Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 1 of 106
STATE OF WISCONSIN CIRCUIT COURT MILWAUKEE COUNTY
THE CITY OF 6287+0,/:$8.(( WK$YHQXH 6RXWK0LOZDXNHH Wisconsin 531
Plaintiff, v.
ACTAVIS PHARMA, INC. f/k/a WATSON PHARMA, INC. c/o Corporate Creations Network, Inc. 4650 West Spencer Street Appleton, Wisconsin 54914
ALLERGAN FINANCE LLC f/k/a ACTAVIS, INC. f/k/a WATSON PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. c/o C T Corporation System 701 South Carson Street, Suite 200 Carson City, Nevada 89701
ACTAVIS LLC c/o Corporate Creations Network Inc. 3411 Silverside Road Tatnall Building, Suite 104 Wilmington, Delaware 19810
WATSON LABORATORIES, INC. c/o Corporate Creations Network, Inc. 8275 South Eastern Avenue #200 Las Vegas, Nevada 89123
ENDO PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. c/o The Corporation Trust Company Corporation Trust Center 1209 Orange Street Wilmington, Delaware 19801
1 Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 2 of 106
ENDO HEALTH SOLUTIONS, INC. c/o The Corporation Trust Company Corporation Trust Center 1209 Orange Street Wilmington, Delaware 19801
PAR PHARMACEUTICAL, INC. c/o C T Corporation System 28 Liberty Street New York, New York 10005
TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC. c/o Corporate Creations Network, Inc. 3411 Silverside Road Tatnall Building, Suite 104 Wilmington, Delaware 19810
CEPHALON, INC. c/o Corporate Creations Network Inc. 4650 West Spencer Street Appleton, Wisconsin 54914
JOHNSON & JOHNSON One Johnson & Johnson Plaza New Brunswick, New Jersey 08933
JANSSEN PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. f/k/a ORTHO-MCNEIL-JANSSEN PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. f/k/a JANSSEN PHARMACEUTICA, INC. c/o C T Corporation System 600 North Second Street, Suite 40 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17101
MCKESSON CORPORATION c/o Corporation Service Company 8040 Excelsior Drive, Suite 400 Madison, Wisconsin 53717
AMERISOURCEBERGEN DRUG CORPORATION c/o C T Corporation System 301 South Bedford Street, Suite 1 Madison, Wisconsin 53703
2
Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 3 of 106 FILED 05-18-2021 John Barrett Clerk of Circuit Court CARDINAL HEALTH, INC. 2021CV002934 c/o C T Corporation System Honorable David 301 South Bedford Street, Suite 1 Swanson-11 Madison, Wisconsin 53703 Branch 11
WALGREEN COMPANY c/o Corporation Service Company 8040 Excelsior Drive, Suite 400 Madison, Wisconsin 53717 ROESCHEN’S HEALTHCARE LLC d/b/a OMNICARE OF MILWAUKEE c/o C T Corporation System 301 South Bedford Street, Suite 1 Madison, Wisconsin 53703
MEDPOINT PHARMACY, INC. c/o Alexander Shister 5335 West River Trail Road Mequon, Wisconsin 53092
HAYWARD PHARMACY, INC. d/b/a SWAN SERV-U PHARMACY c/o Randall Dawes 9130 W North Avenue Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53226
UNION SERV-U PHARMACY, INC. c/o Robert Stresing 709 W Oklahoma Avenue Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53215
LAABS, INC. c/o Thomas E. Volkmann 701 Grand Avenue Racine, Wisconsin 53403,
Defendants.
SUMMONS
THE STATE OF WISCONSIN to each person named as a Defendant:
3
Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 4 of 106
You are hereby notified that the plaintiff named above has filed a lawsuit or other legal action against you. The Complaint, which is attached, states the nature and basis of the legal action.
Within twenty (20) days of receiving this Summons you must respond with a written answer, as that term is used in Chapter 802 of the Wisconsin Statutes, to the Complaint. The Court may reject or disregard an answer that does not follow the requirements of the Statutes. The answer must be sent or delivered to the Court whose address is Milwaukee County Courthouse, 901 North
Ninth Street, Milwaukee, WI, 53233, and to plaintiff's attorney whose address is City Attorney,
Christopher R. Smith, 11402 West Church Street, Franklin, WI, 53132. You may have an attorney help or represent you.
If you do not provide a proper answer within twenty (20) days, the court may grant judgment against you for the award of money or other legal action requested in the Complaint, and you may lose your right to object to anything that is or may be incorrect in the Complaint. A judgment may be enforced as provided by law. A judgment awarding money may become a lien against any real estate you own now or in the future and may also be enforced by garnishment or seizure of property.
Dated: May 17, 2021 City of 6RXWK0LOZDXNHH
By: ______Atty.Atty. CChristopherhristopher R. Smith Attorney for Plaintiff 11402 W. Church Street SBN: 1049922 Franklin, WI 53132 414-529-8900
4 Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 5 of 106
"## &" " !$# $!# &$ $ #( ##( $( ,DJI=%6@: G>K: J96=N0>H8DCH>C $"&+" K #%" ! .2) &#" ! 8 D DGEDG6I: G:6I>DCH':ILDG@"C8 0:HI,E:C8:G,IG::I EEA:IDC0>H8DCH>C ! .2) #%" .2) &#" ! $# " 8 D - DGEDG6I>DC,NHI:B ,DJI= 6GHDC,IG::I,J>I: 6GHDC >IN':K696 #%" 8 D DGEDG6I: G:6I>DCH':ILDG@"C8 ,>AK:GH>9:+D69 -6IC6AAJ>A9>C<,J>I: 0>AB>C )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 6 of 106 ! ! $# 8 D - DGEDG6I>DC,NHI:B %>7:GIN,IG::I ':L2DG@':L2DG@ #% ! $# "$" 8 D DGEDG6I: G:6I>DCH':ILDG@"C8 ,>AK:GH>9:+D69 -6IC6AAJ>A9>C<,J>I: 0>AB>C )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 7 of 106 FILED 05-18-2021 John Barrett Clerk of Circuit Court ! " B" #! ,*) 2021CV002934 ! &$ Honorable David 8 D - DGEDG6I>DC,NHI:B Swanson-11 ,DJI=:9;DG9,IG::I,J>I: Branch 11 &69>HDC0>H8DCH>C # ! ( 8 DA:M6C9:G,=>HI:G 0:HI+>K:G-G6>A+D69 &:FJDC0>H8DCH>C (&! ! ( ,*) "& "!%$ ! ( 8 D+6C96AA 6L:H 0'DGI=K:CJ: &>AL6J@::0>H8DCH>C $ "!%$ ! ( 8 D+D7:GI,IG:H>C< 0(@A6=DB6K:CJ: &>AL6J@::0>H8DCH>C " 8 D-=DB6H /DA@B6CC G6C9K:CJ: +68>C:0>H8DCH>C & &+* )A6>CI>;;I=: >IND; J96=N7N6C9I=GDJ<=I=:JC9:GH> I=: >IND; J96=N=:G:>C6;I:GR J96=NSDGRI=: >INS;>A:HI=>H DBEA6>CI6<6>CHI :;:C96CIH 8I6K>H)=6GB6"C8 ; @ 606IHDC)=6GB6"C8 AA:G<6C >C6C8:%% ; @ 68I6K>H"C8 ; @ 6 06IHDC)=6GB68:JI>86AH"C8 8I6K>H%% 06IHDC%67DG6IDG>:H"C8 C9D)=6GB68:JI>86AH "C8 C9D !:6AI= ,DAJI>DCH "C8 )6G )=6GB68:JI>86A "C8 -:K6 )=6GB68:JI>86AH ., "C8 :E=6ADC"C8 #D=CHDC#D=CHDC#6CHH:C)=6GB68:JI>86AH"C8 ; @ 6(GI=D &8':>A #6CHH:C )=6GB68:JI>86AH "C8 ; @ 6 #6CHH:C )=6GB68:JI>86 "C8 &8$:HHDC DGEDG6I>DC B:G>HDJG8::G<:C GJ< DGEDG6I>DC 6G9>C6A!:6AI="C8 06A )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 8 of 106 !:6AI=86G:%% 9 7 6(BC>86G:D;&>AL6J@::&:9ED>CI)=6GB68N"C8 !6NL6G9)=6GB68N "C8 9 7 6,L6C,:GK .)=6GB68N.C>DC,:GK .)=6GB68N"C8 6C9%667H"C8 8DAA:8I>K:AN R :;:C96CIHS6C9G:HE:8I;JAANH=DLHI=: DJGI6H;DAADLH )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 9 of 106 # # #" " "'-+( . -"(' "" )+-" , )%"'-" "-2( . !2 &'. -.+ + ' '-, R8I6K>HS :;:C96CIH R C9DS :;:C96CIH R-:K6S :;:C96CIH R##S :;:C96CIH ",-+".-(+ ' '-, &8$:HHDC B:G>HDJG8::G<:C 6G9>C6A 06A )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 10 of 106 :;:C96CIH"C;>AIG6I:988G:9>I>C<"CHI>IJI>DCHID G:6I:6':L ,I6C96G9D; 6G:;DGI=:-G:6IB:CID;)6>C6C9)G:H8G>7>C<D;(E>D>9 GJ )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 11 of 106 #! $# -=>H>H686H:67DJI6 B6CJ;68IJG:GH9>HIG>7JIDGH6C9E=6GB68NG:I6>A:GHD;DE>D>9H@C:LDGH=DJA9=6K:@CDLCI=6I I=:>G EGD9J8IH L:G: 96C<:GDJH 6C9 =><=AN 699>8I>K: -=:H: ;68IH A>B>I:9 I=:>G EGD9J8IHU EGD;>I67>A>IN ,D :;:C96CIH9:8>9:9ID8=6C<:I=:;68IH :;:C96CIH HE:CI B>AA>DCH D; 9DAA6GH ID 8G:6I: 6 EJ7A>8>IN B68=>C: I=6I JH>C< HJEEDH:9ANJC7>6H:99D8IDGH6C9DG<6C>O6I>DCH;JC9:97NI=:>C9JHIGN8DCK>C8:9I=:B:9>86A 8DBBJC>IN CDI DCAN I=6I DE>D>9H L:G: H6;: 6C9 CDC 699>8I>K: 7JI I=6I I=: 7:HI IG:6IB:CI ;DG 699>8I>DCL6HBDG:DE>D>9H :;:C96CIHB69:I:CHD;7>AA>DCHD;9DAA6GH B:G>86HJ;;:G:96C9 I=:G:H>9:CIHD; J96=NHJ;;:G:9 (E>D>9 67JH:9:6I=H6G:DCI=:G>H:6C9A:;IID9:6AL>I=I=:;6AADJI;GDBDE>D>9 699>8I>DC J96=N BJHI CDL HI6C9 JE ID I=:H: E=6GB68:JI>86A <>6CIH 6C9 H::@ G:9G:HH ;DG I=: :MI:CH>K:96B6<: :;:C96CIH=6K:86JH:9>IH >IN ,>C8: I=:CJB7:GD;B:G>86CHL=D=6K:9>:96CCJ6AAN;GDB9GJ<DK:G9DH:H =6H>C8G:6H:97NBDG:I=6C E:G8:CI "C I=:G:L:G:9GJ<DK:G9DH:9:6I=H>CI=: . , (E>D>9H L:G: >CKDAK:9 >C ILD I=>G9H D; I=:H: DK:G9DH: 9:6I=H -=: CJB7:G D; DE>D>9 DK:G9DH:9:6I=H>C 6ADC:HJGE6HH:9I=:CJB7:GD;9:6I=H>CI=:" ,:E>9:B>86I>IHE:6@ -=>H9>H6HI:GL6HB6C B69: 8DCHE>G>C<IDEJH=I=:>G96C<:GDJHEGD9J8IHDCIDKJAC:G67A:B:G>86CHA:6K>C<;6B>A>:H6C9AD86A DE>D>9H9:HE>I:I=:>G96C<:G6C9699>8I>K:C:HH6G:L>9:AN6K6>A67A: -=:G:HJAI>HI=:LDGHI9GJ< DK:G9DH::E>9:B>8>CDJGC6I>DCUH=>HIDGN !6K>C<7DGC:I=:8DHIHD;I=:H:8DBE6C>:HU9:8>H>DCHQ )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 12 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 13 of 106 -=GDJ<= HJHI6>C:9 B6G@:I>C< 86BE6> 9D8IDGHL>I=686BE6> EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H>CB:G>866C9>C0>H8DCH>C (E>D>9B6CJ;68IJG:GHHJ88:HH;JAANE:GHJ69:9 9D8IDGH6C9E6I>:CIHI=6IDE>D>9H6G:CDI699>8I>K:I=6IDE>D>9H6G:H6;:;DGADC< I:GBJH:6C9I=6I I=: 8DBE6HH>DC6I: IG:6IB:CI D; E6>C G:FJ>G:9 DE>D>9H :;:C96CIHU >C8G:6H:9 H6A:H D; DE>D>9H HEG:69 68GDHH I=: 8DJCIGN A>@: L>A9;>G: G6K6<>C< I=: 8DJCIGN GD77>C< E6G:CIH D; 8=>A9G:C 6C9 8=>A9G:CD;E6G:CIH -=:CJB7:GD;9:6I=H6IIG>7JI:9IDEG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ 8D86>C:6C9=:GD>C8DB7>C:9 :;:C96CIHUEGD;>I B6M>B>O>C<H8=:B:>C8AJ9:9B>HG:EG:H:CI>C<I=:H6;:ING>H@H 7:C:;>IH6C9:;;>868ND;ADC< I:GBDE>D>9JH: -=:N:BEADN:96BJAI> EGDC<:9HIG6I: 8DCI>CJ>C<B:9>86A:9J86I>DCR & SH:B>C6GH7G6C9:969K:GI>H:B:CIHHE:8>;>86AANI6G<:I>C< DE>D>9 EG:H8G>7:GH 6C9 JC7G6C9:9 69K:GI>H:B:CIH 6>B:9 6I 8DCHJB:GHQ>C8AJ9>C< E6GI>8JA6GAN KJAC:G67A: EDEJA6I>DCH A>@: I=: :A9:GAN :;:C96CIH 6AHD G:A>:9 DC @:N DE>C>DC A:69:GH 6C9 EGD;:HH>DC6ADG<6C>O6I>DCHI=6IL:G:>CG:6A>IN;GDCI EJH=I=:>GEGD DE>D>9EGDE6<6C96 H6G:HJAII=:DE>D>9>C9JHIGNUH86BE6> E:GB:6I:96C99>G:8I:9B:9>86AG:H:6G8=6C9A>I:G6IJG:86JH>C<L>9:HEG:69DE>D>9JH:;DGI=: IG:6IB:CID;8=GDC>8E6>C HEG:H8G>7>C<G6I:HH@NGD8@:I:968GDHHI=:8DJCIGNDE>D>99>HIG>7JIDGH6AHD9G>K:C 7NB6HH>K:EGD;>IH@CDL>C EJG8=6H:H D; DE>D>9H I=6I ;ADL:9 JC>BE:9:9 >CID AD86A 8DBBJC>I>:H (E>D>9 9>HIG>7JIDGH 9>HIG>7JI:9HJEEA>:9HDA96C9EA68:9>CIDI=:HIG:6BD;8DBB:G8:EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9HL>I=DJI ;JA;>AA>C< I=:>G ;JC96B:CI6A 9JIN ID 9:I:8I L6GC 6C9 EG:K:CI 9>K:GH>DC D; 96C<:GDJH 9GJ )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 14 of 106 :;:C96CIHJC>K:GH6AAN;6>A:9ID8DBEANL>I=HI6I:A6L>C8AJ9>C<I=:>G9JINIDB6>CI6>C:;;:8I>K: 8DCIGDAH6<6>CHI9>K:GH>DCD;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H )=6GB68>:H>C6C96GDJC9 J96=N6G:6CDI=:G@:NA>C@>CI=:DE>D>9HJEEAN8=6>C )=6GB68>:H=6K:69JINID6KD>9;>AA>C<EG:H8G>EI>DCH>C9>86I>K:D;67JH:DG9>K:GH>DC6C9IDIG6>C I=:>G:BEADN::HDC8DBEA>6C8:L>I=EDA>8>:H6C9EGD8:9JG:H %>@:B6CJ;68IJG:GH6C99>HIG>7JIDGH E=6GB68>:H 6G: D7A><6I:9 ID G:EDGI EDI:CI>6A 9>K:GH>DC ID I=: DG DI=:G 6EEGDEG>6I: A6L :C;DG8:B:CI6C9G: E=6GB68>:H>C6C96GDJC9 J96=NL:G:9>HEGDEDGI>DC6I:IDCDC8DCIGDAA:99GJ HDA97NI=:H:E=6GB68>:H6C99>HEGDEDGI>DC6I:IDI=:H6A:HD;DE>D>9H>CH>B>A6GANH>O:9E=6GB68N B6G@:IH >HIG>7JIDGH6C9E=6GB68>:H:C<6<:9>CI=:B6G@:I>C<D;DE>D>9H>C8DC8:GIL>I= I=:B6CJ;68IJG:GH -=:NHDA996I6IDI=:B6CJ;68IJG:GHID6AADLI=:BID7:II:GI6G<:II=:>GH6A:H 6C9B6G@:I>C<:;;DGIH6C9:CI:G:9>CID6 -=: 8DC9J8I D; DE>D>9 B6CJ;68IJG:GH 9>HIG>7JIDGH 6C9 E=6GB68>:H G:HJAI:9 >C 6 IDGG:CI>6A ;ADD9 D; B:9>86AAN JCC:8:HH6GN DE>D>9H >CID I=: B6G@:I 6C9 =6H 9>G:8IAN G:HJAI:9 >C 9:E:C9:C8:699>8I>DC6C99:6I=;DGJH:GH>C8AJ9>C<I=DH:>C J96=N 88DG9>C<IDI=: I=:DE>D>9EG:H8G>7>C<G6I:>C&>AL6J@:: DJCINL6H EG:H8G>EI>DCH;DG:K:GN G:H>9:CIH>C &>AL6J@:: DJCINDE>D>9EG:H8G>7>C<G6I:E:6@:9 >C 6I EG:H8G>EI>DCHE:G E:GHDCH -=:E>AA6<:6C9EAJC9:GE=>ADHDE=N6C9G:HJAI>C<68IH6C9DB>HH>DCH:BEADN:97N DE>D>9B6CJ;68IJG:GH9>HIG>7JIDGH6C9E=6GB68>:H=6H>BEDH:96CDK:GL=:AB>C<;>C6C8>6A7JG9:C DC J96=N J96=N;>A:HI=>HA6LHJ>IIDH6NR:CDJ<=>H:CDJ<= S0>H8DCH>CA6LEGDK>9:HG:B:9>:H ;DG I=: 96B6<: 86JH:9 7N :;:C96CIHU 68IH 6C9 DB>HH>DCH H HJ8= J96=N H::@H JC9:G )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 15 of 106 0>H8DCH>C A6L ID G:8DK:G 6AA 96B6<:H >I =6H HJHI6>C:9 6H 6 G:HJAI D; :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I >C8AJ9>C< L>I=DJI A>B>I6I>DC 6 8DHIH 6HHD8>6I:9 L>I= 8G>B>C6A ?JHI>8: A6L :C;DG8:B:CI :B:G<:C8NH:GK>8:H6C9EJ7A>8H6;:IN78DHIH;DG8DBBJC>INDJIG:68=6C9DI=:GEG:K:CI6I>K: EJ7A>8:9J86I>DCEGD H:GK>8:HEGD !#" ##( $( )A6>CI>;; >IND; J96=N>H69JAN>C8DGEDG6I:9I=>G98A6HH8>IN:BEDL:G:97NI=: 0>H8DCH>CA:<>HA6IJG:ID68IJC9:GI=:=DB:GJA:6JI=DG>IND;0>H DCHI 6GI1"P J96=N=6H HI6C9>C<ID7G>C<I=:8A6>BH6AA:<:9=:G:>CEJGHJ6CIID0>H ,I6I P J96=N >H L:A;6G:D;I=:EJ7A>86C9B6N86GGNDJI>IHEDL:GH7NA>8:CH:G: D; BDC:N I6M A:KN 6EEGDEG>6I>DC ;>C: >BEG>HDCB:CI 8DC;>H86I>DC 6C9 DI=:G C:8:HH6GN DG 8DCK:C>:CIB:6CH S0>H ,I6I P H9:H8G>7:9I=GDJ<=DJII=>H DBEA6>CII=: >IND; J96=N9:KDI:HHJ7HI6CI>6A ;>C6C8>6AG:HDJG8:HIDEG:K:CI>C<6C9;><=I>C<DE>D>9 G:A6I:9EGD7A:BH>C>IH8DBBJC>I>:H $#$!! #" I6AAG:A:K6CII>B:HI=:&6CJ;68IJG:G :;:C96CIH:68=D;L=DB>H9:;>C:97:ADL B6CJ;68IJG:9 E68@6<:9 9>HIG>7JI:9 B6G@:I:9 69K:GI>H:9 EGDBDI:9 HDA9 6C9 EA68:9 I=: ;DAADL>C<EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>99GJ )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 16 of 106 )5;.)+:;8-8 86,;+: )4- 5/8-,1-5: )4- 8I6K>H :;:C96CIH $69>6C &DGE=>C:HJA;6I: $69>6C + &DGE=>C:HJA;6I::MI:C9:9G:A:6H: 'DG8D !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" D9:>C:E=DHE=6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" :CI6CNAIG6CH9:GB6AHNHI:B & )" !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C9>7JEGD;:C & )" !N9GDBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" &:E:G>9>C:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" &DGE=>C:HJA;6I: & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C96HE>G>C & )" (MNBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9: C9D :;:C96CIH (E6C6 (MNBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9: (E6C6 + (MNBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9::MI:C9:9G:A:6H: 3N9DC: !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C ):G8D8:I (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C ):G8D96C (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C96HE>G>C C9D8:I (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C C9D96C (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C96HE>G>C & )" D9:>C:E=DHE=6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" :CI6CNADG6AIG6CHBJ8DH6A & )" !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C9>7JEGD;:C & )" !N9GDBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" &:E:G>9>C:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" &DGE=>C:HJA;6I: & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C96HE>G>C & )" (MNBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" (MNBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9::MI:C9:9G:A:6H: -:K6 :;:C96CIH 8I>F :CI6CNA8>IG6I:DG6AIG6CHBJ8DH6A :CIDG6 :CI6CNA8>IG6I:7J886AI67A:I & )" D9:>C:E=DHE=6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" :CI6CNADG6AIG6CHBJ8DH6A & )" :CI6CNAIG6CH9:GB6AHNHI:B & )" !N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" &:E:G>9>C:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" &DGE=>C:HJA;6I: & )" (MNBDGE=DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9: & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9::MI:C9:9G:A:6H: & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C & )" (MN8D9DC:=N9GD8=ADG>9:6C9>7JEGD;:C ## :;:C96CIH JG6<:H>8 :CI6CNAIG6CH9:GB6AHNHI:B )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 17 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 18 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 19 of 106 "CI:GC6I>DC6AEA8>C )6G)=6GB68:JI>86A"C8 >H6AHDA>8:CH:9L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C)=6GB68N D6G96H6L=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGD;EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ I6AAI>B:HG:A:K6CI=:G:ID C9D)=6GB68:JI>86AH"C8 C9D!:6AI=,DAJI>DCH"C8 6C9)6G)=6GB68:JI>86A"C8 =6K:7::CJC>;>:9>CDLC:GH=>E6C9>CI:G:HI6C9=6K:68I:9?D>CIAN 6C9>C8DC8:GIG:<6G9>C<I=:68I>K>I>:H6I>HHJ:>CI=>H86H: -=:H::CI>I>:H6G:6AI:G : DI=:G 6C9 I=:N =6K: 8DAA:8I>K:AN 7::C GJC 6H 6 H>C 8DGEDG6I:;DGB6A>I>:H -=JHI=:H::CI>I>:H6G:?D>CIAN6C9H:K:G6AANA>67A:;DGI=:>G8DC9J8IH:I;DGI= =:G:>C -=GDJ<=DJII=>H DBEA6>CI C9D)=6GB68:JI>86AH"C8 C9D!:6AI=,DAJI>DCH"C8 6C9 )6G )=6GB68:JI>86A "C8 6C9 I=:>G G:<>HIG6CI HJ7H>9>6G>:H6C9 6;;>A>6I:H I=6I B6CJ;68IJG: EGDBDI:9>HIG>7JI:6C9H:AAEG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H6G:G:;:GG:9ID8DAA:8I>K:AN6HR C9D S C9DB6CJ;68IJG:HEGDBDI:HH:AAH6C99>HIG>7JI:HDE>D>9H>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H 6C9 >C J96=N >C8AJ9>C< (E6C6 DMNBDGE=DC: =N9GD8=ADG>9: (E6C6 + DMNBDGE=DC: =N9GD8=ADG>9::MI:C9:9 G:A:6H:3N9DC:=N9GD8D9DC:7>I6GIG6I:6C968:I6B>CDE=:C):G8D8:I DMN8D9DC: =N9GD8=ADG>9: 6C9 68:I6B>CDE=:C 6C9 ):G8D96C DMN8D9DC: =N9GD8=ADG>9: 6C9 6HE>G>C C9D6AHDB6CJ;68IJG:H6C9H:AAH<:C:G>8DE>D>9EGD9J8IH7DI=9>G:8IAN6C9I=GDJ<=>IH L=DAAN DLC:9 HJ7H>9>6G>:H >C8AJ9>C< <:C:G>8 DMN8D9DC: DMNBDGE=DC: =N9GDBDGE=DC: 6C9 =N9GD8D9DC:>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H6C9>C J96=N I6AAI>B:HG:A:K6CI=:G:ID C9D68I>K:ANEGDBDI:9I=:H6A:6C9JH:D;>IHDE>D>9 EGD9J8IHI=GDJ<=DJII=:. , >C8AJ9>C<>C0>H8DCH>C6C9 J96=N @#-<)A-.-5,)5:9 :;:C96CI -:K6 )=6GB68:JI>86AH ., "C8 >H 6 :A6L6G: 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6AEA68:D;7JH>C:HH>C'DGI=06A:H):CCHNAK6C>6 -:K6)=6GB68:JI>86AH.,"C8 >H6 L=DAAN DLC:9HJ7H>9>6GND;-:K6)=6GB68:JI>86A"C9JHIG>:H%I9 6C"HG6:A>8DGEDG6I>DC -:K6 )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 20 of 106 )=6GB68:JI>86AH.,"C8 >H6AHDA>8:CH:9L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C)=6GB68ND6G96H6L=DA:H6A: 9>HIG>7JIDGD;EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ :;:C96CI :E=6ADC "C8 >H 6 :A6L6G: 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6A EA68: D; 7JH>C:HH >C G6O:G ):CCHNAK6C>6 "C -:K6 )=6GB68:JI>86A "C9JHIG>:H %I9 68FJ>G:9 :E=6ADC"C8 -:K6)=6GB68:JI>86AH.,"C8 6C9 :E=6ADC"C8 6G:JC>;>:9>CDLC:GH=>E6C9 >CI:G:HI6C9=6K:68I:9?D>CIAN6C9>C8DC8:GIG:<6G9>C<I=:68I>K>I>:H6I>HHJ:>CI=>H86H: -=:H: :CI>I>:H 6G: 8DAA:8I>K:AN GJC 6H 6 H>C 8DGEDG6I:;DGB6A>I>:H (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;I=:H::CI>I>:H6G:6<:CIHD;:68=DI=:GDGLDG@>C 68I>K:8DC8:GIID<:I=:G:>I=:G9>G:8IANDGI=GDJ<=DC:DGBDG:D;I=:>GL=DAAN DLC:9HJ7H>9>6G>:H DG6<:CIHID9:K:ADE<6>CG: H:AA E=6GB68:JI>86A EGD9J8IH I=GDJ<=DJI I=: .C>I:9 ,I6I:H >C8AJ9>C< L>I=>C 0>H8DCH>C 6C9 J96=N (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;-:K6)=6GB68:JI>86A"C9JHIG>:H%I9 B6C6<:H>IH6HH:IHDC6 8DBE6CNL>9:76H>HCDI7NH: -=:H::CI>I>:H6G:6AI:G : H>C 6C9 H:K:G6AAN A>67A: ;DG I=:>G 8DC9J8I H:I ;DGI= =:G:>C -=GDJ<=DJI I=>H DBEA6>CI -:K6 )=6GB68:JI>86AH.,"C8 6C9 :E=6ADC"C8 6C9I=:>G G:<>HIG6CIHJ7H>9>6G>:H6C96;;>A>6I:H 6G:G:;:GG:9ID8DAA:8I>K:AN6HR-:K6 S -:K6B6CJ;68IJG:HEGDBDI:HH:AAH6C99>HIG>7JI:HDE>D>9H>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H 6C9I=GDJ<=DJI J96=N>C8AJ9>C<8I>F;:CI6CNA8>IG6I:6C9 :CIDG6;:CI6CNA7J886A -:K6 6AHDB6CJ;68IJG:HB6G@:IHH:AAH6C99>HIG>7JI:HB6CN<:C:G>8DE>D>9EGD9J8IH>C8AJ9>C<7JICDI )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 21 of 106 A>B>I:9IDBDGE=>C:8D9:>C:DMN8D9DC:;:CI6CNADMNBDGE=DC:B:E:G>9>C:=N9GDBDGE=DC: IG6B69DA6C9=N9GD8D9DC: I6AAG:A:K6CII>B:H-:K668I>K:ANEGDBDI:9I=:H6A:6C9JH:D;>IHDE>D>9EGD9J8IH I=GDJ<=DJII=:. , >C8AJ9>C<>C0>H8DCH>C6C9 J96=N -:K6L6H>CHIGJB:CI6A>CEDEJA6G>O>C< I=:JH:D;;:CI6CNA>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;;GDB I=GDJ<= -:K6 E6>9B>AA>DCHIDE=NH>8>6CH6C9=DHE>I6AIDEGDBDI:L>9:HEG:69EG:H8G>7>C<6C9H6A:D;>IHDE>D>9 EGD9J8IH -:K6B69:I=DJH6C9HD;E6NB:CIHIDE=NH>8>6CHB6CND;L=DBL:G:CDIDC8DAD<>HIH 6C99>9CDIIG:6I86C8:GE6>CDHI:CH>7AN;DG68I>K>I>:H>C8AJ9>C<E6GI>8>E6I>C<DCHE:6@:GHU7JG:6JH EGDK>9>C<8DCHJAI>C<H:GK>8:H6HH>HI>C<>CEDHI B6G@:I>C<H6;:INHJGK:>AA6C8:6C9DI=:GH:GK>8:H 7JI>C;68IID9:8:EI>K:ANEGDBDI:6C9B6M>B>O:I=:JH:D;DE>D>9H "C -:K66 B>AA>DC H:IIA:B:CI ;DG B6G@:I>C< 8I>F ;DG JH:H CDI 6EEGDK:9 7N I=: DD9 6C9 GJ< 9B>C>HIG6I>DC @A-.-5,)5:9 :;:C96CI#D=CHDC#D=CHDC>H6':L#:GH:N8DGEDG6I>DCL>I=>IHEG>C8>E6AEA68: D;7JH>C:HH>C':LGJCHL>8@':L#:GH:N :;:C96CI #6CHH:C )=6GB68:JI>86AH "C8 ; @ 6 (GI=D &8':>A #6CHH:C )=6GB68:JI>86AH "C8 ; @ 6 #6CHH:C )=6GB68:JI>86 "C8 >H 6 ):CCHNAK6C>6 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6AEA68:D;7JH>C:HH>C->IJHK>AA:':L#:GH:N #6CHH:C)=6GB68:JI>86AH"C8 >H6L=DAAN DLC:9HJ7H>9>6GND; :;:C96CI#D=CHDC#D=CHDC (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;#D=CHDC#D=CHDC>HI=:DCAN8DBE6CNI=6IDLCH>C :M8:HH D; E:G8:CI D; #6CHH:C )=6GB68:JI>86AH "C8 UH HID8@ JGI=:G #D=CHDC #D=CHDC B6C6<:H 6C9 8DCIGDAH I=: DE:G6I>DCH D; 6C9 9:G>K:H EGD;>IH 6C9 DI=:G 7:C:;>IH ;GDB I=: 9:K:ADEB:CI6C9H6A:D;#6CHH:C)=6GB68:JI>86AH"C8 UHEGD9J8IH )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 22 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 23 of 106 -=: >IN6AA:<:HI=:JCA6L;JA8DC9J8I7NI=: >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH>H6HJ7HI6CI>6A86JH:;DGI=: KDAJB:D;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9HEA6 0=:CJH:9>CI=>H DBEA6>CII=:I:GBR >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIHSG:;:GH8DAA:8I>K:AN ID &8$:HHDC B:G>HDJG8::G<:C 6G9>C6A 06A &6CJ;68IJG:GH6C9)=6GB68>:H>9:CI>;>:9=:G:>CI=6I6AHD:C<6<:>CI=:9>HIG>7JI>DCD;EG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9EGD9J8IH +-9965 :;:C96CI&8$:HHDC DGEDG6I>DCR&8$:HHDCS>H6 :A6L6G:8DGEDG6I>DCL>I= >IH EG>C8>E6A EA68: D; 7JH>C:HH >C "GK>C< -:M6H &8$:HHDC >H A>8:CH:9 L>I= I=: 0>H8DCH>C )=6GB68ND6G96H6L=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGD;EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ >C0>C9HDG0>H8DCH>C &8$:HHDC>HI=:A6G<:HIE=6GB68:JI>86A9>HIG>7JIDG>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H6C9I=: :><=I=A6G<:HI8DGEDG6I>DC>CI=:. , &8$:HHDC9:A>K:GHDC: I=>G9D;I=:E=6GB68:JI>86AHJH:9>C 'DGI=B:G>86 &8$:HHDC>IHHJ7H>9>6G>:H6C9>IH6;;>A>6I:H9>HIG>7JI:E=6GB68:JI>86AHIDG:I6>A E=6GB68>:H6C9>CHI>IJI>DC6AEGDK>9:GHI=GDJ<=DJII=:.C>I:9,I6I:H>C8AJ9>C<>C0>H8DCH>C6C9 J96=N :IL::C 6C9 &8$:HHDC9>HIG>7JI:9BDG:I=6C B>AA>DC9DH:HD; =N9GD8D9DC:6C9DMN8D9DC:>CID&>AL6J@:: DJCINL=>8=>C8AJ9:HI=: >IND; J96=N "C I=: 7GDJ<=I 6 86H: 6<6>CHI &8$:HHDC ;DG ;6>A>C< ID 9:H> >BEA:B:CI 6C :;;:8I>K: HNHI:B ID 9:I:8I 6C9 G:EDGI HJHE>8>DJH DG9:GH D; 8DCIGDAA:9 HJ7HI6C8:H 9>HIG>7JI:9ID>CI:GC:IE=6GB68N8JHIDB:GH &8$:HHDC6 9:H> !DL:K:G &8$:HHDC 9>9 CDI ;JAAN >BEA:B:CI DG 69=:G: ID >IH DLC 8DBEA>6C8: EGD )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 24 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 25 of 106 :;:C96CI B:G>HDJG8::G<:C GJ< DGEDG6I>DC RB:G>HDJG8::G<:CS >H 6 :A6L6G: 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6A EA68: D; 7JH>C:HH >C =:HI:G7GDD@ ):CCHNAK6C>6 B:G>HDJG8:7:G<:C>HA>8:CH:9L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C)=6GB68ND6G96H6L=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGD; EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ B:G>HDJG8::G<:C>HI=:I=>G9A6G<:HIE=6GB68:JI>86A9>HIG>7JIDG6C9EGDK>9:H E:G8:CID;6AAE=6GB68:JI>86AHHDA9>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H B:G>HDJG8::G<:C>IHHJ7H>9>6G>:H6C9 >IH 6;;>A>6I:H 9>HIG>7JI: E=6GB68:JI>86AH ID G:I6>A E=6GB68>:H 6C9 >CHI>IJI>DC6A EGDK>9:GH >C I=: .C>I:9,I6I:H>C8AJ9>C<I=DH:>C0>H8DCH>C6C9 J96=N :IL::C 6C9 B:G>HDJG8::G<:C9>HIG>7JI:9BDG:I=6C B>AA>DC 9DH:HD;=N9GD8D9DC:6C9DMN8D9DC:>CID&>AL6J@:: DJCINL=>8=>C8AJ9:HI=: >IND; J96=N "C I=: ;DJC9 I=6I B:G>HDJG8::G<:C 9>9 CDI B6>CI6>C :;;:8I>K: 8DCIGDAH6<6>CHI9>K:GH>DCD;=N9GD8D9DC:ID;DJG>CI:GC:IE=6GB68>:H6C9DG9:G:9I=:8DBE6CNID =6AI9>HIG>7JI>DC;GDB>IH ADG>96;68>A>IN "C#6CJ6GN B:G>HDJG8::G<:C6 B>AA>DCIDH:IIA:6A6LHJ>I7GDJ<=I7N0:HI/>G<>C>6UH6IIDGC:N<:C:G6A;DG;6>A>C<IDHJ7B>IG:EDGIH D;HJHE>8>DJHE=6GB68NDG9:GH B:G>HDJG8::G<:C DL:H I=: >IN D; J96=N 6 9JIN D; G:6HDC67A: 86G: L=>8= >C8AJ9:H69JINIDB6>CI6>C:;;:8I>K:8DCIGDAH6<6>CHI9>K:GH>DCD;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H -=GDJ<= >IH K6G>DJH G:<>HI:G:9 HJ7H>9>6G>:H 6C9 6;;>A>6I:9 :CI>I>:H B:G>HDJG8::G<:C 9>HIG>7JI:H E=6GB68:JI>86A 9GJ &>AL6J@:: DJCIN6C9I=: >IND; J96=N )8,15)3 :;:C96CI 6G9>C6A !:6AI= "C8 R 6G9>C6AS >H 6C (=>D 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6AEA68:D;7JH>C:HH>C J7A>C(=>D 6G9>C6A>HA>8:CH:9L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C)=6GB68N )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 26 of 106 D6G96H6L=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGD;EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ 0>H8DCH>C (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:; 6G9>C6A6C9>IHHJ7H>9>6G>:H6C96;;>A>6I:HH:GK>8:BDG: I=6C E=6GB68>:H 6C9 BDG: I=6C E:G8:CI D; . , =DHE>I6AH 6G9>C6A 9>HIG>7JI:H E=6GB68:JI>86AHIDG:I6>AE=6GB68>:H>CHI>IJI>DC6AEGDK>9:GH6C98JHIDB:GH>C6AA;>;INHI6I:H6C9 9D:HHJ7HI6CI>6A7JH>C:HH>CI=:,I6I:D;0>H8DCH>C :IL::C 6C9 6G9>C6A9>HIG>7JI:9 BDG: I=6C B>AA>DC 9DH:H D; =N9GD8D9DC: 6C9 DMN8D9DC: >CID &>AL6J@:: DJCIN L=>8= >C8AJ9:HI=: >IND; J96=N "C I=: 7GDJ<=I686H:6<6>CHI 6G9>C6A;DG;>AA>C<R7A6I6CIANHJHE>8>DJHS DG9:GH;GDBDCA>C:E=6GB68>:H 6G9>C6AE6>96B>AA>DC;>C: "C(8ID7:GD; I=: L:CI6;I:G 6G9>C6A6<6>CHI6I>C<I=:8DBE6CNREDH:96C>BB>C:CI96C<:GIDI=:EJ7A>8=:6AI= 6C9H6;:IN S"C :8:B7:G 6G9>C6A6 6<6>CQ>I=69;>AA:9HJHE>8>DJHDG9:GHD;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H "C#6CJ6GN 6G9>C6A6 E6N B>AA>DCIDH:IIA:6A6LHJ>I7GDJ<=I7N0:HI/>G<>C>6UHIIDGC:N :C:G6A 0:HI/>G<>C>6 6 8DBB>HH>DC:GHD;&8 DL:AA >IN0:HI/>G<>C>6L=>8==6HI=:HI6I:UH=><=:HIG6I:D;9:6I=;GDB EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ<67JH: 6G9>C6A6C9DI=:GL=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGH>C6H>M N:6GE:G>D9H:CI B>AA>DC=N9GD8D9DC:6C9DMN8D9DC:E>AAHID0:HI/>G<>C>6E:GHI6I:G:H>9:CI "CI=6II>B: I=:G:L:G: ;6I6ADK:G9DH:H;GDBI=:699>8I>K:E6>C@>AA:GH &)3/8--59 :;:C96CI 06A EG>C8>E6A EA68: D; 7JH>C:HH >C ::G;>:A9 "AA>CD>H 06A )=6GB68ND6G96H6L=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGD;EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 27 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 28 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 29 of 106 (C :7GJ6GN I=: D6G9 G:EG>B6C9:9 06A &>AL6J@::;DGA:6K>C<I=:@:NHIDI=:8DCIGDAA:9HJ7HI6C8:H>C6EA68::6H>AN688:HH>7A:IDHI6;; L=>8=G:HJAI:9>CI=:I=:;I7N6CJC>9:CI>;>:9>C9>K>9J6AD;I67A:IHD;DMN8D9DC:K6AJ:96I -=:D6G98DC8AJ9:9I=:K>DA6I>DC8DCHI>IJI:9JCEGD;:HH>DC6A8DC9J8I6H9:;>C:97N 0>H ,I6I P 6 (C :7GJ6GN I=: D6G9 6AHD G:EG>B6C9:9 06A E=6GB68N ;DG;6>A>C<IDI>B:ANEGDK>9:>C;DGB6I>DC8DC8:GC>C<I=:ADHHD;I67A:IHD; DMN8D9DC: 06A >CK:HI><6I>DC9>9CDI>9:CI>;NI=:>C9>K>9J6AG:HEDCH>7A:;DGI=:I=:;I (C :8:B7:G I=: D6G9 G:EG>B6C9:9 HIDG: ;DG :C<6<>C< >C JCEGD;:HH>DC6A 8DC9J8I 6H 9:;>C:9 7N 0>H 9B>C D9:P)=6G 7NR;6>A>C<IDEGDE:GANB6>CI6>CI=:H:8JG>IND;68:GI6>C8DCIGDAA:9 HJ7HI6C8:S6;I:G >C8DCIGDAA:9HJ7HI6C8:H>C8AJ9>C<6IA:6HIDC:7DIIA:D;=N9GD8D9DC: L:G:ADHI9J:IDR:BEADN::E>A;:G6<: S !6-9+0-5B9-)3:0+)8- ,*) 451+)8-6. 13=);2-- :;:C96CI+D:H8=:CUH!:6AI=86G:%% 9 7 6(BC>86G:D;&>AL6J@::R(BC>86G: D;&>AL6J@::S>H60>H8DCH>CA>B>I:9A>67>A>IN8DBE6CNL>I=>IHEG>C8>E6AEA68:D;7JH>C:HH>C >C8>CC6I>(=>D (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;I=:HDA:B:B7:GD;+D:H8=:CUH!:6AI=86G:%% >H ':><=7DG86G: )=6GB68N ,:GK>8:H "C8 6 :A6L6G: 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6A D;;>8:H >C >C8>CC6I>(=>D (BC>86G: D; &>AL6J@:: >H A>8:CH:9 L>I= I=: 0>H8DCH>C )=6GB68N D6G9 6C9 DE:G6I:HDC:>C HI6I:E=6GB68N>CI=: >IND;&>AL6J@:: GDB ID (BC>86G: D; &>AL6J@:: 9>HE:CH:9 BDG: I=6C B>AA>DC DMN8D9DC: 6C9 =N9GD8D9DC: E>AAHQBDG: I=6C 6CN DI=:G E=6GB68N >C &>AL6J@:: DJCIN 6C9 C:6GANIL>8:I=:IDI6A9DH6<:6HI=:H:8DC9 =><=:HI9>HE:CH>C<E=6GB68N>C&>AL6J@:: DJCIN )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 30 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 31 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 32 of 106 696C<:GIDI=:=:6AI=L:A;6G:DGH6;:IND;E6I>:CIDGEJ7A>8>C8AJ9>C<7JICDIA>B>I:9IDEG68I>8>C< >C 6 B6CC:G L=>8= HJ7HI6CI>6AAN 9:E6GIH ;GDB I=: HI6C96G9 D; 86G: DG9>C6G>AN :M:G8>H:9 7N 6 E=6GB68>HI L=>8= =6GB:9 DG 8DJA9 =6K: =6GB:9 6 E6I>:CI S -=: D6G9 ;DJC9 I=6I &:9ED>CI R:C<6<:9>CJCEGD;:HH>DC6A8DC9J8I6H9:;>C:97N0>H 9B>C D9:P)=6G 7N;6>A>C<ID G:EDGIIDI=:E=6GB68N:M6B>C>C<7D6G96CNE=6GB68NEG68I>8:L=>8=8DCHI>IJI:H696C<:GIDI=: =:6AI=H6;:INDGL:A;6G:D;E6I>:CIDGEJ7A>8 S%6HIANI=:D6G9;DJC9I=6I&:9ED>CIR:C<6<:9>C JCEGD;:HH>DC6A8DC9J8I6H9:;>C:97N0>H 9B>C D9:P)=6G 7N6>9>C<DG67:II>C< I=:JCA>8:CH:9EG68I>8:D;E=6GB68N S )>=)8, 0)84)+>5+,*)"=)5"-8<$ 0)84)+> :;:C96CI!6NL6G9)=6GB68N"C8 9 7 6,L6C,:GK .)=6GB68NR,L6C,:GK .S>H60>H8DCH>C8DGEDG6I>DCL>I=>IHEG>C8>E6AEA68:D;7JH>C:HH>C06JL6IDH60>H8DCH>C ,L6C ,:GK . >H A>8:CH:9 L>I= I=: 0>H8DCH>C )=6GB68N D6G9 6C9 DE:G6I:9 DC: E=6GB68N >C &>AL6J@:: DJCIN9JG>C<I=:G:A:K6CII>B:E:G>D9 GDB ID ;GDB>IHH>C 9>HE:CH:9 B>AA>DC9DH:HD;DMN8DCI>C6C9=N9GD8D9DC:IDI=:8>I>O:CHD;&>AL6J@:: DJCIN >C8AJ9>C<G:H>9:CIHD;I=: >IND; J96=N $5165"-8<$ 0)84)+> :;:C96CI .C>DC ,:GK . )=6GB68N "C8 R.C>DC ,:GK .S >H 6 0>H8DCH>C 8DGEDG6I>DC L>I= >IH EG>C8>E6A EA68: D; 7JH>C:HH >C &>AL6J@:: 0>H8DCH>C .C>DC ,:GK . >H A>8:CH:9L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C)=6GB68ND6G96C9DE:G6I:9DC:E=6GB68N>C&>AL6J@:: DJCIN 9JG>C<I=:G:A:K6CII>B:E:G>D9 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 33 of 106 GDB ID ;GDB>IHH>C B>AA>DC 9DH:H D; DMN8DCI>C 6C9 =N9GD8D9DC: ID I=: 8>I>O:CH D; &>AL6J@:: DJCIN >C8AJ9>C< G:H>9:CIHD;I=: >IND; J96=N ))*95+ :;:C96CI%667H"C8 R%667HS>H60>H8DCH>C8DGEDG6I>DCL>I=>IHEG>C8>E6AEA68: D;7JH>C:HH>C+68>C:0>H8DCH>C %667HDE:G6I:96E=6GB68N>C&>AL6J@::0>H8DCH>C;DG6EEGDM>B6I:AN N:6GH "C ;:9:G6AI6H@;DG8:6<:CIH;DGI=: D7I6>C:96H:6G8=L6GG6CI>C;JGI=:G6C8:D;6C >CK:HI><6I>DC>CIDA6G<: H86A:9>K:GH>DCD;C6G8DI>8H>CKDAK>C<%667H "CI=: UH6EEA>86I>DC;DG H:6G8=L6GG6CII=:6<:CICDI:HI=6I;GDB ID %667HG:8:>K:9 DMN8D9DC: B< I67A:IH 6C9 DMN8D9DC: B< I67A:IH L=>8= RH> DG9:G:97NA6G<:G:K:CC6I>DC6AAN@CDLCE=6GB68:JI>86A8=6>CH6C9=DJGE=6GB68>:HDE:G6I>C< >CI=:H6B:<:C:G6A<:D HJGG:C9:G:9>IH0>H8DCH>CE=6GB68NA>8:CH:>CEG>AD; GDB ID ;GDB>IHH>C 9DH:HD;DMN8DCI>C6C9=N9GD8D9DC:IDI=:8>I>O:CHD;&>AL6J@:: DJCIN>C8AJ9>C<G:H>9:CIHD; I=: >IND; J96=N $!"# % $ -=>H DJGI =6H ?JG>H9>8I>DC DK:G I=: HJ7?:8I B6II:G D; I=>H 86H: 7:86JH: I=: 6AA:<6I>DCH6C98A6>BH6G:7GDJ<=IJC9:G0>H8DCH>CHI6I:A6L6C9)A6>CI>;;H::@H6C6BDJCID; 96B6<:H>C:M8:HHD;I=:?JG>H9>8I>DC6AB>C>BJB )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 34 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 35 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 36 of 106 "C I=: 9:8A6G:9EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9DK:G9DH:HID7:6IG:8DG9 7G:6@>C< :E>9:B>8A:K:AH6C9L:G:I=:B6>C9G>K:GD;9GJ<DK:G9DH:9:6I=H>CI=:. , "C B>AA>DC DE>D>9EG:H8G>EI>DCHL:G:LG>II:CIDB:G>86CE6I>:CIH &" " B"! & !"" 0>H8DCH>C =6H HJHI6>C:9Q6C9 8DCI>CJ:H ID HJHI6>CQH> :8DCDB>8ADHH:H6H6G:HJAID;I=:DE>D>9:E>9:B>8 )G:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H6G:G:HEDCH>7A:;DGI=: DK:GL=:AB>C<B6?DG>IND;9GJ<ED>HDC>C<9:6I=H>CI=:,I6I: 0>H8DCH>CUHDE>D>9DK:G9DH:9:6I=G6I:>HDC:D;I=:=><=:HI>CI=:C6I>DC "C 6ABDHI E:G8:CID;6AA9GJ<DK:G9DH:9:6I=H>CKDAK:96CDE>D>9 )J7A>8 =:6AI= >HHJ:H 6HHD8>6I:9 L>I= I=: DE>D>9 :E>9:B>8 9:E:C9:C8:6C99:6I= 0>9:HEG:69DE>D>9JH:K>6>CIG6K:CDJH>C?:8I>DC>HG:HEDCH>7A:;DG6C6GG6N D;=:6AI=EGD7A:BH6C9=6H86JH:98D D88JGG>C<:E>9:B>8HD;:C9D86G9>I>H!"/6C9=:E6I>I>H 86H:H>C0>H8DCH>C -=:DE>D>9:E>9:B>8>HBJ8=BDG:I=6C6EJ7A>8=:6AI=>HHJ: "I=6H;6G G:68=>C< 8DCH:FJ:C8:HI=6I6;;:8II=:FJ6A>IND;A>;:6C9:8DCDB>8L:AA 7:>C<D;8DBBJC>I>:H68GDHHI=: ,I6I: -=: 8G>H>H 8G:6I:H 6 H> 6K6>A67>A>IND;EJ7A>8H:GK>8:H # ##( $( (E>D>9 (K:G9DH: )G:H8G>EI>DC (E>D>9H A6HI JE96I:9 J< 6I =IIEH LLL 898 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 37 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 38 of 106 -=:IG:C9>HH::C68GDHH&>AL6J@:: DJCIN (JID;I=:C:6GAN 9GJ<DK:G9DH: 9:6I=H>C&>AL6J@:: DJCINH>C8: BDG:I=6CE:G8:CI 9:6I=H>CKDAK:96CDE>D>9 "C DE>D>9HL:G:>CKDAK:9>CE:G8:CID;6AA9GJ<9:6I=HA6G<:AN9G>K:C7N6R;DJGI=L6K:S HJG<: >C HNCI=:I>8 DE>D>9H HJ8= 6H ;:CI6CNA H D; I=: DE>D>9 DK:G9DH: 9:6I= G6I: >C &>AL6J@:: DJCIN>H99:G6I: 0 ! , 0",!0>H8DCH>C"CI:G68I>K:,I6I>HI>8HDC!:6AI=*J:GN ,NHI:B 0",! *J:GN GJ< (K:G9DH: :6I=H A6HI JE96I:9 :7 6I =IIEH LLL 9=H L>H8DCH>C )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 39 of 106 /-:7+ 6/5/* ;+7*58++'9.8-+*0:89+* '9+ +7 56:2'9/54 /2<':1++ 5:49>'4*!9'9+5,%/8)548/4 95 ,DJG8:0>H8DCH>C :E6GIB:CID;!:6AI=,:GK>8:H ,>C8: I=:G: =6K: 7::C DE>D>9 G:A6I:9 >CE6I>:CI =DHE>I6A HI6NH 6C9 :B:G<:C8N9:E6GIB:CIK>H>IH>C&>AL6J@:: DJCIN -=:G:L:G:BDG:I=6C DE>D>9 G:A6I:9 =DHE>I6A:C8DJCI:GH>C 6ADC: /-:7+ 22 6/5/* +2'9+*586/9'24)5:49+78-+*0:89+* '9+ +7 56:2'9/54 /2<':1++5:49>'4*!9'9+5,%/8)548/4 95 ,DJG8:0>H8DCH>C :E6GIB:CID;!:6AI=,:GK>8:H + 0>H8DCH>C :E6GIB:CI D; !:6AI= ,:GK>8:H 0",! 0>H8DCH>C "CI:G68I>K: ,I6I>HI>8H DC !:6AI= *J:GN ,NHI:B 0",! *J:GN (E>D>9 +:A6I:9 !DHE>I6A C8DJCI:GH A6HI JE96I:9 :7 6I =IIEH LLL 9=H L>H8DCH>C )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 40 of 106 -=:>C8G:6H:>CDE>D>9 G:A6I:99:6I=H6C9DK:G9DH:H>C 8DGG:HEDC9HL>I=I=: >C8G:6H: >C I=: DE>D>9 EG:H8G>7>C< G6I: >C &>AL6J@:: DJCIN I >IH E:6@ >C I=: DE>D>9 EG:H8G>7>C< G6I: >C &>AL6J@:: DJCIN L6H EG:H8G>EI>DCH E:G E:GHDCHQL=>8= B:6CH :CDJ<=DE>D>9EG:H8G>EI>DCHL:G:7:>C<LG>II:C;DG:K:GNG:H>9:CID;&>AL6J@:: DJCINID=6K: DC: "C I=:DK:G6AAC6I>DC6ADE>D>9EG:H8G>7>C<G6I:7:<6CID9:8A>C:6C9>C I=: EG:H8G>7>C<G6I:=69;6AA:CID>IHADL:HIED>CI>C N:6GH &>AL6J@:: DJCIN=6HA6G<:AN;DAADL:9 I=:C6I>DC6AIG:C9 !DL:K:G>C I=:EG:H8G>7>C<G6I:HE>@:9JEL6G9H>C&>AL6J@:: DJCIN H> /-:7+ 6/5/* 7+8)7/(/4- '9+ /2<':1++5:49> '9+ +7 +78548 95 ,DJG8: >GHI G:HEDC9:GH DE:G6I>C< >C &>AL6J@:: DJCIN =6K: G:EDGI:9 6C >C8G:6H>C< CJB7:GD;HJHE:8I:9DE>D>9DK:G9DH:H:K:GNBDCI=H>C8: $" 6050+ 086,4804. !(9, (68 A6HI JE96I:9 :8 6I =IIEH LLL 898 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 41 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 42 of 106 /-:7+ '25=54+*3/4/897'9/54 '6/9>5,:*'.> '4* G:EDGI:9>C8>9:CIH G:EDGI:9>C8>9:CIH ,DJG8:&>AL6J@:: DJCIN(;;>8:D; B:G<:C8N&6C6<:B:CI6C9 J96=N >G: :E6GIB:CI -=:(K:G9DH:&6E>HH=6G:9L>I=!:6AI= :E6GIB:CID;;>8>6AHL=D6AHDBDC>IDG DE>D>9DK:G9DH:HE>@:H>CI=:8DBBJC>IN 0DG@>C<ID<:I=:GI=: J96=N >G: :E6GIB:CI6C9 !:6AI= :E6GIB:CIJI>A>O:I=:(K:G9DH:&6EID:HI67A>H=*J>8@+:HEDCH:-:6BH*+-UH *+-H 8DCH>HID;6CJGH:EDA>8:D;;>8:G6C9G:8DK:GNHJEEDGIHE:8>6A>HIL=DG:K>:LCDC;6I6ADK:G9DH: >C8>9:CIH:HI67A>H=8DCI68IL>I=I=:>C9>K>9J6ADG;6B>AND;I=:>C9>K>9J6A6C9D;;:G6HH>HI6C8:>C D7I6>C>C<IG:6IB:CIH:GK>8:H6H6;DGBD;>CI:GK:CI>DC -=: >IN:ME:C9HH> ID G:9J8: NDJI= HJ7HI6C8: JH: 6C9 EGDBDI: 9GJ< H6;:IN :9J86I>DC #D>C>C< L>I= C:><=7DG>C< BJC>8>E6A>I>:HI=: >IND; J96=N8DCI>CJ:HIDH::@DJIH>9:;JC9>C<6C9E6GIC:GH=>EHID8G:6I: EGD -=: J96=N !:6AI= :E6GIB:CI =6H E6GIC:G:9 L>I= I=: &>AL6J@:: DJCIN ,J7HI6C8:7JH:)G:K:CI>DC D6A>I>DC& ,)>C>IH:;;DGIHIDREG:K:CI6C9G:9J8:HJ7HI6C8: ) + "! 8:67( " + " ! =IIEH LLL 8J96=N L> )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 43 of 106 JH:6C9B>HJH: S& ,)UHEGD D; EG:H8G>EI>DC E>AA 67JH: -=: J96=N !:6AI= :E6GIB:CI 6AHDDE:G6I:H EGD 9>HEDH6A6C9EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ<9>HEDH6A -=:DE>D>9:E>9:B>8G:B6>CH68:CIG6A;D8JHD;I=: J96=N!:6AI= :E6GIB:CI -=: J96=N)DA>8: :E6GIB:CI>CK:HI><6I:9:68=D;I=: ;6I6A9GJ<DK:G9DH:H I=6ID88JGG:9>CI=: >IND; J96=N>C 6C9>9:CI>;>:9;:CI6CNA6H68DCIG>7JI>C<;68IDG>CD; I=DH:86H:H -=:G>H:>C;:CI6CNA>C J96=NEDH:H6C699>I>DC6AI=G:6IIDI=:=:6AI=6C9H6;:IND; ;GDCI A>C:A6L:C;DG8:B:CI>C J96=N -=:DE>D>9:E>9:B>88DCI>CJ:HID9::EAN6;;:8I J96=N -=: >IN=6H:ME:C9:9 I>B:G:HDJG8:H6C9BDC:N8DB76I>C<68G>H>HI=6IDCAN ;ADD9D;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>99GJ DE>D>9:E>9:B>8>C>IH8DBBJC>I>:H -=: >IN8DCI>CJ:HIDJI>A>O:6AA6K6>A67A:G:HDJG8:HID:CHJG: I=:H6;:IN6C9=:6AI=D;>IHG:H>9:CIH % #"B$ &$ $# H>C9>86I:967DK:7:;DG:I=: HDE>D>9HL:G:EG:9DB>C6CIANEG:H8G>7:9;DG 68JI: H=DGI I:GB E6>C HJ8= 6H IG6JB6 DG 86C8:G G:A6I:9 E6>C 88:EI:9 HI6C96G9H D; B:9>86A EG68I>8:9>H8DJG6<:9I=:JH:D;DE>D>9HIDIG:6I8=GDC>8E6>C9J:ID6A68@D;:K>9:C8:I=6IDE>D>9H >BEGDK:9 ;JC8I>DC 6C9 L:G: :;;:8I>K: ;DG :K:GN96N E6>C B6C6<:B:CI "CHI:69 I=: :K>9:C8: 9:BDCHIG6I:9I=6IE6I>:CIH9:K:ADE:9IDA:G6C8:IDDE>D>9HL=>8=>C8G:6H:9I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DC 6C99:6I= &! " , ) , ) 6I =IIEH B8H6E8D6A>I>DC DG< 8D6A>I>DC B8H6E5HIG6I:<>85EA6C E=E ! " + & ! , =IIEH LLL 8J96=N L> )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 44 of 106 -=GDJ<=6L:AA ;JC9:96C99:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<86BE6> 8DCH:CHJH DC I=: 96C<:G D; DE>D>9H :;:C96CIH JH:9 BJAI>EA: K:=>8A:H ID HEG:69 I=:>G ;6AH: 9:8:EI>K:6C9B>HA:69>C<HI6I:B:CIH67DJIDE>D>9HJH>C<6BDC<DI=:GB:6CH EGDEDJC9>C< 6< E6I>:CIH>C J96=N9>HE6I8=>C<HJEEDH:9AN>C9:E:C9:CI6C9JC7>6H:9I=>G9 E6GI>:HID J96=N ID9>HH:B>C6I:;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:HI6I:B:CIH8DC8:GC>C<I=:G>H@H6C97:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H @CDL>C :C<6<>C< >C DI=:G JCA6L;JA JC;6>G 6C9 ;G6J9JA:CI B>H8DC9J8I >C8AJ9>C< I6G<:I>C< HJH8:EI>7A: EG:H8G>7:GH6C9KJAC:G67A:E6I>:CIEDEJA6I>DCH #"!""% ( $ # ( !# !# #!! ! $#" :;:C96CIH>BEA:B:CI:9I=:>G9>G:8IB6G@:I>C<86BE6> <:C:G6AAN6ADC<I=G::IG68@H>C8AJ9>C< 6 >G:8I ID 8DCHJB:G69K:GI>H>C<86BE6> 7 >G:8IH6A:H8DCI68IHL>I==:6AI=86G:EGDK>9:GH6C9 8 )=NH>8>6CHE:6@:GEGD >GHI :68= :;:C96CI 8DC9J8I:9 69K:GI>H>C< 86BE6> 7:C:;>IHD;I=:>G7G6C9:99GJ :;:C96CIHU7G6C9:969H9:8:EI>K:ANEDGIG6N:9I=:7:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8 E6>C DG :M6BEA: C9D 9>HIG>7JI:9 >C J96=N 6C9 B69: 6K6>A67A: DC >IH EJ7A>8 L:7H>I: LLL DE6C6 8DB L=>8= L6H 6K6>A67A: >C J96=N 6 E6BE=A:I EGDBDI>C< (E6C6 + L>I= E=DID L>I=8=GDC>88DC9>I>DCH>BEAN>C<I=6II=:9GJ<LDJA9EGDK>9:ADC< I:GBE6>CG:A>:;6C9;JC8I>DC6A >BEGDK:B:CI )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 45 of 106 C9DUH69K:GI>H>C<86BE6> I>B:H BDG: EDI:CI I=6C BDGE=>C:Q6H 6C 6EEGDEG>6I: IG:6IB:CI DEI>DC ;DG 6 L>9: B6G@:I D; >C9>K>9J6AHL>I=BD9:G6I:8=GDC>8E6>C C9DUHL:7H>I:>C8AJ9:9R)6I>:CI)GD;>A:HSL=>8=L:G: 9:H8G>EI>DCH D; >C9>K>9J6AH L>I= K6G>DJH 8=GDC>8 8DC9>I>DCH >C8AJ9>C< &>@: 6 R N:6G DA9 688DJCI6CIL=D9:K:ADE:969:<:C:G6I>K:9>H89>H:6H:;GDBEA6N>C<;DDI76AA9JG>C<4=>H5NDJC<:G 96NHS>AA6R N:6GDA98DCHIGJ8I>DCLDG@:GL=D9:K:ADE:9ADL768@E6>CS,I:AA66RN:6G DA9H8=DDAH:8G:I6GNSL>I=RDHI:D6GI=G>I>H>CI=:=>E6C9HE>C:S6C906C966RN:6GDA9I:68=:GS L=DHIDEE:9I6@>C<BDGE=>C:7:86JH:RI=:H>9::;;:8IHL:G:>CIDA:G67A: S-=GDJ<=>IHH:G>:HD; G:A6I67A: R)6I>:CI )GD;>A:HS C9D B6G@:I:9 (E6C6 + 6H I=: HDAJI>DC ID 6 7GD69 HE:8IGJB D; 8=GDC>8E6>C>HHJ:H C9D HE:CI B>AA>DCH DC B:9>86A ?DJGC6A 69K:GI>H>C< )JGHJ6CI ID 6 H:IIA:B:CI 6 D;':L2DG@7JI>I8DCI>CJ:HID9>HH:B>C6I:I=:B:AH:L=:G:>C8AJ9>C<>C0>H8DCH>C :;:C96CIHU69K:GI>H>C<:;;DGIH=6K:7::CE6GI>8JA6GAN>CHIGJB:CI6A>CEGDA>;:G6I>C< I=:L>9:HEG:69JH:D;DMN8D9DC:>CI=:,I6I:D;0>H8DCH>C 68= :;:C96CI EGDBDI:9 I=: JH: D; DE>D>9H ;DG 8=GDC>8 E6>C I=GDJ<= H6A:H G:EG:H:CI6I>K:H L=D K>H>I:9 >C9>K>9J6A EG:H8G>7>C< 9D8IDGH 6C9 B:9>86A HI6;; >C I=:>G D;;>8:H :;:C96CIH 9:KDI:9 B6HH>K: G:HDJG8:H ID 9>G:8I H6A:H 8DCI68IH L>I= EG:H8G>7>C< 9D8IDGH -=: 9>HIG>7JI>DC ID =:6AI= 86G: EGDK>9:GH D; EG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9 EGDBDI>DC6A >I:BH A>@: E:CH ;6CCN E68@H 8D;;:: BJ JCEG:8:9:CI:9;DGDE>6I:H6C9DI=:GC6G8DI>89GJ )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 46 of 106 ##6< I=:9GJ<L6H6EEGDK:97NI=: ;DGIG:6IB:CID;H=DGI I:GBE6>CDCAN "C ##HE:CI B>AA>DCHD;9DAA6GHEGDBDI>C<>IH7G6C9:9DE>D>9EGD9J8IH9>G:8IANID9D8IDGH6C9I=:>GE6I>:CIH -:K6EGDBDI:9>IHC6G8DI>8ADAA>EDE8I>F;:CI6CNA;DGB> I=:86C8:GE6>C;DGL=>8=>I=69G:8:>K:9 6EEGDK6A "C -:K6EA:69:9 K>DA6I>DCD;I=: :9:G6A DD9 GJ<6C9 DHB:I>88I ;DG>IHB>HA:69>C<EGDBDI>DCD; 8I>F6C9ILDDI=:G9GJ 0=>A:E6NB:CIH;GDBDE>D>9E=6GB68:JI>86A8DBE6C>:HID>C9>K>9J6AEG:H8G>7>C< E=NH>8>6CH6G:INE>86AANHB6AA>CK6AJ:I=:>BE68IDCEG:H8G>7>C<=67>IH>HFJ>I:A6G<: HIJ9NEJ7A>H=:9>C#&"CI:GC6A&:9>8>C:H=DLHI=:H> E6>9;DG7N6E=6GB68:JI>86A8DBE6CN86C=6K:DCE=NH>8>6CEG:H8G>7>C<G6I:H +:H:6G8=:GH;GDB DHIDC&:9>86A :CI:G:M6B>C:9E=6GB68:JI>86A8DBE6CNE6NB:CIHB69:IDE=NH>8>6CH>C G6C<>C< ;GDB 8DCHJAI>C< ;::H ID B:6AH 6C9 ;DJC9 I=6I 9D8IDGH L=D G:8:>K:9 6CN DE>D>9 E=6GB68:JI>86AB6G@:I>C<>C8G:6H:9I=:>GEG:H8G>7>C<>C LG>I>C<C>C:E:G8:CIBDG:DE>D>9 EG:H8G>EI>DCHI=6C9D8IDGHL=DG:8:>K:9CDB6G@:I>C< "C699>I>DCIDI=:67DK::;;DGIH :;:C96CIHEGDBDI:9I=:>GEGD9J8IH7N 6 -G6>C>C<I=:>GH6A:HG:EG:H:CI6I>K:HIDB>HG:EG:H:CIID>C9>K>9J6AEG:H8G>7:GHI=:G>H@ D;699>8I>DC 7 +:L6G9>C< I=:>G H6A:H G:EG:H:CI6I>K:H ;DG =><= H6A:H L>I= AJMJGN IG>EH AJ8G6I>K: 6CCJ6A7DCJH:H6C9>C8:CI>K:EGD 8 DBE>A>C<EGD;>A:HD;9D8IDGH6C9I=:>GEG:H8G>7>C<=67>IH>CID96I676H:HIDE>CED>CI I=:9D8IDGHEG:H8G>7>C<I=:BDHIE6>CB:9>86I>DC6C9I6G<:I>C<I=:B;DG6B6G@:I>C< D;;:CH>K: 9 "HHJ>C<E6I>:CIHI6GI:G8DJEDCH;DG;G::A>B>I:9 I>B:EG:H8G>EI>DCHD;(MN DCI>C : ,EDCHDG>C<I=:EJ7A>86I>DCD;;6AH:B:9>86AA>I:G6IJG:I=6IHI6I:9EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9 699>8I>DC>HG6G: )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 47 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 48 of 106 >CHIGJ8I>DCH 67DJI 9DH>C< 6C9 69B>C>HIG6I>DC D; I=: 9GJ B6G@:II=:>GDE>D>9EGD9J8IHL>I=DJI9>H8ADH>C<HJ8=>C;DGB6I>DCID8DCHJB:GH6C97NB6@>C< HI6I:B:CIHI=6IL:G:8DCIG6GNIDC:LAN68FJ>G:9H8>:CI>;>8>C;DGB6I>DC &6CNHIJ9>:HEJ7A>H=:9H>C8:I=: UH6EEGDK6AD; :;:C96CIHUDE>D>9EGD9J8IH 9>G:8IAN8DCIG69>8I :;:C96CIHUEGDBDI>DC6AHI6I:B:CIH6C9B6I:G>6AH (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:; :;:C96CIHL:G:6L6G:D;HJ8=HIJ9>:H6I6AAI>B:HG:A:K6CI=:G:ID (C >C;DGB6I>DC 6C9 7:A>:; :;:C96CIH HJEEG:HH:9 9DLCEA6N:9 DG >C9>G:8IAN 6II:BEI:9IDHJEEG:HHI=:9>HH:B>C6I>DCD;C:LAN68FJ>G:9>C;DGB6I>DC67DJII=:G>H@H6C9:;;>868N D;I=:>GDE>D>9EGD9J8IH DAADL>C<B6G@:I6EEGDK6AH;DGI=:>GDE>D>9EGD9J8IH6C9EG>DGID :;:C96CIH D7I6>C:9>C;DGB6I>DCG:<6G9>C<I=: A67:A>C<IDG:;A:8II=6IDE>D>9HH=DJA9DCAN7:JH:96H6A6HIG:HDGI6;I:GCDC DE>D>9IG:6IB:CIH6C9 I=:G6E>:H;6>A :;:C96CIH:C8DJG6<:9B:9>86AEGD;:HH>DC6AHIDEG:H8G>7:=><=:G9DH6<:HD;DE>D>9H 6H6;>GHIG:HEDCH:ID8=GDC>8E6>C>HHJ:H :;:C96CIH6AHD8DCI>CJ:9ID:C8DJG6<:JH:D;DE>D>9H ;DGI=:IG:6IB:CID;8=GDC>8CDC86C8:GE6>C>CE6I>:CIHL>I=6@CDLC=>HIDGND;DE>D>9699>8I>DC :;:C96CIH:BEADN:96C98DCI>CJ:ID:BEADNI=:67DK:9>G:8IB6G@:I>C<EA6CH HIG6I:<>:H6C9B:HH6<:H>C6C96GDJC9 J96=N -=:H:HJHI6>C:96C9DC =6K: C6IJG6AAN 6C9 EG:9>8I67AN G:HJAI:9 >C JCC:8:HH6GN 6C9 JCL6CI:9 DE>D>9 699>8I>DC 67JH: 9>K:GH>DC6C99:6I= H 6 9>G:8I 6C9 ;DG:H::67A: 8DCH:FJ:C8: D; :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I >C8AJ9>C< >IH ;G6J9JA:CI B6G@:I>C< 86BE6> G:HDJG8:HIDEGDK>9:6C9E6N;DGEJ7A>8H6;:INHD8>6AH:GK>8:HEJ7A>86HH>HI6C8:6C9DI=:GH:GK>8:H I=6I=6K:7:8DB:C:8:HH6GN;DG>IHG:H>9:CIH )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 49 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 50 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 51 of 106 GDCI GDJEH9:E:C9:9DC :;:C96CIH;DG;JC9>C< :;:C96CIH:M:G8>H:98DCIGDA DK:GEGD I=:>G8DCI:CI6C97NHEDCHDG>C<I=:>G9>HH:B>C6I>DC "C9D>C<HD :;:C96CIHB69:HJG:I=:H: GDCI GDJEHLDJA9<:C:G6I:DCANI=:B:HH6<:H :;:C96CIHL6CI:9ID9>HIG>7JI: K:CHDI=: GDCI GDJEH=:A9I=:BH:AK:HDJI6H>C9:E:C9:CIJC7>6H:9E6I>:CI6C9E=NH>8>6C69KD86I:H 88DG9>C< ID I=: HHD8>6I:9 )G:HH 6C9 I=: :CI:G ;DG )J7A>8 "CI: B6CJ;68IJG:GH>C8AJ9>C< :;:C96CIHHE:CIBDG:I=6C B>AA>DCC6I>DCL>9:DCAD77N>C<6C9 86BE6> HIG>8I:G DE>D>9 EDA>8>:H HE:CI :;:C96CIH JI>A>O:9 B6CN D; I=: H6B: GDCI GDJEH I=: BDHI EGDB>C:CID;L=>8=6G:9:H8G>7:97:ADL 3+7/)'4 '/45:4*'9/54@ A -=:B:G>86C)6>C DJC96I>DC) G:8:>K:9BDG:I=6C B>AA>DC>C;JC9>C< ;GDBDE>D>9B6CJ;68IJG:GH;GDB JCI>A>I8ADH:9>IH9DDGH>C&6ND; C9D6ADC:EGDK>9:9 BDG:I=6C=6A;D;I=6I;JC9>C< "C 6C9 BDG:I=6C E:G8:CID;) UHDE:G6I>C<7J9<:I86B:;GDB E=6GB68:JI>86A>C9JHIGNHDJG8:H N ) L6H:CI>G:AN9:E:C9:CIDC;JC9H;GDB :;:C96CIH ) >HHJ:9:9J86I>DC I=:7:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C6C9IG>K>6A>O:9I=:>GG>H@HE6GI>8JA6GANI=:G>H@D;699>8I>DC ) 6AHD:C<6<:9>C6H> ID:9J86I:E6I>:CIH67DJII=:RG><=ISIDE6>CIG:6IB:CIC6B:ANDE>D>9H "C ) EJ7A>H=:9 /"+',& *,)-"-$ ," +'"&& % &+ ') +,)&"& + )&*& ! ") %"$" * -=:7DD@L6HEJGEDGI:9ANI=:B:BD>GD;6G:IJGC>C<"G6F 06G K:I:G6C "C G:6A>IN I=: 7DD@ L6H ;JC9:9 7N )JG9J: ## 6C9 C9D 6C9 8=6G68I:G>O:9 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 52 of 106 RJCG:A>:K:9E6>CS6HR69>H:6H:JCID>IH:A;S86AA>C<DE>D>9HRJC9:GJH:9S6C9I=:R E6>CB:9>86I>DCH S-=>HA6C -=:7DD@L6H688DBE6C>:97N68DBE6C>DCL:7H>I:6C9E6>CHJEEDGI IDEGDBDI:DE>D>9JH:6BDC<LDJC9:9K:I:G6CH /-:7+=/9%5:4*8!:7;/;'2:/*+95 '/4 '4'-+3+49,57 +9:74/4-$+9+7'48'4* ".+/7'3/2/+8 "C ) 9>HHDAK:96;I:G,:C6I:>CK:HI><6IDGH7:<6C6H@>C<67DJII=:CDCEGD;>I G:8:>K>C<C:6GAN E:G8:CID;>IH;JC9>C<;GDBE=6GB68:JI>86A8DBE6C>:H AAD;) UHEGD 6C97:A>:;L:G:>CI:C9:9IDG:68=E=NH>8>6CHE6I>:CIHE=6GB68N7:C:;>IHB6C6<:GH9>HIG>7JIDGH E=6GB68>:H6C98DCHJB:GH>C J96=N =09 &5:4+8 ":7;0;(2 :0+, 95 (04 (4(.,3,49 -57 !,9:7404. %,9,7(48 (4+ #/,07 (3020,8 ) ) =IIE L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7 =IIE LLL E6>C;DJC96I>DC DG< A:6GC EGD )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 53 of 106 3+7/)'4)'*+3>5, '/4 +*/)/4+@ S -=: B:G>86C 869:BN D; )6>C &:9>8>C: )& L>I= I=: 6HH>HI6C8: EGDBEI>C< >CKDAK:B:CI 6C9 ;JC9>C< D; :;:C96CIH HEDCHDG:9 I=: EJ7A>86I>DC D; DE>D>9 EG:H8G>7>C<6C9E6>CIG:6IB:CI <6K: :;:C96CIHU JC7G6C9:9 B6G@:I>C< B:HH6<:H A:<>I>B68N 6C9 8G:9>7>A>IN >C I=: B:9>86A 8DBBJC>IN GDB ID )& G:8:>K:9 B>AA>DC >C ;JC9>C< ;GDB DE>D>9 B6CJ;68IJG:GH >C8AJ9>C< :;:C96CIH )& B6>CI6>C:9 6 8DGEDG6I: G:A6I>DCH 8DJC8>A L=DH: B:B7:GHL:G:E6>9 E:GN:6GDCIDED;DI=:G;JC9>C<IDE6GI>8>E6I: &:B7:GH=>E>CI=: 8DGEDG6I:G:A6I>DCH8DJC8>A6AADL:99GJ<8DBE6CN:M:8JI>K:H6C9B6G@:I>C<HI6;;IDB::IL>I= )& :M:8JI>K: 8DBB>II:: B:B7:GH >C HB6AA H:II>C 8I6K>H6C9DI=:GHL:G:B:B7:GHD;I=:8DJC8>A6C9EG:H:CI:99:8:EI>K:EGD 6II:C9:9 )&UH 6CCJ6A B::I>C :BE=6H>O:9H:HH>DCHDCDE>D>9H )&UHEG:H>9:CIH=6K:>C8AJ9:9>C9JHIGNHJEEDGI:9$(%H GH ,8DII >H=B6C ):GGN >C:6C9+JHH:A)DGI:CDN )6HI)&EG:H>9:CI G ,8DII >H=B6CHI6I:9I=6I=:LDJA9 EA68:I=:DG<6C>O6I>DCR6II=:;DG:;GDCISD;I:68=>C<I=6IRI=:G>H@HD;699>8I>DC6G:I=:G:7JII=:N 6G:HB6AA6C986C7:B6C6<:9 SCDI=:GE6HI)&EG:H>9:CI G ):GGN >C:D;0>H8DCH>C=6H 69B>II:9IDH:GK>C<DCI=:69K>HDGN7D6G9HD;8I6K>H6C9IDH:GK>C<6H6E6>98DCHJAI6CIID## )&JC9:GHIDD9I=6I>I6C9>IH>C9JHIGN;JC9:GHL:G::C<6<:9>C68DBBDCI6H@ :;:C96CIHL:G:67A:ID>C;AJ:C8:)&I=GDJ<=7DI=I=:>GH> D; EGD DE>D>9 $(%H L>I=>C I=: DG<6C>O6I>DC )&UH L:7H>I: FJ>8@AN 7:86B: 6 =J7 ;DG EGD DE>D>96GI>8A:H6C9I=:A6I:HI>CR)6>C':LH S )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 54 of 106 /-:7+ '/4 +<8 #/, />80*0(4B8 %50*, 04 (04 ,+0*04, - " ) & =IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7 =IIE LLL E6>CB:9 DG< A6HIK>H>I:9DCJ< )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 55 of 106 "C )&6C9I=:B:G>86C)6>C,D8>:IN),?D>CIAN>HHJ:968DCH:CHJH HI6I:B:CI! * ' ("'" * ')+! ) +% &+' !)'&" "&L=>8=:C9DGH:9DE>D>9HIDIG:6I 8=GDC>8E6>C6C98A6>B:9I=:G:L6H6ADLG>H@I=6IE6I>:CIHLDJA97:8DB:699>8I:9IDDE>D>9H -=:8D 6JI=DGD;I=:HI6I:B:CI G # 6K>9!699DML6H6II=6II>B:6E6>9HE:6@:G;DGI=: E=6GB68:JI>86A>C9JHIGN )&6C9),>HHJ:9I=:>GDLC 6C98DCI>CJ:9IDG:8DBB:C9JH>C<DE>D>9HIDIG:6I8=GDC>8E6>C DJGI::CD;I=:IL:CIN DC:E6C:A B:B7:GH L=D 9G6;I:9 I=: J>9:A>C:H >C8AJ9>C< $(% :;:C96CIH G )DGI:CDN 6C9 G >C: G:8:>K:9;>C6C8>6AHJEEDGI;GDB## C9D6C9)JG9J: :HE>I:A>B>I:9DGCDHJEEDGI>C<:K>9:C8: I=:)& ), J>9:A>C:HEGDBDI:DE>D>9H6HRH6;:6C9:;;:8I>K:S;DGIG:6I>C<8=GDC>8E6>C6C9 8DC8AJ9:I=6II=:G>H@D;699>8I>DC>HB6C6<:67A:;DGE6I>:CIHG:<6G9A:HHD;E6HI67JH:=>HIDG>:H -=:)& ), J>9:A>C:HL:G:6E6GI>8JA6GAN:;;:8I>K:8=6CC:AD;9:8:EI>DC6C9 >C;AJ:C8:9CDIDCANIG:6I>C<E=NH>8>6CH7JI6AHDI=:7D9ND;H8>:CI>;>8:K>9:C8:DCDE>D>9H -=: )& ), J>9:A>C:H=6K:7::C8>I:9=JC9G:9HD;I>B:H>C6869:B>8A>I:G6IJG: -=: J>9:A>C:H L:G:9>HH:B>C6I:9>C6C96GDJC9 J96=N9JG>C<I=:G:A:K6CII>B:E:G>D96G:HI>AA6K6>A67A:DC A>C:6C9L:G:G:EG>CI:9>CI=:#DJGC6AD;)6>C #/,$8,5- 6050+8-579/,#7,(93,495-/7540* (04548,48:8"9(9,3,49-7539/,3,70*(4*(+,3> 5- (04 ,+0*04, (4+ 9/, 3,70*(4 (04 "5*0,9> # ) =IIEH LLL ?E6>C DG< 6GI>8A: , E9; )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 56 of 106 -.-5,)5:95.13:8):-,++8-,1:15/59:1:;:1659:68-):-) -=":)5,)8, 6.)8-.68:0-#8-):4-5:6. )15)5, 8-9+81*15/6. 7161,8;/9 -=: A6JC9GN A>HI D; JC9:G=6C9:9 I68I>8H JI>A>O:9 7N >C9JHIGN GDCI GDJEH >H :MI:CH>K:6C98DCI>CJ:HID EGDBDI:L>9:HEG:69DE>D>9JH:7N8=6C<>C<DE>D>9EG:H8G>7>C< E6>C "C9D>C<HD :;:C96CIHHJ88:HH;JAAN8G:6I:968JAIJG:D;:A>B>C6I>C<E6>C6I6AA8DHIH "C I=: #D>CI DBB>HH>DC L=>8= 688G:9>IH . , =DHE>I6AH >HHJ:9 C:L HI6C96G9HI:AA>C<=DHE>I6AHIDG: -=:CDL ;6B>A>6GE6>CH86A:L6H>CIGD9J8:9>CB6CN=DHE>I6AHL>I=E6I>:CIH7:>C<6H@:9IDG6I: I=:>GE6>C;GDB ID 6C98>G8A:6HB>A>C<DG;GDLC>C<;68: /-:7+ '/488+883+49!)'2+ .C9:G6C6 9GJ<8DBE6CN6AADL:9ID9>HIG>7JI::9J86I>DC6AB6I:G>6AH6C967DD@67DJIE6>CB6C6<:B:CI 6K>90 6@:G#/,5049533088054B8 (04"9(4+(7+8 70.048(4+;52:9054-# &6N =IIEH LLL ?D>CI8DBB>HH>DC DG< 6HH:IH )6>C5,I95!>HIDGN50:75/:GH>DC5 E9; (04 88,883,49 ) ) =IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7 =IIE LLL E6GIC:GH6<6>CHIE6>C 8DB >C9:M BE 6HEMH>96>9A6HIK>H>I:9J< + 6I6C8:67(CDI: )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 57 of 106 88DG9>C<IDI=: DK:GCB:CI88DJCI67>A>IN(;;>8:)JG9J:UHE6GI>8>E6I>DC>CI=:H:8DCI>CJ>C< B:9>86A:9J86I>DC68I>K>I>:HL>I=I=:#D>CI DBB>HH>DC;68>A>I6I:9 EGDBDI:(MN DCI>C "C I=: :9:G6I>DC D; ,I6I: &:9>86A D6G9H ,& BD9>;>:9 >IH DE>D>9 EG:H8G>7>C< HI6I: B:9>86A 7D6G9H -=: G:K>H:9 E=6GB68:JI>86A>C9JHIGN 99>I>DC6AAN :;:C96CIH JC9:GIDD@ ID 6HHJG: EG:H8G>7>C< E=NH>8>6CH I=6I I=:N LDJA9 CDI ;68: 8G>B>C6A A>67>A>IN DG 69B>C>HIG6I>K: H6C8I>DC>C< ;DG DK:G EG:H8G>7>C< DE>D>9 B:9>86I>DCH "C )&),6C9I=:B:G>86C,D8>:IND;99>8I>DC&:9>8>C:,& 8G:6I:96C9D;;>8>6AAN69DEI:968DCH:CHJH9D8JB:CI)J7A>8)DA>8N,I6I:B:CIDCI=:+><=IH6C9 +:HEDCH>7>A>I>:HD;!:6AI= 6G:)GD;:HH>DC6AH>CI=:.H:D;(E>D>9H;DGI=:-G:6IB:CID;)6>C -=: 9D8JB:CI L6H EJ7A>H=:9 7N I=: ,& 6C9 L6H 6JI=DG:9 6C9 ;JC9:9 7N E=6GB68:JI>86A 8DBE6C>:H>C8AJ9>C<)JG9J: C9D6C9DI=:GHL>I=EGD8::9H "C I=: :CI:G ;DG &:9>86G: &:9>86>9 ,:GK>8:H A6JC8=:9 6 E6I>:CI H6I>H;68I>DCHJGK:N;DG=DHE>I6AHI=6I8DCI6>C:9I=G::FJ:HI>DCHDCE6>CB6C6<:B:CIH6I>H;68I>DC -=>HHJGK:NI=:!DHE>I6A DCHJB:GHH:HHB:CID;!:6AI=86G:)GDK>9:GH6C9,NHI:BH,JGK:NL6H JH:9ID;>C6C8>6AANG:L6G9DGE:C6A>O:=DHE>I6AH6C97:86B:6H> + + ",,,. DC6A9& DA9:C76JB:I6A />80*0(48/(7.,+<09/ 6050+4(2.,80* 7,8*70)04. --,48,8 ) & E=NH>8>6C E6C:A L=>8= >C8AJ9:9 G >H=B6C >HHJ:9 6 G:EDGI 8DC8AJ9>C< I=6I U384G>B>C6ADG69B>C>HIG6I>K:8=6G<:H6C9H6C8I>DCH;DGEG:H8G>7>C<DE>D>96C6A<:H>8H6G:G6G: "C699>I>DCI=:G:6EE:6GH ID7:A>IIA:D7?:8I>K:76H>H;DG8DC8:GCI=6IE6>CHE:8>6A>HIH=6K:7::CWH>C )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 58 of 106 EG:H8G>7>C<7NE=NH>8>6CH -=:E6>CB6C6<:B:CIFJ:HI>DCHL:G:;>C6AAN9>H8DCI>CJ:96HE6GID;I=: ;DGBJA6IDE:C6A>O:E=NH>8>6CH;>C6C8>6AAN>C :;:C96CIH 8DCI>CJ: ID HE:C9 ;6G BDG: I=6C 6CN DI=:G >C9JHIGN ID >C;AJ:C8: EDA>I>8>6CH "C 6ADC:I=:E=6GB68:JI>86A>C9JHIGNQL=>8==6H67DJIILDAD77N>HIH;DG:K:GN B:B7:GD; DC 6AHD8DCIG>7JI:9BDG:I=6C B>AA>DC9>G:8IANIDEDA>I>86A86BE6> H6A:HG:68=:9 7>AA>DC>C :;:C96CIH :BEADN:9 6C9 8DCI>CJ: ID :BEADN I=: 67DK: JC7G6C9:9 B6G@:I>C< EA6CHHIG6I:<>:H6C9B:HH6<:H>C6C96GDJC9 J96=N6C9=6K:9>G:8I:9I=:B6I J96=N>C8AJ9>C< >IH E=NH>8>6CH 6C9 E6I>:CIH -=:H: HJHI6>C:9 6C9 DC EG:9>8I67ANG:HJAI:9>CJCC:8:HH6GN6C9JCL6CI:9DE>D>9699>8I>DC67JH:9>K:GH>DC6C99:6I=>C J96=N6C9HJGGDJC9>C<8DBBJC>I>:H H69>G:8I6C9;DG:H::67A:8DCH:FJ:C8:D; :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I J96=N=6HHJ;;:G:9IG:B:C9DJH>C?JGN6C996B6<:H -.-5,)5:9!-+8;1:-,@-> 715165 -),-89A:6 -87-:;):-&1,-978-), ++-7:)5+-6. 7161,9.68:0-#8-):4-5:6.08651+ )15 "I L6H :;:C96CIHU B>HH>DC ID 8=6C<: I=: 9:;>C>I>DC D; R699>8I>DC S )GDB>C:CI 9D8IDGHQE6>97N :;:C96CIHQL:G:HDB:D;I=:BDHIEGDA>;>8HED@:HE:DEA:>CI=:8DCI>CJDJH6C9 DC :;:C96CIH :BEADN:9 $:N (E>C>DC %:69:GH $(%H ID EGDBDI: 6C9 A:C9 A:<>I>B68N ID I=:>G 86BE6> >9:CI>;>:9G:8GJ>I:9IG6>C:96C9E6>9$(%HIDEJ7A>8AN:C9DGH:DE>D>9JH:IDIG:6I8=GDC>8E6>C ,E:8>;>86AAN$(%E:GE:IJ6I:9;6AH:HI6I:B:CIH67DJI " !,35;,8 (04 (4(.,3,49 :,890548 -753 " ":7;,> , " 'DK =IIE LLL 6H6=F DG< 69KD868N ;96 6C9 L6H=>C )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 59 of 106 6 I=:H6;:IND;DE>D>9H;DGADC< I:GBJH:DG8=GDC>8CDC86C8:G G:A6I:9JH: 7 I=::;;:8I>K:C:HHD;DE>D>99GJ 8 I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DCDK:G9DH:6C99:6I=6HHD8>6I:9L>I=DE>D>9JH: 9 I=:EG:K6A:C8:D;JCIG:6I:9DGJC9:GIG:6I:9E6>C>CI=:. , : I=: :;;>868N D; HD 86AA:9 R67JH: 9:I:GG:CIS G:;DGBJA6I>DCH D; DMN8D9DC: 6C9 =N9GD8D9DC: ; I=:JC9:GAN>C<86JH:HD;DE>D>9 G:A6I:9DK:G9DH:9:6I=H < I=:6EEGDEG>6I:C:HHD;DE>D>9H;DGI=:IG:6IB:CID;CDC86C8:GE6>C>CE6I>:CIHL>I= 6@CDLC=>HIDGND;DE>D>9699>8I>DC6C9 = I=:H6;:IND;C:6G A>B>IA:HH9DH6<::H86A6I>DCH :86JH:D;I=:>GG:HE:8I:9EDH>I>DCH>CI=:>C9JHIGN6C9I=:;JC9>C<EGDK>9:9I=:B 7N&6CJ;68IJG:G6C9 >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH$(%HL:G:>C6C69K6CI6<:DJHEDH>I>DCID8DCK>C8: DI=:GE=NH>8>6CH6C9G:H:6G8=:GHID7:A>:K:;6AH:6C9B>HA:69>C<HI6I:B:CIH67DJIEG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9H &6CJ;68IJG:G6C9 >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIHE6>9$(%HID9:A>K:G8DCI>CJ>C<B:9>86A :9J86I>DC & 8DCI:CI<>K:I6A@HIDHE:8>6A>HIH6C9DI=:G>BEDGI6CIE=NH>8>6C EG:H:CI6I>DCH6ILDG@H=DEH6C98DC;:G:C8:H6C9:K:C<>K:IG6>C>C<H:HH>DCH;DGI=:>GE=NH>8>6C E::GH ,JEEDGI;GDB&6CJ;68IJG:G6C9 >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH=:AE:9$(%H7:8DB:G:HE:8I:9 >C9JHIGN:ME:GIH HI=:NGDH:IDEGDB>C:C8:$(%HIDJI:9I=:7:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9HIDIG:6I8=GDC>8 E6>C 6C9 69K6C8:9 :;:C96CIHU 8DAA:8I>K: EGD DE>D>9 6<:C96 $(%HU EGD;:HH>DC6A G:EJI6I>DCH 7:86B:9:E:C9:CIDC8DCI>CJ>C<IDEGDBDI:6EGD DE>D>9B:HH6<::K:C>C68I>K>I>:HI=6IL:G:CDI 9>G:8IAN;JC9:97N&6CJ;68IJG:G6C9 >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH $(%H9G6;I:98DCHJAI:9DC:9>I:96C9A:CII=:>GC6B:HID7DD@H6C96GI>8A:HDC DE>D>9H -=:N6AHD<6K:HE::8=:H6C9 & HHJEEDGI>K:D;8=GDC>8DE>D>9I=:G6EN &6CJ;68IJG:G 6C9 >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH 8G:6I:9 DEEDGIJC>I>:H ;DG $(% ID E6GI>8>E6I: >C G:H:6G8= HIJ9>:H )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 60 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 61 of 106 :;:C96CIHUEGD DE>D>9B:HH6<: 0=>A:69KD86I>C<;DGDE>D>9I=:G6E>:H>C8=GDC>8E6>CE6I>:CIH G )DGI:CDNG:8:>K:9G:H:6G8=HJEEDGI8DCHJAI>C<;::H6C9=DCDG6G>6;GDB C9D-:K66C9## 6BDC<DI=:GH G )DGI:CDNDE:C:9I=:9DDG;DGI=:G: !:H:GK:9DCI=:B:G>86C)6>C,D8>:IN6C9B:G>86C869:BND;)6>C&:9>8>C: J>9:A>C:H DBB>II::HL=>8=:C9DGH:9I=:JH:D;DE>D>9HIDIG:6I8=GDC>8E6>C;>GHI>C 6C96<6>C>C !: L6H 6AHD 6 B:B7:G D; I=: 7D6G9 D; I=: B:G>86C )6>C DJC96I>DC 6C 69KD868N DG<6C>O6I>DC6ABDHI:CI>G:AN;JC9:97N :;:C96CIH G )DGI:CDN L6H >CHIGJB:CI6A >C I=: EGDA>;:G6I>DC D; :;:C96CIHU EGD DE>D>9 B:HH6<>C< G )DGI:CDN L6H DC: D; I=: ;>GHI E=NH>8>6CH ID 68I>K:AN EGDBDI: I=: JCHJEEDGI:9 6HH:GI>DCI=6I;:L:GI=6C E:G8:CID;DE>D>9JH:GH7:86B:699>8I:9 G )DGI:CDND;I:C8>I:96 ':L C /-:7+**/)9/54 '7+/4 '9/+498"7+'9+* +JHH:AA$ )DGI:CDN$6I=A::C& DA:N/7540*$8,5- 6050+4(2.,80*804 54 (20.4(49 (04 !,65795- (8,8) U0:8DC8AJ9:I=6IDE>D>9B6>CI:C6C8:I=:G6EN86C7:6H6;:H6AJI6GN6C9 BDG:=JB6C:6AI:GC6I>K:IDI=:DEI>DCHD;HJG<:GNDGCDIG:6IB:CI>CI=DH:E6I>:CIHL>I=>CIG68I67A:CDC B6A> )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 62 of 106 -=: HIJ9N HJBB6G>O:9 >C I=: 67DK: LDG9 A:II:G >CKDAK:9 I=: 6C6ANH>H D; 6 96I676H:D;=DHE>I6A>O:9E6I>:CIHL=DL:G:<>K:C6HA>IIA:6H6H>C 8DCIGDAA:9H:II>C<;DG6H=DGIE:G>D9D;I>B:ID:6H:68JI:E6>C AI=DJ<=I=:HIJ9N=69CDI=>C<ID 9DL>I=EG:H8G>7>C<DE>D>9H;DGI=:IG:6IB:CID;8=GDC>8CDC86C8:GE6>C>IL6H8>I:9G:E:6I:9AN 7N G )DGI:CDN6C9DK:G I>B:H>CI=:C:MI N:6GH7N :;:C96CIH6C9I=:>G GDCI GDJEHID EGDK>9:HJEEDGI;DGI=:>9:6I=6IJCIG:6I:9E6>CL6H6CR:E>9:B>8S6C9I=6IDE>D>9H86C6C9BJHI 7:A>7:G6AANEG:H8G>7:9 -=:6JI=DGHD;I=: HIJ9N=6K:HI6I:9I=6II=:>G;>C9>C R"UB:HH:CI>6AANBDGI>;>:9I=6II=6IA:II:GIDI=::9>IDGL6HJH:96H6C:M8JH:ID9DL=6II=:H:9GJ< 8DBE6C>:H 9>9 S JI I=: 96B6<: =69 7::C 9DC: -=:H: >9:6H FJ>8@AN G:68=:9 B6>CHIG:6B B:9>8>C: HEA6CC:96C9>CI:C9:9DE>D>9EG:H8G>EI>DCH;DG8DBBDC6>AB:CIHA>@:768@E6>C 6GI=G>I>H6C9=:6968=:HHJG<:9 "C I=: B:G>86C )6>C ,D8>:IN ), D; L=>8= G )DGI:CDN L6H 6AHD EG:H>9:CI>C;6BDJHAN:C9DGH:9I=:8DC8:EID;E6>C6HRI=: >;I=/>I6A,> BDC>IDG6ADC :CHJG:9I=6I>ILDJA97:8DB:8DBBDCEG68I>8:;DG=:6AI=86G:EGDK>9:GHID6H@67DJIE6>CL=:C 8DC9J8I>C<E6I>:CI:K6AJ6I>DCH GDBI=>HI=:>9:6IDD@=DA9I=6IB:G>86L6HC::9A:HHANJC9:GIG:6I>C<E6>C -=: 8DC8:EID;E6>C6H6R >;I=/>I6A,> 6C9I=:#D>CI DBB>HH>DC G )DGI:CDNA6I:G69B>II:9I=6II=:8A6>BL6HCDI76H:9DCHDJC9 ,6G6=2=6C<#/, 4, (7(.7(6/,99,7-753 #/(9:,2,+9/, 6050+70808- #JC =IIEH LLL I=:6IA6CI>8 8DB =:6AI= 6G8=>K: C:?B A:II:G DE>D>9H 6I6C8:67(CDI: + )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 63 of 106 H8>:CI>;>8:K>9:C8: R"<6K:>CCJB:G67A:A:8IJG:H>CI=:A6I: H6C9 H67DJI699>8I>DCI=6I L:G:CUIIGJ:S G )DGI:CDNH6>9>C6 K>9:DI6E:9>CI:GK>:LL>I=6;:AADL9D8IDG G )DGI:CDNL>I=;JC9>C<6C9HEDCHDGH=>E;GDBDI=:G :;:C96CIH6JI=DG:96C9 8DCIG>7JI:9 ID CJB:GDJH B:9>86A ?DJGC6A 6GI>8A:H I=6I IDJI:9 I=: 7:C:;>IH D; R67JH: 9:I:GG:CIS G:;DGBJA6I:9 DMN8D9DC: ;DG I=: IG:6IB:CI D; 8=GDC>8 CDC86C8:G E6>C 0>I=DJI HJEEDGI>C< :K>9:C8: G )DGI:CDNE:GE:IJ6I:9I=:>9:6I=6IR67JH: 9:I:GG:CISG:;DGBJA6I>DCHD;DMN8D9DC: 6C9=N9GD8D9DC:L:G:H6;:G6C9A:HH699>8I>K: "C#JAND; I=: . & $& ',)&$' " "& EJ7A>H=:96G:IG68I>DCD;I=: DC: E6G6 I=:>CIGD9J8I>DCD;(MN DCI>C S-=:G:IG68I>DCD7H:GK:HI=6II=:DE>D>9:E>9:B>8>CB:G>86 R6GDH:>CE6GI7:86JH:E=NH>8>6CHL:G:IDA9I=6II=:G>H@D;699>8I>DCL6HADLL=:CDE>D>9HL:G: EG:H8G>7:9;DG8=GDC>8E6>CS6C9I=6IR465DC: E6G6 L6HL>9:AN>CKD@:9>CHJEEDGID;I=>H8A6>B:K:CI=DJ<=CD:K>9:C8:L6HEGDK>9:97NI=: 8DGG:HEDC9:CIH S"BEDGI6CIANI=:6JI=DG8DC8AJ9:H6H;DAADLH 405:;DJC9I=6I6;>K: H:CI:C8:A:II:GEJ7A>H=:9>CI=:#DJGC6A>C L6H=:6K>AN 6C9JC8G>I>86AAN8>I:96H:K>9:C8:I=6I699>8I>DCL6HG6G:L>I=ADC< I:GBDE>D>9 I=:G6EN 0:7:A>:K:I=6II=>H8>I6I>DCE6II:GC8DCIG>7JI:9IDI=:'DGI=B:G>86C DE>D>98G>H>H7N=:AE>C<IDH=6E:6C6GG6I>K:I=6I6AA6N:9EG:H8G>7:GHU8DC8:GCH67DJI I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DC6HHD8>6I:9L>I=ADC< I:GBDE>D>9I=:G6EN + ",,,.+JHH:AA$ )DGI:CDN:I6A 54.#,73$8,5-5497522,+!,2,(8, =>*5+54,-57 54*(4*,7 (04!,8:2985-(',(7!,.0897>"9:+> # ) ;>C9>C<I=6II=:UBDHI8DBBDC69K:GH: :K:CIH3D;8DCIGDAA:9 G:A:6H:DMN8D9DC:4L:G:8DCHI>E6I>DC6C9C6JH:66C9I=:>C8>9:C8:D;I=:H::K:CIH9:8A>C:9 DK:GI>B:DCIG:6IB:CIV6C9I=6IU3>4CK:HI><6IDGHG:EDGI:986H:H D;EDHH>7A:9GJ<B>HJH:7JICD:K>9:C8:D; 9: CDKD 699>8I>DC L6H D7H:GK:9V =IIEH ?DJGC6AH ALL 8DB 8A>C>86AE6>C 7HIG68I %DC<5I:GB5.H:5D;5 DCIGDAA:95G:A:6H:5(MN8D9DC:5;DG 6HEM )6B:A6%:AJC9:I6A ,99,7549/,!0815- 6050+++0*9054' # & #JC =IIEH LLL C:?B DG< 9D> ' #&8 + :BE=6H>H699:9 + )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 64 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 65 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 66 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 67 of 106 ;>GHI A>C:I=:G6EN S "I>H>BEDGI6CI G >H=B6C6C9 G >C:6G DE>D>9 G:A6I:99:6I=HRH=DJA9CDIG:9J8:688:HHIDC::9:9I=:G6E>:H S NG:8GJ>I>C<IGJHI:9E=NH>8>6CHID7:@:NDE>C>DCA:69:GH :;:C96CIH:MEAD>I:9 I=:;6>I=I=6IHD8>:INEA68:H>C9D8IDGHIDEGDBDI: >CHIGJB:CI6A>C :;:C96CIHU:;;DGIHID;G6B:DE>D>9H6HH6;:;DG8=GDC>8JH: $(%H=:AE:9EGD9J8: C:LEGD DE>D>98A>C>86AEG68I>8: G: #" ! # ( "! !" # # !"" #" "$ ! !#( !"! # " !! :;:C96CIH :C<6<:9 >C ;6AH: 6C9 B>HA:69>C< 8DC9J8I L=>8= >CI:CI>DC6AANB>HG:EG:H:CI:9I=:G>H@H7:C:;>IH6C9HJE:G>DG>IND;DE>D>9H :;:C96CIHI6G<:I:9I=:B:9>86A8DBBJC>IN6C9I=:EJ7A>8L>I=;6AH:>C;DGB6I>DC 6C98DCK>C8:9I=:BI=6IDE>D>9HL:G:CDC 699>8I>K:6C9H6;:;DGADC< I:GBJH:;DGI=:IG:6IB:CI D;CDC86C8:G G:A6I:9E6>C6I=><=9DH6<:H :;:C96CIH HJ88:HH;JAAN 8DCK>C8:9 9D8IDGH 6C9 E6I>:CIH I=6I DE>D>9H 6G: CDI 699>8I>K:I=6IDE>D>9H6G:H6;:;DGADC< I:GBJH:6C9I=6I8DBE6HH>DC6I:IG:6IB:CID;E6>CG:FJ>G:H DE>D>9H "CHD9D>C< :;:C96CIH@CDL>C 6C97:C:;>IHD;ADC< I:GBDE>D>9JH:I=6IL:G:CDIHJEEDGI:97NDGL:G:8DCIG6GNIDH8>:CI>;>8 :K>9:C8: + + )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 68 of 106 :HE>I: 8DC;A>8I>C< :K>9:C8: <:C:G6I:9 7N :;:C96CIHU DLC G:H:6G8= HIJ9>:H 6 :;:C96CIH=6K:CDI8DGG:8I:9I=:>G8A6>BH67DJIDE>D>9H6C98DCI>CJ:IDHEG:69I=:BID96N -=:G:>HDK:GL=:AB>C<:K>9:C8:I=6ICDC DE>D>9E6>CG:A>:K:GH6G:?JHI6H>;CDI BDG::;;:8I>K:I=6CDE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8CDC86C8:GE6>C "C&6G8=D; I=:#DJGC6AD;I=: B:G>86C&:9>86AHHD8>6I>DCEJ7A>H=:9I=:G:HJAIHD;>IH BDCI=>CK:HI><6I>DC>CIDL=:I=:G DK:G I=: 8DJCI:G9GJ 9GJ 88DG9>C<IDI=:HIJ9NDE>D>9H6G:CD7:II:GI=6C'," H>CIG:6I>C<8=GDC>8CDC86C8:GE6>C6C9 I=:G:HJAIHD;I=:HIJ9NR9DCDIHJEEDGI>C>I>6I>DCD;DE>D>9I=:G6EN;DGBD9:G6I:IDH:K:G:8=GDC>8 768@E6>CDG=>EDG@C::DHI:D6GI=G>I>HE6>C S "I>HDCANG:8:CIANI=6II=:EJ7A>8=6H7:8DB:6L6G: D;L=6I :;:C96CIH=6K:@CDLC;DG9:869:HI=::MIG6G>H@D;9:6I=6C9699>8I>DCI=6I8DB:HL>I= DE>D>9H9D:HCDI8DB:L>I=6CN:MIG67:C:;>I -.-5,)5:9 #81<1)31?-, )5,68 )13-, :6 19+369- :0- 56=5 !1929 6. 7161,$9- -D8DCK>C8:9D8IDGHE6I>:CIH>CHJG6C8: 6<:C8>:H6C9EGD @CDLCG>H@HD;ADC< I:GBDE>D>9JH:E6GI>8JA6GANI=:G>H@D;699>8I>DC -=:H:B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCHQ L=>8= :;:C96CIH@C:LDGG:6HDC67ANH=DJA9=6K:@CDLCID7:JCIGJ:L=:CI=:NB69:I=:BQ G:>C;DG8:9:68=DI=:G6C98G:6I:9I=:96C<:GDJHANB>HA:69>C<>BEG:HH>DCI=6I G>C $G:7H:I6A --,*95- 6050+;8 5456050+ ,+0*(9054854 (04!,2(9,+:4*905404 (90,498<09/ /7540* (*1 (04 57 06 57 4,, 89,5(79/70908 (04 #& &6G =IIEH ?6B6C:ILDG@ 8DB ?DJGC6AH ?6B6 6GI>8A: 67HIG68I + )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 69 of 106 6 ,I6GI>C<E6I>:CIHDCDE>D>9HL6HADLG>H@7:86JH:BDHIE6I>:CIHLDJA9CDI7:8DB: 699>8I:96C97:86JH:I=DH:L=DL:G:6I 7 )6I>:CIHL=D9>HEA6N:9H> 8 .H:D;=><=:GDE>D>99DH:HL=>8=B6CNE6I>:CIHC::9IDHJHI6>CE6>CG:A>:;6HI=:N 9:K:ADEIDA:G6C8:IDI=:9GJ 9 7JH: 9:I:GG:CIDE>D>9H7DI=EG:K:CIDK:G9DH:6C96G:>C=:G:CIANA:HH699>8I>K: :;:C96CIH =6K: CDI DCAN ;6>A:9 ID 8DGG:8I I=:H: B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH 7JI DC >C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;I=:N8DCI>CJ:IDB6@:I=:BID96N>C8AJ9>C<ID J96=NE=NH>8>6CH6C9 E6I>:CIH :;:C96CIH;6AH:AN8A6>B:9I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DCL6HADL6C9JCA>@:ANID9:K:ADE L=:CDE>D>9H6G:EG:H8G>7:96HDEEDH:9IDD7I6>C:9>AA>8>IAN6C9;6>A:9ID9>H8ADH:I=: D;699>8I>DCL>I=EGDADC<:9JH:D;DE>D>9H DG:M6BEA: 6 -:K6;JC9:9) UHEJ7A>86I>DC) +% &+(+"'&* ," ') '($ "-"& ."+! "& L=>8=:MEA6>C:9I=6IE=NH>86A9:E:C9:C8:DCDE>D>9H>HCDGB6A6C9 86K6A>:GAN:FJ6I:9I=:E=NH>86A9:E:C9:C8:G>H@D;DE>D>9HID86;;:>C: /-:7+"7+'93+49 69/548:/*+,57 +562+/;/4- #7,(93,49 690548 :0+, -57 ,562, 0;04. <09/ (04 ) =IIEH 8:A:HH 8DB -:HIH &6I:G>6AH &6I:G>6AH E9; + )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 70 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 71 of 106 9 C9D9>HIG>7JI:96E6I>:CIE6BE=A:I%>K>C<L>I=,DB:DC:L>I= =GDC>8)6>CL=>8= HI6I:9I=6IR4B5DHI=:6AI=86G:EGDK>9:GHL=DIG:6IE:DEA:L>I=E6>C6 : ##HEDCHDG:96E6I>:CI:9J86I>DC /-:7+ /4*/4- +2/+, '/4 '4'-+3+49,57 2*+7*:298 ; ##UH L:7H>I: LLL EG:H8G>7:G:HEDCH>7AN 8DB HI6I:H I=6I 8DC8:GCH 67DJI DE>D>9 699>8I>DC6G:RDK:G:HI>B6I:9S AAD;I=:;DG: 6K6>A67A:IDG:H>9:CIH6C9E=NH>8>6CH>C J96=NL>I=I=:>CI:CII=6IHJ8=7:G:A>:9JEDC6HIGJI=;JA HI6I:B:CIH &6CND; :;:C96CIHU7G6C9:96C9JC7G6C9:9B6I:G>6AH>CHIGJ8IE6I>:CIHID9>H8JHH DE>D>9HL>I=I=:>GEG:H8G>7>C<E=NH>8>6CH7JI :;:C96CIHB69:>I9>;;>8JAI>;CDI>BEDHH>7A:;DG EG:H8G>7>C<E=NH>8>6CHID<:IG:A>67A:JC7>6H:9>C;DGB6I>DC67DJIDE>D>9H (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;>CI=:>G8DBBJC>86I>DCH6C99>G:8I>CI:G68I>DCHL>I= E=NH>8>6CH >C 6C9 6GDJC9 J96=N H6A:H G:EG:H:CI6I>K:H ;DG -:K6 8I6K>H ## 6C9 C9D B>C>B>O:9DGL=DAAN;6>A:9ID9>H8ADH:I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DCB>HG:EG:H:CI:9I=:67JH:EDI:CI>6AD; + 6I + )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 72 of 106 EJGEDGI:9AN67JH: 9:I:GG:CI;DGBJA6I>DCH6C9GDJI>C:AN;6>A:9ID8DGG:8II=:>GB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH L=:CC:L8DC;A>8I>C<>C;DGB6I>DC7:86B:6K6>A67A: :;:C96CIHU 8A6>BH 8DCIG69>8I H8>:CI>;>8 :K>9:C8: H CDI:9 >C I=: J>9:A>C:I=:G:>HR:MI:CH>K::K>9:C8:SD;I=:REDHH>7A:=6GBHD;DE>D>9H>C8AJ9>C<DE>D>9JH: 9>HDG9:G S 88DG9>C<IDI=: 7:86JH:D;I=:G>H@H6HHD8>6I:9L>I=ADC< I:GBDE>D>9JH: >C8AJ9>C< I=: H:G>DJH G>H@ D; 699>8I>DC 67JH: B>HJH: DK:G9DH: 6C9 9:6I= DE>D>9H H=DJA9 7: RG:H:GK:9;DGE6>CH:K:G::CDJ<=IDG:FJ>G:DE>D>9IG:6IB:CI6C9;DGL=>8=6AI:GC6I>K:IG:6IB:CI DEI>DCH: < CDC DE>D>96C6A<:H>8HDGDE>D>98DB7>C6I>DCEGD9J8IH6H6EEGDEG>6I:6G:>C69:FJ6I: DGCDIIDA:G6I:9 S -=: 9>H8JHH:9I=:G>H@HG:A6I:9IDDE>D>9JH:6C9HI6I:9I=6I>CHI6CI G:A:6H:DE>D>9H6G:6HHD8>6I:9L>I=RE:GH>HI:CI67JH:699>8I>DCDK:G9DH:BDGI6A>IN6C9G>H@D; '(0,S4C:DC6I6ADE>D>9L>I=9G6L6AHNC9GDB:CDL6AHDG:;:GG:9ID6H',5 -=: L6GC>C E6I>:CIH6C9DI=:GJH:GHIDI=:G>H@HD;DE>D>9699>8I>DC67JH:6C9B>HJH:L=>8=86CA:69ID DK:G9DH: 6C9 9:6I=S 6C9 I=6I 699>8I>DC R86C D88JG >C E6I>:CIH 6EEGDEG>6I:AN EG:H8G>7:9S DE>D>9H -=:H:L6GC>C DE>D>9H6G:6EEGDEG>6I:6C9H6;:;DG8=GDC>8JH: :0+,204,-57 7,8*70)04. 6050+8-57/7540* (04@$409,+"9(9,8 ) &6G =IIEH LLL 898 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 73 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 74 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 75 of 106 HJ8=6HH8G::C>C<IDDAHE6I>:CI8DCIG68IHJG>C:9GJ<I:HI>C<DGE>AA8DJCIHL>9:AN7:A>:K:97N 9D8IDGHID9:I:8I6C99:I:GDJI8DB:HG:A6I:9ID699>8I>DC6C9DK:G9DH: -.-5,)5:9 198-78-9-5:-,:0): 7161,,,1+:1659)913><61,-,)5, #8-):-, :;:C96CIH 6HHJG:9 EG:H8G>7>C< E=NH>8>6CH I=6I I=: G>H@ D; HI6GI>C< E6I>:CIH DC DE>D>9HL6HB>C>B6A7N8A6>B>C<I=6IDE>D>99:E:C9:C8:>CI=:G6G:>CHI6C8:HL=:G:>ID88JGG:9 8DJA9 7: G:HDAK:9 :6H>AN 7N I6E:G>C< -=JH :;:C96CIH 6;;>GB6I>K:AN G:EG:H:CI:9 I=6I DE>D>9 L>I=9G6L6AL6HCDI6EGD7A:BL=>A:8DC8:6A>C<I=:>C8G:6H:99>;;>8JAIND;HIDEE>C<DE>D>9H6;I:G ADC< I:GBJH: DG :M6BEA: C9DUH & )*"*+ &+ "& "& +! $ ) +" CI 8A6>B:9 I=6I L>I=9G6L6A HNBEIDBH 86C 7: 6KD>9:9 H>BEAN 7N I6E:G>C< 6 E6I>:CIUH DE>D>9 9DH: 7N ID E:G8:CI;DG 96NH :;:C96CIH9:8:EI>K:ANB>C>B>O:9I=:H> 6C9 -.-5,)5:9 198-78-9-5:-,:0): 0>91+1)59)5, ):1-5:96;3,5+8-)9- 7161,69)/-95,-.151:-3>&1:06;:,,-,!192 0>I=E6I>:CIHFJ>8@AN7J>A9>C<IDA:G6C8:H;DGDE>D>9HADL:G9DH:HD;DE>D>9H ;6>A:9IDEGDK>9:G:A>:; "CI=DH:86H:HI=:EG:H8G>7>C<9D8IDGHLDJA9IG69>I>DC6AAN=6K: 676C9DC:9DE>D>9H6HIG:6IB:CI7JI;DG :;:C96CIHU8A6>BHI=6IDE>D>99DH6<:H8DJA97: >C9:;>C>I:AN>C8G:6H:9L>I=DJI699:9G>H@ DG:M6BEA: 6 8I6K>HUH E6I>:CI 7GD8=JG: ;DG $69>6C HI6I:9 R2DJ 86C 7:8DB: 699>8I:9 ID BDGE=>C: 76H:99GJ :0+,204,-57 7,8*70)04. 6050+8-57/7540* (04@$409,+"9(9,8 ) &6G =IIEH LLL 898 )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 76 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 77 of 106 -=: :MEA6>CH I=6I RDK:G9DH: G>H@ >H >C8G:6H:9 6I =><=:G DE>D>9 9DH6<:H S ,>B>A6GANI=:G:>H6CR>C8G:6H:9G>H@;DGDE>D>9JH:9>HDG9:GG:HE>G6IDGN9:EG:HH>DC6C99:6I=6I =><=:G9DH:H S -.-5,)5:9 198-78-9-5:-, :0- ..-+:1<-5-99 6. *;9--:-88-5: 867-8:1-96.-8:)15 7161, 86,;+:9 :;:C96CIH 9:8:EI>K:AN B6G@:I:9 I=: HD 86AA:9 R67JH: 9:I:GG:CIS EGDE:GI>:H D; HDB:D;I=:>GDE>D>9H6C98G:6I:9I=:;6AH:>BEG:HH>DCI=6II=:H:DE>D>9H8DJA98JG7699>8I>DC6C9 67JH: :;:C96CIHH:>O:9JEDCI=:7JH>C:HHDEEDGIJC>INEG:H:CI:97NI=:G6E>9AN D;DK:G9DH:9:6I=H:68=N:6G7NB6G@:I>C<6C:L<:C:G6I>DCD;HD 86AA:9RI6BE:G G:H>HI6CIS6C9 R67JH: 9:I:GG:CISDE>D>9E>AAH -=:H:G:;DGBJA6I:9DE>D>9E>AAH6G:EJGEDGI:9ANBDG:9>;;>8JAIID 8GJH=6C9I=:G:;DG:HJEEDH:9ANA:HHA>@:ANID7:67JH:97N>C?:8I>C<DGHCDGI>C< :;:C96CIH=DA9 BJAI>EA:E6I:CIHDCI=:H:G:;DGBJA6I:99GJ 86H:H9:869:H :HE>I:G:;DGBJA6I>DCC:MI<:C:G6I>DCDE>D>9E>AAH6G:?JHI6H699>8I>K:6C9I=:G: >H A>IIA:Q>; 6CNQEGDD; I=:N G:9J8: G6I:H D; DK:G9DH:H DG 9:6I=H -=6I =6H CDI HIDEE:9 E=6GB68:JI>86A 8DBE6C>:H 6C9 I=:>G H6A:H G:EG:H:CI6I>K:H ;GDB EGDBDI>C< I=:>G G:;DGBJA6I:9 DE>D>9EGD9J8IH6HA:HH699>8I>K: A6GB>C D;)6>CH=DL:9C:6GAN=6A;D;. , E=NH>8>6CH>C8DGG:8IAN7:A>:K:9I=6IG:;DGBJA6I:9DE>D>9H6G: A:HH699>8I>K:I=6CI=:>GEG:9:8:HHDGH :7DG6=!DL:AA:I6A :0+,204,-57 7,8*70)04. 6050+8-57/7540* (04A$409,+"9(9,8 &&0++ + =IIEH LLL 898 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 78 of 106 C9DUH69K:GI>H:B:CIH;DGI=: G:;DGBJA6I>DCD;(E6C6 +8A6>B:9I=6I>IL6H 9:H> -=>H8A6>BL6H;6AH: -=: L6GC:9>C6 A:II:GI=6II=:G:L6HCD:K>9:C8: C9DUH9:H> LDJA9EGDK>9:6G:9J8I>DC>CDG6A>CIG6C6H6ADG>CIG6K:CDJHJH: &DG:DK:G C9DUHDLCHIJ9>:H L=>8=>I;6>A:9ID9>H8ADH:H=DL:9I=6I(E6C6 +8DJA9HI>AA7: "C 6 H:IIA:B:CI L>I= I=: ,I6I: D; ':L 2DG@ C9D 6 HI6I:B:CIH>C':L2DG@I=6I(E6C6 +L6H9:H> I=DH:HI6I:B:CIHID7:;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:7:86JH:I=:G:L6HCD9>;;:G:C8:>CI=:67>A>INID:MIG68I I=:C6G8DI>8;GDB(E6C6 + -=:G:6G:CDHIJ9>:HI=6IHJEEDGII=:CDI>DCI=6IR67JH: 9:I:GG:CISI:8=CDAD<>:H 9:I:GDGEG:K:CI67JH: -.-5,)5:9 198-78-9-5:-,:0--5-.1:96.08651+ 7161,$9- :;:C96CIH B>HG:EG:H:CI:9 I=: 7:C:;>IH D; E6>C G:A>:; EGDK>9:9 7N ADC< I:GB EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9JH:7N;6AH:ANHI6I>C<I=6I 6 %DC< I:GBDE>D>9JH:LDJA9G:HJAI>CE6>CG:9J8I>DC6C96C>C8G:6H:9FJ6A>IND;A>;: ;DGE6I>:CIH 7 -=: JH: D; DE>D>9 EGD9J8IH ;DG 8=GDC>8 E6>C LDJA9 6AADL E6I>:CIH ID E:G;DGB E=NH>86AAN9:B6C9>C<I6H@H 8 (E>D>9HB6@:>I:6H>:G;DGE:DEA:IDA>K:CDGB6AAN6C9>BEGDK:FJ6A>IND;A>;: 9 =GDC>8 DE>D>9 I=:G6EN =6H 7::C H=DLC ID G:9J8: E6>C 6C9 >BEGDK: 9:EG:HH>K: HNBEIDBH6C98D : &JAI>EA:8A>C>86AHIJ9>:H=6K:H=DLCI=6IDE>D>9H6G::;;:8I>K:>C>BEGDK>C<96>AN ;JC8I>DCEHN8=DAD<>86A=:6AI=6C9=:6AI=G:A6I:9FJ6A>IND;A>;:;DG8=GDC>8E6>C E6I>:CIH ",,"9(9,3,49 70.04(2 6(4(!!,208904.,9,7304(9054. , &6N =IIE LLL ;96 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 79 of 106 H>CI:C9:97N :;:C96CIH=DHE>I6AH6C9B:9>86AEGD;:HH>DC6AH>CI=:. , 6C9>C J96=N L:G: HI::G:9 IDL6G9 I=: DK:G IG:6IB:CI D; 68JI: 6C9 8=GDC>8 E6>C 7N :;:C96CIHU B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH H 6 G:HJAI ADC< I:GB DE>D>9 EG:H8G>EI>DCH ;ADJG>H=:9 C6I>DCL>9: 6C9 >C J96=N -=: JC8=:8@:9 :H86A6I>DC D; EG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9 JH: G:HJAI:9 >C 67JH: 699>8I>DC DK:G9DH:>C?JGN6C99:6I= JI ;DG :;:C96CIHU B>HA:69>C< 6C9 ;6AH: >C;DGB6I>DC HJ8= 67JH: 699>8I>DC DK:G9DH:>C?JGN9:6I=6C9I=:>G6II:C96CI8DHIHLDJA9CDI=6K:D88JGG:9 :;:C96CIH=69IDE:GHJ69:9D8IDGHI=6II=:G:L6H6H> DE>D>9JH:>CDG9:GID8DCK>C8:9D8IDGH6C9E6I>:CIHI=6IDE>D>9HH=DJA97:JH:9IDIG:6I8=GDC>8 E6>C !DL:K:GI=:G:>HCDIQCDG=6HI=:G::K:G7::CQ:K>9:C8:D;ADC< I:GB7:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9 I=:G6EN;DG8=GDC>8E6>C "C I=: HI6I:9I=6I>IL6HJC6L6G:D;6CNHIJ9>:H9:BDCHIG6I>C<I=:H6;:IN 6C9:;;>868ND;DE>D>9H;DGADC< I:GBJH: :HE>I:I=:A68@D;HIJ9>:H :;:C96CIH;6AH:AN6C9 B>HA:69>C HJEEDGI:9 7N H8>:CI>;>8 :K>9:C8: 'DI DCAN =6K: :;:C96CIH ;6>A:9 ID 8DGG:8I I=:H: ;6AH: 6C9 9:8:EI>K:8A6>BH7JIDC>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;I=:N8DCI>CJ:IDB6@:I=:BID96NL>I=I=:>CI:CI I=6II=:G:8>E>:CIHD;I=:HI6I:B:CIHG:ANDCI=:B6HIGJI=;JA DG:M6BEA: 6 8I6K>HUH D )6NHH>HI6C8:)GD 7 ##UHE6I>:CI:9J86I>DC 04+04.!,20,- (04 (4(.,3,49-57 2+,7+:298) Q ( &' # ) " =IIE L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7 =IIE LLL E6>CB:9 DG< E9; E6>C5B )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 80 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 81 of 106 ;DG L=>8= DE>D>9H 6G: 8DBBDCAN EG:H8G>7:9 HJ8= 6H ADL 768@ E6>C =:6968=: 6C9 ;>7GDBN6A<>6 S -=: =6H6AHDCDI:9I=6II=:G>H@HD;699>8I>DC6C99:6I=R86C86JH:9>HIG:HH 6C9>C67>A>INID;JA;>AAB6?DGGDA:D7A><6I>DCH SH6B6II:GD;8DBBDCH:CH:6C9B:9>86A :K>9:C8:9GJ >BEGDK:I=:>G;JC8I>DC6C9FJ6A>IND;A>;: "C I=: L6GC:98I6K>HI=6IR4L5:6G:CDI6L6G:D;HJ7HI6CI>6A:K>9:C8: DGHJ7HI6CI>6A8A>C>86A:ME:G>:C8:9:BDCHIG6I>C<I=6II=:B6 =6H>C6AA:K>6I>C<E6>CI6@:CID<:I=:GL>I=6CN9GJ< G:A6I:9H>9::;;:8IHE6I>:CIHB6N:ME:G>:C8: G:HJAIH>C6CNDK:G6AAEDH>I>K:>BE68IDC6E6I>:CIUHLDG@E=NH>86A6C9B:CI6A;JC8I>DC>C< 96>AN68I>K>I>:HDG:C?DNB:CID;A>;: S :;:C96CIH;6AH:AN:BE=6H>O:9DG:M6<<:G6I:9I=:G>H@HD;8DBE:I>C<EGD9J8IHA>@: '," HHD9D8IDGH6C9E6I>:CIHLDJA9ADD@IDDE>D>9H;>GHI;DGIG:6I>C<8=GDC>8E6>C (C8:6<6>C :;:C96CIHUB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH8DCIG6K:C:I=:H8>:CI>;>8:K>9:C8: :;:C96CIH=6K::BEADN:96C98DCI>CJ:ID:BEADNI=:67DK:;6AH:6C9B>HA:69>C< G:EG:H:CI6I>DCH>C6C96GDJC9 J96=N6C9=6K:9>G:8I:9I=:B6I J96=N>C8AJ9>C<>IHE=NH>8>6CH 6C9 E6I>:CIH -=:H: HJHI6>C:9 6C9 DC G:HJAI:9>CJCC:8:HH6GN6C9JCL6CI:9DE>D>9699>8I>DC67JH:9>K:GH>DC6C99:6I=>C J96=N6C9 HJGGDJC9>C< 8DBBJC>I>:H H 6 9>G:8I 6C9 ;DG:H::67A: 8DCH:FJ:C8: D; :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I J96=N=6HHJ;;:G:9:MI:CH>K:>C?JG>:H6C996B6<:H :0+,204,-57 7,8*70)04. 6050+8-57/7540* (04@$409,+"9(9,8 ) &6G =IIEH LLL 898 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 82 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 83 of 106 )GD;:HH>DC6A,:GK>8:H6C9DE:G6I:>C8DBEA>6C8:L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C DCIGDAA:9,J7HI6C8:H8I 6C9DI=:GHI6I:A6L >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH6G:A>8:CH:9L=DA:H6A:EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ<9>HIG>7JIDGH 9D>C<7JH>C:HH>CI=:,I6I:D;0>H8DCH>C H 6AA:<:9 =:G:>C >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIHK>DA6I:9 I=: 0>H8DCH>C .C>;DGB DCIGDAA:9,J7HI6C8:H8I0>H ,I6I PP Q 0>H8DCH>C)=6GB68N%6LH0>H ,I6I PP Q 0>H8DCH>C9B>C>HIG6I>K: D9:0>H 9B>C D9:PP)=6G Q 6C9 :9:G6A DCIGDAA:9,J7HI6C8:H8I6C9G: L>I=DJIB6>CI6>C>C<:;;:8I>K:8DCIGDAH6<6>CHI9>K:GH>DC >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH 688DJCI ;DG ID E:G8:CI D; 6AA G:K:CJ:H ;GDB 9GJ< 9>HIG>7JI>DC>CI=:. , (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:; >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH6G:I=:A6G<:HIDE>D>9 9>HIG>7JIDGH>C J96=N7N68DCH>9:G67A:B6G<>C -D<:I=:GI=: >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIHEA6N6C >CHIGJB:CI6AGDA:>CI=:9>HIG>7JI>DCD;DE>D>9H>C J96=N "C;68I >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH69B>II=6II=:N6G:I=:<6I:@::E:GH6C9I=:A6HIA>C: D;9:;:CH:;DGEG:K:CI>C<DE>D>967JH::MEG:HHANHI6I>C<7:;DG:I=:. , DC B:B7:GHR=6K:CDIDCANHI6IJIDGN6C9G: D;8DCIGDAA:9EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ "C I=:C6I>DC6A6HHD8>6I>DCI=6IG:EG:H:CIH. , E=6GB68:JI>86A9>HIG>7JIDGH B6CJ;68IJG:GH 6C9 E=6GB68:JI>86A HJEEAN 8=6>C 8DBE6C>:HQI=: !:6AI=86G: >HIG>7JI>DC AA>6C8:! ;DGB:GAN@CDLC6HI=:!:6AI=86G: >HIG>7JI>DC&6C6<:B:CIHHD8>6I>DCQ 9:K:ADE:9"C9JHIGN DBEA>6C8: J>9:A>C:HRIDHJEEDGI>C9JHIGNEG68I>8:HDCI=::K6AJ6I>DCD; 7,8*70690547:.0;,7805453)(904.9/,"*5:7.,,(704.,-57,9/,":)*53354533,7*, -. (4+#7(+,5-9/,533544,7.>(4+533,7*, I= DC< 9,:HH HI6I:B:CID;#D=C& G6N )G:H>9:CI6C9 (!:6AI=86G: >HIG>7JI>DC&6C6<:B:CIHHD8 (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:;8JGG:CI! B:B7:GH>C8AJ9: :;:C96CIH C9D)6G)=6GB68:JI>86A#6CHH:C #D=CHDC #D=CHDC &8$:HHDC B:G>HDJG8::G<:C 6C9 6G9>C6A !:6AI= 6BDC< DI=:G B6CJ;68IJG:GH 6C9 9>HIG>7JIDGH ",, ,3),78/06 ! =IIEH LLL =96 DG< 67DJI B:B7:GH=>EA6HIK>H>I:9EG )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 84 of 106 8JHIDB:GDG9:GH;DG8DCIGDAA:9HJ7HI6C8:H6C9I=:G:EDGI>C<D;THJHE>8>DJHUDG9:GHIDI=: S -=: I=DGDJ<=768@ -=:G:;DG:>CB6CN86H:HEDI:CI>6AEGD7A:BH86C7:6KD>9:9:K:C7:;DG:6CDG9:G>HEA68:9 S 2:I 9:HE>I: I=: HJ7HI6CI>6A >C8G:6H: >C I=: DG9:G>C< D; EG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9H 7N G:I6>A:GH>C J96=N >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH=6K::HH:CI>6AAN679>86I:9I=:>GGDA:6H<6I:@::E:GHD; I=:8DCIGDAA:9HJ7HI6C8:HI=:NE:99A:>CHI:69LDG@>C<ID<:I=:GL>I=I=:&6CJ;68IJG:G :;:C96CIH ID>CJC96I: J96=NL>I=BDG:DE>D>9HI=6CLDJA97:8DCHJB:9;DGK6A>9B:9>86AEJGEDH:H +6I=:G I=6C I6@: B>C>B6A B:6HJG:H ID EGDI:8I I=: EJ7A>8 ;GDB 6 @CDLC =6GB >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH >C9>K>9J6AAN 6C9 8DAA:8I>K:AN =6K: G:E:6I:9AN 9>HIG>7JI:9 EG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9H L>I=DJI ;JA;>AA>C< I=:>G A:<6A 9JIN JC9:G 0>H8DCH>C A6L ID HIDE I=: 9>K:GH>DC D; I=:H: 96C<:GDJH9GJ JGI=:G >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH B>HG:EG:H:CI:9 B6I:G>6A ;68IH G:<6G9>C< I=: :M>HI:C8:D;I=:>G>CI:GC6AEDA>8>:H6C9EG68I>8:HIDEGDI:8II=:=:6AI=6C9H6;:IND; J96=N8>I>O:CH ,E:8>;>86AAN >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH8DC8:6A:9I=:;68II=6II=:N;6>A:9ID>BEA:B:CI6CDE>D>9 HJEEAN8=6>CBDC>IDG>C<DGIG68@>C<HNHI:BID EGD9J8IH;DGCDC B:9>86AJH:9:HE>I:G:EG:H:CI>C<IDI=:EJ7A>8I=6II=:NLDJA9 >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH8DCI>CJ:ID8DC9J8I7JH>C:HHL>I=G:8@A:HH9>HG:<6G9;DGI=: G><=IH 6C9 H6;:IN D; J96=N 8>I>O:CH 7:86JH: >I >H I=:>G ;>C6C8>6A >CI:G:HIH ID 9D HD "C ;68I &8$:HHDC8DCI>CJ:HIDE6NAJ8G6I>K:>C8:CI>K:6L6G9HIDH:C>DG:M:8JI>K:H76H:9DC=><=H6A:HD; DE>D>99GJ 7,8*70690547:.0;,7805453)(904.9/,"*5:7.,,(704.,-57,9/,":)*53354533,7*, -. (4+#7(+,5-9/,533544,7.>(4+533,7*, I= DC< 9,:HH HI6I:B:CID;#D=C& G6N )G:H>9:CI6C9 (!:6AI=86G: >HIG>7JI>DC&6C6<:B:CIHHD8 #,(389,78 :8/(*154 *,8854 B8 (>(97;04."/(7,/52+,78 ,,904. & '! )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 85 of 106 :;:C96CIH=6K:7:C:;>II:9BDC:I6G>AN;GDB:68=DI=:GUHJCA6L;JA8DC9J8IL=>8= =6H9>G:8IANG:HJAI:9>C6C>CDG9>C6I:ANA6G<:KDAJB:D;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H;ADL>C<>CIDAD86A J96=N8DBBJC>I>:H >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIHU;6>AJG:HIDB6>CI6>C:;;:8I>K:8DCIGDAH6<6>CHII=:@CDLC 9>K:GH>DC D; EG:H8G>EI>DC DE>D>9H C6IJG6AAN 6C9 ;DG:H::67AN 8G:6I:9 6C DK:G67JC96C8: D; I=:H: C6G8DI>8H>CAD86A8DBBJC>I>:H;J:A>C<699>8I>DCDK:G9DH:6C99:6I=>C J96=N >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH@C:LDGH=DJA9=6K:@CDLCI=6I&6CJ;68IJG:G :;:C96CIH B>HG:EG:H:CI:9B6I:G>6A;68IH67DJI6BDC<DI=:GI=>C 6C9I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DCIDDE>D>9H J96=N=6H7::C=6GB:96H69>G:8I6C9EGDM>B6I:G:HJAID; :;:C96CIHU@CDL>C< G:8@A:HH;6AH:9:8:EI>K:6C9B>HA:69>C<8DC9J8I9:H8G>7:9=:G:>C &! $ #"( ! ( #" )=6GB68N :;:C96CIHK>DA6I:9I=:0>H8DCH>C.C>;DGB DCIGDAA:9,J7HI6C8:H8I 0>H ,I6I PP Q 0>H8DCH>C )=6GB68N %6LH 0>H ,I6I PP Q 0>H8DCH>C9B>C>HIG6I>K: D9:0>H 9B>C D9:PP)=6G Q 6C9 :9:G6A DCIGDAA:9 ,J7HI6C8:H 8I 6C9 G: :;;:8I>K:8DCIGDAH6<6>CHI9>K:GH>DC -=:R9>HE:CH>C 9>HIG>7JI>DCEGD8:HH;GDBI=:E=6GB68NID6C>C9>K>9J6A )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH ;6>A:9 ID 6 69:FJ6I:AN IG6>C I=:>G E=6GB68>HIH 6C9 E=6GB68N I:8=C>8>6CH DC =DL ID EGDE:GAN 6C9 69:FJ6I:AN =6C9A: EG:H8G>EI>DCH ;DG DE>D>9 #JA =IIEH LLL 96AA6HC:LH 8DB 7JH>C:HH 8:D E6N I:6BHI:GH EJH= 768@ B8@:HHDC 8:DH E6N >GK>C< H=6G:=DA9:GH B::I>C< :;:C96CI 06A )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 86 of 106 E6>C@>AA:GH 7 EJI >C EA68: :;;:8I>K: EDA>8>:H 6C9 EGD8:9JG:H ID EG:K:CI I=:>G HIDG:H ;GDB ;68>A>I6I>C<9>K:GH>DC6C9H:AA>C<>CID67A68@B6G@:I88DC9J8I69:FJ6I:>CI:GC6ADG:MI:GC6A G:K>:LHD;I=:>GDE>D>9H6A:HID>9:CI>;NE6II:GCHG:<6G9>C<EG:H8G>EI>DCHI=6IH=DJA9CDI=6K:7::C ;>AA:99:;;:8I>K:ANG:HEDC9ID8DC8:GCHG6>H:97NI=:>GDLC:BEADN::HG:<6G9>C<>C69:FJ6I: EDA>8>:H6C9EGD8:9JG:HG:<6G9>C<I=:;>AA>C<D;DE>D>9EG:H8G>EI>DCH6C9:I6@:B:6C>C<;JA68I>DC ID>CK:HI><6I:DGID:CHJG:I=6II=:NL:G:8DBEAN>C<L>I=I=:>G9JI>:H6C9D7A><6I>DCHJC9:GI=: A6LL>I=G:<6G9ID8DCIGDAA:9HJ7HI6C8:H )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH=69I=:67>A>IN6C9I=:D7A><6I>DC IDADD@;DGG:9;A6 EG:H8G>EI>DCHI=6IHJ<<:HI:9EDI:CI>6A9>K:GH>DC !DL:K:G)=6GB68N :;:C96CIHHNHI:B6I>86AAN > -=: G:HJAI >H I=6I )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH 9>HIG>7JI:9 6C9 9>HE:CH:9 DE>D>9H >C 6 B6CC:GL=>8=86JH:9;ADD9:9 J96=N8DBBJC>I>:HL>I=DE>D>9H6C9;68>A>I6I:96C9:C8DJG6<:9 I=:;ADL6C99>K:GH>DCD;DE>D>9H>CID6C>AA:<6AH:8DC96GNB6G@:I #"B $# $ # %"## $( ( !" !"! # " $" -=:68IH6C9DB>HH>DCHD; :;:C96CIHH:I;DGI=6IA:C I=:DE>D>9:E>9:B>86C9 J96=NUHG:HJAI>C<96B6<:HL=>8=6G::MI:CH>K:6C9DC :;:C96CIHUB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH9:8:>K:9EG:H8G>7>C<9D8IDGH6C9E6I>:CIH67DJII=: G>H@H 6C9 7:C:;>IH D; ADC< I:GB DE>D>9 JH: ,IJ9>:H G:K:6A I=6I B6CN EG:H8G>7>C< 9D8IDGH 6C9 E6I>:CIH6G:JC6L6G:D;DG9DCDIJC9:GHI6C9I=:G>H@HDG7:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H "C9::9E6I>:CIHD;I:C G:EDGII=6II=:NL:G:CDIL6GC:9I=:NB><=I7:8DB:699>8I:9IDDE>D>9HEG:H8G>7:9IDI=:B H )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 87 of 106 G:EDGI:9>C#6CJ6GN 6 HJGK:ND;BDG:I=6C DE>D>9E6I>:CIH;DJC9I=6IRE6I>:CIH 8A6>B:9I=:NL:G:DCANIDA9E6>C@>AA:GH8DJA97:699>8I>K:H>MDJID; I>B:H S :;:C96CIHU9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<H8=:B:86JH:96C98DCI>CJ:HID86JH:EG:H8G>7>C< 9D8IDGH>C6C96GDJC9 J96=NIDEG:H8G>7:DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C8DC9>I>DCHHJ8=6H768@E6>C =:6968=:H 6GI=G>I>H 6C9 ;>7GDBN6A<>6 L>I=DJI 6EEGDEG>6I: 8DCH>9:G6I>DC D; DI=:G CDC DE>D>9 I=:G6E>:H 7H:CI :;:C96CIHU9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<H8=:B:I=:H:9D8IDGHLDJA9CDI=6K:DK:G EG:H8G>7:9DE>D>9HDG7:8DB::B7GD>A:9>CE>AAB>AAHI=6IC:<6I>K:AN>BE68I:9G:H>9:CIHD; J96=N DG:M6BEA:7NI=:>G@CDL>C<6C9>CI:CI>DC6A8DC9J8I>C8AJ9>C<I=:>G9:8:EI>K: B6G@:I>C< H8=:B: :;:C96CIH 86JH:9 9D8IDGH >C J96=N ID EG:H8G>7: 9>HE:CH: 9:A>K:G DG 69B>C>HI:G68DCIGDAA:9HJ7HI6C8:Q>C8AJ9>C<DE>D>9HHJ8=6H(MN DCI>C=N9GD8D9DC:/>8D9>C DG :CI6CNAQ>CI=:8DJGH:D;I=:>GB:9>86AEG68I>8:L>I=DJI6K6A>9B:9>86AEJGEDH: :;:C96CIH @CDL>C 8DJA9CDI=6K:=696A:<>I>B6I:B:9>86AEJGEDH:6H6B:6CHID>C8G:6H:I=:>GDLCEGD;>IH :;:C96CIHU 9:8:EI>K: B6G@:I>C< H8=:B: 6AHD 86JH:9 6C9 8DCI>CJ:H ID 86JH: E6I>:CIHIDEJG8=6H:6C9JH:DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C7:A>:K>C<I=:N6G:H6;:6C9:;;:8I>K: JI;DG :;:C96CIHU9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<H8=:B:;:L:GE6I>:CIHLDJA97:JH>C<DE>D>9HADC< I:GBIDIG:6I 8=GDC>8E6>C6C9I=DH:E6I>:CIHJH>C<DE>D>9HLDJA97:JH>C<A:HHD;I=:B :;:C96CIHU9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<=6H86JH:96C98DCI>CJ:HID86JH:L>9:HEG:69 EG:H8G>7>C<6C9JH:D;DE>D>9H>CI=:. , 6C9>C J96=N "C9::9I=>H9G6B6I>8>C8G:6H:>CDE>D>9 EG:H8G>EI>DCH6C9JH:8DGG:HEDC9HL>I=I=:9G6B6I>8>C8G:6H:>C :;:C96CIHUHE:C9>C<DCI=:>G 088,+ :,890548 088,+ 66579:4090,8 ! # " #6C =IIEH LLL =6O:A9:C7:IIN;DG9 DG< 67DJI JH C:LH B:9>6 EG:HH G:A:6H: 9D8IDGH B>HH>C< FJ:HI>DCH I=6I 8DJA9 EG:K:CI DE>D>9 699>8I>DC )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 88 of 106 9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<H8=:B: :;:C96CIHUHE:C9>C<DCDE>D>9B6G@:I>C<IDI6A:96EEGDM>B6I:AN B>AA>DC>C N I=6IHE:C9>C<=69IG>EA:9IDB>AA>DC -=: :H86A6I>C< CJB7:G D; DE>D>9 EG:H8G>EI>DCH LG>II:C 7N 9D8IDGH L=D L:G: 9:8:>K:9 7N :;:C96CIHU 9:8:EI>K: B6G@:I>C< H8=:B: =6H 86JH:9 6 8DGG:HEDC9>C >C8G:6H:>CDE>D>9699>8I>DCDK:G9DH:H6C99:6I=I=GDJ<=DJII=:. , 6C9 J96=N ,8>:CI>;>8:K>9:C8:H=DLH6HIGDC<8DGG:A6I>DC7:IL::CI=:DE>D>9EG:H8G>7>C<G6I: 6C9I=:G6I:D;699>8I>DCDK:G9DH:6C99:6I= "C6 G:EDGII=: :MEA6>C:9I=6IEG:H8G>7>C< DE>D>9H=6HFJ69GJEA:9H>C8: L=>8==6HG:HJAI:9>C6E6G6AA:A>C8G:6H:>CDE>D>9DK:G9DH: "C9::9I=:G:=6H7::C6ILD I=>G9H>C8G:6H:>CDK:G9DH:9:6I=H;GDBJH>C<DE>D>9HH>C8: DGI=:H:G:6HDCHI=: 8DC8AJ9:9I=6I:;;DGIHIDG:>C>CI=:EG:H8G>7>C<D;DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8 E6>C6G:8G>I>86AIDRG:K:GH:I=:8N8A:D;DE>D>9E6>CB:9>86I>DCB>HJH:I=6I8DCIG>7JI:HIDI=: DE>D>9DK:G9DH::E>9:B>8 S J:IDI=:>C8G:6H:>CDE>D>9DK:G9DH:H;>GHIG:HEDC9:GHHJ8=6HEDA>8:D;;>8:GH6C9 DI=:G A6L :C;DG8:B:CI =6K: 7::C 6C9 L>AA 8DCI>CJ: ID EA6N 6 8G>I>86A GDA: >C 6HH>HI>C< E:DEA: :ME:G>:C8>C<DE>D>9 G:A6I:9DK:G9DH:H JI;DG :;:C96CIHU;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH 6C9DI=:GJCA6L;JA6C9JC;6>G8DC9J8IHJ8=G:HEDCH:LDJA9CDI=6K:7::CC::9:9 (E>D>9699>8I>DC>H6H> HJ7HI6C8: 9:E:C9:C8: H> 6HHD8>6I:9L>I=6EG>B6GN9>6 :29062,(:8,5-,(9/ 0(' +A6HIG:K>H:9#JC =IIE LDC9:G 898 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 89 of 106 6C99:8:EI>K:B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C9DI=:GJCA6L;JA6C9JC;6>G8DC9J8IHJ8=IG:6IB:CILDJA9CDI =6K:7::CC::9:9 :;:C96CIHU8G:6I>DCI=GDJ<=;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:69K:GI>H>C<6C9DI=:GJCA6L;JA 6C9 JC;6>G 8DC9J8I D; 6 K>GIJ6AAN A>B>IA:HH DE>D>9 B6G@:I =6H H> :;:C96CIHU HJ88:HH >C :MI:C9>C< I=: B6G@:I ;DG DE>D>9H ID C:L E6I>:CIH 6C9 8=GDC>8 E6>C 8DC9>I>DCH=6H;DG:H::67AN8G:6I:96C67JC96C8:D;9GJ JH:6C9;J:A:96L6K:D;699>8I>DC6C9>C?JGN "I=6H7::C:HI>B6I:9I=6I ID E:G8:CID;I=: DE>D>9HIDL=>8=E:DEA:6G:699>8I:98DB:9>G:8IANDG>C9>G:8IANI=GDJ<=9D8IDGHUEG:H8G>EI>DCH JI;DG :;:C96CIHU;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C9DI=:GJCA6L;JA6C9JC;6>G8DC9J8I HJ8=699>8I>DCHLDJA9CDI=6K:D88JGG:9 %6L:C;DG8:B:CI6<:C8>:H=6K:>C8G:6H>C L>I=K>DA:CI6C9EGDE:GIN8G>B:H -=:H:6<:C8>:H6G:;68:9L>I=>C8G:6H>C<9>K:GH>DCD;DE>D>9H ;GDB A:<>I>B6I: HDJG8:H ;DG >AA>8>I EJGEDH:H >C8AJ9>C< 9D8IDG H=DEE>C< ;DG<:9 EG:H8G>EI>DCH ;6AH>;>:9E=6GB68NG:8DG9H6C9:BEADN::HL=DHI:6A;GDBI=:>GEA68:D;:BEADNB:CI -=:DE>D>9 :E>9:B>8 =6H EGDBEI:9 6 7JG :;:C96CIHU;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C9DI=:GJCA6L;JA6C9JC;6>G8DC9J8IHJ8= 8G>B:HLDJA9CDI=6K:D88JGG:9 -=:G>H:>CDE>D>9699>8I>DC86JH:97N :;:C96CIHU9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<H8=:B:H =6H6AHDG:HJAI:9>C6C:MEADH>DC>C=:GD>CJH: DG:M6BEA:=:GD>CJH:=6HBDG:I=6C9DJ7A:9>C I=:E6HI9:869:6BDC<69JAIH6<: ID &DG:DK:G=:GD>C G:A6I:9DK:G9DH:H>CI=:. , =6K: BDG: I=6C FJ69GJEA:9 7:IL::C 6C9 JI ;DG :;:C96CIHU ;6AH: 6C9 9:8:EI>K: )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 90 of 106 B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH 6C9 DI=:G JCA6L;JA 6C9 JC;6>G 8DC9J8I HJ8= =:GD>C JH: LDJA9 CDI =6K: D88JGG:9 H 6 G:HJAI D; G:A>6C8: DC I=: K6G>DJH B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH G:<6G9>C< I=: H6;:IN JI>A>IN6C97:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H>C699>I>DCIDI=:9>G:8I:;;:8IHD;B>HJH:D;DE>D>9HL=>8=L6H ;DG:H::67A:7N :;:C96CIH J96=N=6H6AHDHJ;;:G:9ADHHD;EGD9J8I>K:6C9=:6AI=NLDG@:GH9J: ID699>8I>DCDK:G9DH:DG9:6I= J96=NUH8DBBJC>I>:H=6K:7::C9:HI67>A>O:97N7GD@:C;6B>A>:H E=NH>86A6C9B:CI6A=:6AI=EGD7A:BH=DB:A:HHC:HH6C9>C86G8:G6I>DC -=>HG:HJAIH>C>C8G:6H:9 9:B6C9DCH:GK>8:H;JC9:97N J96=NHJ8=6H:B:G<:C8NH:GK>8:HA6L:C;DG8:B:CI6C9EJ7A>8 H6;:IN JI;DG :;:C96CIHU;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K:B>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C9DI=:GJCA6L;JAL>AA;JA B6A>8>DJH6C9JC;6>G8DC9J8IHJ8=ADHH:HLDJA9CDI=6K:D88JGG:9 :;:C96CIH @C:L DG G:6HDC67AN H=DJA9 =6K: @CDLC 67DJI I=: =6GBH I=6I I=:>G 9:8:EI>K:B6G@:I>C<=6H86JH:96C98DCI>CJ:HID86JH:>C J96=N -=::MI:CID;I=:96B6<:L>AA 8DCI>CJ:ID6;;:8II=:;JIJG:D; J96=N6C9>IHG:H>9:CIH :;:C96CIH 8ADH:AN BDC>IDG:9 I=:>G H6A:H 6C9 I=: =67>IH D; EG:H8G>7>C< 9D8IDGH -=:>GH6A:HG:EG:H:CI6I>K:HL=DK>H>I:99D8IDGH6C96II:C9:9 & H@C:LL=>8=9D8IDGHL:G: G:8:>K>C<I=:>GB:HH6<:H6C9=DLI=:9D8IDGHL:G:G:HEDC9>C< :;:C96CIH6AHD=69688:HHID6C986G:;JAANL6I8=:9 I=6IIG68@:9I=::MEADH>K:G>H:>CDE>D>9JH:699>8I>DC>C?JGN6C99:6I= :;:C96CIHCDIDCAN @C:L7JI>CI:C9:9I=6II=:>GB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCHLDJA9E:GHJ69:9D8IDGHIDEG:H8G>7:6C9:C8DJG6<: E6I>:CIHIDJH:I=:>GDE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C :;:C96CIHU68I>DCH6G:C:>I=:GE:GB>II:9CDG:M8JH:97NI=:;68II=6II=:>G9GJ< A67:AHB6N=6K:6AADL:9DG9>9CDI:M8AJ9:I=:JH:D;DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C 6EEGDK6AD; )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 91 of 106 DE>D>9H;DG8:GI6>CJH:H9D:HCDI<>K: :;:C96CIHA>8:CH:IDB>HG:EG:H:CII=:G>H@H6C97:C:;>IHD; DE>D>9H 'DG >H :;:C96CIHU 86JH6A GDA: 7GD@:C 7N I=: >CKDAK:B:CI D; EG:H8G>7>C< E=NH>8>6CH :;:C96CIHUB6G@:I>C<:;;DGIHL:G:J7>FJ>IDJH6C9=><=ANE:GHJ6H>K: -=:>G9:8:EI>K: B:HH6<:H6C9JH:D;$(%HI6>CI:9K>GIJ6AAN:K:GNHDJG8:I=6IEG:H8G>7>C<9D8IDGH8DJA9G:ANDC;DG >C;DGB6I>DC 6C9 EG:K:CI:9 I=:B ;GDB B6@>C< >C;DGB:9 IG:6IB:CI 9:8>H>DCH :;:C96CIH 8DCK>C8:9B:G>86I=6I8DBE6HH>DC6I:86G:G:FJ>G:99D8IDGHIDEG:H8G>7:BDG:DE>D>9H :;:C96CIHU 68I>DCH 6C9 DB>HH>DCH L:G: :68= 6 86JH: >C ;68I D; J96=NUH E6HI EG:H:CI6C9;JIJG:96B6<:H (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:; :;:C96CIHULGDC<;JA8DC9J8I>HI=:9>G:8I 86JH:D; J96=NUHE6HIEG:H:CI6C9;JIJG:>C?JG>:H6C9L6HL>AA;JA6C9B6A>8>DJH ,J8=96B6<:H>C8AJ9:7JI6G:CDIA>B>I:9ID8DHIHID6HH:HHI=:DE>D>98G>H>H6C9 8DHIH 6HHD8>6I:9 L>I= A6L :C;DG8:B:CI EJ7A>8 H6;:IN :B:G<:C8N H:GK>8:H EJ7A>8 :9J86I>DC EGD #" & ## #! "## #" &! " #% !$$ # ( #! " $# :;:C96CIH7DI=>C9>K>9J6AAN6C98DAA:8I>K:ANB69:EGDBDI:96C9EGD;>I:9;GDB I=:>GB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH67DJII=:G>H@H6C97:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C:K:CI=DJ<=I=:N @C:LI=:>GB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCHL:G:;6AH:6C99:8:EI>K: -=:=>HIDGND;DE>D>9H6HL:AA6HG:H:6G8= 6C98A>C>86A:ME:G>:C8:DK:GI=:A6HI N:6GH:HI67A>H=:9I=6IDE>D>9HL:G:=><=AN699>8I>K:6C9 G:HEDCH>7A:;DG6ADC<A>HID;K:GNH:G>DJH69K:GH:DJI8DB:H :;:C96CIHB6C>EJA6I:9I=:>GEGDBDI>DC6AB6I:G>6AH6C9I=:H8>:CI>;>8A>I:G6IJG:ID B6@:>I6EE:6GI=6II=:H:>I:BHL:G:688JG6I:IGJI=;JA6C9HJEEDGI:97ND7?:8I>K::K>9:C8:L=:C I=:NL:G:CDI )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 92 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 93 of 106 +,+4*'4987+'9+*' :(2/) :/8'4)+ H6AA:<:9I=GDJ<=DJII=>H DBEA6>CI :;:C96CIH8G:6I:96C9B6>CI6>C:96EJ7A>8 CJ>H6C8:L=>8=EGDM>B6I:AN86JH:9>C?JGNID J96=N EJ7A>8CJ>H6C8:>HR68DC9>I>DCDG68I>K>IN L=>8=JCG:6HDC67AN>CI:G;:G:HL>I=I=:JH:D;6EJ7A>8EA68:DGL>I=I=:68I>K>I>:HD;6C:CI>G: 8DBBJC>IN S :;:C96CIH >C9>K>9J6AAN 6C9 >C 8DC8:GI L>I= :68= DI=:G =6K: >CI:CI>DC6AAN DG G:8@A:HHAN >CI:G;:G:9 L>I= I=: EJ7A>8 G><=IH >C J96=N :;:C96CIH =6K: 86JH:9 DG 6HH>HI:9 >C 86JH>C<68DC9>I>DCI=6I>H6<6>CHII=:DG9:G6C9:8DCDBND;I=:HI6I:D;0>H8DCH>C6C9L=>8= 6CCDNH>C?JG:H6C9:C96C<:GHI=:8DB;DGIG:EDH:=:6AI=6C9H6;:IND;I=:8>I>O:CHD; J96=N :;:C96CIH =6K: 8G:6I:9 6C9 B6>CI6>C:9 6 EJ7A>8 CJ>H6C8: 7N B6G@:I>C< 9>HIG>7JI>C<6C99>HE:CH>C<DE>D>9H>CL6NHI=6IJCG:6HDC67AN>CI:G;:G:L>I=I=:EJ7A>8=:6AI= L:A;6G:6C9H6;:IN>C J96=N6C9 J96=N6C9I=:G:H>9:CIHD; J96=N=6K:68DBBDCG><=IID 7:;G::;GDBHJ8=8DC9J8I6C9ID7:;G::;GDB8DC9J8II=6I8G:6I:H69>HIJG76C8:6C9G:6HDC67A: 6EEG:=:CH>DCD;96C<:GIDE:GHDC6C9EGDE:GIN J96=N6C9>IHG:H>9:CIH=6K:68DBBDCG><=IID7:;G::;GDB8DC9J8II=6I8G:6I:H 6CJCG:6HDC67A:?:DE6G9NIDI=:EJ7A>8=:6AI=L:A;6G:6C9H6;:IN6C9ID7:;G::;GDB8DC9J8II=6I 8G:6I:H69>HIJG76C8:6C9G:6HDC67A:6EEG:=:CH>DCD;96C<:GIDE:GHDC6C9EGDE:GIN :;:C96CIH >C?JG>DJHAN6;;:8I:9EJ7A>8G><=IH>C8AJ9>C<I=:G><=IIDEJ7A>8=:6AI=EJ7A>8H6;:INEJ7A>8E:68: 6C9EJ7A>88DB;DGID;I=:E:DEA:D; J96=N -=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD; :;:C96CIHULGDC<;JA6C9>AA:<6A68I>DCH6HH:I;DGI=67DK: =6K:6AHDG:HJAI:9>C6C>CI:CI>DC6A>CK6H>DCD;I=:>CI:G:HID; J96=N6C9>IH8DBBJC>I>:H>CI=: JH:6C9:C?DNB:CID;I=:EJ7A>86C9EG>K6I:A6C98DBEG>H>C< J96=NUH7DJC96G>:H )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 94 of 106 -=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD; :;:C96CIHULGDC<;JA6C9>AA:<6A68I>DCH6HH:I;DGI=67DK: =6K:;JGI=:GG:HJAI:9>C:CK>GDCB:CI6A8DCI6B>C6I>DC6C9 DG96B6<:ID J96=NUHEGDE:GIN :;:C96CIHU >CI:G;:G:C8: >H JCG:6HDC67A: 7:86JH: :;:C96CIHU CJ>H6C8: 8G:6I>C< 8DC9J8I 6 "CKDAK:H 6 H> 7 I6AAG:A:K6CII>B:HL6H6C9>HEGDH8G>7:97NHI6I:6C9;:9:G6AA6LH6C9G: 8 "HD;68DCI>CJ>C<C6IJG:6C9=6HEGD9J8:96E:GB6C:CI6C9ADC< A6HI>C<:;;:8I6C9 9 !6H =69 6C9 8DCI>CJ:H ID =6K: 6 H> +,+4*'498B49+7,+7+4)+ +8:29+*/4!/-4/,/)'49'73 :;:C96CIHU>CI:G;:G:C8:L>I=I=:EJ7A>8=:6AI=EJ7A>8H6;:INEJ7A>8E:68:EJ7A>8 8DB;DGI6C9EJ7A>88DCK:C>:C8:G:HJAI:9>C=6GBID J96=NI=6I>H7DI=H> ;GDBI=:=6GBHJ;;:G:97NDI=:GB:B7:GHD;I=:EJ7A>8 :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I =6H 6C9 8DCI>CJ:H ID H> 8DBBDC ID I=: <:C:G6A EJ7A>8 R,> >C8DCK:C>:C8:DGE:IIN6CCDN6C8: :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I=6H9>G:8IAN86JH:9 6 -=:8G:6I>DCD;6C>AA:<6AH:8DC96GNB6G@:I;DGEG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H 7 6HN688:HHIDEG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H7N8=>A9G:C6C9I::C6<:GH 8 "C8G:6H:9 >C8>9:C8: ;G:FJ:C8N DE>D>9 67JH: 699>8I>DC DK:G9DH: >C?JG>:H 6C9 9:6I=H 9 "C;6CIH 7DGC 9:E:C9:CI DC DE>D>9H 9J: ID EG:C6I6A :MEDHJG: 86JH>C< H:K:G: L>I=9G6L6AHNBEIDBH6C9A6HI>C<9:K:ADEB:CI6A>BE68IH : BEADN:GHIDADH:I=:K6AJ:D;EGD9J8I>K:6C9=:6AI=N:BEADN::H6C9 ; "C8G:6H:98DHIH6C9:ME:CH:H;DG J96=NG:A6I:9IDI=:EGDK>H>DCD;:B:G<:C8N H:GK>8:HA6L:C;DG8:B:CIEJ7A>8H6;:IN6C9HD8>6AH:GK>8:H )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 95 of 106 +,+4*'49849+49/54'22>':8+*9.+ :(2/) :/8'4)+ :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8IL6H>CI:CI>DC6A I6AAG:A:K6CII>B:H :;:C96CIH@C:LI=6I I=:CJ>H6C8:L6HG:HJAI>C<DGL6HHJ7HI6CI>6AAN8:GI6>CIDG:HJAI;GDBI=:>G8DC9J8I :;:C96CIH 68I:9;DGI=:EJGEDH:D;>C8G:6H>C<H6A:H6C99>HIG>7JI>DCD;I=:>GDE>D>9EGD9J8IHI=:G:;DG:I=: G:HJAI>C<;ADD9D;DE>D>9H>CIDAD86A8DBBJC>I>:HL6H>C;68I>CI:CI>DC6AAN8G:6I:97N :;:C96CIH :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I 8DCHI>IJI:H K>DA6I>DCH D; 0>H8DCH>C A6L HE:8>;>86AAN 0>H ,I6I P B6C90>H ,I6I P L=>8=6G:HI6IJI:HG:A6I:9IDEJ7A>8H6;:IN6C9EJ7A>8 =:6AI= :;:C96CIHUJCA6L;JACJ>H6C8: 8G:6I>C<8DC9J8I>C8AJ9:HG:E:6I:9K>DA6I>DCHD;8DCIGDAA:9 HJ7HI6C8:A6LH6C9G: 6 &6G@:I>C< 9>HIG>7JI>C< 6C9 9>HE:CH>C< DE>D>9H >C L6NH I=6I ;68>A>I6I:9 6C9 :C8DJG6<:9I=:>G;ADL>CIDI=:>AA:<6AH:8DC96GNB6G@:I 7 >HIG>7JI>C<6C99>HE:CH>C<DE>D>9HL>I=DJIB6>CI6>C>C<:;;:8I>K:8DCIGDAH6<6>CHI I=:9>K:GH>DCD;DE>D>9H 8 =DDH>C<CDIID:;;:8I>K:ANBDC>IDG;DGHJHE>8>DJHDG9:GH 9 =DDH>C<CDIID>CK:HI><6I:HJHE>8>DJHDG9:GH : DCI>CJ>C<IDB6@:H=>EB:CIHD;DE>D>9HIDG:I6>A:GH@CDLCID9>HE:CH:DE>D>9H>C :M8:HHD;I=:B:9>86AC::9D;I=:AD86AEDEJA6I>DC ; =DDH>C<CDIIDG:EDGIHJHE>8>DJHDG9:GHDGEG:H8G>EI>DCH < =DDH>C<CDIIDHIDEDGHJHE:C9H=>EB:CIHD;HJHE>8>DJHDG9:GH = 6>A>C<IDB6>CI6>C:;;:8I>K:8DCIGDAH6<6>CHII=:9>K:GH>DCD;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H :;:C96CIHU68I>DCH6C9DB>HH>DCH8DCHI>IJI:8G>B:H6<6>CHII=:DG9:G6C9:8DCDBN D;I=:,I6I:D;0>H8DCH>C6C96G:=6GB;JAIDI=:EJ7A>8=:6AI=H6;:INE:68:EGDHE:G>IN8DB;DGI 6C9 8DCK:C>:C8: D; J96=N G:H>9:CIH -=DJ<= I=: JCA6L;JA B6G@:I>C< EGDBDI>DC H6A: 9>HIG>7JI>DCD;DE>D>9H :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I=6H=69;6G G:68=>C<69K:GH::;;:8IHDCI=: J96=N 8DBBJC>INL>I==6GB;6GDJIL:><=>C<6CN7:C:;>I )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 96 of 106 :;:C96CIHU 68I>DCH 6C9 DB>HH>DCH =6K: 6CCDN:9 >C?JG:9 6C9 :C96C<:G:9 I=: 8DB;DGI G:EDH: =:6AI= 6C9 H6;:IN D; 8DJCIA:HH J96=N G:H>9:CIH :;:C96CIHU 68I>DCH 6C9 DB>HH>DCH6AHDD;;:C9<:C:G6AEJ7A>89:8:C8N +,+4*'498B54*:)9<'8#47+'854'(2+ :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I >C 86JH>C< I=: CJ>H6C8: L6H JCG:6HDC67A: C >CI:CI>DC6A >CK6H>DCD;6CDI=:GUH>CI:G:HI>CI=:JH:6C9:C?DNB:CID;A6C9>HJCG:6HDC67A:>;6I=: D;I=:=6GBDJIL:><=HI=:JI>A>IND;I=:68IDGUH8DC9J8IDG7I=:=6GB86JH:97NI=:8DC9J8I>H H:G>DJH6C9I=:8DHID;8DBE:CH6I>C<;DGI=>H6C9H>B>A6G=6GBIDDI=:GHLDJA9HI>AAB6@:>I;:6H>7A: ;DG :;:C96CIHID8DCI>CJ:I=:8DC9J8I 0>9:HEG:69 DE>D>9 JH: G:HJAI>C< ;GDB :;:C96CIHU 8DC9J8I =6H >CI:G;:G:9 6C9 8DCI>CJ:H ID >CI:G;:G: L>I= I=: EJ7A>8 G><=IH D; J96=N 8>I>O:CH -=: J96=N 8DBBJC>IN =6H HJ;;:G:9>C?JG>:H6H6G:HJAID; :;:C96CIHUJCA6L;JA8DC9J8I>C8AJ9>C<7JICDIA>B>I:9ID 6 %DHHD;A>;:86JH:97NDK:G9DH: 7 99>8I>DCID6C99:E:C9:C8:DCDE>D>9H 8 >K:GH>DCD;DE>D>9H>CIDH:8DC96GN8G>B>C6AB6G@:IHG:HJAI>C<>C6C67JC96C8:D; DE>D>9H6K6>A67A:;DGCDC B:9>86A6C98G>B>C6AJH:>C J96=N 9 >HGJEI>DCD;E:68:I=GDJ<=>C8G:6H:9EGDE:GINK>DA:CI6C99GJ<8G>B:H : "C8G:6H:9JC:BEADNB:CI6C9ADHHD;EGD9J8I>K>IN ; "C8G:6H:9 9:B6C9 DC J96=N G:HDJG8:H ID DE:G6I: EJ7A>8 ;68>A>I>:H EGDK>9: :B:G<:C8NH:GK>8:H6C9EJ7A>8H6;:IN A6L:C;DG8:B:CIH:GK>8:H < :EA:I>DCD; J96=NUH;>C6C8>6AG:HDJG8:H6H6G:HJAID;;JC9HHE:CIDCDG9>K:GI:9 IDDE>D>9 G:A6I:9H:GK>8:H>C8AJ9>C<7JICDIA>B>I:9ID:B:G<:C8NH:GK>8:HA6L :C;DG8:B:CI6C9EJ7A>8H6;:IN :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I>HDC I=6I :;:C96CIH@C:LDGH=DJA9=6K:@CDLCLDJA96;;:8I6EJ7A>8G><=I :;:C96CIHUJCA6L;JA 8DC9J8I=6HIG6CHE>G:9DK:G6C:MI:C9:9E:G>D9D;I>B:6C98DCI>CJ:HIDI=>H96N "I=6H86JH:9 )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 97 of 106 9:6I=H:G>DJH>C?JGN699>8I>DC6C96HJ7HI6CI>6A>CI:G;:G:C8:L>I=I=:EJ7A>8E:68:DG9:G6C9 H6;:IN>CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H6C9>C J96=N -=:CJ>H6C8:8G:6I:97N :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I=6HCDI7::C676I:9 :;:C96CIHU B>H8DC9J8I6AA:<:9>CI=>H86H:>HDC -=::;;:8IHD; :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I=6K:7::CHDHJ7HI6CI>6A6C9L>9:HEG:69I=6I I=:CJ>H6C8:E:GE:IJ6I:97NI=:>G8DC9J8I>HCDL8DBBDCANG:;:GG:9ID6H6CR:E>9:B>8SDGR8G>H>HS >CI=:.C>I:9,I6I:H6C9 J96=N :;:C96CIH@C:LDGH=DJA9=6K:@CDLCI=:>G8DC9J8ILDJA9 6;;:8I 6 EJ7A>8 G><=I :;:C96CIH @C:L I=6I DE>D>9H EDH:9 9:E:C9:C8:6C99>K:GH>DC7JICDC:I=:A:HHEGD9J8:9EGDBDI:99>HIG>7JI:96C9B6G@:I:9DE>D>9H ;DG7GD69JH:>C J96=N :;:C96CIHEGDBDI:99>HIG>7JI:96C9B6G@:I:96B:9>86AANJCC:8:HH6GNKDAJB: D;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H;DGJH:>C J96=N :;:C96CIH@C:LDGH=DJA9=6K:@CDLCI=:>G8DC9J8ILDJA9>C;A>8IE:GB6C:CIDG ADC< A6HI>C<=6GBDC J96=N :;:C96CIHEGDBDI:96C9;68>A>I6I:9L>9:HEG:69EG:H8G>7>C<6C9JH:D;DE>D>9HID IG:6I8=GDC>8E6>C7NB6@>C<8DJCIA:HHB>HG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C9DB>HH>DCHD;B6I:G>6A;68IL>I= G:HE:8IIDI=:>GG>H@H6C97:C:;>IH :;:C96CIHJI>A>O:97G6C9:96C9JC7G6C9:9B6G@:I>C<B6I:G>6AH:M:GI:9>BEGDE:G >C;AJ:C8:DK:G69KD868N 6C9E:GE:IJ6I:EGD DE>D>9EDA>8>:H6C9EG68I>8:H6C9I6>CI:9HDJG8:HD;B:9>86A>C;DGB6I>DCL>I= B>HA:69>C<>C;DGB6I>DC>CHJEEDGID;8=GDC>8DE>D>9JH: :;:C96CIH B69: DE>D>9H G:69>AN 6K6>A67A: >C J96=N ;DG >AA:<>I>B6I: JH: 7N HJEEAN>C<6C99>HIG>7JI>C<BDG:DE>D>9HI=6C8DJA9H:GK:6I=:G6E:JI>8EJGEDH: )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 98 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 99 of 106 >C8AJ9>C<:ME:CH:H;DGEDA>8::B:G<:C8N=:6AI=8G>B>C6A?JHI>8:8DGG:8I>DCH6C9DI=:GH:GK>8:H 9>G:8IAN6C9EGDM>B6I:AN86JH:97N :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I $ # 22+,+4*'498 J96=NG:EA:69H6C9>C8DGEDG6I:H7NG:;:G:C8::68=D;I=:6AA:<6I>DCH8DCI6>C:9>C I=>H DBEA6>CI6H>;;JAANH:I;DGI==:G:>C :;:C96CIHDL:9 J96=N69JIN6C97G:68=:9I=6I9JIN6C968I:9L>I=G:8@A:HHC:HH 6C986G:A:HHC:HHL=>8=86JH:996B6<:HID J96=N -=JH :;:C96CIH6G:A>67A:ID J96=N;DG C:<:C8: +,+4*'498 <+*:*'.>':9>5, 7*/4'7>57 +'854'(2+'7+ .C9:G0>H8DCH>CA6L :;:C96CIH=6969JINID:M:G8>H:DG9>C6GN86G:JC9:GI=: 8>G8JBHI6C8:HHDI=6II=:>G8DC9J8I9>9CDI8G:6I:6CJCG:6HDC67A:G>H@D;=6GBID J96=N :;:C96CIH =6K: 6 9JIN ID :M:G8>H: G:6HDC67A: DG DG9>C6GN 86G: >C I=: 9:H> B6CJ;68IJG: B6G@:I>C< 9>HIG>7JI>DC 6C9 9>HE:CH>C< D; I=:>G DE>D>9 EGD9J8IH &DG:DK:G :;:C96CIH6G: G:<>HIG6CIH6C96G:A>8:CH:9L>I=I=:0>H8DCH>C :E6GIB:CID;,6;:IN6C9 )GD;:HH>DC6A,:GK>8:H6HL=DA:H6A:9>HIG>7JIDGHD;EG:H8G>EI>DC9GJ HJ8= =6K: 9JI>:H JC9:G HI6I: 6C9 ;:9:G6A A6LH 6C9 G: 9GJ )=6G Q 6C9 + PP 6 6 &6CJ;68IJG:G :;:C96CIH DL: 6 9JIN D; G:6HDC67A: DG DG9>C6GN 86G: >C B6@>C< G:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C96H8:GI6>C>C<I=:688JG68ND;>C;DGB6I>DC<>K:CIDDI=:GH>C8AJ9>C< J96=N 6C9>IHG:H>9:CIH .C9:GI=:8>G8JBHI6C8:H6G:6HDC67ANEGJ9:CI9GJ<B6CJ;68IJG:GLDJA9@CDL I=6II=:>G6;;>GB6I>K:68I>DCHD;6< )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 100 of 106 8=GDC>8E6>CIG:6IB:CIL=>A:;6>A>C<IDEGDK>9:HJ;;>8>:CIL6GC>C D;DE>D>9HLDJA9G:HJAI>CI=:H:K:G:=6GBHD;DK:G EG:H8G>EI>DCB>HJH:9>K:GH>DC699>8I>DC6C9 9:E:C9:C8:;DG:H::67AN86JH>C<E6I>:CIHIDH::@>C8G:6H>C<A:K:AHD;DE>D>9H6C9IDIJGCIDI=: >AA:<6A9GJ<B6G@:I6H6G:HJAID;699>8I>DC >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH=6K:69JINIDI6@:G:6HDC67A:HI:EHIDEG:K:CII=:B>HJH: 9>K:GH>DC 6C9 DK:G 9>HE:CH>C< D; DE>D>9H .C9:G I=:H: 8>G8JBHI6C8:H 6 G:6HDC67AN EGJ9:CI L=DA:H6A: 9GJ< 9>HIG>7JIDG LDJA9 =6K: 6CI>8>E6I:9 I=6I I=:>G 6;;>GB6I>K: 68I>DCH >C8AJ9>C< I=: JC;:II:G:99>HIG>7JI>DCD;B>AA>DCHD;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9HLDJA9G:HJAI>CI=:9>K:GH>DCD;DE>D>9 9GJ 9>HIG>7JIDGH68I6H<6I:@::E:GH7:IL::CB6CJ;68IJG:G8DBE6C>:H6C9E=6GB68>:H>CDG9:GID8DCIGDA 6C9G: GDA:I=:NEA6N>CB6>CI6>C>C<68ADH:9HNHI:B;DGDE>D>9H6C9LDJA9=6K:6CI>8>E6I:9I=:=6GBH I=:>G68I>DCH9:H8G>7:9=:G:>CLDJA986JH: 'DC:I=:A:HH >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH8DBB>II:9I=: JCG:6HDC67A:68IH6C9DB>HH>DCH9>H8JHH:9=:G:>CL=>8=8G:6I:96CJCG:6HDC67A:G>H@D;=6GBID DI=:GH )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH=6K:69JINIDI6@:G:6HDC67A:HI:EHIDEG:K:CII=:B>HJH: 9>K:GH>DC 6C9 DK:G 9>HE:CH>C< D; DE>D>9H )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH =69 6 9JIN ID 9:H> >BEA:B:CI HNHI:BH ID EG:K:CI 9>K:GH>DC D; 8DCIGDAA:9 HJ7HI6C8:H >C I=:>G G:I6>A E=6GB68N DE:G6I>DCH )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH=6969JINID6C6ANO:HJEEAN8=6>C96I6;DG@CDLCG:9;A6 6H6;>AA>C<BJAI>EA:EG:H8G>EI>DCHIDI=:H6B:E6I>:CIJH>C<I=:H6B:9D8IDG7;>AA>C<BJAI>EA: EG:H8G>EI>DCH7NI=:H6B:E6I>:CIJH>C<9>;;:G:CI9D8IDGH8;>AA>C<DG9:GHD;JCJHJ6AH>O:6C9 ;G:FJ:C8N;DGI=:H6B:E6I>:CI9;>AA>C<DG9:GH;GDBDJI D; HI6I:E6I>:CIH:;>AA>C<DG9:GHE6>9 ;DG>C86H=;;>AA>C<DG9:GH;GDBI=:H6B:EG:H8G>7>C<E=NH>8>6C6C9<;>AA>C<DG9:GHD;JCJHJ6A )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 101 of 106 H>O:6C9;G:FJ:C8N;GDBDJI D; HI6I:E=NH>8>6CH .C9:GI=:H:8>G8JBHI6C8:H6G:6HDC67ANEGJ9:CI E=6GB68NLDJA9=6K:6CI>8>E6I:9I=6II=:>G6;;>GB6I>K:68I>DCH>C8AJ9>C<I=:;6>AJG:ID:C;DG8:DG :C68IG:6HDC67A:EDA>8>:H6C9EGD8:9JG:HID LDJA9G:HJAI>CI=:9>K:GH>DCD;DE>D>99GJ +,+4*'4987+').+*9.+/7:9/+895:*'.> "C 8DCIG6K:CI>DC D; I=:H: 9JI>:H 6C9 6H 9:H8G>7:9 I=GDJ<=DJI I=>H DBEA6>CI &6CJ;68IJG:G :;:C96CIH 7G:68=:9 I=:>G 9JI>:H DL:9 ID J96=N 7N 8DBB>II>C< H:K:G6A JCG:6HDC67A:68IH>C8AJ9>C<7JICDIA>B>I:9ID;6AH:ANB>C>B>O>C<I=:G>H@D;699>8I>DCEGD9J8>C< 6C99>HH:B>C6I>C<B>HA:69>C<7G6C9:96C9JC7G6C9:9A>I:G6IJG:IDJI>C<I=:7:C:;>IHD;DE>D>9H EGDK>9>C< >C8DBEA:I: 6C9 >CHJ;;>8>:CI L6GC>C E=NH>8>6CH9:8:EI>K:ANB6G@:I>C<R67JH: 9:I:GG:CISI:8=CDAD H> >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIH 7G:68=:9 I=:>G 9JI>:H DL:9 ID J96=N >HIG>7JIDG :;:C96CIHL:G:C:<:CI>C8DBB>II>C<H:K:G6AJCG:6HDC67A:68IH>C8AJ9>C<7JICDIA>B>I:9ID ;6>A>C<IDI6@:68I>DCIDEG:K:CIDGG:9J8:6C9>C9::9:C<6<>C<>CI=:9>HIG>7JI>DCD;>AA>8>IAN EG:H8G>7:9 DE>D>9H 6C9 GDJI>C:AN @CDL>C B:9>86AEJGEDH:6C9@CDL>C 8DBBJC>IN )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH7G:68=:9I=:>G9JI>:HDL:9ID J96=N )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH L:G:C:<:CI>C8DBB>II>C<H:K:G6AJCG:6HDC67A:68IH>C8AJ9>C<7JICDIA>B>I:9ID;6>A>C<ID I6@: 68I>DC ID EG:K:CI DG G:9J8: 6C9 >C9::9 :C<6<>C< >C I=: 9>HE:CH>C< D; DE>D>9H L>I=DJI B6>CI6>C>C<:;;:8I>K:EDA>8>:H6C9EGD8:9JG:HID B6G@:IH )=6GB68N :;:C96CIHGDJI>C:AN6C9@CDL>C )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 102 of 106 K6A>9 B:9>86A EJGEDH: 99>I>DC6AAN )=6GB68N :;:C96CIH ;6>A:9 ID 6 69:FJ6I:AN IG6>C E=6GB68>HIH6C9I:8=C>8>6CHIDJC9:GI6@:EGDE:G>CFJ>G>:HG:<6G9>C<EG:H8G>EI>DCH769:FJ6I:AN :BEADN96I6ID>9:CI>;N9D8IDGHL=DDK:GEG:H8G>7:88DC9J8I6J9>IHD;DE>D>9H6A:HID>9:CI>;N E6II:GCH D; >BEGDE:GAN ;>AA:9 EG:H8G>EI>DCH 6C9 69DEI EG:K:CI6I>K: EDA>8>:H 6C9 9 G:HEDC9 ID :BEADN::HU8DC8:GCHG:<6G9>C<>C69:FJ6I:DE>D>99>HE:CH>C<EDA>8>:H6C9EGD8:9JG:H I6AAG:A:K6CII>B:H :;:C96CIHL:G:DGH=DJA9=6K:7::C6L6G:I=6II=:FJ6CI>IN D;DE>D>9HI=:N9>HIG>7JI:9DG9>HE:CH:9L6HJCG:6HDC67A:6C9JCI:C67A:<>K:CI=:AD86AEDEJA6I>DC 6C9C::9HD;I=:8DBBJC>IN :HE>I:8A:6GG:9;A6 EJGEDH:H :;:C96CIH;6>A:9IDI6@:B:6C>C<;JAB:6HJG:HID>CK:HI><6I:6C9:CHJG:8DBEA>6C8: L>I=6CI> 9>K:GH>DC8DCIGDAH G:6HDC67ANEGJ9:CI&6CJ;68IJG:G >HIG>7JIDGDG)=6GB68N68I>C< JC9:GI=:H6B:8>G8JBHI6C8:HLDJA9@CDLI=6II=:KDAJB:D;EG:H8G>EI>DCDE>D>9H9>HIG>7JI:9ID 6C99>HE:CH:9>C6C96GDJC9 J96=N>H>C9>86I>K:D;9>K:GH>DC6C9>AA>8>ICDC B:9>86AJH: (C>C;DGB6I>DC6C97:A>:; :;:C96CIH@C:LI=6II=:DI=:GHU8DC9J8I8DCHI>IJI:96 7G:68=D;9JIN7JI9>9CDI9D6CNI=>C<67DJI>I :;:C96CIHL:G:>CKDAK:9>C68DC8:GI:968I>DC L>I=:68=DI=:G7N<>K>C<HJ7HI6CI>6A6HH>HI6C8:DG:C8DJG6<:B:CI;DGI=:H6A:6C99>HIG>7JI>DCD; DE>D>9H +,+4*'498B+.';/57<'8'7+2+88'4* +)12+88 :;:C96CIHU 68IH 6C9 DB>HH>DCH L=:C K>:L:9 D7?:8I>K:AN ;GDB I=: 68IDGHU HI6C9ED>CI>CKDAK:96C:MIG:B:9: EDI:CI>6A=6GB :;:C96CIH=6968IJ6AHJ7?:8I>K:6L6G:C:HHD;I=:G>H@>CKDAK:97JIC:K:GI=:A:HH EGD8::9:9>C8DCH8>DJH>C9>;;:G:C8:6C96G:8@A:HH6C9L6CIDC9>HG:<6G9D;I=:G><=IHH6;:IN6C9 L:A;6G:D;DI=:GH )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 103 of 106 :;:C96CIHU68I>DCH6C9DB>HH>DCH:M=>7>I:96L>AA;JA>CI:CIID>C?JG:6C9;6>AJG:ID D7H:GK::K:CHA><=I86G: :;:C96CIHU86G:A:HHC:HH6C9G:8@A:HHC:HHGDH:ID69: I=: :;:C96CIHU JII:G >C9>;;:G:C8: ID I=: ;DG:H::67A: 8DCH:FJ:C8:H I=:N @C:L DG H=DJA9 =6K: @CDLCB6NG:HJAI 0=:CK>:L:9;GDBI=: :;:C96CIHUHI6C9ED>CII=:>G68IHD;;6AH:ANB>C>B>O>C<I=: G>H@D;699>8I>DC9:8:EI>K:ANB6G@:I>C<DE>D>9H6C99>HIG>7JI>C<DE>D>9HID J96=N>C6BDJCIH ;6GIDDA6G<:;DG6CNK6A>9B:9>86AEJGEDH:EA6>CAN>CKDAK:96C:MIG:B:AN=><=9: EDH:9HJ7HI6CI>6A=6GBIDI=:8DBBJC>I>:HI=:NH:GK:9>C8AJ9>C< J96=N :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8I EDH:9G>H@HI=6IL:G:HJ7HI6CI>6AANA>@:ANIDD88JG7:86JH:I=:>G68IHL:G:CDIHJEEDGI:97N6C9 >C;68IL:G:8DCIG6GNIDG:A>67A:H8>:CI>;>8:K>9:C8: +,+4*'498B +-2/-+4)+'7+2+884+88'4* +)12+884+88':8+*:*'.>B840:7/+8 :;:C96CIHUC:<:CI68IHL:G:HJ7HI6CI>6A;68IDGH>CEGD9J8>C< J96=NUH>C?JG>:H 68=D;I=: :;:C96CIH8DJA9=6K:G:6HDC67AN;DG:H::CI=6II=:>G8DC9J8ILDJA9 86JH:>C?JGNID J96=N H6;DG:H::67A:6C9EGDM>B6I:G:HJAID; :;:C96CIHU7G:68=D;I=:>G9JI>:H 7N L6N D; I=:>G 6;;>GB6I>K: 68I>DCH 8>I>O:CH D; J96=N 7:86B: 699>8I:9 ID DE>D>9 EGD9J8IH HJHI6>C:9DE>D>9 G:A6I:9>C?JG>:H6C9G:FJ>G:9B:9>86A86G:G:=67>A>I6I>DCHD8>6AH:GK>8:HEJ7A>8 H6;:INA6L:C;DG8:B:CIHD8>6AH:GK>8:H6C9DI=:G >IN EGDK>9:986G:86JH>C< J96=NID>C8JG 68IH6C9DB>HH>DCH=><=AN699>8I>K:DE>D>9HLDJA9CDI=6K:H6IJG6I:9I=: J96=N8DBBJC>IN 86JH>C<L>9:HEG:69699>8I>DC>C?JGN6C99:6I= :;:C96CIHU8DC9J8IEDH:9;DG:H::67A:EDI:CI>6A=6GBD; HDJ<=IID<:C:G6I:6HBJ8=DE>D>9JH:6HEDHH>7A:6C9EDI:CI>6A=6GBL6H:MEDC:CI>6AAN L>I= )6<:D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 104 of 106 B:6HJG:H :;:C96CIHIDD@ID6II6>CL>9:HEG:69688:EI6C8:6C9JH:D;DE>D>9H;DG8=GDC>8E6>C >C8AJ9>C<I=:>GH@N =><=H6A:H IDHJEEAN6C99>HIG>7JI: :;:C96CIH L:G: H:AA>C< 6C9 DG B6CJ;68IJG>C< 96C<:GDJH 9GJ 86I: @CDL>C 9>K:GI:9IDDI=:GI=6CA:<>I>B6I:B:9>86AH8>:CI>;>8DG>C9JHIG>6A8=6CC:AH :86JH:D;I=:H:K:G: A:K:AD;96C<:GEDH:97N6C9>C9::9K>H>I:9JEDC J96=N7NI=:H:96C<:GDJH9GJ DL:96=><=9JIND;86G:ID:CHJG:I=6II=:H:9GJ :;:C96CIH8=DH:EGD;>IDK:GEGJ9:C8:6C9I=:H6;:IND; J96=N6C96C6L6G9D;EJC>I>K:96B6<:H >H6EEGDEG>6I:6HEJC>H=B:CI6C969:I:GG:C8: :;:C96CIHL:G:>CI=:7:HIEDH>I>DCIDEG:K:CII=:=6GBHID J96=N:MI:C9>C< ;GDBI=:>G6;;>GB6I>K:8DC9J8I9J:IDI=:>G69K6C8:9@CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<I=:>GDE>D>9EGD9J8IH :;:C96CIHL:G:L:AA6L6G:D;I=:;DG:H::67A:G>H@H>CKDAK:9L>I=I=:>G;G6J9JA:CI 6C9=><=ANG:EG:=:CH>7A:8DC9J8IN:IEGD8::9:9L>I=8DCH8>DJH>C9>;;:G:C8:86G:A:HHC:HH6C9 G:8@A:HHC:HHG:<6G9>C<I=:G><=IHH6;:IN6C9L:A;6G:D;I=DH:L=DLDJA97:6;;:8I:9>C8AJ9>C< J96=N6C9>IHG:H>9:CIH 88DG9>C A6L>C8AJ9>C<68IJ6A96B6<:HEJC>I>K:96B6<:HEG:?J9 8DJGI8DHIH )6<: D; Case 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 105 of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ase 2021CV002934 Document 21 Filed 05-18-2021 Page 106 of 106 - I=>H I=96ND;&6N +:HE:8I;JAANHJ7B>II:9 # *)+"& !"((* &6GI>C# )=>EEH()'! -" ( & "& -:M6H6G'D 67:(GI>O -:M6H6G'D &:6<6C& -6A6;JH: -:M6H6G'D 76H>&6?DG -:M6H6G'D I=,IG::I ,6CCIDC>D-:M6H - BE=>EEHE=>EEHDGI>OI6A6;JH: 8DB )6<: D; H69K:GI>H>C<I=6IEGDBDI:HDE>D>9JH:<:C:G6AAN7JI9D:HD>9HG:;:GHIDI=:;>C6AHI:E>CI=: