concepts or principles, focused on a called twenty-first-century skills have changed on intellectually challenging performance constructive investigation that involves inquiry what it means to provide every child with an tasks for students who experienced this kind and knowledge building, student-driven effective education that prepares them for a of “authentic pedagogy” (Newmann, Marks, & (students are responsible for designing and full and productive life. It’s no longer enough Gamoran, 1995). Indeed, use of these practices managing their work), and authentic, focusing to simply transmit information that students resulted in stronger performance regardless of on problems that occur in the real world and memorize and store for future use. Education race, gender, or prior achievement. that people care about. today must focus on helping students learn how The research highlighting the benefits of Generally, research on project-based to learn, so they can manage the demands of authentic learning, together with a growing learning (PBL) has found that students who changing information, technologies, jobs, and interest in providing students with more engage in this approach benefit from gains in social conditions. engaging, thought-provoking learning factual learning that are equivalent or superior How do we prepare our students for these opportunities, has prompted teachers at all to those of students who engage in traditional twenty-first-century skills? grade levels to experiment with incorporating forms of instruction (Thomas, 2000). The Traditional academic approaches—narrow inquiry-based learning into their curriculum. goals of PBL are broader, however, than simply tasks that emphasize memorization or the But interest alone does not make for effective the development of content knowledge. This ideas well enough to answer the questions of others. There are many ways in which performance assessments con- tribute to learning. For example, exhibitions, projects, and portfolios provide multiple occasions for review and revision toward a polished performance. These opportunities help students examine both how they learn and how to improve their performance. Students are of- ten expected to present their