Redalyc.In Search of Fulgencio Batista
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Revista Mexicana del Caribe ISSN: 1405-2962 [email protected] Universidad de Quintana Roo México Argote Freyre, Frank In Search of Fulgencio Batista: A Reexamiation of Prevolutionary Cuban Scholarship Revista Mexicana del Caribe, vol. VI, núm. 11, 2001 Universidad de Quintana Roo Chetumal, México Available in: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=12801104 How to cite Complete issue Scientific Information System More information about this article Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America, the Caribbean, Spain and Portugal Journal's homepage in redalyc.org Non-profit academic project, developed under the open access initiative IN SEARCH OF FULGENCIO BATISTA AREEXAMINATIONOFPRE-REVOLUTIONARYCUBANSCHOLARSHIP FRANKARGOTE-FREYRE DepartmentofPuertoRicanandHispanicCaribbeanStudies Rutgers,TheStateUniversityofNewJersey* Abstract Thisarticlereviewsawide-rangingbibliographyofscholarlystudiesfrom bothsidesoftheideologicaldivideconcerningacademicandofficialrep- resentationsofthePrerevolutionaryperiodinCuba.Theresearchpoints toavarietyoffactorswhichhaveinfluencedscholarlystudiesinthepast –avoidanceoftheperiodaltogether,theabsenceofreliablebiographies oftheprincipalpre-revolutionaryfiguresofthe1930-1959period,re- strictedaccesstoarchives,promotionofofficialinterpretations-,amongst others.Thisstudyalsopointstotheground-breakingworkofleading specialistswhoseektobridgetheideologicalchasmbetweenUSand Cubanversionsoftheirrecenthistory.Thearticlecentresonthefigure ofFulgencioBatistaandaimstousehiscareerasawindowtotheperiod, ameansbywhichtosuggestavarietyofissuesthatneedtobere- examinedandchallenged.Acentralpointofthisanalysiswillbetheneed tostudytheleadingpoliticalfigureswithintheirhistoricalcontext, andtobeingawareofdifferentandcontrastingstagesintheircomplex politicalcareers,andtothevarietyofimplicationsthatresult. Keywords:FulgencioBatista,Prerevolutionaryperiod(Republican);CubanRevo- lution;US-Cubarelationship;bibliographyofscholarlystudies. Resumen Esteartículorevisaunaextensabibliografíadeestudiosrealizadospor académicosdeambosladosdelaseparaciónideológica,sobrelasrepresen- tacionesdelperiodoRepublicanoenCuba(prerrevolucionario) yseñala unavariedaddefactoresquehaninfluenciadoaestosacadémicos.Esta propuestatambiénllamalaatenciónhacialostrabajospionerosdedes- tacadosespecialistasquienesbuscansuperarlosobstáculosytender puentessobreelabismoideológicoentrelasversionescubanasynortea- mericanasdelahistoriareciente.ElartículosecentraenFulgencioBa- tista.Elanálisispartedelanecesidaddeestudiaralasprincipalesfiguras políticasensucontextohistóricoydeconsiderarlasdistintasetapasde suscarreraspolíticascomplejasylavariedaddeimplicacionesqueresultan. Palabrasclaves:FulgencioBatista,Periodoprerrevolucionario(Republicano), RevoluciónCubana,RelacionesEEUU-Cuba,bibliografíasespecializadas. *TillettHall231,LivingstonCampus,53Ave.E.Piscataway,NJ08854-8040. RMC,11(2001),193-227 [193] EN BUSCA DE FULGENCIO BATISTA UNAREVISIÓNDELTRABAJODELOSACADÉMICOS CUBANOSANTESDELAREVOLUCIÓN FRANKARGOTE-FREYRE DepartmentofPuertoRicanandHispanicCaribbeanStudies Rutgers,TheStateUniversityofNewJersey Résumé C´estunerévisiondel´amplebibliographieconsacréeauxétudessurles représentationsdelapériodeRépublicaineaCuba(pré-révolutionnaire) effectuéepardesuniversitairesidéologiquementséparés.Cetterévision montrequ´ilsontétéinfluencéspardiversfacteurs.Cetteétudesouligne aussil´aspect“pionnier”destravauxspécialisésquitententdejeter unpontsurl´abîmeidéologiqueséparantversionscubainesetversions nordaméricainesdel´histoirerécente.Unarticlecentrésurlepersonnage deFulgencioBatista. Samenvatting HetartikelbeschrijfteenuitgebreideliteratuuroverzichtvanCuba tijdensdeRepublikeinse(pre-revolutionaire)periode.Erwordtverwezen naareenveelheidvanfactorendieacademicivanbeideideologische kampenhadbeinvloed.Ookwordtpionierswerkengeprezen,diedeze belemmeringenprobeerdeteoverstijgenendiebruggenbouwdentussende CubaanseenNoordamerikaanseinterpretatiesvanderecentegesschiedenis. HetartikelbehandeltvooraldefiguurvanFulgencioBatista.Decentrale stellingisdatdevoornaamstepolitiekefigureninhunhistorischecontext geplaatstmoetenworden,endatinbeschouwingmoetwordengenomen deverschillendefaseninhunpolitiekecarriereendeconsequenties hiervan. RMC,11(2001),193-227 [194] hetimehascometoreexamineaspectsofthecareer T ofFulgencioBatistaduringthe“pre-Revolutionary”pe- riod(1902-1958)ofCubanhistory.Formorethan40years,Batista andmanyofthepoliticalleadersoftheperiodhavebeende- pictedasstickfigurecaricatures,spinelesslackeysoftheUnited States,corruptanddecadentpoliticoswithnopoliticalagenda beyondliningtheirownpockets.Thesestickfigureshaveserv- edFidelCastroandtheRevolutionarygovernmentverywell.By debasingpre-Revolutionaryleaders,withafewchoiceexcep- tions,Castrohassucceededincastinghimselfasthespiritual heirtoJoséMartí,whileeveryoneelsepalesincomparison.In anarticleontheusesofhistorybytheRevolutionarygovern- mentduringthefirsttwodecadesinpower,LouisA.Pérez,Jr. wrote: TherenderingoftheCubanpastinthelasttwentyyearsmaybein partdishonest,inpartmythical,perhapscontrived.Ithas often functionedasadeliberatedeviceforgarneringloyaltyand sacri- fice.Indeed,Cubanshaveusedhistorytoaffirm,define,andde- fendthebeliefsbasictotheenterpriseofRevolution[Pérez,1980, 79-89]. Littlehaschangedduringthesubsequenttwenty-plusyears upthrough2001.InsideCuba,seriousscholarshipontheperiod, alsoknownastheRepublicaneraorthe“pseudo-republic,”must walktheideologicaltightropesetbythe Revolution.Theoffi- cialinterpretationoftheperiodisondisplayattheMuseodela Revolución(theformerPresidentialPalace),whichhasdesig- natedBatistaforaspecialplaceofshame— ElRincóndelos Cretinos—TheCretinsCorner,alongwithformerUnitedStates PresidentsRonaldReaganandGeorgeBush.Intheexhibitthe corruption,decadenceandracialdiscriminationofthepre-Revo- lutionaryperiodareelaboratelydetailed.Theexhibitleadsone tobelievethatthesesocialillsvanishedwiththetriumphofthe Revolutionof1959. INSEARCHOFFULGENCIOBATISTA:AREEXAMINATIONOF.../195 196/FRANKARGOTE-FREYRE Withfewexceptions,suchastheworkofLionelSoto 1and JoséTabaresdelReal,2mostCubanscholarsavoidthepre-Revo- lutionaryperiodaltogetherandconcentrateonthenineteenth century,afieldmuchlesslikelytooffendthegovernmentand itsofficialversionofhistory.Thelackofscholarlyattentionto theperiodbetween1902and1958mightleadonetobelievethat littleofimportancehappenedintheperiodbetweentheinde- pendencewarsandtheRevolutionof1959.Morethanfourdec- adesafterthetriumphoftheRevolutionmanyCubanarchival collectionsfocusingonthemilitaryandthePresidencyofFulgen- cioBatistaremainoff-limits,availableforreviewbyonlyselect scholars.3 IntheCubanexilecommunity,theattacksagainsttheCas- trogovernmentareimpassionedandincessant,andstillcapable ofsparkingapoliticalcrisisbetweentheUnitedStatesandCuba astheeventssurroundingtheEliánGonzálezcaserecentlyillus- trated.ThetwoCubancommunitiesseethepre-Revolutionary periodinfundamentallydifferentways.After40years,thereis stilllittleinthewayofdialogue.Abriefreviewofthebibliogra- phiesandfootnotesofmanyofthescholarlyworksproducedby thetwosidesrevealsalackofengagement.Theotheroftenover- looksthescholarshipofone.Untilthetwosidesbeginaconversa- tionprogressinreinterpretingthepre-Revolutionaryperiodwill continueataslowpace. OutsideCuba,ourunderstandingoftheperiodhasbenefited fromtheworkoftheprolificLouisA.Pérez,Jr.,whoseworks spantheentireeraandMarifeliPérez-Stable,whoseground-break- ingstudy, TheCubanRevolution:Origins,CourseandLeg acy, strivestodealwiththepreandpost-Revolutionaryerasaspart ofacontinuouswholeratherthandisconnectedpieces(Pérez, 1SotoanalyzestheperiodfromaMarxistperspectiveandbringstogether awiderangeofprimaryandsecondarysources.Oneofthemostthoroughworks ontheperiod. 2TabaresdelRealreviewstheentireperiodfrom1902to1935,butcon- centratesonthe1930s. 3Repeatedrequestsonmyparttoreviewmilitaryrecordsfromtheperiod havebeenignoredordenied. RMC,11(2001),193-227 INSEARCHOFFULGENCIOBATISTA:AREEXAMINATIONOF.../197 “GraciasCretinoporayudarnosAHACERLARevolución” Batistaenel“RincóndelosCretinos”delMuseodelaRevolucióndeLaHabana (Foto:FrankArgote-Freyre) RMC,11(2001),193-227 198/FRANKARGOTE-FREYRE 1986a,1990,1995;Pérez-Stable,1999).4CarlosAlbertoMontaner raisesanumberofthoughtprovokingquestionsinarecentes- sayinwhichhearguedthattheRevolutionaryethosoftwenti- ethcenturyCubacreatedapoliticalclimatewhichmadeit inevitablethatcaudilloswouldrule.Amongthecaudilloshein- cludes,JoséMiguelGómez,MarioGarcíaMenocal,GerardoMa- chado,BatistaandCastro(Montaner,2001).Arecentbookand articlebyRobertWhitneyattemptstoplacetheBatistaofthe 1930swithinapopulistframeworkandsuggestsadditionaltop- icsforfurtherstudy,includingtheroleofcorporatismandstate effortsto“discipline”theCubanmasses(Whitney,2000,2001a). EarlierworksbyHughThomas,JorgeDomínguez,LuisE.Aguilar andHerminioPortell-Vilámadesignificantcontributionstoour understandingoftheperiod(Thomas,1971;Domínguez,1978, 1998;Aguilar,1972;Portell-Vilá,1986). Nonetheless,pre-RevolutionaryCubaremainsthestep- childoftwentiethcenturyCubanhistoriographyandscholarship. ThedramaticeventsoftheCubanRevolution—TheBayofPigs, theCubanMissileCrisis,theefforttospreadRevolutionthrough- outLatinAmerica,CubaninvolvementinAfrica,theMariel Boatlift,theaftermathoftheSovietcollapseandongoingef- fortstotightentheUnitedStatesembargo—havedominated scholarlyeffortsintheUnitedStates.Asaresult,scholarshipon pre-RevolutionaryCubahasbeenspottyatbest,exceptforworks ontheprocessoffomenting Revolutioninthe1950sforwhich scholarshipandfirst-handaccountsabound. 5Pérez-Stablear- guesthattherehasbeenafailuretoincorporatepre-Revolu- tionaryCubaintoourunderstandingofmodernCubaandnotes