Kmen+Weinzirl Master Thesis

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Kmen+Weinzirl Master Thesis Stockholm School of Economics Institute of Marketing & Strategy Master Thesis Spring 2013 RETOUCHED! A quantitative study on how the digital modification of models in print advertisements affects consumer reactions The display of highly attractive models in advertising and the negative psychological effects the exposure to such unattainable beauty ideals has on consumers is a controversial topic that is widely discussed in literature. Current scandals related to digitally manipulating models fuel the debate. This raises the question why marketers retouch models in the first place. No empirical research has yet proved whether digitally idealizing the body of an already attractive female model in print advertisements leads to increased perceived attractiveness ratings or more positive consumer reactions. Thus, the purpose of this study is to fill this research gap by exploring whether the positive effects that marketers claim idealized advertising imagery to have on advertising effectiveness truly exist. This is done by digitally manipulating the looks of a female model according to standards common in the industry. Two print advertisements where this decorative model promotes either an appearance-related product (razor) or and appearance-unrelated product (vitamin water) are created. In a quantitative laboratory experiment a total sample of 422 Romanian students is exposed to one of the product ads, in one of three ad conditions: an ad showing the untouched model, an ad showing the retouched model, or an ad showing the product-only. Subsequently, a questionnaire assesses their reactions in terms of cognitive responses, attitudes and intentions. There is evidence that the idealization of female models in print advertisements fails to produce higher levels of ad, brand and product attitude, product intention, willingness to pay a higher price or word of mouth intention, at a statistically significant level. The only statistically significant difference was found for the product and brand recall of the appearance-unrelated product (vitamin water), where the retouched model led to a higher cognitive response. Keywords: retouching, Photoshop practices, female model attractiveness, decorative models, advertising effectiveness Authors: Tutor: Madalina Kmen (40360) Hanna Berg Andrea Weinzirl (40290) Examiner: Discussants: Jonas Colliander Frida Fogström (21700) Malin Sundqvist (21124) Presentation: May 30, 2013 Retouched! Kmen & Weinzirl 2013 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We would like to thank our tutor Hanna Berg for her input, inspiration and guidance throughout the semester, our expert interviewees Alexandru Malaescu, Art Director of BBDO Bucharest as well as Tudor Bercea and Andrei Stoica, Graphic Designers, for providing us with invaluable insight into their fields of expertise the Canadian fashion retailer Jacob for allowing us to use their untouched model pictures the professors at The Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Bucharest National School of Political Sciences, Bucharest University of Agronomic Science and Veterinary Medicine, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration Iasi and Grigore T. Popa Faculty of Medicine Iasi for letting us conduct the survey during their classes all participants of our pre-studies and main experiment for taking the time and effort to help us with our research and everyone else who supported us on our journey. Thank you very much! Madalina Kmen & Andrea Weinzirl i Retouched! Kmen & Weinzirl 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................................................1 1.1 Background ...........................................................................................................................................1 1.1.1 The Increasing Popularity of Digital Manipulation............................................................1 1.1.2 The Idealization of Female Models and Related Negative Effects...................................2 1.1.3 Movements against Digital Manipulation............................................................................3 1.2 Problematization...................................................................................................................................5 1.3 Purpose and Relevance .......................................................................................................................7 1.4 Expected Knowledge Contribution...................................................................................................7 1.5 Delimitations .........................................................................................................................................8 1.6 Definitions and Clarifications.............................................................................................................9 1.7 Thesis Outline .....................................................................................................................................10 2 THEORY AND HYPOTHESES GENERATION .......................................................................11 2.1 The Physical Attractiveness Phenomenon.....................................................................................11 2.1.1 Physical Attractiveness in Advertising...............................................................................12 2.1.2 Consequences of the Exposure to Idealized Imagery.......................................................13 2.2 Factors Other than Physical Attractiveness Influencing Advertising Effectiveness ..............14 2.2.1 The Role of the Model: Decorative Model Versus Spokesperson ..................................14 2.2.2 Model-Product Congruence..................................................................................................15 2.3 A Framework for Evaluating Advertising Effectiveness ............................................................15 2.4 Hypotheses Generation.....................................................................................................................19 2.4.1 The Relation Between Perceived Model Attractiveness and Retouching.....................19 2.4.2 The Impact of Retouching on Cognitive Response...........................................................19 2.4.3 The Impact of Retouching on Attitude ...............................................................................20 2.4.4 The Impact of Retouching on Intentions ............................................................................21 2.5 Summary of Hypotheses...................................................................................................................24 3 METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................................................25 3.1 Overall Research Strategy.................................................................................................................25 3.1.1 Initial Qualitative Interviews................................................................................................25 3.1.2 Literature Review ...................................................................................................................25 3.1.3 Quantitative Experimental Study ........................................................................................26 3.2 Preparatory Work...............................................................................................................................27 3.2.1 Pre-selection of Product Categories.....................................................................................27 3.2.2 Pre-selection of Models..........................................................................................................27 3.2.3 Pre-test 1: Model and Product Category.............................................................................28 3.2.4 Pre-test 2: Brands ....................................................................................................................31 3.2.5 Ad Creation..............................................................................................................................31 3.2.6 Pre-test 3: Ad............................................................................................................................33 ii Retouched! Kmen & Weinzirl 2013 3.2.7 Pre-test 4: Questionnaire........................................................................................................33 3.3 Main Survey ........................................................................................................................................33 3.3.1 Sample and Data Collection..................................................................................................33 3.3.2 Questionnaire ..........................................................................................................................35 3.4 Research Quality.................................................................................................................................39 3.4.1 Reliability..................................................................................................................................39 3.4.2 Validity .....................................................................................................................................40 3.5 Instruments and Methods of Analysis............................................................................................42 4 RESULTS AND
Recommended publications
  • Pragmatic XML Access Control Using Off-The-Shelf RDBMS
    Pragmatic XML Access Control using Off-the-shelf RDBMS Bo Luo, Dongwon Lee, and Peng Liu? The Pennsylvania State University fbluo, dongwon, [email protected] Abstract. As the XML model gets more popular, new needs arise to specify access control within XML model. Various XML access control models and enforcement methods have been proposed recently. However, by and large, these approaches either assume the support of security fea- tures from XML databases or use proprietary tools outside of databases. Since there are currently few commercial XML databases with such ca- pabilities, the proposed approaches are not yet practical. Therefore, we explore the problem of \Is is possible to fully support XML access control in RDBMS?" We formalize XML and relational access control models us- ing deep set operators. Then we show that the problem of XML AC atop RDBMS is amount to the problem of converting XML deep set opera- tors into equivalent relational deep set operators. We show the conversion algebra and identify the properties to ensure the correct conversion. Fi- nally, we present three practical implementations of XML access controls using off-the-shelf RDBMS and their performance results. 1 Introduction The XML model [9] has emerged as the de facto standard for storing and ex- changing information in the Internet Age. As more information is exchanged over the Web, the issues of security become increasingly important. Such issues span from data level security to network level security to high-level access controls. In this paper, our focus is on how to support access control for XML data.
    [Show full text]
  • Internviews-No 1
    is an internal view about the sustainable education, provided mainly in English language at ”Virgil Madgearu” Economic College from Ploiești, Prahova district is a serie of interviews, sometimes with ourselves, a mixture of feelings & perspectives gathered into a periodical st 1 Isssue/2017 is a 2☺17 spring vision of a teacher and some students turned into reality late in September Colectivul de redacție și de coordonare a primului număr: Simona Lupu (director) Corina Popescu (profesor) Gabriela Grigore (profesor) Mihail Karaghiaur (profesor) Corina Lazăr (profesor) Corina Cristescu (profesor)– Redactor-șef Tehnoredactare, corectare și corectură: Paul Iulian Voicu (elev) Ramona Ioana Sandu (elev) Corina Cristescu (profesor) Grafică logo: Laurențiu Dumitru (artist grafic) Prelucrare foto: Alin Iancu (elev) Profesorii și elevii își asumă originalitatea materialelor redactate. Brand inițiat de Corina Cristescu 1 C☺NTENT 1. ECOviews 1.1. International Practice Enterprise Trade Fair for Students, Prague, March 2017 by Lucian Toma, former 11th E3 p. 3 1.2. Buds in Macedonia by Andrei Iulian Filip, former 9th I p. 4 1.3. Turkish Delight by Miruna Ana Stoica, former 9th S6 p. 5 1.4. Locart: th I Need Not Go by Alexandra Pătrășcioiu, former 9 S2 p. 6 th Do Speakart! by Gabriel Iulian Gavrilă, former 9 I p. 7 2. REtoldVIEWS 2.1. REtelling NICHITA - 35 Senior & Junior students & 3 teachers p. 8. 2.2. RE-creations by Ramona Ioana Sandu (former 9th I) & other 10 Junior students p. 29 2 International Practice Enterprise Trade Fair for students- Prague, March 2017 by Lucian Toma- former 11th E3 Retrospection: One day to go until our first competition.
    [Show full text]
  • Industry Catalogue
    ACADEMIA FILM OLOMOUC #AFO #AFO 52 INDUSTRY 4SCIENCE Thanks to the digital revolution of the 21st century, popu­ larization of science field develops with an exceptional speed. The Industry 4Science programme focuses not only on new technological trends, inventions of documentary narrative or new media innovations, but also on the role of science commu­ nicators and their methods of science popularization. This year the programme provides a backstage insight of unique projects in the process of their development, production and distribution stages. In the Industry section, local experts and world leaders in the popu larization of science focus on the most attractive and entertaining ways of how to share scientific information. Petr Jan Juračka, the 2016 world record holder in drone flying at high altitude, presents a multimedia show including a demonstration of a new drone model. With hundreds of thousands of subscrib­ ers, YouTube social influencers such as Vanessa Hill (BrainCraft) and Anna Rothschild (Gross Science) provide a unique insight into the content and production aspects of developing and presenting science videos on social networks. At Fort Science, delegation from distant Chile represents diversity within the gen­ re in the South American film industry. The essential part of this section consists of festival guests, for whom Industry 4Science creates a platform within which they have the opportunity for networking and pitching their new projects. Professionals from the audiovisual industry and festival organizators meet scientific experts, creating a dynamic energy which is unique for the at­ mosphere of AFO. Because where else do you get the chance to meet science stars, represented for example by Richard Dawkins himself? Besides Industry programme section mentioned above, 4Science platform also offers a workshop Camp 4Science which focuses on the development of upcoming science documentary films.
    [Show full text]
  • The 15Th International Conference on Business Excellence
    Society for Business Excellence Faculty of Business Administration in Foreign Languages Bucharest University of Economic Studies Abstracts The 15th International Conference on Business Excellence Digital Economy and New Value Creation Edited by Carmen PĂUNESCU Constantin BRĂTIANU Roxana CLODNIȚCHI 18-19 March 2021, Bucharest, Romania ©The Authors, 2021. All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission may be made without written permission from the individual authors and, if permission granted, papers should be cited accordingly. Review process All the papers submitted to the 15th International Conference on Business Excellence have been double-blind peer reviewed before final acceptance. Abstracts have been reviewed for relevance and scientific merits and successful authors were invited to submit full papers. We thank our reviewers for ensuring a swift, fair and qualitative review process. Published by: Business Excellence (Publishing House) The Conference Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business Excellence is published with an ISSN and it is submitted to Thomson ISI Web of Science and Elsevier Scopus, by De Gruyter Publishing House. ICBE 2021 Page 2/214 Contents PREFACE ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE ......................................................................................................................... 6 SESSION CHAIRS .......................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Country Report: Romania
    Country Report: Romania 1 Farcaș, R., Moldovan, B., Moisă, C., Oltean, I., Levell, J., Harvey, O., Healy, J., Cole, T., Pritchard, C. (2021) Country Report: Romania. The Other Side of the Story: Perpetrators in Change. (REC-RDAP-GBV-AG-2019 - 881684) This report is the result of the 2nd work package “Time for Change: Evidence Bases research for new practice approaches” of the European project " The Other Side of the Story: Perpetrators in Change” (REC-RDAP-GBV-AG-2019 - 881684) This publication has been produced with the financial support of the European Union’s Rights, Equality and Citizenship Programme (2014-2020) Disclaimer The information and views set out in this report are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the European Union. Neither the European Union institutions and bodies nor any person acting on their behalf may be held responsible for the use which may be made of the information contained therein. Published: 2021 2 Country Report: Romania The Other Side of the Story: Perpetrators in Change 3 Contents Organizational Information ................................................................................................. 7 The Objectives of DASM: .................................................................................................. 7 The Structure of DASM: .................................................................................................... 7 The main departments: ................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Glory Kickboxing
    GLORY KICKBOXING Glory 40: Copenhagen Copenhagen, Denmark April 29, 2017 Weight Class Winner Loser Method Round Time Middleweight Championship Middleweight 85 kg Simon Marcus © New Jason Wilnis © Decision (split) 5 3:00 Middleweight Contender Tournament Final Middleweight Yousri Belgaroui Alex Pereira Decision (unanimous) 3 3:00 Lightweight Niclas Larsen Yodkhunpon Sitmonchai Decision (unanimous) 3 3:00 Middleweight Contender Tournament Semi‐Finals Middleweight Alex Pereira Burim Rama TKO (3 knockdowns) 3 1:42 Middleweight Yousri Belgaroui Agron Preteni Decision (unanimous) 3 3:00 Superfight Series Welterweight Jamie Bates Richard Abraham Decision (unanimous) 3 3:00 Lightweight Mohammed El‐Mir Simón Santana Decision (unanimous) 3 3:00 Light Heavyweight Freddy Kemayo Imad Hadar TKO (punches) 2 2:21 Lightweight Josh Jauncey Antonio Gomez TKO (doctor stoppage) 2 1:05 Featherweight Yuhang Xie Chris Mauceri Decision (unanimous) 3 3:00 Glory 39: Brussels Brussels, Belgium March 25, 2017 Weight Class Winner Loser Method Round Time Welterweight Championship Welterweight Cedric Doumbe © Def Yoann Kongolo Decision (Unanimous) 5 3:00 Featherweight Contender Tournament Final Featherweight Petchpanomrung Kiatmookao Serhiy Adamchuk Decision (Split) 3 3:00 Heavyweight Jamal Ben Saddik Guto Inocente Decision (Unanimous) 3 3:00 Featherweight Contender Tournament Semi Final Featherweight Serhiy Adamchuk Nafi Bilalovski Decision (Unanimous) 3 3:00 Featherweight Petchpanomrung Kiatmookao Alexei Ulyanov Decision (Unanimous) 3 3:00 Lightweight Championship
    [Show full text]
  • Raport Starea Economico Sociala Si De Mediu in Anul
    RAPORTUL PRIMARULUI MUNICIPIULUI CRAIOVA PRIVIND STAREA ECONOMICĂ, SOCIALĂ ŞI DE MEDIU A MUNICIPIULUI CRAIOVA ÎN ANUL 2018 Cuprins Descrierea municipiului Craiova ............................................................................................................. 3 Cadrul fizico-geografic ....................................................................................................................... 3 Relieful ................................................................................................................................................ 3 Geologia şi litologia ............................................................................................................................ 3 Clima ................................................................................................................................................... 4 STAREA ECONOMICĂ ........................................................................................................................ 5 Evoluţii sectoriale ................................................................................................................................ 5 Industria ........................................................................................................................................... 5 Rezultatele şi performanţele întreprinderilor .................................................................................. 5 Agricultură .....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Raport Național ROMÂNIA
    "The Other Side of the Story: Perpetrators in Change" (OSSPC) RAPORT NAȚIONAL ASUPRA SITUAȚIEI VIOLENȚEI DOMESTICE ȘI A MUNCII PROFESIONIȘTILOR CU AGRESORII FAMILIALI ÎN ROMÂNIA Nr. Contract de finanțare REC-RDAP-GBV-AG-2019 - 881684 Farcaș, R., Moldovan, B., Moisă, C., Oltean, I., Levell, J., Harvey, O., Healy, J., Cole, T., Pritchard, C. (2021) Raport national asupra situației violenței domestice și a muncii profesioniștilor cu agresorii familiali în România, elaborat în cadrul proiectului „The Other Side of the Story: Perpetrators in Change” (REC-RDAP-GBV-AG-2019 - 881684) Acest raport este rezultatul celui de-al doilea pachet de activități (WP 2) intitulat „Timpul schimbării: cercetări bazate pe dovezi pentru noi abordări practice” din cadrul proiectului "The Other Side of the Story: Perpetrators in Change”, co-finanțat prin Programul Uniunii Europene Rights, Equality and Citizenship (2014-2020). (REC-RDAP-GBV-AG-2019 - 881684) Disclaimer ”Conţinutul prezentului raport reprezintă responsabilitatea exclusivă a autorilor. Comisia Europeană nu este responsabilă pentru modul în care va fi folosit conţinutul informaţiei”. Această publicație a fost realizată cu sprijinul financiar al Programului Uniunii Europene Rights, Equality and Citizenship (2014-2020) Publicat: 2021 1 Co-funded by the European Union’s Rights, Equality and Citizenship Programme (2014-2020) Cuprins: Informații organizaționale .................................................................................................... 4 Direcția de Asistență Socială și Medicală
    [Show full text]
  • Open Access Journals), EBSCO Discovery Service, Econbiz, Google Scholar
    Conference Program Draft - 12.03.2021 - ICBE Conference Founders Constantin BRATIANU, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Nicolae Al. POP, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Honorary President Nicolae ISTUDOR, Rector of Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Conference President Alina Mihaela DIMA, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Bucharest, Romania Conference Programme Chair Constantin BRATIANU, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Bucharest, Romania Academic Coordinator Tănase STAMULE, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Conference Director Roxana CLODNIȚCHI, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Editor in Chief Carmen PĂUNESCU, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania International Relations Manager Anca BOGDAN, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania PR Manager Georgiana Oana STĂNILĂ, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Financial Manager Sorin ANAGNOSTE, Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE Andrzej Marjański – University of Social Sciences, Poland Anikó Csepregi – University of Pannonia, Hungary Alexandru Minea, University Clermont Auvergne, France Constantin Bratianu –Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania Cristian Badarinza – National University of Singapore, Institute of Real Estate Studies, Centre for Economic Policy Research, London, UK Daniel Glaser-Segura – Texas A&M University-San Antonio, USA Emil Papazov – University of National and World Economy, Bulgaria Fabrizio
    [Show full text]
  • Bugetarea Participativă a Rămas Doar O Amintire CLUJ-NAPOCA „Minunea” Participativă N-A Mai Apucat Să Facă Doi Anișori 0
    Când vor avea loc alegerile pentru președinția CJ ? După demisia lui Horea Uioreanu, mingea a ajuns în curtea Guvernului care trebuie să stabilească data alegerilor pentru şefia Consiliului Judeţean Cluj. Pagina 3 MARŢI | 21 OCTOMBRIE 2014 | anul XVII, nr. 201 (4408) | 12 pagini | 1,50 lei Telefon Monitorul: 0264/59.77.00 PUBLICITATE Bugetarea participativă a rămas doar o amintire CLUJ-NAPOCA „Minunea” participativă n-a mai apucat să facă doi anișori 0 METEO 16 C Detalii în pagina 2 1 = 4.4176 LEI Detalii în pagina 5 ACTUALITATE Drumul până la Bucureşti – doar „trei ore cu maşina”! Ministrul Ioan Rus ne povesteşte visurile sale frumoase. Clujenii cred că mai bine ar face cu adevărat autostrada. Pagina 3 PUBLICITATE Bugetarea participativă este un proces prin care clujenii spun cum și pe ce să fie Tel 0264-414076 cheltuit banul public. Anul trecut, ei au hotărât modernizarea fostului cinema Dacia. www.hotelonix.ro, [email protected] Str. Septimiu Albini Nr. 12, Cluj-Napoca Anul acesta n-au mai hotărât nimic! Pagina 4 PUBLICITATE Dacă aveţi informaţii care pot constitui o ştire, scrieţi-ne pe adresa [email protected] 2 actualitate.monitorulcj.ro marţi, 21 octombrie 2014 PUBLICITATE Dan Şova, la DNA Fostul ministru PSD este urmărit penal sub acuzaţia de trafic de influenţă. Senatorul PSD Dan Şova a fost pus sub acuzare de pro- curorii DNA pentru săvârşi- 0 0 rea infracţiunii de trafi c de 10 /16 C infl uenţă, în dosarul în care Înnorat este urmărit penal şi depu- tatul social-democrat Viorel Hrebenciuc. Potrivit unui comunicat al DNA,
    [Show full text]
  • Romanian Agency for Quality Assurance in Higher Education (Aracis)
    ENQA AGENCY REVIEW 2018 ENQA AGENCY REVIEW: ROMANIAN AGENCY FOR QUALITY ASSURANCE IN HIGHER EDUCATION (ARACIS) David William Cairns, Agnes Leinweber, Hannele Marjatta Niemi, Simona Dimovska 13 September 2018 ............................................................................................................ 3 ................................................................................................................................ 5 ............................... 5 BACKGROUND OF THE REVIEW .............................................................................................................. 5 MAIN FINDINGS OF THE 2013 REVIEW ................................................................................................... 5 REVIEW PROCESS ................................................................................................................................ 6 ........................... 7 HIGHER EDUCATION SYSTEM ................................................................................................................. 7 QUALITY ASSURANCE ........................................................................................................................... 8 ............................................................................................................................................ 9 ARACIS’S ORGANISATION/STRUCTURE .................................................................................................. 9 ARACIS’S FUNCTIONS, ACTIVITIES, PROCEDURES ..................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Ziarul El Rumano
    Cabinet avocaturăde AVOCAT CARMEN POP OFERIM SERVICII JURIDICE LA NIVEL NAŢIONAL Divorţuri și Dreptul familiei Moșteniri și donaţii Litigii de muncă Cazuri penale Drept administrativ Teme imobiliare și închirieri www.periodicoelrumano.es Contracte facebook.com / PeriodicoRumano en España Calle Alonso Cano, nr. 46, 2º B, Madrid Anul VIII / NR. 164 / 20 pagini / 3 martie 2016 Tel: 672.643.035 / 915.353.746 ZIAR ROMÂNESC GRATUIT / EL PERIÓDICO DE LOS RUMANOS EN ESPAÑA ACTUALITATE 8 9 din 10 respondenți declară că au tot mai Grupul „Mândrii Românași” te invită din luna martie puțină încredere în partidele din România la Cursuri de Dansuri Populare Românești EXTERNE 14 Ungaria va organiza un referendum privind cotele obligatorii de refugiați ESPAÑOL 15 Rumania se incluye entre los destinos preferidos para inversiones Foto: bzc.ro Institutul Român pentru Evaluare și Strategie (IRES) a dat publicității recent un studiu referitor la raportarea românilor față de partidele din România. Neîncrederea este principalul aspect al felului în care românii se raportează la partidele politice și la activitatea lor. 3 Foto: ideasparanegocios.net Mundo 800 România Spania 800 Franța Regatul Unit MINUTE naţionale şi internaţionale* Italia și multe altele... 15€ către fix & mobil 107,7FM Valabil 30 zile TVA inclus Pentru activare trimite 3004 la 3535 Se aplică termeni şi condiţii radioromanul.es Solicitaţi o cartelă SIM pe www.lycamobile.es Publicitate: 91 877 10 12 sau sunaţi la 632100321 LM_SPAIN_El_Rumano_March2016_128x80mm.indd 1 02/03/2016 10:14 www.periodicoelrumano.es Nr. 164 3 martie 2016 CONTACT 2 | facebook.com / PeriodicoRumano INSTITUŢII ALE STATULUI ROMÂN ÎN SPANIA Ambasada României în Regatul Spaniei Consulatul General al Telefon de urgență: cazuri de deces sau acci- Web: http://castellon.mae.ro Adresa: Avenida de Alfonso XIII, nr.
    [Show full text]