The Thomasina Jordan Indian Tribes of Virginia Federal Recognition Act and the Grand River Band of Ottawa Indians of Michigan Referral Act
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
S. HRG. 109–576 THE THOMASINA JORDAN INDIAN TRIBES OF VIRGINIA FEDERAL RECOGNITION ACT AND THE GRAND RIVER BAND OF OTTAWA INDIANS OF MICHIGAN REFERRAL ACT HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON INDIAN AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION ON S. 437 TO EXPEDITE REVIEW OF THE GRAND RIVER BAND OF OTTAWA INDI- ANS OF MICHIGAN TO SECURE A TIMELY AND JUST DETERMINATION OF WHETHER THAT GROUP IS ENTITLED TO RECOGNITION AS A FED- ERAL INDIAN TRIBE S. 480 TO EXTEND FEDERAL RECOGNITION TO THE CHICKAHOMINY INDIAN TRIBE, THE CHICKAHOMINY INDIAN TRIBE—EASTERN DIVISION, THE UPPER MATTAPONI TRIBE, THE RAPPAHANNOCK TRIBE, INC., THE MONACAN INDIAN NATION, AND THE NANSEMOND INDIAN TRIBE JUNE 21, 2006 WASHINGTON, DC ( U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 28–348 PDF WASHINGTON : 2006 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512–1800; DC area (202) 512–1800 Fax: (202) 512–2250 Mail: Stop SSOP, Washington, DC 20402–0001 COMMITTEE ON INDIAN AFFAIRS JOHN McCAIN, Arizona, Chairman BYRON L. DORGAN, North Dakota, Vice Chairman PETE V. DOMENICI, New Mexico DANIEL K. INOUYE, Hawaii CRAIG THOMAS, Wyoming KENT CONRAD, North Dakota GORDON SMITH, Oregon DANIEL K. AKAKA, Hawaii LISA MURKOWSKI, Alaska TIM JOHNSON, South Dakota MICHAEL D. CRAPO, Idaho MARIA CANTWELL, Washington RICHARD BURR, North Carolina TOM COBURN, M.D., Oklahoma JOHN TAHSUDA, III, Majority Staff Director SARA G. GARLAND, Minority Staff Director (II) C O N T E N T S Page S. 437 and S. 480, text of ........................................................................................ 3 Statements: Adkins, Stephen R., chief, Cickahominy Indian Tribe, Charles City, VA ... 86 Allen, Hon. George, U.S. Senator from Virginia ............................................ 72 Comp, Fran, vice chairman, Grand River Bands of Ottawa Indians, Grand Rapids, MI ......................................................................................... 91 Dorgan, Byron L., U.S. Senator from North Dakota, vice chairman, Com- mittee on Indian Affairs ............................................................................... 78 Fleming, Lee, director, Office of Federal Acknowledgment, Department of the Interior, Washington, DC .................................................................. 79 Levin, Hon. Carl, U.S. Senator from Michigan .............................................. 70 McCain, Hon. John, U.S. Senator from Arizona, chairman, Committee on Indian Affairs ........................................................................................... 1 Moran, Hon. James P., U.S. Representative from Virginia .......................... 75 O’Conner, Michael, president, Virginia Petroleum, Convenience and Gro- cery Association, Richmond, VA .................................................................. 94 Rountree, Helen, professor emerita of anthropology, Old Dominion Uni- versity, Norfolk, VA ...................................................................................... 89 Warner, Hon. John W., U.S. Senator from Virginia ...................................... 77 Willerup, David, pastor, Westwood Reform Church, Muskegon, MI ............ 93 Yob, Ron, chairman, Grand River Bands of Ottawa Indians, Grand Rap- ids, MI ............................................................................................................ 91 APPENDIX Prepared statements: Adkins, Stephen R.(with attachment) ............................................................. 101 Allen, Hon. George, U.S. Senator from Virginia (with attachment) ............ 105 Barton, Rev. Jonathan M., general minister, Virginia Council of Churches (with attachment) ......................................................................................... 121 Fleming, Lee ..................................................................................................... 124 O’Conner, Michael ............................................................................................ 127 Rountree, Helen (with attachment) ................................................................ 131 Warner, Hon. John W., U.S. Senator from Virginia ...................................... Willerup, David (with attachment) ................................................................. 152 Yob, Ron (with attachment) ............................................................................. 167 Additional material submitted for the record: Kildee, Hon. Dale E., U.S. Representative from Michigan letter to Hon. Peter Hoekstra, U.S. Representative from Michigan ................................. 221 (III) THE THOMASINA E. JORDAN INDIAN TRIBES OF VIRGINIA FEDERAL RECOGNITION ACT AND THE GRAND RIVER BAND OF OTTAWA INDIANS OF MICHIGAN REFERRAL ACT WEDNESDAY, JUNE 21, 2006 U.S. SENATE, COMMITTEE ON INDIAN AFFAIRS, Washington, DC. The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:30 a.m. in room 485, Senate Russell Office Building, Hon. John McCain (chairman of the committee) presiding. Present: Senators McCain, Dorgan, and Thomas STATEMENT OF HON. JOHN MCCAIN, U.S. SENATOR FROM ARIZONA, CHAIRMAN, COMMITTEE ON INDIAN AFFAIRS The CHAIRMAN. Good morning. We are here today to receive tes- timony on two bills, S. 437, the Grand River Band of Ottawa Indi- ans of Michigan Referral Act, and S. 480, the Thomasina E. Jordan Indian Tribes of Virginia Federal Recognition Act of 2005. These bills, if enacted, would allow the mentioned Indian groups to bypass the Department of the Interior Federal acknowledgement process regulations. According to a status report sent to the com- mittee by the DOI Office of Federal Acknowledgement, each of the groups listed in the bills have submitted petitions for recognition through the DOI regulations. The solemnity of Federal recognition which establishes a govern- ment-to-government relationship between the United States and an Indian tribe demands not only a fair and transparent process but a process that is above reproach. And, while the relationship estab- lished is Federal, the impacts are felt locally, as well, as has been reported to this Committee by States attorneys general and local communities. Hearings held by this committee in the past have indicated that the regulatory process, although well intentioned, can be criticized as too slow, too costly, and too opaque. Recognition by legislation, on the other hand, has been justly criticized for being too summary and arbitrary. Therefore, it is Congress’ responsibility to ensure that the decision whether to extend recognition to an Indian group be conducted in a fair and transparent fashion, in keeping with the gravity of that decision. It has long been my view that Congress is ill equipped to conduct the rigorous review needed to provide the basis for such a decision. (1) 2 It is also my view that is substantively unfair to provide a legisla- tive path short-circuiting the process for some tribes while others labor for years to get through the regulations. On the other hand, there are, from time to time, extenuating circumstances for particu- lar Indian groups that require Congressional resolution, and I have supported legislation in those circumstances. The witnesses today will provide testimony, both pro and con, as to the unique history of each of the groups listed in these bills and whether the extenuating circumstances exist such that Congres- sional recognition is warranted. I also welcome our colleagues from the Senate who are here and those from the House who have sponsored this legislation. [Text of S. 437 and S. 480 follow:] 3 II 109TH CONGRESS 1ST SESSION S. 437 To expedite review of the Grand River Band of Ottawa Indians of Michigan to secure a timely and just determination of whether that group is entitled to recognition as a Federal Indian tribe. IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES FEBRUARY 17, 2005 Mr. LEVIN (for himself and Ms. STABENOW) introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred to the Committee on Indian Affairs A BILL To expedite review of the Grand River Band of Ottawa Indians of Michigan to secure a timely and just deter- mination of whether that group is entitled to recognition as a Federal Indian tribe. 1 Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representa- 2 tives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, 3 SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS. 4 (a) SHORT TITLE.—This Act may be cited as the 5 ‘‘Grand River Band of Ottawa Indians of Michigan Refer- 6 ral Act’’. 7 (b) TABLE OF CONTENTS.—The table of contents of 8 this Act is as follows: 1 4 2 Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents. Sec. 2. Definitions. TITLE I—REFERRAL TO THE SECRETARY Sec. 101. Purpose. Sec. 102. Report. Sec. 103. Action by Congress. TITLE II—MEMBERSHIP; JURISDICTION; LAND Sec. 201. Recognition. Sec. 202. Membership. Sec. 203. Federal services and benefits. Sec. 204. Rights of the Tribe. Sec. 205. Tribal funds. Sec. 206. Jurisdiction of trust land. 1 SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS. 2 In this Act: 3 (1) BAND; TRIBE.—The terms ‘‘Band’’ and 4 ‘‘Tribe’’ mean the Grand River Band of the Ottawa 5 Indians of Michigan. 6 (2) DATE OF RECOGNITION.—The term ‘‘date 7 of recognition’’ means the date on which recognition 8 of the Tribe by the Secretary was published in the 9 Federal Register under section 201. 10 (3) INDIAN TRIBE.—The term ‘‘Indian tribe’’ 11 has the meaning given the term in section 4 of the 12 Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance 13 Act (25 U.S.C. 450b). 14 (4) SECRETARY.—The term ‘‘Secretary’’ means 15 the Secretary of the