Report of the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics Delegation to China

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Report of the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics Delegation to China Parliament of Australia Report of the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics Delegation to China 28 July to 6 August 2014 © Commonwealth of Australia 2014 ISBN 978-1-74366-196-3 Printed version 978-1-74366-197-0 HTML version This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License. The details of this licence are available on the Creative Commons website: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/au/. ii Members of the Committee Ms Kelly O’Dwyer MP, Chair Hon Ed Husic MP, Deputy Chair Mr Scott Buchholz MP Dr Jim Chalmers MP Mr David Coleman MP Mr Pat Conroy MP Dr Peter Hendy MP Mr Kevin Hogan MP Mr Craig Kelly MP Mr Clive Palmer MP Members of the Delegation Ms Kelly O’Dwyer MP Leader of the Delegation Mr Pat Conroy MP Deputy Leader of the Delegation Mr Scott Buchholz MP Dr Peter Hendy MP Mr Peter Banson Delegation Secretary iii Table of Contents Members of the Committee ................................................................... iii Abbreviations .......................................................................................... v Chapter 1 – Introduction ......................................................................... 1 Background ........................................................................................... 1 Context for the Committee’s visit ......................................................... 2 China’s economy ............................................................................ 2 The Committee’s current inquiry ................................................... 2 Chapter 2 – The Delegation’s discussions ............................................... 4 Economic reform in China ..................................................................... 4 Banking and non-bank finance sectors.................................................. 5 Shadow banking ............................................................................. 5 Chinese investment in Australia ............................................................ 6 State-owned enterprise reform ............................................................ 7 Free trade negotiations......................................................................... 8 Environmental policy in China ............................................................... 9 Urban development in Chengdu ........................................................... 9 Shanghai Pilot Free Trade Zone........................................................... 10 Conclusion .......................................................................................... 11 Appendix A – Program of meetings ..................................................... 12 iv Abbreviations CBRC China Banking Regulatory Commission CDB China Development Bank CIRC China Insurance Regulatory Commission CSRC China Securities Regulatory Commission FIRB Foreign Investment Review Board FTA Free trade agreement GDP Gross domestic product ISDS Investor-state dispute settlement PBOC People's Bank of China RMB Renminbi SMEs Small to medium sized enterprises SOEs State-owned enterprises v Chapter 1 Introduction Background delegation’s aims, allowing delegates to Since 2011, an annual parliamentary gain a substantial insight into committee visit to China has been developments across China and issues included in the official outgoing being faced in individual provinces, and delegation program of the a better understanding of where Commonwealth Parliament. The visit opportunities exist to strengthen rotates each year between House of Australia’s relationship with China. Representatives, Senate and Joint Committees, and this year the House of The delegation felt very welcome in Representatives Standing Committee every region of China it visited, and was on Economics nominated and was warmly received by parliamentarians selected to undertake the visit. and Government officials, business representatives and academics. It was The intention of the annual visits is to clear that Australia is held in high strengthen the parliamentary and regard in China, and the delegation bilateral links between Australia and found good opportunities to build on China, and to fulfil a commitment in the the strong bilateral relationship memorandum of understanding between our two countries. between the Australian Parliament and the Chinese National People’s Congress The delegation wishes to record its to seek broader contacts through appreciation of the work that went into committee visits. preparing for the visit, including the briefings provided by the Department The main aims of the Economics of Foreign Affairs and Trade and the Committee in undertaking the visit various arrangements made by the were to gain a deeper understanding of International and Parliamentary the Chinese economy, and to learn Relations Office of the Department of about China’s economic reform agenda, the House of Representatives. The its banking and non-bank lending delegation would also like to thank sectors, its trade and investment Australia’s Embassy in Beijing, and relationship with Australia, and where Consulates in Chengdu and Shanghai for opportunities might exist to strengthen their work in developing the programs ties between our two countries. and the excellent support and Discussions also extended to areas hospitality provided during the visit. including health, education, environmental policy, social This report outlines the matters development and security. discussed and places visited with a broad focus on China’s economy and The delegation visited the cities of reform agenda and in the context of Beijing, Chengdu and Shanghai. The Australia’s trade and investment program of activities in each city was relationship with China. The program of well-targeted and relevant to the meetings is included as an appendix to the report. Context for the Committee’s visit authorities in some cities to loosen property restrictions in an effort to China’s economy tempt buyers back into the market. If Following a remarkable period of the market continues to soften, growth over recent decades, China is expectations are that this could lead to targeting gross domestic product (GDP) a drop in GDP growth and have impacts growth of 7.5% in 2014, which follows across the economy, particularly in 7.7% in 2012 and 2013. This target areas such as construction and steel represents China’s plans to rebalance production, and public infrastructure its economy towards a more investment. sustainable market based system, consumption-driven and open to trade. Other aspects of China’s economy currently attracting interest, particularly China’s 12th Five-Year Plan, endorsed in in the context of its economic reform 2011 and in place until 2015, agenda, include the shadow banking emphasises higher quality and inclusive sector and State-owned enterprises growth, as China attempts to solve (SOEs), both of which are discussed in issues of poverty and increasing wealth more detail later in this report. disparity among its citizens. The Plan prioritises the following seven The Committee’s current inquiry industries, with the aim of increasing The House of Representatives Standing their contributions to GDP from 2% to Committee on Economics is currently 8% by 2015: undertaking an inquiry into Australia's 1. new energy foreign investment policy as it applies 2. energy conservation and to residential real estate, which was environmental protection referred to the Committee by the 3. biotechnology Treasurer on 19 March 2014. 4. new materials 5. new IT While the inquiry is not focused on 6. high-end equipment manufacturing investments coming from any particular 7. clean energy vehicles. country, questions have been raised by submitters, witnesses and China is currently the world’s second- commentators about the level of largest economy, largest holder of investment by Chinese individuals and foreign exchange reserves, largest enterprises in Australian residential real manufacturer, and second-largest estate. destination for foreign direct investment. The ways in which Chinese investors may be obtaining funding to purchase However, the country is facing some property in Australia has also been serious economic problems. Debt levels queried, particularly in terms of the in China have been rising rapidly, with sustainability of China’s so-called the credit to GDP ratio currently at ‘shadow banking’ sector. The lack of around 210%, raising concerns for transparency within the non-bank investors and leading to speculation financing industry in China has fueled about a credit crisis. In addition, speculation that poor asset quality in housing prices in China have been shadow banking entities could not only falling over recent months, leading local 2 lead to a financial crisis in China but could also cause problems for countries with exposure to Chinese foreign investment. In this context, the Committee was interested in utilising its visit to China to gain a better understanding of China’s banking system and lending processes, including those within the ‘shadow’ financing industry. 3 Chapter 2 The Delegation’s discussions Economic reform in China 6. opening up of financial system At the Third Plenum of the 18th Chinese 7. political reform Communist Party Congress, a package 8. legal reform of reforms were endorsed which were 9. anti-corruption aimed at reforming China’s economy 10. culture management over the coming years. The reforms 11. welfare reform include opening the financial sector
Recommended publications
  • Second Morrison Government Ministry 29 June 2021 Overview
    Barton Deakin Brief: Second Morrison Government Ministry 29 June 2021 Overview Prime Minister Scott Morrison MP has announced his new Cabinet and Ministry following the change in The Nationals leadership. Cabinet Changes - Barnaby Joyce MP is the new Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport and Regional Development. Michael McCormack MP has been removed from the Cabinet and is now on the backbench. - David Littleproud MP retains his position as the Minster for Agriculture and is now also the Minister for Northern Australia. The role of Minister for Drought and Emergency Management will be given to Senator Bridget McKenzie. - Senator McKenzie will be returned to the Cabinet and is also the new Minister for Regionalisation, Regional Communications and Regional Education. - Keith Pitt MP, the Minister for Resources and Water will move to the outer Ministry, with his Northern Australia portfolio goes to David Littleproud MP. - Andrew Gee MP has been promoted to the Cabinet as the Minister for Defence Industry and Minister for Veterans’ Affairs. - Darren Chester MP, the former Minister for Veterans Affairs and Defence Personnel has been removed from the Cabinet and the Ministry. Ministry Changes - Mark Coulton MP, formerly the Minister for Regional Health, Regional Communications and Local Government is no longer a Minister. - Dr David Gillespie MP has become the Minister for Regional Health. For more information - The Ministry List from the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet For more information, contact David Alexander on +61 457 400 524, Grahame Morris on +61 411 222 680, Cheryl Cartwright on +61 419 996 066 or Jack de Hennin on +61 424 828 127.
    [Show full text]
  • Submission to the Senate Select Committee Into the Political Influence of Donations
    Submission to the Senate Select Committee into the Political Influence of Donations Dr Charles Livingstone & Ms Maggie Johnson Gambling and Social Determinants Unit School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine Monash University 9 October 2017 1 Introduction Gambling in Australia is a prime cause of avoidable harm, with the harms of gambling estimated to be of the same order of magnitude as alcohol, and far higher than that associated with illicit drug consumption. (Browne et al, 2016; 2017). The gambling industry is a major donor to Australian political parties and politicians and appears to hold considerable cachet with many political actors, at both federal and state level. In this, it appears to be similar to other industries that produce harmful products, such as alcohol and tobacco. Its purpose in donating to political parties and politicians is similar; it seeks to deny the harmful effects of its products, delay or wind back reform, avoid effective regulation, and continue to extract profits for as long as possible. a) The level of influence that political donations exert over the public policy decisions of political parties, Members of Parliament and Government administration; The Australian gambling industry has utilised political donations as a mechanism to exert considerable influence over relevant public policy. This has been facilitated by the current donations regime, which has numerous flaws from the perspective of transparency and support for policy that acts in the genuine interest of the public. The industry is both significantly resourced and politically organised, and has actively sought opportunities for political engagement via donations to politicians and political parties.
    [Show full text]
  • With a New Prime Minister Nominated, the Nationals Have a Rare Chance to Assert Themselves Gregory C
    University of Wollongong Research Online Faculty of Law, Humanities and the Arts - Papers Faculty of Law, Humanities and the Arts 2018 With a new prime minister nominated, the Nationals have a rare chance to assert themselves Gregory C. Melleuish University of Wollongong, [email protected] Publication Details Melleuish, G. (2018). With a new prime minister nominated, the Nationals have a rare chance to assert themselves. The onC versation, 24 August 1-3. Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] With a new prime minister nominated, the Nationals have a rare chance to assert themselves Abstract So, Scott orM rison, MP for The hirS e, has won the leadership of the Liberal Party. One must wonder what role external factors played in his victory, including the vague threat by some National Party members that they would sit on the crossbenches had Dutton been victorious. Keywords nationals, assert, have, themselves, rare, chance, prime, minister, nominated Disciplines Arts and Humanities | Law Publication Details Melleuish, G. (2018). With a new prime minister nominated, the Nationals have a rare chance to assert themselves. The onC versation, 24 August 1-3. This journal article is available at Research Online: https://ro.uow.edu.au/lhapapers/3637 8/27/2018 With a new prime minister nominated, the Nationals have a rare chance to assert themselves Academic rigour, journalistic flair With a new prime minister nominated, the Nationals have a rare chance to assert themselves August 24, 2018 4.48pm AEST It is often forgotten that the Liberals cannot govern without the support of the Nationals, and this has been the case for almost 100 years.
    [Show full text]
  • Stubbornly Opposed: Influence of Personal Ideology in Politician's
    Stubbornly Opposed: Influence of personal ideology in politician's speeches on Same Sex Marriage Preliminary and incomplete 2020-09-17 Current Version: http://eamonmcginn.com/papers/Same_Sex_Marriage.pdf. By Eamon McGinn∗ There is an emerging consensus in the empirical literature that politicians' personal ideology play an important role in determin- ing their voting behavior (called `partial convergence'). This is in contrast to Downs' theory of political behavior which suggests con- vergence on the position of the median voter. In this paper I extend recent empirical findings on partial convergence by applying a text- as-data approach to analyse politicians' speech behavior. I analyse the debate in parliament following a recent politically charged mo- ment in Australia | a national vote on same sex marriage (SSM). I use a LASSO model to estimate the degree of support or opposi- tion to SSM in parliamentary speeches. I then measure how speech changed following the SSM vote. I find that Opposers of SSM be- came stronger in their opposition once the results of the SSM na- tional survey were released, regardless of how their electorate voted. The average Opposer increased their opposition by 0.15-0.2 on a scale of 0-1. No consistent and statistically significant change is seen in the behavior of Supporters of SSM. This result indicates that personal ideology played a more significant role in determining changes in speech than did the position of the electorate. JEL: C55, D72, D78, J12, H11 Keywords: same sex marriage, marriage equality, voting, political behavior, polarization, text-as-data ∗ McGinn: Univeristy of Technology Sydney, UTS Business School PO Box 123, Broadway, NSW 2007, Australia, [email protected]).
    [Show full text]
  • AFPA Congratulates New Nationals Ministry and Urges Focus on Forest Industries’ Regional Economic Potential
    28 June 2021 AFPA congratulates new Nationals Ministry and urges focus on forest industries’ regional economic potential The Federal Coalition Government has a great opportunity to use the latest Nationals’ Ministry changes to secure Australia’s future timber needs and turbocharge regional manufacturing jobs by backing Australia’s sustainable forest industries, the Australian Forest Products Association (AFPA) said today. AFPA Chief Executive Officer Ross Hampton congratulated the new Ministers and says now is the time for the Government to future-proof our housing construction needs and harness the climate and economic benefits of our sustainable forest industries. “On behalf of Australia’s forest industries I congratulate the new Nationals Ministers, especially Senator Bridget McKenzie who has been a tireless advocate for our timber industries, especially in her home state of Victoria, over the past year,” Mr Hampton said. “Senator McKenzie is a great choice to lead the Government’s regional economic development agenda. As well as being a passionate voice for the regions, Senator McKenzie also recognises the importance of our $24 billion-a-year forest industries and their potential to play an even greater role in regional Australia. “We congratulate new Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce and new Ministers, Andrew Gee, David Gillespie and Kevin Hogan, all of whom have vital forest industries resources and processing facilities in their electorates. “We also pay tribute to former Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack and former Minister and Member for Gippsland, Darren Chester, both of whom will no doubt continue to be strong advocates for forest industries in their electorates.” Mr Hampton said Australia’s forest industries are primed for growth to add to the 80,000 existing forest industry jobs around the nation.
    [Show full text]
  • Local Government As the Delivery Partner for Covid-19 Economic Stimulus Measures Via the Financial Assistance Grant Program
    A Co-operative venture of the municipalities of: Cockburn, East Fremantle, Fremantle, Kwinana, Melville & Rockingham Friday, 17 April 2020 Enquiries: Tom Griffiths – (08) 9364 0631 The Hon. Scott Morrison, Senator the Hon Marise Payne, The Hon Ken Wyatt AM MP, The Hon Greg Hunt MP, The Hon Ben Morton MP Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet PO Box 6500 CANBERRA ACT 2600 The Hon. Michael McCormack MP, The Hon. David Littleproud MP The Hon. Paul Fletcher MP, The Hon. Alan Tudge MP The Hon. Mark Coulton MP, The Hon. Andrew Gee MP The Hon. Scott Buchholz MP, The Hon. Kevin Hogan MP The Hon. Nola Marino MP Ministers for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Communications GPO Box 594 CANBERRA ACT 2601 Letter sent by email RE: LOCAL GOVERNMENT AS THE DELIVERY PARTNER FOR COVID-19 ECONOMIC STIMULUS MEASURES VIA THE FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE GRANT PROGRAM The South West Group (SWG) congratulates the Federal Government on the effectiveness of its fiscal stimulus measures to date. The Government should be commended on the substantial financial package it developed, the third largest in the world as a percentage of GDP, to support the nation through these difficult times. The measures have been very well received by the near 450,000 residents within the SWG region and have provided much needed relief to businesses badly affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. The purpose of this letter is to recommend the expanded use of the existing Financial Assistance Grants (FA Grants) Program as a further stimulus mechanism during the COVID-19 economic recovery phase. The FA Grants program is considered to be a highly effective and swift mechanism to directly stimulate Australia’s economic recovery by engaging Local Government Authority’s as the delivery partner.
    [Show full text]
  • The Australian Capital Territory New South Wales
    Names and electoral office addresses of Federal Members of Parliament The Australian Capital Territory ......................................................................................................... 1 New South Wales ............................................................................................................................... 1 Northern Territory .............................................................................................................................. 4 Queensland ........................................................................................................................................ 4 South Australia .................................................................................................................................. 6 Tasmania ........................................................................................................................................... 6 Victoria ............................................................................................................................................... 7 Western Australia .............................................................................................................................. 9 How to address Members of Parliament ........................................................................... 10 The Australian Capital Territory Ms Gai Brodtmann, MP Hon Dr Andrew Leigh, MP 205 Anketell St, Unit 8/1 Torrens St, Tuggeranong ACT, 2900 Braddon ACT, 2612 New South Wales Hon Anthony Abbott,
    [Show full text]
  • The House of Representatives Results Ben Raue
    7 The House of Representatives Results Ben Raue At the 2016 Australian federal election, the first-term Liberal–National Coalition government faced a significant swing against it, suffering a net loss of 12 seats. The government managed to win a narrow majority, with just 76 out of 150 seats. This chapter covers the results of the election in the House of Representatives, focusing on key electoral contests, as well as explaining the electoral system used for the House of Representatives, redistributions conducted prior to the elections, by-elections held during the previous term, the number of nominations made for the House of Representatives and the impact of preferences on the election result. Electoral system The House of Representatives is the lower house of Australia’s bicameral parliament. Elections are usually held simultaneously with elections for the upper house (Senate), although Senate elections are conducted using a method of proportional representation. House of Representatives elections are due once every three years. Australia’s House of Representatives consists of 150 members, each elected to represent a single-member constituency. Members are elected using compulsory preferential voting, with voters required to effectively choose preferences between every candidate on the ballot. If no candidate wins more than half of the vote, 159 DOUBLE DISILLUSION the vote for the lowest-polling candidate is redistributed according to the preferences of that candidate’s voters, and this process is repeated until a candidate has a majority of the vote. Due to this preferential voting system, this chapter will refer to the vote for candidates before and after preferences are distributed.
    [Show full text]
  • Morrison Government Ministry Reshuffle 2021
    Morrison Government Ministry Reshuffle 2021 Portfolio Minister Prime Minister The Hon Scott Morrison MP Minister for the Public Service The Hon Scott Morrison MP Minister for Women Senator the Hon Marise Payne Minister for Indigenous Australians The Hon Ken Wyatt AM MP Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport and Regional Development The Hon Michael McCormack MP Minister for Communications, Urban Infrastructure, Cities and the Arts The Hon Paul Fletcher MP Minister for Regional Health, Regional Communications and Local Government The Hon Mark Coulton MP Minister for Decentralisation and Regional Education The Hon Andrew Gee MP Treasurer The Hon Josh Frydenberg MP Assistant Treasurer The Hon Michael Sukkar MP Minister for Housing The Hon Michael Sukkar MP Minister for Superannuation, Financial Services and the Digital Economy Senator the Hon Jane Hume Minister for Women’s Economic Security Senator the Hon Jane Hume Minister for Finance Senator the Hon Simon Birmingham (Vice-President of the Executive Council) (Leader of the Government in the Senate) Minister for Agriculture, Drought and Emergency Management The Hon David Littleproud MP Minister for the Environment The Hon Sussan Ley MP Minister for Resources, Water and Northern Australia The Hon Keith Pitt MP Minister for Foreign Affairs Senator the Hon Marise Payne Minister for Trade, Tourism and Investment The Hon Dan Tehan MP Minister for International Development and the Pacific Senator the Hon Zed Seselja Minister Assisting the Minister for Trade and Investment
    [Show full text]
  • Morrison's Miracle the 2019 Australian Federal Election
    MORRISON'S MIRACLE THE 2019 AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL ELECTION MORRISON'S MIRACLE THE 2019 AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL ELECTION EDITED BY ANIKA GAUJA, MARIAN SAWER AND MARIAN SIMMS In memory of Dr John Beaton FASSA, Executive Director of the Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia from 2001 to 2018 and an avid supporter of this series of election analyses Published by ANU Press The Australian National University Acton ACT 2601, Australia Email: [email protected] Available to download for free at press.anu.edu.au ISBN (print): 9781760463618 ISBN (online): 9781760463625 WorldCat (print): 1157333181 WorldCat (online): 1157332115 DOI: 10.22459/MM.2020 This title is published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). The full licence terms are available at creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/legalcode Cover design and layout by ANU Press Cover photograph: Scott Morrison Campaign Day 11. Photo by Mick Tsikas, AAP. This edition © 2020 ANU Press CONTENTS Figures . ix Plates . xiii Tables . .. xv Abbreviations . xix Acknowledgements . xxiii Contributors . xxv Foreword . xxxiii 1 . Morrison’s miracle: Analysing the 2019 Australian federal election . 1 Anika Gauja, Marian Sawer and Marian Simms Part 1. Campaign and context 2 . Election campaign overview . 21 Marian Simms 3 . The rules of the game . 47 Marian Sawer and Michael Maley 4 . Candidates and pre‑selection . .. 71 Anika Gauja and Marija Taflaga 5 . Ideology and populism . 91 Carol Johnson 6 . The personalisation of the campaign . 107 Paul Strangio and James Walter 7 . National polling and other disasters . 125 Luke Mansillo and Simon Jackman 8 .
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of AEC Donation Data 1999-2000 to 2014-2015 Gambling Industry Interests
    Analysis of AEC donation data 1999-2000 to 2014-2015 Gambling industry interests Interim report 1 – Registered Clubs Association of NSW (t/a ClubsNSW) Dr Charles Livingstone and Ms Maggie Johnson School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine Monash University Introduction and disclosure In Australia, donors to political parties or associated entities are required to disclose donations above a particular threshold. The current threshold is set at $13,000 and is the subject of annual indexation linked to CPI. There has been continuing controversy in relation to the current system of disclosing donations, including the relatively high threshold and the significant delay in publication of the data, use of associated entities to avoid clear disclosure, and inappropriate use of taxpayer funded resources to facilitate fundraising (see, for example a recent episode of Four Corners, and Fairfax media articles on the Liberal Party linked Millennium Forum and fundraising activity in the Victorian electorate of Menzies.). However, some data are published on the Internet by the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) on an annual basis. These data have the potential to provide information about the financial influence exerted on policy and politicians by corporate and other vested interests. All data referred to in this report are sourced from the AEC unless otherwise specified. The research reported in this interim report is intended to provide information to the Alliance for Gambling Reform (which commissioned and funded the research), and to support the preparation of research papers as a component of an Australian Research Council (ARC) Linkage Project (LP130100046) in which the author is a Chief Investigator.
    [Show full text]
  • 9. House of Representatives Results
    9 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES RESULTS Ben Raue The Liberal–National Coalition Government obtained a small swing towards it at the 2019 Australian federal election, gaining a handful of seats. This result restored the government’s narrow majority, which now stands at 77 (of 151) seats. This is an increase of one from 2016, although the government had subsequently lost that majority through various by-elections in the final months of the previous parliament. This chapter covers the results of the 2019 election in the House of Representatives (the House), in individual seats and looking at the overall trends in terms of preference flows, the impact of early voting and the varying swings across the country. 2016 election To place the 2019 House results in context, it is worth recapping the main results of the previous election. In 2016, the first-term Coalition Government went into the election with a sizeable majority, but the loss of 14 seats left it with the slimmest of majorities. The Coalition won 76 seats in the House of Representatives. Labor won 69 seats, which was a net gain of 14 seats. The Greens and Katter’s Australian Party (KAP) retained one seat each, as did two Independent MPs. The Nick Xenophon 179 MORRISON'S MIRACLE Team (NXT) also gained a single seat in the House of Representatives. The Coalition suffered a swing of 3.5 per cent against it on primary votes. Labor gained a 1.3 per cent swing, alongside a 1.6 per cent swing to the Greens. The NXT gained 1.9 per cent in its first outing.
    [Show full text]